News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:30AM (#13722986)
According to the official statistics on The Swedish Crime Survey, the sexual violence rate in Sweden remained about the same between 2005 and 2014. The refugee crisis began around 2014, and since then, the rates for sexual violence went down in 2015[1] something you never see mentioned on certain parts of the internet. 2016 saw an increase in crimes, but still less than pre-immigration levels in 2014.

Also the Swedish national council for crime prevention expected this rise over the last few years because in 2013(before there was a serious influx of migrants) Sweden broadened the definition of rape. A similar increase in crime was seen around 2006 because of 'legislative changes' about how things were recorded.

In the US research on the link between immigration and crime largely find no link between the two[2], and of the relative minority of studies that find a link, there are twice as many studies that find that increased migration reduces crime as the reverse.

In Germany, refugees are less likely to commit a crime than the average citizen[3]. From the publicly available information it is impossible to conclude with certainty that taking in refugees increases crime, especially considering that the vast majority of 'crimes' they do commit are non-violent things like not travelling with a ticket.[3]

What is rarely mentioned is the increasing crimes committed against refugees in refugee camps. In germany, there were 1,029 attacks against refugee residences in 2015, following 199 in 2014. Attacks on refugees increase the crime rate themselves.

[1]-https://www.bra.se/bra/bra-in-english/home/crime-and-statist...

[2]-(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_crime#United_S...).

[3]-https://www.thelocal.de/20151113/police-refugees-commit-less...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by polack on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:01AM (#13723205)
It's totally irrelevant that the crimes has decreased. The point is that a majority of all violence and sexual crimes is performed by immigrants (as confirmed by Sweden's most famous crime professor GW a couple of days ago).

Why are you so afraid to see that immigrants are over represented in this category of crimes?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by freeflight on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:40AM (#13723520)
>The point is that a majority of all violence and sexual crimes is performed by immigrants

Source please? Because the available data, at least for Germany, does not support this claim at all.

Latest BKA report from first quarter of 2016 puts the amount of "offenses against sexual self-determination" for migrants at 1.10%. [1]

As somebody who's lived over 10 years right next to Bavaria's biggest initial reception center, in Zirndorf, I'm always amazed by all those claims as to how insanely criminal these people supposedly are. I've never witnessed anything like that, Zirndorf is actually quite peaceful town with barely anything ever happening.

[1]- https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/EN/Themen/Siche...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by rndgermandude on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:55AM (#13723642)
Not attempting to prove the grandparent right (because they are not), but the 1.1% figure is misleading. It's the portion of migrant crimes that are sex crimes, not the portion of sex crimes committed by migrants of the all sex crimes.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Paradigma11 on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:58PM (#13725921)
"The point is that a majority of all violence and sexual crimes is performed by immigrants" I definitely read that as "the portion of sex crimes committed by migrants of the all sex crimes".
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by rndgermandude on Friday February 24, 2017 @06:18PM (#13728848)
I was referring to the BND report taking about "1.1%", not that...
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by beefield on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:20AM (#13723358)
> It's totally irrelevant that the crimes has decreased.

That depends. If you are looking for excuses for racism, it obviously is not relevant. But if you claim that the Swedish society has turned dangerous because of the immigrant crimes, it should be highly relevant for the discussion.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by dep_b on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:41AM (#13723525)
> If you are looking for excuses for racism

Why is the conclusion that immigrants dominate the statistics of violence against women racist? I don't think there are many people who believe the cause of this statistic is genetic.

I thought women should be safe regardless the perpetrator but there is this weird dual standard where the whole company Uber (correctly!) gets the blame because of it's douchebag culture even when some of it's key executives don't directly partake in denigrating women, yet when migrants dominate negative statistics in far worse crimes against women all of a sudden imagined racism is the worst crime instead of actually abuse of women.

I think the problem with that particular violent subset of the Muslim subset of immigrants is exactly what you try to blame other people for: right-wing asshole mysogonist gay jew or "soft men" (i.e. respectful mostly left wing so yes you) hating retards. With absolutely no ground for respect let alone a chance of a better life in a modern society. And you should fight them with the same energy you fight "native" right wing hate groups.

People fleeing from that kind of violent and oppressive people should not go to Sweden only to be confronted by exactly the same people they were trying to get away of.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by daveguy on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:20AM (#13724976)
> Why is the conclusion that immigrants dominate the statistics of violence against women racist?

Because it appears to be a made up conclusion for the purpose of stoking anti-immigrant sentiment. You have yet to provide a source. OP has sources. GP has sources. You have fear mongering.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by dep_b on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:36PM (#13728576)
> The 2005 report by the Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention studying 4.4 million Swedes between the ages of 15 and 51 during the period 1997-2001 found that 58.9% of crime suspects were born to two Swedish parents (74.5% of total population), 10.4% of those born to one Swedish parent (9.3% of total population), 5.2% of those born to two foreign parents (3.2% of total population), and 25% of foreign-born individuals (13.1% of total population). The report found that male immigrants were four times more likely to be investigated for lethal violence and robbery than ethnic Swedes. In addition, male immigrants were three times more likely to be investigated for violent assault, and five times more likely to be investigated for sex crimes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_crime#Sweden

If you don't think WikiPedia is correct feel free to change the lemma, I bet they can use a certified statistician like you with all kinds of sources to prove them wrong. But until then:

Five times as much

And now I need to believe that I'm the one that needs to be corrected?

And another thing: once you split it up to region there's a bigger difference. East Asian and Western immigrants generally have lower or similar statistics compared to natives, meaning there are also groups that exceed the five times average.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by beefield on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:53PM (#13728693)
> And now I need to believe that I'm the one that needs to be corrected?

Your original claim was:

> immigrants dominate the statistics of violence against women

Let's see what "dominate" means [1]:

to be predominant in

And further, predominant [2]:

being most frequent or common

There is simply nothing to discuss here. Your original claim was wrong, even using your own statistics. (Of course, you may have tried to say or you meant that immigrants are over represented, which would be correct. But you did not say that. Thus you are the one to be corrected.)

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dominate [2] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/predominant

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by beefield on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:18AM (#13723811)
> Why is the conclusion that immigrants dominate the statistics of violence against women racist? I don't think there are many people who believe the cause of this statistic is genetic.

First, if the very first sentence of wikipedia article of racism[1] tells that racism can be against a race or ethnic group, it should be accepted that the word "racism" is used not only to genetically different groups, but also against ethnic groups.

Second, your claim that immigrants dominate the statistics is wrong. They are over-represented. But even if we take that as your claim, no, the conclusion in itself is not racist. However, if you read what I wrote more carefully, that conclusion can be used as an excuse for racism.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by cowl on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:58AM (#13723664)
It is irrelevant since they refuse to keep statics based on the Ethnicity. Example (fictitious) if total Crime has decreased by 1% but crime by Swedish citizens has decreased by 5% it would actually show a 4% crime increase in non Swedish population. although this fictitious figure may seems small it would be nonetheless an unwarranted risk increase. Not everything that distinguishes based on ethnicity is racism otherwise the vast majority of Medical research would be racist because they target specific populations for specific drugs.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by beefield on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:09AM (#13723746)
> figure may seems small it would be nonetheless an unwarranted risk increase.

That is again another discussion where it may be relevant.

I took a quite specific discussion ("Sweden has turned dangerous because of crimes by immigrants") and in that discussion the fact(?) that total crime numbers have not increased is very relevant.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by concinds on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:04AM (#13724822)
> I took a quite specific discussion ("Sweden has turned dangerous because of crimes by immigrants") and in that discussion the fact(?) that total crime numbers have not increased is very relevant.

Not necessarily the case because demographics are never homogeneously distributed across territory. If the rape/crime numbers didn't fall uniformly across the whole population, then you could have scenarios where crime fell by 20% in some regions and increased 25% in others, and overall it would be constant. I'm making up the numbers to illustrate.

More data would make your point much more convincing.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by kaveh_h on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:53PM (#13726488)
Lots of factors contribute to change in criminal activity, urbanization, rise of income inequality but also more people in segregated areas will probably not work out very well either.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by ptaipale on Saturday February 25, 2017 @04:39AM (#13730834)
There's no particular rise in Swedish income equality during this millennium. Income inequality after social transfers is quite stable.

Segregation of areas is however becoming stronger, as many minorities like to live in their own ethnic enclaves.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by yummyfajitas on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:38AM (#13723977)
A more relevant question is whether immigrants are making Sweden more dangerous than it would otherwise be.

It's possible that Sweden became safer because Swedes commit fewer crimes, and this decrease outweighed a crime increase caused by immigrants. Crime-by-nationality data would help resolve this question. Why is the Swedish government hiding it?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by estomagordo on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:49AM (#13724679)
Every criminologist, relevant government institution or agency already knows that immigrants are over-represented in crime. I'm not sure what would be learned and what strategies would change if one were to learn exactly how that over-representation looks today.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by someguydave on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:56AM (#13724740)
So data that discredits an ideology should remain unpublished? That sounds like theocracy.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by ptaipale on Saturday February 25, 2017 @04:42AM (#13730841)
Generally, an analysis for how to solve a problem starts with finding out and admitting the facts. The steadfast refusal in this case is actually worsening the situation because it is creating distrust in government.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by gaff33 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:16AM (#13723327)
They talk about it in the article

> People from foreign backgrounds are suspected of crimes more often than people from a Swedish background [...] In a later study, researchers at Stockholm University showed that the main difference in terms of criminal activity between immigrants and others in the population was due to differences in the socioeconomic conditions in which they grew up in Sweden.

So it seems that whilst immigrants are suspected of more crimes than average, they commit the same amount of crime as poor deprived members of indigenous populations.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:33AM (#13723456)
> So it seems that whilst immigrants are suspected of more crimes than average, they commit the same amount of crime as poor deprived members of indigenous populations.

"Commit the same level of crime as the subset of the population who commit the highest level of crime" does not sound very reassuring.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by AlexTelon on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:50AM (#13723591)
The quote was:

"In a later study, researchers at Stockholm University showed that the main difference in terms of criminal activity between immigrants and others in the population was due to differences in the socioeconomic conditions in which they grew up in Sweden."

That means that the most important factor in terms of criminal activity is that immigrants are largely poor and poor commit more crimes. Not that rich immigrants perform as much crimes as the poorest of non-immigrants.

Or do you disagree with that assesment of what the study said?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:40AM (#13725191)
The point is that most of these immigrants are poor, correspondingly prone to crime, and therefore not the sort of people you want to blast into your tiny population by the tens of thousands. Things are also confounded by the fact that most of these people are heavily theologically indoctrinated, making social integration and upward mobility effectively impossible, so they're going to stay poor.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by SamBam on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:55AM (#13725354)
> Things are also confounded by the fact that most of these people are heavily theologically indoctrinated, making social integration and upward mobility effectively impossible

This is when your biases are walking uninvited into a discussion about data.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:03PM (#13725427)
Pointing out that religious fundamentalists don't integrate well is not a good example of "bias".
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by kaveh_h on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:36PM (#13726299)
That you believe a majority are religious fundementalist is bias
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Friday February 24, 2017 @03:25PM (#13727556)
Pew research does per-country religious belief surveys. I think you will find it very enlightening to look up the religious beliefs of the average Syrian.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by SamBam on Monday February 27, 2017 @12:27PM (#13745926)
And can you tell me what makes someone a refugee? Whether an average refugee is ideologically/culturally identical to the average non-refugee from that country? And how about a refugee who's choosing to go live in a country very different from their own?

Pointing us to "per-country religious belief surveys" is incredibly simplistic.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by ptaipale on Saturday February 25, 2017 @04:43AM (#13730848)
Can you give a link to the results?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Sunday February 26, 2017 @07:39PM (#13740978)
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by kaveh_h on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:34PM (#13726280)
"Things are also confounded by the fact.."

Which facts? What do you base this belief on? Any sources to any studies?

Swedens tiny population of 10 million can't handle immigration of tens of thousands? That's laughabale, it's been doing exactly that for decades now. Iraq, Iran, Bosnia, Kosovo, Somalia, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Afghanistan, Iraq again, Ukraine, Syria. Only recently has a resistance to these policies been seriously challenged...

Upwards mobility will happen, even during the worst conditions, like the slavery in US, did they manage to break free. This is not about when but how, true solidarity or true civil war and tragedy..

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Friday February 24, 2017 @03:31PM (#13727604)
> What do you base this belief on? Any sources to any studies?

http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religi...

You should think very carefully about why you had an incorrect model of these people. You may be making similar mistakes in other areas.

> Swedens tiny population of 10 million can't handle immigration of tens of thousands?

Depends how you define "handle". If by "handle" you mean "avoid cultural erasure", then maybe not.

I'd also like to point out that it's tens of thousands per year. There are almost 100,000 Syrians in Sweden.

> Upwards mobility will happen

On what do you base this claim? Has upward mobility happened in the countries from which these refugees originate?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by matthewmacleod on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:39AM (#13723509)
Sure, if you deliberately misinterpret things you can make them sound as bad as you want.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by alkonaut on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:58AM (#13724774)
If immigrants in a certain area/age/education level/income level commit fewer crimes than the corresponding group of natives that would be surprising.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by kaveh_h on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:33PM (#13726906)
That would exclude "no go zones" as they are inhabitated by the poorest AKA immigrants, and very few Swedes.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by facepalm on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:21AM (#13723374)
I'd say THAT is irrelevant. If I become victim of a crime, it doesn't console me if the perpetrator is poor. I just don't want to become a victim of a crime.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by brown9-2 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:26AM (#13723406)
It is relevant to the topic of how to prevent crime - it tells you that eliminating immigration won't help, but that addressing poverty will.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by nmeofthestate on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:44AM (#13723543)
Well, except some immigration adds to the number of people in poverty, so avoiding immigration that does that would address poverty and by extension crime.

This is reasonable, unless the theory is that when an immigrant arrives in Sweden, a person already in poverty gets 'promoted' and the immigrant takes their poverty space, thus keeping poverty levels constant.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Voloskaya on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:07AM (#13723720)
One of the reason Sweden is welcoming migrants is because the birth rate is becoming really low, so there is need for new workers paying taxes. They are accepting more poors (and by extension statistically more crime-prone) people today, to hopefully have a still sane and stable economy in the future (thus with less poors).
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by ptaipale on Saturday February 25, 2017 @05:02AM (#13730897)
> One of the reason Sweden is welcoming migrants is because the birth rate is becoming really low, so there is need for new workers paying taxes.

People have a hard time believing that because the current migration does not bring in more but less working people - the migrants have a worse dependency ratio than native population, i.e. the proportion of migrants who have a job is lower than proportion of people already in country. Among OECD countries, migrants in Sweden have the largest difference in dependency ratio to native population.

[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tomlock on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:15AM (#13724337)
What are the reasons to assume it won't?

Keep in mind that a lot of these first world countries have an aging population - so younger people being imported is good because it brings in more taxpayers versus pensioners. See this bloomberg article for some of the problems particularly immigrant-shy countries face: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-23/why-immig...

The article itself also addresses some of these points:

>Sweden has had one of the highest rates of growth in Europe over the last two years. Youth unemployment has declined considerably and is now at its lowest level for 13 years, and long-term unemployment (12 months or longer) is the lowest in the EU.

Compare this with Japan: http://nationalinterest.org/feature/what-ails-japans-economy...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tropo on Monday March 06, 2017 @08:43PM (#13807688)
Japan is and will remain Japanese. The same can not be said of Sweden.

I think I see a bias here: culture is valuable, unless it is western. In the future, it will not be possible to go visit Swedish culture.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by k_swden on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:29AM (#13725056)
In Sweden the vast majority of immigration are refugees and so the main reason they are allowed in is on humanitarian concerns, not economical ones.

Thougt many argue both in favor and against further immigration for various reasons.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by aaron-lebo on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:36AM (#13723484)
Cutting off immigration is not some kind of autosolution, but if immigrants commit higher levels of crime compared to the rest of the population, eliminating immigration would help.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by croon on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:25AM (#13723398)
The point isn't to console you. The point is to explain why crime happens, so it can be mitigated. Ie:

* Stop immigration.

OR

* Integrate poor people into society, the workforce, etc.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:33AM (#13723457)
Those aren't in conflict.

Immigration of more poor people from a different culture makes the already difficult task of integrating poor people even more difficult.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tomlock on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:30AM (#13723435)
So you think it would be fair to suggest the same restrictions on poor people as people are suggesting we place on immigrants?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by facepalm on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:35AM (#13723947)
I think it would make sense to reduce the number of poor people. If taking in immigrants is likely to increase the number of poor people, there is a problem.

The discussion is not about what should be done, only about Sweden's claim that there is no problem. If they say "yes there are criminals, but only because they are poor", they are dodging the issue.

-----

edit: Hacker News doesn't let me post more comments. So here is the comment I wrote, but I'll probably refrain from further ones:

"poor swedes could be deported and rich immigrants could take their place"

This is already happening in a way - it is called gentrification (not replacement with rich immigrants, but in general rich people will cluster together).

But Swedes formed a "state" and endowed some people with citizenship, but also giving them responsibility for their own people. So their responsibility should be to their own people first. Of course you can argue that forming such a state is immoral, but I think there are some practical arguments in favor of it.

As history has shown, states are very well capable of deporting significant fractions of their citizens, though. But presumably atm Swedes rate the ensurance to not be deported higher than the inconvenience of living with poor people.

The gender angle: yes, that is a popular argument in Germany, "but the refugees are only criminal because they are all men". But it should be possible to take that into account statistically. And even if the higher proportion of males would be the only issue, it still wouldn't change the fact that immigrants are causing problems. After all, they have a higher proportion of males.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tomlock on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:53AM (#13724136)
>I think it would make sense to reduce the number of poor people.

This could be achieved in a number of ways. For example, poor swedes could be deported and rich immigrants could take their place - this would actually be more effective than halting immigration altogether.

Another form of issue dodging is when people suggest that immigrants are the issue without admitting that the situation is a complex combination of factors. One of the best predictors of criminality from a statistical viewpoint is gender. Of course, excluding all men from immigrating into our countries probably strikes most as inhumane :) To say the immigrant status of a person is to be specially focused on seems particularly convenient, but not humane.

edit: Its funny you're willing to accept taking gender into account statistically, but not the wealth of most immigrants.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by facepalm on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:48AM (#13725277)
What do you mean by "willing to take into account"? Male or poor, the problem is still that if immigration imports many male and/or poor, crime levels rise.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tomlock on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:54PM (#13728698)
>But it should be possible to take that [being a man] into account statistically.

So why not take being an immigrant "into account statistically"?

It seems like the anti-PC folk have some things they think we should be PC about and take into account (like being a man) while being an immigrant is fair game. It doesn't make any sense to blame crime on one demographic factor, and ignore the others.

Its a matter of anti-PC folk selectively ignoring evidence that doesn't fit their worldview.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by facepalm on Saturday February 25, 2017 @02:52PM (#13733460)
By "take into account" I meant it should be possible to statistically distinguish the factors of being male and being male+immigrant. So that it can be seen if being male is really the only factor driving increase of crime.

As for male criminal citizens, they should be sent to jail. In any case, as I mentioned before, they are already citizens, so the state has a special obligation towards them.

The point is also not to consider every immigrant a criminal just because some of them are, but to deal with life in one's country. If for example you could devise a test that would tell with 100% certainty if an immigrant will become a good, law-abiding citizen, a lot of immigration discussions would become a lot easier.

Btw suppose your suggestion would be followed, and male citizens would be deported because they are such a high risk for crime. Who would do the deporting? The world feminist army? Or should men just pack up and leave by themselves, admitting their own tendency to become criminals?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tomlock on Monday February 27, 2017 @12:23AM (#13742079)
As the world feminist army sweeps the nation - the alt-right will form a guerilla force - middle-aged white men will rise up to fight - I can see it now.

It should be possible to statistically distinguish the factors of being poor and being poor+immigrant. Or education level+immigrant or degree choice+immigrant. Point is, focusing on immigrants demographically makes no sense when there are plenty of other demographic factors that are better indicators of criminality.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:42AM (#13723533)
"the main difference in terms of criminal activity between immigrants and others in the population was due to differences in the socioeconomic conditions in which they grew up in Sweden."

This is a classic red-herring.

'They were poor therefore they have bad behaviours'.

The failure of the logic is the assumption of correlation/causation.

One might argue that 'bad behaviour will lead one to being poor'.

I have no doubt that immigrants from Somalia will have a harder time than 'Sven Swede' growing up. At the same time, there are some truly terrible behaviours among specific immigrant groups.

This is the hardest part: the pro and anti immigrant camps are speaking past each other.

Important note: For some reason, ethnic minorities in Europe are considerably more marginalized then they are in the US - it's completely different.

Europe has a 'strong social safety net' - and 'social policy' of welfare etc. - BUT - they have very strong sense of ethnic identity, and very close social circles. A young Somalian may have very few Swedish friends.

In the US - people are far more gregarious and open personally. It's nothing to see a table of people of different ethnic backgrounds - but the social safety net is usually much weaker, no health insurance etc..

I live in Montreal, we have a good chunk of Muslims. They don't look too 'out of place'. You can't tell they are Muslim by looking. They could be Indian, Southern Italian, Greek.

But go to Belgium - the various Muslim communities are distinct, and ethnic identity is obvious. I've never seen a Burqa in Montreal, and Hijab not too often. In Belgium they are all over. Muslims live in 'broad areas' in Montreal, but in Belgium very specific communities.

It's a little bit of a mystery to me but I think it has everything to do with 'very traditional and conservative' social culture in Europe - even though paradoxically they are 'intellectually liberal'. Example: if you drink with a nice, well educated, open minded and kind Belgian - you may hear an 'African joke'. It's not considered as racist as it would be in America. Yet the Belgian will likely be more supportive of giving refuge and social services to the Africans than the average American. It's weird.

Sweden has a notorious degree of censorship in their press - they self-censor to control information in terms of what they 'deem is best for Sweden'. They will absolutely suppress information if it may cause some populist sentiment. It's just part of their culture.

The problem, of course, is that by suppressing real dialogue, then the loudest and craziest right-wing voices are the one's that get hard, and they cause a fuss, which is bad, and it may come to a breaking point.

I suggest that more transparency on the issues would be better for all involved.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by usrusr on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:28PM (#13725632)
Taking about Belgium, I often suspect that they have an extra level of difficulty there due to the bifurcated national identity. What identity could newcomers assimilate into? You won't be particularly drawn to feeling Wallonian if you live in Brussels speaking French and even less to feeling Flandrian. I guess there isn't much Belgianness left if you are neither, so people are more or less predispositioned to stick to whatever parody of their original background they can still piece together.

I sense a similar difficulty in my native Germany, where so much of the current national identity is defined by feeling bad for something your grandparents maybe did (or by violently refusing to do so), that the absence of it in non-descendants of that generation is causing a noticeable "identity gap" even generations after immigration. This kind of stuff causes zero problems for those who have goals and education and achievement, but everybody else occasionally leans on group identity and will take whatever fits best.

P.S. I've actually come tho think that whatever ridiculous (from the German perspective, yes, totally ridiculous, if not outright scary) business Americans do with flags does serve a purpose after all. It gives both established and new Americans confidence that the new ones can belong, easing the process for everyone involved.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @03:23PM (#13727533)
Agree on Belgian. Belgian is a 'nation' but the ethnic identity is Walloon or Flemish.

I live in Montreal and immigrants have the same problem: English or French? There is a 3rd category here (we use linguistic categories) - called 'Allophone' - meaning essentially neither English nor French, but 'multi' or 'something else'.

Despite the self-loathing of the past few generations - Germans are generally very German. A flag is a national symbol, not an ethnic one. Even the Nazis didn't use the flag of Germany - totally unnecessary!

'American' is not an ethnicity. All Americans have is the 'idea' of America. Which is represented by the flag.

In a way - 'nationalism' is more essential and necessary in a place like America.

Germany would be German with or without even the state of Germany.

America would disintegrate without national symbols.

In Canada - we are less nationalist because we are a British colony. Canadians had British passports up until very recently, just before I was born!

Mass migration is a new issue for Germany though - if it were just a few immigrants, it would be a non-issue. But the sheer scale of it makes it an existential issue, one that is akin to changing the Constitution - in fact - even stronger. A constitution can always be re-written. A nation can be rebuilt. But once a people decide that they are a 'nation' but not an ethnicity - and 'go multicultural' - there is no going back. I think that's a decision that should require a 'supermajority' vote type thing, not a decision made, de-facto in a 'crisis' policy by Merkel & Co. - obvious humanitarian issues notwithstanding.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Broken_Hippo on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:51AM (#13724698)
It really isn't like that everywhere in North America. Chinatowns, for example. Heck, I lived in a little town of 3000 people and it had a "mexican" part of town.

I lost friends for dating outside my own percieved race. Folks seperate based on the color of their skin and background quite often. It isn't that folks don't break from the molds, but they are definitely there.

The little town didn't have many Muslims, so that wasn't as common, but it did have a fair amount of Mennonite communities in the area. Women with heads covered and conservative, long-sleeve dresses even during the hot summer months and men with beards. They generally kept to themselves, most likely due to cultural similarities. Some areas in the US have some section of Jewish coursts that handle some things and conservative Jews have a network within their communities (friend of mine, American, nearly went through an arranged marriage through them). These are probably much like many of the conservative Muslim communities you spotted - they are simply a different sort of conservative religion.

On the other hand, the majority of immigrant Muslims went to language class with are fairly progressive women. Lawyers and nurses and such. They stand out about as much as I do here in Norway.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:28AM (#13725054)
"It really isn't like that everywhere in North America"

I totally agree. America is a big place, so is Europe. It's varied.

But I would say, on the whole that EU is far more 'enclave-ish' than the US.

In fact, Europe is a big patchwork of ethnic enclaves.

America is not. People identify a lot less with their identity.

And yes, for sure, some people, i.e. Orthodox Jews, Mennonites etc. are different.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by 1_2__3 on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:49AM (#13725288)
> In the US - people are far more gregarious and open personally.

Can I just share my belief that this is polite fiction? It's certainly the view of America that we Americans have for ourselves, but can you honestly say you see evidence of it in day-to-day-life - and can you compare it to western Europe?

In my personal experience no, EU migrants are no more marginalized than they are here, and no, American migrants are no more "integrated". Vast swaths of SoCal and Texas is basically Mexico. Huge parts of Florida are basically Cuba. The Somali influx in Minnesota is real and highly separated from the rest of white society there. You don't need to look for ghettos to find large areas of extremely insular immigrants, often 2nd or 3rd generation still with no intention of or interest in immigrating in any sense other than physical location.

I'm not even commenting on if it's a good or bad thing, but ultimately I don't think we've EVER been the melting pot we claim to be, certainly the evidence around us doesn't suggest we are.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tropo on Friday February 24, 2017 @03:44PM (#13727706)
The melting was prior to about 1960, with the strongest melting during the World War I. During the wars, German-speaking communities switched fully to English. Everybody was expected to conform to a universal American culture, and most of them proudly did so.

Had the melting pot not grown cold, we'd have a lot less internal conflict today.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by kohanz on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:27AM (#13724463)
This post had a lot of thought and effort put into it. I have no idea why it's downvoted. Regardless of whether you agree or disagree with the premise, it's put forward in an excellent manner and that's what we should strive for here: quality discussion.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Exofunctor on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:37AM (#13725144)
> they commit the same amount of crime as poor deprived members of indigenous populations.

That's probably why people want to stop importing them en masse.

[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:35AM (#13723472)

    > Socioeconomic factors are
    > not the major ones
... is your opinion, contradicted by the available evidence. You finish with a suggestion to call things "by its real names", so I will: pushing a false narrative of cultural superiority is racism. Begone.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by DoofusOfDeath on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:41AM (#13723526)
Wouldn't that be called "culturism"?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:50AM (#13723587)
"... is your opinion, contradicted by the available evidence"

This is false.

In fact - the evidence points much more strongly towards 'behaviour' than it does 'economic status'.

(By the way, I'm not making the case entirely that 'ethnicity is it' - rather, saying that there's tons of evidence to support it. I believe that it's rather more complicated).

'Economic status' is loosely correlated with crime in the USA for example. More crime is committed in poorer areas. Ok - so are they poor and therefore commit crime - or they have bad behaviours and are therefore poor?

The problem is - 'ethnicity' is considerably more correlated with crime, particularly violent crime.

For example, poor African Americans commit considerably more violent crime than their poor White or Asian peers.

Now - you could argue it's due to 'racism' etc. - and that's a good point, but it only goes so far.

Also - I'd argue that this is not about 'racism' - it's about 'ethnicity'. What is 'ethnicity' but a group of values, behaviours, norms, viewpoints, beliefs, patterns etc? Two groups with different ethnic backgrounds are likely to have very different outcomes overall in life. That's just reality - and it doesn't have to have anything to do with race.

I'm not actually making an argument one way or another - I think there's a lot to be said for how hard it is go grow up poor, or how hard it is to grow up facing racism and injustice - but at the same time - behaviours, mannerism, values etc. will define most of an individuals future - and those are passed down to children from their parents, and close community members, i.e. ethnicity. So it would be basically crazy to ignore this issue as well.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:54AM (#13723621)
Can we exit crazy world for a moment and say that "there's tons of evidence" doesn't cut it unless you provide that evidence?

The level of rampant irrationality here is disheartening.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by w0utert on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:21AM (#13723828)
Well I'm not from Sweden so I cannot comment on that, but it's a well-known and documented fact that e.g. here in the Netherlands, ethnicities other than 'Dutch' are over-represented in about every negative statistic that is being tracked, amongst which are crime statistics. I could point you to cbs statline, which is the goverment statistics body, but it's in Dutch so I don't know if it's of any use to you, see [1] and particularly [2] for an overview table of crime statistics grouped by native, non-native, non-native+non-western, etc.

Whether these groups are over-represented because of socio-economic status, cultural factors, genetics or whatever seems largely irrelevant to me if you ask me, especially if you are reasoning about immigration in the context of public safety. None of these factors are controllable, and typically immigrants from distressed countries will both fall in the 'different culture' and 'low economic status' category at the same time. For public safety, the root cause why they are over-represented in 'bad lists' seems irrelevant to me.

Let's be clear that I don't mean to pass judgement on immigration policy, just pointing out that if you are creative with statistics you can prove or disprove almost anything to be related to everything, depending on your agenda. Correcting a statistic 'immigrants are over-represented in crime statistics' by saying 'but not compared to swedes with low economic status' seems like a pretty desperate attempt to paper over the fact that accepting large number of immigrants will not improve public safety, so to say.

[1] http://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/

[2] http://statline.cbs.nl/StatWeb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=81947...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by readittwice on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:49AM (#13724682)
Same for Austria. Immigrants are both over-represented both in prisons and criminal statistics.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Saturday February 25, 2017 @04:02AM (#13730733)

    > Whether these groups are
    > over-represented because of 
    > socio-economic status, 
    > cultural factors, genetics 
    > or whatever seems largely 
    > irrelevant to me
Then I'm entirely unsure why you're contributing to a thread of conversation about evidence on that specific point, and providing evidence for something else entirely.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sharemywin on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:09AM (#13724286)
So, what's the point. Should I judge you based on your specific actions or based on what all idiots(myself included) on the internet post?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by aaron-lebo on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:39AM (#13723511)
Cultures advance. Some are more refined and progressive than others. The practice of throwing homosexuals to their deaths is obviously not enlightened. Of course other cultures have their faults, too, but to argue that comparing cultures is racism is willfully ignorant.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by peteretep on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:52AM (#13723606)
The parent comment stated that differences were due to culture and not baseline economic status. This is inspite of evidence.

What alternative explanation - other than racism or ignorance - is there for that mistruth?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by aaron-lebo on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:55AM (#13723633)
Culture != race.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by MK999 on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:56PM (#13725892)
Shouting "racism!" is a good way to shut down the discussion

Shouting "culture!" doesn't really work as well.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:35AM (#13723476)
What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones', to the extent that that you can confidently state that it is 'plainly' wrong to attribute differences to poverty and lack of education?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:08AM (#13723731)
> What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones'?

How about the Swedish government themselves?

- A 1996 BRA (Swedish Criminal statistics) study found that "there any indication that immigrants in Sweden are discriminated in the courts. Immigrant overrepresentation in registered crime is almost certainly real...nor is it caused by any generally lower social economic status (calculated as per SEI code) in Sweden."

- Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention determined that between 1985 and 1989 individuals born in Iraq, North Africa (Algeria, Libya, Morocco and Tunisia),Africa (excluding Uganda and the North African countries), other Middle East (Jordan, Palestine, Syria), Iran and Eastern Europe (Romania, Bulgaria) were convicted of rape at rates 20, 23, 17, 9, 10 and 18 greater than individuals born in Sweden respectively."

http://www.pdf-archive.com/2011/05/08/br-1996-2-invandrares-...

Besides, socioeconomic factors to justify rape....really?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:37AM (#13723968)
Is there a link to an actual government site instead of pictures of a book in Swedish that was published decades ago?

> Besides, socioeconomic factors to justify rape....really?

I'm sorry, but it is really difficult to have a serious conversation with someone unable to differentiate between the process of analyzing reasons for crimes and 'justifying' crimes. That is elementary stuff.

And your point doesn't even make sense. Are you saying rich, well educated muslims or african immigrants are still more likely to rape someone than a white person? Is your argument genetic? If that is not what you are implying - and I'll pay you the complement of assuming it's not, then you will have to at least consider socioeconomic factors.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:50AM (#13724106)
> is there a link to an actual government site instead of pictures of a book in Swedish that was published decades ago?

That book was published by the goverment of Sweden. Does the host matter?

In 2005 BRA (Swedish Criminal statistics) published an update saying: "Immigrants’ risk of being registered for crime has not changed in any pronounced way since the previous study conducted by the National Council, which related to the situation at the end of the 1980s" Link: https://www.bra.se/download/18.cba82f7130f475a2f1800010674/1...

> it is really difficult to have a serious conversation with someone unable to differentiate between the process of analyzing reasons for crimes and 'justifying' crimes.

Justification: "give grounds for, give reasons for, give a justification for". Pointing at socioeconomic factors is justifying the crimes by allusion to the circumstances of the crime.

Maybe you're confused it with 'condoning' which means something else.

So my point is, do we think we can analyze and find reason for aggravated rape within socioeconomic circumstances?

> Are you saying rich, well educated muslims or african immigrants are still more likely to rape someone than a white person?

Am I? I don't think that I am.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:16AM (#13724345)
1)'Justify' meaning: https://www.google.co.uk/#q=justify+meaning

"show or prove to be right or reasonable"

2) > That book was published by the goverment of Sweden.

Probably, but pictures on "pdf-archive.com" are not a valid source since anyone can doctor them. It should be trivial and take a matter of minutes to find a link to the official government manual from a government site, if you're familiar with the study.

>So my point is, do we think we can analyze and find reason for aggravated rape within socioeconomic circumstances?

Possibly. We do not have any information that makes socioeconomic factors irrelevant, and comparable studies strongly tilt the balance in the favour of such an explanation.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by glormph on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:33AM (#13723934)
I am not arguing against your point, but are there reports which are not 20+ years old?

Also, my understanding of the words may be wrong but I didn't see anyone _justifying_ rape in this thread.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by factsaresacred on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:40AM (#13724000)
> are there reports which are not 20+ years old?

I asked the same question. In 2005 Bra released a report saying "Immigrants’ risk of being registered for crime has not changed in any pronounced way since the previous study conducted by the National Council, which related to the situation at the end of the 1980s".

https://www.bra.se/download/18.cba82f7130f475a2f1800010674/1...

Your claim was "What are your sources that try to prove that socioeconomic factors are not 'the major ones'?" so my question is 'what of rape'? This is the main crime making headlines. How does one explain it with socioeconomic factors? And even if you could, would that be a satisfactory explanation?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by glormph on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:01AM (#13724208)
I see you have already dealt with my question about the word justify with another commenter.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:44AM (#13723545)
It is obvious - poor but educated people are different from poor and uneducated. To lift people out of misery and poverty is what education is for in the first place.

In countries like India that could be clearly seen. Poverty alone does not account for the behavioral patterns. Education is the key. People knew this since antiquity, independently of a particular civilization - Indians knew this, Chinese knew this, you name it.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Voloskaya on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:03AM (#13723698)
In many country, including France where issues similar to sweden exists, the quality of the education you receive is directly correlated with the median wealth of your neighborhood. Poor suburbs have way worse education than rich ones.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:36PM (#13726944)
Education is not only about academic knowledge per se. It is also a set of habits of self-control, acquired skills, social behavior patterns and transformed perceptions. This is what we call conditioning or exposure to certain culture.

Street kids, usually members of a gang, who never have experienced transforming influence of the culture of a good school and a good teacher are definitely not the same as those who vent through one.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by jkscm on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:37AM (#13723493)
[citation needed]

Socioeconomic factors are significant factors: http://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/publications/violence.as...

As a side note: You seem to agree with your parent poster since you mention “well-educated people” which are most likely richer.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:49AM (#13723578)
Education is asymmetric. Educated could clearly see the world in the same naive way as uneducated, but the contrary is not true. This constitutes the fundamental difference and incompatibility which is supposed to be eliminated by providing the basic right for receiving an education.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by k_swden on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:42AM (#13725224)
First you state socioeconomic factors are not major factor, but then you go on saying "well-educated people of any origin would behave more or less similarly", but socioeconomic factors are: income, EDUCATION and occupation, ergo you're contradicting yourself or you have no clue what socioeconomic factors are.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by lngnmn on Saturday February 25, 2017 @07:35AM (#13731320)
Yes, you are right, I have messed it up a little. What I have tried to say is that there are major and minor factors, and the major ones, with highest weights, so to speak, are cultural instead of economical, and I will keep my stand.

A culture, which is a set of shared values, views and behavioral patterns, defines a person more than just his income. Occupation is important, (think of the castes of India) but the modern world a truck driver could be a physicist or a philosopher could make and sell sandwiches.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by rbehrends on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:53AM (#13723608)
The problem is that "immigrants" is an extremely imprecise category. I don't know enough about Sweden, but I know that in Germany, foreign crime is primarily dominated by organized crime from abroad: pickpocket gangs from North Africa, burglary gangs from Serbia and Georgia, the Russian Mafia, Lebanese crime clans, etc.

In contrast, Syrian refugees seem to be among the most law-abiding foreigners you can find (followed by Iraqi refugees, as I recall).

"Immigrants" is a fairly useless category for criminological purposes, as it combines several other categories with vastly different profiles, some with outsized crime rates, some below that of natives.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by mikeash on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:39AM (#13724595)
If the total number has remained steady, but the majority of perpetrators are now immigrants, then that implies the total number committed by native Swedes has dropped by roughly half in just a few years. This is highly implausible, so somebody's claims here are wrong.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Svenskunganka on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:11AM (#13723297)
Leif GW Persson, who the above commenter is talking about clarified this on TV just a couple of days ago. The segment starts 18 minutes in and is in Swedish: http://www.svtplay.se/video/12505960/veckans-brott/veckans-b... (hoping there is no region blocking...)
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by mercer on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:21AM (#13723366)
Would you mind giving a quick summary of the video? I'm somewhat challenged in the 'understanding Swedish' department.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tiatia on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:10PM (#13725492)
"The point is that a majority of all violence and sexual crimes is performed by immigrants "

This makes you a "right wing thug" for many people in Europe. Europe is lost. They lost their immunity for enemies of their open society. Uneducated immigrants from violent tribal societies will first make the social system implode, then the society.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by id122015 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:17AM (#13723337)
And regional stats should not be diluted by national stats. I want to know if crime increased in Stockholm?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by zurn on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:59AM (#13724187)
> The point is that a majority of all violence and sexual crimes is performed by immigrants

This claim is false,

> (as confirmed by Sweden's most famous crime professor GW a couple of days ago)

and this attribution is also false.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by polack on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:17AM (#13724356)
Source video: http://www.svtplay.se/video/12505960/veckans-brott/veckans-b...

He says that "if you look across the board on all convicted crimes it's half-half between natives and immigrants. But if you look at the more 'sensitive' crimes there is a significant over representation of immigrants"

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by fulafel on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:19AM (#13724971)
That's different, overrepresentation vs majority of crimes.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by orcdork on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:56AM (#13723648)
Hah, what a joke.

Leif GW Persson is famous for writing books and being on tv shows - not for being a crime professor (and he is no longer a professor of criminology). There's a reason googling his name comes up with breitbart first, and goodreads second.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tobylane on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:59AM (#13724196)
What difference does that make? As we've seen in USA, a job that has always been filled by career politicians or soldiers has been filled by a man famous for being on tv.

On the other hand this guy was in a relevant position. Is being a former professor of criminology different to currently being a professor?

[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by turc1656 on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:21AM (#13724988)
"No one is even contesting that immigrants commit more crimes"

You must be joking. There is a huge amount of people who claim they don't. For example, these media outlets which many people find to be reputable:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/immigrants-...

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/26/us/trump-illegal-immigran...

http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-bersani-piquero-i...

Or you could hear the (former) US ambassador to Sweden claim the increase of 1.5 million violent crimes in Sweden is not attributable to refugees (around 3:58) - "...does not mean that is somehow related to migrants." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CFPjEM0Izpc

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by alkonaut on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:47AM (#13725269)
It's all semantics. Immigrants commit more crimes. Adjust for economic/social factors and most of that disappears. So in one war they do and in others they don't. Statistics is hard and both sides use it to prove their point.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by turc1656 on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:07PM (#13725461)
My point was simply that there is not agreement across the board that they commit more crimes.

Yes, people are unscrupulous when it comes to statistics, that's definitely true. But "adjusting" for things is usually a way for people to get the result they want with the numbers. The government does this all the time with "seasonal adjustments" to housing and employment data. There never appears to be any rhyme or reason to the adjustments other than getting a better/desired number. Also, when people argue that it's because of socioeconomic factors or whatever else they may claim, that doesn't change the fact that they either do or do not commit more crimes. The reason for it can be discussed and addressed but many people try to use such an explanation as a way to weaken the fact that is presented.

I think the general citizen needs to become far more knowledgeable about math and statistics since they are always used to justify public policy nowadays. The common person is terrible at being able to weed out the bullshit that is presented by sources which all have agendas.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by alkonaut on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:15PM (#13726083)
If you didn't adjust, and immigrants somehow still were convicted of fewer crimes then that would be truly astonishing since then the poor/unemployed immigrants would be committing vastly fewer crimes than the corresponding group among non-immigrants.

Doing these kinds of adjustments is not dishonest if done correctly and in these circumstances it's often absolutely necessary to produce useful stats.

How stats are to be massaged depends on what argument one tries to make though. There are valid arguments from uncontrolled data too.

An example could be e.g "the immigrants we allow in are going to be unemployed and poor which means we are going to get more crime, I don't want that so I'm against immigration" - this is an entirely valid argument to make from uncontrolled data.

This is a two step argument: immigrants are poor and poor people more criminal.

This is not the same as saying "immigrants commit more crimes" because if unqualified such a statement always assumes controlling for relevant factors.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by turc1656 on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:50PM (#13726447)
I agree that controlling for certain factors is a core principal in statistics so that you can tease out relationships once you quantify the impact of other factors.

Also, "if done correctly" is a huge assumption with everyone having an agenda in the current climate.

But what I was trying to get at is not that the argument should just be with that one uncontrolled data point. My issue is that society can't even agree on that basic, top level data point to arrive at the first-stage fact of whether immigrants do/don't commit more violent crime. Everyone would have to agree on that first, then they can dig into the "all else being equal" scenarios where you control for the other factors that influence crime.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by dragonwriter on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:25PM (#13725622)
> But "adjusting" for things is usually a way for people to get the result they want with the numbers. The government does this all the time with "seasonal adjustments" to housing and employment data. There never appears to be any rhyme or reason to the adjustments other than getting a better/desired number.

While "adjusting" may be used for misleading purposes, government seasonal adjustments generally used a disclosed-in-advamce methodology with a clear purpose; they only seem to have no rhyme or reason if you don't bother to do even the most basic checking.

An overview of seasonal adjustment at the Bureau of Labor Statistics is available at [0], and more detailed information about the specific methodology and factors used in particular series are readily available.

[0] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/cpisahoma.htm

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by turc1656 on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:35PM (#13726288)
I disagree. That link shows no formulas whatsoever, just a generalized explanation of what they do. Without a hard set of rules to follow, it's useless. Also, looking into the X-13 ARIMA software documentation, it looks similar to other statistical software packages like Eviews, which I have used in the past. This methodology they follow still highly subjective based on the parameters used in the model.

This is very much like what my employer does for publishing public documents for financial compliance. We are required to publish a public methodology/rulebook for our products so that investors can, in theory, replicate everything we are doing on our side. In practice, though, forget it. No one can replicate it. The document serves to explain the concepts behind the product and the general guidelines, but no one can fully know the granular details that make all the difference.

It sounds like the same thing is going on here. No one can realistically be expected to take the same gigantic set of data, individually set a dozen or more parameters and run it through software and get the same result. And that's not even counting data sets that the "clean" by discarding certain outliers before running the model.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by dragonwriter on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:30PM (#13726865)
> I disagree. That link shows no formulas whatsoever, just a generalized explanation of what they do.

I said the link was a general overview of seasonal adjustment used in data series by the BLS, and that they provide additional detail the about the specific methodology used in specific series elsewhere.

But the key part from that summary relevant to your comment upthread is that not only are the specific methodologies for particular series published in advance, but the resulting adjustment factors for future time periods are determined and published in advance, before the data to be adjusted exists.

One may disagree with the methodology or the figures, but neither is the methodology opaque nor are the factors chosen to get desired results (since the actual raw data, and thus the factors necessary to get produce desired results, are not available.)

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by laxentasken on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:07AM (#13723267)
Because politics, really.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Shalle135 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:12AM (#13723300)
Good to know though is what GW is famous for. Being an infamous alcoholic.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by ra1n85 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:22AM (#13723381)
How is this relevant to the discussion? It's almost as if you seek to undermine his argument by pointing out that he has an addiction. Why would you do that? Are you scared of what he thinks and says?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by cancancan on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:45PM (#13726386)
That's just an ad hominem. Try addressing his arguments instead of his lifestyle.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by chappi42 on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:55AM (#13723635)
I don't know. Maybe HN should refrain from this subject.

Never trust any statistics that you didn't... - Believe this or go with the anecdotal real-world experience from a cop, linked below, Peter Springare, see e.g. http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/764574/Political-Sweden-.... Never read about it in 'good' newspaper before. So who knows? The politic is under much pressure to tell the 'right' things now.

I just wish they would just tell the delicate numbers, e.g. ethnical, religious, economic, <whatever> background of inmates, terror, crime. And allow to talk about it freely. We now are a data driven society, why not here? Why afraid?

Why not give (collect) the full data? (I browsed around a bit, but I think I would need more detailed raw data to say something)

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by cik2e on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:11AM (#13723763)
It seems that the main point of contention is whether migrants are more or less likely to commit crimes (in Sweden). This article doesn't answer this question at all for us. The following is the one remotely relevant statistic:

>> People from foreign backgrounds are suspected of crimes more often than people from a Swedish background. According to the most recent study, people from foreign backgrounds are 2.5 times more likely to be suspected of crimes than people born in Sweden to Swedish-born parents.

And even this isn't really what we're looking for because accusations != convictions. One can easily postulate that foreigners would have higher chances of being falsely accused, and factors like this have to be accounted for in the analysis.

The only factual evidence that we have to go on so far is otalp's reference to a study that showed German refugees are less likely to commit crimes than the average citizen.

Sadly, in this kind of argument, facts rarely matter and will likely not change erroneous views.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by draugadrotten on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:45AM (#13723548)
> According to the official statistics on The Swedish Crime Survey, the sexual violence rate in Sweden remained about the same between 2005 and 2014

Why picking the period 2005 to 2014? Immigration started 1960s and increased a lot 2014-2016. It would make a lot more sense to look at the sexual violence rate 1960-2016. Do you dare?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:55AM (#13723152)
> In Germany, refugees are less likely to commit a crime than the average citizen

Meanwhile in Sweden:

> According to the most recent study, people from foreign backgrounds are 2.5 times more likely to be suspected of crimes than people born in Sweden to Swedish-born parents.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sgift on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:02AM (#13723215)
First quote: "commit" vs Second quote: "suspected of crimes"

Two completely different things.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:03AM (#13723222)
"Commit" should be clarified.

We don't know who actually committed a crime. That should probably be either "arrested for" or "convicted of".

"Suspected of" probably means "arrested for", but there too, the author has chosen a word that's unclear.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by k-mcgrady on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:17AM (#13723336)
I would read that completely differently. The fact that 2.5x more immigrants are 'suspected' reads as a comment on racial profiling. Unless the author clarifies it's hard to read anything into the Sweden stat.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edblarney on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:54AM (#13723625)
It depends on the context.

Generally, the most valid data from crime apparently comes from 'victimization surveys' - as opposed to actual police data, which is politicized.

So, from victimization surveys - people can only necessarily be 'suspected' of a crime i.e. 'were you robbed in the last year'? Well, if the person answered 'yes' - then the language may only imply that a specific individual was 'suspected' of a crime. Also, it's pretty difficult to determine ethnicity.

So this may not simply be a case of 'police suspects' vs 'police arrests' etc.. It's complicated. Better to have the references.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:19AM (#13723351)
Judging by the other statements in the article, the author seems to have more interest in inspiring that doubt than in clarifying.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sgift on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:09AM (#13723281)
Fair remark, so let's clarify what I understand:

commit: Convicted of

suspected of: Not convicted

These are as far as I (and the law) are concerned the only two things that matter. If you've been convicted you are guilty, if not you are not. If you're guilty we can say you've committed a crime, if not not.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:17AM (#13723342)
Actually looking at the source of that remark (highlighted intro to an article on thelocal.de), it's not supported by the rest of the article:

> The documents note that while the number of refugees in the country has risen sharply throughout 2015, the crime rate has not gone up correspondingly, but has "merely risen steadily".

Of course it would not rise sharply even if refugees do commit more crimes. Refugees are a small portion of the population and will only have a small effect on overall crime rates.

> Interior Minsiter Thomas de Maizière responded to the news by saying: "The current trend shows that refugees are just as unlikely to commit crimes as comparable groups among the current population. The majority of them don't commit crimes, they are seeking protection and and peace in Germany."

Note: "just as" and "comparable groups", rather than the whole population.

> The rate of crime in refugee reception centres has gone up most quickly.

It sounds like thelocal.de took some liberties.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:28AM (#13723421)
There's a difference between 'people from foreign backgrounds' and refugees. Even in Germany, I wouldn't be surprised if 'people from foreign backgrounds' commit crimes at a higher rate when you don't adjust for socio-economic conditions.

However the majority of Syrian refugees - about 70%[1][2][3] are women and children. Again, something that is rarely mentioned in certain parts of the internet.

[1]- http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/feb/...

[2]-https://data.unhcr.org/syrianrefugees/regional.php

[3]-http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/jan/...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by thaumasiotes on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:11AM (#13724900)
What kind of children? Verified how?

http://www.unz.com/isteve/great-moments-in-real-news-tm-from...

If you incentivize people to say they're "children", and don't bother to verify claims of being a "child", you get a lot of "children", but that statistic won't mean much.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by yAnonymous on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:06AM (#13723716)
They do. According to official police statistics, 'people from foreign backgrounds' are responsible for about 30% of violent crimes, which makes them about three times as likely to commit such a crime, and they make up about 30-40% of the prison population.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by acqq on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:05AM (#13723708)
> However the majority of Syrian refugees - about 70%[1][2][3] are women and children.

However the majority of all 2015 refugees aren't Syrian?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sp332 on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:30AM (#13724506)
I was pretty sure they were actually. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-34131911

Edit: I misread this chart... a lot. Syrians are the largest group but not the majority. Never mind!

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by acqq on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:11AM (#13724896)
acqq> the majority of all 2015 refugees aren't Syrian

> I was pretty sure they were actually (link to BBC)

Your link has 1.32 million asylum claims, around 360 thousand Syrians, then roughly one fourth are Syrians, three fourths aren't, that is, the majority of all aren't.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by belorn on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:44AM (#13724042)
Of the current population in Sweden, 60% are women and children and 60% are men and children. Children are 17,43%, so if you include them as both the group "women and children" and "men and children", you get a total of almost 120%.

70% is thus a very unclear number unless you can split out the number of children, or if one do not include how big the "men and children" group is.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by tropo on Friday February 24, 2017 @04:15PM (#13727970)
They are "children" like this 12-year-old with a receding hair line, Adam's apple, and stubble:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CringeAnarchy/comments/47ri8u/this_...

Claimed ages are accepted without question. To question the age is considered racist. There is an incentive to lie: minors get instant citizenship and lots of help.

So really, it isn't children. It's men.

Would you want a 30-year-old dude in your daughter's 7th grade class?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by literallycancer on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:03AM (#13723223)
>> According to the most recent study, people from foreign backgrounds are 2.5 times more likely to be suspected of crimes than people born in Sweden to Swedish-born parents.

What do you imply exactly? So Swedish police are more likely to suspect you if you are a foreigner, how unexpected.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:06AM (#13723253)
I think you made just the leap the authors intended you to.

I wish the authors had included a link to that study so we could see what "suspected of" means exactly.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by literallycancer on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:33AM (#13723453)
I don't need a link to a study to tell you what it means. The meaning is exactly the same as in normal speech, too bad for you since you'll have to do even more mental gymnastics to resolve your cognitive dissonance.

It means someone was suspected (e.g. were at any time a suspect during the investigation), regardless of whether they actually committed anything or not.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:34AM (#13723469)
You don't want to read the actual study before jumping to conclusions?

Ok then.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by yAnonymous on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:09AM (#13723745)
In Germany the percentage of foreign suspects about matches with the percentage of convictions, so statistically speaking the suspicions are correct.

I'd be surprised if it was different in Sweden, or any other country with similar problems, as it's easy to distinguish the looks of most immigrants and the local population.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by germanier on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:31AM (#13723921)
> as it's easy to distinguish the looks of most immigrants

It's not. To take Germany as an example, the largest group of foreigners are Turks, followed by Poles and Italians. More than half of foreigner's in Germany are from European countries. On the other hand, many people from that groups are now German citizens and have grand-children that are in Germany in the third generation. A large number of German citizens have foreign born parents and many foreigners are born in Germany. If you can reliably distinguish between immigrants and the rest of the population by the looks your skills would be in high demand.

See https://www.destatis.de/EN/FactsFigures/SocietyState/Populat... for detailed statistics.

[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by egeozcan on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:10AM (#13723286)
You've been bombarding this discussion with your alternate reality. Do you have any references?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by brorfred on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:34AM (#13723464)
Have you ever met the Swedish police? Does the term "baseball gang" say anything?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by 8draco8 on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:59AM (#13723185)
Can you share the source?
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by leereeves on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:01AM (#13723200)
Facts about migration and crime in Sweden from the Swedish government.

http://www.government.se/articles/2017/02/facts-about-migrat...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Sacho on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:42AM (#13723074)
Thank you for the actual statistics; can you provide a source for the legislative change? I found sources for 2005 and 2008 changes, but not one for 2013.

There's also one particular thing that doesn't pass the smell test for me from your German article:

"Less than 1 percent of the total crimes committed by refugees are sex crimes, going against rumours spread on social media that these have become more common with the arrival of hundreds of thousands of refugees."

1% doesn't strike me as a very low percentage of sex crimes, but I googled around for some statistics, and found another article from the same source - https://www.thelocal.de/20160218/refugees-to-germany-commit-...

Here, the title is that "refugees commit less crime than Germans". However, the stats they quote show otherwise - despite refugees being anywhere from 0.8 to 2%, they committed at least 4% of the sex crimes in the country - a factor of at least 2. The article itself says that the sexual assaults reported during the New Year's Eve were not part of this number, so this is a conservative estimate. The article quotes a ratio of 2:1 men over women as a mitigating factor, however, doing the math most favorably towards refugees(100% of sexual assaults committed by men, 40/60 split in men/women in Germany) leaves you with an adjusted rate of ~2.6% of crimes, still significantly higher than their proportionate population.

From that article though I was able to acquire this statistic for 2015:

"The total number of this type of crime committed nationwide throughout 2015 was almost 47,000"

From here - https://www.osac.gov/pages/ContentReportDetails.aspx?cid=170... - I found that the total criminal offenses in germany were close to ~6mil. From this you can calculate the rate of sexual assault for the german population - 47k / 6mil ~ 0.8%. It's not as significantly different from the previous number, but still doesn't support the claim that, at 1%, refugees commit less sexual crimes than the german population.

EDIT: There is also a mitigating factor I just thought of that the newspaper didn't mention; refugees are likely to have a poor economic status in Germany, and are thus more likely to commit crimes for that factor alone. I don't know how to calculate for that as well.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by rndgermandude on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:43AM (#13723537)
I figured the same (the original Welt article thelocal.de quotes does not even say "refugees commit less crime than Germans" btw).

So, "less than 1%" of the "very low six figure" number of total crimes committed by refugees are sex crimes. Ok then, so let's conservatively say it's 100,000 * 0.009 = 900 sex crimes (not sure about what time range that even covers? 1 year? First 9 months in 2015 since the report was compiled in Oct 2016).

There have been 7022 sex crimes (reported) in 2015[1], total.

Using that, the conservative estimate for sex crimes committed by refugees of the total sex crimes committed is: 900 / 7022 = 12.8%

Let's assume (and grossly overestimate really) there were about 1.5 million refugees total in (the end of) 2015 and a total population of 81 million.

So 1.8% of the population was refugees, yet that cohort committed 12% of sex crimes.

But 900 / 1.5M refugees is a at most 0.06% of refugees (not even considering multiple offenders) who commit sex crimes, compared to the total population rate of 7022 / 81M = 0.009%

Downplaying the issue is not helpful. On the other hand, it's not helpful either but actually dangerous to rubberstamp all refugees as sex offenders when only at most 0.06% of them committed a sex crime in 2015.

As pointed out already, there are many mitigating factors to put this into context.

[1] http://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Broschueren/2...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by edmccard on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:11AM (#13723298)
>>"Less than 1 percent of the total crimes committed by refugees are sex crimes"

That seems to mean something different than "less than 1 percent of total sex crimes are committed by refugees".

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by etatoby on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:36AM (#13723485)
Precisely. These articles are full of Bayesian conceptual mistakes like this. It's going to be hard to prove anything without the source figures.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by rndgermandude on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:47AM (#13723565)
The original German article quoting the actual internal police paper is very clear that out of the "very low six digit figure" of total crimes committed by refugees, less than 1% of those "refugee crimes" were sex crimes.

It does not in any way state the what chunk out of the total sex crimes were committed by refugees, indeed.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by freeflight on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:48AM (#13723574)
How about you stop trying to interpret articles that try to interpret reports and instead go straight to the source aka the reports?

Here's the BKA report on "Crime in the context of migrant influx 1st Quarter of 2016": https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/EN/Themen/Siche...

That report also puts the number of "sexual assaults", out of all the crimes committed by migrants, at 1.10%.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Sacho on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:57AM (#13723653)
But I wasn't contesting that at all? I was taking the number of 1.1%, quoted as purportedly "really low", and trying to extrapolate what the number of sexual assaults is among the population at large. Like my last paragraph says, that extrapolation is around 0.8%, still not enough to justify a title "refugees commit less crime than Germans". The report you linked doesn't help me at all, only providing an even larger number than I started with for migrant crimes.

In fact, the report just reaffirmed what I've already heard elsewhere - the vast majority of crimes come not from "Syrian refugees", but migrants from countries without a crisis that would lead to them seeking asylum. This has been a very common criticism of the "floodgate" approach to accepting all immigrants regardless of their ability to justify their refugee status.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by freeflight on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:19AM (#13723817)
>The report you linked doesn't help me at all, only providing an even larger number than I started with for migrant crimes.

The report is the only thing that actually matters in this context because it's the actual data. All your sources are just news-outlets trying to interpret data from sources they don't even share with the reader.

>but migrants from countries without a crisis that would lead to them seeking asylum

And half these countries are not even "Muslim countries", yet they are overrepresented in the crime rates, while people from countries like Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan are proportionally lower with their crime rates. Which goes straight against the common misconception of "It's their Islamic culture that makes them so criminal and incompatible to our culture!".

> This has been a very common criticism of the "floodgate" approach to accepting all immigrants regardless of their ability to justify their refugee status.

You first have to accept them to check if they actually qualify for refugee status, those that don't qualify don't get the status and thus have to leave the country.

How else would you want to handle this? Leave them all outside the border so they create their own communities, without any infrastructure or law enforcement? Do you seriously think creating these kinds of "slums" would be beneficial to anybody?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by madmax96 on Friday February 24, 2017 @09:50AM (#13724105)
>You first have to accept them to check if they actually qualify for refugee status, those that don't qualify don't get the status and thus have to leave the country.

Then what? THEN they go back to the border and they create their own communities? How can you __actually__ make that many people leave?

>Do you seriously think creating these kinds of "slums" would be beneficial to anybody?

No, but the fact is these refugees are not able to contribute to the societies they come to in a meaningful way. For instance, in Germany only 1 in 10,000 refugees that arrived last year are employed. Is accepting a large quantity of people, most of whom do not have the kind of formal education required to be successful in a highly developed economy, beneficial to anybody? What's the end-game for this?

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by freeflight on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:04AM (#13724240)
>Then what? THEN they go back to the border and they create their own communities? How can you __actually__ make that many people leave?

I never claimed the system is perfect because there is no perfect system for such complex problems.

>No, but the fact is these refugees are not able to contribute to the societies they come to in a meaningful way. For instance, in Germany only 1 in 10,000 refugees that arrived last year are employed.

That's because they are legally not allowed to work until their status has been cleared. It's not a matter of them "not wanting to work", it's a matter of not having the right status to work.

The other alternative, one that many populist right-wingers are advocating for, is forcing them to work even when their refugee status is still not cleared up.

But that would actually wreck havoc on labor wages because then you'd suddenly have created a whole new class of people that would work far below average wages just to "justify" their stay in the country. Do I really need to spell out what that would mean for the average low-income worker in the country? Average wages would be pushed even lower than they already are, which has already been a growing problem in Germany for over a decade.

There are no easy solutions to any of this, people who claim there are easy solutions are simply deluding themselves about the long-term ramifications of their solutions.

And no: Just "not letting them in" also ain't no solution, these people won't simply "disappear" just because you hide them behind big fences and walls.

No matter how you frame it, "globalizations" and freedom of movement has it's advantages and brings a lot of positive changes. As somebody who crossed the "Iron curtain" several times, when it still existed, I hardly wish those times back. It would be a step back for Europe and humanity as a whole. Fences and walls don't solve problems, they only compartmentalize them.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by madmax96 on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:37AM (#13724568)
>I never claimed the system is perfect because there is no perfect system for such complex problems.

Agreed. But my real problem here is that there doesn't seem to be any sort of plan. There are many questions that need to be answered, among these:

1. Should a country accept refugees? If yes, how many?

2. Are these refugees permanent residents? If not, what is the timeline of their departure?

3. How do we integrate thousands of people with very diverse backgrounds into our system?

>That's because they are legally not allowed to work until their status has been cleared.

Finding concrete numbers on this issue is surprisingly difficult. I have found from a few different sources that only 13% of in-status refugees have found work. Again, there are real challenges in integrating refugees, and there is no clear plan for how this is to be accomplished.

>these people won't simply "disappear" just because you hide them behind big fences and walls.

Agreed, and something should be done to help them. But I think that the default shouldn't be to let them in. That's foolhardy, especially when governments don't have clear policy answering the questions that I have asked.

In the absence of a clear plan regarding the status of refugees, I can't help but feel that it is irresponsible to accept all. It will require real, concentrated efforts by a government to make a refugee system work in the interests of both refugees and citizens, although I agree that it is an effort worth making.

I respect your experiences with free movement. We agree that we don't desire for "iron curtains" to be re-established. Coming up with an approach to these problems that works is beyond my skill set -- I only hope to see that those who come up with possible systems are able to clearly articulate their details, strengths and weaknesses, and allow the people to make a choice from a selection of systems.

EDIT: I am also going to add that I am aware that some of these questions have definite legal answers, but given that there is so much turbulence and desire to modify existing legal systems that predate the current refugees-crisis, there is a lack of certainty and dialog regarding policy designed to face today's issues.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Nemcue on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:43AM (#13723542)
For context: thelocal is not a reliable newspaper, you shouldn't base your facts from their articles.
[dead]
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by sctb on Friday February 24, 2017 @12:21PM (#13725593)
We need users to comment civilly and substantively, especially on controversial subjects. This just doesn't pass muster.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by gjjrfcbugxbhf on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:56AM (#13724739)
There's lies, damn lies, statistics and biased people interpreting statistics...

2014 is a funny time to end the analysis... We are in 2017.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by vowelless on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:35AM (#13723470)
> The refugee crisis began around 2014, and since then, the rates for sexual violence went down in 2015[1]

Based on your link, it seems clear that the rates went up in 2015 (unless I am grossly misreading that graph).

For 2014 it was a little less than 2%. For 2015 it is more than 3%.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by otalp on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:56AM (#13723646)
You're presumably reading the graph of the % of population polled every year who say "they've been exposed to sex offences"(not necessarily in that specific year), not the actual yearly crime rates, which are lower down and which state:

"In 2015, a total of 18,100 sex offences were reported; this is an 11 per cent decrease as compared with 2014. The number of rapes reported to police decreased by 12 per cent to 5,920 between 2014 and 2015. Reported offences regarding sexual molestation and sexual coercion, exploitation etc. also decreased to 8,840 (-8 %) and 1,430 (-6 %) respectively. "

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by oligopoly on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:11AM (#13723294)
Most of the crimes in Sweden is done by immigrants. Sweden is the rape capital of Europe. It's creepy to see this kind of behaviour condoned and labeled as nothing.

Sweden: Rape Capital of the West https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/5195/sweden-rape

Everything is factual in that statement but seems to burst some peoples bubble.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by matthewmacleod on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:43AM (#13723534)
You are deliberately lying and citing well-known unreliable sources. Why are you doing this? Are you trying to push some pre-concieved agenda? I genuinely don't understand.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by oligopoly on Friday February 24, 2017 @10:34AM (#13724537)
UN rape statistics is unreliable source? It's creepy how lot of people downplay rape in this thread.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by matthewmacleod on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:26AM (#13725031)
There, you're doing it again! You are purposefully seeking to distort the truth, and I don't really understand why you are doing so. Nobody is seeking to 'downplay rape' – an obvious dog-whistle accusation – and instead I reckon people generally want to understand if there is a problem, and if there is, then why there is a problem.

The problems with what you are doing are:

1. You are citing a right-wing think tank. I know that all sources have bias, but this is not even pretending to be an objective one. It's a poor source for data.

2. That think tank bases it's analysis on UN data which explicitly points out that it is not suitable for direct international comparison.

I do not personally know if an increase in immigration in Sweden's resulted in more sexual violence, but I am absolutely certain that we will not figure that out using the sort of facile "why do you love rapists so much" shit that you are spewing.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by cromulent on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:03AM (#13724815)
The source itself says that it is is unreliable :)

"Please note that when using the figures, any cross-national comparisons should be conducted with caution because of the differences that exist between the legal definitions of offences in countries, or the different methods of offence counting and recording."

http://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/statistics/...

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by Entalpi on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:14AM (#13723317)
This my friends is propaganda.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by oligopoly on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:20AM (#13723364)
Excuse me? Downplaying migrant rape and crimes is propaganda.
Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by cromulent on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:36AM (#13723488)
The original chart used in the report you reference comes with cautions in interpreting Sweden's position, which do not seem to have been heeded by the authors of the report.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_statistics#Sweden

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by joshuahedlund on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:58AM (#13725376)
Sweden's definition of rape and the way they count them is much more inclusive than other countries, so it is not valid to compare statistics across countries. See http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-39056786

> if a person comes to the police and reports being raped by a partner or husband every day for the past year, the police will record each of these events. In many other countries these incidents would be recorded just once: one victim, one type of crime and one record.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by facepalm on Friday February 24, 2017 @08:20AM (#13723359)
Doesn't the claim about refugees in Germany use the same trick the Swedish Government uses? There are fewer refugees than native Germans, so even if the absolute number of crimes conducted by Germans would be higher than the absolute number of crimes by refugees, it doesn't say anything about the prevalence of crime in the populations.

For example, if you have 100 "native" Germans and 10 refugees, and there were 3 German criminals and 1 refugee criminal, 10% of refugees would be criminals, but only 3% of Germans, even though more Germans than refugees would be criminals.

Re:Facts about migration and crime in Sweden by pharrington on Friday February 24, 2017 @11:23AM (#13725005)
To me it seems the obvious problem is that the socio-economic dynamical system called Sweden doesn't know how to integrate foreigners. The core problem has nothing to do with the migrant crisis or Muslim cultures. The solution definitely requires a serious examination of the current migrant crisis and Muslim cultures.