News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by flukus on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:41AM (#12317995)
What's China's policy if, in a conventional war, someone starts attacking there nuclear facilities?
Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by dogma1138 on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:58AM (#12318377)
Define nuclear facilities (reactors, launch silos?).

Under MAD an attack on the nuclear capabilities of a nuclear armed state or any attempt at unilateral disarmament is usually defined as a nuclear attack/first strike. This often interpreted both indirect and indirect means which is why the ABM work the US is been doing over the years in Europe causes such a big mess with the Russians.

The US spends trillion on missile defense, trillions that Russia cannot afford, so Russia is forced to spend it on improving their nuclear delivery capabilities. Russia restarting their investment in their nuclear arms made the US go and say "see Europe, we weren't just fear mongering, they are rearming you need our missile defense" which pushes the Russians even further.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by flukus on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:20AM (#12318639)
I was thinking launch silos when I wrote it, but it's a deeper question now that I think of it.

Could a conventional attack on a power plant and the fallout from it be considered a nuclear attack? What about a nuclear powered air craft carrier?

Is an attack on a nuclear armed submarine, would they be considered an attack on their nuclear capabilities? The attacker might not even know what type of submarine it is.

Re:In Defence of a ‘No First Use’ Nuclear Doctrine by dogma1138 on Friday August 19, 2016 @06:13AM (#12319033)
Well when it comes to MAD any attempt to disarm the nuclear capability of your partner in MADness has to be considered as a first strike which would lead to a retaliatory nuclear 2nd strike even if the 1st strike was not nuclear it self.

Like everything in life you have to take it into proportion, if Russia or the US sink a single SSBN that's not exactly nuclear disarmament, if one party launches a preemptive non-nuclear strike against the SSBN fleet at large as well as the fixed and mobile ground based platforms that would likely invoke a very harsh response which traditionally under MAD has to be nuclear because if you do not use your nuclear arsenal while you still have it effectively you've lost it for good.

And if the other party knows or suspects you would not use your nuclear arsenal unless you've been attacked with nuclear or non-conventional non-nuclear weapons first even if the conventional attack is against your nuclear capability they would attempt to disarm you without thinking twice.

MAD works well when you under no circumstances would use your nuclear arsenal first in an offensive manner, but have very clear and public guidelines for nuclear response.