Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine
by dingaling on Friday August 19, 2016 @07:54AM
(#12319404)
> Realistically, there is no situation in which the U.S. today would actually make a first use
During Operation Desert Storm there was consideration of using nuclear weapons to demolish very-deeply-set bunkers until it was determined that they weren't built under rock sheets. Although technically excellent thanks to Yugoslav and East German expertise, they had been dug-and-covered rather than drilled-out.
A GBU-28 conventional penetrator can punch through about 20 feet of rock, whereas a shallow-detonation 400kT B61-11 will crack structures several hundred feet deeper through shock effects.
The B61-11 remains in the inventory and has now been supplemented by the penetrating B61-12. I wouldn't rule-out first use of either type in the face of suitably challenging targets.
During Operation Desert Storm there was consideration of using nuclear weapons to demolish very-deeply-set bunkers until it was determined that they weren't built under rock sheets. Although technically excellent thanks to Yugoslav and East German expertise, they had been dug-and-covered rather than drilled-out.
A GBU-28 conventional penetrator can punch through about 20 feet of rock, whereas a shallow-detonation 400kT B61-11 will crack structures several hundred feet deeper through shock effects.
The B61-11 remains in the inventory and has now been supplemented by the penetrating B61-12. I wouldn't rule-out first use of either type in the face of suitably challenging targets.