Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by Psyonic on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:30PM
(#1342914)
As backwards as it seems... isn't that copyright infringement?
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by sliverstorm on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:41PM
(#1342951)
What, infringing Myth's copyright on the crack? Even if you're right- they had a copyright, and it was enforceable- I doubt there is a person who would be willing to step forward and claim ownership of the crack. Whole point of anonymous groups was nobody could pin it on you.
Plus, restitution of copyright infringement is usually based on damages done. Considering Myth's 'product' was free, there are no sales damages.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by pmh on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:09PM
(#1343020)
Technically, restitution could come in form of statutory damages instead of actual damages. In the US though, the work has to be registered and the crack would certainly fall foul of the DMCA anyway.
It would be interesting if a cracker in another country claimed infringement.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by flomo on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:53PM
(#1343126)
If you accept the other poster's theory that the crack is a reconstructed binary, then the crack itself is copyright infringement.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by guelo on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:59AM
(#1343453)
Sounds like the advantages of open source. What they should have done is "accidentally" leaked the code several years ago and now they'd have tons of extras and addons to sell.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by llimllib on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:41PM
(#1343096)
Are you sure that the binary is virus free? Why do you believe so?
(I suspect it is, but how do I know?)
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by codexon on Thursday May 13, 2010 @12:20AM
(#1343274)
and was extremely well tested by the pirate community
and perhaps stuffed with a trojan or two for good measure
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by mambodog on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:01AM
(#1343550)
provided it came from a high level source (ie they didn't download it off limewire) then i very much doubt it. the original group doing something like that would be scene suicide. keep in mind these groups are only doing it for the kudos.
Re:Steam version of Max Payne 2 is a version cracked by pira...
by codexon on Thursday May 13, 2010 @03:48AM
(#1343632)
There is no evidence that this particular version was an original.
It is beyond their control if some hackers in Russia downloads the original, stuffs a trojan, and then passes it off as a copy.
No brainer if you ask me. He just forgot to remove the credits.