They don't dangle from a cable when falling like normal headphones or Bluetooth headphones that have a cable between each earpiece. Since it's also so comfortable, the user might not even notice they lost an earpiece immediately if they are not listening to anything. (which will specially happen if the user has incentives to use it day long).
And more annoyingly, you will most likely lose just one of the pair. Will you be able to buy just one eapiece and pair it alongside the old pairless earpiece? I don't think so...
edit: fixed wording as eric_h pointed out
>But what about the possibility of losing the earpieces?
It's interesting to see how many people seem want to stop the conversation at "you're bound to lose one so what's the point."10-15 years ago people the argument could have been made about cell phones, "why carry a phone you're bound to leave at a restaurant or on a train..."
If the AirPods or wireless mini computers in your ears become so integrated into our day to day lives one falling out will become obvious pretty quick. And the price will drop, maybe not for the Apple versions, but what about Google Now in $40 wireless earbuds in two or three years?
I don't want more batteries and dongles to carry around. A phone and a headphone are already cumbersome in my pocket.
Eventually we will have batteries powerful enough to eliminate the need for that dental floss thing, and the industry will finally standardize induction charging making charging the earpieces anywhere a reality.. but until then, apple is just ahead of the time.
But in a bad sense. Instead, they could just have made a product that is more realistic with the technology we have.
I will politely disagree. If the automation/augmentation/functionality provided is good enough then losability is a non-factor. If the capabilities afforded by the wireless W1 chips don't live up to the hype then dental floss ain't going to save them.
Could. But it wasn't because they were big and exciting so you would look pretty stupid saying that.
Losing those cigarette buts though is not a big problem. I have some Plactronics for some years now and there is a reason why they still hang at your neck.
But I guess, people who jump on that right now will have no problem spending that money again and again and...
My particular form of obsessive-compulsive behavior revolves around finding and losing things. One of my big life lessons is that things don't get lost when you have a place for them — the keys go here, the wallet goes here, the phone goes here, they never get lost.
If the Airpods never needed to be charged, or could charge wirelessly by being dropped on a magnetic pad or something, I fully expect that they would get lost all the time. But the tic-tac case is an integral accessory — when you're wearing Airpods, the case is in your pocket, and when you're not wearing Airpods, the the Airpods are in the case.
(I was sad when Apple stopped including docks with iPhones, those solved a problem that most people don't realize they have)
I think the number of people who lose these things will be surprisingly low.
Also, I imagine you mean "likely lose just one of the pair", as losing one pair means losing both of them (not intended as a dig, just helping to clarify; your intentions seemed clear)
I don't think I'm alone in that though, which is great for Apple: if they're working better than expected, then consumers will love it. Expectations are everything.
Why didn't Apple allow for custom earbuds e.g. Comply or provide some way to modify the physical design to accomodate people with different ears.
It's not a hipster 'artisinal' thing as much as they ostensibly work better, and they aren't "hand carved"... there are refined process for this.
But they are supposed to be much more comfortable and sound better. I can't comment becasue I don't play enough (or make enough playing) to justify spending $500-800 on them.
And I believe (but am not sure) that there are existing bluetooth solutions, though I couldn't imagine using those in a professional music monitoring context.
So I can easily imagine that there will be custom refitting of these devices. However, custom molds often cost $200-300 (or more) by themselves, plus the drivers, so not in my proce range.
I do use my "cheap" (Shure se215 ~$100) wired IEMs with my iphone now when I want more isolation than open-backed earbuds like ones that came with my phone. They are great for mowing the lawn.
But maybe the airpods are more reliant on the ambient sound, so I dunno if there is much to gain from custom molds.
Physics?
Is it possible Apple could implement some sort of loss alert mechanism for this?
Ideally each earpiece would have a low-power heartbeat even when in your pocket to continually verify they haven't been lost.
(Apple has already said there will be a way to replace a lost single unit.)
Get on any rush hour subway in NYC and see how very wrong you are.
Have you never seen anyone jogging or on a train or a bus?
I've seen plenty of men with the stud earrings that are probably upwards of $400 that go jogging and do everything as normal but I've never heard of those falling off.
That said, you're spot on with your forecasts of how great this could be, the AR of audio is potentially awesome.
You really think that Apple removed the headphone jack to make a bit more cash? Seriously? Hand-on-heart honestly, you think that's why? Come on.
I think it's because they love cool new things. Thank fk they do because, frankly, nobody else seems to be doing anything interesting. I know, I know, they're not perfect. AirPods are late. They're expensive. I know.
But I guarantee you that, come 2020, you will be hard pushed to find a set of wired headphones that resemble those we wear today. I would bet my current net worth on it†. The time has come to do new things with headphones. You want to call them "magical"? Maybe not. But a tiny thing that sits in my ear, Star Trek style, that I can tap and talk to Siri, that detects when I'm talking, that mutes itself, that swaps between paired devices seamlessly, that charges in a little tic-tac case, that's cool. That's what the world wants. It's certainly what I want.
But hey, I guess we can just assume they're trying to scrape a few more dollars out of everyone. Yep, that's probably what this is about.
(†Not currently all that much, but hey.)
Yes.
And honestly, if you think a big company like Apple does anything without the motivation of making money, then frankly you're being starry-eyed and naive.
Maybe if they were a little start-up or something, sure, I could buy that argument. But yes, I entirely, whole-heartedly believe that Apple is doing this for money. If not, why not release the air pods first, then release a few generations of iPhones with audio jacks? It's not like having that little hole in the bottom of a phone would stop Apple from generating more "magical" technology.
I don't doubt Apple thinks that air pods are cool, but come on, seriously.
So do you really think they will jeopardize sales of their most profitable iphone devices to squeeze some extra cash from a niche earpod device?
Also water proofing.
But I guarantee you that, come 2020, you will be hard pushed to find a set of wired headphones that resemble those we wear today.
Yup, commenting just in case I really want to see if this prediction pans out in only three years: wired earbuds will no longer be sold. Oh! You said, "found". Oh, OK, "found"I'm biased. When I want to put on earphones, I want to hear, not be heard. That's the primary function. Not to be some bizarre com. THESE Airbuds are totally useless to me, even if I have a device that supports them. Can I take them running, or cycling? That's a good majority of my "not sleeping, not working" time. I don't need another attempt at augmented reality, I need to remember I used to go to places to talk to people, not manipulate a screen, or talk to a computer assistant.
I remember when Bluetooth headsets came out. They were decidedly not cool. Like, "look at the crazy person talking to themself while walking" not cool.
(†Not currently all that much, but hey.)
It's more than me. I'm taking the bet.But when I'm out and about, cycling to work, listening to a podcast on the train, at work on a conference call? The AirPods are going to be amazing for that sort of thing. That's what I mean by "hard pushed to find a set of wired headphones that resemble those we wear today".
I wasn't clear in my frothing rage, for which I apologise. ;-)
Siri sucks. Once you've spoken to Google via "Ok Google" you quickly realize how bad Siri is.
The world doesn't need Airpods. I get that you want them, but the overwhelming majority in the _world_ can not afford Airpod. I would bet that sales of Airpods will be as transparent as the iWatch... as in completely opaque.
And it overtook all other regular watchmakers, except for Rolex, in sales: http://wornandwound.com/apple-second-rolex-worldwide-sales-m...
Apple doesn't make products for "the world", they make products for well-off people who have the cash to spend. "The World" still uses sub-$100 Android phones or dumbphones and will do so for the foreseeable future.
I'm positive most people will still be using cheap wired headphones 3 years from now. If you're willing to lay money on it, I'll take any bet you offer.
A simple press of a button on my BT headset (Sony btw, not Apple) and "Call my wife" is a lot easier in the winter than digging out my phone, removing my glove for TouchID and browsing to my wife's contact in the phone app.
A quick shout of "Hey Siri, set timer for 12 minutes" while cooking is faster than fiddling with the kitchen timer - which I had lost. Again.
Also "What's the weather like tomorrow morning" when I come home to see if I need to plug in my car heater for the night or not.
There are just some things that are faster spoken to a digital assistant (Siri, Cortana or Google Assistant) than done by tapping on a screen.
On the other hand, tapping the screen is a lot more appropriate in public than asking "Navigate to my proctologist appointment" :P
There is like 4-5 others simple interactions like that that I do in private every day and it's totally worthwhile.
"Hey siri, delete all my alarms"
Today:
- "Call John Smith on speaker"
- "What's 110 pounds in kilograms?"
Both simple, granted, but both got me what I wanted much quicker than I could have done manually.
And Siri will just open the Wikipedia entry for "price" :)
Jokes aside, Siri has fallen really, really far behind Google Now. It's jokingly bad at even the most mundane tasks.
The best thing about Google Assistant (not Google Now) is the context sensitivity. You can ask "how tall is Tom Cruise", get an answer and then ask "how old is he" and Assistant will pick up who you're talking about. Siri will just get completely baffled.
Unless the came up with better design there is no way I am forgetting I am wearing apple earbuds.
Edit: I should add that with in-ear headphones, I was always able to get a good fit by using the one-step smaller rubber ends for the left ear and the default one for the right ear. Never had a problem that way. Still, I prefer over the ear these days, and they also double as earmuffs in the winter time!
You wear them, they ache until your ears adjust, then it's second nature.
Assuming you wear them more than 10 minutes at a time.
I can't be the only one who used those garbage earbuds included with the game boy for years afterwards.
If you really dislike wireless for some reason, you can also get lighting earbuds (I think the iPhone 7 actually includes some).
Finally, if you like all these ideas so much, you can avoid purchasing the product you dislike. It's not like they're forcing this onto existing clients by disabling the existing 3.5mm jack.
Well yeah, they sort of are. The future is wireless, there's really no denying that at this point.
Where is the augmented reality device they're going to be targeting with this?
If anything you'll see them take on something like google cardboard or oculus directly before they do something really left field with headphones. But even that is a couple years away.
[1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/vue/vue-your-everyday-s...
[2] http://www.macrumors.com/2016/11/16/apple-augmented-reality-...
[3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-14/apple-sai...
Just look at any product in their history - they took music players that were fine but bulky and time-consuming to use and turned them into a single intuitive device that could fit in your pocket, carry your entire library, and sync to the computer without any user intervention. I know a lot of tech people are annoyed with iTunes and want to be able to manually drag and drop the files that they want, but, for the non-tech user, iTunes (which already had all their music organized) would just let them sync their music by plugging in without any intervention at all. Apple may have made an assumption for the masses by assuming everyone's music was organized on the computer they were syncing from (and in iTunes, no less), but, when it worked, it was amazing from an experience standpoint.
That's what these headphones are. Just think about the list of things that suck about headphones in a perfect world - cables and wires suck on anything, wireless is more convenient in every case, pairing bluetooth headphones sucks when they get disconnected, the batteries on wireless headphones suck. These are their answer to those complaints - headphones that last much longer than others with a charger that is also a case that syncs to all your devices and intelligently plays wherever from whatever device you're using. Whether they succeed is another story, but the explanation for this product is there.
Nobody listens to music 24/7 ...
(This is a rhetorical question. You don't have to answer, because the answer is self-evident.)
Two extra months isn't going to fix that IMHO. If you are struggling to get a minimum viable product, it's worrisome.
Who knows though, maybe the problems they had were in the actual manufacturing of them.
This product category is not worth the hassle for the average user. Very few people will buy a second pair of wireless earbuds. Not enough to warrant building all the features you mention.
> and possibly most people
This is where you and Apple disagree, and Apple's record here is pretty good.1. I would hate to talk to a person with those things in their ears.
2. I use my bluetooth headphones the same way I use my wired headphones.
3. I don't feel comfortable talking out loud to nobody in public. It doesn't feel right to talk the phone, I will probably never talk to the air. I'm not a self conscious person, but I care if people think I'm crazy.
I think we're already past the point of that being a barrier.
These things are probably the (nearish) future. I thought the Moto Hint was great a year or so ago and with Apple stepping into the market it should encourage the competition.
I don't have a problem with a cable. I actually don't understand why people would want to replace a cheap, robust, simple technology like a cable with non-replaceable batteries and signal-degrading wireless.
Also I don't need my phone to talk at me all day.
But, "courage".
These are light weight, designed for comfort.
I am sceptical
The concept explained by erikpukinskis wouldn't require a neutral canvas; it could generate the speech audio adapted to the binaural system.
If they add positioning, this product becomes Magic Leap without the visuals. I don't think they see this as a music device, they see it as a new platform for audio. Interesting things start happening when people start leaving one or both in their ears all day. Arrival times in your ear at the bus stop. Ask Siri for a price check while at the store, etc.
A cable to your phone makes the earbuds hard to forget. This makes it easy, but the design details have to be right for you to truly forget they are in.
I know "forget they're in" doesn't sound like a groundbreaking feature, because it's not connected to any obvious technical challenge, but I think if they succeed at that it would in fact put these in a new category.
Positional audio would seal the deal. You can walk around your kitchen and it would feel like your invisible conversation partner was in the room with you.