Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by SwellJoe on Saturday March 11, 2017 @04:12PM
(#13847291)
The "half-maximized" feature sounds great, and one of the things that I feel like no one has right, still. Windows has actually gotten pretty good, surprisingly (drag to corners to get a quarter screen window, drag to sides to get half screen). Gnome is clumsier than I'd like. I really would love a window manager that handles tiling well, but doesn't require complete buy-in to a fully tiled concept. I doubt I'll be going back to Window Maker for this (I used it up until switching briefly to Enlightenment and then on to various Gnome standard window managers....Sawfish, and some others), but it seems like it's reasonably well thought out implementation.
Also, I find it really funny when a project has been around for decades, and has been regarded as stable for nearly as long, and still hasn't done a 1.0 release.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by zeotroph on Saturday March 11, 2017 @07:49PM
(#13848199)
Unfortunately in Window Maker the left/right edges of the screen move a window to another virtual desktop (by default), so this would have to be limited to the top or bottom edges which do not seem to have an action tied to them so far.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by sho_hn on Saturday March 11, 2017 @11:51PM
(#13849047)
And you can left click and middle click the maximize button on a window title bar to maximize it on the vertical and horizontal axises only. Combined with edge snapping making it easy to move a window on only one axis at that point, you can set up a few column tiles that way very easily.
Funny memory: I've been a KDE developer for 12 or 13 years. I think one of my first patches ever was a fix for the window manager to restore to correct window geometry when cancelling a partially maximized state using the restore action. A friend of mine was using the above feature to set up tiled text editors and I wanted to fix it for him.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by wernercd on Saturday March 11, 2017 @06:41PM
(#13847929)
I knew about and use the hell out of the Win+Arrow combo... but I didn't know you could drag to corners/sides to get the same effect.
Always nice to have alternatives - and I'm always dragging stuff around to different windows so it'll be nice to not have to drag, drop and then window key stuff.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by to3m on Sunday March 12, 2017 @10:18AM
(#13850745)
I'm going to plug my dispswitch program (https://github.com/tom-seddon/dispswitch - Windows only. You run it from a hotkey manager such as AutoHotKey). It does a better job of preserving monitor-relative size and position when you've got monitors with work rects of different sizes.
For tiling windows, try align_window3 (https://github.com/tom-seddon/align_window3 - again, it's for Windows, and use AutoHotKey). It gives you more portrait-friendly options than the Windows default stuff.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by shakna on Sunday March 12, 2017 @03:53AM
(#13849713)
> I really would love a window manager that handles tiling well, but doesn't require complete buy-in to a fully tiled concept.
I use OpenBox and awesomewm together. I can tile if I want, but I also have access to a more traditional approach.
Because of OpenBox's configuration of everything, I can often link the two together to do fun things like, tile all windows equally around my active window, that I can drag and resize as I like.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by thedaemon on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:28AM
(#13858047)
I use a similar application AltDrag. I can't live without it. I of course set it to the Win Key instead of Alt, as Alt key is used heavily in Blender and some other of the software that I use.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by vanderZwan on Sunday March 12, 2017 @06:17AM
(#13850084)
Yes, I know :). Taekwindow adds X11-like behaviour with ALT+left/right click drag to move/resize. Also let's you have scroll-under-cursor instead of scroll-focused-window behaviour.
So it's entirely complementary, and you can customise to your liking.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by simongr3dal on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:36PM
(#13847636)
Personally I find Magnet[1] (for Mac) to be wonderful, it moves your windows around to halves, thirds, and two-thirds presets with either dragging or keyboard shortcuts.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by Elv13 on Saturday March 11, 2017 @06:47PM
(#13847956)
AwesomeWM is both a tiling and floating WM. It has this feature (including snap to corner for 1/4). Awesome is a window manager framework allowing its users to be pretty much anything they want.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by marricks on Saturday March 11, 2017 @04:27PM
(#13847358)
Moom for Mac is great with near perfect functionality. Hover over the "Fullscreen" button and you can select by a customizable grid for size and placement. Also quick half sized options.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by X86BSD on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:04PM
(#13847507)
Argh! Yet another incredible piece of software I never heard of until stumbling across the posts here in a HN thread. Why is finding these great pieces of software so hard!
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by kitsunesoba on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:41PM
(#13847655)
Another fan here. There are other small utilities that provide the same functionality, but Moom is best to me because it doesn't hijack screen edges/corners, preventing accidental maximizing and playing more nicely with a workflow with an even mix of maximized and odd-sized windows.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by userbinator on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:34AM
(#13850584)
drag to corners to get a quarter screen window, drag to sides to get half screen
Incidentally, that behaviour was one of the first things I had to figure out how to turn off in Windows, because I just wanted to move the window there; I did NOT want to resize it. I found it quite annoying.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by wjoe on Sunday March 12, 2017 @09:25AM
(#13850551)
Cinnamon has similar "drag to edge" tiling as Windows, and you can also configure keyboard shortcuts for it - I have win+arrow keys configured to move windows to the edges/corners.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by michel-slm on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:19PM
(#13846715)
Feeling nostalgic ... Window Maker was my window manager of choice per year (up to the GNOME 1 days when it was still easy to run gnome-panel on top of WM).
The NeXTSTEP way in which menus can be triggered by right-clicking is really usable - I only wish it's possible to attach the app menu bar as well. The global menu bar approach of macOS and GNOME can feel a bit ridiculous on large displays.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by digi_owl on Saturday March 18, 2017 @12:24PM
(#13901991)
I have taken to likening Wayland to svgalib.
The basic task of Wayland is to facilitate that a program (most commonly a DE compositor/WM) can draw on the screen using the GPU without the programmer having to write OpenGL code.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by bcrescimanno on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:53PM
(#13846880)
> I only wish it's possible to attach the app menu bar as well. The global menu bar approach of macOS and GNOME can feel a bit ridiculous on large displays.
I personally disagree. It's still highly relevant to be able to "slam" the pointer upward to always land on the menu bar.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by mavhc on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:42PM
(#13847149)
Problem is returning to where you came from again.
RISC OS has the best menus, just click the mouse button anywhere in the window, maximum Fitts score, and you can select menu items and keep the menu open to select more, also select a menu item that has a submenu, and have windows as submenus, for palette selection etc
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by kitsunesoba on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:45PM
(#13847684)
>Problem is returning to where you came from again.
I have cursor speed set high on all of my machines for this very reason. Easy to slam edges, minimal movement to get back to where you started. It takes a day or so to adjust to being precise with small hand movements, but it was totally worth it, at least for me.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by kitsunesoba on Monday March 13, 2017 @09:39PM
(#13864266)
My day to day pointing device is a trackball (CST L-Trac) but I occasionally use a mouse and the trackpad on my MBP. At one point I used a dell precision laptop with a trackpoint. Pointer speed is high on all of them, and I used to use hot corners but now the only corner I use is bottom left for screen lock.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by zeotroph on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:38PM
(#13847642)
As someone still using Window Maker, these mini-DockApps are a a reason why I keep using it. The dock is on the left or right, so it does not take the more precious vertical screenspace. And dockapps are reasonably sized (64x64 pixels by default) and thus can show useful information. I am especially fond of one showing CPU activity like blobs in a lava lamp (wmforkplop).
I also got very used to the way WM does virtual desktops, though KDE can be configured to behave nearly identical by now.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by badsectoracula on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:24AM
(#13855217)
A unique feature to Window Maker's virtual desktops is the clip. The clip basically allows you to create a kind of separate dock per virtual desktop so if you have a separate VD per type of task (e.g. web, chat, code, art, media, games, etc) you can put the relevant launchers on the clip instead of the dock and leave only the global stuff (like docklets and utilities like a terminal, notepad, file browser, etc) in the dock.
I actually ignored that for years, until i decided to try it out and found it much easier to work with since i could create many more launchers than if i had to fit everything in the regular dock (of course i could also use drawers - which sadly are not yet supported by the clip - but i think having the launchers per virtual desktop is better).
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by dredmorbius on Sunday March 12, 2017 @03:25PM
(#13852523)
A number of the older WMs are not entirely dissimilar. Some aren't, though. FVWM for example has a grid rather than flat layout, which I find confusing (you might go left/right, you might go up/down). The boxes generally struck me as pretty good -- Blackbox I think most especially.
KDE comes close to WindowMaker in functionality (I've been watching/using that occasionally since ~1999), but never quite seems to get it right. KDE's windowlist, for example, isn't pinnable, and if you're walking that, you have to re-open, and re-acquire your current working spot, for each window you're traversing. That extra bit of friction rubs me raw every damned time.
The crazy thing about WindowMaker, for me, is how for such a ... not particulalry beautiful* desktop (though I find its asthetics completely acceptable), it's so damned useful. It's either exceptionally well designed ... or I've just got it cold-welded to my muscle memory. I couldn't honestly tell you which.
(Though I think its design is particularly good, with its design stability a major part of that.)
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by mixedbit on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:32PM
(#13847092)
Window Maker was my first encounter with virtual desktops and since I started using it I can no longer imagine working efficiently without virtual desktops. Was Window Maker the first manager that had virtual desktops?
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by antfarm on Saturday March 11, 2017 @04:04PM
(#13847249)
The first time I have seen virtual desktops was on a UNIX workstation running the FVWM window manager in 1995, a couple of years before Window Maker's inital release.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by fiorix on Saturday March 11, 2017 @06:37PM
(#13847914)
My first encounter with virtual desktops was on AfterStep, and later on I migrated to Window Maker as it was becoming more popular in Brazil. But I think CDE had virtual desktops long before. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Desktop_Environment
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by gnuvince on Saturday March 11, 2017 @09:25PM
(#13848567)
Window Maker was one of the reason why I decided to start using Linux back in 1999. I was running Windows 98 back then, and I was so taken by the style of the different window managers available for Linux. I marveled at how flexible Enlightenment looked and fvwm either looked like crap or like a work of art depending on the time the user spent in his configuration file.
But by far, my favorite look was Window Maker. I liked the large icons, the blocky menu, and the intriguing dockapps. After I managed to install Linux (that was a hard task for a 16 year-old who couldn't read English), I used Window Maker for a number of years. It was fast, it was functional, and it was really cool! These days I use LXDE with Openbox, but I'm always thrilled to hear about new developments in Window Maker.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by jwr on Saturday March 11, 2017 @04:37PM
(#13847398)
This brings back memories. I have screenshots of my desktop running Window Maker from 1997 (on a SparcStation). Guess I could start using it again, after 20 years :-)
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by jstewartmobile on Saturday March 11, 2017 @10:52PM
(#13848842)
I love WM. I hope they stay off the radar though. If it ever picks up any momentum, RedHat or the Gnome team are going to move in and start "improving" it.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by laumars on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:25PM
(#13847056)
Windows 95 and 98 worked pretty well with alternative shells. I think originally the option was there just so users could run the classic 3.x shell (progman.exe I think it was called) but it was pretty trivial to write you own ones; as I often did when I was bored.
You couldn't do much to change the title bars et al though.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by peller on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:35PM
(#13847115)
I don't think this is anymore a valid concern. From the Wayland FAQ:
"How can I replace Wayland's Window Manager?
The Wayland architecture integrates the display server, window manager and compositor into one process. You can think of Wayland as a toolkit for creating clients and compositors. It is not a specific single compositor or window manager. If you want a different window manager, you can write a new one. A 'libweston' effort is underway in order to allow new environments to reuse Weston's codebase and mechanics, whilst providing their own look and feel."
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by vertex-four on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:38PM
(#13847127)
There's a handful of Wayland compositor frameworks - including one built by the KDE project - and Weston provides an interface by which custom UIs can be created. I don't think there's going to be much of an issue, aside from potential problems with the spec itself.
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by notalaser on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:28AM
(#13849977)
Some of them can still be found if you look around on Google. Unfortunately, they haven't aged well -- their wallpapers are mostly for 4:3 monitors and low resolutions, the textures are for low-res screens etc..
Re:Window Maker 0.95.8 released
by ktRolster on Sunday March 12, 2017 @05:59PM
(#13853385)
Yeah, you're right. Back in 2001-2002 people would walk by my computer screen and be impressed, ask, "What OS is that??" Now the other OSes have caught up in appearance.
Also, I find it really funny when a project has been around for decades, and has been regarded as stable for nearly as long, and still hasn't done a 1.0 release.
Funny memory: I've been a KDE developer for 12 or 13 years. I think one of my first patches ever was a fix for the window manager to restore to correct window geometry when cancelling a partially maximized state using the restore action. A friend of mine was using the above feature to set up tiled text editors and I wanted to fix it for him.
Holy shit on a shingle... how did I not know about this magic incantation!
With those two features now in Windows (for a while) I could finally drop my autohotkey windowing script.
Always nice to have alternatives - and I'm always dragging stuff around to different windows so it'll be nice to not have to drag, drop and then window key stuff.
For tiling windows, try align_window3 (https://github.com/tom-seddon/align_window3 - again, it's for Windows, and use AutoHotKey). It gives you more portrait-friendly options than the Windows default stuff.
I use OpenBox and awesomewm together. I can tile if I want, but I also have access to a more traditional approach.
Because of OpenBox's configuration of everything, I can often link the two together to do fun things like, tile all windows equally around my active window, that I can drag and resize as I like.
Add a dash of Taekwindow to the mix, and you'll have everything you need:
http://taekwindow.net/
https://stefansundin.github.io/altdrag/
So it's entirely complementary, and you can customise to your liking.
You get granular ad-hoc tiling that fits the need you have when you have it.
http://mizage.com/divvy/
[1]: http://magnet.crowdcafe.com
(disclaimer, I am a contributor)
Thanks for the tip on it!
Incidentally, that behaviour was one of the first things I had to figure out how to turn off in Windows, because I just wanted to move the window there; I did NOT want to resize it. I found it quite annoying.
If an API, 1.0 means stable. If an application, 1.0 means fully featured (as dictated by the author or community).
The NeXTSTEP way in which menus can be triggered by right-clicking is really usable - I only wish it's possible to attach the app menu bar as well. The global menu bar approach of macOS and GNOME can feel a bit ridiculous on large displays.
One more thing to mourn the loss of with Wayland i guess...
The basic task of Wayland is to facilitate that a program (most commonly a DE compositor/WM) can draw on the screen using the GPU without the programmer having to write OpenGL code.
I personally disagree. It's still highly relevant to be able to "slam" the pointer upward to always land on the menu bar.
RISC OS has the best menus, just click the mouse button anywhere in the window, maximum Fitts score, and you can select menu items and keep the menu open to select more, also select a menu item that has a submenu, and have windows as submenus, for palette selection etc
I have cursor speed set high on all of my machines for this very reason. Easy to slam edges, minimal movement to get back to where you started. It takes a day or so to adjust to being precise with small hand movements, but it was totally worth it, at least for me.
Interesting, screen lock at bottom left. I'm guessing you're not using Windows, or that you open the menu with the Windows key if you do.
Window Maker became my favourite window manager around 1997, after trying out the majority of them since I installed Slackware 2.0 for the first time.
I kept on using it until around 2006, when I switched back to Windows as my main desktop.
Back the in day I had a nice collection of mini apples, pity that GNUStep never came to be fully integrated with it.
Nowadays my GNU/Linux VMs run Ubuntu/Unity, I guess I will have to try WM again. :)
I also got very used to the way WM does virtual desktops, though KDE can be configured to behave nearly identical by now.
I actually ignored that for years, until i decided to try it out and found it much easier to work with since i could create many more launchers than if i had to fit everything in the regular dock (of course i could also use drawers - which sadly are not yet supported by the clip - but i think having the launchers per virtual desktop is better).
The Windowlist shows all open windows. You can pin it, then walk through the list if you've lost track of something.
Windows can be pinned to all desktops.
Nothing I've seen in 30 years comes close.
KDE comes close to WindowMaker in functionality (I've been watching/using that occasionally since ~1999), but never quite seems to get it right. KDE's windowlist, for example, isn't pinnable, and if you're walking that, you have to re-open, and re-acquire your current working spot, for each window you're traversing. That extra bit of friction rubs me raw every damned time.
The crazy thing about WindowMaker, for me, is how for such a ... not particulalry beautiful* desktop (though I find its asthetics completely acceptable), it's so damned useful. It's either exceptionally well designed ... or I've just got it cold-welded to my muscle memory. I couldn't honestly tell you which.
(Though I think its design is particularly good, with its design stability a major part of that.)
But by far, my favorite look was Window Maker. I liked the large icons, the blocky menu, and the intriguing dockapps. After I managed to install Linux (that was a hard task for a 16 year-old who couldn't read English), I used Window Maker for a number of years. It was fast, it was functional, and it was really cool! These days I use LXDE with Openbox, but I'm always thrilled to hear about new developments in Window Maker.
On Windows there is LiteStep which is free and fully customizable. Makes Windows more palatable.
You couldn't do much to change the title bars et al though.
"How can I replace Wayland's Window Manager?
The Wayland architecture integrates the display server, window manager and compositor into one process. You can think of Wayland as a toolkit for creating clients and compositors. It is not a specific single compositor or window manager. If you want a different window manager, you can write a new one. A 'libweston' effort is underway in order to allow new environments to reuse Weston's codebase and mechanics, whilst providing their own look and feel."
And here's a list of "alternative" WMs already in progress for Wayland/Weston: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Wayland#Window_managers...
box-look.org has a few more recent ones.
Thanks.
So fvwm95 will also come with a release?