News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:02AM (#16123423)
On this subject of not having a choice in accepting rules: https://medium.com/@gordonguthrie/no-deal-wont-happen-e185f9...

"This is a tale of three dates. On 13th August 1969 the Irish Taoiseach went on television and called on the United Nations to send a peacekeeping into the United Kingdom to protect Irish people in Derry and Belfast.

On 30th January 1972 the Parachute Regiment massacred 13 people on Bloody Sunday, and an Irish mob burnt the British Embassy in Dublin to the ground — thankfully with no deaths.

In between on 15th February 1971 Ireland decimalised its currency, the same day the British did. It introduced the new 7-sided 50p coin — designed by the British, identical in weight and shape but with the Harp on it, not the Crown.

Britain was a rule-maker for Ireland and Ireland was a rule-taker: and all its bile and hope and hatred and determination and pride and desperation and anger and fear and dreams could do nothing about it.

Its not as if Ireland didn’t have sovereignty and wouldn’t fight for it. Before becoming Taoiseach Jack Lynch served under Éamon De Valera and Seán Lemass, veterans both of 1916, with Dev coming within inches of being executed for his part.

This is where the UK stands now. There are three rule-makers, the US, China and the EU and everyone else takes."

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:24AM (#16123601)
I just want to highlight an an interesting parallel you've drawn here, between the "sovereignty" Ireland obtained leaving the UK, and the "sovereignty" the UK, or rather parts of England and Wales hope to obtain by leaving the EU.

Though we define ourselves as "different" from the English, we are very much "the same" in a great many respects, and there is nobody more like us in this world than the English. In that respect England is kind of like an older brother that periodically gives us a kick but whom we tell jokes about behind their back. But we love them all the same and they us.

However, you also allude to some human rights abuses by the crown in the North, and in some respects this was a continuation of policy that had heretofore gone on in the rest of Ireland.

Do you think this is far fetched? The potato famine for a start. This was very much a political matter, and not merely a matter of a few spuds. Then there was 1916 where by far in excess the majority of fatalities were civilian and inflicted by the British army trying to regain control. Not to mention the subsequent illegal executions.

This was the backdrop against which Ireland sought independence, which seems a bit different from the narrative beneath brexit which appears to read as "something something sovereignty something something take back control".

With all that said, the UK would do well to look at how Ireland fared economically after independence. Not too well for a number of years but our eventual accession into the European Union helped to relieve that.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by oblio on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:21AM (#16123984)
The EU is not "putting down" the UK economically.

And the UK can't really become a major tax haven (too many citizens, it would draw way too many resources from every big country... and too much attention).

I don't think the analogy holds.

Re:Does Brexit end not with a bang but a whimper? by rusk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:02AM (#16124239)
Did you mean to respond to GP?

This is effectively what I wrote, albeit with more detail and supporting arguments.