News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by dmix on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @02:13PM (#13979101)
Tesla recently announced they are ramping up their Model 3 production even more than what some people thought was already optimistic numbers: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-03-27/tesla-mod...

> For Musk to hit all of his targets, Tesla would need to build about 430,000 Model 3s by the end of next year. That’s more than all of the electric cars sold planet-wide last year.

> Even if half of the Model 3 inventory shipped to other countries, 2 U.S. sales under Musk’s targets would outpace the BMW 3 Series and the Mercedes C class—combined.

> To sell that many $35,000 sedans in the U.S. “would be absolutely unprecedented based on what we know about car markets today and how people spend their dollars,” said Salim Morsy, electric car analyst at Bloomberg New Energy Finance. “It could happen. I’m pretty sure it won’t.”

If they could pull this off this might be a great investment by Tencent.

It's also great for the car industry and environment as well. Especially considering their work on automated driving. If they get that many cars on the road it would give them a ton of data and a big advantage/lead in AI over other companies. But it could also be setting the bar too high and setting them up for failure (even though they might otherwise have nailed targets).

Regardless, as a design fan it would be interesting to see so many Teslas on the road. They are great looking cars.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by aphextron on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @02:40PM (#13979376)
> To sell that many $35,000 sedans in the U.S. “would be absolutely unprecedented based on what we know about car markets today and how people spend their dollars,” said Salim Morsy, electric car analyst at Bloomberg New Energy Finance. “It could happen. I’m pretty sure it won’t.”

Model 3's will sell literally as fast as Tesla can push them off the production line. The pent up demand for this thing is insane. Over 400,000 people have already paid $1000 deposits on their cars.

The only thing that could possibly stop Tesla is their own inability to deliver.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by hueving on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @02:44PM (#13979423)
Or withdrawals from people. The deposits are non-committal so people can cancel without losing anything.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by flexie on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#13980252)
I can't think of any product I'd rather have than a Tesla.

I think Tesla will sell millions of Model 3. Which other car is 400,000 people waiting patiently to buy for two years, even putting down a $1,000 deposit?

Tesla is doing to traditional car manufacturers what Apple did to Nokia.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:37PM (#13981892)
> Tesla is doing to traditional car manufacturers what Apple did to Nokia.

Sincerely, and with all due respect, this is a false analogy.

What happened to Nokia was pretty much self inflicted. Mismanagement, competing empires, complacency.

Apple did not start shipping low end brick phones and eat Nokia's market.

Post '08 bailout automotive manufacturers are lean and hungry (for the most part)

Furthermore, the 'traditional' car market, while slow to move, is not far behind. And in some cases is taking a longer view. E.g. Ford is going straight to Level 4 in 2022. Forget the ICE v. electric debate, that ship has sailed and everyone is heading to EV. The real battle will be to produce the safest self driving product.

I am long on TSLA, I expect them to do well however they are in a far riskier spot than Apple was when the iPhone dropped. They were healthy, profitable and experienced (+Jobs). TSLA is none of those.

I'm not disagreeing with your sentiment. I just thought we were past the Apple analogies.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jaimex2 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:25PM (#13982187)
I dont know...

Tesla is currently training their driving AI using the existing fleet in shadow mode. How do you skip this step and go straight to level 4? They need months of tuning outside a lab, worldwide.

A lot of car manufacturers still refuse to build an EV from the ground up. They are reusing an ICE platform and converting them to EVs.

Mazda don't even acknowledge that they need to build EVs. https://electrek.co/2017/03/07/mazda-no-pressure-from-custom...

heh, I'm sorry. Musk is still alive and surpassed Jobs long ago now, he's up to his 5th disruptive successful company. Online Payment, Cars, Space, Solar roofs and AI beat shiny laptop and smartphone.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:59PM (#13982366)
I see car companies getting off the shelf solutions from companies like Nvidia, which is what is being trained in Tesla's today. And Nvidia have their own demo. I genuinely wonder who owns the algorithm...

It actually makes sense to jump to level 4 from both a liability & design/platform perspective.

The fact that Tesla is bleeding through the first few stages with driver-in-the-loop doesn't necessarily mean they get to maintain a competitive advantage long term.

(Also, Mazda is a 2nd tier manufacturer, little resources, mostly Ford parts Inc drivetrain, engine and firmware)

Finally, I appreciate the Musk fandom. As someone with a little skin in TSLA, I aim to take an objective view fwiw.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by pmorici on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:50AM (#13983506)
That is no longer true with respect to Mazda.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:31AM (#13985075)
Good to know, just sold my '04 Mazda 6 which was pretty much all Ford. After looking it up I see that Ford reduced ownership from 1/3rd to 10% in '08. Thanks for the correction.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by kayoone on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @02:22AM (#13983880)
The german manufactures are not asleep at the wheel, get into the newest E-Class and despite it being a lot cheaper than a Model S, the self driving capabilities are impressive. Don't even let me start on the interieur quality, which is my biggest gripe with Tesla considering their price segment.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by vsl on Saturday April 01, 2017 @07:35AM (#14011628)
"Impressive" is not the word I'd use. If you didn't drive Model S, perhaps. Otherwise, meh.

http://www.thedrive.com/tech/4591/the-war-for-autonomous-dri...

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Tepix on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:47AM (#13984625)
I agree. However they are still behind with regards to cars that are designed from the ground up to be electric.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Retric on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:05PM (#13982088)
Car companies are selling bricks. In large part because of the used car market no company makes reliable and cheap because the cost conscious don't buy new cars.

Further, the dealer model forces high markups, heavy advertising, etc to attract the kind of people that buy new cars.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by AOsborn on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:17PM (#13982445)
Fair opinion, but I think you are arguing the wrong point.

Apple ate market share from Nokia because of brand advantage.

Many commentators mention that manufacturers are improving their EV product, but I think that boat has long sailed: Tesla vs. Ford won't be about features, but the brand.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:22PM (#13982787)
Sorry, when the product is north of 30K, you'll find a significant number of people will put what they can afford ahead of brand loyalty.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ethbro on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @09:17AM (#13985879)
Lots of people really love Ford.

And with an EV, there won't be that awkward moment when their friends ask how their transmission is doing...

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by NeutronBoy on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:16PM (#13982146)
> Which other car is 400,000 people waiting patiently to buy for two years, even putting down a $1,000 deposit?

None, but I would hazard a guess that's because if you want to buy a BMW, a Mercedes or an Audi, you don't need to. You can simply go and buy one!

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jkchu on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:54PM (#13982343)
But the closest thing to a $35k electric car from BMW, Mercedes, or Audi is BMW's i3 - which I think is targeting a different market.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by NeutronBoy on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:49AM (#13983495)
Agreed, but it's not about the brand - it's just that in the market segment for a $35-40k mid-size sedan, there's not a whole lot of need to wait two years for a car, which is why it's so uncommon. The reason it doesn't happen to other manufacturers, is because although they have 3-4 year lead times on new models they produce, they're still continuously producing the current models
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:38PM (#13983176)
Don't forget about two car households. We have an x1 and an i3 as our commuter car. The i3 will eventually be replaced with a Tesla, the x1 will not.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ryanmonroe on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:34AM (#13983712)
Mercedes has the $40k B-Class electric car.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by cjrp on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @09:54AM (#13986194)
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by coryfklein on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:03PM (#13982380)
How about retiring 2-5 years early? That's about what you get if you invest the $35k instead...
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Pxtl on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:10PM (#13982417)
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by alister on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:44AM (#13984618)
Here's another illustration of how our intuition about compound interest can be really wrong:

Futurama scene where Fry has been transported to the year 3000 and he still has his ATM card: The bank teller checks Fry's bank balance. She says, "You had 93 cents in your account in 2000. With an average interest rate of 2.25% compounded for 1000 years . . . that brings your balance to $4.3 billion dollars."

The math is correct. Plug those numbers into the compound interest formula, Pn = P0 (1 + r/100)^n, and you really do get $4.3 billion.

Your gut feeling is that even with 93 cents, you could retire rich. Not a billionaire, but comfy. It ain't so. In 50 years, you'd have $2.83. And even that $2 gain would be wiped out by a single monthly banking fee :-).

In 400 years, $6820. My intuition told me that I should be in the millions by then. Wasn't even close. Didn't even account for taxes and inflation.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by misja111 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:37AM (#13985098)
Another thing that many people forget is that while compound interest gives you more money, at the same time inflation makes your money worth less. So what you should really be looking at is the difference between the inflation and the interest rate: the so called 'real interest rate'. Currently in the US, that rate is negative ..
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by JBReefer on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:47AM (#13985548)
I feel like I can't get a handle on the inflation numbers I see. I pay - and the math checks out - roughly the same amount for gas, produce, and essentials. My smartphone is 1/3 the cost it was 10 years ago.

And then housing and health insurance is like 2.5 times higher. It all totals to be the official rate, but man does it feel uneven.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:42PM (#13983198)
Ten years is short. Thirty years at 6% gives you $200k, for instance.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Ntrails on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:31AM (#13984365)
what? Not on $1k it doesn't.

1.06^30 is like 5.5 ish? Unless you mean on saving 1k pa which is not what they are talking about, and means you're very much changing the game (and apparently not derisking towards retirement)

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:55AM (#13985624)
On $35k, the price of a Tesla, which is what prompted that xkcd link
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Ntrails on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @10:49AM (#13986738)
Ah, that makes more sense. Sorry!
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by sidegrid on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:48AM (#13985560)
35k?
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by thrillgore on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:05PM (#13988325)
My life priorities will be different when i'm 59.5 years old compared to now.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by antisthenes on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:57PM (#13981632)
I'm with you 100%.

If my basic needs like housing and healthcare were already met (unfortunately they aren't), my next purchase would probably be a Tesla or a Solar/Powerwall combo for the house, or both.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jordache on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:03AM (#13985232)
you do realize market forces for a $600 consumer device is very different than a durable good that costs 50x more?

Your anecdotal insight into how desirable the tesla is to you means nothing in terms of the market

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Matt3o12_ on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:33PM (#13979884)
Well, they lost access to $1,000 until they cancel (plus 3-6 weeks, since it can allegedly take Tesla this long to refund the money).

I don't think 400,000 have just $1,000 to spare for a really anything they will just cancel. The $1,000 mean that the person who reserved it really wanted the car and is unlikely to just refund it unless they have a very good reason to do so.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by slg on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:51PM (#13980571)
I think the commitment of $1000 is overblown. What is the actual opportunity cost here? Maybe $50-$150 depending on the interest rate and time frame you want to use for your estimates. That is nothing in the scale of a car purchase and it buys you the right to receive the car several months quicker. Relatively speaking it is like someone paying $10 to have a new laptop shipped to them overnight instead of by ground except the shipping has been prepurchased a year before the laptop.

If you aren't the type of person who can find a spare $1000, you also probably shouldn't be the type of person who spends $30,000 on a car.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MarkMc on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:14AM (#13985270)
You are missing the psychological element. In general, people:

(a) Feel a strong obligation to be consistent with past behaviour - not just in placing the deposit, but then thinking and reading about the new car design and wanting a Tesla for months or years.

(b) Want to avoid admitting the 'mistake' of giving Tesla a free loan. Not just admitting the mistake to themselves, but also to all their friends they told about their deposit.

(c) Hate giving up something they 'own' - ie. their place in the queue

(d) Value something that's scarce more than something that's easily available

(e) Are more likely to want something that other people love and are queueing up to buy.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MarkMc on Friday March 31, 2017 @01:05PM (#14005771)
Thinking about this a bit more, Musk should run a split test: Half the people queued for a Model 3 are offered $100 to move to the back of the queue. People who decline such an offer will feel compelled to buy the car when it is released in order to be consistent with their previous actions. I'm confident this would boost sales, but the split test would tell us for sure.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by rco8786 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:07PM (#13981201)
I think you vastly underestimate how much demand is represented by 400,000 people willing to part with $1k before a product even exists. Refundable or not.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by slg on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:38PM (#13981483)
I am not questioning the demand. I am questioning the commitment of people who put down a refundable deposit on a product they had very little information about. I am one of those people who threw down my $1000 before any of the presentations. I am still not sure whether I will purchase one. My interest has actually waned with recent leaks like the complete lack of any dashboard readouts. However I am still perfectly fine with Tesla keeping my deposit until I make a final decision. The opportunity costs of that extra $50-$150 is worth a lot less to me than the chance of securing a Tesla quickly if a do make the purchase (not to mention it increases my odds of a full federal tax rebate). I can't imagine I am the only one of the 400,000 with that mindset.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by dtparr on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:02AM (#13983553)
You're not the only one. I'm nearly identical. Losing access to $1k for a year or two (with the ability to get it back within a few weeks) is completely a non-factor, and since it increases my chance of a $7500 rebate, seems like a pretty good investment, actually.

Also, same feeling of 'meh' based on leaks so far. I was really hoping for a scaled down S with fewer amenities, lower performance, etc. rather than something from scratch. The no dashboard instrument cluster thing bugs me, as does the fact that AWD won't be available initially (hurting the chances of the rebate if I want AWD), but I'll wait until at least the final reveal if not later to make my decision.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by elihu on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#13980263)
The sort of people who would consider buying an expensive sedan can probably afford to loan Tesla $1000 for a year or so.

I reserved a Model 3 because I figured that if I didn't, I would be at the end of a very long waiting list and would probably lose out on the federal rebate. The most likely outcome is that I'll decide that's too much to spend on a car and cancel, but it still made sense to me to keep my options open.

I expect a lot of those reservations to be converted to actual sales, but a lot of them won't. In any case, I think Tesla will have plenty of demand if the product meets expectations.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Matt3o12_ on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:26PM (#13980875)
Fair enough but there are many foreigners who do not have a tax credit and still made a reservation.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by manquer on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:05PM (#13983014)
You could always sell it immediately.. you would probably get even a slightly higher price than you paid by impatient people
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by _ph_ on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:06PM (#13981190)
A $1000 deposit is a significant commitment to ordering the car, even if it is fully refundable. Very few people would do this until they are basically decided on buying this. For everyone who would reconsider, there are for certain plenty of people, who are interested in the car but would not put down money without a test drive first. So, judging from the deposits, I would rather assume the actual list of interested buyers way exceeds the amount of people who put money down.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by an_account on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:11PM (#13982422)
I disagree. I put down the deposit because I wanted to reserve my spot in line. Putting down $1k now isn't that much if it might save me $8K in tax credits by having an earlier spot in line.

I still haven't figured out if I can get a charger in my apartment building. I haven't decided I like the look of the car. I haven't even decided I want a sedan.

I love Tesla, so on the chance that I do want the car I put down the deposit. But I'm still 50/50 on actually buying it. I imagine many are in a similar positions.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by agumonkey on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:03PM (#13980682)
Curious, did Tesla published updated stats ? or anyone else for that matter. The announcement numbers were way above expectations, but it's not much if half of that evaporated after the hype.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by greglindahl on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:18PM (#13980828)
Apparently Tesla has not published an update. This article https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/03/14/teslas-model-3-res... guesses that the number hasn't changed much, due to the "Customer Deposits" line on Tesla's quarterly balance sheet.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by wfunction on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:25PM (#13979799)
> Or withdrawals from people. The deposits are non-committal so people can cancel without losing anything.

I feel this is going to be the killer for them.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MattRix on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:34PM (#13980412)
Sure, there will be tons of people who cancel... but then there will also be tons of people who wanted to wait until the car was fully finished before signing up to get one. They'll be fine.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by harichinnan on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:08PM (#13980728)
This is the car version iphone, with people queuing up at the store days before the product is seen. I would believe they would stop production exactly at 400K cars, the current waiting list and start a new Model 4 waiting list. They have an air of exclusivity now with their current models. People still gawk at the sight of a Tesla. They would want to maintain that awe factor with Model 3 as well.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by TheSmiddy on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:35PM (#13980936)
You're assuming a pure profit motive. Literally everything Elon Musk is doing has a strong element of trying to save the world.

The goal of Tesla is to make every new car sold electric, if they have to command 100% of the market they will do that, but they'd rather there be some competition.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MegaButts on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:13PM (#13982129)
> Literally everything Elon Musk is doing has a strong element of trying to save the world.

Maybe. Or maybe he's just saying that to make money. If Elon Musk ends up being completely successful in all of his endeavors, he will be the world's richest person by far.

I suspect the truth is in the middle. He does want to change the world, but he's not willing to become poor (let's say a net worth of less than a million dollars) in the process.

I have no problem with people getting rich, especially if they've earned it. But I see Elon Musk as a salesman more than anything, and he's damn good at it. He has generated a cult following of people who believe he is doing everything possible to save the planet.

I am very skeptical that Elon Musk is half as great as he's made out to be on certain internet forums. I do not mean to say he is not an incredibly accomplished person, only to say that he does not live up to his self-generated hype.

Of course time will tell. I truly hope he is as great as people make him out to be. But I just don't see it. Hopefully he makes me into a believer by delivering on all his promises.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:00PM (#13982984)
He's 79th richest person on the planet at age 45 with only Zuckerberg being richer while also being younger.

He was foundationally involved in one of the biggest early online payment companies, one of few private rocket launch companies with NASA contracts, basically the single electric car company to change the world's views on electric vehicles, and a major solar / battery company.

https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu...

https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu...

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2rgsan/i_am_elon_musk...

These are Reddit AMA quotes from a car company CEO.

Do you really think it's likely that he can't code, can't handle electronics, doesn't understand rocketry, doesn't understand any engineering, hasn't earned any riches, and is just tricking everyone and leading a cult of personality?

If the combined 50,000 employees of Tesla, SpaceX and Solar City can't deliver on his promises, that means he's a fraud? And if they can, it's solely down to his brilliance?

If he's only half as great as he's made out to be, that's still 200th richest person in the world and head of only one or two international industry changing companies, but that's just not good enough for you?

smh.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MegaButts on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:30PM (#13983138)
"I do not mean to say he is not an incredibly accomplished person, only to say that he does not live up to his self-generated hype."

I think that summarizes how I feel, which is why I said it. I never said any of the things you imply. But let's take a specific example which shows why Elon Musk isn't as great as he says.

Tesla's autopilot function has killed at least 2 people (one in the US and one in China). Elon Musk continues to spin this technology as amazing, and completely overhype the technology by saying it can achieve level 4 autonomy. As someone who's spent over 10 years working on self-driving cars, I can tell you definitively that the sensor suite on the upcoming Tesla cannot do it. And now you'll say "well maybe he knows something you don't" You're right - maybe he does. But if he doesn't then he's a liar and he should be called out on it because people have literally died and he has shirked himself of responsibility for it.

Elon Musk is a salesman first and foremost and people have literally died as a result of it.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by nickjarboe on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:34AM (#13983430)
World annual traffic deaths in 2010 were estimated by the WHO to be 1.25 million. If Elon Musk has the guts to let people voluntarily test out a system that ends up killing 100 people (and this estimate seems very high. The system could save more than it kills during development) but develops a system that reduces traffic deaths by just 50% one year earlier, that would be saving 625,000 lives. From a practical human suffering perspective, I am glad he is pushing hard to develop automatic cars a soon as possible.

Also: reusable rockets.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MegaButts on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:47AM (#13983481)
The problem with this is he is selling it as a working product. Imagine if pharmaceutical companies could eventually cure diseases by testing a drug on consumers, but sold it to them as working - when in reality it is going to kill a bunch of people while the company figures out what works. In the long run this could be a win, but would you be okay with that?

The obvious solution to my complaint - rename Autopilot something else so people don't confuse it as a self-driving car (and many people do think this).

I don't think Elon Musk is interested in educating the public. I think he's interested in dazzling them. Which is why he strikes me as a salesman.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Anchor on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:53AM (#13984451)
Imagine a car company that sells cars that may kill people driving them. And imagine that it would actually be one of the most common accident type that kills people. Would you be okay with that?

The thing is, every product is working and not working at the same time to a degree. It is only a matter of statistics - are we better off with or without the product.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MegaButts on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:57AM (#13985646)
The difference is, until recently, nobody knew the statistics for self-driving cars and how often they disengaged (by the way, Tesla is doing horribly in this regard). The information for traffic deaths has been public for decades.

Again, my emphasis is on the point that Elon Musk is spinning the information to his advantage. He has no interest in bringing attention to the shortfalls of his technology, only to sell the public on his soon-to-be-level-4 Autopilot system. He is also wildly misleading the public as to the capabilities of his technology, but unless you work on self-driving cars you wouldn't know that.

Of course it's his job to do this, and any sane businessman would. Which is entirely my point - Elon Musk is a salesman first and foremost.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Anchor on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @11:00AM (#13986874)
But he does bring the shortfalls to public attention, he has repeatedly said that driver's should not view current version of the system as self-driving vehicle, for example.

His plan is to evaluate the self-driving capability by comparing its performance to the human drivers, in shadow mode, perfect the technology to surpass human driver (10 times safer, per his comments), then present statistics from that to the relevant authorities (who should be qualified to evaluate any claim they make on these grounds), and only then proceed to release the self-driving technology to market.

I disagree that he is first a salesman. He is an engineer - and as an engineer he knows that anything he sells has to work or the product - and the company - does not last. He knows that very well, and has bet his fortunes on his engineering skills.

He is a salesman only second. And that is why this can actually work.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by consultSKI on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:04AM (#13984953)
>> Of course time will tell.

Time has already done that. He is simply put, the real deal. Major car OEMS are always talking about what they will do in three (or more) years from NOW. Elon has done it. Is doing it. And will continue to push the envelop. Zig Ziglar reminds us that EVERYONE sells. Elon is just that much better at it. Then he executes unlike very few others. I didn't get the merger, but now with the home batteries and commercial ones, I do. Brilliant.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MegaButts on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @09:07AM (#13985762)
Tesla is nowhere near GAAP profitable, and after numerous instances of "this is the last time we're raising money" Elon Musk has once again secured a large loan for Tesla. It is still very risky, especially now that GM is already selling the Bolt before the Model 3 has even come out.

SpaceX is nowhere near their goal of colonizing Mars. Yes, they are working on it, and more power to them, but it's not done yet. I love what this company has accomplished, but it's nowhere near reaching Musk's current trajectory.

Solar City went bankrupt and Elon had to pull several strings in order to save his relatives' company. Sure, there is an obvious alignment between Solar City and Tesla but it clearly wasn't doing great.

Elon Musk has an excellent track record of making promises and delivering on them years later. As his promises become more ambitious, and he spreads himself thinner, it becomes more and more likely that he will fail at some point. My money is on Elon Musk becoming the modern Greek tragedy. I want the guy to succeed, but he's clearly making promises he can't deliver with Tesla (it doesn't matter how good their software is - and frankly it's pretty bad compared to the competition - they can't make a level 4 vehicle with their intended sensor suite) and I suspect he's doing the same for SpaceX.

Elon Musk has accomplished a lot, and he deserves recognition for that. But if he makes a promise and fails, he should also be called out on his bullshit.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by harichinnan on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:12PM (#13982744)
Unless Musk gives away much of his wealth in his lifetime, he could very well be the world's first trillionaire. Think of Toyota and Exxon Mobil rolled into one with virtually no competition in sight.

To put things in perspective, this car is just 10 grand more than a full featured Toyota Camry. In countries that import both cars and oil like India, the price of the Tesla would be less than a Camry if they reduce the import tariffs. It's a foreseeable option to reduce foreign oil dependency. Also in developing countries, for every person that can afford to buy a Tesla and also knows how to drive, there would be dozens more who can't drive but could very well afford one. Once Tesla delivers their first 400K cars and proves they can drive themselves anywhere in the world, the demand would far exceed supply in the foreseeable future.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Tepix on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:54AM (#13984660)
He will need all the money he can get to realize the Mars colonization efforts.

If most of the things he plans to to are realized he will make even more money in the process.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by tuna-piano on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:44PM (#13979981)
I would assume that a company investing billions would try very hard to make accurate sales estimates.

I would be surprised if Tesla isn't surveying random people on the list, asking questions about their planned purchase and making estimates on the % that will end up cancelling.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by wfunction on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:51PM (#13980045)
> I would be surprised if Tesla isn't surveying random people on the list, asking questions about their planned purchase and making estimates on the % that will end up cancelling.

I hope this would give an accurate result. People might say one thing and do something else when they have to actually shell out the money...

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by philmcc on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:50PM (#13980561)
I disagree. The backlog will be so long, that there will almost certainly be someone who will pay for your spot in line.

The same thing happened with the S and the X. "Flipping" a 3 won't be difficult.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Tepix on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:57AM (#13984674)
That will be a good reason why people who choose not to buy a Model 3 for themselves will not cancel their preorder and sell it instead.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by mpclark on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:45PM (#13979991)
Is there a secondary market for places in the line?
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ryanmarsh on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:52PM (#13982639)
I can't remember a product that sold 400,000 preorders (many of which were sight unseen) with a $1,000 deposit in my lifetime. I think anyone trying to downplay the demand isn't looking at it in the right context.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by smogcutter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @02:51PM (#13979492)
A related concern is how well their repair and service operation scales. There are already repair horror stories all over internet for the relatively tiny number of cars already on the road.

The model S is a beautiful car, but it's a luxury toy. I'll venture that most Model S owners have at least one additional car. If you're in the market for a 35k sedan though, you're looking for a commuter and family car that needs to be reliable. Having it out of commission for three weeks while the one repair shop within 50 miles waits for a backordered part is unacceptable.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by w8vY7ER on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:41PM (#13979953)
It is worth noting that Jon McNeill (Pres. Global Sales and Service) took the time to post on a user forum in direct response to service delays and spoke with a fair bit of detail about how they are fixing the problem. Whether or not you are a fan, I think everyone can agree that this level of engagement is a strong positive for their cause. https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/posts/2004525/
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by smogcutter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:08PM (#13980731)
That's really interesting. Seems like the answer is they need a lot more third party shops - the problems that McNeill describes sound like the kind of thing that happens when there isn't enough competition. If I'm a model 3 customer, I don't really care about your service record in Palo Alto. What can you do for me in Skokie?

Very interested to see how all this plays out. The success or failure of the Model 3 could decide whether Tesla is the next Ford or the next Delorean.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by koreyb on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#13980848)
Ford doesn't do batteries, solar, supercharging stations, autopilot tech, etc. Delorean produced 8,583 vehicles. :) But I get your point.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:58PM (#13982041)
> autopilot tech

On the contrary. They're well along that path.

Not sure what solar has to do with cars.

And charging stations? Do you think that's profitable secret sauce?

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:04PM (#13983011)
Tesla bought SolarCity http://www.theverge.com/2016/11/21/13698314/tesla-completes-... - even if they totally flump on cars they still have solar installations, gigafactory (developments), charging stations they could lease and tech/patents they could sell to other EV manufacturers.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:44AM (#13985130)
Sorry, Tesla bought struggling Solar City as it needed a complete residential energy storage solution to leverage rebates from energy companies. I.e. the sum of the parts is greater than the whole in terms of final price to consumer.

SolarCity was/is $4B in debt at the time of the acquisition. If Tesla's car division fails, solar panels is not the cash cow the company is going to fall back on.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by koreyb on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @11:46AM (#13987382)
Let me know when Ford autopilot is available on the street. They did buy Argo, but current Ford projections are saying 2021..

"whether Tesla is the next Ford or the next Delorean" Tesla is neither of these because it is more than a car company. It is vertical integration that incumbents can't match at this point.

? Yes, of course. You must not own an electric car.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by radiorental on Thursday March 30, 2017 @11:22AM (#13996141)
> Yes, of course. You must not own an electric car.

You may have responded to me instead of someone else. I own a Leaf, I didn't say "whether Tesla is the next Ford or the next Delorean". I work at an organisation that supplies both Tesla & Ford with the toolchains in which they do all their control design. (And Nvidia for that matter). I'm intimately familiar with what these companies are doing today and are capable off. It's amazing to see what they are producing.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by koreyb on Thursday March 30, 2017 @12:18PM (#13996683)
Agreed.

"And charging stations? Do you think that's profitable secret sauce?"

Would you drive your Leaf from LA to Phoenix in a day? Guessing not. With the superchargers it's one more piece of the TSLA ecosystem.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by greglindahl on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:23PM (#13980859)
The problem McNeill discussed was related to 3rd party body shops. Tesla does not do any body work in its repair centers.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by smogcutter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:22PM (#13981807)
Right. The point is that soon they'll need a whole lot more of them, and first party repair centers as well. "Sorry, we have trouble with quality control at 3rd party shops" isn't going to cut it for a mass market car.

Re: Ford and Delorean, this is not the hill I want to die on. But what I mean is that the batteries, charging stations, etc, all live or die with the cars. If they can successfully create a mass market for consumer EVs, sky's the limit. If not, you can see a future where Detroit eats their lunch and the Model S is a footnote.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by greglindahl on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:32PM (#13981869)
Uh, what fraction of body shops do aluminum? Model 3 is not like Model S/X. And problems at body shops has nothing to do with problems at first party repair centers. I'm happy to agree that the future is uncertain, but you aren't adding much in the way of fact into the discussion.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by JBReefer on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:50AM (#13985578)
I'm sure a growing number do, now that the most popular vehicle in America is made out of the stuff (F150)
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by greglindahl on Thursday March 30, 2017 @01:04PM (#13997071)
Only a small fraction of the F150 is aluminum, but yes, I'm sure it's a growing number of body shops.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by koreyb on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:48PM (#13981030)
Yep :)
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by greglindahl on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:14PM (#13981264)
I was responding to smogcutter, not you. Your comment about Ford and Deloran was great, so I didn't need to make that point, and I upvoted you for it.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by koreyb on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:25PM (#13981363)
My mistake, I read it incorrectly.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by dilemma on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:06PM (#13982717)
So they need a network of dealers.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jd20 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:02PM (#13980667)
Personally, I've found The vehicle itself to be very reliable. But they need to scale out service operations. I can call an Audi dealer and have my car brought in within a couple days (or go to one of many third party shops). With Tesla, they're typically booking 1-2 months out (and that's in the bay area, where we have like 3 service centers). Luckily, the only times I've had to bring in my Tesla, it was something super non-trivial.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ithinkinstereo on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:08PM (#13979642)
This reminds me when the iPhone came out. Tesla is making a revolutionary new product. Millennials are also coming of age now through the next decade. Many of these buyers, either purchasing first-time, or upgrading their "college/hand-me-down" car, will buy Tesla, just because it's fashionable (ala iPhone).

I'm bullish on Tesla and Musk.

Edit: I should add that the product extends past the car itself. The whole direct to consumer, transparent pricing, no haggling, will win over a new generation of buyers.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Revisor on Thursday March 30, 2017 @03:46AM (#13993635)
> Millennials are also coming of age now through the next decade.

Millenials start from 1981 so some of them are nearing 40. Generation Z is coming of age.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by kpil on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:35PM (#13980420)
If they can deliver the cars, and at a reasonable price, you are probably spot on.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ithinkinstereo on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:07PM (#13981717)
I think for a young late 20s, early 30s professional with disposable income, maybe a baby on the way, it's really a no-brainer deciding between a 3-series, C-class, Volvo, vs a Model 3.

And if you can only afford a Camry/Altima/Jetta/etc. a 5-10K increase in price for a much better (perceived) product is also a no-brainer. People will def max out their credit to get the upgrade to a Tesla.

The above, doubly-so for Chinese consumers.

Model T :: iPod --> Model 3 :: iPhone

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:03PM (#13982078)
Does the model 3 have sufficient room for a rear facing car seat? One of my main concerns
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bitexploder on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:41PM (#13982576)
If I can fit a family of four in a 2012 Mustang it is nearly inconceivable a mid-size EV would not have enough space. Almost inconceivable that it won't have plenty of space.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by jd20 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:45PM (#13980514)
One thing I've wondered about this: exactly what data is Tesla able to collect from the vehicles on the road? I've not found this on their website, nor any way to opt-out of data collection. For a vehicle with an always-on camera and cellular connection that can't be shut off, you'd think more people would be concerned about this.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by taneq on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:41AM (#13984181)
This is my primary concern about Teslas. I'd love one from a pure tech and driving point of view, but I'm not willing to submit to a panopticon just to get one.

My second concern is aftermarket serviceability. I would never buy a car that the manufacturer could later remotely disable (leaving me with no recourse) just because they feel I've breached their ToS or something. Tesla is far too much like Silicon Valley software companies in that regard - 99.9% of the time "you'll be fine", but the other 0.1% of the time you're screwed and there's no way to fix it.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by SXX on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:58PM (#13981651)
How many people you know concerned about what data their phone software collect on them? Their laptop? Web browser? Facebook?

Probably not many. So Tesla will do just fine too.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by grecy on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:15PM (#13980239)
> “would be absolutely unprecedented based on what we know about car markets today and how people spend their dollars,” said Salim Morsy, “It could happen. I’m pretty sure it won’t.”

That quote implies people won't choose to buy that many Model 3's. We know there are almost that many pre-orders, so it's not a question, and it's not something to be doubted. It's a fact people will spend their money that way.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by kristianp on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:34PM (#13981879)
Isn't it an error for the article to compare the Model 3 to the luxury brands? The 3 isn't going to be a premium/luxury car like the S is.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:59AM (#13984683)
Has anyone looked into the various subsidies around the world? It seems that Tesla are smart enough to design around various regulations and taxes. SUVs became a thing in part because of differential tax treatment, and I've heard in the UK that company cars and business vehicles are heavily slanted towards electrification (both hybrid and full EV) I can see things changing faster than people would think based on the retail prices.

An interesting follow up would be investigating how much those subsidies cost or earn for the governments that provide them e.g. if you can provide all your electricity from homegrown hydro electricity rather than imported gasoline, then how much money does it save you to have an EV on the road. Is all that value being passed onto EV users?

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by forgotpwtomain on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:46PM (#13979997)
> environment as well

It's not going to do anything great for the environment and we've been over this on previous Tesla threads (years ago). Driving electric cars instead of hybrids in areas where the electricity is primarily derived from unclean sources is not better than hybrids for the environment.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by heygrady on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:57PM (#13981100)
> Driving electric cars where the electricity is from unclean sources is not better than hybrids for the environment

Some of the widely reported research about the power generation and electric cars is flawed [1]. Electric vehicles and hybrids come out about even in the worst markets, like Missouri [2]. But nearly everywhere else, an electric vehicle is better for the environment. People don't always consider that the electric grid is moving away from coal [3], which means your electric car will get greener during the time you own it without you having to upgrade it.

[1] http://midwestenergynews.com/2016/04/20/minnesota-study-chal...

[2] http://blog.ucsusa.org/rachael-nealer/gasoline-vs-electric-g...

[3] http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2016/08/renewab...

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by smilekzs on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:22PM (#13980301)
Unclean power plants are still vastly more efficient than the most efficient internal combustion engines. That's why trains are electric wherever possible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_locomotive

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by wott on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:45PM (#13982593)
> Unclean power plants are still vastly more efficient than the most efficient internal combustion engines.

I don't think so.

> That's why trains are electric wherever possible.

1. Thing is, you don't have to refuel electric locomotives, so that saves time and logistics. Unless you plan to install a pantograph on the roof of your Tesla, you still have to refuel it.

2. Unlike cars, diesel locomotives do not use any kind of direct transmission anyway, they generate electricity from Diesel engines to power electric motors. Because unlike cars, they have to transmit huge power and torque to make the first wheels turns, and mechanical transmissions are not good for that, but electric engines are. So since they use electric engines anyway, why not power them from electrical energy instead of diesel? That's why locomotives are electrical wherever possible.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Coincoin on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:14PM (#13982756)
You don't think so? Is that your opinion or a fact?

Most calculations I've seen seem to conclude electric are more CO2 efficient per mile; from 2 to 9 times depending on which state is producing the power.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:49PM (#13983228)
> Unclean power plants are still vastly more efficient than the most efficient internal combustion engines.

I'm an automotive engineer specializing in hybrid vehicle powertrains. Published and everything.

As of two years ago the only country in the world where the power source makes an EV not worthwhile, well-to-wheel emissions-wise, was India. Every other country in the world has clean enough power production to make EV cars an environmental net positive.

And I believe India's power is getting much cleaner over the next few years, so it may not be the case much longer.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by toephu2 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:14AM (#13983339)
Side topic: just curious what powers Caltrains's trains?
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by knappe on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:58PM (#13980110)
And everyone said that of the Prius too. And now we have fully electric cars. You have to start somewhere or you get nowhere.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by j6m8 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:23PM (#13980311)
The important distinction is that this abstracts the "cleanliness" away from the individual. Replacing one coal plant with a wind plant, for instance, is far more easily done than waiting for all affected consumers to replace their cars.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:55PM (#13983256)
> Driving electric cars instead of hybrids in areas where the electricity is primarily derived from unclean sources is not better than hybrids for the environment.

As of two years ago the only country where that was the case was India. Right before that, South Africa and China both became clean enough for EVs to be an environmental net positive.

Power produced in the US is some of the cleanest in the world, and getting cleaner every day as coal plants are decommissioned. We are well above the environmental net benefit line.

> Driving electric cars instead of hybrids in areas where the electricity is primarily derived from unclean sources is not better than hybrids for the environment.

There are no longer significant areas where this is the case. Even most coal markets in the US are clean enough (not sure what will happen with new de-regulations). The US, on average, is by far clean enough.

Source: I'm a hybrid vehicle powertrain engineer

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by kriro on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:01AM (#13984474)
The entire clean energy argument depends on your classification of nuclear energy. Long term storage issues put it squarely in the unclean category for me so I'd argue that US energy is by and large pretty unclean. I'm also pricing in the expected value of meltdowns in my unclean rating. It's hard to quantify exactly but the black swan events have pretty catastrophic consequences for the environment. Since I've witnessed two very severe ones in my lifetime, one in what many people would call a technically very advanced country I don't think it's unreasonable. If you think that's tinfoilhat-crazy, fell free to talk to an insurance or reinsurance company about insuring nuclear plants fur a fon conversation.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by bkanber on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @09:02AM (#13985698)
Nuclear power is only 20% of US energy production.

Nuclear waste is a political problem, not a scientific or engineering one. We're not allowed to recycle it the way we want. Blame President Carter.

Coal power puts more radiation into the atmosphere than nuclear does.

You have no idea how to "price" the cost of meltdowns into your "unclean" rating. TMI's incident did not have any effect on public safety.

I don't think it's tinfoil-hat-crazy, I just think it's uninformed.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by kriro on Friday March 31, 2017 @05:45AM (#14002320)
Just to clarify. the two incidents I was referring to were Chernobyl and Fukushima (as they are INES 7). The Three Mile you mention was "only" INES 5. I'd argue it's still pretty bad but INES 7 is what I'd consider the black swan events.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by Qwertious on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @10:25AM (#13986469)
>Driving electric cars instead of hybrids in areas where the electricity is primarily derived from unclean sources is not better than hybrids for the environment.

ICE cars are far less efficient than fossil-fuel power plants, due to the weight/size restraints of a car-engine form-factor. Given this, electric cars actually do emit less energy than cars that burn fossil fuels.

But frankly, you're looking at this the wrong way - most electric cars are at the start of their life, and have at least 10 years' worth of use, if not 20 or more. Given that renewables will inevitably become a major portion of the electricity grid within 10 years (and realistically, almost certainly within 5), they'll become more efficient in the future, and make renewables reduce even more CO2 emissions, since they're punting petrol away, too.

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by m_mueller on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:24PM (#13980332)
as you indicated - this depends on where you live - and if you're ready to just fix the problem yourself with solar power. Stating that it won't help is IMO misleading - Tesla is basically offering you all the missing tools to carry a high energy American lifestyle towards being carbon neutral. The footprint you missed in terms of consumed goods or at home, could be compensated by buying CO2 certificates.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16K4gNhy_AN8Eg4Ov3z7p...

Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by MattRix on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:36PM (#13980423)
Not better in the short term, but still better in the long term, as it leads to greater adoption of electric cars, etc.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by colordrops on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:19PM (#13980286)
What would you propose instead?
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by karussell on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:10PM (#13990100)
Instead of the battery the less toxic way would be hydrogen based engines.
Re:Tencent buys 5% of Tesla by colordrops on Thursday March 30, 2017 @01:43AM (#13993211)
How would you make the hydrogen though? Does it suffer the same criticism as your original comment?