News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by DHMO on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:08AM (#12317926)
In addition to the two actually dropped in Japan, the US and Russia have been close to accidentally firing nuclear weapons since then, in each case because they thought they were getting ready to respond to what they thought was an aggressive act. It's just not a good idea to have nuclear weapons at all.

So, instead of "no first use", I would just have a global agreement never to have or use nuclear weapons for any reason, not even for defense.

Nuclear pulse propulsion should be allowed for spacecraft, however. This was outlawed years ago by the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_Nuclear_Test_Ban_Treat... but would be much more efficient than other currently used methods and safe if used with clean bombs in space. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_pulse_propulsion

Weapons by their nature will continue to escalate as long as technology improves, so if nuclear weapons continue to be allowed, time will surely bring a weapon even more destructive to counter them. Whether you believe they've brought peace or not, do you want someone to invent an even greater weapon and test it as the next "weapon of peace"? I don't.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by gizmo686 on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:19AM (#12317954)
>including for spacecraft in space- something which was outlawed years ago.

What are you talking about? NASA is facing a plutonium-238 shortage, but that is because we ran out of our stock-pile that was produced as a by-product of bomb manufacturing. Production of plutonium-238 started again back in 2013.

The only international laws I could find regarding nuclear spacecraft seem to be reasonable safety requirement (eg, not crash into Earth while still radioactive).

>So, instead of "no first use", I would just have a global agreement never to have or use nuclear weapons for any reason, even for a defensive strike.

The problem is that this policy removes the main dynamic that has prevented use of nuclear weapons: the threat of reprisal. If a country (verifiably) agrees to never use nuclear weapons, then a bad actor country can safely break the agreement. Under the current system this does not happen, because that would lead to a nuclear counter attack.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by akiselev on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:05AM (#12318062)
NASA uses plutonium for radioisotope thermoelectric generators whereas the OP is talking about nuclear pulse propulsion, which uses the shockwave from nuclear warhead detonations to propel a spacecraft. These are two fundamentally different things. The latter is illegal in most countries because of the aforementioned Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, which bans any atmospheric or outer space detonations.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by XorNot on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:51AM (#12318541)
Also unnecessary because thermal lightbulb rockets deliver better ISP.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by akiselev on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:06AM (#12318591)
Yes but unfortunately after the UTC research was canceled all development on the nuclear lightbulb design was stopped while other methods of nuclear propulsion received at least some mindshare from theoreticians and engineers. The nuclear lightbulb now rots in the NASA technical archives. Most of the engineers who worked on it are dead and we haven't made much progress on the material science needed to pull it off (I.e. we still don't have a solution to neutron damage and runaway heating in the single crystal berrillium oxide sheath as well as a viable design for the fuel injector).
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by XorNot on Friday August 19, 2016 @09:13AM (#12319708)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Pluto

But we did actually build prototype engines of a similar principle. There were actual mechanical artifacts test-fired. This is a much more viable looking option then Orion which only proved the pusher-plate design seems viable on a small scale, and which is unlikely to ever clear the problem of "build a lot of nuclear weapons...then deliberately start setting them off".

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by netheril96 on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:00AM (#12318763)
> I would just have a global agreement never to have or use nuclear weapons for any reason, not even for defense.

And how would that be enforced?

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by DHMO on Friday August 19, 2016 @07:29AM (#12319301)
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by netheril96 on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:23AM (#12319519)
Do you really think any of these organizations have the power to "regulate" the nuclear weapons of the United States, Russia, or China?
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by gozur88 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:16PM (#12317771)
"No first use" invites attack by anyone who has a stronger conventional military. This is one of those cases where ambiguity is the right course of action - if you say "all our options are on the table, and we'll decide on a case-by-case basis" potential adversaries have to consider the possibility they'll lose even if they win. They're likely to be more circumspect.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by vilhelm_s on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:04AM (#12317914)
Yes, the reason the U.S. has historically not ruled out a first use was to deter a conventional attack (mainly in Europe). At the same time, the Soviet union declared that they would not make a first use (because their conventional army was much stronger anyway). However, now the tables are turned, and NATO has more conventional forces than Russia. (And indeed, Russia changed policy and says that they would use nuclear weapons in response to a conventional attack). Realistically, there is no situation in which the U.S. today would actually make a first use, so they can afford to change their formal policy to reflect that.

At the same time, keeping the policy ambiguous has a cost, namely that the other side will feel more threatened, raising the risk of an accidental nuclear war. (C.f. Able Archer 83).

Ruling out first use is the option that gives the lowest risk of nuclear war. To give the maximal stability, everyone should adopt as restrictive a policy as possible (the ideal example is China, who rule out both first use and use against non-nuclear countries). Such a policy makes the weapons less "useful", in the sense that they only used to deter a nuclear attack and not for "getting away with" weaker conventional forces, but it is safer.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by dingaling on Friday August 19, 2016 @07:54AM (#12319404)
> Realistically, there is no situation in which the U.S. today would actually make a first use

During Operation Desert Storm there was consideration of using nuclear weapons to demolish very-deeply-set bunkers until it was determined that they weren't built under rock sheets. Although technically excellent thanks to Yugoslav and East German expertise, they had been dug-and-covered rather than drilled-out.

A GBU-28 conventional penetrator can punch through about 20 feet of rock, whereas a shallow-detonation 400kT B61-11 will crack structures several hundred feet deeper through shock effects.

The B61-11 remains in the inventory and has now been supplemented by the penetrating B61-12. I wouldn't rule-out first use of either type in the face of suitably challenging targets.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by flukus on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:41AM (#12317995)
What's China's policy if, in a conventional war, someone starts attacking there nuclear facilities?
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by dogma1138 on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:58AM (#12318377)
Define nuclear facilities (reactors, launch silos?).

Under MAD an attack on the nuclear capabilities of a nuclear armed state or any attempt at unilateral disarmament is usually defined as a nuclear attack/first strike. This often interpreted both indirect and indirect means which is why the ABM work the US is been doing over the years in Europe causes such a big mess with the Russians.

The US spends trillion on missile defense, trillions that Russia cannot afford, so Russia is forced to spend it on improving their nuclear delivery capabilities. Russia restarting their investment in their nuclear arms made the US go and say "see Europe, we weren't just fear mongering, they are rearming you need our missile defense" which pushes the Russians even further.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by flukus on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:20AM (#12318639)
I was thinking launch silos when I wrote it, but it's a deeper question now that I think of it.

Could a conventional attack on a power plant and the fallout from it be considered a nuclear attack? What about a nuclear powered air craft carrier?

Is an attack on a nuclear armed submarine, would they be considered an attack on their nuclear capabilities? The attacker might not even know what type of submarine it is.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by dogma1138 on Friday August 19, 2016 @06:13AM (#12319033)
Well when it comes to MAD any attempt to disarm the nuclear capability of your partner in MADness has to be considered as a first strike which would lead to a retaliatory nuclear 2nd strike even if the 1st strike was not nuclear it self.

Like everything in life you have to take it into proportion, if Russia or the US sink a single SSBN that's not exactly nuclear disarmament, if one party launches a preemptive non-nuclear strike against the SSBN fleet at large as well as the fixed and mobile ground based platforms that would likely invoke a very harsh response which traditionally under MAD has to be nuclear because if you do not use your nuclear arsenal while you still have it effectively you've lost it for good.

And if the other party knows or suspects you would not use your nuclear arsenal unless you've been attacked with nuclear or non-conventional non-nuclear weapons first even if the conventional attack is against your nuclear capability they would attempt to disarm you without thinking twice.

MAD works well when you under no circumstances would use your nuclear arsenal first in an offensive manner, but have very clear and public guidelines for nuclear response.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by gozur88 on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:08AM (#12317925)
>Ruling out first use is the option that gives the lowest risk of nuclear war.

I don't believe this is true. You lower the risk that an enemy will misinterpret something as a nuclear attack, but you raise the risk of getting involved in a conventional war that goes nuclear.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by nickff on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:26AM (#12318282)
This is a very interesting (Bayesian?) point.

Probability of enemy nuclear first strike decreased

Probability of enemy conventional first strike increased

Probability of enemy nuclear escalation ?

I am only addressing policy effects on enemies because the policy may be an intentional lie.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by rdtsc on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:41PM (#12317841)
But since nobody has a stronger conventional military, this could be a good propaganda move -- because others can't say "well Americans are beligerant, they could nuke us any day without warning, look! it's right there in their military doctrine, so we have to seek nuclear technology to defend outselves.".

This could also be a potential boost for military contractors since because now we need a stronger conventional military so more, tanks, bombers, drones, etc. If anyone asks why they can say "because our doctrine changed, so a bigger military means more peace".

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by nickff on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:30AM (#12318298)
The Hawks say every change means they need larger and expensive armed forces, and the doves will come up with reasons why the same change requires disarmament. Such debates have not proven very productive.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by chroma on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:10AM (#12317930)
Yes, "no first use" means a nuclear state can be stymied in conventional proxy wars. That's an acceptable trade-off, since it limits escalation. Better to lose a proxy war than to "win" a nuclear exchange.

Also, only an insane attacker would test the limits of "no first use" by invading a nuclear state's sovereign territory. If there's any time to renege on such a policy, that's it. Not to mention: if an enemy invades, your nukes are at risk of falling into their hands.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by yks on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:43PM (#12322910)
Recent events show that "sovereign territory" is a somewhat fluid notion.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by JDDunn9 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:20PM (#12317789)
How about a more general no first strike policy? If you are willing to pre-strike a country, logically they should be willing to pre-pre-strike you. A no first strike policy allows for us to reach a Nash equilibrium.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by ArkyBeagle on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:02AM (#12318770)
Not really - you can't rule out defectors.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by captainmuon on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:29AM (#12318457)
Somewhat related, I've never believed the conventional doctrine of mutual assured destruction.

The way I see it, the only rational thing to do once you have been hit hard by nuclear weapons is to forget your original plan of retaliation and to surrender immediately. Retaliating would only kill more people and potentially render the planet uninhabitable, but would give you no gain.

MAD only works if you tie your own hands. If you make the retaliation absolutely automatic and unstoppable. As far as I know, the only such system that was built was the Soviet "Perimetr" or "Dead Hand" system, which was never completely activated. As long as there is a human component, you will be able to, and rationally have to, turn around once you have taken the hit.

I think the naive story about MAD comes from applying game theory but assuming your strategy is static throughout the whole "game".

Likewise, the main reason we (US, NATO) have not used another nuclear bomb is that we have not been in a "real" war against an opponent where it would make sense. I mean for example an all out land war against Russia on Russian or European territory and/or where US territory is under danger. Where it would make sense to use a nuclear bomb to quickly destroy a huge tank unit or weapons factories, or to bomb the enemy into submission (if you have given up on sparing civilian lives). Once we would be stuck in such a horrible war, a "no first use" doctrine like any peacetime strategy would be up for discussion immediately, IMO.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by Noseshine on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:52AM (#12318546)
Incidentally, I read that "perimeter" - the Soviet automatic MAD system - was actually not meant against the Americans, but against the "hawks" in the Soviet government. Which is why it wasn't publicized. It assured them that the USSR had a way to retaliate in any case - so there was no need to launch nukes right away at the slightest suspicion, but waiting if there actually was an impact somewhere was possible without losing the ability to retaliate. With the "hawks" assured the calmer people now had more time to think, talk, and check data in an emergency and faced less pressure to act immediately.

And to the MAD scenario, I too came to the conclusion that the only sane thing to do if I was someone in the chain of command to launch nukes was

a) Always make your unwavering commitment to launch clear - to everyone, including at home.

b) When it happens, refuse to launch, contradictory to anything people know about you.

You can't tell b) to anyone though, because there is a chance the enemy may find out. It's important to only reveal that you won't ever launch nukes when it actually happens, not before.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by captainmuon on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:49AM (#12318935)
Yeah, the most important thing about deterrence is to make a certain impression to the enemy.

I always found it mind-boggling that the Soviets kept "Perimeter" secret, but the theory you write about makes a lot of sense.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by ArkyBeagle on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:58AM (#12318758)
I think you'd have to follow through in case it didn't turn out that the world was destroyed in the first strike[1] and other nuclear capable actors remained.

[1] there's so much non-information about what would actually happen that the uncertainty is the strongest signal in the channel.

The point of MAD is the "logic" ( that actually inspired Heller to write "Catch-22" ) which is:

Nuclear weapons are no good if you use them. They're only any good if you don't use them.

Played properly, not only is there no nuclear war, there is no conventional large scale war. This happened. We still ran one of the warm spots in the Cold War at the German/Russian border. And nothing actually ever happened.

We could only have stupid and in cases, possibly ruinous proxy wars in Vietnam and Afghanistan (1980 version). That's (globally) better than WWII, conventional or nuclear. Those were not psychologically sustainable. So they ended.

I attribute this to MAD. Any technology which allows us to use one simple koan of bullsh8t to keep from killing each other is a very useful technology.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by deepfriedbits on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:36AM (#12318485)
Nukes were strongly considered during the Korean War due to the massive number of Chinese fighting on the side of the aggressors in that war. MacArthur wanted badly to nuke China or more specifically, Chinese divisions and the threat of nukes helped lure China to the negotiating table when the U.S. wanted to wind down the conflict.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by netheril96 on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:03AM (#12318782)
> I think the naive story about MAD comes from applying game theory but assuming your strategy is static throughout the whole "game".

Care to elaborate?

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by captainmuon on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:44AM (#12318919)
Here I'm using "game theory" in the pop-sci sense, no deeper mathematics. Assume you and your opponent commit to the following strategy:

- If attacked by nuclear weapons, retaliate by completely destroying the enemy with nuclear weapons

- Do everything you can to preserve second-strike ability

Then it follows it is rational to not use nuclear weapons.

So far so good and true, but there is one problem with this argument: if your enemy does use nuclear weapons on you for any reason, is it then still rational to stick to your strategy?

Before the war, you do anything you can to cement your retaliation strategy, to preserve deterrence, MAD, and ultimately peace.

But after the war starts, and once you realize you cannot win anymore, it does not make sense anymore to go through with the second strike. You have nothing to gain. You don't punish your enemy so he doesn't attack you again "next time". If your preparations in cementing your strategy haven't been 100% thorough, and you have a way to stop retaliation, then the logical thing would be to do so and surrender unconditionally (assuming you value preserving life over revenge, when there is nothing to gain militarily anymore).

What I meant with "naive" is that the standard story about MAD assumes a steady state - both sides commit to a strategy, there is no time development, from this it follows that you should not use nuclear weapons ("the only winning move is not to play"). But if you allow the strategy to be a function of time, players can change their mind, and this changes the whole situation.

You no longer have to ask, "what is rational before playing the game" (=> not playing), but "what is rational at every time t >= 0". I believe then it is no longer about being able to second-strike, but about being able to abort the second-strike. If your enemy is in any way able to abort the second-strike (and you are already in an escalated global war, and don't value sparing enemy lives over winning), then the most rational step at t > 0 becomes to nuke the enemy as soon as possible, so they can no longer achieve their goals. If they are rational, they should immediately proceed to surrender.

I believe this "alternative story" is somewhat justified, as at least it was believed at some point by certain decision makers in both west and east militaries - I say that because there were many different nuclear strategies floating around during the cold war, and some were very different than the "Dr. Strangelove" scenario. There were ideas to fight a conventional tank war supported by nukes for example. Another rather spectacular one was (declassified one or two years ago I believe), if the soviets were to declare war and to occupy Berlin, to overkill Berlin with nuclear weapons (-> they can no longer achieve their goal, and you'd take out a significant portion of their tanks)... but of course we were never anywhere near a level of escalation where such a crazy, inhuman plan would have been considered.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by ThrustVectoring on Friday August 19, 2016 @07:00PM (#12324130)
>if your enemy does use nuclear weapons on you for any reason, is it then still rational to stick to your strategy?

Yup. If you're the kind of agent that wouldn't stick to your strategy of retaliation, then that changes the best strategies for other players in a way that harms you.

Interestingly, there's a significant amount of "removing the steering wheel" going on in terms of nuclear strategy. I remember reading that British nuclear submarine commanders would have a sealed envelope, to be opened and read only in case nuclear war destroys the British Government. It contains one of four orders - retaliate with nuclear weapons, do not retaliate, try to place yourself under American command, or to use your own judgement.

The very interesting part is that it convinces others that nuking London might automatically mean that they get hit back, but does not obligate Britain to actually making nuclear war worse.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letters_of_last_resort

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by jjcc on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:04PM (#12317727)
The principle is beyond the Nuclear policy. It's a famous winning strategy in game theory called "tit for tat" which can be considered as the foundation of all moral principles of human society.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by Xcelerate on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:03AM (#12318057)
The funny thing is that for the iterated prisoner's dilemma, tit for tat is less optimal than an extortionist strategy. I don't know what this entails for the moral principles of human society though haha.

https://www.edge.org/conversation/william_h_press-freeman_dy...

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by samcheng on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:15AM (#12318094)
We're not likely to iterate on thermonuclear war, though!
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by Xcelerate on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:31AM (#12318145)
Touché
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by oxide on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:42AM (#12317996)
does the concept of Mutually Assured Destruction have roots in game theory? or does the concept itself simply tie back into tit for tat?
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by aidenn0 on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:22AM (#12318265)
The person credited with creating the term was a mathematician, (and also extraordinarily hawkish). He was almost certainly aware of Nash's work, as he coauthored a book proving the existence of Nash equilibria for zero-sum games prior to Nash's more general proof:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann#Mutual_assure...

[edit]

As a note, I can't find a date for Von Neumann coining the MAD term. It seems likely to me that it would predate Nash's work, though as I said earlier, the existence of such equilibria was already well known (It was jut not proven that for large classes of non-zero-sum games there must exist at least one such equilibrium, which was Nash's contribution).

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by gizmo686 on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:02AM (#12318053)
I have never seen the phrasing "mutually assured destruction" in game theory (outside of nuclear references). However, outside of edge cases, it is the same concept as a Nash equilibrium. Specifically, it is a strategy where defecting leads to a worse outcome for both parties.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by ianunruh on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:09PM (#12317749)
> Firstly, it is important to recall that in the entire span since the United States acquired nuclear weapons it has not seen fit to use them.

Uhhh, did the author forget about 1945?

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by ubernostrum on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:44PM (#12317848)
Looks like it's been corrected, but there are people who try to exclude the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings due to the significant difference between those weapons (usually calling them "atomic bombs") and the later classes of boosted-fission and finally fission-fusion thermonuclear devices ("hydrogen bombs") which formed the bulk of the Cold War nuclear arsenal on both sides.

Not saying it's correct to try to sweep the WWII bombings under the rug that way, but it is a thing I've seen people try to do.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by masteryupa_ on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:21PM (#12317791)
Apologies for the miss-type, the error has been corrected:

"Firstly, it is important to recall that in the entire span since the United States acquired nuclear weapons, outside the two instances in Nagasaki and Hiroshima, it has not seen fit to use them."

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by SilasX on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:27AM (#12317969)
"Other than the death of her husband, Mrs. Lincoln enjoyed the play."
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by madgar on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:55AM (#12318028)
Yeah because avoiding nuclear holocaust during the Cold War was a walk in the park and definitely not worth highlighting /s
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by DHMO on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:53PM (#12317872)
And: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_weapons_tests_...

And others have also set off the bomb: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_weapons_tests

Granted, weapons testing is a little different than intentional use in war against an enemy.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by pluma on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:00AM (#12318764)
"a little"
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by duncan_bayne on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:25PM (#12324431)
Not as little a difference as you might hope, in the case of atmospheric testing.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_testing_at_Bikini_At...

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by Animats on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:13AM (#12318084)
There's a new argument for enacting this as legislation, and requiring the permission of Congress for first use of nuclear weapons. Trump might be elected.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by duncan_bayne on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:07PM (#12324371)
You get that it's Clinton, not Trump, with the established history of starting and encouraging wars?

Not that I'd vote for either of them, but it bothers me when people claim that a Trump presidency would be any more dangerous in this regard then if Clinton were elected.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by solotronics on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:44AM (#12318002)
I imagine it could be a tactic to launch a single ICBM from a submarine at yourself to give cause to launch a nuclear offense. In reality it doesn't matter who shoots first against a determined enemy who is willing to execute a false flag.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by pluma on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:02AM (#12318776)
Or you could just launch the nukes anyway because if there is a thermonuclear war it doesn't matter what asshole started it for which reason unless there's someone alive to hold you accountable when the dust has settled.

Only the worst kind of human would ever actually use a nuclear weapon in any scenario.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by thomasruns on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:02AM (#12318384)
I believe you're looking for infowars or some other bs site where conspiracy nutjobs hang out.