News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by downandout on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:07AM (#11642810)
From the video it looks like it lands on a ship in rough seas and they do nothing to secure it. Won't it just fall over if the seas are rough enough, and if so, why don't they have some sort of robotic system that locks it down tight the moment it lands?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by andygates on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:06AM (#11643026)
If the sea is still enough to land, it's still enough to take time securing. The previous stage was secured by tying down the thrust structure ("octaweb") to tack-welded fixings on the deck with hoofing big chains. There may also have been shoes, we couldn't see clearly.

Tack-welding fixtures to a steel deck is apparently SOP in big shipping, so it's not as radical as it sounds.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by gizmo on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:11AM (#11643054)
Securing is purely a safety precaution, it's not actually required.

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/726218218109444096

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:30AM (#11643147)
With respect to Musk, that is total bunk. Any structure like this will have to be secured to the deck. The fact that it is a rocket doesn't matter. He may think that it is safe from falling over, but the insurance company and/or the health and safety people will tell him that cargo that tall needs to be secured. Ropes, chains, welding ... it cannot just sit there. A Volvo station wagon, on that deck at sea, would be tied. A box of onions would at least be secured so that it doesn't shift onto someone's foot. Boats move, cargo cannot.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by SEJeff on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:34AM (#11644642)
I suspect he is in a unique situation to know the numbers for this much better than you do, because he runs the company that has successfully done this.

Bonus points that the overwhelming majority of ships lack the giant oil rig thrusters that all of the ASDS armada contain to keep them as stable as feasible and prevent listing too much in normal ocean condiditons.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by elif on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:25PM (#11645723)
It is amusing that you insist your speculation about something you've never done is more valuable than the experience of someone that has pioneered it.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:45PM (#11645862)
Ya, because SpaceX is the only company to have ever transported something on the deck of the ship. It was a rocket until the moment it landed. Now it's cargo.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by Inconel on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:33PM (#11646214)
This isn't my area of expertise and what you've said certainly makes sense, however from my understanding ship-to-ship, or in this case ship-to-barge, boardings at sea aren't without their own inherent risks.

It could be that having the first stage untethered is deemed less risky to personnel than having a team of welders board the barge and tie it down.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:13PM (#11647382)
The key is movement. Doing something like moving objects from one ship to another is pretty standard, but only in good conditions and normally not when the ship is moving. The rocket may well be safe to stand on the ship at the moment it lands. The conditions at that moment are good enough to make the choice to do the move. Once it is on the ship, that choice is over. Conditions change, most dramatically in that the stationary ship is going to drive away to port. Not bringing the object aboard is no longer an option, as it was prior to the rocket landing. Under those conditions the cargo has to be secured not against current conditions, but against all possible conditions.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by Inconel on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:27PM (#11647458)
Thanks for the clear explanation.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by nkurz on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:52PM (#11646324)
If they don't need it, they don't need it, but I wonder if there would be any other way do the secure the rocket without requiring welders to board the barge. Coat the deck with solder and put heaters in the feet to attach? A robotic Roomba-style welder? Giant arms that rise up to clasp the rocket regardless of the exact landing position? Fun to think about...
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by dmihal on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:36PM (#11647205)
Maybe something with magnets?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by stcredzero on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:18PM (#11645323)
Cargo shifting is a big deal. The yearly casualty rate for Bering Sea crab fishing used to be over 1% per year, because the shifting weight of crab pots on overloaded vessels in heavy seas. I saw a training film when I was aboard a tender boat in Alaska. Those boats could look fine one minute then capsize and be as good as sunk in the next 2. Shifting weight on vessels has and does cause rapid capsizing and deaths at sea.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by mikeash on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:02PM (#11645990)
This is pretty light cargo relative to the weight of the ship. It's a few tons of rocket and thousands of tons of ship. I don't think it's going to matter to the ship if it shifts, the only risk is losing the rocket over the side.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by stcredzero on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:09PM (#11646038)
What you say is True. My comment explains why the shipping industry and regulatory bodies seem paranoid about shifting weights at sea. There are good reasons to be conservative about certain things and brook no exceptions.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by d_theorist on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:03AM (#11643324)
Somehow I suspect they have run the numbers.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:06AM (#11643346)
What numbers? Unsecured cargo is unsecured cargo. A metal object sitting on a flat metal deck gets tied/braced/chained.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by rz2k on Friday May 06, 2016 @12:43PM (#11645107)
Just to elaborate: due to wave action and leverage on the underside of the hull, parts of the deck of a ship can accelerate downward faster than the acceleration from Earth's gravity, and while the deck underneath the rocket has fallen faster than the rocket and its heavy engines it can also lurch to a side. Even if the center of gravity makes it equivalent to a sheet of rolled steel, so that it wouldn't tip over, it could become displaced, then go overboard or cause unwanted damage.

While I suppose that the rocket could be heavy enough to lower the center of gravity of the entire vessel below the troughs of any waves enough to make it incredibly unlikely, it isn't just the prospect of tipping over that makes it important to secure cargo.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by zardo on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:20PM (#11645333)
Of course if there is any chance of the rocket moving, it isn't even safe to pull up alongside, let alone send people onto the deck to secure it.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:48PM (#11645885)
There are protocols for securing unsecured cargo. Whether delivered by rocket or crane, things land on decks every day and are tied down by hand.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by zardo on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:29PM (#11647175)
In conditions where it's going to be sliding around on the deck?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by pol0nium on Saturday May 07, 2016 @07:40AM (#11649206)
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by d_theorist on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:33AM (#11643479)
I think you're trying to apply rules designed to govern shipping in general to a very specialised and controlled situation.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by stcredzero on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:26PM (#11645369)
A lot of rules around shipping actually have to do with physics. See my other comment. Shifting cargo can be very bad news. It has caused a lot of deaths. It's probably not a big deal in this case, except that booster is worth about (I'm guessing) 20 million dollars, SpaceX's cost? It's tall, but the center of gravity is low and it's on a barge.

Engineering is conservative "just in case." So are a lot of practical activities that happen on the sea. In neither case, is this irrational or a waste of time.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by andygates on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:03AM (#11643645)
They will of course have modelled the cargo scenario, and I suspect that Musk means that it's nice and stable when they do that -- but then shipping norms come into play because, like you say, unsecured cargo is unsecured cargo.

It needs to be both stable and secured, because only one is inviting woe.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sylvinus on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:46AM (#11643551)
They mentioned multiple times that because the stage is empty, its center of gravity is much lower than what you'd expect.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by fixermark on Friday May 06, 2016 @09:00AM (#11643629)
By whom? The drone ship has no on-board crew.

... which means there's nobody around to be injured or killed if the rocket falls post-landing. Maybe it's a precaution worth taking when they intend these stages for commercial re-use; for now, the whole thing is one big experiment.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by skykooler on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:58AM (#11644811)
There is a ship a few miles away with engineers on it. Once the stage has vented all excess liquid oxygen and is safe to approach, they can return to the ASDS and secure it.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by est on Friday May 06, 2016 @12:37PM (#11645067)
By the time the rocket lands, there's very few fuel left, basically you see a near empty Pepsi can. It's as stable as it can get.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sandworm101 on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:42PM (#11645835)
Ever see an empty pepsi can in a stiff breeze?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by blater on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:32PM (#11646535)
More like a Pepsi can with a bloody big brick in the bottom 9*470 kg merlins). Main threat to stability would seem to be wind, but doesn't seem to be the case in practice
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by beachstartup on Friday May 06, 2016 @03:45PM (#11646278)
how much money and time would a robotic lashing system cost? hint: a shitload.

how much money would a few ditched rockets cost, in comparison? hint: less than a shitload

would a recovery crew approach this platform in rough seas, even if a robotic lash were in place? hint: nope

then what exactly is the point of securing this 'cargo'? hint: there isn't one.

problem solved.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by manicdee on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:23PM (#11647133)
The point of securing the cargo is to prevent it being lost to toppling, sliding off the side, or being catapulted off the side of a rolling deck.

And yes, it will be secured. The previous recovered rocket was secured, this one will be too.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by beachstartup on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:07PM (#11647353)
i'm talking about the landing pad.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by rblatz on Friday May 06, 2016 @05:58PM (#11646989)
What port will let them in with giant explosive unsecured cargo? Hint no port.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by beachstartup on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:01PM (#11647004)
and yet, they seem to be doing just fine.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by rblatz on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:08PM (#11647358)
Everything I've seen says they secure their load. Is there something I'm missing?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by beachstartup on Friday May 06, 2016 @08:06PM (#11647639)
i'm referring to the landing platform.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by ncallaway on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:11PM (#11645282)
Hence the phrase "purely a safety precaution"
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by _kst_ on Friday May 06, 2016 @05:14PM (#11646763)
Before it landed, the most likely scenario was that the rocket was going to crash into the deck and be destroyed. (That's happened several times before.) If they can deal with that, they can deal with the rocket landing safely and then falling over.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by rblatz on Friday May 06, 2016 @05:55PM (#11646979)
They can until it gets to a busy port with other ships and people around. Then it becomes a huge safety issue.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by _kst_ on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @02:44PM (#11678036)
Copying my other comment:

Apparently they do secure to the deck after landing.

Discussed here: http://space.stackexchange.com/q/6403/574

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by robin_reala on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:10AM (#11642822)
All of the centre of gravity is low down with the engines. The rest is basically just a thin empty tube.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by bkor on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:19AM (#11642842)
To add to above: In the previous barge landing they did weld the landing legs to the barge using some kind of bracket. But they discovered that the centre of gravity is low enough to not need any welding. During the previous attempt the sea was heavier than this time.

Maybe they still weld it this time, but that is done by having someone go to the barge and do it.

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by vermontdevil on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:06AM (#11643031)
Actually no they did not weld anything to the legs. Elon said that they realize it wasn't needed. They did use octojack though to support the weight off the legs.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by tlrobinson on Friday May 06, 2016 @01:08PM (#11645266)
What's octojack? Can't seem to find any other references to that.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by vermontdevil on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:30PM (#11645752)
Sorry meant Octoweb jacks

https://imgur.com/5GTW1CO

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by MertsA on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:37PM (#11648280)
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by sqeaky on Friday May 06, 2016 @02:02PM (#11645585)
Everyone seems worried about waves and tilting, but you are saying the rocket is pretty much a metal sail. Can wind blow it over?
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by simonh on Friday May 06, 2016 @06:18AM (#11642839)
Plus the platform has four computer controlled engines on basically universal joints to stabilize it. A crew then boards the barge and puts 'shoes' over the landing legs then welds them to the deck.
Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by _kst_ on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:18PM (#11672438)
Apparently they do secure to the deck after landing.

Discussed here: http://space.stackexchange.com/q/6403/574

Re:SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite la... by SEJeff on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:32AM (#11644634)
From the last landing, Elon said (on twitter), that the ASDS can list up to 8% and the rocket can still land or stay upright.