News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by estefan on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:12AM (#12114156)
This doco (Bitter Lake) suggests they don't want radicalisation at all:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p02gyz6b/adam-curtis-bi...

It claims the Saud family needed to appease conservative clerics to maintain power, so that's why they sponsored all these fanatical clerics. They kicked the can down the road and now their chickens are coming home to roost.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:23AM (#12114619)
As have stated other film critics [1] this documentation takes a rather one-sided approach in that it's basically the fault of the west (and of the USSR).

It seem to lack fact checking and leaves out one of the main issues surrounding modern arabic history: the delayed formation of nation-states and the threat modernism posed to existing, usually aristocratic power structures.

Specifically Saudi-Arabia felt threatened by movements like Pan-Arabism and Ba'athism and used religeous radicalism as an ideology to counter them.

Yes, the cold-war factions quickly found their adversaries on either side but it doesn't take a grain away from the pile of guilt the Saudi Establishment has amassed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Lake_(film)#Reception

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @11:39AM (#12115697)
> As have stated other film critics [1] this documentation takes a rather one-sided approach in that it's basically the fault of the west (and of the USSR).

This is also a major cultural problem to overcome for Muslims before they can be able to build enduring and prospering societies.

The thing is that every major power constantly meddles in the affairs of everyone else and it will never end, that's for sure. The Russians do it to the West, the West to the Russians, same as the Chinese, the Japanese and Indians do.

Yet these societies are not constantly on the verge of collapse and total chaos.

It is because these societies are more resilient to outside influence, because members of these societies feel more strongly connected to their government and to other members of their societies.

On the other hand in many Muslim societies I see tribal attitudes, one clan against all other clans. One Muslim group might even declare another Muslim group as an enemy on the basis of the smallest imaginable disagreement and start total war. No wonder their governments can be toppled and controlled from the outside if many don't feel a strong connection to their own nation and people.

Here this belief that all bad that has happened to you in your life is primarily caused by the US, the Soviets or more generally the infidels gives them an easy way to redirect their energy towards useless fighting (often among each other) instead of working together to improve their own societies.

This is a bad motivator for progress and nothing good or useful will ever come out of it.

If you face outside meddling then work hard on strengthening your own society so you can handle that stress, because it will never, ever stop.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:41AM (#12128516)
> this belief that all bad that has happened to you in your life is primarily caused by the US, the Soviets or more generally the infidels gives them an easy way to redirect their energy

Exactly! In general, everything is the fault of the west/infidels. You see this in nowadays Turkey. And that alone says a lot about the state of muslim countries, since Turkey used to be a beacon of progress (Genocide aside).

I think Atatürk is rolling over in his grave for quite some years now.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arethuza on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:35AM (#12114664)
From what I can see pretty much every analysis of something like the recent war in Afghanistan has its own perspective and it's only by reading different accounts that you can get any idea of what actually happened.

[e.g. I've read multiple accounts of the "why can't the Paras install a washing machine in a hospital" incident - each from wildly different perspectives].

I guess this need to get different perspective might be obvious to trained historian - but my degree is in CS :-)

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday July 18, 2016 @10:05AM (#12115068)
> the delayed formation of nation-states

Do you think that between the British, the French, the Russians, and the Ottomans all controlling the region, the development of nation-states may have been delayed by understandable reasons.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:32AM (#12128466)
I think so. Or to put it in another perspective: Nations often (if not mostly or everytime) came into being by an outside threat.

USA = the British England = The French/Catholic Church Germany = France Poland = Germany and Russia

and so on. Threats make possible that people see an "us". I very much like the term "imagined communities" (Benedict Anderson) in this regard.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by arethuza on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:09AM (#12114349)
I can give a strong recommendation for Inside the Kingdom by Robert Lacey - someone mentioned it the last time I recommended Bitter Lake on HN.

http://www.robertlacey.com/?q=book/inside-kingdom

[NB Bitter Lake is awesome for both content and style].

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @06:56AM (#12114309)
They are still part of the problem if they sponsor these fanatics.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by estefan on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:09AM (#12114351)
Yeah absolutely, but the doco argues they aren't doing it to create some parallel of Catholicism, but rather as a way to appease the extremists who could have toppled them from power 50 years ago. The trouble is, those schools have now created a load of brainwashed idiots who are now causing trouble.
Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by DominikR on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:19AM (#12114393)
It is one thing if you spread internally crazy ideologies or if you spend considerable resources to go out there and try to subvert every society you possibly can.

Saudi education literally teaches children that they must wage jihad against the infidels (to spread their faith) and that's after 9/11 when they supposedly reviewed their textbooks for children to remove all texts that might spread hate.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05...

I say if that's the only way the Saud family can hold onto power then it's not worth supporting them.

These guys have done more to make Islam look bad than anyone else in the last decades combined.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by afarrell on Monday July 18, 2016 @08:03AM (#12114553)
> Who do you think will be in power if the Saudis aren't

The Hashemites

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by tt44 on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:58AM (#12114539)
> I say if that's the only way the Saud family can hold onto power then it's not worth supporting them.

Who do you think will be in power if the Saudis aren't?

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by woodpanel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:45AM (#12128553)
Why I oppose this view completely (please don't take this personally, I mean what the movie conveys) apart from leaving out the question of Arabian Nationality: You don't need to spread Wahabism globally to quite some local clerics in your country. But the latter is what the Saudis spent much effort in. For decades they've flown in Clerics or Soon-To-Be-Clerics from countries all over the world, putting them in their religous universities for some years and then sending them back as a measure to spread radicalism into other countries.

Boko Haram is direct descendent of this policy.

Re:Saudi Ties to 9/11 Detailed in Documents Suppressed Since... by ljf on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:53AM (#12114519)
A most excellent documentary, well worth a viewing.