News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:40AM (#12907949)
Obama is a huge part of why this happened. He promised change and delivered empire.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by scarmig on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:56AM (#12908164)
Eh, I do have plenty of foreign policy disagreements in particular with him. But he's the best we've had in living memory.

Liberalism has had a smug aspect as long as I've been alive, but at this point that aspect has metastasized to something worse. The norms that have developed are toxic to progressive movements. They certainly alienate people, but beyond that they make it so you don't even have the institutional capacity to understand or formulate policies relevant to those people.

It's a perverse version of the situation people thought Republicans were in in 2012, where they seemed to have driven out most non-white people and thereby lacked the capacity for effective outreach to them. Except in this case, if you're a poor white male in Wisconsin who's done everything right but is still struggling like hell, you're an evil oppressor who just doesn't recognize your privilege. People who can understand where the poor white male perspective is coming from are literally shouted out of discussions for diverting attention from the people uniquely experiencing True Suffering and blessed with progressive sainthood.

It's beyond Obama. Who, for what it's worth, has always struck me as the thoughtful type who wouldn't buy into those kinds of fake dichotomies. It's a broader issue with progressive movements where people earn cred by honing their sensitivities enough to maximize the level of offense they can experience.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @04:07AM (#12908294)
I agree with everything you have said. Obama is a thoughtful type and a great orator. I'm sure he would have liked to enact some of the change he promised but he didn't. In many ways America regressed further under his watch and this is the outcome.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by triplesec on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:36AM (#12909379)
I think it's not that he didn't, but he couldn't, with the most obstructive Congress in modern history
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by privong on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:56AM (#12909867)
> I think it's not that he didn't, but he couldn't, with the most obstructive Congress in modern history

Ironically, some of that might have been his own doing, though. The healthcare reform was passed essentially without republican support; I think that's a very rare example of major [healthcare] legislation that was not passed with bi-partisan support. Not doing more to bring R's on board likely burned lots of political capital and hardened opposition to him in Congress. I'm not saying Obama didn't try at all to bring R's on board, just that a bit more effort might have result in a more cooperative Congress.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:41AM (#12910130)
The GOP congress decided to bring Obama down from the start, and never gave an inch. He tried valiantly to collaborate and compromise but the GOP didn’t have the political capacity to work with Obama for fear of being challenged in primaries from the right.

You’re right that the ACA ended up being a political disaster for the Democrats though.

The ACA was basically the same as “RomneyCare” in MA, and was a style of healthcare reform supported by mainstream center-right Republicans and some center-left Democrats (most Democrats wanted a single payer plan, or at least a public option, but took what they could get because the healthcare system was/is at a breaking point), but once Obama’s name was on it they all decided to throw everything they could against it.

The GOP campaigned hard against the ACA after it passed, and won massively in the midterm elections in 2010 on the back of wall-to-wall anti-ACA messaging on right-leaning media and a huge amount of organizing and spending (the first post-Citizens United election). They took control of the House, Senate, and many state legislatures, following which they redrew all the district boundaries to cut Democrats permanently out of competition in the House and many state legislatures.

After the crushing defeat in 2010, there weren’t enough Senate seats up for grabs in 2012 for the Democrats to regain control. Thus Obama had to deal with 6 years of GOP control, which has been the most obstructionist Congress in US history. As soon as McConnell won in 2010 he publicly declared that his #1 goal was to make Obama a 1-term president. We had multiple government shutdown threats, unprecedented obstruction of executive appointments including judges at every level of the federal court system, bogus investigation after bogus investigation into e.g. Benghazi, and dozens of purely symbolic votes to repeal the ACA.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by chimeracoder on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:50PM (#12913334)
> The ACA was basically the same as “RomneyCare” in MA, and was a style of healthcare reform supported by mainstream center-right Republicans

Romneycare never really had widespread support of Republicans at the national level. Or, really, the support of Republicans in general. It was passed by a governor in a state where almost every single elected state legislator is a Democrat, so it's hardly a measure of what to expect Republicans to support when the population they represent is more moderate, conservative, or Republican-affiliated.

Using Romney's actions as governor of MA as a yardstick is a really skewed perspective to try and apply to national politics. Massachusetts has a history of electing Republican governors as a way of placing a "check" on the legislature. Currently, Massachusetts has a Republican governor - but Baker would likely have run under the Democratic party if we were talking about Montana or Kansas instead of Massachusetts.

> and some center-left Democrats (most Democrats wanted a single payer plan, or at least a public option, but took what they could get because the healthcare system was/is at a breaking point)

It was never the case that "most" Democrats wanted a single-payer plan. The public option was more popular within the Democratic party, but even then was very controversial, and didn't have strong enough support from the Democrats.

There was, incidentally, a proposal that did have bipartisan support (the Wyden-Bennett bill), but it fell short of 60 votes.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by pessimizer on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:22AM (#12910452)
And to not just push single-payer when they were never going to get Republican support burned a lot of his support on the left. He spent an enormous amount of effort whipping the Democrats to the right in order to pass ACA as the great compromise that he conceived (it was a Heritage Foundation policy after all); and the most controversial part of it (the universal cash penalty for being uninsured) was a Clinton policy that he campaigned against in the primary and won.

He didn't have to bring any Republicans on board. What he had to have was the integrity to push for what he had the mandate to deliver, instead of all of this pre-compromising, losing anyway, then eventually quarter-assing something through presidential fiat or lack of enforcement. If President Obama had chosen to pursue the policies that Candidate Obama had been elected on, the voters would have punished congressmen who got in his way. Instead he had one of the least transparent administrations imaginable, passed a bunch of complex garbage with a million special interest carveouts, and tried to create social change through undemocratic executive action.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rndmize on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:43AM (#12911738)
Not even remotely close to true. Obama put in a ton of effort into crossing party lines, and was rejected, delayed, lied about - I remember how the discussion of the ACA was going on for months and month and MONTHS of stonewalling, how he went to the Republican retreat to discuss the issue and make some points after most of a summer and fall of obstructionism and demolished Republican arguments effectively enough that Fox cut away from the live broadcast after 20 minutes. I remember the supercommittee, and how the Republican absolutely refused to bend on any of their points, while the Democrats bent on theirs, over and over. The debt ceiling showdowns...

After his first year in office, Obama started getting shit from people on the left because a lot of them thought he was trying too hard to reach across the isle and unify the nation instead of ignoring the obstructionists and getting stuff done.

http://www.politico.com/story/2010/01/obama-rumbles-with-hou... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2010/ja...

> Consider that Obama's $787bn stimulus bill of last spring was heavily weighted toward tax cuts, against the advice of many economists, in an effort to win some Republican support. In the end, the bill received not a single Republican vote.

> Consider that he nominated a moderate, pro-prosecution Supreme Court justice, Sonia Sotomayor, only to see her tagged as a racist over some rather innocuous remarks she made about being a "wise Latina".

> Consider, too, that healthcare reform became bogged down in such a compromise-ridden mess because Obama ruled out a single-payer system ahead of time and never strongly backed a government-owned insurance alternative (the "public option") to compete with private insurance companies.

> As with the stimulus bill, the idea was to bring along a few Republican senators thought to hold reasonable views on the subject, such as Charles Grassley of Iowa and Olympia Snowe of Maine. And again, no Republican support was forthcoming, forcing Senate leaders to cut outrageous deals with recalcitrant Democrats Ben Nelson of Nebraska and Mary Landrieu of Louisiana.

> Obama's attempts to find compromise solutions did not stop Republicans from labelling him as a radical – or their nutty tea-party allies from calling him a "socialist" and worse. And, in retrospect, that was going to happen no matter what he did. His real problem has been that, to his supporters, he looked as though he'd been sucked into the very system he was elected to reform. Thus an Obama ally like Martha Coakley, a loyal Democratic apparatchik who'd long been criticised for her reluctance to take on political corruption in Massachusetts, became the perfect foil. (Coakley is best known for prosecuting Louise Woodward, a British nanny accused of killing a baby in her care.)

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by xherberta on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:13AM (#12909976)
Particularly troublesome is the dynamic where congresspeople need campaign funds, and largely get them from PACs and industry. With ObamaCare (ACA), the insurance and pharma industries were well-represented, coming away with concessions worth billions.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by humanrebar on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:24AM (#12909310)
You're too kind to Obama. Obama did troll his opponents on many occasions (like saying snarky things about birth certificates). He ran on a better type of politics, but he gave up on it very quickly, to phrase it charitably.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:41AM (#12910133)
"He's the best we've had in living memory."

uh, WOW. you must have a short memory because reagan, bush sr, and clinton were all superior in almost every way, and none will eat a terrible policy failure like the aca.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:53AM (#12910223)
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by arethuza on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:17AM (#12910400)
Somewhat surprisingly for a leftish Scot I am a fan of Reagan - for one very important reason. He understood that the standard US view of the Soviets was actually wrong and it was the Soviet leadership who were utterly afraid of the US (perhaps for good reasons) and he changed his approach.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:23AM (#12910462)
It wasn’t widely realized at the time even at high levels of the US government, but the USSR collapsed under its own economic weight, and was in demographic free-fall before Reagan ever took office. It’s unlikely that any action the Reagan administration took had a significant effect on the end result, though arguably US policies might have accelerated or retarded the decline by a couple years.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by arethuza on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:27AM (#12910491)
The Soviet's might have been broke in the 1980s but they were armed to the teeth and I do think that the change from "evil empire" rhetoric to actually engaging with their new leadership probably reduced the risks of an all-out war which few of us would have survived - certainly not here in the UK.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:01AM (#12910282)
not the least bit interested in partisan "journalism". i was alive then.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by jacobolus on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:14AM (#12910383)
This is an excerpt from a mass-market history/biography book by a renowned historian at UNC Chapel Hill (emeritus), a foremost scholar of FDR’s life and work. It’s not journalism per se (with or without scare quotes) https://www.amazon.com/dp/0195176162/
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by judahmeek on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:13AM (#12910369)
And what metrics are you basing your statements on?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by artimaeis on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:35AM (#12910542)
Alright - so we are two people that have very different views of the past 50 years it sounds like.

So, in your perspective, what was something that made Bush Sr a superior president to Obama? Or any of the others you listed? Help me understand your perspective.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:53AM (#12911066)
Wait, what? He ran on fixing the economy (done), ending the war in Iraq (done), restoring our relationship with the rest of the world (done), universal health care (done) and improving the acceptance of minority groups (somewhat done - at least the LGBT community).

Illegal immigration is down, unemployment is down, crime is down.

There are definitely things Obama hasn't done, but he absolutely delivered change, and he did it while facing a completely obstructionist Congress and Senate for most of his tenure. People just get complacent, even when things are going great. No matter how much any president does, or how good things are, people will get antsy just because our human nature forces us to constantly avoid what we perceive as stagnation.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:45AM (#12911779)
Ending the war? He has escalated on all fronts and opened new ones too. Obama talks a good game but under it all is more surveillance, more economic inequality and more violence.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:29PM (#12913738)
Escalating on all fronts? Please elaborate how getting the US out of a major war has done that. I certainly won't claim that Obama's foreign policy is golden, but it was said 'empire'...which would mean invading and occupying all over the globe. Obama isn't even close to the imperialist policies we had under Bush.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:37PM (#12916900)
You haven't been paying attention. Ukraine, Syria (and by proxy Iraq), Libya, Arab Spring, Yemen .... now moving clandestine operations into central Africa. We also have Brazil in SA, we've had dronings in countless other countries, even against US citizens without trial which is also a first and I'm sure I'm missing a few on the hit list. Just because the tactics change doesn't mean he gets a green card.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:11PM (#12912898)
> Wait, what? He ran on fixing the economy (done)...

Not really. It's not at the point of collapse, but it sure wasn't a normal recovery. It's better than 2008, but it's still broken in some very real ways.

> ... ending the war in Iraq (done)...

Sort of. The battle for Mosul was in the news just last week, with US involvement.

> ... restoring our relationship with the rest of the world (done)...

Russia is fighting against our goals in Syria, and illegally occupied the eastern Ukraine. Iran has a nuclear deal with us, but immediately started thumbing its nose at us. China is trying to see how much influence they can gain at our expense in Asia. North Korea's nuclear and missile programs are, according to their rhetoric, aimed explicitly at us.

> ... universal health care (done)...

Seen the premium changes for 2017? The law was passed, but "bending the cost curve" sure didn't happen.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by knz on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:04PM (#12914091)
> Seen the premium changes for 2017?

I'm amused by the Republican concern for rising premiums this year. My health insurance rates have gone up every year by 5-10% for the last 10 years after my work switched to high deductible plans. Between my employer and I the total cost of insurance is $14,400/year. That's more than the total income tax for a median income back in my country of birth. Just for insurance!

There are a lot of things wrong with the ACA/Obamacare but let's not pretend that the giant mess known as the American medical system is solely the responsibility of the Democrats. Every other OECD nation seems to have figured it out....

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @03:09PM (#12914137)
That's definitely a concern I have - Republicans want to repeal ACA and roll it back to the incredibly expensive system we had before that was bankrupting people. That's exactly what they intend to do.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by silverbax88 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:27PM (#12913713)
That's what I mean about having some issues. I would have liked to see healthcare be more sweeping, better implemented.

But the 'normal' recovery? What does a 'normal' recovery look like when the global economy is on the brink of collapse, and the US has run up a deficit never seen before? The Great Depression needed a World War to finally pull the US back to recovery.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by zigzigzag on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:42AM (#12918735)
Maybe the second time around.

The first time I remember him talking about reform of Washington.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by mrow84 on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:38AM (#12909758)
I'm no expert on US politics, but wasn't he hidebound by a Republican house and senate?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:18AM (#12910010)
Promises were made. Why they weren't kept is irrelevant.

Edit: to clarify this is not my personal position but more a reflection on how I see the electorate behaving.

Re:The smug style in American liberalism by crispyambulance on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:26AM (#12910479)
... yes, "promises" are how people defend their vote, and now we're going to get a front-row seat to see what happens to "promises" when the bullshit artist, Trump, is in charge.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by hash-set on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:54AM (#12910668)
Yeah, see you really need to listen to yourself? That article says it all. Now he's a bullshit artist because he can't possibly be competent since he's ostensibly a conservative. It's a fallacy.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by crispyambulance on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:57PM (#12913399)
No, he's a bullshit artist because he has made promises which he is CLEARLY not going to be able to keep like building a wall between Mexico and USA and getting Mexico to pay for it. I could go on and on, but that's a good, concrete example of a "promise" that will go unfulfilled.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by lintiness on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:42AM (#12910140)
he controlled both houses when he took office. he rammed through ideological policy aca with zero opposition party input or support; he quickly lost his majorities.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by esja on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:15AM (#12910390)
He also did this at a time when he should have been focused on finishing the job with banking reform.
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by verbify on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:23AM (#12910459)
Which is why he has an approval rating of 55%?
Re:The smug style in American liberalism by hash-set on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @09:52AM (#12910651)
Obama failed to even fundamentally pretend to enforce the laws of the land.