This way, no-one cuts across lanes where traffic has a green light.
They work even better with dedicated bike infrastructure as depicted in the diagram about half way through this article: https://www.vox.com/2015/8/12/9139771/protected-intersection...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yh92LirlCf8
My wife used to drive in the Melbourne CBD daily for work, but would always go around the block instead of attempting one.
In "normal" fashion, you'd have to stay on the left of your lane, and wait for the traffic coming in front of you to die down before you can cross. That puts you straight in the middle of the intersection for some time, which is dangerous.
With a hook turn, you go and wait along with the traffic coming from the east to the west. They are stopped, so they are not a danger to you. When the east-west traffic light finally turns green, you won't be crossing anyone's traffic, and you'll be already standing on the rightmost part of your new road.
This is known in the right-hand drive cycling world as a Copenhagen left, and many consider it to be bad infrastructure design.
http://www.aviewfromthecyclepath.com/2010/07/not-really-so-g...
The traffic is a single lane, and you want to turn left. Light turns green, and you wait for the oncoming traffic to clear. All traffic behind you is stopped on a green because they can't get around you.
And I’m sure the risks associated with the “Pittsburg left” are significantly mitigated when everyone expects it.
Typically, the "Pittsburgh left" is used in places where there should be a protected left turn as part of the signal cycle, but there isn't, and at times of high traffic flow it's the only way for any traffic to complete the turn (since waiting for oncoming traffic to clear on a green essentially means waiting until the multi-hour-long period of high traffic is over).
My point was, why do you need to do that when you can just enter the intersection during the green light and complete your turn once the light turns red?
Then the laws in Pittsburgh are just bad. Not a design question at all.
Here you oull into the intersection on green, turn slightly ti a big white cross on the road for exactly this purpose and go when it is clear. This happens when the oncoming side has red, but before the crossing cars have green. The time between red and green is long enough for all two or three cars to clear the intersection.
Get better laws i guess?
Which is why you need to move onto the intersection as the light turns green -- you've now passed the traffic light, so once the oncoming traffic gets the red light, you are clear to turn.
As someone else pointed out, you can do three right turns instead.
The behaviour you just described is what everyone does in Michigan. The Pittsburgh left sounds friendlier, but more risk prone to people who don't expect it or respect it.
Urgh, that's something missing from the other comments. Now it makes sense to me.
The Pittsburgh left sounds like a recipe to get T-boned by an inattentive driver. Pulling into the intersection, and making a left turn when it is safe is a much better alternative.
a) Just sit there, in the middle of the intersection, blocking traffic.
b) Attempt to back up, hoping there are no other cars behind you in the left turn lane blocking your path.
c) Continue through the intersection.
Unless the law says "never stop in the intersection in the first place", I can't imagine it enforcing any option other than c.
Most states say it's OK if you enter the intersection on yellow, but a handful (not including WA, but including neighboring OR) require that you clear the intersection before the red appears.
I've sometimes wondered if "entering the intersection" includes entering the crosswalk adjacent to the intersection.
https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/57ajjq/til_w...
Wait, why? No new car should enter the intersection when the lights turn to yellow. The yellow light should last long enough for everyone to be able to safely drive off the intersection, in orderly manner.
Cars will obviously enter the intersection under a yellow. It's why we have a yellow.
Even if everyone wanted to stop for every yellow, at 35 mph with average reaction time, cars will travel a minimum of 100 feet after the yellow phase starts. Some of those cars will enter the intersection.
With a typical 4 second yellow, some drivers don't even choose to stop for the first half of the yellow, of course.
In driving school I was taught to generally be ready to brake when approaching a light, but to also then pick a reasonable point of no return (depending on speed, maybe a couple dozen meters before the light) beyond which I would not be braking, no matter what the light does. That way braking should never ever feel anything close to emergency braking you do when there‘s an actual unforeeen obstacle. It should always be smooth.
Also, when making a left turn at an intersection in Germany you drive into the intersection and then you wait for the oncoming traffic to clear. At this point you cannot even see the lights. The only thing that is relevant for you is to wait for oncoming traffic to clear up (or if you obviously see they have stopped since the light has since turned red and have verified optimally by eye contact that you are free to go).
Other traffic from left and right obviously have to wait until you have cleared the intersection even if they have a green light.
Likewise, it's illegal to enter an intersection, going straight, when there isn't enough space in your lane, for the back of your car to clear the intersection. Doesn't stop people, though.
[0] https://dmv.ny.gov/about-dmv/chapter-5-intersections-and-tur...
> RCW 46.61.202 says "no driver shall enter an intersection or a marked crosswalk or drive onto any railroad grade crossing unless there is sufficient space on the other side of the intersection, crosswalk, or railroad grade crossing to accommodate the vehicle he or she is operating without obstructing the passage of other vehicles..."
Some people bring out the following passage to be in conflict with it, but I strongly disagree.
> RCW 46.61.190, which says drivers must stop at a marked stop line or "at the point nearest the intersecting roadway where the driver has a view of approaching traffic on the intersecting roadway before entering the roadway, and after having stopped shall yield the right-of-way to any vehicle in the intersection or approaching on another roadway so closely as to constitute an immediate hazard..."
The 'intersecting roadway' obviously refers to the crossing street, not the lane you want to turn into. Therefore, if you can see oncoming traffic without pulling into the intersection, then crossing past the white line, and waiting there is illegal.
The second point is irrelevant, as it pertains to stop/yield intersections, which are not being discussed here.
Edit: oh sorry misunderstood what pittsburg left meant. I was describing situation when both cars turn left. There are 2 options: cube path, that is paths cross, cars pass one by one, or 2 arc paths not intersecting.
I can't imagine how this is a Pittsburgh quirk; its the obvious thing to do when the option is available
"Even harder for autonomous cars to master are local quirks; things like "the Pittsburgh left." That's a custom unique to the city that allows the first driver trying to make a left turn to do so before oncoming cars pass through an intersection. It's one thing that Emily Duff Bartel says Uber's fleet of self-driving cars won't be programmed to practice. "We're following the rules on this one," she says."
https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2017/04/03/52...