News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:54AM (#16475283)
How would we increase speeds? Self-driving cars aren't magic and can't defy the laws of physics. In most cities, roadways are at capacity already, and convincing people to switch from dense modes of transit to sparse modes of transit (in terms of people per square meter) would only exacerbate those capacity crunches. Surface roads with at-grade intersections can't be sped up meaningfully, and there's no space for relatively high-speed highways, not without spending exorbitant amounts of money on building them.

If anything, the fact that humans tend to do things like drive too fast for conditions or leave too little a gap for safety means that properly safe cars will go slower than the average driver.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by djrogers on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:12PM (#16475485)
Most commuting in the US is done on highways, no at-grade crossings, and most congestion is caused by the imperfection of humans driving (look up rubber banding effect on traffic). Self driving cars can use the same 4/5/6 lane highway MUCH more efficiently than mere mortals can...
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:29PM (#16475676)
If you watch the track (not at a station) of a "dense mode" of transit, say BART, what you will see is multiple minutes of zero density and then a few seconds of high density. If you can have some density all the time, one can have a car like amount of space for each person and have the same throughput as current, standing-room-only, train systems.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:08PM (#16476145)
But cars need lots of space as well too. If you actually run the numbers in practice, a section of track is actually more likely to be physically occupied than a section of roadway.

Numbers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16196483

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @02:03AM (#16481257)
I envision, with automatic cars, a situation where the cars run bumper-to-bumper, like train cars, and then can detach and exit the track. Best of both worlds.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @08:46AM (#16482896)
If cars run bumper-to-bumper, that mean the entire line must come to a halt when you detach one car, then the front half must move forward to give some clearance, the car can then leave, then the rear must speed up faster to catch the front half.

The experience from the train world is that having to switch trains on a line severely crimps performance: you can get 40tph on an unswitched line, but only about 30tph on a switched line. The limiting factor on trains tends to be ingress and egress.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by detaro on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @08:59AM (#16482972)
if they are physically coupled then yes, but if they are independent it likely would be more flexible and you could create and close spaces with smaller speed adjustments. Surely someone has already modeled this?

The biggest problem I see with approaches like this is how it's going to get going while they have to share roads with individual traffic. Street infrastructure isn't designed for long convoys that have to stick together, otherwise something like this would be a good start e.g. for trucking: Lead truck can even be human-driven, and a group of trucks in automatic mode follows as a closed unit while their drivers rest.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by njarboe on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:37PM (#16484839)
Thus "The Boring Company" was born.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:31PM (#16475699)
We would increase speed limits. Self driving cars will likely be limited by the law. Nobody wants their self driving taxi to be going 55mph when the humans are doing 80. I described this in reply to a different comment.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16475369

>Surface roads with at-grade intersections can't be sped up meaningfully, and there's no space for relatively high-speed highways, not without spending exorbitant amounts of money on building them.

Every red left or right arrow could be replaced with a blinking yellow or solid green for starters. I think we'll see laws about stop signs being equivalent to yield if turning right.

There's a lot of inefficiency baked into the system as a means to mitigate stupid people at high volume points.

For example, we don't bother stopping cross traffic for someone to take a left on solid green but we do at an intersection with a dedicated left turn lane/arrow because of volume. The volume in the latter case is high so we bother to include redundancy to protect the several people per year that would cause problems if they tried to take the left without cross traffic stopping. It's not worth it to have a lane and an arrow to protect at an intersection with a lower volume of left turns so we use a solid green and left turning traffic yields. As self driving cars decrease the number of people that wouldn't be able to take the left on a solid green or blinking yellow then we'll gradually see more of those and less dedicated turn lanes.

>If anything, the fact that humans tend to do things like drive too fast for conditions or leave too little a gap for safety means that properly safe cars will go slower than the average driver.

What's "too fast" isn't defined by us. It's defined by how people actually drive in the conditions. A self driving vehicle that drives like a student driver and gets from A to B no faster than the letter of the law allows is at a huge disadvantage. Nobody's gonna buy a car that's 20% slower everywhere and frustrating to watch operate. Nobody's gonna recommend it to their friends if they have to press the override button every time they want to pull out into traffic in a timely manner or if they're always getting honked at.

Sure, you can hand wave about it not being a problem with full adoption but you need to get to full adoption first and that requires a product that's better in at least one way and comparable/acceptable in all the rest. Look at electric cars. They didn't exist in the high end until Tesla made one that was better in a few ways and comparable in the rest.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:10PM (#16476179)
> We would increase speed limits. Self driving cars will likely be limited by the law. Nobody wants their self driving taxi to be going 55mph when the humans are doing 80. I described this in reply to a different comment.

Higher speeds results in lower capacity. At higher speed, you need extra stopping distance for safety.

> Every red left or right arrow could be replaced with a blinking yellow or solid green for starters. I think we'll see laws about stop signs being equivalent to yield if turning right.

Too bad about those pedestrians, then.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by sbr464 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:52PM (#16476600)
There could be sensors placed at the intersection that could broadcast information about pedestrians to approaching cars. If a car cannot accept those signals, not compatible etc, it must stop, if it can, then it can include that data in it's decision process. We have offline tools like this currently with mirrors in garages, and blinking signs when a light will be red if on a fast moving highway.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#16478718)
That is completely unrealistic and downright dangerous. There are no sensors or pattern recognition algorithms which can detect pedestrians (and animals and bicyclists) reliably enough to even consider doing something like this. A false negative would literally be deadly.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by sbr464 on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:02AM (#16566309)
There are also currently no mainstream self driving cars. I believe the context is brainstorming ideas for things obtainable in the (near) future, not limiting ourselves to current tech. Although I feel a $50 motion sensor from the JC Penney dressing room may cover (or come close) to what you mentioned. We’ve been to the moon! Let’s not be so bleak.
Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:06PM (#16476748)
>Higher speeds results in lower capacity.

The car in front is not going to instantaneously stop. If it could then you can prove by induction why this conversation is irrelevant ;)

The effective road space occupied by a car is the car plus the distance in front of it. The distance in front increases with reaction distance, not stopping distance. Assuming everyone is (on average) always following at the safe minimum following distance for that speed then you get the same capacity and less travel time.

However, at lower speeds people (on average) tend to follow at greater than the theoretical safe minimum so as speed increases the average following distance gets closer to the safe minimum so higher speed = higher capacity. This is basically a long winded way of saying that following distance is determined by reaction time, not stopping distance and high speed traffic negates the outliers who use high speed following distances at low speed.

Re:California to allow testing of self-driving cars without ... by jcranmer on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:26PM (#16477527)
> The car in front is not going to instantaneously stop. If it could then you can prove by induction why this conversation is irrelevant ;)

In normal conditions, no. But there are several circumstances in which cars could come to abrupt halts: sudden failures in road conditions (e.g., pothole), crashing into another cars, etc. There's a reason 100-car pileups are a thing.

> However, at lower speeds people (on average) tend to follow at greater than the theoretical safe minimum

What speeds are you thinking about? On urban highways, it is virtually impossible to travel at a safe driving distance, and this is at both freeflow speeds and congested (but not stop-and-go) speeds.