News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by meri_dian on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:25AM (#16474134)
People are excited about self driving cars for their potential to reduce accidents by removing human error from the equation. It's not just human error that causes accidents though.

Human emotion in general causes dangerous situations. When we drive now, we're restricted to driving and driving alone. We can listen to the radio but for the most part we are restricted. Because of this, we tend to want to get to our destination as quickly as possible. We drive fast to get the restrictive experience of driving over with.

However if we were free to do other things, like get work done or sleep or watch TV while in our cars, I think we would generally be much more tolerant of travelling at a lower speed. While eventually our self driving systems may be capable of being very safe at very high speeds, I think reduced speeds tolerated by people could offer an extra layer of safety.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by KKKKkkkk1 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:11AM (#16474740)
Have you never had the experience of being on a crawling train and counting the minutes after the meeting you were supposed to be at has already started?
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by joe_the_user on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:08PM (#16477331)
It seems you're confusing the effects of travel being slow with the effects of travel being unreliable. It's not the slowness of a train that's annoying you, it's that the train has slowed unpredictably.

That said, I suppose there's every reason to think traffic impacts of self-driving cars (more cars circling, waiting for passengers) would make traffic slower and more unpredictable.

Edit: And, of course, the people in the non-self-driving cars would get the slowness without any direct benefit to themselves.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dmix on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:15AM (#16474796)
Well technically you could be telepresence into the meeting because your car can be outfitted with a nice TV/monitor, audio recording equipment, and high speed wifi... so you can have meetings while you drive to work. Or you spend your quiet time in the car working, and instead use office time for meetings.

Besides, in the hypothetical self-driving future the transit times will likely be far more predictable than it is today... with AI running and optimizing everything.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by blang on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:31PM (#16476387)
We can already telepresence into the meeting. I moderately understand your argument, but I think the parent is talking about meetings you have to be in physically. And if your argument is "Why do you have to be there physically" I would counter that if you don't have to be there physically why do you ever need to get into a self driving car.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by throwaway76543 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:17PM (#16477425)
I can't telepresence into a meeting while I'm driving, or while I'm on public transit.

Being able to videoconference during my commute would be an enormous boon.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by maccard on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:30PM (#16477570)
Why not? We regularly have people join in in calls from home/on trains. They just have to mute when they're not speaking.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by fixermark on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:47PM (#16478274)
I'm curious what Utopia you live in that has network coverage reliable enough in subway tunnels or on trains going through rural communities to make teleconferencing from mass transit a tractable solution. ;)

(No, but more seriously: I'm a bit envious that this is working for your teams. It's completely impractical in the East Coast US cities I've frequented).

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by redfern314 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:48PM (#16479697)
In the SF Bay Area, Caltrain is aboveground and is more than quiet enough to call into meetings. Think NYC's MetroNorth, there's no reason you wouldn't be able to make a call until you get into the tunnels near Manhattan. On the other hand, BART is underground with signal repeaters just about all the way through - but it's very noisy so you could call in and listen but probably not contribute.

If your transit system is underground without repeaters though, I agree that you're out of luck. I can't imagine trying to take a call on the T.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by audreyt on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:49PM (#16480285)
Here in Taiwan, we also offer free Wi-Fi access across the High Speed Rails system (~180mph, ~200 miles of coverage), reliable enough even in tunnels, as of this year.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by freeone3000 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:07PM (#16478451)
Montreal->Toronto corridor has complete coverage (unless you take the route through Windsor). 4G LTE the entire way.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by kosievdmerwe on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:54PM (#16477783)
Because confidential information is a thing.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by ShorsHammer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:50PM (#16480290)
> in the hypothetical self-driving future

In suburbia/regional areas certainly, but most large cities are already heavily congested, how many more people could possibly fit in peak hours? As optimised as we can make it, there's still a predictable one-directional crush every day.

The real optimisation of roads would be incentivising companies to make their employees start/finish outside of work hours.

A self-driving future will likely still heavily involve public transport in the short term at least.

Hopefully fully autonomous vehicles will get far smaller, travelling pods which are both cheap to buy and maintain, much like a motorbike but without the downsides that turn most people off.

Smaller vehicles, especially trucks will quickly be needed to reduce road wear and offset the likely cost of greater road usage. Smaller personal transportation would also be a boon to road efficiency.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dmix on Thursday March 01, 2018 @12:11PM (#16493865)
Ultimately the key point is predictability. Being able to plan when your meeting will be. Even if congestion doesn't change or gets worse, the point is that it will be easier to plan as trip times become more predictable thanks to machines. That way you won't be late for meetings. as the OP inmplied.

Selfing driving + fleet cars will most certainly reduce the average car size. People buy 4-5 seats for the edge cases when they might need to pick up some friends or more than one child at a time, or merely because it's the most common type of vehicle available, which people buy out of habit or whatever social reason.

But looking at car on any highway and you'll only find more then 1-2 drivers a minority of the time.

When we eliminate the need to buy a single car for all general use-cases, and have a high quantity of self-driving Uber style cars available, then 1-2 seater cars with become the most popular size. Which in itself with reduce climate damage and increase capacities on roads.

Especially as self-driving cars can drive at higher speeds and closer together, potentially linking up like trains for long-distance rides.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dopamean on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:29PM (#16475672)
You're not going to feel any better if you're late in your car on the way to the meeting.

I take the bus every day to work even though in total it takes exactly twice as long than if I took my motorcycle? Why because I like to read on the bus. It's not actually important to me to get there any quicker. In fact on days I have earlier meetings I just leave my apartment earlier. I think the idea that people wouldn't mind going slower may be real for a lot of people.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:02PM (#16478413)
That idea isn't real for anyone who had obligations outside work at fixed times. Especially for parents of small children who have to be reliably picked up and dropped off.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dopamean on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @01:54PM (#16485614)
I didn't say it would apply to everyone.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by komali2 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:24PM (#16475626)
Yes, it's wonderful, I get to not attend the meeting and blame it on something that nobody can lambaste me for blaming :D
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:27PM (#16475655)
> blame it on something that nobody can lambaste me for blaming

I once had somebody pull this shtick for being late to a meeting. I put it in the same category as using "traffic" as an excuse. Disasters which make the news are acceptable. Routine inconveniences causing one delays are okay, once in a while, but never if treated as an immunity against criticism. One should have planned better, by leaving earlier or taking another mode of transportation. Then there are the characters who leave the office late and blame it on traffic every time.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by squeaky-clean on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:33PM (#16475713)
Well I assumed the example in GP's case is some kind of notable breakdown or delay. If you're just late because you don't account for random 10 minute delays in the trains and such, that's entirely your fault, as much as being late because an accident slowed down highway traffic today.

But if your train is stuck in the middle of a tunnel for 3 hours because a crazy person ran onto the track and authorities are chasing them, that's a pretty fair excuse.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by gowld on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:17PM (#16477423)
Travel time has variance. Does your job pay people to clock in early on low-traffic days?
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jes5199 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:52PM (#16475954)
maybe you should consider scheduling your meetings at a resonable time
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:58PM (#16476039)
In my experience, chronic lateness is a function of the person. The person who is late at 9am will be late at 6pm or when they choose the time or when it's a block from them or a city and a half away. (Note: I used to be this person when I was younger. I now leave for any meeting in my city one hour before and then hang out until the start time.)
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jes5199 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:34PM (#16477049)
perhaps they realize that your meetings are low-value
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:55PM (#16477225)
Perhaps. That doesn't help them when I'm considering who to promote, retain or allow to move on.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by gowld on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:18PM (#16477429)
Might be a win-win.

People who are idling all day to be available for meetings likely aren't part of a high-value organization.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:26PM (#16477530)
> People who are idling all day to be available for meetings likely aren't part of a high-value organization

Why would one be idling? The founders and executives who do well have a handle on their schedule. They avoid over-scheduling, keep thing short, show up on time and get shit done. At the larger scale, my friends at Google, Apple or Amazon don't run late for anything, be it a personal brunch or M&A negotiation. Properly functioning as an adult, and fixing problems over making excuses, is simply well internalized.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by chillacy on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:16PM (#16478526)
I find meetings tend to start a few minutes in. Also at one of those companies you mentioned, people did run late or just didn't show up, especially the more senior they were (not out of laziness, they tended to run more important meetings late, or be double-booked).

I hear in Germany if people aren't there when the meeting starts, it gets cancelled. It's definitely part of the culture.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by heyyyouu on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:36PM (#16479211)
Not Germany but at my company we wait about 5-6 minutes and if you don't show up for the meeting everyone drops off. Exceptionally rude to schedule something and expect people to wait. Doesn't happen again after everyone hangs up the first time.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jacquesm on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:53PM (#16476619)
You'd probably feel a bit different if it was your business that depended on you making it to the meeting. Being an employee has its advantages.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by meri_dian on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:20AM (#16474850)
I have been unfortunate enough to have that experience. Being on a commuter train is like being a sardine packed into a can though. I imagine fully autonomous vehicles will offer more comfort.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by staz on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:27PM (#16475652)
Yup. Best case I meditate worst case I get angry.

What I never do however is get distracted by being angry while driving one ton of steel...

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by ben_jones on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:57AM (#16474544)
I train commute everyday and despite the ability to watch a movie or whatever, I still just want to get to my destination and move on with my life.

I think it'll be interesting to see society push the Time to arrival vs. general safety balance. I think we'll see a rising speed limit as the risk becomes more and more mathematical.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by munk-a on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:01PM (#16478398)
I am excited to see what effect moving transit into private vehicles will have. I currently enjoy my commute time with a book but there are other things I'd prefer to be doing. What if I could enjoy a bit more evening in exchange for shifting my showering/breakfasting/working out into the morning commute? I'd be pretty happy with that.

Especially if we move sleeping into self-driving cars then that long commute of yours might start before you're awake

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by r00fus on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:51PM (#16478814)
What I think would be even better is to exercise to commute - many folks I know have the joy of this option e.g. biking 10mi or less to your work and showering there.

I'm more excited about hybrid bikes (allowing even older folks to be more mobile) than self-driving cars.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by eric-hu on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:26AM (#16480880)
Having spent the last two years in various Asian cities, I feel confident in saying most American cities could halve average commute times with no sacrifice to safety. To name a few cities that have much better commutes than the bay or NYC: Tokyo, Hong Kong, Shanghai, Taipei, and Seoul.

Whether things get better in American cities is not a matter of technical innovation at all, but politics and economics.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by kerbalspacepro on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @10:04AM (#16483404)
There are four other US metro systems larger than the Bay's and smaller than NYC's... and they all suffer from the same problems. :)
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:00PM (#16475369)
>I think we'll see a rising speed limit as the risk becomes more and more mathematical.

Risk and speed limits are already mathematical. See the 90th percentile rule. If self driving cars makes obvious the disparity between the letter of the law and actual practice then the law will get changed.

Pretty much the only stakeholders that want the current mismatch between 90th percentile speed and speed limit are the cops who want a pretext to go fishing and the states that want revenue.

Self driving taxis, delivery vehicles, etc that are doing (for example) 55mph "because the law" when the road should really be an 80 is a terrible user experience, especially on roads with mixed human/ai traffic. Insurance, self driving fleet owners, car companies, etc all have a huge incentive for self driving cars to be able to get from A to B just as fast as a human car. Nobody will take your self driving taxi if a human taxi is faster and comparably priced.

We'll see a higher speed limits because the automakers, fleet operators, etc will lean on the states and if that doesn't work they'll lean on the feds (nhtsa, dot and similar) to lean on the states to set limits that are actually consistent with the 90% rule.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by smileysteve on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:37PM (#16478709)
MADD is actually a primary reason for highway speed limits being as low as they are.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by danjc on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:30AM (#16474187)
Could have the unintended effect that people are ok with spending longer traveling in a car though. E.g. people commute 2 hours a day to get into London via train
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:16AM (#16474805)
Thats not necessarily a bad thing if you make transportation efficient enough. Self driving pod that hooks up to public transport, giving me privacy the entire time? Sure.

2 hours is time for art, digital or pen and paper (I draw while on airplanes and such and have learned to compensate for bumps and things). I could knit. Watch things. Read. My spouse would sometimes make music. Some of these are good even if the commute is shorter, and would be an improvement for anyone commuting a good distance already due to traffic and whatnot.

4-5 hours? Split sleep schedule. (I have no children).

It also means folks can better commute to work from small farming towns that lack jobs. I know that an hour commute each way (by car) is too much for me, but I've had to just to make decent money. This was living in the midwest, mind you, and it might be different other places. It wouldn't have been an issue if I wasn't actively driving.

Yes, I do understand that some of the hope would be that people live closer, but that's the hope and push now and it breaks often enough.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by notheguyouthink on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:36AM (#16475061)
Yea, I have no idea if it would be good or not realistically, but being able to move further away from the city sounds amazing.

I'd live way out in the country if I didn't have to drive it. There's a ton of things I can do on my laptop. It really sounds nice.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by komali2 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:25PM (#16475632)
There's always remote work as a possibility, right? Check stackoverflow jobs, I often see [remote ok] jobs there.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by lawlessone on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:05PM (#16475412)
Could we remodel the inside of cars to be more lounge like?
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Noos on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:33PM (#16476407)
I'm worried about them because they will replace human error with computer error, which although rarer, is systemic and harder to predict and deal with. Human error is bad, but I don't want to wake up one day and find a Heartbleed-level error in self-driving cars, or the equivalent of a hardware-level recall.

I'm always surprised people are so accepting of it, to be frank.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by landryraccoon on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:50PM (#16477183)
If fewer people are killed in auto accidents, it’s a win even if the type of error is different. Dead people is dead people.

Why are you surprised? People are cool with massive metal murder machines flying down roads just because it’s a human driving it and not a computer? I seriously can’t wait for all us flesh drivers to be replaced with computers. The thing is that over time computers become better and better drivers. Humans don’t, actually we just get worse as we age and stay on the road anyway. Our human reflexes and biology also limit how fast we can react and subject us to road rage, stress, fatigue and other problems that can’t be debugged. Why is it worse to have software that we might actually be able to fix?

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by joe_the_user on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:17PM (#16477420)
If fewer people are killed in auto accidents, it’s a win even if the type of error is different. Dead people is dead people.

Well, I think the GP was sketching a scenario where fewer people might be killed until one day when a lot of people are killed by a bug/hack/zero-day that suddenly generates huge crashes.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by 2474 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:04PM (#16477295)
Where does blame get placed when there is a computational error and my self-driving car kills another human-being? Am I still liable under my insurance policy even though the error was out of my control? Is there any conversation going on about insuring self-driving vehicles and responsibility when an error does occur and someone is killed?
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by landryraccoon on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:38PM (#16480241)
> Where does blame get placed when there is a computational error and my self-driving car kills another human-being?

Why do you assume the courts are incapable of handling this, or the law doesn't deal with it? Most likely you won't even own a self driving car, you'll be getting into a car owned by Uber or Google and they'll have to face liability, the same way you aren't liable as a passenger in a taxi if the driver gets into an accident.

On the victim side, you're actually more protected because a self driving car is less likely to be uninsured. If an uninsured driver hits you, you're just out of luck, they may go to jail but nobody is paying your bills. In the near term Uber or Google will have loads of insurance and loads of money to pay out claims.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by 2474 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:28PM (#16480677)
There was no assumption. Just a simple question. If we are using assumptions, I assume it won't be as easy for the courts to handle initially as you suggest. It's a newer technology therefore there won't be any/many precendents. I'm not a lawyer but it seems quite obvious that this type of thing could get complex fast.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by fitzroy on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:34PM (#16477603)
There are a lot of conversations happening about this. In short, right now the autonomous features available to consumers are considered level 2 so the driver is required to be alert and ready to take control at all times (similar to using cruise control).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car_liability

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by 2474 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:47PM (#16477722)
Thanks, fitzroy. That is interesting I'll have to read more about this. It's just my opinion but at this time I can't see self-driving vehicles as a viable option for anyone. It just seems like another layer of complexity added into an already complex situtation.

In the case I need to assume control of the vehicle am I going to be fighting against the autonomous system for control? Not only will I need to understand the current environment and what others are doing around me; I also need to understand how the system is computing the situation and maintain control based on my observations and my observations of what the system is trying to do.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by smileysteve on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:36PM (#16478698)
GM has already announced vehicles with no steering wheel.

This will perhaps remind all of the Runaway Prius drivers something that people stopped teaching; Remove the key, It's the kill switch.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by PoachedSausage on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:15PM (#16477972)
It has been talked about from the start. I remember a documentary from the late 90's about self driving cars (it may have been BBC Horizon) and the liability issue was discussed.

Maybe the answer will be Uber-like car fleet services that self-insure.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by bb611 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:25PM (#16477513)
> is systemic and harder to predict and deal with

Is it actually harder to deal with? About 1/6 of fatalities are drunk drivers[2], and they cause another 1/6 of of car accident fatalities[1]. Almost half of all front-seat (driver + front passenger) fatalities aren't wearing seatbelts while on average 90% of Americans do wear seatbelts[2]. There's no way of solving either these problems without identifying people individually and improving their behavior, which is a pretty intractable issue.

1. https://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/impaired_driving/impa...

2. http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalit...

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by tachyoff on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:20PM (#16478560)
I would argue that aggressive education campaigns (similar to anti-smoking campaigns which drastically reduced the number of smokers) could help with seatbelt awareness. Showing how far someone crashes brought a windshield even at 35 mi/h can be pretty effective at getting the point across.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by PoachedSausage on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:19PM (#16478018)
I don't think we will have much choice about accepting the risks of computer errors/bugs. Transportation systems generally are probably reaching the the limits humans ability to manage them, we will have to turn them over more fully to computers at some point.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by foobarian on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:15AM (#16474791)
Road rage is one of the bad emotion-induced states as well. Something competitive about human nature makes us bristle at minor events like another car getting ahead or cutting in line, and likewise makes ourselves do dangerous things.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by mseebach on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:44AM (#16474364)
Humans driving faster than is safe, even if due to emotions, is still human error. The primary limiting factor on safe speeds (at least on "proper" highways) are humans and their poor reaction times.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by rhacker on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:58AM (#16474552)
Couldn't be said enough. What's sad about people that speed too, is that they mistakenly believe that they are the only ones affected by their speed. When in fact most of the affected people are the ones that feel safe pulling into an left-turn intersection knowing the speed limit is 25 and realize too late that someone is barreling toward them at 45. I wish there was more statistics about this phenomenon, but I wholeheartedly believe the mistake speeders make is thinking they have complete control and, yes while they may be good drivers in a certain aspect - the ignoring of commonly known road speeds is why they are, in fact, not good drivers.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by artursapek on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:01AM (#16474594)
I tend to get motion sickness and eye strain when I try reading or working in a moving car. Maybe TV would be a bit easier on the eyes, but I think it's not a healthy habit in general.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:17AM (#16474817)
I can't read for long in a moving car. I can, however, draw or paint, knit, watch tv, or any number of things like this. It helps to take breaks often to look around or focus on things further from your eyes so you aren't noticing every bump.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by lawlessone on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:11PM (#16475471)
A lot of this i think is down to how people drive. I feel nausea when one particular friends drives. His driving is aggressive.

But i can get the train and have 0 motion sickness.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:10PM (#16477922)
I've had that experience as well, but this is different. I don't generally get motion sickness in vehicles - but reading will make me get an upset stomach, regardless of who is driving. I just learned how to minimize some of it and realized the stuff I can do on long trips.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by artursapek on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:34PM (#16476417)
That's because the train doesn't stop and start, and make sharp turns nearly as often as a car.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by daveFNbuck on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:05AM (#16474648)
You could leave for work later and have your first daily meeting be part of your commute.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by ianmcgowan on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:57AM (#16475324)
In my experience a lot of BigCorps in my area (SFBay) already do that. The inevitable morning meetings filled with status updates, daily standups and plans for the day. Also with people beeping in and out, "sorry I was on mute" and all the associated nonsense that goes with it. No work gets done until after 10am...
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by gowld on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:20PM (#16477453)
People are having trouble connecting to an a priori useless meeting. Paging Dilbert.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Clanan on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:58AM (#16474559)
That's an excellent (unintended?) consequence. I would certainly be more amenable to a longer commute if I could work remotely from the car and count it as work time.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:44AM (#16475146)
We're not gonna reduce speeds. If anything we'll increase them because it's a near zero cost (in terms of taxpayer $) way of increasing capacity/throughput without more infrastructure.

I fully welcome pizza delivery at triple digit speeds.

The cost of travel (time, money, $otherMetric) is basically economic dead weight.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:54AM (#16475283)
How would we increase speeds? Self-driving cars aren't magic and can't defy the laws of physics. In most cities, roadways are at capacity already, and convincing people to switch from dense modes of transit to sparse modes of transit (in terms of people per square meter) would only exacerbate those capacity crunches. Surface roads with at-grade intersections can't be sped up meaningfully, and there's no space for relatively high-speed highways, not without spending exorbitant amounts of money on building them.

If anything, the fact that humans tend to do things like drive too fast for conditions or leave too little a gap for safety means that properly safe cars will go slower than the average driver.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by djrogers on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:12PM (#16475485)
Most commuting in the US is done on highways, no at-grade crossings, and most congestion is caused by the imperfection of humans driving (look up rubber banding effect on traffic). Self driving cars can use the same 4/5/6 lane highway MUCH more efficiently than mere mortals can...
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:29PM (#16475676)
If you watch the track (not at a station) of a "dense mode" of transit, say BART, what you will see is multiple minutes of zero density and then a few seconds of high density. If you can have some density all the time, one can have a car like amount of space for each person and have the same throughput as current, standing-room-only, train systems.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:08PM (#16476145)
But cars need lots of space as well too. If you actually run the numbers in practice, a section of track is actually more likely to be physically occupied than a section of roadway.

Numbers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16196483

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @02:03AM (#16481257)
I envision, with automatic cars, a situation where the cars run bumper-to-bumper, like train cars, and then can detach and exit the track. Best of both worlds.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @08:46AM (#16482896)
If cars run bumper-to-bumper, that mean the entire line must come to a halt when you detach one car, then the front half must move forward to give some clearance, the car can then leave, then the rear must speed up faster to catch the front half.

The experience from the train world is that having to switch trains on a line severely crimps performance: you can get 40tph on an unswitched line, but only about 30tph on a switched line. The limiting factor on trains tends to be ingress and egress.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by detaro on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @08:59AM (#16482972)
if they are physically coupled then yes, but if they are independent it likely would be more flexible and you could create and close spaces with smaller speed adjustments. Surely someone has already modeled this?

The biggest problem I see with approaches like this is how it's going to get going while they have to share roads with individual traffic. Street infrastructure isn't designed for long convoys that have to stick together, otherwise something like this would be a good start e.g. for trucking: Lead truck can even be human-driven, and a group of trucks in automatic mode follows as a closed unit while their drivers rest.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:37PM (#16484839)
Thus "The Boring Company" was born.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:31PM (#16475699)
We would increase speed limits. Self driving cars will likely be limited by the law. Nobody wants their self driving taxi to be going 55mph when the humans are doing 80. I described this in reply to a different comment.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16475369

>Surface roads with at-grade intersections can't be sped up meaningfully, and there's no space for relatively high-speed highways, not without spending exorbitant amounts of money on building them.

Every red left or right arrow could be replaced with a blinking yellow or solid green for starters. I think we'll see laws about stop signs being equivalent to yield if turning right.

There's a lot of inefficiency baked into the system as a means to mitigate stupid people at high volume points.

For example, we don't bother stopping cross traffic for someone to take a left on solid green but we do at an intersection with a dedicated left turn lane/arrow because of volume. The volume in the latter case is high so we bother to include redundancy to protect the several people per year that would cause problems if they tried to take the left without cross traffic stopping. It's not worth it to have a lane and an arrow to protect at an intersection with a lower volume of left turns so we use a solid green and left turning traffic yields. As self driving cars decrease the number of people that wouldn't be able to take the left on a solid green or blinking yellow then we'll gradually see more of those and less dedicated turn lanes.

>If anything, the fact that humans tend to do things like drive too fast for conditions or leave too little a gap for safety means that properly safe cars will go slower than the average driver.

What's "too fast" isn't defined by us. It's defined by how people actually drive in the conditions. A self driving vehicle that drives like a student driver and gets from A to B no faster than the letter of the law allows is at a huge disadvantage. Nobody's gonna buy a car that's 20% slower everywhere and frustrating to watch operate. Nobody's gonna recommend it to their friends if they have to press the override button every time they want to pull out into traffic in a timely manner or if they're always getting honked at.

Sure, you can hand wave about it not being a problem with full adoption but you need to get to full adoption first and that requires a product that's better in at least one way and comparable/acceptable in all the rest. Look at electric cars. They didn't exist in the high end until Tesla made one that was better in a few ways and comparable in the rest.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:10PM (#16476179)
> We would increase speed limits. Self driving cars will likely be limited by the law. Nobody wants their self driving taxi to be going 55mph when the humans are doing 80. I described this in reply to a different comment.

Higher speeds results in lower capacity. At higher speed, you need extra stopping distance for safety.

> Every red left or right arrow could be replaced with a blinking yellow or solid green for starters. I think we'll see laws about stop signs being equivalent to yield if turning right.

Too bad about those pedestrians, then.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by sbr464 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:52PM (#16476600)
There could be sensors placed at the intersection that could broadcast information about pedestrians to approaching cars. If a car cannot accept those signals, not compatible etc, it must stop, if it can, then it can include that data in it's decision process. We have offline tools like this currently with mirrors in garages, and blinking signs when a light will be red if on a fast moving highway.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#16478718)
That is completely unrealistic and downright dangerous. There are no sensors or pattern recognition algorithms which can detect pedestrians (and animals and bicyclists) reliably enough to even consider doing something like this. A false negative would literally be deadly.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by sbr464 on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:02AM (#16566309)
There are also currently no mainstream self driving cars. I believe the context is brainstorming ideas for things obtainable in the (near) future, not limiting ourselves to current tech. Although I feel a $50 motion sensor from the JC Penney dressing room may cover (or come close) to what you mentioned. We’ve been to the moon! Let’s not be so bleak.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:06PM (#16476748)
>Higher speeds results in lower capacity.

The car in front is not going to instantaneously stop. If it could then you can prove by induction why this conversation is irrelevant ;)

The effective road space occupied by a car is the car plus the distance in front of it. The distance in front increases with reaction distance, not stopping distance. Assuming everyone is (on average) always following at the safe minimum following distance for that speed then you get the same capacity and less travel time.

However, at lower speeds people (on average) tend to follow at greater than the theoretical safe minimum so as speed increases the average following distance gets closer to the safe minimum so higher speed = higher capacity. This is basically a long winded way of saying that following distance is determined by reaction time, not stopping distance and high speed traffic negates the outliers who use high speed following distances at low speed.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:26PM (#16477527)
> The car in front is not going to instantaneously stop. If it could then you can prove by induction why this conversation is irrelevant ;)

In normal conditions, no. But there are several circumstances in which cars could come to abrupt halts: sudden failures in road conditions (e.g., pothole), crashing into another cars, etc. There's a reason 100-car pileups are a thing.

> However, at lower speeds people (on average) tend to follow at greater than the theoretical safe minimum

What speeds are you thinking about? On urban highways, it is virtually impossible to travel at a safe driving distance, and this is at both freeflow speeds and congested (but not stop-and-go) speeds.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by Shivetya on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:25AM (#16474926)
but are they even close to delivering on that promise. Self Driving cars are marketed as a safety feature, safety features compensate for in bad and unpredictable conditions. Think ABS, air bags, traction control, and even seat belts.

Yet how many demonstrations of self driving are anything but well lit and well marked roadways? Self driving won't be a thing until regardless of weather and road conditions are person can have a car take them somewhere. Self driving will have to be smart enough to protect people who are actively driving from making a fatal error.

per that last point, if a self driving becomes a thing cars that can do it will have to intervene or have legislation absolving the system from fault if it does not. even the act of letting a self driving car exceed the speed limit raises legal issues. then comes privacy concerns, if you are not doing the driving then you can bet law enforcement is going to push to do a lot more on the grounds a self driving car has no rights

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by amelius on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:47PM (#16475901)
Traffic will slow to a crawl anyway, with all the unmanned self-driving cars driving around trying to avoid parking costs.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jacksmith21006 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:50PM (#16475943)
Do not think so. Cars will be where they should be and when and lower traffic.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by tim333 on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:30AM (#16480900)
They could tax them to avoid that.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by ksk on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:31PM (#16477008)
I personally feel the better option (prioritizing energy savings and time) is to avoid the commute altogether. We can figure out ways to structure workplaces and organizations where physical presence could be substituted by phone/email/skype or VR.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by efsavage on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:28PM (#16478110)
95% of the value to me of self-driving cars is being able to sleep/nap on the way, so I'd agree with you that a slower trip is generally going to be more tolerable.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by joe_the_user on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:36PM (#16478173)
Well, given skyrocketing housing prices, a self-driving mobile home would be a perfect solution. Living in a vehicle by the side of the road is against the law but living in a vehicle that's always moving from place to place seems like it's legal.

"Welcome to perverse-incentives-R-us, what paradox of this world of plenty can we serve you today?"

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by decacorn on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:36PM (#16475749)
this scenario still will not be possible for another 30 years