News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by forinti on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:38AM (#16123289)
I can't decide if Brexit is good or bad for the UK. On the one hand, there's the common market and freedom of movement. On the other there's Germany's dominance and lots of fragile banks.

What would be worse, losing access to the free market or being around if the banks fail? Or would being outside the market make a difference if Deutsche Bank failed?

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:46AM (#16123336)
Bad.

If anything because they'll have to rewrite thousands of laws and procedures that came from the EU times, and deal with the caos that that will cause. That only will cost so much money (and pain) that it would justify staying in the EU.

Then, of course there are companies that have left and that will leave, highly-skilled workflow for London that will be harder to get, etc.

They have to negotiate with the EU so that they're not completely cut out of commerce, with nothing to offer in exchange and therefore no negotiating power.

It's old people in the country that have decided this, based on their ignorance on the matter and lies spread before the vote. Funny enough, it's them who mainly benefit from European aid.

Pretty sad, really (I'm Italian, just talking based on what I've read and a handful of friends who live in London).

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by mkohlmyr on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:15AM (#16123531)
Your first argument boils down to "it's difficult to leave so why bother". That's an objectively terrible reason to stay, no matter your political affiliation or feelings about the EU.

As far as the "old people did this to us" meme. The 75% of young people who purportedly are so strongly against brexit probably should have bothered to vote if they wanted that outcome.

Additionally, there are other factors than just age that correspond to voting outcome. E.g. degree education, having a passport, income level.

And if we afford those people a bit of empathy rather than casting them all as gullible fools or bad people, we might consider that they actually stand to benefit far less (or have plausible reasons to feel this way) from the EU than someone (such as the average HN reader) who has the privilege to e.g. be choosy about employment opportunities, be able to afford educating themselves, be able to afford to travel at will.

In any case there are many reasons to feel ambivalent about the EU. I do, and I've taken every opportunity that membership has afforded me. I still don't like how (or by whom) it is run or how expansive its powers have become over time.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by b5 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:30AM (#16123648)
And if we afford those people a bit of empathy rather than casting them all as gullible fools or bad people, we might consider that they actually stand to benefit far less (or have plausible reasons to feel this way) from the EU than someone (such as the average HN reader) who has the privilege to e.g. be choosy about employment opportunities, be able to afford educating themselves, be able to afford to travel at will.

Thank you for writing your comment, and for this part in general. I voted 'Remain' but I couldn't agree more with what you wrote -- the backlash against those who voted 'Leave' has been appalling. With just a little bit more compassion, willingness to listen, and understanding, the division between both sides could possibly be healed. We seem further than ever from that, and the likelihood diminishes every day.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:37AM (#16123706)
Rationally, I agree with you. But if I went with my guts, from the little I know it was old people selling/ruining young people's life.

I'd be pretty pissed off, too.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:56AM (#16123824)
"it's difficult to leave so why bother"

- It's difficult to beat with a whisk than an electrical blender so why bother.

- It's difficult to play field sports with half a team so why bother.

- It's difficult to cut off your nose to spite your face so why bother.

At this time, this is how this argument sounds to me. The EU is an emergent phenomena. The natural course for a collection of neighbour states that wish to have peace and free trade.

The UK still wants to have peace and free trade for sure, but has decided to construct an entirely different artifice through which to pursue these goals, quite apart from the states with whom she wants to continue to have peace and free trade!

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:47AM (#16123762)
> Your first argument boils down to "it's difficult to leave so why bother".

How

> we might consider that they actually stand to benefit far less (or have plausible reasons to feel this way) from the EU than someone (such as the average HN reader)

Not really. I've seen documentaries where they showed how good Europe was (and still is) to the countryside in many countries where the State didn't allocate any resources and all of a sudden they had money to build libraries in small villages. Those villagers just didn't know where that money came from, but that doesn't change the fact. My girlfriend's sister lives in the Polish country and Europe is giving the area money to take care of the national park around her house that was previously left abandoned and in such bad conditions that you couldn't even walk around with the vegetation left to itself.

> I do, and I've taken every opportunity that membership has afforded me. I still don't like how (or by whom) it is run or how expansive its powers have become over time.

Actually, the EU seems to be pretty efficient, considered the huge amount of stuff they do. Of course, there's always room to complain, but I don't see any better alternative out there. If you're from the UK though, you'll get to see if your government is a better option I guess?

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by cmdkeen on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:11AM (#16123495)
While I appreciate Brexit hasn't happened yet there's little to no evidence yet of any exodus of highly skilled workforces. London remains an incredibly attractive destination for inflows of both investment, workers and tourists. Will some companies leave, no doubt, however the high profile mass departure of European HQs and banks has yet to bear out.

To the OP, and going back to the article, a major issue is that of services, our major export. The EU does not have a single market in services, and has shown little interest in progressing it. It isn't so much Deutsche Bank as the mittelstand that demonstrates that the EU as a whole favours particular economic systems. Italy is a prime example of a sclerotic services sector that their own government has failed to reform, despite the EU being willing and able to influence the appointment of Mario Monti it isn't willing to impose a free market in service in the same way it has for goods - and stand up to blatant protectionism.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by gambiting on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:56AM (#16123825)
This is purely anecdotal, of course, but our company which is a large software developer in the UK, is facing a lot of difficulty hiring from EU(candidates drop out citing Brexit half way through the process too) and we already had several EU employees leaving specifically because they don't want to live in UK anymore due to perceived hostility of Britain towards them. We also work with a local Russel group university and I know for a fact that after the referendum, number of applicants for PhD positions in CS from EU countries has dropped down from an average of 160 applications/year, to....3 applications last year. Everything that is happening is monumentally bad, but I think UK won't see some of the bad effects for years which of course makes everyone think it's absolutely fine.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:24AM (#16123597)
> there's little to no evidence yet of any exodus of highly skilled workforces

Like I mentioned, I'm speaking from what I read and a few friends living there. My friends all left because of uncertainty (all of them are programmers).

> Mario Monti it isn't willing to impose a free market in service in the same way it has for goods - and stand up to blatant protectionism

It's not protectionism, it's corruption and/or mafia. The government is ruled by companies (much like that of the US), and the mafia. Only when you realize this the initiatives they take (or don't take) start to make sense.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by DanBC on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:14AM (#16123522)
> there's little to no evidence yet of any exodus of highly skilled workforces

The NHS has plenty of evidence that EU workers (doctors, nurses, allied health professionals -- all skilled staff, all hard to replace from UK recruits) are leaving, and that's despite the clear assurances given by SoS Health that EU NHS staff are guaranteed to be allowed to stay.

EDIT: the guarantee of being allowed to stay was provided rather late, so many people left before it was given, but they're still leaving.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ljf on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:43AM (#16123743)
Indeed, here are two articles for those that are downvoting.

Brexit: One in five EU doctors make plans to leave NHS because of withdrawal - http://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/brexit-nhs-doctors-...

European nurses and midwives leaving UK in droves since Brexit vote - https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/nov/02/european-nur...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by DanBC on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:16AM (#16123956)
Here's a UK government report: http://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summ...

And here's a link to the NHS Digital Workforce statistics:

http://content.digital.nhs.uk/workforce

One example file is here: http://content.digital.nhs.uk/media/23993/Leavers-by-age-and...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ljf on Saturday January 13, 2018 @09:18AM (#16139687)
And more Fears of Brexit drain as more EU27 ambulance staff quit the NHS

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jan/13/nhs-ambulanc...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by hacker_9 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:15AM (#16123532)
Most of what you wrote is mis-information, for example it is written in the Repeal Bill [1] that all existing EU legislation will be copied across into domestic UK law to ensure a smooth transition on the day after Brexit.

Trade wise, there will be bumps, but it is mutually beneficial to both us and the EU to keep trading as much as possible the same as it is now. The only benefactors from making trading more difficult are the EU politicians who want to 'make an example of the UK' (Michel Barnier words).

Also these 'old people' were there when the UK voted to join the EU in 1975. So if they want out, then maybe they are seeing something you are not.

[1] https://services.parliament.uk/bills/2017-19/europeanunionwi...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by moomin on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:26AM (#16134046)
That's hugely misleading. It's one of those things that sounds reasonable if you're not a lawyer, but a lawyer will have questions:

1) Will cases be decided according to the same principles as currently? (No, the bill specifically strikes out specific principles, including the animal rights one.) 2) What will the status of existing EU case law be? (Unclear.) 3) What will the status of post-exit EU case law be? (Unclear.)

In other words, it'll be similar, but different enough that it's going to cause problems.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by AstralStorm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:28AM (#16124512)
It won't be kept up to date for sure. Plus the law will definitely change all arbitration clauses from ECJ to British version.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:22AM (#16123581)

    If anything because they'll have to rewrite thousands of
    laws and procedures that came from the EU times, and deal
    with the caos that that will cause.
I've never understood this argument. Surely all you have to do is write a law that says: in the absence of British law, default to EU legislation. That's the essence of the great repeal bill, is it not?

    They have to negotiate with the EU so that they're not
    completely cut out of commerce, with nothing to offer in 
    exchange and therefore no negotiating power.
Uhm, there is the little matter of the ~£60 billion shortfall that the EU has to find from somewhere.

    It's old people in the country that have decided this,
    based on their ignorance on the matter...
What makes you so sure that old people are more ignorant than young people? I think you'll find that it usually works the other way round.

    I'm Italian, just talking based on what I've read and a
    handful of friends who live in London
Take what you hear from London with a massive pinch of salt. The EU has done very well for Londoners, thank you very much, and they aren't very happy about the fact that the rest of the population of the UK have just made their comfortable futures a lot less certain.

Consequently, the rhetoric aimed at the other side comes with more than a little hyperbole.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by sornars on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:35AM (#16123689)

   I've never understood this argument. Surely all you have to do is write a law that says: in the absence of British law, default to EU legislation. That's the essence of the great repeal bill, is it not?
My understanding of one of the big issues with defaulting to EU law is that disputes under EU law are settled by the ECJ and EU regulatory bodies (which are governed by ECJ rulings). This is not suitable for post-Brexit Britain's red lines. Accommodating this requires revisiting and rewriting the law to use British equivalents and I suspect this is a more time consuming process than a simple find-replace job.

This is also why Theresa May plans to use the 'Henry VIII clauses'[1] which allows the Government to amend laws (in this case, the Great Repeal Bill) without further scrutiny from parliament. This is potentially problematic as those amendments can include pretty much anything.

[1] https://www.parliament.uk/site-information/glossary/henry-vi...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:05AM (#16123880)
Thanks for clarifying that for me.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tom_mellior on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:54AM (#16123815)
> there is the little matter of the ~£60 billion shortfall that the EU has to find from somewhere.

What is this figure? https://fullfact.org/europe/our-eu-membership-fee-55-million... claims a UK net contribution to the EU of UKP 8.6 billion in 2016.

You could argue that that would be a yearly shortfall over a number of years, is that what then comes out to 60 billion? Or are you talking about something else? Also there is the matter of the exit bill, which should offset part of that amount.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by EliRivers on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:27AM (#16123631)
Law is not a functional programming language, in which we insert facts, turn a handle and get an answer. The law is essentially what you can successfully argue, bolstered by existing law and case history and all the rest of it.

"in the absence of British law, default to EU legislation" would by no means be any kind of clarity, and I would anticipate such a thing would give years and even decades of discussion and argument in the various legal forums and courts to interpret that in all the various permutations and possibilities.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by crdoconnor on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:18AM (#16123550)
More than chaos I'm worried that it's going to be used as an excuse to ram through a lot of unpopular and horrible reforms 'under the radar'. Maybe NHS sell offs or a tax hike on "people who work" similar to recent Trump one.

You could practically see the Tories salivating when they mulled over the great repeal bill.

There are some positives - bringing the pound down is good for manufacturing output and employment. This is especially good for some of the more neglected areas of the UK. Of course, that will only give Londoners more reason to despise them - it's probably going to be worst for the London economy.

>It's old people in the country that have decided this

Actually that's not really true:

https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2017/10/brexit-cry-financial...

Just going to point out here that Brexit appears to be the ultimate in identitarian politics and that identitarian politics is all about divide and conquer and leave it at that.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by spiralx on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:05AM (#16123449)
> If anything because they'll have to rewrite thousands of laws and procedures that came from the EU times, and deal with the caos that that will cause. That only would justify stay in the EU.

No, we'll keep most of those laws, because in order to trade with the EU we'd have to comply with them anyway. We just lose any ability to control them.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:03AM (#16123430)
Losing access to the free market would be fine if we gain access to the global market, at least in the medium to long term. The ability to drop tariffs on imports would be a big deal even in the short term.

In reality, though, I don't see us leaving the trappings of the EU with this current govt: we'll just lose our seat at the table (to coin a phrase). This was never going to be quick, though: the Brexit issue will be at the centre of politics for at least a generation.

I'm actually more interested in how this has shone a light on the issue of the slow erosion of our sovereignty and our traditional British liberal values. On this point I agree with the author that the younger generation seem to be far more ambivalent about freedom of speech, democracy, et al. to the point that they seem to be actively suspicious of it.

The severity of this division has been a bit of a shock, but I'd rather we deal with it now than not at all, especially when Trump shows us that the alternative could have been to vote in a radical populist party instead, which would have had far more power than Trump has.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by Angostura on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:06AM (#16123451)
> the younger generation seem to be far more ambivalent about freedom of speech, democracy, et al. to the point that they seem to be actively suspicious of it.

Oddly enough, I suspect that the younger generation probably think that about the Daily Mail reading older generation.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:07AM (#16123463)
> the ability to drop tariffs on imports would be a big deal even in the short term

That is, the benefit is the ability to replace British-made goods with cheaper foreign imports? I'm just saying because normally people make the argument the other way round.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:03AM (#16123867)
Exactly so. Well, British and European goods.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ddalex on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:47AM (#16123764)
> slow erosion of our sovereignty

What exactly are changes in the UK's sovereignity?

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:22AM (#16123987)
The UK govt spends a lot of its time rubber stamping EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist.

I don't have time to give this reply the attention it deserves, but consider that it is now illegal to sell your home made jam in your local charity shop, and it was almost made illegal to tinker with your own motor vehicle. Then there's the never ending torrent of health and safety legislation.

These things aren't intended to destroy individual sovereignty, but that's what they end up doing. Perhaps this sort of thing matters more to the British than other nationals. An Englishman's home is his castle, as they saying goes.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:34AM (#16124071)
> EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist

What does that actually mean?

> now illegal to sell your home made jam in your local charity shop

I googled for this, and the only reference I could find was Mail and Express articles, so I suspect it's not true. The EU fake British news debunking site has this to say:

http://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/in-a-jam-over-non-existe...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Friday January 12, 2018 @09:27AM (#16132990)

    What does that actually mean?
It means that most of the laws that are passed by the EU are done so at the behest of big industry. All laws are proposed by the unelected EU commission, and they are lobbied heavily by the industries.

High tariffs on imported food are intended to protect the farming industry. Laws banning DIY are intended to protect the trades. Laws promoting green energy (read: noxious diesel gases) are designed to provide a ready market for German car manufacturers.

If you're British then you'll know about HS2, the high speed rail network nobody wants and many are protesting against. Everyone seems to agree that it will be a waste of money but the govt are determined to go ahead with it anyway.

Presuming this has nothing to do with TEN-R [1], which I doubt, you would think that the British govt might want to spend British tax-payers' money on British workers to build the trains, to help the economy and stuff, right? Well maybe they do, but they are required by law to put the tender out to the whole of the EU, so British companies actually make up the minority of bidders for the contract [2].

    I googled for this, and the only reference I could find
    was Mail and Express articles, so I suspect it's not true.
It is true. A friend of mine manages a charity shop and makes homemade jam, which she used to sell at the counter. She was forced to stop selling it after the legislation came in.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-European_high-speed_rail... [2] https://www.gov.uk/government/news/hs2-reveals-bidders-in-ra...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tpm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:46AM (#16124144)
It's not illegal to 'sell your home made jam in your local charity shop' in many EU countries, so if it is in UK it has either nothing to do with the EU or is a rule misinterpreted by local legislation (which happens quite often).

"EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist"

sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. But UK also wants to leave the jurisdiction of ECHR which is a very corporatist move.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Friday January 12, 2018 @09:31AM (#16133027)
I think you mean the ECJ. But either way, European courts aren't popular in the UK because they are able to override British law. Seems reasonable that the country that invented the concept of human rights might want to retain her jurisprudence.

As for the homemade jam, see above.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tpm on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:26AM (#16134048)
Both ECJ and ECHR, but Theresa May has been fighting a long war against the ECHR: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/theresa-may-ca...

And given that many times ECHR was the court that sided with individuals against either corporations or states, it's really hard to frame this as supporting individual freedom.

Yes, European courts are able to override British courts and British law, because the UK agreed to that. That's the mysterious element of UK's relation to anything European: the UK agrees to some rules and then complains about the consequences.

As for homemade jam:

- what laws banning DIY? Are they UK laws? Are you sure it's the EU who mandated the precise letter of the law?

- Yes, the British have the HS2 to tender out to the whole EU (which it is still a part of you know), because that is actually a way to save money and decrease local connections between builders and politicians, also known as corruption. These are rules the UK has agreed to. But they don't have to build an inch of HS2 against their will, as the HS2 is not financed by Brussels and therefore they don't have the say.

- laws promoting 'green' energy are a mixed bag, I agree with that. But they are getting better, Euro 6 for example has hit diesel car manufacturers hard. And not everything is about cars.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @09:12AM (#16158251)

    ...but Theresa May has been fighting a long war against
    the ECHR
I'm not often on May's side but I was in that case. How we got ourselves into the position where we were unable to expel a man as dangerous to civil society as that is beyond me.

    Yes, European courts are able to override British courts
    and British law, because the UK agreed to that. That's the
    mysterious element of UK's relation to anything European:
    the UK agrees to some rules and then complains about the
    consequences.
It's not that mysterious. The establishment are very pro EU, the British people not so much.

    As for homemade jam:

    - what laws banning DIY? Are they UK laws? Are you sure
    it's the EU who mandated the precise letter of the law?
At this point I don't really care. I get a bit tired of these circular arguments. If this really is just some parliamentary conspiracy theory to blame the EU for its own inadequacies then fine, let's take away the excuse.

To bring the discussion back to sovereignty, we've never had a discussion in the UK about the issue with regard to the EU. I don't think you can deny that have ceded at least some sovereignty to the EU, otherwise we wouldn't have the institutions you have already mentioned. The question is: how do we feel about it? Do we think those institutions are better, worse or indifferent?

You can't just take a country into a new political landscape and expect everyone to be just fine with it.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:47AM (#16123340)
Not sure how being outside the EU would help the UK against "Germany's dominance" Surely out of the EU means by definition that the UK has less control over Germany?
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:52AM (#16123365)
Sure, but Germany will have less control over the UK.

From what I can tell and have read Germany has huge influence on pretty much every country besides Poland and--perhaps--Hungary (I live in Poland, not sure about Hungary actually). Poland definitely thinks about its own citizens _first_, and _then_ at what's good for the EU, which is after all what politicians have been elected to do.

I'm Italian and Italy is a mess in part because of having no balls to stand up for what Italians would need. Totally different story in Poland, from what I can tell from living here.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:02AM (#16123423)
On this subject of not having a choice in accepting rules: https://medium.com/@gordonguthrie/no-deal-wont-happen-e185f9...

"This is a tale of three dates. On 13th August 1969 the Irish Taoiseach went on television and called on the United Nations to send a peacekeeping into the United Kingdom to protect Irish people in Derry and Belfast.

On 30th January 1972 the Parachute Regiment massacred 13 people on Bloody Sunday, and an Irish mob burnt the British Embassy in Dublin to the ground — thankfully with no deaths.

In between on 15th February 1971 Ireland decimalised its currency, the same day the British did. It introduced the new 7-sided 50p coin — designed by the British, identical in weight and shape but with the Harp on it, not the Crown.

Britain was a rule-maker for Ireland and Ireland was a rule-taker: and all its bile and hope and hatred and determination and pride and desperation and anger and fear and dreams could do nothing about it.

Its not as if Ireland didn’t have sovereignty and wouldn’t fight for it. Before becoming Taoiseach Jack Lynch served under Éamon De Valera and Seán Lemass, veterans both of 1916, with Dev coming within inches of being executed for his part.

This is where the UK stands now. There are three rule-makers, the US, China and the EU and everyone else takes."

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:24AM (#16123601)
I just want to highlight an an interesting parallel you've drawn here, between the "sovereignty" Ireland obtained leaving the UK, and the "sovereignty" the UK, or rather parts of England and Wales hope to obtain by leaving the EU.

Though we define ourselves as "different" from the English, we are very much "the same" in a great many respects, and there is nobody more like us in this world than the English. In that respect England is kind of like an older brother that periodically gives us a kick but whom we tell jokes about behind their back. But we love them all the same and they us.

However, you also allude to some human rights abuses by the crown in the North, and in some respects this was a continuation of policy that had heretofore gone on in the rest of Ireland.

Do you think this is far fetched? The potato famine for a start. This was very much a political matter, and not merely a matter of a few spuds. Then there was 1916 where by far in excess the majority of fatalities were civilian and inflicted by the British army trying to regain control. Not to mention the subsequent illegal executions.

This was the backdrop against which Ireland sought independence, which seems a bit different from the narrative beneath brexit which appears to read as "something something sovereignty something something take back control".

With all that said, the UK would do well to look at how Ireland fared economically after independence. Not too well for a number of years but our eventual accession into the European Union helped to relieve that.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by oblio on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:21AM (#16123984)
The EU is not "putting down" the UK economically.

And the UK can't really become a major tax haven (too many citizens, it would draw way too many resources from every big country... and too much attention).

I don't think the analogy holds.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:02AM (#16124239)
Did you mean to respond to GP?

This is effectively what I wrote, albeit with more detail and supporting arguments.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:11AM (#16123498)
> Poland and Hungary (luckily I live in Poland), which seem to me as the only countries that look after their own citizens _first_ and _then_ at what's good for the EU

As someone who lives in a country where loads of Hungarians move to because they don't like their government I'm not sure I can agree. From what I can see here Hungary has a massive brain drain and unless you live in Budapest the state of infrastructure and public services is less than stellar. Hungarians consistently poll as one of the most unhappy countries in the EU with trust to their own government.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:25AM (#16123617)
I'm also not entirely sure how well the Polish line holds of late either. Hasn't there been a bunch of religious conservatives elected there lately? I honestly don't know if what I'm reading is propaganda any more but it seems they were doing lots of ugly things like cracking down on free speech.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:35AM (#16123680)
> Hasn't there been a bunch of religious conservatives elected there lately?

Yes, like are most Poles. It makes sense, no..? Not my cup of tea, but what's wrong with that?

> I honestly don't know if what I'm reading is propaganda any more but it seems they were doing lots of ugly things like cracking down on free speech.

It's partly true. You're talking about an incident where they fined a newspaper for their coverage of protests by using a law that prohibited to incite violence. It's sure not cool, but when Italy's Berlusconi was governing 3 out of 6 main TV channels where his, and it was proved in court that he actively censored the other 3 government-controlled ones. Yet, no one is/was talking about Italy becoming a dictatorship.

The truth is that the media is very pro-EU, and therefore any little thing they do is the end of the world.

Having seen how Italy was _absolutely ruined_ by both Germany-fueled mass migrations and not standing up to the EU in general, I can't really blame them for not wanting to repeat other European countries' mistake(s).

Life in Poland is pretty great, honestly. Doing business is easy (or at least 1000 times easier than Italy), very high buying power, etc., and no tanks on the streets in sight so no coup happening anytime soon.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:38AM (#16123713)
Life in Poland is pretty great,

What's the story with unemployment there these days? I read recently it was among the highest in Europe?

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:50AM (#16123792)
Nope. You're probably confusing Poland with Greece.

Poland's unemployment rate is about 100% better than Ireland, Italy, France, and others and almost 50% better than the EU.

In big cities is perceptively non-existant among young people (my perception and my girlfriend's).

Here is a chart: https://www.statista.com/statistics/268830/unemployment-rate...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:15AM (#16123945)
Okay my bad. Hard to separate truth from fiction with everything that comes across in the media these days.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:37PM (#16125810)
Well it's not really surprising. People have been emigrating from Poland for a long time. This eventually has to show up in low unemployment numbers.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Friday January 12, 2018 @04:51AM (#16131673)
I thought that too, but when I looked at the numbers they're far from having the highest level of emigration [0] in Europe either, at 11.5% ...

[0] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DSts9UUW0AAKmXd.jpg:large

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:15AM (#16123537)
Yes, I don't know anything about Hungary, I can only talk about Poland because I live there.

I've updated my comment so that it's clearer that I don't know what I'm talking about when mentioning Hungary :-)

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by virgilp on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:57AM (#16123395)
Whoa there. I'm not so sure about Poland, but I'm pretty sure that Orban looks after himself first, second and third... only then comes "citizens" and "EU", and the order there is not clear.

In general, I'm deeply suspicious of politicians that claim "citizens first, EU second" - that seems counterproductive, unnecessary, and more likely to be empty populism than truth.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:04AM (#16123440)
I'm only speaking from experience and can't really talk about Hungary.

As for Poland, I can tell you that the difference with Italy is like night and day.

As Italians, we are often asked to make sacrifices for Europe (and we did, look up "tesoretto"), like if we were in danger of being kicked out of the EU.

It's a complicated matter, but in general Italy is more corrupt and hardly takes any meaningful step to improve its citizen's lives, while Poland (although barely less corrupt if I remember correctly? Not sure) looks after Poland's interests first, and then at what Germany would like Europe to do. The result is that living here is about 100 times easier compared to Italy.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by AstralStorm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:33AM (#16124579)
Instead we have locally corrupt politicians and expensive social programmes we cannot afford in any term.

More recently a grab at Department of Justice by executive branch.

As to unemployment in another branch, the underemployment stats are huge and salaries in median quite low.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tonyedgecombe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:57AM (#16123388)
Germany doesn't have much influence over the UK, largely because the UK isn't in the Euro.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by romland on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:57AM (#16123391)
Are you suggesting that Poland and Hungary are leechers?
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by Tomte on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:59AM (#16123405)
No, they are autocratic regimes, well on their way to full dictatorship within a few generations of "presidents".
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:05AM (#16123444)
Sure. Based on..?
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:10AM (#16123492)
Actually following the news of the Polish constitutional crisis?

(Translated into American: imagine if Trump decided to simply fire and replace the Democrat-appointed members of SCOTUS)

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:26AM (#16123620)
Translated into American: imagine if the president was able to appoint Supreme Court judges ;-)

Jokes aside, from that to saying that it will become a dictatorship... I just don't see it, sorry.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by nkkollaw on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:59AM (#16123404)
> Are you suggesting that Poland and Hungary are leechers?

No, are you?

I'm suggesting what I wrote in my comment.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by alkonaut on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:20AM (#16123570)
I live in Sweden and never even thought about how Germany "dominates". Is it just because I come from a much smaller country with much smaller population and therefore much smaller expectations about what we can accomplish on the world stage? Or is it because our views align much better with those of Germany, so we are part of the same "bloc" in EU politics whereas the UK would want to pull in another direction but can't?
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by adventured on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:46AM (#16123756)
If you go back a few years, there was a large hysteria across much of the Eurozone about German domination of the bloc. Magazine cover after magazine cover painting them in terrible light, including some going so far as to reference back to Nazi times.

That coincided with the post effects of the great recession, when Germany essentially refused to allow more liberal central bank posturing and action to try to follow the more aggressive US Fed lead on how to properly respond to the terrible recession and the financial system consequences. Germany wanted a very restrictive, conservative approach. There was a split at that point between the members that were suffering and Germany which was in mostly solid shape (the peak of the Greek disaster was also near a peak of the anti-German sentiment).

The US recovery took root relatively quickly, after about a year, thanks in part to the Fed taking aggressive action to stabilize the banks and financial system (the US would have seen Citi, Bank of America, etc. all collapse otherwise; those banks are now extremely healthy and printing massive profits again). It was only when the ECB finally copied the Fed's approach that the broad EU and Eurozone economies began to rapidly recover (and for those already in good shape, it has pushed them into something closer to economic boom). You can look at a chart of EU or Eurozone economic growth, you'll see a nasty double recessionary dip around 2011-2012. After that, the ECB finally began to shift its behavior and do what they should have done years prior, which has led to a sustained recovery in most parts of the EU since then (you see it in meaningfully increased growth rates, from Finland finally recovering after a disastrous 8-10 years, to Spain and Portugal finally seeing serious improvement, to German growth picking up, to French unemployment finally declining significantly, etc).

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by alkonaut on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:50AM (#16123791)
> there was a large hysteria across much of the Eurozone about German domination of the bloc. Magazine cover after magazine cover painting them in terrible light, including some going so far as to reference back to Nazi times.

I try to keep up with politics and news and saw none of this (I watch foreign TV but don't read foreign newspapers a lot). So I don't think there has been a lot of painting germany as a bad guy in Swedish media, no. Why that is, I can only speculate. Would be interesting to hear if the same is true in e.g. Denmark, Finland.

> That coincided with the post effects of the great recession, when Germany essentially refused to allow more liberal central bank posturing and action to try to follow the Fed lead on how to properly respond to the terrible recession and the financial system consequences

If the 2008 recession was behind it, Sweden recovered very quickly and wasn't as hard hit (Partly because we weren't as influenced by ECB interest rate politics). Perhaps that is also a reason.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by adventured on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:00AM (#16123847)
> So I don't think there has been a lot of painting germany as a bad guy in Swedish media, no

I think you have to consider that would very likely be because Sweden isn't in the Euro. For example there has been widespread blame in Finland, that their protracted economic suffering was from being unable to control their own currency to respond better to their long recessionary environment.

It got extremely heated amongst Eurozone members.

http://www.dw.com/en/germany-painted-as-villain-in-euro-cris...

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/feb/15/eurozone-de...

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/17/business/global/the-rest-o...

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/dec/26/german...

https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/politics/2012/06/angel...

"Why not blame Germany?"

https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2011/10/euro-cr...

"Who is responsible for the eurozone crisis? The simple answer: Germany"

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/who-is-responsible-for-t...

https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/politics/2012/06/angel...

"Eurozone recession deepened at end of 2012" (Germany was blamed for that, due to their ECB preferences of policy) -

http://www.bbc.com/news/business-21455423

"Two versus 'La Merkel'; Italy and France Team Up against Germany" (2012)

http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/two-versus-la-mer...

It keeps going for a hundred more stories like those. If you dig into local Greek, Spanish, Italian, French, British media over those couple of years, Germany is largely the villain of the Eurozone economic crisis. You'd even see it represented constantly on media sites like Imgur.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by djsumdog on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:01AM (#16123421)
I thnk Brexit is a good thing .. for the EU. The UK has refused to adopt the Euro. The GBP is totally overvalued. The UK/Ireland have no plans to join the Shengen zone (which is a good thing for American backpackers I'll admit, as when you're 90 days in the EU run out, you can stay in the UK for 120, until the reset period). Politically, the UK is more closely aligned to US foreign policy (that of war mongering) than the EU.

With such a long transition period, I'm guess most UK citizens living/working in Europe have hopefully started work visa application processes, in case the EU parliament decides to not allow a bi-lateral work agreement.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by JohnStrange on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:35AM (#16123681)
I believe Brexit is a loose-loose deal. It's bad for the UK because it causes a lot of complications without producing real benefits. Basically, the UK will loose lot of political influence and control while having to abide to the EU's trade rules anyway. It's bad for the EU, because the union may loose cohesion, as it may turn out that the UK is doing not so bad after all and local anti-European socialist and nationalist movements will capitalize on that a bit, because the EU looses influence on the US without the UK, and because the UK provided a counter-balance to the axis France-Germany and now smaller countries fear that the EU will move forward faster than they wish for.

My prediction is that the net result will make everyone a little worse off in 10-20 years from now than if the UK had stayed in the EU, but the effect will not be very noticeable and overall hard to quantify.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by Symmetry on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:05AM (#16123446)
Germany's dominance mostly just hurts countries that have to depend on the Euro, so not the UK. They experienced a little bit of the Eurozone's double dip recession brought on by premature tightening in 2011 but that was mostly a matter of trade exposure which isn't something that can change just by leaving the EU. And since the whole reason for the UK's trouble then was getting less trade from Europe then abandoning that trade altogether would be strictly worse.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:53AM (#16123371)
There are few "firewalls" between financial markets, there's one market and it's global. If there's another bank crisis, it's going to happen everywhere. Iceland was particularly badly hit and is not actually in the EU.

Let's not forget that the last crisis started in the "Anglosphere" (Lehman, RBS, Northern Rock, Anglo-Irish etc) and spread elsewhere!

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by isostatic on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:46AM (#16123335)
The UK isn't part of the euro, it will be just as badly affected by a collapse in european banks as our trade will still remain with europe
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ben_w on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:55AM (#16123383)
I thought London was supposed to be one of the major banking centres of Europe? So if the banks are fragile, the UK is just as exposed in that regards, or perhaps more exposed as it will no longer be (as?) able to ask the ECB for assistance?
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tonyedgecombe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:58AM (#16123401)
The UK isn't in the Euro so the ECB doesn't really matter to the UK.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ben_w on Friday January 12, 2018 @03:58AM (#16131472)
Noted. I kinda assumed ECB was for all EU states, not just for all Eurozone states.