News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by elthran on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:11AM (#11923079)
Are there any Americans here who are able to explain why the US is so backwards when compared to European countries?

Visa and Mastercard and the banks all offer Chip and Pin services here in the UK, and have done for years.

I can understand the delay in adopting chip cards, with the ridiculously large number of terminals and cards that would have to be replaced - but I really don't see why when you're performing the migration to cards with a chip, you wouldn't implement PIN at the same time

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by rogerbinns on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:24AM (#11923169)
(I'm a brit who moved to the US.) It is far more common for people to have multiple cards. There are also a lot of affinity cards - associated with airlines, stores, sports teams etc. A random site[1] claims just under 4 cards on average for those who have any cards. A card issuer also requiring that the consumer remember yet another PIN isn't going to find it too useful for expanding their business, just as the consumer is going to prefer less hassle.

[1] http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/ownership-statis...

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by elthran on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:32AM (#11923222)
Those stats made quite interesting reading - what I felt is missing is the reason /why/ there is such a high multiple-card ownership rate?

I personally have a single debit card, and a single credit card, as do most people I know - is the culture in the US really so different that people need so many cards?

I've visited the US, but do not live there - I never felt properly safe when I was just swiping my card and signing to pay for things. I don't even know if the fraud protection would apply to my European chip and pin card if I paid for things that way.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by rogerbinns on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:08PM (#11923459)
There are quite simply a lot more banks and other financial institutions that issue credit cards. When I lived in the UK there were essentially 4 banks, plus a dozen building societies (US equivalent: credit union). Today the US has about 6,000 banks and similar number of credit unions.

In order to get customers they have to stand out from their competitors which means marketing, card perks and rewards. With that much activity, it is almost inevitable that people will end up with more cards.

Americans also like their stuff complicated. Look at health care and politics as two examples. What it often manifests itself as is different choices for different circumstances, whereas others would lump it all together. For example you generally don't have a single "bank account", but instead you have a checking account and a savings account, not necessarily at the same bank even! And yes there is federal law around what constitutes a savings account.

When making a purchase, the optimum card to use will vary. For example a store affinity card will likely offer discounts at that store and affiliated ones. Some offer cashback but it varies by category (eg it may be 5% for petrol stations, 2% for restaurants, 1% for supermarkets) with each having its own percentages and other limitations (eg min quantities, max cash back). And if you are saving up airline miles, you may want to use that relevant card instead of the others until hitting your goal.

I try to keep my cards to an absolute minimum but ended up with 4 all from my bank: a debit/atm card, another one tied to my health savings account (which has to be different), a credit card, and a second backup credit card.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:47PM (#11924707)
This. Amazon card gets better returns for me on Amazon purchases (plus it got stolen half a dozen times so now it only gets used on Amazon...this happened because someone physically pried my locked apartment mailbox open and used that info to order more replacement CCs to their address), other card gets better returns for travel at restaurants, other card gets better returns for everything else, then I have a debit card since some gas stations only accept those. I also carry cash since some places are cash-only, and some parking meters only accept quarters, so I have a stack of those in my car as well.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by Larrikin on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:42AM (#11923290)
You're basically leaving money on the table if you're doing most of your transactions on a debit card or in cash in the US. The credit card companies all offer set percentage cash back, rotating categories of higher cash back, and/or heavily discounted miles. Discover and Chase both offer cards with 5% rotating categories that are different between the two and have no yearly fees. Even the cards with a fee often end up being worth it due to the large amount of miles you can rack up with them.

Thats not even getting into the shadier side of card churning for the sign up bonuses or buying gift cards so that you can pay your rent and for other things that have a fee associated with them when you do anything besides a bank transfer.

https://www.nerdwallet.com/ has a good primer on the different cards

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by riprowan on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:06PM (#11923448)
Not to mention the very common practice of using one card with a very high balance and 0% intro fees to sweep lots of other card balances onto, in order to effectively suspend all your interest for a year.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by sethhochberg on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:03PM (#11923808)
Indeed. This works even for balances that didn't originate on credit cards - I have a Chase Slate card which has literally never left my house because I only use the account for its 18-month zero-interest offer, which was useful for a small student loan I wanted to pay down quickly.

Many people I know use special card offers similarly. Want those 50,000 airline miles? Better sign up for Delta's Amex, can always cancel after the first year... etc, etc. There are very strong incentives from the card issuers themselves for Americans to carry multiple credit cards, and if you use the cards responsibly you can rack up some serious benefits for no cost.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:50PM (#11924729)
Your student loans could be paid via credit card without a surcharge? Or is it just that the surcharge was lower than the interest rate and you planned to pay it off in 18 months so it was worthwhile? That's an interesting strategy I haven't seen before.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by aianus on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:32PM (#11925026)
You can withdraw cash or transfer to your bank account from credit cards (at least in Canada).
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:44PM (#11925098)
Interesting. Is that different than a cash advance on the CC?

My cards which are otherwise great have ridiculously high fees for cash advances (20%+).

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by aianus on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:49PM (#11925131)
No, it's not different.

That's not a fee, that's the interest rate. You would pay 20% over a year of interest. There are many many cards with promotional rates between 0% and 5% per year.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:11PM (#11925257)
It's the cash advance fee (different from the normal interest rate on the card).

Source: I used it once to get money out like a debit card... without realizing there would be a fee, and got charged the nasty fee. For the card I tried it on at the time, the fee was somewhere between $10–20 on a $100 withdraw. Never tried it again.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by aianus on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:20PM (#11925298)
Oh, on my card it's a 1% fee with a $5 minimum. Still totally worth it if they're doing the 0% interest promotion.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:24PM (#11925323)
Yeah, interesting "loophole" in the whole loans system. I'll have to do more research.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by sethhochberg on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:14PM (#11926326)
Yep, my scenario was exactly like aianus's above. 1% transfer fee was much better than 6% interest since I planned to pay the balance off within the 18-month zero-interest period anyways. The card company issued paper checks specifically for the purpose of a balance transfer.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by 0xfeba on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:52PM (#11924269)
Few of those apply to card balance transfers though.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:48PM (#11924718)
This is sadly why my apartment complex and every apartment I've lived in in the Bay Area requires a bank transfer to pay rent.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by lostlogin on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:49PM (#11925130)
Why is this sad? What's an alternative method? Keep in mind I'm not in the US!
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by Larrikin on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:24PM (#11925320)
My bank and college allowed credit card payments, but there was always a percentage fee that was much higher than what you would get back from credit card rewards
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by lostlogin on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:33PM (#11926942)
Can you not just direct debit it into a landlords account? That's what's done here but is there a down side?
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by dangrossman on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:00PM (#11923404)
In the US, almost every major retailer issues their own branded credit card, and they offer financial incentives for using that card at their stores.

As a card issuer, they get a cut of the interchange fees whenever you shop with their card, even if you're shopping at other stores. That provides both a discount on their own payment processing costs (some of the fees they pay their processors come back to them when their own branded card was used), and an additional revenue stream unrelated to their own store sales.

To entice consumers to sign up for retailer-branded cards, they offer significant discounts or rewards on purchases at that retailer.

Banks can offer rewards programs for use of their branded credit cards as well, but their reward programs can never pay out as much as a retailer-branded rewards program, because the retailer can cut into their profit margin to finance it while the bank's program has to be financed entirely through interchange fees.

It's perfectly rational to sign up for an Amazon card that offers 5% off your Amazon purchases if you shop there often. It's similarly rational to sign up for a similar program at each retailer you shop with often. So a rational consumer can end up holding a number of credit cards, some of them issued by their bank, some issued by retailers, simply in order to minimize their bills.

Beyond all that, there's also people that churn through cards in order to earn rewards for opening new accounts, or whom carry large debts and transfer balances to new cards with introductory 0% interest rates periodically to avoid accruing interest on their debt, essentially using new cards as loan extensions.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by chatmasta on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:44AM (#11923301)
Having more credit cards can benefit your credit score in a variety of ways. The fundamental reason for this is, of course, that credit card companies want you to have a lot of cards. They're betting they can make more on your interest payments than it costs to acquire you as a customer.

Some ways having multiple cards can benefit your credit score:

- More cards = higher credit limit = lower utilization percentage when you carry a balance. [0]

- If you're young, opening lots of cards early can make sense because in a few years the "average age of accounts" will only take small hits if you add a new card. Also, if you foresee a mortgage in your future, you can cancel your credit cards and they will still continue to "age" on your credit report

- If you've missed a payment in the past, since payments are calculated as "percentage of on time payments," you can increase that percentage faster by opening more cards and making all payments on time.

- At least according to creditkarma, more accounts actually translate directly to a higher score.

[0] edit - see jdmichal's comment below. utilization = current balance / limit.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by jdmichal on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:34PM (#11924131)
> More cards = higher credit limit = lower utilization percentage when you carry a balance.

Just want to mention that, at least some card companies report the current balance and not the carried balance. I have never carried a balance on my card, always pay in full every month, and my report still shows an amount for that card, which is basically whatever random amount I have on the card when they report.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by ams6110 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:06PM (#11924376)
Same. I recently had credit report pulled for a mortgage refinance, and although I pay all my credit card balances in full every month, it still showed several accounts with a "high balance relative to credit limit" or some such thing.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by op00to on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:38PM (#11926965)
The high transient balance really only affects your credit a few points if you have otherwise excellent credit. It starts to ding you more if you have delinquencies or really high balance to overall limit.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:55PM (#11924778)
Call each of the CC companies and ask them if they can raise your limit.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by ams6110 on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:55PM (#11924287)
I have half-a-dozen credit and debit cards. Several reasons:

1) Your credit score is negatively impacted if you close a credit card account.

2) Specific cards have specific benefits. For example my insurance company issues a credit card and if I use that card when I rent a car, I not only get automatic collision damage insurance (pretty standard on many cards) but also coverage against "loss of use" charges and other risks with rental cars that many other credit cards don't offer.

3) Some places don't take all cards. My AMEX card gives me hotel points that I use a lot but AMEX isn't accepted everywhere.

4) Many benefit programs have debit cards that are to be used for specific purposes. My HSA has a debit card, but I can only use it for medical expenses and prescription drugs.

Because the need for a particular card can be somewhat unpredictable, (and just to avoid losing them) I end up carrying about six cards in my wallet at all times.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by AngrySkillzz on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:35PM (#11924596)
To 1, it actually isn't or at least not as much as you might think. Relevant factors are utilization and average age of your credit accounts, going back 10 years; an account doesn't stop aging when you close it, and it doesn't fall off of your report until 10 years from the closing date. If closing an account decreases your amount of available credit enough that your utilization spikes (over 20%), then you should leave it open. Otherwise it's fine.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:52PM (#11924748)
Another note on that, if you normally spend more than about 10% of your credit limit across your cards each month, get another card or get one of them to raise your limit. Debt utilization ratio higher than that can also drop your score. Sign up for CreditKarma and keep an eye on it to get the best rates and rewards.

Edit: another alternative is to manually pay your bill every other week to keep the utilization ratio down.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by jjawssd on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:05PM (#11924366)
> Your credit score is negatively impacted if you close a credit card account

What happens if you raise the credit limit on your remaining cards to eat the loss of total credit?

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:56PM (#11924790)
The number of cards open is less important than the average age across your cards.

https://www.creditkarma.com/article/credit-score-factors

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by ams6110 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:08PM (#11924390)
I don't know the answer. I had assumed that it was the act of closing the account that was viewed as a negative and not the reduction in the aggregate credit limit. But I could be wrong.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by freehunter on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:44PM (#11924675)
My wife is a manager of a bank branch and her brother is a credit analyst at another bank, and I've been told the reason it impacts your credit is because you now have less credit available to you, and you're likely now using more of your available credit.

If you have $50 available on one card and $50 on another card, you have $100 of available credit. If you close one of the cards, you now only have $50 of available credit. If one card is maxed out and the other is empty (because you're about to close it), before you close it you are only using 50% of your available credit. Once you close it, you're now using 100% of your available credit, which looks bad.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by cmurf on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:58AM (#11923394)
Americans have been made totally neurotic with card rewards. My mom will dither for probably 10-15 seconds every time she pays for something, which card to put that particular transaction on, in order to extract the best points. Restaurants get a better kickback on card A, gas on card B, airline tickets on card C. It's crazy I hate it.

This is why merchants get hit with anywhere from 2% to 5% fees and have no idea which card cost them so much. And why friends say they're "losing money" if they don't play this game. It's fakaked.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by rmwaite on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:22PM (#11924010)
uh, why begrudge someone for trying to maximize? it's a system there to use for people willing to put the effort in
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by cmurf on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:30PM (#11925688)
If their efforts were actually productive, which they aren't, it wouldn't bother me so much. Their reward depends on everyone else paying higher costs but not getting the reward

The whole shenanigans is only possible because the issuers have a monopoly where the merchant can't charge the true cost of a transition to each specific consumer. If the consumer was paying for his own kickback, the whole party would end. It works because of obfuscation and free loading off others, especially those who pay by debit card and cash.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by throwanem on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:32PM (#11924112)
> fakaked

'Verkakte'.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by cmurf on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:21PM (#11925649)
It is derived from that word, similar to a common saying ertsnats in the small town my grandparents grew up in, which comes from ersatz. shrug
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by sjg007 on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:55PM (#11924290)
Sounds like a good app idea.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tzs on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:23PM (#11923577)
There are at least a couple of reasons to have more than one credit card, even if your cards are chip and pin.

1. Chip and pin protects against someone who gets your card number making a fraudulent card with it and using that for card present fraud. It doesn't do very much to protect against someone who gets your card number using it for card not present fraud.

If the chip card also implements tokenization, that protects against losing your card number to attacks on card present payment systems. If it does not implement tokenization, then you can lose your card number if someone hacks into payment terminals or merchant back end systems. Also you can lose your number if an online merchant who keeps your card on file gets hacked.

So, even with chip and pin it can be a good idea to have more than one card, such as one that you only use for card present transactions, and one that you use for online transactions.

2. Cards often offer rewards. At one point I had four cards, because one gave me cash back on gasoline purchases, one gave me cash back on grocery purchases, one had a very low interest rate, and one had a rotating cash back program that changed what category of purchases it rewarded every month.

They all had no annual fees, and I usually paid my bill in full every month, so basically each card was free money to me from the rewards, except for the low interest rate card which I only used if I wanted to make a big purchase that I would take a couple of months or so to pay off.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tass on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:54AM (#11923364)
There are a lot of different cards with different incentives. Shopping at REI? Use the REI credit card for 5% cash back. Groceries? Use this different card for 6% back.

There are advantages to the stores providing the card (data, CC fees, brand loyalty) and very easy for shoppers to apply while in the store.

Additionally, to get a good credit score, you need a high amount of available credit and long lived accounts. There aren't many disadvantages to having multiple accounts assuming you are able to manage your spending.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by ghaff on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:36AM (#11923257)
Single debit card, yes. But many people, including myself, have multiple credit cards for various reasons. (Backup in case of loss/rejection due to anti-fraud error, various types of affinity card rewards that want to spread around for various reasons, etc.) Also, to the degree that many still have AMEX cards, those aren't as widely accepted as Visa/Mastercard.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by jamesroseman on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:39AM (#11923274)
One American's opinion. I'm in my early 20s and in good financial standing, I have 3 credit cards with airline miles programs. Using them means for the past year I've used a free flight every 3rd flight, and my girlfriend and I will be traveling to Europe RT for $1200 for 2 tickets. I fly a lot, and it's saved me a couple hundred dollars to have a few credit cards, and the inconvenience of keeping < 5% balance on each.

I'd imagine it's because the credit card companies have less restrictions on what they can do here compared to Europe, so they can afford more extravagant offerings.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:47PM (#11924706)
> Is the culture in the US really so different that people need so many cards?

Varied rewards across cards is a big reason. One card offers 5% cash back on gas and 1% otherwise (so you only use it on gas). Another offers 2% back generally, so you use it for most things.

Also stores convince a lot of Americans to make expensive purchases by starting a store credit card that has no interest for 12+ months.

For debit cards I keep two, but only because my main bank does not offer chipped debit cards yet and I need one that does for travel abroad.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by illumin8 on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:38PM (#11924155)
The reason why US consumers have multiple cards (at least intelligent consumers) is because of the various cashback programs.

For example, Costco's Visa card gives me 4% cash back on all gas purchases. Costco's Visa also gives me 3% back on all travel related purchases like hotels, airlines, and restaurants. Citi Double Cash Mastercard gives me 2% back on all other purchases. Discover card runs 5% cash back each quarter on up to $1500 of one category, like online shopping, or home improvement retailers.

It's a bit of a chore to determine which card to use for every transaction, however, if you don't have credit cards, or just use debit cards, you're effectively leaving money on the table.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by omarchowdhury on Saturday June 18, 2016 @12:14AM (#11927075)
Does that online shopping mean any ecommerce transaction?
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by illumin8 on Monday June 20, 2016 @07:46PM (#11942517)
Yes, basically.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by pessimizer on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:33PM (#11924115)
Early training and aggressive marketing.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by Johnny555 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:23PM (#11924493)
The lawsuit explains it, I never bought the "Americans are too dumb to remember a PIN" excuse, and it turns out that it's about the money -- PIN transactions cost less than signature transactions so Visa/MC want more signature transactions:

The banks collect higher merchant fees for signature-based credit-card transactions than PIN-based ones.

“While chip-and-PIN authentication is proven to be more secure, it is less profitable for Visa, MasterCard, and their member banks and it provides a greater threat to their market dominance,” the lawsuit claimed.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by Slump on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:39PM (#11925407)
This is closer to the core issue in my opinion. Wal-Mart and Home Depot do not want to support processing EMV Debit cards as credit. Most debit processing rails require PIN data to process the transaction. Running a debit card using the signature CVM means processing the transaction over credit networks which costs the retailer more and is more profitable for the issuers.

This is the main reason retailers want to use Chip and PIN all the time and drop signature. It would mean they could simply run debit transactions over debit rails all the time which would cost them less. Obviously the issuers want the opposite since processing over debit rails is less profitable for them.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:43PM (#11924669)
U.S. chip cards ≠ chip and PIN. For the majority of them, we aren't issued pins and it's not even an option.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:13AM (#11923098)
Credit cards compete with other forms of payment, like cash. Making credit cards harder to use makes people shift payments to other forms. Implementing PINs is about balancing the costs of fraud against the costs of shifting those payments. If you cut fraud by X but you lose out on Y > X revenue due to reduced credit card use, it's a net loss. Card companies here apparently think that Y is indeed greater than X.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by acangiano on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:32AM (#11923221)
In Canada, we have a good compromise. Up to $100 (depending on your bank) you can simply use RFID "touch" payments. Fraud is much higher but it increases credit card usage so credit card companies promote it heavily (after all, the possible fraud will be for very small amounts). For larger purchases, a PIN is required. I think it's a good system.

When I travel to the US I'm always surprised by how backwards the approach to credit cards is:

- Waiter grabs my card and walks away with it. (In Canada they'd bring you the machine to your table.)

- In the unlikely scenario that they actually place the card in the chip reader, as opposed to just swiping it, they usually come back to me with a puzzled face. Last time I had the following interaction, "Sir, your card is giving us an error". "What's the error?". "It wants a code". "OK, I'll come and enter it". Then waiter proceeds to ask me for id, inspecting my card, checking the signature on the back carefully, etc. Basically, he thought I was up to no good because my card has a PIN. :)

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by wvenable on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:33PM (#11924120)
> Fraud is much higher

Is it? From what I understand they basically use their fraud-detection algorithms to determine whether the transaction should go through. That's why, every so often, the tap will fail and you have to do chip & pin.

I once had a chip&pin transaction refuse to go through because I was out of town and used a gas station brand that I almost never use. I called the CC company and they said pretty much that was reason. They monitor all transactions for behaviors out of the norm.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by nickonline on Saturday June 18, 2016 @05:29AM (#11927728)
Credit card fraud is the highest in the US compared to any country in the world.

Probably because it is so easy to swipe someone's wallet and then go on a spending spree without having to know a second detail.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:00PM (#11924805)
I really enjoyed all the wireless handheld CC terminals in Canada where the transaction felt like I was doing the work, and at my own pace. Much nicer than restaurants here as you describe.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by hx87 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:17AM (#11923126)
Honestly though I'd rather enter a PIN than use a dull piece of plastic to make an unreadable signature on a feedbackless screen. I punch keys all day but rarely write by hand.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:24AM (#11923170)
I think you're unusual. Many people struggle with PINs, or at least think they would, which in terms of hurting credit card use amounts to the same thing.

Another issue is that PIN adoption often implies a liability shift. Right now I have zero liability for fraudulent uses of my credit card. Some places place liability on the cardholder if the cardholder didn't take sufficient care to protect their PIN and a fraudulent transaction is made with the PIN. If that happened, I would stop using credit cards unless it was absolutely necessary, and the mere possibility is enough to make me extremely skeptical of any move to require PINs.

By the way, there is no requirement for your signature to be readable or reproducible or even anything resembling your name. Just do a quick freehand scribble. There's no reason for it to be harder than entering a PIN.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by stephengillie on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:38AM (#11923271)
If signatures don't have to match a previous signature, then what is the point of entering the scribble in the first place?

Aren't signatures still used as nominal security verification? If not, what is the legal significance of "signing" a document?

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:58AM (#11923391)
It used to be a security thing, but that seems to have completely fallen by the wayside. I think these days it's basically just formally indicating that you're agreeing to make the purchase at hand, so you can't later go back and say that you somehow didn't realize you were handing over money, or that you thought you were paying less than you were charged.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by kalleboo on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:13PM (#11926683)
> If signatures don't have to match a previous signature, then what is the point of entering the scribble in the first place?

Here in Japan traditionally identification for things like contracts and bank transactions is done with a seal (custom-carved rubber stamp). A lot of foreigners who move here think it's absolutely bonkers, since what if someone stole it? Isn't it really easy to clone?

Many banks here let you use a signature instead of a seal though, and some foreigners opt for it. They usually switch to using a seal after they have to re-fill a form 4 times in a row to get their signature to match the one on file, since they actually verify the things here!

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by btkramer9 on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:35PM (#11924132)
I find signing these days utterly pointless. I literally draw a line on every signature asked for these days.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:02PM (#11924832)
You also have to hit "yes" or otherwise agree to the amount. I do wonder what legal purpose a "signature" actually serves these days. The doodles definitely do get stored and sent to the processor. Sometimes they're also on the receipt.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by stock_toaster on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:59PM (#11926049)
Now I want to try drawing incredibly poor quality cartoons in the signature areas.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by hx87 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:35AM (#11923245)
With the vast majority of chip and pin schemes the liability for fraudulent transactions still falls on the bank, unless the merchant/processor hasn't implemented chip and pin, in which case it falls on them.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:33PM (#11924118)
When I think of "chip and PIN" my first thought is of the UK for some reason, and the UK is one of those that tries to put some liability on the cardholder.

In the US, our experience with PINs is mostly around debit cards. Those have significantly weaker fraud protections for debit transactions with a stolen PIN, up to $500 if you don't notice the fraud until after two days, and unlimited if you manage to miss it for two months.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by madeofpalk on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:19AM (#11923137)
What about contactless? PayPass/PayWave/Apple Pay is accepted universally here in Australia. Doesn't that make it easier for customers to pay?
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:25AM (#11923181)
Yes, I'm not sure why it's slow in catching on here. We've had contactless payments for years (I had a card that supported it around 2008) but they're still not common.

I suspect that one is more of a chicken-and-egg problem, with merchants not really caring to adopt it as long as few people have the cards, and card issuers not really caring to issue them as long as few merchants accept them. But I don't really know.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanalltogether on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:18PM (#11924455)
I believe the crux of the lawsuit (and oddly isn't really covered in the article) is that the credit card companies are trying to have their cake and eat it too. Visa & MC have created a new system that is only marginally more secure, but have required retailers to now shoulder the costs of any fraud that occurs on those new cards.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:28PM (#11925336)
If they'd just adopt chip readers then liability stays with the card companies.

This is actually something that has really puzzled me about the American chip rollout. As of October 2015, any merchant without a chip reader bears full liability for fraudulent chargers. I was sure that this would mean everybody would be switched over on time. Forcing merchants to pay for fraud is a pretty big threat! And yet here we are most of a year later, and I still see tons of stores with no chip readers. Even weirder, I see tons of stores with chip readers that don't work because they haven't activated it on the backend. Why....

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by Perceval on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:41AM (#11923284)
Here is a good article explaining U.S. path dependence on a clearing/settlement infrastructure that's stuck in the 1970s: http://priceonomics.com/how-credit-cards-tax-america/
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by duaneb on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:14PM (#11925264)
Does the Chip and Pin really afford that much protection? Surely it doesn't help with the underlying payment network, i.e. internet payments. The only thing that would really help here would be something like a credit card 2fa required for all transactions (which, to my understanding, the chip provides).
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tedmiston on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:41PM (#11924652)
> ridiculously large number of terminals and cards that would have to be replaced

I've heard from some Canadians running a payment processing company that it was the U.S. credit card companies lobbying for decades against it for precisely this expense. Right nextdoor in Canada they've had chipped cards for over a decade.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by bradleyjg on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:15AM (#11923111)
American consumers aren't responsible for fraud on their credit cards (technically only up $50 or something but in practice not at all). That means that they don't care much about security as compared to the inconvenience of having to remember and use a PIN.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by germanier on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:18AM (#11923131)
That can't be the reason for the difference because (roughly) the same applies to the European market.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by function_seven on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:17AM (#11923125)
All the more reason for the credit card companies to insist on implementing PINs, right? Since they're the ones eating the fraud.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by icebraining on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:18AM (#11923133)
No, it's the merchant that eats the cost, they have to return the money from the fraudulent payment.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by function_seven on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:21AM (#11923149)
Ah, good point. I guess this circles back to Home Depot's complaint then. All the merchants would have to band together somehow to insist on Chip-and-PIN.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by rhino369 on Saturday June 18, 2016 @03:09PM (#11930103)
Traditionally Europe had higher fraud rates than America. So the cost to benefit calculus was different. A lot of retailers still don't think it's worth the hassle.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by tdicola on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:06PM (#11923837)
The US is much larger than individual European countries and has an order of magnitude more credit card readers, etc. in circulation. Every single one of those had to be updated to use the new system.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by falsedan on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:27PM (#11924053)
Europe has a common market, so practically every card works everywhere else in the EU.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by germanier on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:12PM (#11923895)
I don't know why you would need to activate them all on the same day (and in fact that did neither happen in the US nor anywhere in Europe). An incremental rollout is always possible and the size of a market does not change anything about that. My European credit card still works with legacy systems deployed somewhere in the world that hadn't been updated. That doesn't change the benefits they got from updating most system here.

Incidentally, the large schemes usually set Europe-wide rules anyway.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by hackuser on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:20PM (#11923986)
The US therefore loses the economy of scale. Also, the US didn't even start before the tech had already been deployed across Europe.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by kbenson on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:59PM (#11924326)
Partly that's because the US banks didn't think the EU standard was secure enough. They were proven somewhat right when a fraud ring found a way to bypass some of the authentication[1]. Long story made short: The EU system did something like authorizing the pin to the card using the chip, but not requiring the bank to authenticate, which allowed the terminals to function without a network connection. Criminals inserted the chip from one card over the chip from another, intercepting the pin authentication request to the card and allowing it, and then allowing the transaction to proceed against the regular card. This would not work in the US where all the requests are verified by the bank over the network (which is why it takes longer).

That the US card industry is trying to move away from requiring a pin is somewhat strange, but I think can be explained by different people weighing in at different stages. Engineers nixed the EU type system as not secure enough, and then different company decision makers start pushing for no pin, to make sure they don't see a dip in usage. What you end up with is this.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10414375

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by lostlogin on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:53PM (#11925145)
But you don't have one or the other, you have both. Then you can upgrade slowly. It's not a great example (very small) but that's how it was done in New Zealand.