News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by dforrestwilson on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:44AM (#12114486)
For anyone looking for a primer on jihad, and the influence of Saudi Wahhabism here is a great read: https://www.amazon.com/Future-Jihad-Terrorist-Strategies-aga...

Walid Phares wrote 10 years ago that Europe was going to experience a wave of attacks, and also foresaw the Arab Spring.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by retox on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:52AM (#12114739)
To be fair a prediction of unrest in the middle east/Africa doesn't require much insight. I predict there will be unrest for the next 50 years at least.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by imglorp on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:01AM (#12114780)
It doesn't help there are 1st world influences mucking up the natural ecosystem there. For example, US attempting to overthrow Assad is not a natural process.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/24/world/middleeast/us-relies...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by varjag on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:27AM (#12115202)
Leaving aside how much of your statement is true, there is no such thing as natural process in international relations.

The only concept approaching that would be social darwinism, but from that perspective it would be quite "natural".

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jbooth on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:33AM (#12115239)
Dude. We talking about animals here? Their natural ecosystem? People deserve more respect than that.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by trelltron on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:50AM (#12115361)
Ecosystem: a complex network or interconnected system.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by hx87 on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:57AM (#12115399)
There's hardly anything "natural" about human ecosystems, or human relationships for that matter.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by 0xfeba on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:10AM (#12115488)
Depends on your definition of natural. The religious claim of 'special creation', esp. w.r.t. humans has it easy here:

> existing in nature and not made or caused by people : coming from nature

This definition really stems from man's early assumption that we are distinctly "different" from all other natural things.

But reality tells us otherwise: People are a part of nature; they are natural. It's easier to discuss in terms of what isn't the same instead of what is the same. And that is, we are the smartest known species (being the sole species with self-consciousness is still up for debate). Therefore everything people do is natural.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by hx87 on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:44AM (#12115736)
So either everything humans do is natural or nothing humans do is natural. Either way, it's incorrect to say that 1st world actions in the Middle East are any more "unnatural" than what the indigenous people do.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by imglorp on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:06PM (#12115908)
That was kinda my point. As long as they're being okay neighbors and keeping the human rights violations in line, IMHO countries deserve self determination without the superpowers bullying via overthrowing (Assad)--or just plain invading (eg Ukraine).
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jbooth on Monday July 18, 2016 @01:29PM (#12116587)
That's a reasonable point (although it's not like Assad is short on human rights violations), but implying there's some sort of "natural line of development" that would have happened without interaction with the west really strikes me as (unintentionally) racist.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by imglorp on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:19PM (#12118117)
No, I was making an obtuse reference to non-interference. Perhaps a poor metaphor.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by g8oz on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:06PM (#12115904)
For those who don't know Walid Phares was a high ranking political official in a Christian religious militia responsible for civilian massacres during Lebanon's civil war. Now he's a favorite Islam "scholar" for right-wing reactionaries in the U.S.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by whoopdedo on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:21PM (#12116019)
He may be a demagogue. But is his analysis wrong?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by aburan28 on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:17AM (#12113802)
If Saudi Arabia is linked to 9/11 we need to have a serious look at the past 15 years and reevaluate our entire foreign policy justification
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:36AM (#12114033)
I hate to sound confronting, but anyone living in a western counrty which leadership sees these documents as the reason to reevaluate its relationship with Saudi Arabia should be scared by his leadership's incompetence:

Those documents aren't needed to see that the whole Saudi Establishment is the no. 1 reason for jihadist terrorism. Just look at the massive investments the Saudis made since the 1950s to recruite, edjucate and influence muslim clerics basically everywhere in the world. And boy, need I say that civil rights wasn't on their curriculum?!

The Saud Family wants the radicalization of Islam for power reasons that are comparable to the situation of the Papal States and catholic influence over christian countries hundreds of years ago. It's not Islam that is cancerous, it is the Saud Family.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by estefan on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:12AM (#12114156)
This doco (Bitter Lake) suggests they don't want radicalisation at all:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p02gyz6b/adam-curtis-bi...

It claims the Saud family needed to appease conservative clerics to maintain power, so that's why they sponsored all these fanatical clerics. They kicked the can down the road and now their chickens are coming home to roost.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:23AM (#12114619)
As have stated other film critics [1] this documentation takes a rather one-sided approach in that it's basically the fault of the west (and of the USSR).

It seem to lack fact checking and leaves out one of the main issues surrounding modern arabic history: the delayed formation of nation-states and the threat modernism posed to existing, usually aristocratic power structures.

Specifically Saudi-Arabia felt threatened by movements like Pan-Arabism and Ba'athism and used religeous radicalism as an ideology to counter them.

Yes, the cold-war factions quickly found their adversaries on either side but it doesn't take a grain away from the pile of guilt the Saudi Establishment has amassed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Lake_(film)#Reception

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:39AM (#12115697)
> As have stated other film critics [1] this documentation takes a rather one-sided approach in that it's basically the fault of the west (and of the USSR).

This is also a major cultural problem to overcome for Muslims before they can be able to build enduring and prospering societies.

The thing is that every major power constantly meddles in the affairs of everyone else and it will never end, that's for sure. The Russians do it to the West, the West to the Russians, same as the Chinese, the Japanese and Indians do.

Yet these societies are not constantly on the verge of collapse and total chaos.

It is because these societies are more resilient to outside influence, because members of these societies feel more strongly connected to their government and to other members of their societies.

On the other hand in many Muslim societies I see tribal attitudes, one clan against all other clans. One Muslim group might even declare another Muslim group as an enemy on the basis of the smallest imaginable disagreement and start total war. No wonder their governments can be toppled and controlled from the outside if many don't feel a strong connection to their own nation and people.

Here this belief that all bad that has happened to you in your life is primarily caused by the US, the Soviets or more generally the infidels gives them an easy way to redirect their energy towards useless fighting (often among each other) instead of working together to improve their own societies.

This is a bad motivator for progress and nothing good or useful will ever come out of it.

If you face outside meddling then work hard on strengthening your own society so you can handle that stress, because it will never, ever stop.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:41AM (#12128516)
> this belief that all bad that has happened to you in your life is primarily caused by the US, the Soviets or more generally the infidels gives them an easy way to redirect their energy

Exactly! In general, everything is the fault of the west/infidels. You see this in nowadays Turkey. And that alone says a lot about the state of muslim countries, since Turkey used to be a beacon of progress (Genocide aside).

I think Atatürk is rolling over in his grave for quite some years now.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arethuza on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:35AM (#12114664)
From what I can see pretty much every analysis of something like the recent war in Afghanistan has its own perspective and it's only by reading different accounts that you can get any idea of what actually happened.

[e.g. I've read multiple accounts of the "why can't the Paras install a washing machine in a hospital" incident - each from wildly different perspectives].

I guess this need to get different perspective might be obvious to trained historian - but my degree is in CS :-)

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:05AM (#12115068)
> the delayed formation of nation-states

Do you think that between the British, the French, the Russians, and the Ottomans all controlling the region, the development of nation-states may have been delayed by understandable reasons.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:32AM (#12128466)
I think so. Or to put it in another perspective: Nations often (if not mostly or everytime) came into being by an outside threat.

USA = the British England = The French/Catholic Church Germany = France Poland = Germany and Russia

and so on. Threats make possible that people see an "us". I very much like the term "imagined communities" (Benedict Anderson) in this regard.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arethuza on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:09AM (#12114349)
I can give a strong recommendation for Inside the Kingdom by Robert Lacey - someone mentioned it the last time I recommended Bitter Lake on HN.

http://www.robertlacey.com/?q=book/inside-kingdom

[NB Bitter Lake is awesome for both content and style].

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:56AM (#12114309)
They are still part of the problem if they sponsor these fanatics.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by estefan on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:09AM (#12114351)
Yeah absolutely, but the doco argues they aren't doing it to create some parallel of Catholicism, but rather as a way to appease the extremists who could have toppled them from power 50 years ago. The trouble is, those schools have now created a load of brainwashed idiots who are now causing trouble.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:19AM (#12114393)
It is one thing if you spread internally crazy ideologies or if you spend considerable resources to go out there and try to subvert every society you possibly can.

Saudi education literally teaches children that they must wage jihad against the infidels (to spread their faith) and that's after 9/11 when they supposedly reviewed their textbooks for children to remove all texts that might spread hate.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05...

I say if that's the only way the Saud family can hold onto power then it's not worth supporting them.

These guys have done more to make Islam look bad than anyone else in the last decades combined.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by afarrell on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:03AM (#12114553)
> Who do you think will be in power if the Saudis aren't

The Hashemites

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by tt44 on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:58AM (#12114539)
> I say if that's the only way the Saud family can hold onto power then it's not worth supporting them.

Who do you think will be in power if the Saudis aren't?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:45AM (#12128553)
Why I oppose this view completely (please don't take this personally, I mean what the movie conveys) apart from leaving out the question of Arabian Nationality: You don't need to spread Wahabism globally to quite some local clerics in your country. But the latter is what the Saudis spent much effort in. For decades they've flown in Clerics or Soon-To-Be-Clerics from countries all over the world, putting them in their religous universities for some years and then sending them back as a measure to spread radicalism into other countries.

Boko Haram is direct descendent of this policy.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by ljf on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:53AM (#12114519)
A most excellent documentary, well worth a viewing.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by _yosefk on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:38AM (#12114682)
Islam obviously doesn't equal jihad as proven by >1000 years of history, but do you think civil rights are "on Iran's curriculum", to pick a Muslim country as far from Saudi Arabia both religiously and politically as possible?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by cm2187 on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:37AM (#12114036)
I don't know is Saudi Arabia sponsored directly 9/11 but what is clear is that Saudi Arabia is the main sponsor across the world of wahabism/sunni extremism, of which Al Quaeda, ISIS, etc are the direct offsprings.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by semi-extrinsic on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:56AM (#12114533)
Some of the Saudi royal family ( /= Saudi Arabia) appear to have sponsored 9/11, at least indirectly. On the official level, they stopped giving the US intelligence on Bin Laden in the mid 90's, since they knew that if caught, he would spill the beans on a lot of Saudi dark deeds, past and present.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by mtgx on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:52AM (#12114512)
I'm not sure of Gary Johnson's position on this, but I know Jill Stein agrees that Saudi Arabia should not be US' partner anymore, and that US should stop arming Saudi Arabia.

Even Bernie Sanders wanted US to remain a partner of Saudi Arabia to "get rid of ISIS", but I don't think he ever thought it through too much.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by ZenoArrow on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:26AM (#12114898)
> "Even Bernie Sanders wanted US to remain a partner of Saudi Arabia to "get rid of ISIS", but I don't think he ever thought it through too much."

Sanders has built his popularity on his domestic policies. His record on foreign policy is somewhat less stellar.

http://www.alternet.org/election-2016/bernie-sanders-troubli...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by chatmasta on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:54AM (#12114525)
There is one mainstream candidate who is against an alliance with Saudi Arabia, and his name is Donald Trump.

(But but but he's a racist!!!!)

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by semi-extrinsic on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:58AM (#12114540)
s/a racist/completely unfit for running even a small town, let alone a large country/
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by douche on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:16AM (#12114595)
Yet perfectly competent at running a multi-billion dollar corporation... The cognitive dissonance is strong.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by semi-extrinsic on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:56PM (#12116312)
Actually, evidence says he's not. He started in 1987 with $1 billion, and has tripled that in ~30 years. But simply putting the initial investment into index funds would have made a 13x ROI. So he's significantly underperformed the stock market. In fact, he's barely kept up with inflation. That's far from perfectly competent, any money manager with that record would be a laughing stock.

http://fortune.com/2015/08/20/donald-trump-index-funds/

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by hx87 on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:38AM (#12115686)
If I ran my company with the same "competence" Trump ran his, I would have gone out of business a long time ago.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by busterarm on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:16AM (#12114849)
His mom was and his children are, that's for sure.
[dead]
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:06AM (#12115074)
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by saiya-jin on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:31AM (#12113850)
i suspect this is not a shocking story to government, so I wouldn't expect much change here...
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by raverbashing on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:54AM (#12113911)
If?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by rado on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:09AM (#12113950)
Justification?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by drjesusphd on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:31AM (#12113846)
You've been listening to the wrong people for the past 15 years if you think 9/11 had anything to do with US foreign policy.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by nitrogen on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:54AM (#12113912)
You have the logic of the parent's comment reversed. However, a case can be made that US support for the Taliban against the USSR contributed in some way.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jonnybgood on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:22AM (#12114876)
The US didn't support the Taliban against the USSR. The Taliban came in to existence after the Afghan-Soviet war. Matter of fact, many of the Mujahideen supported by the US during the war later fought against Taliban.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by armenarmen on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:54AM (#12113914)
eh?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by ZenoArrow on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:40AM (#12114053)
If I've understood correctly, the point the GP was making was that 9/11 attacks were used as a cover for the foreign policy decisions rather than attempting to hold the perpetrators to account.

For example, what did Iraq have to do with 9/11? Nothing. What did Libya have to do with 9/11? Nothing. What did Yemen have to do with 9/11? Nothing. Did Guantanamo help keep the US safer? By many accounts, it mainly acted as fuel for the fire.

By declaring a 'war on terror' rather than targeting the specific groups involved in the 9/11 attacks, the US can now be engaged in perpetual war. How is that going to help make the US safer?

The actions only really make sense when you take into account the military-industrial complex and the desire for imperialism. 9/11 was just a convenient excuse used to push forward on those fronts.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Shivetya on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:57AM (#12114107)
The US has been in perpetual war ever since WW2. They just rebrand it as the times move on. That said, if anyone wants to trace the strife in the Middle East to its rightful owners just go look at European Colonialism and their slicing, dicing,and merging, of different groups in the early 1900s.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:37AM (#12114942)
While colonialism certainly didn't help, the Middle East has been a sliced, diced, merged region of perpetual war since the beginning of recorded history, and undoubtedly before.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by CelestialTeapot on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:48AM (#12114724)
The US has been in perpetual war ever since its founding.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_the_Uni...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:53AM (#12114292)
If the West would have bombed Saudi Arabia instead of Afghanistan and would have taken their oil we might be better off today.

Saudia Arabia is notorious for sponsoring mosques here in the EU that only ever seem to produce Salafi radicals and Jihadists which is in contrast to other Muslim communities that seem to have less of that problem.

Some countries in the EU already banned this influence from Saudi Arabia as it is widely considered as harmful to our societies.

But there are also some Muslim countries that did the same as they also consider their ideology as aggressive and inherently dangerous. (some of the Central Asian Muslim countries)

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Eutow on Monday July 18, 2016 @12:56PM (#12116311)
>If the West would have bombed Saudi Arabia instead of Afghanistan and would have taken their oil we might be better off today.

We never learn, do we?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:30PM (#12118162)
What would you propose? Leaving a country alone that backstabs us and incites fanatics to attack us while pretending to be our friend?

Just look at what resources they have and what they potentially could do with it if they openly declared that the West is their enemy.

I'm quite sure that no one will allow Saudi Arabia to use its resources against the West. If they do we'll take all they have away from them.

By the way: It is absolutely legitimate to retaliate with force when you are under attack by another nation.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by y04nn on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:51AM (#12120823)
The problem is if you attack Saudi Arabia, most if not all Arab countries will be on the side of SA, which would start a major conflict.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jacquesm on Monday July 18, 2016 @03:06AM (#12113587)
"Much of the information in the 28 pages is not new and has been mentioned in previously released documents on the 9/11 investigation. As such, the public release of these suppressed pages is unlikely to precipitate major changes in the relationship between the United States and the Saudi government. In a statement issued on Friday, the Saudi Embassy in the United States said that it “welcomes the release” of the suppressed pages, saying that they exonerate Riyadh of any direct role in the attacks."

If so then I really don't get why they would suppress these at all.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by divbyzer0 on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:22AM (#12113818)
It was likely suppressed as it would have drawn attention away from Iraq, and the insinuated link between Iraq and 9-11.

The fallback argument was WMD, bring democracy and prosperity.

Instead we got ISIS.

I was very surprised that this was released as it adds to the evidence that the decision to attack Iraq and to dismantle its security services was based on lies and deception.

The timing of the release, when the repercussions of creating political and military instability in the region are becoming more frequent in Europe and the US is what surprises me the most. Perhaps the US has reduced its energy dependence on the middle east sufficiently to begin focusing on Saudi Arabia?

With this release and the Chilcot report, the leaders of US/UK have created a serious deficit in credibility and trust.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jacquesm on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:28AM (#12113836)
> With this release and the Chilcot report, the leaders of US/UK have created a serious deficit in credibility and trust.

I don't feel any different before / after. As far as I'm concerned the whole thing was a set-up from day #1 (the Iraq war, not 9/11, obviously), after Dr. Kelly's death and the Plame affair there was very little doubt we were being railroaded.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by lmmlzxx on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:20AM (#12113980)
I personally think there is enough evidence to at least begin inquiry into the possibility of foreknowledge within the Bush administration and/or some US intelligence agencies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks_advance-k...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arethuza on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:11AM (#12114357)
There is an interesting book by a former US prosecutor arguing that there is a case for charging G.W. Bush with murder:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Prosecution_of_George_W._B...

It wouldn't surprise me if there are private prosecutions of Tony Blair in the UK along similar lines [NB I don't think there is any chance of an actual prosecution of GWB in the US].

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by im4w1l on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:47AM (#12113890)
ISIS' rise to prominence happened under Obama, a long time after the invasion of Iraq.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by nl on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:16AM (#12113971)
ISIS' rise to prominence happened under Obama, a long time after the invasion of Iraq.

Absolutely true, technically. Also a completely useless and misleading statement.

The ISIS group splintered and grew out of the Al-Qaeda in Iraq after its defeat during the Anbar Awakening[1]. Ironically, the Iraqi goverment's behaviour towards the awakening groups[2] directly contributed to this.

Many of the same people involved in Al-Qaeda in Iraq, the Anbar Awakening groups as well as the Ba'ath party ended up fighting for ISIS.

There is plenty of blame to go around, but the range of possible actions and outcomes Obama had was much smaller compared to that Bush had.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anbar_Awakening

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sons_of_Iraq

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jacquesm on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:08AM (#12113947)
ISIS could only rise to prominence because of the power-vacuum the Iraq war left behind.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by im4w1l on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:19AM (#12113977)
The power vaccuum happened when the troops were withdrawn.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jacquesm on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:36AM (#12114034)
The troops would have been withdrawn sooner or later anyway, this was something that was known before the Iraq war was even started. Unless you want to argue that the US had plans for a permanent occupation of Iraq after getting rid of Saddam.

Please do not try to re-write history in a way that suits your narrative, it is pointless and counterproductive.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:57AM (#12114762)
Define "permanent" and "occupation". You mean like the way the U.S. still has troops in Europe after 75 years, and Korea after 60? Do those count as "occupations"?

There's a lot of room between keeping support troops on hand and a full-scale military occupation.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by eumoria on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:24AM (#12114887)
US troops do absolutely nothing on Korea and Europe other than as stand-by and a geopolitical deterrent. The troops in Iraq were acting as the fighting force for the official regime. These are very VERY different things. US toops were occupying Iraq, they are not occupying South Korea.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:31AM (#12114917)
That's more or less my point, isn't it? It would have been possible to (attempt to) hand over responsibility to the Iraqi military while still keeping troops there in case things went south (as they did).
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Noseshine on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @01:35PM (#12123278)
This NYT article has some very interesting background:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/22/world/middleeast/united-st...

After reading the article and learning some of the intricacies I really don't feel ready to blame anyone in particular. It seems to be a "system outcome" of the interactions and the (local) conditions.

Let's not forget a lot of Irakis wanted the US to leave, fully and completely:

> Possibilities being discussed are for some troops to return in 2012, an option preferred by some Iraqi politicians who want to claim credit for ending what many here still call an occupation,...

That "some" is about the politicians, the mood in the streets wasn't just "some" people who wanted all foreign soldiers to leave, if I remember anything from the news we heard at that time.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by hx87 on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:40AM (#12115699)
Given the state of the Iraqi military, things would have gone south immediately, and the troops would never leave.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @01:22PM (#12116523)
Would they, though? I think it is a plausible argument that things would have been less likely to go south if the opposing force knew the U.S. forces were there to step in if necessary. While things might still have ended badly, I think there's no question that pulling the U.S. troops out so soon made the collapse a certainty.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by brbsix on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:28PM (#12117879)
At the very least, ISIS would not have been armed to the same extent by fleeing Iraqi security forces.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by im4w1l on Monday July 18, 2016 @01:35PM (#12116649)
You only get to shift blame to your predecessor if you predict and warn about the unavoidable problems and state your plan for how to handle it.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by retrogradeorbit on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:06AM (#12113784)
"Much" is not "all" and the released documents are heavily redacted. So a large amount of the information has been scrubbed. This seems to me more about controlling public opinion about the documents than releasing any information.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by herghost on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:23AM (#12115177)
We're in the age where everyone brings their own facts to the table - even when the facts are the same, they take the facts and state that they support their position even as the other guy is claiming the opposite.

It doesn't even matter what they say anymore, as the realisation has set in that people won't actually read them - they'll wait for the headline and the related quotes from affected people and stop there.

So as long as you get there with a quote that states you're exonerated, it makes no difference what's actually been found.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by saturn_vk on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:05AM (#12113778)
I'm guessing they've suppressed them to prevent the public from wanting to start a war with the saudis
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jacquesm on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:39AM (#12113873)
Now why would anybody want to start a war with a country not directly involved in an attack. Oh, wait.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:39AM (#12114955)
Ah, yes, the "BOOOOSH WANTED TO STEAL THEIR OIL" theory.

So, exactly how much of their oil did the U.S. actually "steal"? You have a barrel figure for that? A rough estimate will do.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by acqq on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:00AM (#12115053)
"Why we did it"

https://vimeo.com/88670339

Oil. As in for "free market."

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:04AM (#12115065)
I'm not going to go watch a propaganda video.

How much oil did the U.S. steal from Iraq?

Do you have an answer to that question or not?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by acqq on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:23PM (#12117839)
It's your turn now to give the reference for your claim, I've given mine. Alternatively, you'd have to specify what actually from that documentary isn't true, and given the high possibility of the authors to be sued, I'm quite sure they double checked their sources.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:43PM (#12118453)
What "claim"? That the U.S. didn't "steal Iraq's oil"?

No, I don't have to watch your video to determine that this didn't happen. Nor does anyone else.

Edit: can you point out to me on this chart where all the "stolen oil" shows up?

https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=PET&s=M...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by acqq on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @12:09AM (#12126832)
See the video, the most of Iraq oil was taken over by western petrol companies and physically sold to Europe. And that's why you won't see much in the chart you quote.

The video is much more nuanced than you imagine, as the goal was never to "steal the oil to bring it directly to the US" but merely to "control" the oil.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by Turing_Machine on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:13AM (#12115512)
I'm assuming from the down mods that no one actually has an answer for this. :-)

Here are the facts: if the goal was to "steal their oil", that could easily have been accomplished.

1) Secure oil fields and terminals. 2) Fly in Texans and Okies to run everything. 3) Shoot anyone who approaches. Leave the rest of the country to fend for itself.

That didn't happen. Why not?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by im4w1l on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:48AM (#12113898)
Reddit asked a very important question regarding that: So why is it being released then? And why now?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jbmorgado on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:06AM (#12113940)
... and instead start a war with Iraq.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by ralfd on Monday July 18, 2016 @03:56AM (#12113741)
> "exonerate Riyadh of any direct role in the attacks"

And indirectly?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by venomsnake on Monday July 18, 2016 @04:24AM (#12113821)
You are expected to read the PR pieces, not think about their content. Critical thinking is dangerous and sign of subversion of the system.

My opinion is that a branch of their government has gone rogue. But that puts SA elite in very uncomfortable position - their later kings are reformers and progressives (baby steps, baby steps) with somewhat strained relationship with the clergy. But they either cannot control their government - implying they are weak or admit they are involved - which is casus belli for the US.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by nerthus on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:39AM (#12114243)
Isn't the right question to ask, why the information was released now? Who can win by publishing a report, showing the wrongdoing of a former leadership?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:28AM (#12114431)
I'm sure Trump will profit the most from that in the upcoming election.

Makes you think about how much in control of its own government the current leadership really is.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by wfunction on Monday July 18, 2016 @05:16AM (#12113969)
So there was [1] in 2004 and [2] in 2009. I'm not sure what I'm supposed to take away from the recent news now... it seems like it's just confirming what people already pretty much knew? Or is there surprising new information released?

[1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3815179.stm

[2] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/24/world/middleeast/24saudi.h...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by rhizome on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:12AM (#12114153)
Emptywheel went over the already-knews and new-news pretty concisely the other day:

https://www.emptywheel.net/2016/07/15/fbi-established-saudi-...

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by nxzero on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:07AM (#12114813)
Given the topic, curious if anyone knows anything about "Able Danger" operations:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Able_Danger

Or the rapid decline of terrorism (80%) following the end of the Cold War: https://www.start.umd.edu/gtd/

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by jtlien1 on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:33AM (#12115236)
Have you seen anyone interview Norm Mineta about what really happened in the Situation Room on 9/11? He was fired and exiled practically when people started to point out his damning statements about what happened in the Situation Room when the Pentagon was seeing a plane approach. Or how about the 66 video tapes confiscated by the FBI that could show what really did hit the Pentagon?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by dopamean on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:44AM (#12115310)
Are you seriously implying that it wasn't a plane that hit the Pentagon?
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arca_vorago on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:49AM (#12114730)
I'll just say this: never forget who created the house of Saud in the first place. They were puppets from the start and still are.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by AlexCoventry on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:13AM (#12114829)
Who do you have in mind?

From a glance at the wikipedia page, the history looks intricate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Saud

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by mk89 on Monday July 18, 2016 @09:40AM (#12114958)
Could you please articulate? I am totally ignorant about it, and after the release of this document, I am getting more curious.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by douche on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:10AM (#12115095)
Ibn Saud essentially came to power as a local strongman, supported by the British, set up in opposition to the Ottoman-supported faction during the First World War. Saud originally controlled the Red Sea bordering portion of Arabia, which was astride the sea route through the Suez to India.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_Saud#Rise_to_power

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by mk89 on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:43AM (#12142418)
Thanks a lot! I finally had time to read the article.

I always wonder if that was short term thinking, or if nowadays there is still something going on. We all know that empires fall, therefore, it might be that maybe at that time the UK didn't expect Saudi Arabia to become so powerful as it is nowadays. It's like playing monopoly: you help X to destroy Y, which you don't like, but then X becomes so powerful that it starts to be a pain in the ass.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by hx87 on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:41AM (#12115717)
Ibn Saud initially controlled the Najd, the central portion of the peninsula. The Hashemites held the Red Sea coast.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by shitgoose on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:11AM (#12115103)
it is probably about Zionists ruling the world, who else...