News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by angusgr on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:19PM (#1342892)
My guess, on no basis apart from outside knowledge of some other game developer build systems, is that they couldn't actually build this game any more.

I bet either their build system fell apart from disuse, or the one person who understood it left, or it wasn't documented and people just forgot over the years. It was all too time-consuming, manual, and complex compared to using the cracked executable.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by veeti on Thursday May 13, 2010 @05:10AM (#1343716)
That would make sense, since the original creators of Max Payne sold the rights to the game and aren't involved anymore.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:37PM (#1342937)
Seems the most likely, the software industry is pretty bad about maintaining old tooling for this sort of thing.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by mahmud on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:47PM (#1343213)
Sometimes tool vendors deliberately sabotage your maintenance efforts.

A friend of mine called me over to show me his codebase, which is diligently maintained over 12 years using MS Visual Studio 6. As he booted the machine, a .NET update dialog popped up and he clicked "OK". .NET was updated, along with some important VS6 components, and when he fired up the IDE it told him it need to upgrade VS. After upgrading VS, reluctantly, he was no longer able to build the project.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by roofone on Thursday May 13, 2010 @11:32AM (#1344539)
To be pedantic, that's not MS deliberately sabotaging the project. That's perhaps MS being reckless with their upgrades, resulting in (I would suspect), an alienated customer.

My lesson from this comment and the story is that configuration management is more important than I thought.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by phaedrus on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:26AM (#1343379)
The code doesn't even have to be that old - in my indie game company, my partner and I often run into issues just moving code between my machine and his. Things like compiler versions, C++ library versioning issues, third party libraries. I never understood before why big businesses' IT departments are so conservative about upgrading and changing systems, until one day as I was spending my whole weekend fixing problems caused by (needlessly) upgrading to the latest version of GCC I had the epiphany, "You know, this was avoidable."
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by angusgr on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:51AM (#1343441)
Did you have a separate build machine, preferably that built automatically on every checkin, so there was a canonical "it's broken here, but not there" point?

(Not that this avoids this problem, it's just - in my experience - it makes it easier to pinpoint and fix.)

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by dalore on Thursday May 13, 2010 @07:03AM (#1343842)
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by amichail on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:39PM (#1343089)
Why can't they crack it themselves?
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by eru on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:51PM (#1343123)
Would have probably been more work.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by angusgr on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:31PM (#1342919)
The other scary thing is this isn't based on decompilation and analysis of the instructions. It's based on Notepad.

Which implies that Rockstar not only used the crack, they didn't even verify what the crack changed in their binary (otherwise I assume they would seen the logo and at least blanked it out.)

This, in my opinion, crosses the line from "inventive, unethical and lazy" to "extremely reckless, unethical and lazy."

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by romland on Thursday May 13, 2010 @12:11AM (#1343263)
Rockstar not only used the crack

If I recall correctly Myth was not just a cracking group (as in ISO release), they did ripping as well. This basically means that you remove some content from the game (or by other means making the game smaller) in order to fit it into whatever space is the current standard.

Unfortunately I can't find a .NFO regarding the release that lists Myth as the cracker... But it makes me wonder if something was ripped here. :)

NB: Only searched here: http://www.nfohump.com/index.php?menu=quicknav&item=sear... -- enter Myth into "Group" field if you are curious about what else they were up to.

Edit This was Myth's farewell note: http://www.defacto2.net/groups/myth/mythbye.nfo which states that they did ripping:

     We believe that the rip scene is one of incredible skill. Not only 
     is there the cracking talent needed to be successful like that of ISO,
     you must have dedicated coders and rippers to fully complete the task. 
     Much time is needed to perfect a rip like that of Neverwinter Nights. 
     (We'll never forget you old friend)
A bit later on in that same paragraph they continue with saying "We see groups throw out games now with stolen cracks...". Now, who would have thought that Rockstar...

That said, I am not 100% convinced that this was actually a stolen crack. I'll wait for Rockstar to confirm or deny this (or if someone actually has the original release and does a full diff). I base this mainly on three things:

1) I could not find any release information stating Myth as the release group of MP2. This does not mean much, however. And it was just a quick search.

2) It could actually be a joke by Rockstar. I mean, imagine you sit there with the task to remove the copy protection of the game, you bounce it with your boss he laughs and nods and you throw in that Myth logo.

3) It's also not completely unlikely that the guy recompiling the game had some connection with Myth once upon a time. Back in the day (teenager, very long ago <sigh>) we were a bunch of people cracking games for the fun and the race and the majority of them actually went on to work in the gaming industry.

So, can anyone do a diff of the binaries? :)

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by aw3c2 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:42AM (#1343620)
Yeah, this is weird. Max Payne 2 was originally "scene released" by DEViANCE. There is no hint at Myth anywhere on any pre-db I checked. Seeing as many of the Remedy Entertainment developers had their origins in the demoscene, a connection to the warez scene and thus an ex-scener "faking" this does not sound too unlikely.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @05:57AM (#1343775)
See my comment below. Myth and DEViANCE were partners.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by aw3c2 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @07:45AM (#1343899)
You are right, the DEViANCE executables both have the Myth logo in them.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:53AM (#1343538)
The ripping groups had the best crackers, while the ISO groups had the best suppliers. It was normal for Myth to partner with an ISO group to get a game, crack it for them, and then rip the audio/videos and release the 0day version.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by s3graham on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:29AM (#1343387)
> So, can anyone do a diff of the binaries? :)

Probably not easily. SecureROM and similar do full file encryption, so you'd have to crack it yourself and then diff.

I'd like to believe #3, but I'm guessing someone needed to "get it done today", googled up a nocd, and went home early.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by romland on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:32AM (#1343395)
Me too. And yeah, you are most likely right (on both accounts). But I couldn't help but throw in the speculation. :)
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by phaedrus on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:36AM (#1343403)
This doesn't sound plausible as a joke. If you were going to do such an obscure joke, why choose Myth? Why not say "Gotcha" or make up an obviously fake cracking group name.

Number 3 is at least plausible, but anyone who could do this would have to also know that he'd be caught if someone read the binary. Now, if someone wanted to play a real practical joke, it would be to patch the compiler binary so that the compiler automatically inserts this binary watermark in whatever is compiled.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by staunch on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:17PM (#1343034)
They're playing with fire. If I can't trust Steam games to be 100% virus free I'm a heck of a lot less likely to continue buying them. They owe their customers a full and complete explanation.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by angusgr on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:32PM (#1342922)
Unless it was intentionally left there as some kind of in-joke, I suppose.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by enqk on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:23AM (#1343491)
Cracking groups have as much of an incentive not to add viruses to executables than companies do. Their only worth is their fame and the status it procures them. Hurting it through delivering a botched product would erase years of work in building that reputation.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by jpcx01 on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @08:24PM (#1342755)
Pretty funny, but seems like a perfectly valid approach. Some dude at Rockstar could either code a no-cd workaround himself to get it listed on Steam, or just reuse one that already works (and was extremely well tested by the pirate community). Imagine trying to obtain (and understand) the source code for a game binary released 7 years ago

No brainer if you ask me. He just forgot to remove the credits.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by Psyonic on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:30PM (#1342914)
As backwards as it seems... isn't that copyright infringement?
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by sliverstorm on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:41PM (#1342951)
What, infringing Myth's copyright on the crack? Even if you're right- they had a copyright, and it was enforceable- I doubt there is a person who would be willing to step forward and claim ownership of the crack. Whole point of anonymous groups was nobody could pin it on you.

Plus, restitution of copyright infringement is usually based on damages done. Considering Myth's 'product' was free, there are no sales damages.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by pmh on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:09PM (#1343020)
Technically, restitution could come in form of statutory damages instead of actual damages. In the US though, the work has to be registered and the crack would certainly fall foul of the DMCA anyway. It would be interesting if a cracker in another country claimed infringement.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by flomo on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:53PM (#1343126)
If you accept the other poster's theory that the crack is a reconstructed binary, then the crack itself is copyright infringement.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by guelo on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:59AM (#1343453)
Sounds like the advantages of open source. What they should have done is "accidentally" leaked the code several years ago and now they'd have tons of extras and addons to sell.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by llimllib on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:41PM (#1343096)
Are you sure that the binary is virus free? Why do you believe so?

(I suspect it is, but how do I know?)

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by codexon on Thursday May 13, 2010 @12:20AM (#1343274)
and was extremely well tested by the pirate community

and perhaps stuffed with a trojan or two for good measure

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by mambodog on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:01AM (#1343550)
provided it came from a high level source (ie they didn't download it off limewire) then i very much doubt it. the original group doing something like that would be scene suicide. keep in mind these groups are only doing it for the kudos.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by codexon on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:48AM (#1343632)
There is no evidence that this particular version was an original.

It is beyond their control if some hackers in Russia downloads the original, stuffs a trojan, and then passes it off as a copy.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by taitems on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:21PM (#1342895)
I guess a lot of the stigma is associated with the cracks, as well as the warez websites themselves that would constantly infect computers.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:27PM (#1343066)
This was probably more than just a no-cd crack. Most retail games are protected by some type of packing system (meaning the .code section of PE executable is encrypted on the hard disk and then decrypted once in memory). The cracker has to dump the .code section to the disk once it is unpacked while in memory and then rebuild the executable (hence the ability to put the Myth logo in the file) to run properly (and probably cracking the additional no-cd checks).

So this is could be bad, real bad, since it's a executable that was basically rebuilt from a memory dump, not by a compiler.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by DCoder on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:21AM (#1343487)
Electronic Arts did a similar thing when creating the C&C First Decade collection DVD: Red Alert 2 was recompiled to modify CD checks (the game compares the CD label against a hardcoded one, on top of the usual CD checks), but its expansion pack, Yuri's Revenge, was hex-edited instead to the same effect. This was done to maintain compatibility with the community-made patch that hooks into the EXE at assembly level to add new functions and fix bugs. (I'm the current lead developer for said patch.)

See, EA is not all bad. :-)

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by thenbrent on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:53PM (#1342979)
Maybe the Myth team now work for Rockstar and just wanted to reuse their own code haha.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by kevinh on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:22AM (#1343488)
Max Payne 2 just updated on Steam. I'll give you guys two guesses at what happened to the executable.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by est on Thursday May 13, 2010 @12:00AM (#1343243)
I remember years ago the same thing happened to another steam game?
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by romland on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:19AM (#1343366)
Yeah, Ubisoft used a Reloaded crack for Rainbow 6: Vegas 2. :)
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:16PM (#1343033)
uh, will someone just do a fc.exe /B already?
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by romland on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:22AM (#1343371)
Not sure why you were down modded. I'm pretty curious myself.

(fc.exe = filecompare)

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by yread on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:47AM (#1343630)
I think he is getting down modded because game executables are usually packed when they come from the distributor and the crack groups pack them again some more to save space and protect the changes they made from competition.

Cracking a game like that involves running it getting the image of it from memory (perhaps multiple times) and then reconstructing important loader structures (library imports, sections, resources). And only after that can you actually concern yourself with removing or overcoming the actual software protection

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @06:00AM (#1343780)
I know how they are cracked (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1343066). I was wondering why no one was doing a file compare on the original Myth cracked exe and the one from Steam.

But you're wrong about game exes being packed by release groups. There is nothing to "hide" from other groups. Once you remove the commercial protector (SecureROM, etc.) the rest of the patches are pretty trivial.

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by tlb on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @08:39PM (#1342798)
Probably just a Martian face. I suspect you could find equally plausible logos in many binaries by trying enough combinations of screen width & formatting and doing some kind of image recognition on the ascii art.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by chaosmachine on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:02PM (#1342860)
It's much easier to see when you use the proper font.

http://imgur.com/ztRPu.png

Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by u238 on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:00PM (#1343000)
+1 for DAMN NFO Viewer ;) old skool
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by pmcginn on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:41PM (#1342950)
Thanks for the picture. This is a minor but persistent pet peeve of mine. The first thing I do on a fresh Linux install is grab terminus.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira... by aresant on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @08:41PM (#1342804)