News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:13AM (#11923098)
Credit cards compete with other forms of payment, like cash. Making credit cards harder to use makes people shift payments to other forms. Implementing PINs is about balancing the costs of fraud against the costs of shifting those payments. If you cut fraud by X but you lose out on Y > X revenue due to reduced credit card use, it's a net loss. Card companies here apparently think that Y is indeed greater than X.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by acangiano on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:32AM (#11923221)
In Canada, we have a good compromise. Up to $100 (depending on your bank) you can simply use RFID "touch" payments. Fraud is much higher but it increases credit card usage so credit card companies promote it heavily (after all, the possible fraud will be for very small amounts). For larger purchases, a PIN is required. I think it's a good system.

When I travel to the US I'm always surprised by how backwards the approach to credit cards is:

- Waiter grabs my card and walks away with it. (In Canada they'd bring you the machine to your table.)

- In the unlikely scenario that they actually place the card in the chip reader, as opposed to just swiping it, they usually come back to me with a puzzled face. Last time I had the following interaction, "Sir, your card is giving us an error". "What's the error?". "It wants a code". "OK, I'll come and enter it". Then waiter proceeds to ask me for id, inspecting my card, checking the signature on the back carefully, etc. Basically, he thought I was up to no good because my card has a PIN. :)

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by wvenable on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:33PM (#11924120)
> Fraud is much higher

Is it? From what I understand they basically use their fraud-detection algorithms to determine whether the transaction should go through. That's why, every so often, the tap will fail and you have to do chip & pin.

I once had a chip&pin transaction refuse to go through because I was out of town and used a gas station brand that I almost never use. I called the CC company and they said pretty much that was reason. They monitor all transactions for behaviors out of the norm.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by nickonline on Saturday June 18, 2016 @05:29AM (#11927728)
Credit card fraud is the highest in the US compared to any country in the world.

Probably because it is so easy to swipe someone's wallet and then go on a spending spree without having to know a second detail.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:00PM (#11924805)
I really enjoyed all the wireless handheld CC terminals in Canada where the transaction felt like I was doing the work, and at my own pace. Much nicer than restaurants here as you describe.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by hx87 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:17AM (#11923126)
Honestly though I'd rather enter a PIN than use a dull piece of plastic to make an unreadable signature on a feedbackless screen. I punch keys all day but rarely write by hand.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:24AM (#11923170)
I think you're unusual. Many people struggle with PINs, or at least think they would, which in terms of hurting credit card use amounts to the same thing.

Another issue is that PIN adoption often implies a liability shift. Right now I have zero liability for fraudulent uses of my credit card. Some places place liability on the cardholder if the cardholder didn't take sufficient care to protect their PIN and a fraudulent transaction is made with the PIN. If that happened, I would stop using credit cards unless it was absolutely necessary, and the mere possibility is enough to make me extremely skeptical of any move to require PINs.

By the way, there is no requirement for your signature to be readable or reproducible or even anything resembling your name. Just do a quick freehand scribble. There's no reason for it to be harder than entering a PIN.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by stephengillie on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:38AM (#11923271)
If signatures don't have to match a previous signature, then what is the point of entering the scribble in the first place?

Aren't signatures still used as nominal security verification? If not, what is the legal significance of "signing" a document?

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:58AM (#11923391)
It used to be a security thing, but that seems to have completely fallen by the wayside. I think these days it's basically just formally indicating that you're agreeing to make the purchase at hand, so you can't later go back and say that you somehow didn't realize you were handing over money, or that you thought you were paying less than you were charged.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by kalleboo on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:13PM (#11926683)
> If signatures don't have to match a previous signature, then what is the point of entering the scribble in the first place?

Here in Japan traditionally identification for things like contracts and bank transactions is done with a seal (custom-carved rubber stamp). A lot of foreigners who move here think it's absolutely bonkers, since what if someone stole it? Isn't it really easy to clone?

Many banks here let you use a signature instead of a seal though, and some foreigners opt for it. They usually switch to using a seal after they have to re-fill a form 4 times in a row to get their signature to match the one on file, since they actually verify the things here!

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by btkramer9 on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:35PM (#11924132)
I find signing these days utterly pointless. I literally draw a line on every signature asked for these days.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanp2k2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:02PM (#11924832)
You also have to hit "yes" or otherwise agree to the amount. I do wonder what legal purpose a "signature" actually serves these days. The doodles definitely do get stored and sent to the processor. Sometimes they're also on the receipt.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by stock_toaster on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:59PM (#11926049)
Now I want to try drawing incredibly poor quality cartoons in the signature areas.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by hx87 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:35AM (#11923245)
With the vast majority of chip and pin schemes the liability for fraudulent transactions still falls on the bank, unless the merchant/processor hasn't implemented chip and pin, in which case it falls on them.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:33PM (#11924118)
When I think of "chip and PIN" my first thought is of the UK for some reason, and the UK is one of those that tries to put some liability on the cardholder.

In the US, our experience with PINs is mostly around debit cards. Those have significantly weaker fraud protections for debit transactions with a stolen PIN, up to $500 if you don't notice the fraud until after two days, and unlimited if you manage to miss it for two months.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by madeofpalk on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:19AM (#11923137)
What about contactless? PayPass/PayWave/Apple Pay is accepted universally here in Australia. Doesn't that make it easier for customers to pay?
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:25AM (#11923181)
Yes, I'm not sure why it's slow in catching on here. We've had contactless payments for years (I had a card that supported it around 2008) but they're still not common.

I suspect that one is more of a chicken-and-egg problem, with merchants not really caring to adopt it as long as few people have the cards, and card issuers not really caring to issue them as long as few merchants accept them. But I don't really know.

Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by seanalltogether on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:18PM (#11924455)
I believe the crux of the lawsuit (and oddly isn't really covered in the article) is that the credit card companies are trying to have their cake and eat it too. Visa & MC have created a new system that is only marginally more secure, but have required retailers to now shoulder the costs of any fraud that occurs on those new cards.
Re:Home Depot Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Visa, MasterCard by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:28PM (#11925336)
If they'd just adopt chip readers then liability stays with the card companies.

This is actually something that has really puzzled me about the American chip rollout. As of October 2015, any merchant without a chip reader bears full liability for fraudulent chargers. I was sure that this would mean everybody would be switched over on time. Forcing merchants to pay for fraud is a pretty big threat! And yet here we are most of a year later, and I still see tons of stores with no chip readers. Even weirder, I see tons of stores with chip readers that don't work because they haven't activated it on the backend. Why....