News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:03AM (#16123430)
Losing access to the free market would be fine if we gain access to the global market, at least in the medium to long term. The ability to drop tariffs on imports would be a big deal even in the short term.

In reality, though, I don't see us leaving the trappings of the EU with this current govt: we'll just lose our seat at the table (to coin a phrase). This was never going to be quick, though: the Brexit issue will be at the centre of politics for at least a generation.

I'm actually more interested in how this has shone a light on the issue of the slow erosion of our sovereignty and our traditional British liberal values. On this point I agree with the author that the younger generation seem to be far more ambivalent about freedom of speech, democracy, et al. to the point that they seem to be actively suspicious of it.

The severity of this division has been a bit of a shock, but I'd rather we deal with it now than not at all, especially when Trump shows us that the alternative could have been to vote in a radical populist party instead, which would have had far more power than Trump has.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by Angostura on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:06AM (#16123451)
> the younger generation seem to be far more ambivalent about freedom of speech, democracy, et al. to the point that they seem to be actively suspicious of it.

Oddly enough, I suspect that the younger generation probably think that about the Daily Mail reading older generation.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:07AM (#16123463)
> the ability to drop tariffs on imports would be a big deal even in the short term

That is, the benefit is the ability to replace British-made goods with cheaper foreign imports? I'm just saying because normally people make the argument the other way round.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:03AM (#16123867)
Exactly so. Well, British and European goods.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by ddalex on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:47AM (#16123764)
> slow erosion of our sovereignty

What exactly are changes in the UK's sovereignity?

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:22AM (#16123987)
The UK govt spends a lot of its time rubber stamping EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist.

I don't have time to give this reply the attention it deserves, but consider that it is now illegal to sell your home made jam in your local charity shop, and it was almost made illegal to tinker with your own motor vehicle. Then there's the never ending torrent of health and safety legislation.

These things aren't intended to destroy individual sovereignty, but that's what they end up doing. Perhaps this sort of thing matters more to the British than other nationals. An Englishman's home is his castle, as they saying goes.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:34AM (#16124071)
> EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist

What does that actually mean?

> now illegal to sell your home made jam in your local charity shop

I googled for this, and the only reference I could find was Mail and Express articles, so I suspect it's not true. The EU fake British news debunking site has this to say:

http://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/in-a-jam-over-non-existe...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Friday January 12, 2018 @09:27AM (#16132990)

    What does that actually mean?
It means that most of the laws that are passed by the EU are done so at the behest of big industry. All laws are proposed by the unelected EU commission, and they are lobbied heavily by the industries.

High tariffs on imported food are intended to protect the farming industry. Laws banning DIY are intended to protect the trades. Laws promoting green energy (read: noxious diesel gases) are designed to provide a ready market for German car manufacturers.

If you're British then you'll know about HS2, the high speed rail network nobody wants and many are protesting against. Everyone seems to agree that it will be a waste of money but the govt are determined to go ahead with it anyway.

Presuming this has nothing to do with TEN-R [1], which I doubt, you would think that the British govt might want to spend British tax-payers' money on British workers to build the trains, to help the economy and stuff, right? Well maybe they do, but they are required by law to put the tender out to the whole of the EU, so British companies actually make up the minority of bidders for the contract [2].

    I googled for this, and the only reference I could find
    was Mail and Express articles, so I suspect it's not true.
It is true. A friend of mine manages a charity shop and makes homemade jam, which she used to sell at the counter. She was forced to stop selling it after the legislation came in.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-European_high-speed_rail... [2] https://www.gov.uk/government/news/hs2-reveals-bidders-in-ra...

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tpm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:46AM (#16124144)
It's not illegal to 'sell your home made jam in your local charity shop' in many EU countries, so if it is in UK it has either nothing to do with the EU or is a rule misinterpreted by local legislation (which happens quite often).

"EU legislation, which is largely corporatist, not individualist"

sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. But UK also wants to leave the jurisdiction of ECHR which is a very corporatist move.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Friday January 12, 2018 @09:31AM (#16133027)
I think you mean the ECJ. But either way, European courts aren't popular in the UK because they are able to override British law. Seems reasonable that the country that invented the concept of human rights might want to retain her jurisprudence.

As for the homemade jam, see above.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by tpm on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:26AM (#16134048)
Both ECJ and ECHR, but Theresa May has been fighting a long war against the ECHR: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/theresa-may-ca...

And given that many times ECHR was the court that sided with individuals against either corporations or states, it's really hard to frame this as supporting individual freedom.

Yes, European courts are able to override British courts and British law, because the UK agreed to that. That's the mysterious element of UK's relation to anything European: the UK agrees to some rules and then complains about the consequences.

As for homemade jam:

- what laws banning DIY? Are they UK laws? Are you sure it's the EU who mandated the precise letter of the law?

- Yes, the British have the HS2 to tender out to the whole EU (which it is still a part of you know), because that is actually a way to save money and decrease local connections between builders and politicians, also known as corruption. These are rules the UK has agreed to. But they don't have to build an inch of HS2 against their will, as the HS2 is not financed by Brussels and therefore they don't have the say.

- laws promoting 'green' energy are a mixed bag, I agree with that. But they are getting better, Euro 6 for example has hit diesel car manufacturers hard. And not everything is about cars.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by marrs on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @09:12AM (#16158251)

    ...but Theresa May has been fighting a long war against
    the ECHR
I'm not often on May's side but I was in that case. How we got ourselves into the position where we were unable to expel a man as dangerous to civil society as that is beyond me.

    Yes, European courts are able to override British courts
    and British law, because the UK agreed to that. That's the
    mysterious element of UK's relation to anything European:
    the UK agrees to some rules and then complains about the
    consequences.
It's not that mysterious. The establishment are very pro EU, the British people not so much.

    As for homemade jam:

    - what laws banning DIY? Are they UK laws? Are you sure
    it's the EU who mandated the precise letter of the law?
At this point I don't really care. I get a bit tired of these circular arguments. If this really is just some parliamentary conspiracy theory to blame the EU for its own inadequacies then fine, let's take away the excuse.

To bring the discussion back to sovereignty, we've never had a discussion in the UK about the issue with regard to the EU. I don't think you can deny that have ceded at least some sovereignty to the EU, otherwise we wouldn't have the institutions you have already mentioned. The question is: how do we feel about it? Do we think those institutions are better, worse or indifferent?

You can't just take a country into a new political landscape and expect everyone to be just fine with it.