Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by jondubois on Sunday July 02, 2017 @05:56AM
(#14681765)
I'm tired of all these stories about reckless people remortgaging their houses to work on a startup. It's as though being reckless is a virtue. It's encouraging others to do the same and fall flat on their faces.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by TeMPOraL on Sunday July 02, 2017 @08:26AM
(#14682185)
The startup investment machine needs constant supply of fresh, young, foolish blood to work. Those stories are not written to help founders live a better life.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by jondubois on Monday July 03, 2017 @04:58AM
(#14686878)
It's scary to think that it's those same reckless people who end up being CEOs and industry leaders. I guess that explains why the stock market goes through violent cycles of booms and bursts. It means that everything appears to work exceptionally well until it all collapses due to lack of long-term foresight.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by falcolas on Sunday July 02, 2017 @10:12AM
(#14682550)
Any time this guy is brought up, I feel compelled to point out that he inherited a house he was able to sell, and held a > $250,000 a year job to create the seed for his investments. And he is still working (on this ad-laden site, as a motivational speaker) to supplement his income from investments.
Anybody with that kind of starting position could retire early. Most folks don't have that kind of starting position.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by mgkimsal on Sunday July 02, 2017 @10:20AM
(#14682585)
Thank you for that clarity. Something about it always bugged me, but didn't know all the history there.
Of course, there are plenty of folks who inherit a house, make $200k+, and still do not manage to have the discipline to do what he's done (reduce expenses, etc). But... yes, he's had lucky breaks and situations not everyone will have. To the extent he helps encourage people to reduce expenses and get a handle on their finances, it's useful, imo, but yeah, knowing how he got started can help keep a perspective on the advice.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by paulddraper on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:30PM
(#14683156)
You're probably one of those cranky people that don't like reading about lottery winners. Many thousands of people win the lottery every day, and you can too :/
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by keyle on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:59PM
(#14680812)
They will do alright because of the art and the amount of press already generating sales ahead of time.
That's what you need as an indie developer. A lot of publicity and great art. It doesn't matter that you essentially reproduce the exact same recipe as any other Nintendo platformer, as long as you have great art and music, people will love your content.
Similar to hollywood movies being a rehash of each other with different actors and a different setting. It's all about the human condition.
So yeah, in the rare case of Cuphead, they will do well. Maybe enough to make the next one, if they didn't over-extend themselves.
For most small indies though, I can tell you first hand, it's tough. Especially since the whole Hello Games and No Man Sky's debacle, every 'gamer' out there is out to hate indie by default. We're scammers in sheep clothing.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by 60654 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:26AM
(#14680895)
> That's what you need as an indie developer. A lot of publicity and great art. It doesn't matter that you essentially reproduce the exact same recipe as any other Nintendo platformer, as long as you have great art and music, people will love your content.
Oh how I wish that were true, it would make for such an easy formula to follow to commercial success! :)
The visual style is definitely unique, and will get them a lot of media attention. Good for them! But translating that into sales - that's not easy at all...
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by elcapitan on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:20AM
(#14681042)
Agree. I would say that part of that is due to the fact that gaming gets more open and new concepts and ideas are being introduced, which is naturally prone to underdelivering first, before becoming mainstream. This is similar to literature and movies and shows that the medium is growing up.
To some degree this is the result of the formulaic, hollywoodesque way how AAA games are being made, and the over-stated excitement about even small developments which indie games feature in terms of gameplay and storytelling.
On the other hand, there is also a significant hipster-ish culture around some games where "overhyped" really describes it. The documentation of attitude and lifestyle of the people who write and who play those games seems to be more important than the games themselves. This is similar to instagramming your own cooking all the time and instagramming your fashionable hip meals all the time.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by richardknop on Sunday July 02, 2017 @08:18AM
(#14682165)
Agree. I remembered Daikatana as a classic example of overhyped and underdelivered game. And it wasn't indie at all, it was a mainstream title from John Romero.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by detaro on Sunday July 02, 2017 @02:55AM
(#14681250)
> Especially since the whole Hello Games and No Man Sky's debacle, every 'gamer' out there is out to hate indie by default. We're scammers in sheep clothing.
Maybe I'm just missing that part of the community, but that seems over the top. Pre-orders and crowdfunding, now those got a relatively widespread bad rep, and some people dislike themes primarily covered by indie games, but I don't see very many people care about general "indieness" of the developer.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by flohofwoe on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:42AM
(#14681901)
That's a very optimistic view. Even if you do everything right, have enthusiastic press coverage, unique art style and gameplay, in the end it's still entirely a lottery. Betting the farm (or house in this case) on the success of one game is utterly insane.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by greenmana on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:16AM
(#14681029)
This is what bothers me about the "every man for himself" type of rhetoric in politics and wherever. If you just work hard enough, you can get everything for yourself with your own persistent commitment and then you deserve everything and blah blah. Of course that's a great place to get to, but there are tons of people out there doing just that, which means that not everyone gets to be the lucky ones. Societies should support and appreciate failure a lot more, and succesful people shouldn't generally be so entitled just because they won the hard working lottery. There's never enough space for all the people trying hard, and not the ones trying the hardest will always succeed. But it still makes me very happy when people give it their truly best shot.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by Cozumel on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:18PM
(#14680472)
Exactly. How many untold stories are there where they 'quit their jobs, remortgaged their houses' and now they live in a cardboard box under a bridge and their kids have been taken into care.
Passion is a fantastic asset but a lot of these people confuse it with stupidity.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by grecy on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:56PM
(#14680611)
> How many untold stories are there where they 'quit their jobs, remortgaged their houses' and now they live in a cardboard box under a bridge and their kids have been taken into care
Oh please, stop with the scare mentality.
Even if things go badly they are still educated, hard working people and would have no problem at all getting an entry level position in one day flat and living modestly for a decade or so.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by j7ake on Sunday July 02, 2017 @04:32AM
(#14681523)
I agree they won't be living in cardboard boxes but the majority of these business risks end up in failure, with a portion of those ending up with significant debt.
This debt can prevent sending kids to college, and being able to purchase a home. Many of these are historically considered attainable by the middle class.
It is not so clear whether it is always a good idea to go this route, considering other options. The survivorship bias is strong in this space and it needs to be taken into account.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by SyneRyder on Sunday July 02, 2017 @05:37AM
(#14681707)
> They're not going to live in cardboard boxes.
Maybe not, but I've seen quite a few indies with massive debt, and who are struggling with depression & anxiety as a result, and that's huge pressure on their family. Which makes keeping the family together an added anxiety, and then it's a vicious cycle. [It echoes the Phil Fish line from Indie Game: The Movie about wanting to kill himself.]
Burning yourself out on making a game (or a startup, or anything) is not worth that. Family and general happiness is so important. Keep things in scope so that if the lottery ticket doesn't work out, you've still got things to fall back on.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by PhasmaFelis on Sunday July 02, 2017 @04:11AM
(#14681467)
> Oh please, stop with the scare mentality.
This industry has a huge problem with survivorship bias. We keep encouraging people to burn themselves out doing startups that usually fail. Some cold reality is necessary, IMHO. By all means chase your dreams, but have a backup plan and don't bet anything you can't afford to lose.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by GuiA on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:22PM
(#14680695)
They're in Canada, so yes, you are correct - there is a fairly decent net of social programs that will cover them even if they go broke and get really sick or have to pay for their kids' education.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by taneq on Sunday July 02, 2017 @01:05AM
(#14680998)
> entry level position in one day flat and living modestly for a decade or so
It's still essentially setting your career back by 5-10 years... that's a significant downside. And given that it's by far the most likely outcome, it's foolish to discount it.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by koolba on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:21PM
(#14680690)
On the contrary, just like the repeated wisdom of controlling expenses and investing in diversified index funds, the merits of sticking with a steady job will always be espoused here. It's hacker news, not delusional koolaid news.
I take GPs comment to be a sincere hope that things work out for them.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by pcunite on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:31PM
(#14680516)
One of the most difficult things you'll do to explain success is say, "I just happened to be in the right place at the right time". So, lacking that, reasons must be provided to explain all that work and risk that was taken.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by tunetine on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:55PM
(#14680801)
I'm curious if anyone can provide insight as to what the profits of a moderately successful game would be. Let's say they've spent $600-700k over the past three years. Is there any possibility of them saving their homes without the game becoming a massive success?
To recoup $600k and then make another $600k in net profit (to be able to finance the next game, remember valve's 30% fee & taxes) will require it to basically be a huge hit in indie-terms.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by mattbee on Sunday July 02, 2017 @03:31PM
(#14683955)
I thought this community could recognise passion, hard work & genuine innovation, but wow, the comments on this thread. This team might not make their investment back, but they're shipping a game and a work of art in a way that literally nobody has tried before, and probably nobody will try again.
Cuphead is a bizarre and wonderful experiment in one way, and a classic genre piece in another. Yeah, you do have to try something different to stand out in indie games and this team is delivering. I've not been more excited for a title in years.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by rl3 on Sunday July 02, 2017 @12:00AM
(#14680815)
The art looks even better in motion, as the trailer shows.[0]
The resemblance to the cartoons of the era is uncanny. I really hope Disney doesn't sue them or something. Hopefully they're on rock-solid legal footing. In a just world all those copyrights would be ancient and long expired, but hey—Mickey Mouse is still Disney's IP until 2023, and they'll probably figure out something to keep it going past that.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by tribby on Sunday July 02, 2017 @07:10AM
(#14681983)
this reminds me more of fleischer than disney, personally, but there's no legal risk either way. disney can't point to imitators and call foul on white gloves or bouncing up and down, what disney can litigate is the use of its characters and names.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by draw_down on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:27PM
(#14680505)
I look forward to seeing it! I still remember seeing the trailer and now impressed I was, and was recently wondering what happened with it. If it lives up to its promise it will really be something.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by booleanbetrayal on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:45PM
(#14680778)
Been waiting for this game for over a year ... Think it'll make a big splash. Best of luck to the team. They're trying something new and injecting some actual art into the art form.
Re:“We quit our jobs, remortgaged our houses” – how passion ...
by yitchelle on Sunday July 02, 2017 @10:18AM
(#14682579)
While I like reading these type of posts, and getting inspired by it. I know that there are many, many more projects that did not make it and forced to close. Where are those stories? I would to read those and to learn from those.
Anybody with that kind of starting position could retire early. Most folks don't have that kind of starting position.
Of course, there are plenty of folks who inherit a house, make $200k+, and still do not manage to have the discipline to do what he's done (reduce expenses, etc). But... yes, he's had lucky breaks and situations not everyone will have. To the extent he helps encourage people to reduce expenses and get a handle on their finances, it's useful, imo, but yeah, knowing how he got started can help keep a perspective on the advice.
https://xkcd.com/1827/
That's what you need as an indie developer. A lot of publicity and great art. It doesn't matter that you essentially reproduce the exact same recipe as any other Nintendo platformer, as long as you have great art and music, people will love your content.
Similar to hollywood movies being a rehash of each other with different actors and a different setting. It's all about the human condition.
So yeah, in the rare case of Cuphead, they will do well. Maybe enough to make the next one, if they didn't over-extend themselves.
For most small indies though, I can tell you first hand, it's tough. Especially since the whole Hello Games and No Man Sky's debacle, every 'gamer' out there is out to hate indie by default. We're scammers in sheep clothing.
Oh how I wish that were true, it would make for such an easy formula to follow to commercial success! :)
The visual style is definitely unique, and will get them a lot of media attention. Good for them! But translating that into sales - that's not easy at all...
that's a bit of an over exaggeration. Gamers hate overhyped, but under delivered games. It doesn't matter if it's indie or not.
To some degree this is the result of the formulaic, hollywoodesque way how AAA games are being made, and the over-stated excitement about even small developments which indie games feature in terms of gameplay and storytelling.
On the other hand, there is also a significant hipster-ish culture around some games where "overhyped" really describes it. The documentation of attitude and lifestyle of the people who write and who play those games seems to be more important than the games themselves. This is similar to instagramming your own cooking all the time and instagramming your fashionable hip meals all the time.
Maybe I'm just missing that part of the community, but that seems over the top. Pre-orders and crowdfunding, now those got a relatively widespread bad rep, and some people dislike themes primarily covered by indie games, but I don't see very many people care about general "indieness" of the developer.
Passion is a fantastic asset but a lot of these people confuse it with stupidity.
Oh please, stop with the scare mentality.
Even if things go badly they are still educated, hard working people and would have no problem at all getting an entry level position in one day flat and living modestly for a decade or so.
They're not going to live in cardboard boxes.
This debt can prevent sending kids to college, and being able to purchase a home. Many of these are historically considered attainable by the middle class.
It is not so clear whether it is always a good idea to go this route, considering other options. The survivorship bias is strong in this space and it needs to be taken into account.
Maybe not, but I've seen quite a few indies with massive debt, and who are struggling with depression & anxiety as a result, and that's huge pressure on their family. Which makes keeping the family together an added anxiety, and then it's a vicious cycle. [It echoes the Phil Fish line from Indie Game: The Movie about wanting to kill himself.]
Burning yourself out on making a game (or a startup, or anything) is not worth that. Family and general happiness is so important. Keep things in scope so that if the lottery ticket doesn't work out, you've still got things to fall back on.
This industry has a huge problem with survivorship bias. We keep encouraging people to burn themselves out doing startups that usually fail. Some cold reality is necessary, IMHO. By all means chase your dreams, but have a backup plan and don't bet anything you can't afford to lose.
You bet, I'm driving around Africa right now! :)
this is me http://theroadchoseme.com
Not the case in every country.
It's still essentially setting your career back by 5-10 years... that's a significant downside. And given that it's by far the most likely outcome, it's foolish to discount it.
I.e. about 1/5 of your adult life. That's a huge setback, and I'd say a serious and irreparable damage to one's life.
I take GPs comment to be a sincere hope that things work out for them.
To recoup $600k and then make another $600k in net profit (to be able to finance the next game, remember valve's 30% fee & taxes) will require it to basically be a huge hit in indie-terms.
A positive outcome does not equal a wise choice.
Cuphead is a bizarre and wonderful experiment in one way, and a classic genre piece in another. Yeah, you do have to try something different to stand out in indie games and this team is delivering. I've not been more excited for a title in years.
The resemblance to the cartoons of the era is uncanny. I really hope Disney doesn't sue them or something. Hopefully they're on rock-solid legal footing. In a just world all those copyrights would be ancient and long expired, but hey—Mickey Mouse is still Disney's IP until 2023, and they'll probably figure out something to keep it going past that.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5iGwE0XJ1s
...which is actually pretty cool.
Cool site though. Didn't know it existed.