That said, I have no idea where he got that number, whether 40 m/s or 40 m/s^2; both are incorrect.
The best estimate available for the flight dynamics can be found at flightclub.io, specifically for JCSAT-14: https://flightclub.io/results/?id=eeaf889e-f3d8-4f9b-be98-b7...
This shows the landing burn starting at a velocity of 269 m/s and experiencing a peak deceleration of 12.3g = 121 m/s^2
I don't know how accurate these numbers are, but some fans put quite a bit of effort into getting the flightclub.io profiles as close to reality as possible, so they tend to be pretty good.
The approximation I had is almost certainly less reliable than flightclubs, not sure why it was so low, will have to look at the math I did and figure out what I screwed up.
The actual force would have been closer to 5.1G
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4htenu/rspacex_jcsa...
Ugh sorry, there's a bug of some sort in Flight Club there. There's no way it was that large. A constant deceleration down from terminal velocity over 6 seconds is
a = (300 - 0)/6 = 50m/s2 = 5.1g
I'll need to look into that
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4htenu/rspacex_jcsa...
So it looks like that peak is due to the sudden increase in drag during my landing legs deployment. I deploy them at 500m altitude which is a time when the stage is probably still moving a bit too fast. It's a really large increase in cross-sectional area, but I'm probably not treating it correctly. I'll revise before Thaicom-8
The overall structure actually goes through all sorts of stresses, not all of which are measured in G. The combination of push from the rocket and air resistance compresses the rocket from both ends, something that isn't reflected in G numbers.
I think this is only sort of true. Yes, the fueled rocket is much, much heavier. But not all parts of the rocket are load bearing as it sits on the pad waiting for launch. All parts of the rocket experience the 12g (or whatever it was) deceleration.
Also, rocket skins are really, really thin (relative to their size, the forces they endure, etc.) I've read that without the fuel inside to reinforce the rocket, it is quite fragile - think of trying to crush an empty soda can vs a full one. This is part of why rockets which deviate too far from prograde on launch are ripped apart mid-air.
The Falcon 9 has a sort of partial balloon tank. It's strong enough for ground handling without pressurization, but it requires pressurization to handle flight loads.
Note however that it's pressure, not fuel, that provides the extra strength. These tanks are still pressurized even when almost empty.
Tack-welding fixtures to a steel deck is apparently SOP in big shipping, so it's not as radical as it sounds.
Bonus points that the overwhelming majority of ships lack the giant oil rig thrusters that all of the ASDS armada contain to keep them as stable as feasible and prevent listing too much in normal ocean condiditons.
It could be that having the first stage untethered is deemed less risky to personnel than having a team of welders board the barge and tie it down.
While I suppose that the rocket could be heavy enough to lower the center of gravity of the entire vessel below the troughs of any waves enough to make it incredibly unlikely, it isn't just the prospect of tipping over that makes it important to secure cargo.
Engineering is conservative "just in case." So are a lot of practical activities that happen on the sea. In neither case, is this irrational or a waste of time.
It needs to be both stable and secured, because only one is inviting woe.
... which means there's nobody around to be injured or killed if the rocket falls post-landing. Maybe it's a precaution worth taking when they intend these stages for commercial re-use; for now, the whole thing is one big experiment.
how much money would a few ditched rockets cost, in comparison? hint: less than a shitload
would a recovery crew approach this platform in rough seas, even if a robotic lash were in place? hint: nope
then what exactly is the point of securing this 'cargo'? hint: there isn't one.
problem solved.
And yes, it will be secured. The previous recovered rocket was secured, this one will be too.
Apparently they do secure to the deck after landing.
Discussed here: http://space.stackexchange.com/q/6403/574
Maybe they still weld it this time, but that is done by having someone go to the barge and do it.
Discussed here: http://space.stackexchange.com/q/6403/574
This mission was to launch JCSAT-14 to geosynchronous orbit which requires the falcon 9 to move the already heavy satellite into a geosynchronous transfer orbit. That meant the first stage had to do a lot more work and was left with a lot less fuel as a result. Therefore, the re-entry burn was less aggressive, the first stage came in with twice the speed, and SpaceX needed to do a far harder landing with three engines lit in the quicker and riskier suicide burn. Somehow, despite playing down expectations, they managed an even more precise landing than last time.