News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:59AM (#12907453)
This is definitely the preference falsification election.

Those who know me on HN know that I'm an outspoken proponent of unorthodox ideas. I'm regularly shouted down, called racist/evil/etc, downmodded and flagged on HN. I also get a steady stream of private emails: "I wouldn't say this publicly cause of the bullies, but that .gov link with all the data does seem to support you. I think you might be right, I need to rethink my views." These folks very rarely post here - they are afraid of social and perhaps professional approbrium (ala Brendan Eich and Curtis Yarvin).

Those folks are engaging preference falsification.

Off HN there is a similar manufactured consensus, similar social penalties for expressing the wrong ideas, and similar levels of preference falsification. When pollsters call the preference falsification continues.

Apparently in the privacy of a voting booth, people are willing to express their true beliefs.

Note: I don't support Trump - search my posting history for "open borders" - but I do understand why folks like him. I don't agree with him on basically any policy, but my visceral emotional reaction to his victory is positive: I love the great big "fuck you" to the biased media sneering at him, calling him racist based on "dog whistles" and then writing hit pieces against Ken Bone (let alone the bullying of folks like Tim Hunt, Brendan Eich and Curtis Yarvin).

See also Scott Aaronson who explains this in more detail: http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2777

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by scarmig on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:19AM (#12907690)
Full disclosure: I'm a Hillary voter, after much internal fretting about voting third party or writing in Obama.

Looking at the reactions on my Facebook feed, the large majority of people seem to be taking from this experience the learning that Trump voters are all disgusting misogynistic racist pigs, and America deserves to be damned for its sins against the pro-Clinton media orthodoxy.

It's tiring, because in terms of concrete policies, I line up fairly closely with what I imagine Clinton's "true" beliefs to be. But anyone who mentions anything against the progressive catechism is evil. If you even misprioritize items on the agenda, you become evil. And everyone with actual power seems to be in on this train out to condemn the bad think--academia, the media, corporate management, you name it. Even now I worry about this comment being tracked to my real identity and facing professional repercussions because of implying that the bad think can sometimes be reasonable.

My hope is that this loss forces left activists to re-evaluate how they treat dissent.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by clifanatic on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:16AM (#12910806)
I remember my Facebook feed from 8 years ago - my liberal friends were celebrating, and my conservative friends were disappointed, but trying to be (somewhat) conciliatory. Now, my conservative friends are celebrating but my liberal friends attitude is "screw America, I hope you choke in your own vomit, you racist bastards".
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by andrewvc on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:42AM (#12910966)
Oh please. There's been 8 years of racist conservative commentary about Obama. Trump was leading the racist 'birther' movement charge. Don't act like its a double standard.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by talmand on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:33AM (#12911605)
I'm forgetting the details; can you explain how the birther movement, no matter how stupid, was about race?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by andrewvc on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:24PM (#12912304)
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by talmand on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:31PM (#12913763)
I see nothing in that article that shows the birther movement (again, no matter how stupid) was based on racial reasons, other than certain people's opinions that it did.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by inflagranti on Friday November 11, 2016 @04:51AM (#12929275)
What else was it based on though? Honest question, to my knowledge there was never ever any similar issue raised for any president before and there seems to never have been any really good reason to doubt he was born here, no you, except that one. So I don't really think it's just opinion but the only logical conclusion to why this was started, no?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by dopamean on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:09AM (#12911260)
This is a meaningless, useless anecdote. My experience eight years ago was that conservatives were foaming at the mouth in anger when Obama won. They had literally just spent the last year calling him the antichrist and saying that he was literally not American. And today my experience on facebook is literally frowny emojis from liberals and not much else.

Edit: LITERALLY

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by knowaveragejoe on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:09PM (#12926039)
It's almost like the previous person forgets the(fairly serious) talk of secession after Obama won again 2012.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by clifanatic on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:56PM (#12923121)
I don't remember seeing conservatives rioting in the streets, or burning flags, or calling for the death of Obama voters in 2008.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:47AM (#12911007)
You have significantly nicer conservative friends than I do. It's been 8 years of racist, xenophobic bile from most of the conservatives on my FB feed, and several of their politicians (Ted Cruz) as well.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by goda90 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:29AM (#12910888)
Remind them that the DNC actively worked to get both Trump and Clinton into the candidacy, thinking that their corrupt status quo candidate could beat an unsavory populist. Just pushing negative media about Trump validated the scapegoats of many disenfranchised people and has increased the hate in this country.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:40AM (#12907949)
Obama is a huge part of why this happened. He promised change and delivered empire.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by scarmig on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:56AM (#12908164)
Eh, I do have plenty of foreign policy disagreements in particular with him. But he's the best we've had in living memory.

Liberalism has had a smug aspect as long as I've been alive, but at this point that aspect has metastasized to something worse. The norms that have developed are toxic to progressive movements. They certainly alienate people, but beyond that they make it so you don't even have the institutional capacity to understand or formulate policies relevant to those people.

It's a perverse version of the situation people thought Republicans were in in 2012, where they seemed to have driven out most non-white people and thereby lacked the capacity for effective outreach to them. Except in this case, if you're a poor white male in Wisconsin who's done everything right but is still struggling like hell, you're an evil oppressor who just doesn't recognize your privilege. People who can understand where the poor white male perspective is coming from are literally shouted out of discussions for diverting attention from the people uniquely experiencing True Suffering and blessed with progressive sainthood.

It's beyond Obama. Who, for what it's worth, has always struck me as the thoughtful type who wouldn't buy into those kinds of fake dichotomies. It's a broader issue with progressive movements where people earn cred by honing their sensitivities enough to maximize the level of offense they can experience.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:07AM (#12908294)
I agree with everything you have said. Obama is a thoughtful type and a great orator. I'm sure he would have liked to enact some of the change he promised but he didn't. In many ways America regressed further under his watch and this is the outcome.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by triplesec on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:36AM (#12909379)
I think it's not that he didn't, but he couldn't, with the most obstructive Congress in modern history
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by privong on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:56AM (#12909867)
> I think it's not that he didn't, but he couldn't, with the most obstructive Congress in modern history

Ironically, some of that might have been his own doing, though. The healthcare reform was passed essentially without republican support; I think that's a very rare example of major [healthcare] legislation that was not passed with bi-partisan support. Not doing more to bring R's on board likely burned lots of political capital and hardened opposition to him in Congress. I'm not saying Obama didn't try at all to bring R's on board, just that a bit more effort might have result in a more cooperative Congress.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:41AM (#12910130)
The GOP congress decided to bring Obama down from the start, and never gave an inch. He tried valiantly to collaborate and compromise but the GOP didn’t have the political capacity to work with Obama for fear of being challenged in primaries from the right.

You’re right that the ACA ended up being a political disaster for the Democrats though.

The ACA was basically the same as “RomneyCare” in MA, and was a style of healthcare reform supported by mainstream center-right Republicans and some center-left Democrats (most Democrats wanted a single payer plan, or at least a public option, but took what they could get because the healthcare system was/is at a breaking point), but once Obama’s name was on it they all decided to throw everything they could against it.

The GOP campaigned hard against the ACA after it passed, and won massively in the midterm elections in 2010 on the back of wall-to-wall anti-ACA messaging on right-leaning media and a huge amount of organizing and spending (the first post-Citizens United election). They took control of the House, Senate, and many state legislatures, following which they redrew all the district boundaries to cut Democrats permanently out of competition in the House and many state legislatures.

After the crushing defeat in 2010, there weren’t enough Senate seats up for grabs in 2012 for the Democrats to regain control. Thus Obama had to deal with 6 years of GOP control, which has been the most obstructionist Congress in US history. As soon as McConnell won in 2010 he publicly declared that his #1 goal was to make Obama a 1-term president. We had multiple government shutdown threats, unprecedented obstruction of executive appointments including judges at every level of the federal court system, bogus investigation after bogus investigation into e.g. Benghazi, and dozens of purely symbolic votes to repeal the ACA.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by chimeracoder on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:50PM (#12913334)
> The ACA was basically the same as “RomneyCare” in MA, and was a style of healthcare reform supported by mainstream center-right Republicans

Romneycare never really had widespread support of Republicans at the national level. Or, really, the support of Republicans in general. It was passed by a governor in a state where almost every single elected state legislator is a Democrat, so it's hardly a measure of what to expect Republicans to support when the population they represent is more moderate, conservative, or Republican-affiliated.

Using Romney's actions as governor of MA as a yardstick is a really skewed perspective to try and apply to national politics. Massachusetts has a history of electing Republican governors as a way of placing a "check" on the legislature. Currently, Massachusetts has a Republican governor - but Baker would likely have run under the Democratic party if we were talking about Montana or Kansas instead of Massachusetts.

> and some center-left Democrats (most Democrats wanted a single payer plan, or at least a public option, but took what they could get because the healthcare system was/is at a breaking point)

It was never the case that "most" Democrats wanted a single-payer plan. The public option was more popular within the Democratic party, but even then was very controversial, and didn't have strong enough support from the Democrats.

There was, incidentally, a proposal that did have bipartisan support (the Wyden-Bennett bill), but it fell short of 60 votes.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pessimizer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:22AM (#12910452)
And to not just push single-payer when they were never going to get Republican support burned a lot of his support on the left. He spent an enormous amount of effort whipping the Democrats to the right in order to pass ACA as the great compromise that he conceived (it was a Heritage Foundation policy after all); and the most controversial part of it (the universal cash penalty for being uninsured) was a Clinton policy that he campaigned against in the primary and won.

He didn't have to bring any Republicans on board. What he had to have was the integrity to push for what he had the mandate to deliver, instead of all of this pre-compromising, losing anyway, then eventually quarter-assing something through presidential fiat or lack of enforcement. If President Obama had chosen to pursue the policies that Candidate Obama had been elected on, the voters would have punished congressmen who got in his way. Instead he had one of the least transparent administrations imaginable, passed a bunch of complex garbage with a million special interest carveouts, and tried to create social change through undemocratic executive action.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rndmize on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:43AM (#12911738)
Not even remotely close to true. Obama put in a ton of effort into crossing party lines, and was rejected, delayed, lied about - I remember how the discussion of the ACA was going on for months and month and MONTHS of stonewalling, how he went to the Republican retreat to discuss the issue and make some points after most of a summer and fall of obstructionism and demolished Republican arguments effectively enough that Fox cut away from the live broadcast after 20 minutes. I remember the supercommittee, and how the Republican absolutely refused to bend on any of their points, while the Democrats bent on theirs, over and over. The debt ceiling showdowns...

After his first year in office, Obama started getting shit from people on the left because a lot of them thought he was trying too hard to reach across the isle and unify the nation instead of ignoring the obstructionists and getting stuff done.

http://www.politico.com/story/2010/01/obama-rumbles-with-hou... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2010/ja...

> Consider that Obama's $787bn stimulus bill of last spring was heavily weighted toward tax cuts, against the advice of many economists, in an effort to win some Republican support. In the end, the bill received not a single Republican vote.

> Consider that he nominated a moderate, pro-prosecution Supreme Court justice, Sonia Sotomayor, only to see her tagged as a racist over some rather innocuous remarks she made about being a "wise Latina".

> Consider, too, that healthcare reform became bogged down in such a compromise-ridden mess because Obama ruled out a single-payer system ahead of time and never strongly backed a government-owned insurance alternative (the "public option") to compete with private insurance companies.

> As with the stimulus bill, the idea was to bring along a few Republican senators thought to hold reasonable views on the subject, such as Charles Grassley of Iowa and Olympia Snowe of Maine. And again, no Republican support was forthcoming, forcing Senate leaders to cut outrageous deals with recalcitrant Democrats Ben Nelson of Nebraska and Mary Landrieu of Louisiana.

> Obama's attempts to find compromise solutions did not stop Republicans from labelling him as a radical – or their nutty tea-party allies from calling him a "socialist" and worse. And, in retrospect, that was going to happen no matter what he did. His real problem has been that, to his supporters, he looked as though he'd been sucked into the very system he was elected to reform. Thus an Obama ally like Martha Coakley, a loyal Democratic apparatchik who'd long been criticised for her reluctance to take on political corruption in Massachusetts, became the perfect foil. (Coakley is best known for prosecuting Louise Woodward, a British nanny accused of killing a baby in her care.)

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xherberta on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:13AM (#12909976)
Particularly troublesome is the dynamic where congresspeople need campaign funds, and largely get them from PACs and industry. With ObamaCare (ACA), the insurance and pharma industries were well-represented, coming away with concessions worth billions.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by humanrebar on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:24AM (#12909310)
You're too kind to Obama. Obama did troll his opponents on many occasions (like saying snarky things about birth certificates). He ran on a better type of politics, but he gave up on it very quickly, to phrase it charitably.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:41AM (#12910133)
"He's the best we've had in living memory."

uh, WOW. you must have a short memory because reagan, bush sr, and clinton were all superior in almost every way, and none will eat a terrible policy failure like the aca.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:53AM (#12910223)
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by arethuza on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:17AM (#12910400)
Somewhat surprisingly for a leftish Scot I am a fan of Reagan - for one very important reason. He understood that the standard US view of the Soviets was actually wrong and it was the Soviet leadership who were utterly afraid of the US (perhaps for good reasons) and he changed his approach.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:23AM (#12910462)
It wasn’t widely realized at the time even at high levels of the US government, but the USSR collapsed under its own economic weight, and was in demographic free-fall before Reagan ever took office. It’s unlikely that any action the Reagan administration took had a significant effect on the end result, though arguably US policies might have accelerated or retarded the decline by a couple years.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by arethuza on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:27AM (#12910491)
The Soviet's might have been broke in the 1980s but they were armed to the teeth and I do think that the change from "evil empire" rhetoric to actually engaging with their new leadership probably reduced the risks of an all-out war which few of us would have survived - certainly not here in the UK.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:01AM (#12910282)
not the least bit interested in partisan "journalism". i was alive then.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:14AM (#12910383)
This is an excerpt from a mass-market history/biography book by a renowned historian at UNC Chapel Hill (emeritus), a foremost scholar of FDR’s life and work. It’s not journalism per se (with or without scare quotes) https://www.amazon.com/dp/0195176162/
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by judahmeek on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:13AM (#12910369)
And what metrics are you basing your statements on?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by artimaeis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:35AM (#12910542)
Alright - so we are two people that have very different views of the past 50 years it sounds like.

So, in your perspective, what was something that made Bush Sr a superior president to Obama? Or any of the others you listed? Help me understand your perspective.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:53AM (#12911066)
Wait, what? He ran on fixing the economy (done), ending the war in Iraq (done), restoring our relationship with the rest of the world (done), universal health care (done) and improving the acceptance of minority groups (somewhat done - at least the LGBT community).

Illegal immigration is down, unemployment is down, crime is down.

There are definitely things Obama hasn't done, but he absolutely delivered change, and he did it while facing a completely obstructionist Congress and Senate for most of his tenure. People just get complacent, even when things are going great. No matter how much any president does, or how good things are, people will get antsy just because our human nature forces us to constantly avoid what we perceive as stagnation.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:45AM (#12911779)
Ending the war? He has escalated on all fronts and opened new ones too. Obama talks a good game but under it all is more surveillance, more economic inequality and more violence.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:29PM (#12913738)
Escalating on all fronts? Please elaborate how getting the US out of a major war has done that. I certainly won't claim that Obama's foreign policy is golden, but it was said 'empire'...which would mean invading and occupying all over the globe. Obama isn't even close to the imperialist policies we had under Bush.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:37PM (#12916900)
You haven't been paying attention. Ukraine, Syria (and by proxy Iraq), Libya, Arab Spring, Yemen .... now moving clandestine operations into central Africa. We also have Brazil in SA, we've had dronings in countless other countries, even against US citizens without trial which is also a first and I'm sure I'm missing a few on the hit list. Just because the tactics change doesn't mean he gets a green card.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:11PM (#12912898)
> Wait, what? He ran on fixing the economy (done)...

Not really. It's not at the point of collapse, but it sure wasn't a normal recovery. It's better than 2008, but it's still broken in some very real ways.

> ... ending the war in Iraq (done)...

Sort of. The battle for Mosul was in the news just last week, with US involvement.

> ... restoring our relationship with the rest of the world (done)...

Russia is fighting against our goals in Syria, and illegally occupied the eastern Ukraine. Iran has a nuclear deal with us, but immediately started thumbing its nose at us. China is trying to see how much influence they can gain at our expense in Asia. North Korea's nuclear and missile programs are, according to their rhetoric, aimed explicitly at us.

> ... universal health care (done)...

Seen the premium changes for 2017? The law was passed, but "bending the cost curve" sure didn't happen.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by knz on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:04PM (#12914091)
> Seen the premium changes for 2017?

I'm amused by the Republican concern for rising premiums this year. My health insurance rates have gone up every year by 5-10% for the last 10 years after my work switched to high deductible plans. Between my employer and I the total cost of insurance is $14,400/year. That's more than the total income tax for a median income back in my country of birth. Just for insurance!

There are a lot of things wrong with the ACA/Obamacare but let's not pretend that the giant mess known as the American medical system is solely the responsibility of the Democrats. Every other OECD nation seems to have figured it out....

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:09PM (#12914137)
That's definitely a concern I have - Republicans want to repeal ACA and roll it back to the incredibly expensive system we had before that was bankrupting people. That's exactly what they intend to do.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:27PM (#12913713)
That's what I mean about having some issues. I would have liked to see healthcare be more sweeping, better implemented.

But the 'normal' recovery? What does a 'normal' recovery look like when the global economy is on the brink of collapse, and the US has run up a deficit never seen before? The Great Depression needed a World War to finally pull the US back to recovery.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:42AM (#12918735)
Maybe the second time around.

The first time I remember him talking about reform of Washington.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by mrow84 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:38AM (#12909758)
I'm no expert on US politics, but wasn't he hidebound by a Republican house and senate?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:18AM (#12910010)
Promises were made. Why they weren't kept is irrelevant.

Edit: to clarify this is not my personal position but more a reflection on how I see the electorate behaving.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by crispyambulance on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:26AM (#12910479)
... yes, "promises" are how people defend their vote, and now we're going to get a front-row seat to see what happens to "promises" when the bullshit artist, Trump, is in charge.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by hash-set on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:54AM (#12910668)
Yeah, see you really need to listen to yourself? That article says it all. Now he's a bullshit artist because he can't possibly be competent since he's ostensibly a conservative. It's a fallacy.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by crispyambulance on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:57PM (#12913399)
No, he's a bullshit artist because he has made promises which he is CLEARLY not going to be able to keep like building a wall between Mexico and USA and getting Mexico to pay for it. I could go on and on, but that's a good, concrete example of a "promise" that will go unfulfilled.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:42AM (#12910140)
he controlled both houses when he took office. he rammed through ideological policy aca with zero opposition party input or support; he quickly lost his majorities.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by esja on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:15AM (#12910390)
He also did this at a time when he should have been focused on finishing the job with banking reform.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by verbify on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:23AM (#12910459)
Which is why he has an approval rating of 55%?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by hash-set on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:52AM (#12910651)
Obama failed to even fundamentally pretend to enforce the laws of the land.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:44AM (#12910150)
I've yet to meet a Trump voter who didn't meet that criteria. Just because people don't like to be described in a certain way doesn't mean that it doesn't describe them. Trump didn't win because of any sort of liberal catechism. He won because the media has done a bang up job of scaring the crap out of the average citizen about immigration and terrorism while pimping his brand because he's a perverse curiosity in a suit.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jessaustin on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:10AM (#12910345)
This says more about you than about the American public in general. My brother and his wife, and many of the people with whom I work, are not "disgusting misogynistic racist pigs". Actually I know many more Trump voters than disgusting racist pigs.

The media really couldn't help it, however. Every president from here on out will be a reality show star. Look for Chris Christie to get a show as soon as he gets booted out of the cabinet for another ethical lapse. Chelsea and Ivanka will both start new shows (perhaps together?) in about a decade.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by thecynh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:10AM (#12918611)
> My brother and his wife, and many of the people with whom I work, are not "disgusting misogynistic racist pigs".

I am sure they aren't (well actually I don't know, and as you rightly convey, I obviously CAN'T know just from their pro-Trump vote) but would you agree that people that voted for Trump have to be at least OK with being represented by one "disgusting misogynistic racist pig(s)" without themselves being one? … I really don't want to imply that all or even the majority of Trump voters are bad people (because I don't know any due to not being from the US) but they sure seem OK with having a repulsive person as their prime representative?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jessaustin on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:27PM (#12923397)
Trump is Br'er Rabbit, not a pig. The statements he made that have received the most opprobrium, were made precisely to receive that opprobrium. He correctly calculated that opprobrium, not the statements themselves, would gain him enough votes to win the election. Trump got far more votes from people who wished to reject the standard media narrative than from race-motivated one-issue voters.

The statements themselves may well be racist, but racist speech is a different thing than racist action. People who don't mind appearing to the weak-minded as racists may well actually be racists. However they are different sorts of racists than politicians like Richard Nixon and the Clintons who have destroyed minority lives and communities for political gain.

Children may be excused for only thinking about surface meanings, but after one has voted in several elections, it's time to put away childish things.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zyx321 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:58AM (#12919976)
That's the trouble in a two party (Winner-takes-all AKA first-past-the-post) system is that you can never tell who genuinely approves of Trump, and who merely disapproves of Clinton.

Would you be OK with being represented by a crook, without yourself being one?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by thecynh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:39AM (#12920223)
Your point with the fptp system makes a lot of sense. I didn't think about these implications since where I am from we have a pluralistic political system. Thanks for the insight!

And no, I would not be OK with being represented by a crook. If you are asking for my personal opinion in case of HRC/DT I'd still would have preferred her downsides over his though. Good thing I didn't have to chose I guess.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by BrandonM on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:45AM (#12919909)
Are you suggesting that there were no reasons to dislike Hillary? Or that misogyny and racism live on a plane above all other issues? Because in the end, the people only had two choices in this election.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by thecynh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:37AM (#12920206)
No, sorry I did not want to suggest either of those things. There are reasons to dislike Hillary I am sure, and voting for her would in my opinion imply "being OK" with these reasons. I was really just looking for input, not making a point.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:15PM (#12912176)
Nice. You quoted something I didn't say. Twice.

That says a lot more about you than it does about me.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jessaustin on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:04PM (#12912795)
'scarmig: ...the large majority of people seem to be taking from this experience the learning that Trump voters are all disgusting misogynistic racist pigs...

you: I've yet to meet a Trump voter who didn't meet that criteria.

Are you confused by the English language? Is threaded conversation a new concept for you?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:37AM (#12920208)
Sometimes, cognitive dissonance catches people off guard. MisterBastahrd has just experienced it.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ams6110 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:15AM (#12910799)
I know some Trump supporters who are neither racist nor homophobic nor misogynistic. I also know Hillary voters who will drop the "N" word talking about blacks. You can't really divine who a person is by who they vote for.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by thecynh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:06AM (#12918585)
> You can't really divine who a person is by who they vote for.

Can you elaborate a bit on this? Obviously you can't get to know EVERYTHING a person is just from what they vote for every 4 years but I always felt like you can't vote for Trump and not at least be OK with his sexism, misogyny and yes, racism. What am I missing (not being snarky here, not even from the US)

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by BrandonM on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:38AM (#12919874)
...and you can't vote for Hillary without being OK with obstructing democracy, corporate bailouts, and welfare handouts. At least that's how a lot of people felt who didn't want to vote for Hillary. (I preferred her to Trump, personally.)

People have different priorities. It can be really hard to care about various isms when your life has been borderline misery for a half decade or more.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by thecynh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:41AM (#12920239)
I guess this is true (and another comment implied it has a lot to do with the first past the post system) … It seems just like a lot of other people it's hard for me to be neutral/objective in this when I care more about some issues (Trump's "negatives") than others (Clinton's)

Thanks for your input.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by wcarron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:27AM (#12911487)
Yeah, but there are strong statistical correlations between party affiliation and personal/moral views. Example: Trump voters generally support repealing abortion. They also are heavily white, and either old. or young and poorly educated.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:41AM (#12920232)
But none of those stats said they're racist. It is your own opinion. You're judging them to be racists, even though the stats didn't say so.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:16PM (#12912188)
Please point out where I said anything about homophobia, racism, or misogyny.

Wait... you can't. Nevermind.

And yes, I CAN divine what a person is like by who they vote for when the person they voted for is a ridiculous caricature with zero understanding about how any of this works. If you wouldn't go to a faith healer to get treated for a serious medical condition that required surgery, then why in the hell would you go to a completely unqualified, inexperienced buffoon to run the country?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by cafard on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:17AM (#12910401)
Out of curiosity, how many have you met? I have relatives and in-laws I assume to have voted for Trump. I have friends and acquaintances I assume to have voted for neither major party candidate. But I don't know many Trump voters. Nor, I think, would be I be likely to: Clinton took 94% of my precinct, Trump 2.5%, barely ahead of Stein at 2%.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by usmeteora on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:01AM (#12910275)
I actually agree with you in some cases here. I'm not a huge fan of Hillary. However, as a young women working in technology and male dominated environments, it's really hard for me to believe the pathological sexism isnt a fundamentally limiting component in making everything better. I don't believe women should get free rides and everything should be equal overnight. I'm not a man hater. I know many educated male programmers I work with who agree both work and college culture and the products made in technology would be better if there were an equal gender ratio in the workforce.

As a woman who has been spoken to in previous workplaces the way Trump has spoken poorly of women, it's too much for me to overlook. It may seem like a one off issue for intelligent men who are (and you should) looking at all the contributing components, not just focusing on the pieces targeted media ads bring to light, but to me its a fundamental component for economic and technology depressions that women are not making money and contributing to technological advances and product creation geared for the masses.

It's fundamentally hypocritical to be a proponent for economic growth and treat 3.5 billion people in the population as potential girlfriends instead of opportunity for economic growth beyond buying diamonds on TV (the business his ex supermodel wife has).

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by maratd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:52AM (#12911058)
> products made in technology would be better if there were an equal gender ratio in the workforce.

There is no justifiable reason for a 50/50 split in any industry. Some industries are dominated by women and some by men. That's OK. It just reflects the differences between men and women, and yes, they do exist.

The same applies to the workforce at large. If a larger percentage of women than men choose not to participate in a traditional manner, that's OK. Just because we don't put a dollar figure on rearing kids or community engagement, doesn't mean those activities don't bring substantial value to the table.

> As a woman who has been spoken to in previous workplaces the way Trump has spoken poorly of women

There is a fundamental difference between guys "shooting the shit" and actually behaving that way. He's far too much of a pussy to be grabbing anyone by the pussy. That said, there are certainly scumbags out there who would behave that way and neither you (nor anyone present) should tolerate that kind of behavior, regardless of repercussions.

Well, the last part is easy to say and hard to do. One of the reasons I'm not in a traditional employment setting is that I have a very low tolerance for shitty behavior.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:17PM (#12923315)
>There is a fundamental difference between guys "shooting the shit" and actually behaving that way.

There's also a fundamental difference between killing someone and threatening to kill someone, but that doesn't make either ok.

In any case, there is abundant evidence that Trump does in fact grope women.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:52AM (#12918780)
Hillary was undone by her own sexism. Her loss and Trump's win is the final bankruptcy of feminist ideology, reaping what it sowed.

When Obama ran, did he repeatedly suggest people should vote for him because he was black? I don't recall so. I remember him talking about his policies and beliefs.

Hillary's campaign rapidly devolved after the primaries to "vote for me because I'm not Trump and I'm a (in my view) super competent woman". Her supporters slogan became "I'm with her".

The bigger problem though is how the Dems cleared the way for her to run almost unopposed except for Bernie, an independent who didn't give a crap what the Democrats thought. Trump defeated many primary challengers. Where were the D alternatives to Hillary? Apparently the idea spread that it was Hillary's "turn", that after a black man there should be a woman, and wouldn't that be a nice historical motif.

So the Dems tipped the playing field towards one of the weakest, most easily attacked candidates in US history. She can't give speeches. She has few policy ideas beyond starting a war with Russia (NFZ in Syria). She exudes corruption. She epitomises the widely disliked status quo. She has more skeletons in her closet than a medical student. She would have been the continuation of a dynasty. Yet somewhere, the groupthink-saturated world that decides these things decided it was time for a female President and after that her qualifications became irrelevant. Feminists, both male and female, became so transfixed with breaking "the last glass ceiling" that they grabbed the first female to come along and demanded she be made top dog.

Disagree? Give me a better explanation for how the Democrats mysteriously found themselves with an almost empty stable of primary challengers to Clinton.

People and especially women need to stop talking about gender imbalances or the "injustice" of them or how to fix them - it's yesterday's conversation. Trying to "fix" these non-problems by tipping the playing field towards women gives you Trump, a man who is the walking embodiment of not giving a shit about feminists. If the Dems had simply treated HRC as anyone else, they might be in power now.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by usmeteora on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:06AM (#12920428)
yeh so, I was not at all trying to defend Hillary, at all, as I mentioned in the first sentence, so I'm not sure why I need to reagree with you on all of this you just said, because I do, entirely, which is why me and almost every female I know, most of whom are highly educated and work in tech/male dominated fields, did not vote for her. I agree with you about this and so do most of the women I know.

She absolutely embodies the outdated and old school corrupt version of aggressive angry corrupt feminism and was riding on the idea of being a female but outside of that was not a compelling candidate, and was a bad choice for females in the first place.

I would love to see a Female President in my lifetime, but a qualified one who sets a good example for women not validating an outdated extremist feminist gone awry version.

However, that is unrelated in my opinion about the degrading and vulgar comments Trump has made about his female employees, and Hillary is unrelated to the men that have personally spoken to me that way, who are only going to feel further validated by this election.

I absolutely agree with you about this, and I think this happening to Hillary is a good thing, because it is an impetus for women to actually change and not just cry "I'm a woman".

I don't get respect from the men I work with because I am a woman and play the gender card, I get respect from the men I work with because my work is up to par and I DONT play that card.

With that being said, every guy I work with for the past few days has gone out of their way to make it clear to me they do not support men who talk to women the way Trump has spoken of woman, because they view me as a real person who is capable of being hurt by comments like this, not a freebie that comes in a party launch goodie bag, and NONE of them want to be associated with it.

But yes, I agree with you regarding Hillary's campaign.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:20AM (#12921080)
In that case you sound like my kind of feminist!
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by saiya-jin on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:44AM (#12910979)
there's not much to disagree on, you are completely right and I am sorry if you encountered any of this low idiotic approach before. I presume we come from very different places (me from eastern Europe, currently in Switzerland).

I've never ever seen any negative bias or behavior discussed towards women neither in engineering school, nor in any of the numerous job in my 12 year career. In uni, out of 120 students graduating in IT, there was exactly 1 woman. She was in the center of attention, the teachers were more tolerant to her during exams (not giving free passes though!) and overall she was cherished and very welcomed.

While working, women were/are a bit more common now, and again there is more positive bias towards them rather than equality. Not complaining, far from it, it's refreshing to see slightly different attitude at some times, and more often than not, there is no difference.

To me it seems the whole time tech jobs are just not that interesting to women, too abstract, work too nerdy and who knows what. This seems to be changing, hopefully the trend will continue. Nothing to lose, just gain for all of us.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by usmeteora on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:09AM (#12920452)
There is a female Romanian Engineer who works in my department, a bit older and she said she never encountered sexism even being an issue until she came to America ten years into her Engineering career, and that in Europe being a female engineer was no big deal, welcomed like you said but not biased one way or the other, and she has pointed out that America has a weird issue with sexism shes never experienced working anywhere in Europe, so I find it interesting you echo the same observations.

With that being said, I'd love to work in Europe, maybe I should check that out aha.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by cronjobber on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:58AM (#12908185)
> This is definitely the preference falsification election.

I agree. In fact, the point at which I started to think that Trump could win was Hillary's "Basket of Deplorables" blunder. It was a blunder because the way she phrased it, she put far too many in that basket.

Paradoxically, because people believed what she said —that there are many Deplorables— she might have initiated the very preference cascade that cost her the election.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ScottBurson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:31AM (#12908537)
It was a terrible blunder, that might have cost her the election, and not because of the number of people she put in the basket.

It was a blunder because she called people deplorable. Had she talked about deplorable attitudes, she would have been on firm ground. I hope it doesn't sound like a fine distinction, because it isn't.

I voted for her; I am terrified of Trump -- rightly or wrongly, we'll now find out; but I knew this was a bad, bad mistake when she made it, right up there with Mitt Romney's infamous "47%" comment.

And yes, in my opinion, Trump made a lot more serious mistakes. But I am not totally surprised that a majority of Americans don't seem to agree with me.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:18PM (#12912991)
I don't think the election was about mistakes. It was about loathing for both candidates. Turns out the loathing for Hillary was higher.

I should qualify that. Trump, for all his negatives, had people who genuinely agreed with him. He also had a bunch of "not really for Trump, but I am sick to death of Hillary and her scandals and her Machiavellian machinations" voters. Hillary had a bunch of "good heavens, not Trump" voters, some "female in office, therefore has to be good voters", and not all that many "really love her positions" voters.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by emless on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:57AM (#12909873)
With the risk of sounding "smug", I think most of this thread offers a poor analysis of the election.

The reason Trump won is, presumably, to a large extent that he managed to make his message more relevant. If this election would have been about schools, even in the same context, he most likely wouldn't have won and the deplorables comment wouldn't have mattered or even happened in the first place.

We've seen this in Europe repeatedly with new candidates offering easy solutions and a straight forward message, leaving the established parties on their heels trying to defend themselves. In Europe this normally results in 5-15% of the seats in parliament, while in the US (once you're in the running) this can win you the election because of the political system.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by goostavos on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:16AM (#12911349)
It doesn't sound smug, it just sounds massively over simplified and assumed.

The reasons for Trump's win probably varies wildly from region to region and person to person. Anecdotally, I know several who voted only because he was _not_ Hilary, not due to any message resonance. Hell, I mean, personally, despite being politically closest to Hilary on paper, I had no intention of voting for her, and none of those reasons had anything to do with Trump.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by emless on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:44AM (#12911762)
A large part of Trumps message was that Hillary was unsuitable as president. If Trump hadn't manage to get that message through and elevated that issue in favor of other issues much fewer people would have voted for him.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by humanrebar on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:26AM (#12909321)
Or, you know, she could have apologized for some of the things people were upset about with respect to the interminable lying and weasel wording.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by esja on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:25AM (#12910473)
Agreed. And compounding the problem: she also put Trump in that basket.

"Well, she said I was deplorable, but couldn't be more wrong, because I'm a good person... she must be wrong about him too"

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rbehrends on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:07AM (#12909571)
> When pollsters call the preference falsification continues.

I don't buy this. Sam Wang had projected Clinton winning the popular vote by 4.0% (+/- .6%). She's currently projected to win the popular vote by about 1% (the Electoral College margin is an artifact of the electoral system and unrelated to voting preferences). That means that maybe 1 in 60 Americans voted differently from what the polls predicted. So, while the margin of error relative to the margin of victory [1] was pretty big, the margin of error relative to the electorate was fairly small. It doesn't seem that a whole lot of people were hiding their actual preferences prior to the election.

[1] "Victory" only in the narrow mathematical sense of winning the national popular vote, obviously.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by gcp on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:25AM (#12909673)
the margin of error relative to the electorate was fairly small

But was it fairly small in statistical significance? A polling error of 3% is likely big enough to confirm a consistent and very significant bias.

It's like throwing a coin and getting 52000 heads and 48000 tails. "Only" a 4% error, but sure as hell evidence your coin is biased.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by nostrademons on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:43AM (#12910973)
Typical political polls have a margin of error of between 3-5%. You'd expect to see to see a 3% miss roughly 5% of the time.

What's perplexing to me is that the 3% error occurred in a polling average of dozens, perhaps hundreds of polls. If it were just one poll, a 3% miss is quite within the realm of possibility. But in this case it was a range of polls that centered on Clinton +4% and itself had a roughly Gaussian distribution between Trump +2% and Clinton +10%. This makes me wonder if the polling samples were themselves not independent, or some other form of systematic bias amongst mainstream pollsters.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by krakensden on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:59PM (#12916666)
I suspect it's about demographic turnout weighting. Lots of polls were using 2012 as the template.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rbehrends on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:46AM (#12909799)
Obviously, it's a bit of a black eye for the pollsters. But it does not reveal that a huge number of voters hid their preferences, which is what the original comment was about; if anything, it indicates the opposite.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Sacho on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:44AM (#12910978)
Sam Wang called a Trump win practically impossible:

https://twitter.com/samwangphd/status/788544053059153924

http://edition.cnn.com/videos/tv/2016/11/05/poll-expert-i-wi...

http://election.princeton.edu/2016/10/10/some-secrets-are-no...

Specifically the last link exhibits the smugness this article is talking about. Here's a quote from it:

> This seems like a good time to reveal one of the Princeton Election Consortium’s own secrets. Thankfully, it does not involve an Access Hollywood video. Here it is: poll-based Presidential prediction is not very hard. I guess that is a pretty boring secret. Sorry.

Sam Wang was predicting a 95% chance of winning for Hillary. I guess we're in the 5%. I'd further like to point out that Hillary is right now winning the popular vote by 0.1%, and the NYTimes has adjusted their prediction down to 0.5% when all the votes are tallied.

Obama's win over Romney was slightly less than 4.0%, and he won 332-206 in the electoral college. Here's how Sam Wang describes it:

> President Obama’s re-election in 2012 carried even less suspense: he never lost the lead to Romney. The closest he came was right after the first debate, though even then he was slightly ahead.

The pressure to express a Trump sentiment is not high in a non-swing state; If you are in an entrenched blue state, people do not care about you(guaranteed democrat win anyway). If you are in an entrenched red state, then you have plenty of support around you. The voters in swing states are a much smaller percentage of the total, and preference falsification would have affected those states the most.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rbehrends on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:12AM (#12911287)
As you may have noticed, I pointed out myself that the polls were wrong. My point wasn't that they were right, but that the amount by which they were off contradicted claims that more than a small minority of voters were hiding their preferences from pollsters.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Sacho on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:25AM (#12911463)
I dedicated most of my post trying to describe how much Sam Wang was assured despite "just" a 4% margin, how big it actually is. That may have clouded my real point.

In my last paragraph, I tried to put forth a theory that leaves the preference interpretation valid. What do you think about it?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by gadders on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:48AM (#12909101)
A similar thing happened with Brexit, and the last UK General Election. Right-leaning voters just can't be bothered to identify themselves and get involved in debates about it. They just vote.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by tnmrnis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:30AM (#12909710)
The similar thing is happening all over europe right know. Right-leaning voters don't want to identify themselves because the negative social implications can be quite significant.

Also the west seem to have lost its debate culture. These days most debates of conservatives and progressives in shouting 'commie' and 'racist' at each other. In a good debate you wanna help your opponent to give the best possible argument for his position and then try to disprove it. Everything else is lazy and not beneficial for anyone.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by czottmann on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:37AM (#12910106)
> Also the west seem to have lost its debate culture.

That, more than anything.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by taserian on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:53AM (#12910659)
Debate competitions have devolved into some sort of speed-talking, where the number of arguments that the opponent needs to address is more important than the substance of the points themselves.

There's a RadioLab episode about that at http://www.radiolab.org/story/debatable/ An example they use is that if a debater A has six points in his speech that need to be addressed, and the opponent B only addresses four, A wins by default, since there were two points that were unaddressed.

It reminds me a lot about this election, where there's so much polluting the discourse that there's no time to address the substance (and it plays better to the audience, as Moonves stated).

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:03AM (#12918834)
A key problem is that the internet, which should be the best debating forum ever created, is actually a waste of time because of downvotes.

I hate downvote buttons. Programmers seem to put them there only because we demand symmetry. If there's a plus there must also be a minus. I rarely, if ever, see negative votes used to suppress actual spam or obvious trolling ... the only place I've ever seen that actually happen is on Slashdot where the system actually does suppress auto-generated garbage, page-widening posts, etc. Everywhere else people use +/- buttons to indicate disagreement.

Unfortunately, the further left you go, the more you become convinced that people who disagree with you are dumb and easily manipulated. Thus suppressing opinions you disagree with becomes more and more acceptable. Thus downvoting any right-wing thinking into invisibility becomes not just acceptable but important. This trend of course culminates in far-left communist countries where political censorship is an official state policy.

So people with those opinions then rapidly learn that they aren't welcome, that people aren't interested in real debate ... and leave. Forums that could have been debating centers for mutual understanding turn into echo chambers.

The solution is to eliminate downvoting and do what Slashdot does: require you to pick a reason when upvoting, use randomly chosen moderators, and meta-moderate the moderators.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by greedo on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:00AM (#12911158)
At least in the US, it's been gone since the Nixon era. I was too young to vote in Carter v. Reagan, but the hyperbole around his candidacy was amazing. I remember my parents being freaked out when McGovern lost in 1972; it was the end of the world...
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:38AM (#12909391)
The thing about the UK situation that most worries me is the smug left trying to grasp at any way they can to overturn the referendum result or undermine subsequent action. There seems to be the idea that of we just keep ignoring and denigrating hard enough then the morons will be safely put back in their box and we can go on as before.

It never occurs to them that that would just make everything even worse in the long run, that now is the time to understand and compromise. They still seek absolute victory.

The article could just as well have been written about the UK.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:09AM (#12910339)
The thing is that the only alternative to putting the morons back in their box appears to be letting the morons run the country. Sometimes public opinion really is just wrong, and there is no easy way forward when that happens.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:07AM (#12910749)
I think that attitude sums up the problem nicely.

Anyone that disagrees with my take on this issue is a moron.

I disagree fundamentally - if you stop regarding the 'other side' as 'other', as stupid, as meritless, and start to consider their opinions when making policy, well we might make progress.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:52AM (#12911053)
>Anyone that disagrees with my take on this issue is a moron.

It's wrong to think that everyone who disagrees with you on anything is a moron. It's also wrong to deny the existence of morons who occasionally do moronic things.

I mean, we are talking about a group of people who held a referendum, knowing that the vote would be close, and then didn't even have a plan for what to do afterwards. The country is in chaos and the leaders of the Brexit brigade have all sodded off, having absolutely no idea what to do next.

We did consider the opinions of Brexit supporters. Their concerns were taken seriously. The Conservative government went overboard in its attempts to reduce migration and negotiate a more favorable deal with Europe. They really couldn't have done any more without doing something outright ridiculous. But that wasn't enough. So the public insisted that they do something ridiculous.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:03AM (#12911201)
A last minute, failed attempt to do something a few months before a referendum that they comfortably and smugly assumed they would win easily. No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory.

All this after AFAICT two decades of ignoring or belittling people for their deeply held views.

That doesn't really cut it and so we get the result we got.

Personally I neither think the country is in chaos nor do I believe that a vote for Brexit is a mark of idiocy. And even if I did I would try to recognise that I share a country with such folk and have a duty to take their views into account. The catastophising and continued moralistic judgements are another symptom of this poisonous thought pattern.

Brexit was the breakpoint, but the preceding decades of smug politics are what got us there.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:13AM (#12911292)
>No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory.

No plan was made by long-term Brexit supporters either. Where is Nigel Farage's plan? What useful suggestions has Boris Johnson made?

>And even if I did I would try to recognise that I share a country with such folk and have a duty to take their views into account.

We did take their views into account, as I said. The Conservative government bent over backwards to accommodate them.

The strategy you're proposing (engagement) was tried and has failed. It only had the effect of making Brexit seem more reasonable than it really was. Now we are in a position where the electorate have done something insane, and yet are in a position to demand that we take their insane views seriously.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:34AM (#12911607)
Once again - please don't think I'm defending the outcomes.

The attitude that anyone disagreeing with you is insane is the problem. The fact you call leaving a political union 'insane' is part of the problem.

And if the views on restricting migration hadn't been dismissed as insane for years, we might not be here.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:39AM (#12911694)
But what if a large number of people actually have done something insane? You seem to refuse to accept this as a possibility.

To my mind, the view that migration should be severely restricted never was dismissed. The present Conservative government agreed, and imposed all kinds of overly draconian restrictions. (I ended up paying several thousand pounds to get my Canadian husband a visa to live here.)

Now the idea that immigration should be even further restricted is mainstream, even though it is mad.

I'm interested in any plans that Farage might have made because it would be evidence that someone on the Leave side of the issue perhaps has a clue.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:03PM (#12912011)
Yet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective.

I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"?

Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:19PM (#12912237)
>Yet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective.

Which, consulting Wikipedia’s list of countries by net migration, puts us below (amongst many others) Norway, Spain, Australia, Canada, Sweden, Switzerland, Italy, Ireland and Portugal. So it’s not exactly an unreasonably large number of immigrants we’re talking about here. (Especially when you consider that our net migration figures are bogus, since international students are wrongly included in them. Around 135,000 non-EU students entered the UK in 2014, for example.)

>I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"?

We have an aging population and an economy that was just coming out of a recession. It’s not difficult to see why we need more immigrants. They’re young and net contributors to the economy. The idea that we could make things any better by shutting everyone out is, simply, mad. Perhaps in the short term some unemployed British people could switch from being unemployed to doing very badly paid, very menial jobs that are currently being done by Polish people. The net cost to the economy would most likely be far greater than the cost of simply increasing their benefits, though.

>Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back.

I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:45PM (#12912569)
The British people considered it unreasonably large, for whatever reasons. They considered it important enough that after years of being ignored millions voted for UKIP or the Tories.

Again I'm not here to argue merits. What you have there is more justifications for ignoring the views of large sections of the electorate.

The rest of your argument is purely economic, as if that is or should be everything to everyone. And some of those points are arguable. I don't think that warrants calling people who disagree "mad".

>> I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean.

Oh just that I've been trying to make the point that politicians have been at this for decades and you bring up the conservatives as having tried to engage.

I don't think they really did, and by the time they did it was too late. Engagement should have been there from Blair onward.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:47AM (#12919601)
>The British people considered it unreasonably large, for whatever reasons.

For no good reason. That's why I said that it's mad.

The economic argument is the only respectable argument against immigration, which is why I focused on it. The only other arguments against immigration that people put forward are racist and/or xenophobic.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:51AM (#12919622)
More of the smug I'm afraid.

You don't think it's important so it's mad.

You don't agree with other arguments so they're racist.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:26AM (#12919806)
Ok, so what is an argument against current levels of immigration to the UK that is neither racist, xenophobic, nor based primarily on economic considerations?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:33AM (#12919845)
Most EU immigration is to London and the South East, somewhere that already feels like it's creaking at the seems and overcrowded.

We could start a massive programme of building houses and infrastructure, but that would further change the face of the country. Limiting immigration would alleviate some of the pressure.

That's just one off the top of my head.

Remember, the point made in this article is not that you have to agree. The point is that calling people mad and shouting them down as racist is toxic to politics and drives people away.

--edit--

I also find it strange when people bring up racism in the context of limiting migration from the EU - a region primarily peopled by white Europeans.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:27AM (#12920130)
>Most EU immigration is to London and the South East, somewhere that already feels like it's creaking at the seems and overcrowded.

> Limiting immigration would alleviate some of the pressure.

First of all, housing is an economic issue.

Second, London voted overwhelmingly for remain. I live in London. No-one here seriously thinks that London’s housing crisis can be solved by stopping immigration. Nor did the country vote Leave because people in the North were particularly interested in solving London’s housing crisis.

Third, London out of all areas of the UK would be harmed the most by greater restrictions on immigration, and the vast majority of the people who live here know that.

>I also find it strange when people bring up racism in the context of limiting migration from the EU - a region primarily peopled by white Europeans.

Actually I was careful to say “racist and/or xenophobic” in anticipation of this kind of pedantry, but I guess I needn’t have bothered. The current climate is such that even Polish people aren’t considered sufficiently Anglo-Saxon to be entitled to live here!

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:59AM (#12920374)
That doesn't tell you that motivations are something other than race, then?

None are so blind as those who will not see.

I wasn't only talking about housing provision, I was talking about housing in terms of changing the face of the country and increasing urbanisation.

I said London and the South East, not just London, and there were Brexit voters in London, approximately 3.5 million of them.

But at least we're engaging now, rather than using terms like "mad"

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:03AM (#12920896)
> I was talking about housing in terms of changing the face of the country and increasing urbanisation.

"Changing the face of the country" just means "there are too many brown people and foreigners here".

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:18AM (#12921039)
I meant it as "building on the greenbelt" and more people living in apartments rather than houses.

But if you're determined to see racism everywhere I guess that's up to you.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:46AM (#12921945)
I asked for an argument against current levels of immigration that was neither based primarily on economic considerations nor racist/xenophobic. I really don't think there is any such argument. Unless you're really saying that people are opposed to immigration because they're worried about houses being built on the greenbelt.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:19PM (#12922223)
Overcrowding of the country is a valid concern, for more than purely economic reasons, the south east is one of the nost densely populated parts of Europe already.

As I say, if you want to see racism everywhere, and if you presume that the economic arguments are all won then fine, you just carry on shouting everyone down as mad and racist, and watch as your political viewpoints fail to gain traction over and over again.

Again, I'm not really here to argue the merits of Brexit or Trump, I voted for neither. But I am taking great delight in the frustration of those who hector, judge and shut down all discussion, shouting loudly about virtue while in fact practising all the bigotry they claim to despise.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:45PM (#12924165)
Ah yes, "overcrowded". Like the posh restaurant that’s “fully booked”, or the country club that’s “not accepting any new members at the moment”.

If people were really worried about overcrowding, they’d be advocating for a one child per couple policy, not trying to reduce already rather moderate migration figures.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:41AM (#12928992)
Now that is some fucked up thinking. Deeply fucked up.

Firstly, natural population growth in the UK is at around 150k per year, under half the net migration figure. Secondly, are you kidding me? People should favour continuing migration pver having their own children?

WOW. Are you even human?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:49AM (#12929564)
The 300k net migration figure is bogus, as I already explained. The effect of natural population growth and immigration on the size of the population is roughly equal (http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings...), and natural population growth could be cut much more than immigration. You're illustrating perfectly that people don't really care about "overcrowding" at all. If they did, they wouldn't find the idea of limiting natural population growth outrageous. My reference to a one child policy was hyperbolic, but more funding for family planning would probably do the job.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:37AM (#12929755)
Family planning, to allow people to choose, is a far, far different proposition from the one you put forward.

In order to limit population growth you think people should stop having kids in order to be better able to play host to newcomers.

It's a position almost beyond parody and so far out of touch with human wants and needs. I repeat - are you human?

Your figures are interesting but not conclusive, over half of population growth between 1991 and 2014 was due to migration. The latter years of that period saw far higher rates than the early and middle years, and it continues to be over 300k pa, according to the ONS.

Regardless, I'll say again, you're not talking to a die hard brexiter or Trump supporter. I voted to stay in the EU, for a start.

You're talking to someone who thinks that the bigotry of calling anyone that disagrees with you a racist is political poison, and that it will continue to set back progressive politics.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:01PM (#12933811)
>In order to limit population growth you think people should stop having kids in order to be better able to play host to newcomers.

I don't want to limit population growth in the first place. You're the one who was suggesting that it's a problem.

But someone who really did want to limit population growth would obviously be interested in policies that would reduce the number of births. So, at minimum, they'd support lots of extra funding for teen sex education and family planning, since a significant number of births are unplanned. But of course we don't hear a peep about that -- only about immigration.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by aninhumer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:46AM (#12911784)
>The strategy you're proposing (engagement) was tried and has failed.

What was tried wasn't engagement, it was an attempt to suppress the issue by holding what they expected to be a doomed referendum, so they could use the result as an excuse to ignore the issue.

True engagement would mean acknowledging people's concerns, and explaining their true causes and how you're going to address them.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:29AM (#12919234)
How are you going to address the concerns of people who are opposed to all immigration from non-white and/or non-English-speaking countries? The Conservatives had already restricted immigration to a greater degree than is sensible.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:07AM (#12918849)
They did actually make suggestions, despite not campaigning to form a government. For example, an Australian style immigration system, striking a trade deal with the EU, continued cooperation in defense issues and so on. You just ignored them.

Unfortunately it's rather hard to make plans about leaving the EU because the EU itself is in a catatonic state of denial. Their glorious leader banned even writing things down about the possibility of exit before the referendum, and afterwards announced they would still refuse to discuss it until Article 50 is invoked.

This total denial of reality and absolute refusal to discuss it, is then used by people like Martin Schulz and yourself to claim Leave had no plan!

Yes, Leave has a plan! It's called "get the hell out of this madhouse as quickly as possible". That's it!

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:24AM (#12919211)
You can blame it all on the EU if you like. We're still fucked. There's no way the EU will give us a good deal, and it turns out that no-one had any kind of realistic negotiating strategy. (Remember all that delusional nonsense from the Leavers about how Germany would have to give us a good deal because the country is run by its car industry? Oops...)
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:14AM (#12919442)
No?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the US is now run by a guy who thinks the EU sucks, that Brexit was great, and whose best buddy in Europe is Nigel Farage.

And is it not the case that the most popular politicians in other core countries are all anti-EU?

Let's see how this plays out.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:46AM (#12919593)
Ah I see, so their plan was for Trump to win the presidency and for the entire EU to collapse before we make a deal. Sure, let's see how that plays out. Third time lucky?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:19AM (#12921057)
"Let's get out before the EU implodes" was actually a campaigning point, though not one that affected my own decision much. I would be surprised if the EU collapses. But then again, almost everyone was taken by surprise when the USSR disintegrated, and the conventional wisdom was that neither Brexit nor Trump could happen. So we'll see. Suffice it to say that there are structural weaknesses there.

Regardless, sometimes you have to leave a social group if that group is becoming self-destructive, even if it hurts in the short run.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:25AM (#12921762)
Right, so we are going to have to negotiate while the EU is still in tact. What's the plan for how we do that? What reason does the EU have to give us a good deal?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:18PM (#12922217)
Well, I'd say "because it'd be what's best for people in EU countries" but I don't honestly believe the EU cares about that, beyond perhaps avoiding mass expulsions on both sides. So far they seem more interested in securing payments into their pensions.

So my view is that they have no incentive to give the UK a good deal. This does not imply the UK should have remained. They have no incentive because they aren't accountable to the people, except via very indirect and essentially broken ways, and besides lots of Europeans buy the argument that they must suffer to preserve the union.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:34PM (#12922919)
>So my view is that they have no incentive to give the UK a good deal.

Right.

>This does not imply the UK should have remained

It probably implies that we shouldn't have thrown a temper tantrum without having a strategy.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:21PM (#12923347)
What would your strategy be for leaving?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:44PM (#12924151)
I would not leave. I don't think there is a good strategy, which is why we should not have done it.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by Nursie on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:30AM (#12911553)
Why is any plan Farage might have come up with of the slightest interest? Are you suffering from the misapprehension that the referendum was an election for the leave campaign?

Boris? Who knows.

I'm not really defending Brexit here. My argument is that something along these lines was inevitable due to decades of ignoring people.

The conservative government wanted to put a lid back on this and make it go away, their strategy was to show it up for what they assumed was the obviously stupid, minority viewpoint it was. They failed, but they were just the latest in a line of governments suffering from the smugness identified in the article.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by aninhumer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:14AM (#12911322)
>So the public insisted that they do something ridiculous.

The public aren't the ones who decided to have a referendum, the government are. If you're arguing that it was moronic to hold a referendum with no clear plan for one of the possible outcomes, I totally agree, but that's not the public's fault.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:18AM (#12911368)
I mean that the public insisted that we leave the EU by voting to leave the EU. Just because someone asks a silly question doesn't mean that you have to give a silly answer.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by aninhumer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#12911471)
People voted in the way that best expressed their beliefs given the choice as presented. If they'd voted remain, the government wouldn't have said "Oh I guess that was a poorly defined referendum, let's work out a proper plan and have another." they'd have used it as an excuse to ignore the issue.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:43AM (#12911747)
>People voted in the way that best expressed their beliefs given the choice as presented.

That is true of any election, no?

>If they'd voted remain, the government wouldn't have said "Oh I guess that was a poorly defined referendum, let's work out a proper plan and have another." they'd have used it as an excuse to ignore the issue.

Quite possibly, but I don't see how that is relevant. We seem to be in agreement?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by aninhumer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:01PM (#12911976)
Hmm, I thought the "silly question" was the referendum, but maybe you meant that's the silly answer?

I thought you were blaming the public, but if you're primarily blaming the politicians then I agree.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:20PM (#12912258)
Sorry, I'm not sure what you're getting at. I think that it was silly of David Cameron to hold a referendum, and I think it was silly of the British electorate to vote to leave.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by s_kilk on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:57AM (#12909874)
The "Shy Tory" problem. I'm continually amazed at how pundits brush it aside.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pmyteh on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:04AM (#12910295)
It's really not clear it actually exists. Both the 2015 general election and Brexit misses were primarily due to turnout modeling problems: people accurately reported which candidate they preferred, but different groups turned out in different numbers than had happened historically, so the (educated) guess about who would actually vote turned out to be wrong.

The British Polling Council postmortem is a very interesting read. They considered 'shy Tory' but once again ended up ruling it out.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:05AM (#12920425)
>It's really not clear it actually exists.

It's pretty clear if you're a Trump supporter.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pmyteh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:03AM (#12921526)
I get that social desirability bias is a thing, and that those with views considered socially unpopular are less willing to share them. But for a hypothetical Shy Tory effect to have an effect on polling you'd need something like all of the following:

* Tories to be unwilling to admit to voting Tory (plausible);

* Tories to claim to be voting for someone else, instead of refusing to answer, as if they refuse to answer then the demographic weighting will increase the impact of similar respondents who will tend to also be Tories (somewhat less plausible);

* The source of errors from the above to outweigh other known problems such as turnout modelling, non-response bias, demographic variations in telephone/Internet access, late changing of minds, anti-Tories in Tory areas doing the same things for the same social desirability reasons (I suspect it wasn't any more fun being a Hillary supporter in Trumpland than a Trump fan in Hillaryland this cycle), and so on.

Polling is not easy. Its statistical guarantees are only valid under circumstances that basically don't hold, and there is a great deal of variation due to design decisions which cannot be empirically grounded. You don't need a "shy Tory" effect to produce the misses seen recently, and the evidence doesn't support it happening on a scale big enough to have any impact at all.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:58PM (#12923701)
So what are you suggesting for why the all polls were wrong? What do you think contributed to the inaccuracy of the polls?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pmyteh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:33PM (#12924612)
I already gave an answer earlier in the thread that is true for the two similar polling misses in the UK and my best guess for what happened in the US: differential turnout. Trump supporters voted with higher probability than they had historically (or Clinton supporters voted with lower probability, which seems more plausible looking at the turnout figures). So even if people's preferences for president were completely honest and recorded correctly, the projected "likely voter" poll results were wrong.

This is known to have happened in Britain, because there was a very thorough postmortem by the pollsters' professional body after the 2015 miss.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:10AM (#12910768)
> Apparently in the privacy of a voting booth, people are willing to express their true beliefs.

It appears that Trump won because of working-class people in the Rust Belt, who repeatedly got the short end of the stick by the neoliberal policy of both parties. Democrats should have had their backs, but they'd abandoned them, instead, serving the "professional meritocracy". He did not win because of spoiled, well-off contrarians on the coasts. I'd like to believe that this election was decided by people who have really suffered the devastating consequences of being economically marginalized (also, relatively old), not by tech dudes who were offended they'd been called sexist on Twitter.

Presenting this election as a contest between anti-PC gamergaters and safe-space college girls is not only wrong, but suffers from the same blindness of the elites that Clinton suffers from. If it were the true story, then it would be far too depressing to think that the elites are so obsessed with themselves that they are unable to take anything seriously. Fortunately, this is not what happened because Trump's voters are too old to belong to either group. But if it were the true story, then Trump is exactly what both groups deserve.

> I love the great big "fuck you" to the biased media

You know something? Me too. This is the same media that shot down Sanders. But I feel sorry for those contrarians who voted for him just for this "fuck you". He's going to be their president, too. But I'm not sorry for them for that; fortunately for them, they're probably well-cushioned enough to not suffer any direct consequences that are too severe. I'm sorry for them because their empathy is so lacking that they don't mind the real harm done to real people by their lol-spite decision (even though that's probably not what directly handed Trump the victory). The ray of hope I see in this outcome is that maybe the American "liberals" Clinton represented would realize how much their empathy towards the victims of neoliberal capitalism was lacking, too.

> sneering at him, calling him racist

That's because he is racist and/or certainly doesn't mind the association, although I don't see what this has to do with anything. Xenophobia was his overt battle-cry, no dog-whistles needed, and he enjoyed endorsements by people who would have been offended not to be called racist. It is clear that Trump believed that being labelled a racist would only help his chances. He certainly enjoyed and invited the sneers. If there is one thing Trump has shown himself to be good at, it is manipulating the media to a sort of symbiotic relationship. But if anything, he is a product of the media, not its victim.

> called racist

Wait, what? I thought you liked to present yourself as a male- and white-supremacist of the long, proud scientific racism tradition. You have repeatedly expressed a belief that men and whites are innately superior to women and people of other races in many qualities that you value (oh, sorry, you believe Asians and Ashkenazi Jewish men are naturally superior to whites). I always figured that you enjoyed bathing in the air of "unorthodoxy" and contrarianism by pretending to hold those views. You can't both identify as racist to appear unorthodox and at the same time present yourself as a victim of your own show. Pick one.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:29AM (#12911513)
> who repeatedly got the short end of the stick by the neoliberal policy of both parties.

I agree with this assessment of voter outrage due to economic issues in the rust belt and elsewhere, but now what? Walmart isn't buying smartphones made domestically that cost 8x what the ones in China cost because Walmart can't sell them. I can see the complaint, but its a bit like voting against hurricanes and tornadoes. They're bad and we don't like them, but we can't legislate them away.

I think Trump's playing up global trade as a conspiracy against "good hardworking people" is fairly disingenuous. Instead of accepting a long changed global economy and re-training these people into the service level sector, they seem to think a little protectionism will suddenly bring back the booming factory work of the 1960s and 70s. Trump has badly misled these people for his own gain. Worse, Trump's own companies are managed in a way against the interests of these people (anti-union tactics, buying Chinese steel, lack of investment in poor rural communities, etc). Trump just follows the laws of economics everyone else does. How does he propose something that even he and his companies would never do?

Re-training and investment in the service sector is exactly what Xi Jinping in China is attempting because he knows other Asian nations will continue to successfully poach his manufacturing due to their lowered cost of labor. Meanwhile in the more advanced economy here in the US, we're somehow going to try to compete with factory work in places like Vietnam which has a monthly wage of $145? What did these people vote for other than another empty suit who had made promises he simply cannot deliver?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:37AM (#12911662)
That Trump has misled them is obvious, but not because of any policy he may have suggested, but because he is too preoccupied with tweets, self-portraits, marking stuff with his name, gilded chairs and boobs to effectively enact any policy; it is reported that he is unable to read even short texts or engage in a conversation that isn't about him for more than ten minutes, for god's sake (although I am not yet sure if I'll be horrified or pleasantly surprised if he proves me wrong). But as to global trade, I don't understand your point. What, is there one god-given, "natural" policy and no other? I'd like to believe that societies can shape the economy -- if not fully, then at least in part -- to serve their chosen goals, rather than just serve it.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:47AM (#12911795)
Americans can certainly reshape their society to bring back factory work, but there are practical concerns here. Who are your buyers, what are you making, who are your competitors, etc. Its not all fantasy make-believe on the economic level. There are real economic laws that you can't break via legislation.

You guys want to compete with the Vietnamese? Fine, but be prepared to have the lifestyle $150 a month in wages brings. I suspect Trump voters aren't going to find that acceptable.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:51PM (#12912646)
> Americans can certainly reshape their society to bring back factory work, but there are practical concerns here.

That's not the policy I was suggesting, but pretending that current neoliberal policies (that aren't shared by all successful countries) are the only option is both false, and the main reason that gave us Trump in the first place.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:13PM (#12912160)
It appears that Trump won because of...

You missed the point I was making - I was speculating why electoral predictions were wrong, not speculating why Trump won.

I rather hope liberals don't develop empathy for the wealthy Americans who handed the election to Trump. Empathy is truly a destructive force in the world. We feel far more empathy for those close to us, those who look like us, those who are blessed with attractiveness. If we follow our empathy Indians and Chinese will remain poor just to help wealthy white Americans maintain their social status.

Wait, what? I thought you liked to present yourself as a male- and white-supremacist of the long, proud scientific racism tradition.

No, your (and those of other likeminded folks) attacks on me are not representative of how I present myself. They simply represent what you believe to be the easiest attack mode.

I have also expressed a belief that black women are innately "better" than others in certain qualities that I value: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8300225

That particular belief has explicitly motivated more action on my part than any of the beliefs you criticize me for. Does that make me a black female supremacist?

Somehow I suspect you will be unwilling to apply your original logic to this case, and in fact you'll apply some weird reverse logic to support the same conclusion.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:50PM (#12912631)
The false speculations -- shared by both liberals and conservative, BTW -- were the result of the same blindness of the elites that has led to the outcome. If you've read those who weren't blind, like Thomas Frank,they saw it coming (although I think even Frank thought that the blind establishment would prevail in this cycle).

I can't tell if you're joking in the rest of your comment or not, but as to qualities you value, the test is simple: are those the qualities that you'd attribute to those you consider your social equals or superiors, or, in other words, are those the qualities you truly believe give people most social power (status and influence) in your own society? One of the distinguishing characteristics of scientific racism, from its modern rise in the late 19th century has always been to attribute "good" qualities to the races considered inferior as an attempt to paint itself not as a hate group but as simply the objective understanding of the natural order: every species has its good and bad qualities, and so does every race; every species has its place, and so does every race. Of course, scientific racism has always attributed to its believers those very qualities that happen to coincide with most power, because it's not about "better" or "worse", but naturally deserving of power or not. In other words, I smiled when I saw your "black female supremacist" comment, because I've read the exact same thing by writers in late 19th century many years ago in school, that I can't tell if you're ironically referencing classic scientific racism tropes or not. In any event, the view you're presenting here is actually called scientific racism. It is not an "attack on you" by any means, just as calling me socialist isn't an attack on me. I believe that if you read some of the vast scientific racism literature, you'll gladly identify yourself as a member (unless realizing how familiar and old your opinions are would make you understand how far they are from true heterodoxy).

BTW, attributing Jews with qualities that actually do coincide with social power is also a trademark feature of antisemitism, scientific or otherwise. It is crucial for (or at least, the habit of) nativist/racist movements to paint themselves as both deserving of power as well as victims, at once weak and powerful. So if you want to follow up with a question of whether or not you're a Jewish supremacist, you can spare it. I've read it all in 100+-year-old books.

I don't know if empathy is primarily destructive or not, but I still pity those who lack it.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:40PM (#12913246)
Yes, when I choose to date a woman (in part because of her beauty), I consider her my social equal. I also believe beauty gains a woman status and influence. Do you disagree with these two claims?

(In fact, I consider beauty to be one of the most underappreciated virtues in the modern world. As a weird tangent, one of the major things I prefer about NYC to Bombay is how NYC weights beauty over wealth.)

I'm beginning to think that what you call "scientific racism" is what I'd simply call "science" applied to humans. Do you believe it differs? If so, how?

I suspect that question will be dodged. I suspect you are using the term "scientific racism" rather than "science" in order to create equivalence between scientists and "hate groups", and imply I feel hatred towards some group. That's definitely an implication I object to.

So if you want to follow up with a question of whether or not you're a Jewish supremacist, you can spare it. I've read it all in 100+-year-old books.

As I suspected, all possible viewpoints I might hold result in you believing I'm a white supremacist.

Have fun with the highbrow dismissal and vague hints that some uncited authority supports your views.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:11PM (#12913521)
> when I choose to date a woman (in part because of her beauty), I consider her my social equal. I also believe beauty gains a woman status and influence. Do you disagree with these two claims?

I have no idea whether you consider the women you date to be your social equal or not -- it is none of my business -- but I don't think it is necessarily the case that every man (or woman) considers their romantic partners their social equal. As to the other claim, I wholeheartedly disagree. There is no question that beauty is a source of power. But you'd need to be blind to think that it is a greater source of power in our society than other qualities. Note, also, how beautiful women are often brought down (just a pretty face etc.), whereas powerful men are not discussed in the same way (nah, he's just an ugly billionaire).

> I'm beginning to think that what you call "scientific racism" is what I'd simply call "science" applied to humans. Do you believe it differs? If so, how?

What "I call" scientific racism is what is known by historians as scientific racism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_racism. The difference (aside from question of whether actual science is involved or not) is the following:

Just to be sure, first of all let me say that I do not believe (based on the evidence at hand) that scientific-racist claims have any merit whatsoever, and based on the history I studied, I am quite certain that even if there were some truth to them, the effect size is negligible compared to social effects. But, for the sake of argument (although it makes me sick to my stomach), let’s suppose that scientific-racism’s claims are absolutely true. There is a crucial distinction to be made between the veracity of a claim and the importance of discussing it.

There’s a parable (by Kierkegaard, I think) about a man who escapes from an insane asylum and, determined not to be sent back, decides to appear sane by only saying true statements. To everyone he meets, he says, "The earth is round. The earth is round," which, naturally, gets him sent back. Or consider Trump’s statement about Carly Fiorina’s looks. I think most people would agree that the important question about the event is not whether Fiorina is actually ugly or not, but why Trump saw the need to make that statement, regardless of its empirical truth. Often, finding the need to say something tells more about the speaker than about the object of the statement. In Trump’s case, it was an expression of how he thinks women should be valued.

Given the treatment of, say, blacks in the US, the question of whether and by how much blacks are innately stupider than whites is completely uninteresting to me. What is interesting to me is why some people think the question of their innate abilities is so important to merit discussion and/or investigation at this point in time. After all, there is much to be done to treat people more fairly and with more dignity even before getting to the question of their innate worth. Once all people are treated with the dignity they deserve, we can try addressing every person's individual abilities. We've invented technological solutions to short-sightedness; maybe we can find technological solutions to stupidity, too.

So to answer your question: scientific racism often has motivations that are completely different from those behind most science.

Expecting your next question, let me say that the reason racism and sexism are studied collectively yet innate abilities should be studied at the individual level -- putting aside the obvious answer of respective effect size and variability -- is this: it has been found as conclusively as anything in social science, that many social forces are best studied collectively, just as gas molecules are; that's just how they work.

> in you believing I'm a white supremacist.

I honestly don't understand this. I don't believe you're a white supremacist; I don't know you personally at all! You just keep claiming to be a white supremacist, maybe not using those exact words, but by repeating textbook scientific racism claims. I could insist not to be a billionaire, only to have a billion dollars in my bank account, and to talk about "your definition of billionaire". Scientific racism has a pretty well accepted definition, and your well publicized views coincide with it well.

> highbrow dismissal and vague hints that some uncited authority supports your views.

What views? That you're repeating classic scientific racism claims? The Wikipedia page has dozens of relevant references.

Also, I don't understand your point about "highbrow dismissal". If I were to tell you "just use logic! Quantum mechanics can't possibly be true!" would your educated response be considered highbrow dismissal?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:40PM (#12917794)
But, for the sake of argument (although it makes me sick to my stomach)...

Given this strong emotional motivation, do you really think you can objectively evaluate the truth of these claims without bias? I certainly don't.

So to answer your question: scientific racism often has motivations that are completely different from those behind most science.

Juxtaposing this with your term "hate group", I assume you mean the motivation is some sort of collectivist hatred or other negative feelings?

In that case, it's pretty clear that you intend this to be a mere ad-hominem attack. You simply refuse to acknowledge the possibility that a person might hold certain positive beliefs without also holding certain normative beliefs. Essentially: "Anyone who believes in evolution must therefore worship the devil. The church opposes both of these things!"

Have fun with that. If you ever want to understand the world better, consider the possibility that atheists are not necessarily satanists.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:40AM (#12918035)
> do you really think you can objectively evaluate the truth of these claims without bias?

Yes, more or less, just as many kinds of professionals are required to do the same. But regardless, my entire point is that the truth of these claims is the least important thing about them, just as the interesting question about a wager between two college students of whether a vagrant would shit his pants or not when they set him on fire is not which of them was right.

> I assume you mean the motivation is some sort of collectivist hatred or other negative feeling

I did not study psychology but history, and I'm not interested in feelings but in the distribution of power. Yes, the motivation is to justify and perpetuate a distribution of power that's favorable to the groups where those ideas are found.

> In that case, it's pretty clear that you intend this to be a mere ad-hominem attack. You simply refuse to acknowledge the possibility that a person might hold certain positive beliefs without also holding certain normative beliefs.

Not at all. When discussing the history of ideas we do not attempt to track every single person's motivations, just as I don't suppose you "refuse to acknowledge the possibility" of some black woman being smarter than some Asian man. Your beliefs -- as I hope you know -- are not only not unique at this point in time, they echo almost precisely very old and well studied ones, and thus can be and indeed have been discussed in general without attributing anything to you personally. Even in proper science (leaving aside the question of whether a certain strain of scientific racism qualifies as such or not), researchers often discuss why they're interested in a specific question (and need to justify the importance of their research in order receive grants). So the question of what motivates certain people to be interested in studying and publicly writing about any scientific topic is not only reasonable and pertinent, but a fairly common one. Even on a personal level, a scientist often needs to answer it to herself and to others.

Also, I am absolutely not attacking you, but merely pointing out that the name of the school of thought your beliefs (in this context) belong to is scientific racism. Perhaps now that you know what your philosophy is called, you can more easily find academic discussions about it if you are interested in learning more. But just as I wouldn't be able to fairly say, "people here are call me names like billionaire", after telling them I have billions in the bank regardless of my personal feelings towards the name, I don't think you get to say that people "call you racist" when it is you who present yourself as such (and not in any subtle way, or one that's open to interpretation), even though it turns out that you don't like the title.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:11AM (#12919423)
But regardless, my entire point is that the truth of these claims is the least important thing about them...

That much is clear, and the source of our differences. I do care about reality and I don't mind if bad people have learned true facts.

Yes, the motivation is to justify and perpetuate a distribution of power that's favorable to the groups where those ideas are found.

And the motivation for studying evolution is to reduce people's faith in the one true god, and prevent them from getting to heaven. Therefore I can refer to an individual evolutionist as a satanist.

When discussing the history of ideas we do not attempt to track every single person's motivations

You aren't discussing the history of ideas. You are discussing specifically whether I am a "scientific racist" and "white supremacist". And you've defined these terms as people having specific motivations which I don't share.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:04AM (#12919997)
> That much is clear, and the source of our differences. I do care about reality and I don't mind if bad people have learned true facts.

That cannot possibly be our difference because I also care about reality and I don't mind if bad people have learned true facts. I have no reason to believe that I care about reality any less than you do. There are only two differences between our views : 1. I do not think there is currently any evidence whatsoever that innate differences between human races are a significant causal factor in the observed power difference, and 2. I think that in the whole of science there are few questions that are less interesting. In fact, while I have occasionally found myself pondering scientific questions that can be said to be utterly ridiculous and pointless, the thought of whether blacks are less intelligent than whites has never even crossed my mind. When a question does cross my mind, I always -- always -- ask myself why is it important to me that I should spend time pondering it, let alone writing about it. I think that in all of science, pretty much the only time uninteresting questions (i.e., those not given explicit justification for study by scientists) become interesting is when there is incontrovertible evidence for something totally surprising (even if uninteresting). I don't think that this is the case with scientific racism, either.

I wonder why it is that this question is so important to you, that you'd rather spend your time writing about it, than say, how cats purr or why we yawn.

> You are discussing specifically whether I am a "scientific racist" and "white supremacist". And you've defined these terms as people having specific motivations which I don't share.

I'm afraid I don't think it is possible to believe whites are innately more intelligent than blacks and not be a white supremacist (at least not without some clearly spelled out motivation), or to believe that differences in traits such as intelligence between races are either supported by science or should be studied by science without being a scientific racist, sorry. I sort-of understand your desire to both have a billion dollars and yet not be considered a billionaire, but I'm just not sure how this can be done.

You may claims that scientific racism is an interesting and valid scientific discipline or that your motivations are pure etc., but you cannot argue that you are not a scientific racist if those are your views.

Also, I did not define scientific racism as having specific motivations. I restated the well accepted -- and, AFAIK, the only definition of scientific racism, as the belief that some races are innately superior or inferior to others (usually in qualities that coincide with social power) and that this can and/or should be proven with science. I added, in response to your question, that it has been well established (although that is not the definition) that scientific racism is an all-too-familiar tool being used in the same ways, making the same assertions, time and again by people with similar motivations. Your personal motivations are your own business, but I wonder if you've asked yourself why you are personally so drawn to such questions, especially as most people (even those who care a lot about reality) aren't.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by tnone on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:33AM (#12921844)
Just like a creationist, when you finally stop going around in circles, you end up questioning the motivations of your opponent as a shaming attack, even as you insist they are not your business.

This is what religion looks like.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:48PM (#12924185)
First, I did not question anyone's motivations, simply expressed curiosity, because the scientific questions that interest yummyfajitas are so unusual. It was through him that I first learned of contemporary scientific racism, and I am truly and honestly curious about this. E.g., how far do they go? Do they also think we should investigate whether people of Irish descent are more intelligent than people of German descent? If so, what are their hypotheses? Are they also interested in studying qualities like sense of humor? Love of satirical novels? To my ears, someone saying that we must know the truth about whether or not blacks are dumber than whites sounds no less bizarre than someone who says we must know by how much the angle of a cat's raised tail changes after dreaming of mice, and to anyone who asks why this question is of so much interest, they say, "why are you trying to hide the truth?" I think most scientist find a person's (let alone a group's) fascination with such questions of far greater scientific interest and importance than the actual answer to the questions.

Second, I don't know how much you're involved with the scientific community, but every researcher is required to explain their motivation for studying just about anything (at least in the first half of their careers, and even when they're not required, it is something that they're expected to be able to answer when interviewed, for example). That's just how science works. Third, I don't recall making any kind of attack in this thread.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:35PM (#12926242)
If your curiosity is genuine I can tell you the answer.

First, a casual perusal of any human biodiversity blog will tell you that they do in fact care about differences between Germans and Irish as well. Or Tamils and Gujuratis, or a variety of other groups that exhibit interesting differences.

Intelligence is particularly interesting relative to other traits since it explains so many social outcomes, but many other traits are interesting. For example, clannishness: https://jaymans.wordpress.com/2013/09/07/how-inbred-are-euro... Some people just find human biology intrinsically interesting, and don't have the same negative emotional reactions to it that you do.

If you want a more traditional "give me a grant" motivation, here it is: public policy. Consider racial disparities across fields. One possible cause of such disparities is disparate treatment - e.g., judging white job applicants more harshly than Asian ones. Another possibility is disparate ability - e.g. a greater proportion of Asian people than white people are smart.

Different causes of disparities would significantly change what policy you would choose. For example, if disparate ability is the cause and equal outcomes is your goal, you would choose a quota system to cap the number of Asians.

and to anyone who shouts them down, calls them racist and attempts to get them socially ostracized, they say, "why are you trying to hide the truth?

Fixed that for you.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pron on Friday November 11, 2016 @03:32AM (#12928952)
> If you want a more traditional "give me a grant" motivation, here it is: public policy.

In that case, I can set your mind at ease. There is a wide scientific consensus -- no less conclusive than the consensus on global warming and based on decades of research -- that social policy itself and other social forces are by far the leading causes for power disparity.

Just to be clear: differences in ability among social groups are real, variance of ability among individuals due to biology is also real, and ability is indeed one factor in power disparity among individuals. What we're debating is the relationship between the three. The debate is whether biological differences are the main explanation for differences in abilities between social groups, and, more importantly, whether biological differences have any significant explanatory power for the vast power disparity between social groups.

Also, it is unclear to me how a positive answer for the biological explanation could possibly affect public policy. Your point that "if ... equal outcomes is your goal, you would choose a quota system to cap the number of Asians" is a non-sequitur. For one, "equal income" in the public policy sense doesn't remotely resemble what you imply you think it does in your suggestion. For another, I don't see why your suggestion would be different if the difference in ability was environmental rather than biological.

> don't have the same negative emotional reactions to it that you do

My emotional reaction stems from the fact that empirical evidence is so much against a biological explanation for the power disparity, and arguments against it are based on findings of such small effect size (which doesn't even suggest causality, but even assuming it does) combined with strong potential self-interest. This is a very similar emotional response to that towards climate-change deniers. Their evidence is weak, and denying human-caused global warming serves their interests. Maybe the reaction is unjustified and we should approach every single time anyone brings up an idea without consideration for the thousands of times similar ideas have been expressed in the past, but the reaction is nonetheless, I think, very reasonable.

> calls them racist

I think you are way too obsessed with labels. Definitions in social science are not the same as definitions in the exact sciences, and they are more used as a shortcut to frame a first guess. The opinions you express are textbook scientific racism, lifted almost verbatim from late-19th or early-20th century texts. I use the name to roughly place them in a tradition of ideas; you think it is an insult. Such rough categorization (which are well recognized by social researchers as such) are an invaluable tool in disciplines with too many variables. Without them, we cannot even begin to discuss models in the history of ideas. Denying that your ideas are part of the traditions is silly and factually wrong, and completely separate from the question of whether they're true or not. So how about instead of saying that you're a scientific racist, I'd simply say that your ideas are part of the scientific racism tradition?

You may counter and say that because scientific racism has bad connotations today (even though it was once the consensus), this is an implied insult. But scientific racism has always made scientific claims, and those claims have turned out to be false, that I think that if you're trying to go against scientific consensus (as you yourself claimed you do) -- which is certainly scientifically valid -- and if you think that unlike previous incarnations, scientific racism in its current incarnation is different the burden of proof is on you. If you want to dispel the negative connotations behind scientific racism, you can't attack their validity, because they are very valid; you should just prove us wrong (I would suggest, however, that you employ better data and better analysis than you did, for example, when writing about women's abilities in STEM, because your assumptions basically dictated the result, and were absolutely not justified, so that's going to do the very opposite of changing scientific consensus).

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:17AM (#12907656)
Regarding the difference between polls and election results: maybe many people are racist, sexist xenophobes and if they tell the preference in public, they get rightfully derided for it. But with the secrecy of the ballot, they can give into their deep desire to kick out the Muslims and the Blacks, kick the females back into the kitchen and make America white again.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:25AM (#12907763)
There are other reasons to support Trump. Being an unorthodox person who they perceived as nonjudgemental, quite a few people have confided in me that they like him. Only one of these people was white, several were female, and none are particularly racist.

Reasons I've been told include:

- A "fuck you" to the establishment and orthodoxy.

- A belief that Hillary is corrupt.

- Entertainment value. One Trump voter I know also donated to Hillary in order to get the "Woman Card": https://shop.hillaryclinton.com/products/the-woman-card

- A support for nationalism and economic populism.

- A belief that Trump can do for the country what he did for Wolman skating rink: http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/features/2015-09-29/a-1980... (I think Peter Thiel falls into this category.)

I know it's tempting to level the worst insult you can think of - raaaciiiissstt - against anyone who disagrees with you. Consider the possibility that this is what allowed Trump to win in the first place.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:43AM (#12907980)
I've done a fair bit of arguing with the folks here on HN, it's interesting because it doesn't match the echo chamber I have on twitter or facebook. There seem to be a lot of Trump supporter here, which I find very surprising.

This idea keeps coming up again and again that using the word 'racist' in the context of the Trump campaign is essentially name-calling, an insult.

The problem is, racism is a big, big, big issue. And Trump is a racist bigot, you simply cannot deny it. That's why people that are described as 'on the left' feel so strongly about him. It's not 'pulling the race card', it's an actual big problem. America has spent 200 years trying to overcome it, and it's still so far behind. The open racism displayed by Trump is the reason why so many people viscerally hate him. Add to it the sexism (and sexual assault), the bullying, and the xenophobia, and the support for him becomes essentially unfathomable for many who consider his attitudes and behaviors completely incompatible with basic democratic values.

The article posted calls it smug, the commuter above called it 'not tolerating dissent'. I would call it a zero tolerance policy on racism, sexism, bullying and xenophobia.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:02AM (#12908227)
Using 'racist' in the context of criticizing Republicans is just name-calling. Bush displayed no open racism, bullied no one, and was not xenophobic. Same for Romney. Yet the anti-Trump language is just a more hysterical version of the anti-Bush and anti-Romney language.

At some point the term "racist" came to mean "insufficiently left wing". This happened because left wing types called every Republican "raaacciiiiist" - like a bored shepherd boy yelling "wolf" for amusement and likes on social media.

How's that working out?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by maxerickson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:15AM (#12909249)
Trump is looking to get about the same amount of votes as Romney.

Clinton is getting a lot less votes than Obama got.

So there is an alternative explanation there, that rather than one group of people getting sick of shrill accusations of racism, a different group of people just doesn't like Hilary Clinton all that much.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pessimizer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:32AM (#12910528)
Or that different group of people weren't as afraid of Trump as Clinton needed them to be.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by maxerickson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:45AM (#12910613)
A whole coalition of groups with different reasons for not voting for Clinton.

I'm just pushing back against the "unprecedented Trump blowout" narrative. So far he's got less popular votes than the loser of the last presidential election (Romney got 60,933,504 votes. Trumps at 59,088,517 with 98% of precincts reporting. He probably won't pick up another 1.8 million votes).

A different argument is that Trump attracted new people to the polls. I'd be more inclined to believe that many of those people are sick of establishment politics and their tactics. But I don't think they are actually a majority of Trump's support.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by deviate_X on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:50AM (#12909827)
He used it in the context of "Trump" not "Republican's"

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-racist-exam...

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by triplesec on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:41AM (#12909405)
Bush was pretty inclusive racially. McCain too. IDK about Romney, but Mormons have written history and religion that makes him suspect on that, but he campaigned reasonably. Trump campaigned openly on a racist, xenophobic platform. They were key parts of his rhetoric and key to a good proportion of his winning. That is the difference here.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:11AM (#12920468)
Which parts of his policies/campaign/platform are racist?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by LanceH on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:36AM (#12910922)
And we're right back to smug. You smugly state that it's a zero tolerance policy on racism, when it's going to be the progressive cohort who gets to declare things racist. Specifically, they'll cry racism every time someone disagrees with them. Don't like what the president wants to do? Racist. Have an issue with Mexico? Racist. Mildly suggest that college admissions should have a class based adjustment instead of racial quotas...racist.

Or just sit in the wrong place and you get to hear, "all white men are racist." It may guilt some to action, but it makes others disinclined to help.

Look at the #blacklivesmatter. Look at all the people who have been railing against police militarization for decades being called racist by the recent arrivals to the issue just because they say there is a larger problem.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:50AM (#12909109)
I'm not a Trump supporter... far from it however looking at my HRC social media bubble it's clear that practically 95% of my social circle are way off base when it comes to their analysis of why Trump won, which is precisely why he did win. If you don't understand your 'enemy' you cannot organise against him... or in this case liberals are so out of touch of what life is like in less fortunate areas of the country that they cannot begin to communicate with the people that live there on a level playing field. We needed a more extreme version of Bernie but instead we got offered the status quo. Racism, which has always been a big problem, has very little to do with this election and the sooner we accept that the better for everyone. This is economic.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:49AM (#12908057)
Do you have any examples of what you call racism from Trump. I haven't been following him super close (not American), but from what I've seen he wants to tighten up immigration. It's my understanding that this is not racism, but protectionism. Here in NZ it's very hard for people to immigrate here (I have had friends have to leave) but we don't associate racism with tight immigration policy.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:57AM (#12908171)
The Huffpost did a round-up: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/donald-trump-racist-exam...

For example there were proposals to not allow Muslims to immigrate to the US. There was calling Mexicans 'criminals' and 'rapists'. Beating of black people at Trump rallies (which he endorsed).

This shows up this night on my twitter feed: "I am at a Trump rally in Manhattan, and thousands are chanting 'We hate Muslims, we hate blacks, we want our great country back'. Disgusting" https://twitter.com/SRowntreeNews/status/796141495573155840

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by BakaRakuda on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:00AM (#12908766)
That twitter thing you just linked, did you read the replies under it?

I'm not 100% sure of the context. But it looks like it's fake.

@SRowntreeNews @WALTBACON Dude that's a fake account. Don't RT that garbage.

@aobrien7 good catch, thanks

@SRowntreeNews This is fake, @michaeldweiss. Part of disinfo network spreading false rumors. They were very active during Euro soccer riots.

--

If thats case aren't you just perpetuating a narrative about Trump supporters being a bunch of racist bigots, when in this case its made up BS????

This is exactly what pissed off a lot of regular people and got them to the polls IMO.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by snsr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:55PM (#12914006)
> If thats case aren't you just perpetuating a narrative about Trump supporters being a bunch of racist bigots

You are though.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:18AM (#12911371)
> ...aren't you just perpetuating a narrative...

Uh, no. I wrote that something 'showed up on my twitter feed', implying it's unverified. Last night there wasn't a way to verify it, it merely seemed plausible. In any case, the Huffpost article sufficiently makes the case.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jahewson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:00AM (#12909167)
I want to agree with you but Muslims are not a race. Neither are Mexicans for that matter. And being Islamaphobic and xenophobic genuinely is different from being racist. Perhaps not very different, but different nonetheless.

N.B. The chant you mention was in fact a hoax.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:29AM (#12911515)
It's worth bearing in mind that the US is a much more racialized society than the UK. We don't think of 'Mexican' or 'Muslim' as racial categories. But they de facto are racial categories in the US. That may not be very logical, but then neither are most Trump supporters. How many of them do you think are able to carefully parse the distinctions between 'Latino', 'Mexican' and 'illegal brown person'?

And of course, racism very often comes wrapped up in other prejudices which are thought (rightly or wrongly) to be more respectable. All of the groups Trump has targeted are groups that just so happen to consist mostly of people who aren't white. They're the groups that, in the public imagination, are responsible for the loss of an imagined homogenous White America.

Trump can't say "I want a white America". But the people who do want this haven't had any difficulty picking up on his hints.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:17AM (#12920507)
>How many of them do you think are able to carefully parse the distinctions between 'Latino', 'Mexican' and 'illegal brown person'?

And yet, Trump supporters understands that Mexican and Muslims are not a race. Hence, why they think Trump is not racist.

>Trump can't say "I want a white America". But the people who do want this haven't had any difficulty picking up on his hints.

Now you're just making up things in your mind about Trump and Trump supporters, and then accusing them of it.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:46AM (#12920751)
> Trump supporters understands that Mexican and Muslims are not a race. Hence, why they think Trump is not racist.

So they think he's xenophobic and religiously bigoted instead? How is that better?

>Now you're just making up things in your mind about Trump and Trump supporters, and then accusing them of it.

I'm not making up the fact that white supremacists supported Trump.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:32AM (#12921198)
>So they think he's xenophobic and religiously bigoted instead? How is that better?

He is not against all immigrants. He is ONLY against ILLEGAL immigrants. He still supports LEGAL immigrants from all over the world.

Also, he is not against the Islamic religion. He is just against immigration from countries with known ties to terrorism.

>I'm not making up the fact that white supremacists supported Trump.

The KKK also supports Hillary too, so that's just the typical election rhetoric you see every four years.

These are misconceptions by people who have not listened to Trump's rally speeches. They only hear a small part of the quotes without the context and form these misconceptions about him. And now, they're shocked and confused to find that the majority of the country supports him.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pmyteh on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:10AM (#12921599)
> Also, he is not against the Islamic religion. He is just against immigration from countries with known ties to terrorism.

He expressly called for all Muslims to be barred from the United States. I'm afraid that claiming he's "not against the Islamic religion" is not a fact-based argument.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:35PM (#12922417)
Which he also later clarified to meant immigrants from countries with direct ties to terrorism. And TEMPORARY only, until they can figure something out, like a vetting program, from those countries with direct ties to terrorism.

He wants to protect everyone from terrorism. Yes, he wants to protect Muslims from terrorism too. He even asked them for their help in the fight against radical terrorism, because he knows that terrorism affects them too.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:01PM (#12923162)
>Which he also later clarified to meant immigrants from countries with direct ties to terrorism.

That's not a clarification, that's just saying something completely different from what he originally said.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:51PM (#12923628)
But at no point was it racist like you claimed.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:40PM (#12924111)
We already covered that. You're changing the subject.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:00PM (#12924302)
Accusation of racist where there is no racism.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:05PM (#12926002)
Yep, we already covered that. Feel free to call it xenophobia and religious bigotry instead.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:24PM (#12926544)
But it is not xenophobia to want to keep terrorists out by temporary stopping immigration from countries with ties to terrorism. And that has nothing to do with their religion. It has to do with the fact that terrorists want to blow people up.

Calling that xenophobia and religious bigotry is just a straight out lie.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:42AM (#12929518)
He called for a ban on all Muslims. Try explaining how that has "nothing to do with religion".
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Saturday November 12, 2016 @11:55AM (#12938743)
>...all Muslims...

Not ALL Muslims.

ONLY the Muslims IMMIGRANTS from countries with direct ties to terrorist groups.

So how can he be racist if he's only banning the Muslims from countries with direct ties to terrorism, and not ALL Muslims? He's not banning ALL Muslims immigrants like you claim.

And this has nothing to do with religion. An immigrant don't even have to be Muslim. ANY immigrants (ANY, not just Muslims) that are attempting to enter the United States from a country with direct ties to terrorism will not be allowed into the United States until vetting can be done.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:59AM (#13021935)
He is on video calling for a ban on all Muslims.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday December 01, 2016 @04:31AM (#13078249)
He was also on video calling for ban for only immigrants from nations with direct ties to terrorism.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:25AM (#12921747)
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:38PM (#12922437)
Like I said, election rhetoric meant to smear the opponent.

Voters are smarter than this. Voters care more about the real issues that are affecting them (jobs, economy, etc). They don't care who the KKK is voting for. The result of the election have shown that.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:00PM (#12923154)
Huh? My point was that the KKK really was supporting Trump, whereas it was not really supporting Hillary.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:56PM (#12923674)
We have no way of knowing whether they genuinely support Trump, or whether they did actually support Hillary like they claimed to. It's all election smearing and rhetoric, which voters don't care about, as the election results have shown.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:39PM (#12924103)
They didn't claim to support Hillary; see link. David Duke did, however, endorse Trump.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:00PM (#12924295)
I understand.

They claimed to have donated $20,000 to Hillary. The website claimed the claim is false.

We will never know, but more importantly, the voters didn't really care who the KKK was supporting, as the election results have shown.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:06PM (#12926006)
We know that David Duke supported Trump. We don't know of anyone associated with the KKK supporting Hillary. That the voters don't care is to their discredit.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:23PM (#12926530)
We do know of Hillary's mentor, he claimed to have left the KKK. We know of other KKK Grand Master who have claimed to have donated to Hillary. It's all just claims and accusations to smear the opposite opponents in the election cycle. These are not important issues. Voters knows these are just election smears.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Friday November 11, 2016 @05:43AM (#12929528)
Nope, we know for sure that David Duke endorsed trump. Everything else you're referencing is baseless speculation.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Saturday November 12, 2016 @11:56AM (#12938750)
But we also know that the KKK donated $20,000 to Hillary.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:24AM (#12908456)
Fair enough if the stuff with Trump Management Corporation and his action at the casino are correct I'd say it's a fair call he's probably a bit racist.

Not allowing Muslims in could be seen as racist, but I don't know that was at the core of what he was trying to do. Don't get me wrong I don't think it's a good idea. But 100% of radical Islamic terrorist are Muslim so banning them would have made people less afraid of the radical Islamic threat the media were hyping up as ISIS was taking hold of Iraq. It's dumb and unfairly treats good honest safe people, but racist is a stretch.

That tweet holds little water with me each side has been mud slinging, most of the time it's either BS or an exaggeration.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by foldr on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:12AM (#12910360)
>It's dumb and unfairly treats good honest safe people, but racist is a stretch.

That's all racism is. Dumb thoughtless prejudice. It doesn't have horns and a tail.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by cheald on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:21AM (#12908429)
I'm a little suspicious of that tweet. Seems like that's the sort of thing that would show up on at least one cell phone video somewhere.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by DefaultUserHN on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:08AM (#12920442)
>And Trump is a racist bigot, you simply cannot deny it.

There you go with the name calling again. How about you listen to Trump supporters for once. Or maybe you just don't want to know the real reason why Trump supporters supported Trump.

Stop talking and start listening.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:34AM (#12907865)
This is the issue. People did not vote Trump to satisfy hateful racism and sexism, they voted Trump despite everyone painting them as racist sexist pigs.

The other option was so far from what they wanted they had little choice. Please try to understand why people disagree with you, why the majority disagrees with you.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by johndoez on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:20AM (#12908423)
Precisely. Political Correctness is now starting to work against the Left.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by gcp on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:00AM (#12908767)
Many democracies in Europe have or have had extreme right nationalists/fascists in power and much of the same trajectory happened. Uttering that there might be problems with immigration policies was a complete taboo as the extreme right made extremely strict (and thus different) policies there a major point of their discourse.

But what happens when you don't discuss a subject that the voters consider (right or not - that's not even the issue!) important and worrying?

It wasn't until the subject was considered debatable by more centrist parties that this rise was halted, or at least coupled with less worrying ideologies.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by johndoez on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:12AM (#12908858)
Indeed. Here is the great truth - for most people, race matters, and always will. They want to live with people of the same ethnicity, with the same history, in the same territory. The breakup of Yugoslavia suggested ethno-nationalism was on the rise, but the elites continued to push (if not intensified) mass immigration in the West. This has created the seedbed for the new "anti-politics". It is in its first phase, and I expect it to last for around 30 years.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by bobwaycott on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:22PM (#12914797)
I think you overstate your defense. Some people did not vote Trump to satisfy hateful racism or sexism. On the other hand, some most certainly did. In my neck of the woods, that some is not an insignificant amount.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:03AM (#12918330)
Do you really know the motives of your neighbors that well?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by bobwaycott on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:15AM (#12920494)
Yes. I live in a staunchly conservative area, and the people are very vocal here.

Here is a campaign sign outside a polling place about 20ish miles away. https://tribwgno.files.wordpress.com/2016/11/white-again.jpg

Beyond that, anyone who attempts to deny the sexism/misogyny of the Trump campaign and its pull with some of his supporters must have entirely missed all the various materials/items made & sold with hateful messaging about Clinton, using sex-based slurs and insults. The evidence is there and overwhelming. Around here, people are proud to wear those shirts and buttons and affix stickers to their cars with the messages. We will continue seeing them for some time in this area.

EDIT: You might be interested in perusing this stream of day 1 after the election:

https://twitter.com/i/moments/796417517157830656

Here's a couple particularly notable ones:

- Man walks out to his car, on video, to find "fuck you nigger" written on his windows with "Trump" also written on the front & back glass.

- Assaults on Muslim women by white people making racist comments and mentioning Trump or wearing Trump campaign gear

- A group of whites threatening the life of a black woman at a gas station, with a firearm, while calling her nigger

You're left with one of two conclusions to draw:

- There are hateful racists and sexists/misogynists out there who supported & are emboldened by Trump's victory

- All of these people are making these events up

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:50AM (#12908076)
The problem is, I don't buy it. I don't believe it. I listen to how Trump talks, how Trump supporters talk, all the racism, the sexism, the xenophobia, it's just not right. There's no excuse.

It's the beginning of fascism.

Btw, I'm German. (I've lived in North America for more than ten years)

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:10AM (#12908327)
Trumps treatment of women in the past makes my skin crawl, as an individual I think his behavior on that count is despicable. But if I were given the option of Hillary or Trump I'd vote Trump.

I might be wrong but I've not heard him say anything that is racist. No doubt there are some that are supporting him because they're racist, that doesn't mean all are. On that note I would love someone to prove me wrong and show me a clear example of Trump actually being racist.

I'm a conservative Christian. As a conservative, the left look down on me and assume there is only ignorance fueling my world view. There are issue like abortion, that to me are like the holocaust. I know most don't agree with me on that, and I can understand that they don't see a fetus as a life, I get it. But imagine for a second that you were firmly convinced that a fetus was as much a life as a new born. Things like that will drive you to vote Trump despite hating some of his actions.

The left also treats Christians with disdain. You have to get people on side if you want them to vote for you. Not tell them they're idiots.

While I don't agree with them some see gun rights as fundamentals to their freedom. You can't just tell these people were going to restrict guns, you have to get them to believe that it's for the best. Not tell them they're idiots. Then call them racist sexist bigots when they don't vote your way.

Immigration in the states is not in a good way, having so many people living illegally is not good for anyone. Trump might sound harsh but at least he is willing to tackle the problem (even in a way I'd not go for).

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by ant6n on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:23AM (#12908447)
Well, you say abortion is an issue that feels like a Holocaust to you.

To me racism and xenophobia are the the things that fuelled the actual Holocaust. I tried to outline some of the racism inherent to Trump further up.

To be honest, I don't understand conservative Christians love for republicans. They preach social darwinism, often they preach fear of others. Is it all based on this notion that "The left also treats Christians with disdain"?

My view of Christianity (I come from a more Lutheran view...) is one of 'love thy neighbor' and charity towards the poor as the guiding principles. I consider myself a humanist, but understand that my flavor of Western humanism is essentially the non-secular continuation of Christian values -- which are inherently compatible with leftist values that are also very much based on compassion and empathy. This all seems to be incompatible with the hatefulness I see from republicans, especially somebody like Trump. To me, Trump is a selfish nihilist.

One of my favorite Presidents is Jimmy Carter, and his strong moral center based on religious beliefs is the main reason.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:44AM (#12908642)
This is one of the things I don't understand about modern politics, morally conservative always seem to go towards extreme capitalism and morally progressives tend to go towards socialism. Personally I'm more middle of the road on socialism VS capitalism. But I tend to vote and align with parties on their moral stance. Even though Trump appears to have a crappy personal Moral standard his policies at least align more with the conservative end. I'd rather a hypocrite that legislates conservatively (Even though that's a really crappy thing to have as the best option).

But on the Christian view, there are actually themes in the Bible that talk about a "worker deserving his wage", and "if a man doesn't work he doesn't eat". So I don't know if Christianities version of "Love thy neighbor" is what non Christians think it is. The concept of Love in Christianity doesn't always map to what non Christians see as Love. For example discipline is seen as a form of love. Sometimes doing something that is unpleasant for an individual but helps them in the long run can be seen as love. But to be honest I don't think biblical concepts really align with the left or the right.

If I were convinced as you are that Trump wanted to introduce racist policies as president then I'd agree there is no way in good conscience to vote for him. I'm not yet convinced of that and as I'm not American did not bother researching enough to be fully convinced.

But then I don't know who I'd have voted for. I'm not a fan of Hillary and then there is the Libertarian and Green candidates, neither really align with my moral views either.

It would have been nice if there was a strong moral candidate, but I don't know that either were this election.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by unprepare on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:26AM (#12910055)
>here are actually themes in the Bible that talk about a "worker deserving his wage", and "if a man doesn't work he doesn't eat".

wow some fantastic turns of logic you are using.

Christian means Christ-like. did Christ preach social darwinism, or did he spend his time with prostitutes and lepers?

Did Christ preach having the poor fend for themselves, or did he feed the hungry?

Did Christ praise the wealthy, or does he say "It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God."

You can of course interpret your religion as you see fit, but in my eyes, right wing politics is incompatible with being Christ-like.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by noobiemcfoob on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:18AM (#12910821)
There is a lot more to Christianity than being "Christ-like". The parent's point is there exists a healthy serving of many unChrist-like, by your definition, ideas in the Bible. And even then, there is much more to a religion than its holy texts or doctrine.

I'd leave it to the practitioners to exhibit what it means to be one of their followers, and it seems the American practitioners haven't noticed this incompatibility you're concerned about.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:30PM (#12913747)
Those were actual quotes from the bible. I'm not sure how that's a u turn in logic?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by unprepare on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:09AM (#12920025)
Well, the entire first half of the Bible is before the birth of Christ, and when Christ arrived the religion began whats called the New Covenant with God, replacing the old covenant which bound followers to the old laws of the old testament.

something being "in the bible" is meaningless without its context. Theres quite a breadth on the capturing, keeping and treatment of slaves - would you argue that these verses are the same as Christs teachings?

>As for the male and female slaves whom you may have, it is from the nations around you that you may acquire male and female slaves.

> You may also acquire them from among the aliens residing with you, and from their families that are with you, who have been born in your land; and they may be your property.

>You may keep them as a possession for your children after you, for them to inherit as property.

But hey, if you think being a Christian means following any phrase you happen to pick out of the Bible, go for it.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by BrandonM on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:46AM (#12920275)
FYI: This reply is exactly one of the "smug styles" that the original article highlights:

> Christianity, as many hastened to point out, is about love. Christ commands us to render unto Caesar what is Caesar's. If the Bible took any position on the issue at all, it was that divorce, beloved by Davis, was a sin, and that she was a hypocrite masquerading among the faithful.

> How many of these critiques were issued by atheists?

> This, more than anything I can recall in recent American life, is an example of the smug style.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by maxerickson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:50AM (#12909112)
This is one of the things I don't understand about modern politics, morally conservative always seem to go towards extreme capitalism and morally progressives tend to go towards socialism.

A cynical and maybe excessively nasty answer is that people that just care about lower taxes have pandered to moral conservatives in order to get tax cutting representatives elected.

The more nuanced answer is probably that there has been a coalition for 30-40 years along those lines. I think over the next several elections, those alignments are going to shift in a big way. Trump doesn't come from the historic coalition, Sanders almost won as an outsider in the Democratic primary. The parties are not well aligned with the electorate.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jahewson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:22AM (#12909298)
The simple explanation is that the left won't touch socially conservative ideas, leaving the right free to pander to that base. Combine this with policies that look like tax cuts to the casual observer and you've got a winning formula, despite that fact that the socially conservative electorate isn't interested in libertarian capitalism at all.

Just look at how Trump changed his views on abortion to pander to the social conservatives, and as a consequence won huge evangelical support.

So the right has taken the attitude that they don't care about morals, they'll adopt any policy which allows them to win so they can go about pushing the agenda of liberal capitalism for the benefit of themselves. Sure, there are some genuine moralists on the right too - but none of those just won an election.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by maxerickson on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:46AM (#12909087)
The irony to me about immigration violations is that a major factor in reducing them has been...NAFTA.

There is even currently a net migration of Mexicans back to Mexico.

http://www.pewhispanic.org/2015/11/19/more-mexicans-leaving-...

I'm not sure I count as part of the left, but as an atheist, I have no trouble understanding a fetus was as much a life as a new born as an honest and principled position. On the other hand, I'm not sure how you come to a political compromise with people that disagree with it (how do they reach out?).

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:18AM (#12918385)
"I have no trouble understanding a fetus was as much a life as a new born as an honest and principled position" Starting with that is huge. Getting called a women hater, or getting told as a man you have no right to have an opinion, or get written off as a religious idiot, starts to polarize your opinions. But when each side recognizes the others opinion is valid then you can start to look for a compromise.

Personally I think making abortion something that has to be legislated at the state level and leaving moral issues up to public referendum would go a long way to removing it from the normal political divide.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by noobiemcfoob on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:27AM (#12910876)
> On the other hand, I'm not sure how you come to a political compromise with people that disagree with it (how do they reach out?).

I've often found myself with the same question. What's a satisfactory answer for "THIS IS MURDER!?" vs. "Eh, I don't think so, more like a nasty wart...". I understand both, but I just don't see place for a bridge other than telling one side to get over it.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by kofejnik on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:21PM (#12915322)
http://spot.colorado.edu/~heathwoo/Phil160,Fall02/thomson.ht...

You wake up in the morning and find yourself back to back in bed with an unconscious violinist. A famous unconscious violinist. He has been found to have a fatal kidney ailment, and the Society of Music Lovers has canvassed all the available medical records and found that you alone have the right blood type to help. They have therefore kidnapped you, and last night the violinist's circulatory system was plugged into yours, so that your kidneys can be used to extract poisons from his blood as well as your own. The director of the hospital now tells you, "Look, we're sorry the Society of Music Lovers did this to you--we would never have permitted it if we had known. But still, they did it, and the violinist is now plugged into you. To unplug you would be to kill him. But never mind, it's only for nine months. By then he will have recovered from his ailment, and can safely be unplugged from you." Is it morally incumbent on you to accede to this situation? No doubt it would be very nice of you if you did, a great kindness. But do you have to accede to it? What if it were not nine months, but nine years? Or longer still? What if the director of the hospital says. "Tough luck. I agree. but now you've got to stay in bed, with the violinist plugged into you, for the rest of your life. Because remember this. All persons have a right to life, and violinists are persons. Granted you have a right to decide what happens in and to your body, but a person's right to life outweighs your right to decide what happens in and to your body. So you cannot ever be unplugged from him."

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:47AM (#12919044)
I've never understood this argument. Why doesn't that apply to feeding and clothing a new born? If you give birth to a child and let them die in the cold that is seen as murder. Why does a parent have to provide for a child before they were born and not after.

Also many societies have concepts where people are required to care for others, parents and close relatives.

I just don't agree, I think if the violinist has only one chance at life and that one chance has been wasted because he was tethered to you without concent then he should have the right to life. But the people who did it should also go to jail for a very long time.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by kofejnik on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:21PM (#12926523)
The difference wrt kids is that you have an option to refuse care in the long run, eg by giving up kids for adoption. In the violinist example, if lets say a suitable volunteer is available but needs time to come to the hospital, then yes, you need to stay attached for a short while and disconnecting would be immoral. But if this choice is not given to you, can you be expected to sacrifice an important chunk of your life for someone else?

Otherwise, should you be compelled to donate one of your kidneys?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by artimaeis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:06AM (#12910740)
> "There are issue like abortion, that to me are like the holocaust. I know most don't agree with me on that, and I can understand that they don't see a fetus as a life, I get it. But imagine for a second that you were firmly convinced that a fetus was as much a life as a new born."

Okay, so here I am - lifelong progressive Democrat. And I'll open up to this discussion.

So, I'm believing that at the moment of conception a full viable life is formed. And that life has the full rights and protections afforded by the State (both federal and all levels beneath).

Let's start with the simple route - the parents are happy to have the child, are financially capable, and medically sound for delivery. In this nothing is different from how it is today. A healthy child is born to a happy family.

Our differences seem to come from all the complications in the process.

Let's start with an understandable one - the life of the mother is in danger if she delivers the child. This is a horrifying decision. Does the state force the delivery of the child and thus condemn the mother to death? Is not one of the roles of modern medicine to protect people from death? This is, after all, why we now give birth in hospitals.

So, before I go further arguing with myself - what's your rationale as a conservative Christian on that scenario? Is it really as simple as "protect the child's life at all costs"?

For what it's worth - I don't think anyone's an idiot for being on the conservative side. I think a lot of the issues we struggle with in this day and age (such as abortion) are just far more complicated and intricate than most give credit for.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:56PM (#12913390)
"Life of the mother" is very different from "it's my body", though. If I believe that life begins at conception, I can perhaps bend to a "life of the mother" exception. "It's my body"? But it's not just your body - there's another life involved as well - so you can't just do what you want with your body.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by artimaeis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:52PM (#12914507)
Okay, so you can bend to "life of the mother" exception. I can follow this a bit further then.

How do you handle and account for miscarriages? A sizable number of pregnancies end in miscarriage - especially if we view life as beginning at conception. So in miscarriage the mother has ended the life of the child.

What's the framework with which you believe this should be dealt with? What's to be done with people who have biological disorders leading to problems with gestation? After all, if life starts at conception then it's pretty quickly no longer just a woman's body.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:58PM (#12915678)
How is a miscarriage any different to an infant dying of natural causes?

Sometimes babies die naturally it's sad, but there is a huge difference between dying naturally and dying due to intervention or neglect.

Surly you can see there is a big difference between a woman having medically difficulty bringing a child to term and an abortion? In the one case she has done all she can to provide for the child in the other she has actively pursued this child's termination.

If the mother and the child are going to die with out intervention you attempt to save both. That may mean an early birth or c-section giving the child little to no chance at survival, but you still try, you still treat that child as a human.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by artimaeis on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:21AM (#12921083)
Of course I see the difference. But think of the perspective of the state here. The state must protect the life of the child, as it is a full citizen of the state.

When an infant dies of natural causes it's usually trivially simple to rule out murder. But in the case of miscarriage/abortion the procedure for early-term abortion simply causes a miscarriage. So in order to adequately protect the life of the child we'd need to be able to determine if the miscarriage was forced or not.

What, in your view, is the ideal role of the state as a protector of life in this situation?

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xupybd on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:26PM (#12913700)
I think if the mothers life is at risk the doctor has to make the call on who to save. Sometimes this has to happen. I'd compare it to triage, docotors sometimes have to make a call that means one person lives and another dies. I have no issue with this as long as they recognise both lives and make judgments based on that.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by tnmrnis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:09AM (#12909952)
I also followed the elections very closely and I don't buy the "racism", "sexism" and "xenophobia". I looked up a lot of scandals and looked at the speeches, videos and leaks itself. Often times I didn't consider the outrage as justified.

Example 1: Trump never called all mexicans racist, what he said was that a lot of the people crossing the border are criminals while other s are decent. Some of the criminals are racist.

Example 2: His "approval" of sexual assault, was nothing but locker room talk. Two guys "out alphaing" each other in a not so nice way.

As a conservative from Germany that has been accused of racism for showing support for the shut down of the balcan route I find it much easier to sympathize with the falsely accused then with the accuser.

That doesn't mean that I agree with Trump, but I would have voted for Trump over Clinton.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by gcp on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:24AM (#12907748)
they get rightfully derided for it

Yeah but one could have observed that shouting/bullying down someone because of their beliefs is counterproductive in getting them to reconsider them. It's not like there wasn't any warning to this.