News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by brightball on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:12AM (#11619824)
To make it work you'd have to take whatever the amount is and extract it from all other government benefit programs.

You get $700 / month from the government for basic income. Your social security, welfare, unemployment, disability, etc is reduced by $700 / month. Reducing all of those programs by the first $700 would effectively gut each of them enough to finally make some reforms without inducing panic in everyone who uses them.

If you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well. The only difference is that you increase the stipend to the level of the BI.

For kids, you give the parents their basic income until they hit school age and then the BI goes towards funding their school. This would also enable people who wanted to utilize private schools a much easier choice by essentially becoming a voucher.

No loan could utilize the BI as security...except for student loans. That would allow driving down of interest rates as well as default aversion too. Payments could be automatically extract from the BI since student loans would finally be secured against something other that expected future earnings.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by notahacker on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:20AM (#11620322)
Why would you get bipartisan support for the FairTax? Redesigning the tax structure to favour millionaires (massive net beneficiaries because their US consumption expenditure is usually a tiny fraction of their capital gains tax and/or income tax bills) over the middle classes (no matter how high the stipend is someone has to pay for the millionaires' tax cut) isn't exactly a popular proposal even on the right

That said, agree with your main point that making BI deductible from [mostly] retained existing benefit entitlements is the least messy way of introducing it, but it also makes it more politically difficult since it's paid for purely by tax increases.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by criley2 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:28AM (#11620975)
Poster is crazy to think liberals will EVER support a hugely regressive tax scheme. Consumption taxes destroy the middle class by acting as vehicle to transport wealth from the middle to the ultrawealthy, which makes it surprising that people continue to suggest it.

Now perhaps a consumption tax combined with a large capital gains tax and inheritance tax -- to keep taxes going in the oligarchs economy AND the regular economy, and prevent capital from being tied up between generations in the least productive way possible, then you might get some of them on board.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by clarkmoody on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:42AM (#11621099)
What about the consumption taxes we have on the books? Gas tax? Hugely regressive. Wouldn't liberals support additional carbon taxes? Value-added tax? Wouldn't those continue to "destroy the middle class"?

What about the tax of inflation that serves to redistribute wealth from savers to debtors? (middle class -> government)

Also interesting how you know better than others how they should arrange their financial lives. Would like to hear your thoughts on the "productive ways" the "oligarchs" could better deploy their capital.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:22PM (#11622557)
> What about the consumption taxes we have on the books?

The broader they are, the more likely liberals are to oppose them, and oppose expanding them. Replacing the progressive income tax system with something regressive isn't something that's going to get support on the left.

> Gas tax? Hugely regressive.

But very narrow.

> Wouldn't liberals support additional carbon taxes?

Many liberals support the concept of carbon taxes as a behavior control mechanism, but not as the main way of funding government, and many raise concerns about the regressive impact. But, with them, the goal is to limit the thing being taxed and fund efforts to improve our ability to avoid it, not be the primary funding method for government.

> Value-added tax?

Virtually all the support I've seen on this in the US is on the right (often competing against flat tax proposals.)

> What about the tax of inflation that serves to redistribute wealth from savers to debtors? (middle class -> government)

While the classical middle class (e.g., Marx's petit bourgeoisie) are net holders of assets, the "middle class" as the term is used in modern discussions in the US (which is largely the middle income segment of wage laborers) aren't really net savers.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nightski on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:18PM (#11624701)
Having studied the fair tax in a fair bit of depth I can say that it probably would not penalize net spenders. In fact, they would probably be better off. Not only would you have more money to spend, but goods and services would likely cost less. There are numerous reasons for this given in easily accessible sources on the fair tax proposal.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ori_b on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:31PM (#11623518)
> Wouldn't liberals support additional carbon taxes?

With the goal of eliminating carbon use (and through this, eliminating the carbon tax), yes. The key understanding is that destroying the environment is a significantly worse problem than a regressive tax.

And destroying the environment also has a highly regressive impact; The impact on livability is not uniform, and people that can afford to relocate will have a much better time of it.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by skybrian on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:11AM (#11621328)
It depends. If the proceeds from the carbon tax get paid out equally to all citizens (similar to basic income) then it's not regressive.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by marknutter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:08AM (#11621307)
Or cigarettes? Or lottery tickets? Or the AMA penalty?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by prostoalex on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:13PM (#11622948)
If you followed recent headlines, tax on sugary drinks has been a subject in Democratic primaries. Even though high-fructose corn syrup has been linked to obesity, diabetes and myriad of other problems related to that, some members of liberal community oppose a consumption tax on sugary drinks on the basis that it hits lower-income families disproportionally http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/Tax-VOX/2016/0430/Bernie-s...

Apparently obesity and diabetes hit lower-income families disproportionally as well http://www.livescience.com/37923-type-2-diabetes-low-income-... (who would have thunk), but we can always create a government program to conduct more research on causes.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by hfsktr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:43PM (#11624068)
Why is the new tax needed? What are we trying to fund that other taxes don't already cover? Don't we (the government) subsidize HFCS? Wouldn't not doing that raise the prices and not require a tax then?

I will oppose a 'sugar' tax because I don't think the government should be deciding what foods I consume, especially when I think taxes should be for raising money.

I am aware it's not the full picture and I haven't explained it well but I hope I got a little bit of my view across.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mjevans on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:40PM (#11624456)
Maybe we should stop subsidizing unhealthy sugar (because it is in -everything- cheep as a result).
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by hfsktr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:20PM (#11624714)
I agree with this. Then there would be no need for a new tax right?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by prostoalex on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:27PM (#11624754)
From the tax simplification point of view you're right. But removing the subsidy would still raise the prices on soft drinks, and affect lower income households disproportionally, so it's a regressive measure as well.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by majewsky on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:08AM (#11627732)
Depends on the scope. If you can reduce obesity and obesity-induced diseases, that could affect the average budget of a low-income family very positively. Of course, I don't have numbers on how the two effects weigh against each other.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ageek123 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:46PM (#11623624)
European countries, which are quite to the left of the US, have much higher consumption taxes than the US. So I don't think it's fair to say it's "crazy to think liberals will EVER support" consumption taxes. They already do.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:15PM (#11624983)
European countries that are quite to the left of the US also tend to have higher (both nominal and effective) income taxes and more sharply progressive income taxes than the US (especially when all taxes on income, including social security taxes, are considered); supporting a consumption tax in such a regime can still leave the aggregate more progressive than the US.

What liberals aren't likely to support is replacing the current federal tax system with a consumption tax. Making it much more progressive and including a consumption tax alongside, they might, but probably not (just because that might look like what exists in some more leftish European states, there are path dependencies.)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:50PM (#11624880)
> Poster is crazy to think liberals will EVER support a hugely regressive tax scheme. Consumption taxes destroy the middle class by acting as vehicle to transport wealth from the middle to the ultrawealthy, which makes it surprising that people continue to suggest it.

So the proposal is to combine something like VAT with a basic income.

Doing that would cause low income people to have a negative effective tax rate (basic income exceeds taxes), low-middle income people to have a near-zero tax rate (basic income equals taxes), high-middle income people to have a moderate tax rate (taxes exceed basic income by a little) and high income people to have a higher tax rate (taxes exceed basic income by a lot).

In what sense is that regressive? It's the purest form of a progressive tax system. It even has a built in social welfare system for low income people.

The fallacy which is usually put up against this is that the super rich don't spend as much as they earn. The problem is, that's not how income tax works either. Bill Gates doesn't have to pay tax on the appreciation of Microsoft stock until he sells the shares and he doesn't have to sell the shares until he wants to spend the money. "Super-rich don't pay tax on money they don't spend" is the status quo.

And consumption taxes benefit debtors at the expense of creditors. Income tax makes the debtor pay back the debt with after-tax dollars. Consumption tax causes the creditor to be paid in pre-tax dollars.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:39PM (#11625106)
> "Super-rich don't pay tax on money they don't spend" is the status quo.

Only if you ignore estate taxes...which FairTax eliminates.

For the rich (defined here as anyone with enough wealth that, if they don't spend it down, they will face estate taxes) they either have to realize the gains (and be taxed) and spend down or leave an estate which will be subject to estate taxes, giving them a maximum time window on taxation equal to their lifespan.

With "FairTax", which eliminates estate tax and goes to a strict consumption tax, there is no such maximum window.

> And consumption taxes benefit debtors at the expense of creditors. Income tax makes the debtor pay back the debt with after-tax dollars. Consumption tax causes the creditor to be paid in pre-tax dollars.

Because it also changes the cost structures on which debt is occurred, this only is meaningful as a one-time effect on debts that exist at the time of the transition to a predominantly-consumption-tax system, not as durable feature.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @03:54AM (#11626863)
> For the rich (defined here as anyone with enough wealth that, if they don't spend it down, they will face estate taxes) they either have to realize the gains (and be taxed) and spend down or leave an estate which will be subject to estate taxes, giving them a maximum time window on taxation equal to their lifespan.

It would be if not for the "estate tax holiday" we have periodically which together with a bunch of other ways of avoiding the estate tax is why it only constitutes a negligible amount (0.6%) of federal revenue.

The fundamental problem with the estate tax is that it's a huge tax that happens with semi-unpredictable timing, which induces rich families to do estate tax planning to avoid having liquidity problems when it happens. But "estate tax planning" means paying fifty million dollars to tax lawyers and lobbyists to avoid paying a billion dollars in estate taxes.

In practice what it means is that rich families will do much more to avoid and lobby against the estate tax than they would against a tax that collected the same amount of money from them but more predictably over a longer period of time. Which makes it a losing proposition if your goal is to get the rich to pay taxes.

> Because it also changes the cost structures on which debt is occurred, this only is meaningful as a one-time effect on debts that exist at the time of the transition to a predominantly-consumption-tax system, not as durable feature.

It applies equally to the interest paid on the existing debt. And given that the total interest generally exceeds the principal (and exceeds it moreso for poorer people paying higher interest rates), the "one time effect" would be with us for a generation or more.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @12:14PM (#11629371)
> The fundamental problem with the estate tax is that it's a huge tax that happens with semi-unpredictable timing, which induces rich families to do estate tax planning to avoid having liquidity problems when it happens.

Well, yeah, it would be much simpler and more effective if inheritances were just taxed as income to the recipient with provisions allowing them to be split and recognized over several subsequent tax years (e.g., if the total inheritance received in any year is greater than 1/10 the pre-inheritance AGI, the excess can be recognized for tax purposes in subsequent years, with a minimum per year amount equal to the lesser of 1/10 the pre-inheritance AGI in the year received or 1/20 the total amount of the inheritance.)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:39PM (#11624039)
>Poster is crazy to think liberals will EVER support a hugely regressive tax scheme.

I just want to make one glib comment here about liberals and regressive taxes.

The Northeast is generally thought of as the most liberal part of America (aside from coastal California maybe). So why is it that I've seen far more toll roads and bridges there than in any "red state"?

I think some liberals make some good points about regressive taxes, but in practice, it seems like the liberals who actually get to power just love them.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by xiaoma on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:58AM (#11628370)
>The Northeast is generally thought of as the most liberal part of America (aside from coastal California maybe).

I sure don't think of the northeast that way. I see it as fairly conservative both in politics and business. One data point is that it wasn't anywhere in the northeast that first legalized weed. It was Colorado and Washington, followed by Oregon and Alaska. Another data point is that people wear jeans or shorts at work in Silicon Valley (or Socal, Oregon, Colorado, etc) whereas they're far more likely to be required to wear suits in the north east.

The northeast is very urban, which has some overlapping effects with but is still very different from actually being liberal. Change is mostly driven by the west. It's just that the change reaches the dense cities of the northeast more quickly than the rural areas in between.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @11:02AM (#11628811)
Excellent point, but good luck convincing all the Hillary-voting, suit-wearing Democrats in the northeast that they're not "liberal". Just look at the other responses to my post here even.

But agreed, there's absolutely a huge difference between west coast liberals and east coast "liberals".

The marijuana issue is an interesting thing to look at too, when you compare to red-vs-blue state maps. The "liberal" northeast still hasn't legalized weed (not even Vermont), whereas Colorado was one of the first two, and CO is a rather purple state (CO Springs is a ridiculously conservative place), and Alaska is very much a red state, being the place that elected Palin governor. It really seems to come down to social libertarianism versus authoritarianism. The "liberals" in the northeast want to ban sodas for your health, whereas the liberals in the west want to legalize drugs.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by zardo on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:42PM (#11630090)
That just gets to how silly the idea is that you can map policy opinions onto a single principal component and get good separation.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:15PM (#11630386)
Exactly; we try to distill everything political in this country into two "teams", but the problem is that the teams are not even remotely homogeneous or agreed on policies. Trump vs. establishment GOP and Bernie vs. establishment DNC show this.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:43PM (#11624479)
> The Northeast is generally thought of as the most liberal part of America (aside from coastal California maybe). So why is it that I've seen far more toll roads and bridges there than in any "red state"?

Because the Northeast was also the most heavily developed area of the country before the Interstate Highway System came about with a funding system that made non-toll roads the norm for new limited-access highways (funding rules which have since changed, weakening the financial incentive against new toll roads.) Modern political orientation has little to do with it: outside the Northeast, the people trying to introduce toll roads where they haven't been in the past are conservatives, the people opposing them are liberals.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:25PM (#11625527)
Ok, but that was well over a half century ago. The liberals have had more than enough time to eliminate these horribly regressive tolls which only hurt working class people, so why haven't they? Why are we still paying ridiculously-high tolls on bridges that are falling apart because they're so old?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by criley2 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:07AM (#11628429)
Could you compare Toll Roads and Population Density?

Then, when you realize that toll roads are correlated with population density, perhaps you could realize that toll roads are then only also correlated with politics of state, not caused by them.

For example: If liberals loved toll roads, then California, Oregon and Washington would be full of them. But only the NorthEast is, right?

So your hypothesis falls apart here anyway.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:53AM (#11628737)
No, my hypothesis is correct. West coast liberals are nothing like east coast liberals. East coast liberals are authoritarians; west coast liberals are not. There's a reason all the states which have legalized marijuana are west coast states, and not northeast ones. This also happens to correlate with toll roads, and it's not a coincidence.

BTW, the population density of metro areas in California is higher than most places in the northeast.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by someguydave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:35PM (#11625777)
I perceive the income tax as helping the rich roll rocks on the upper-middle labor class while getting the poor to cheer them on. Most rich don't want competition or independent power bases to develop from bourgeois power bases.

Also how is taxing labor in any way liberal?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by thegp on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @03:27AM (#11626778)
What specifically makes you perceive that?

And for your last question:

1. What is your working definition of liberal(positive vs. Negative freedoms)? 2. Income tax taxes... Income. Not labour. Ideally not discriminating between capital and labour income.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by someguydave on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:07PM (#11633471)
>What specifically makes you perceive that?

The rates for long-run capital returns and dividends are such that they are very beneficial to owners of capital, and they like to keep it that way. The upper-middle class folks who are working have their labor and ordinary income taxed at increasingly higher marginal rates. The rich often fund demagogues who talk about handouts for the poor while ensuring that "progressive" tax rates remain high on their potential rivals who pay high labor taxes.

>1. What is your working definition of liberal(positive vs. Negative freedoms)?

Today, I think the word "liberal" means "someone who thinks that the poor should benefit at the expense of the rich, through government coercion"

>2. Income tax taxes... Income. Not labour. Ideally not discriminating between capital and labour income

Why tax income? Why not your bodyweight? Or height? Why not tax consumption? If the answer is "to punish those with high _incomes_" you are in violent agreement with the ultra-rich.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by brightball on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:50PM (#11624128)
By bipartisan support, I mean that if you want to get a basic income to appeal to people on the right you can appeal to existing branding. FairTax is just a basic income with a smaller stipend. Brand it that way. When you co-brand it with the ability to gut a lot of existing federal programs so that they can be reformed without inducing panic that will also garner support.

Consumption tax paired with a BI would significantly raise the offset at which it starts to affect people.

Things that hurt the middle class much worse than a consumption tax are an income tax that is a percentage and continually increases in that percentage until the percentage caps at the point that most people would call "incredibly wealthy" (IMO).

The perk to something like a Fair Tax is that it's also an economic solution to illegal immigration. If you're in the country, you're paying taxes. If you're legal, you're getting the BI/stipend. If you're illegal you are basically paying to be here. It guts a big portion of the cost argument.

A FairTax + Basic Income hybrid solution could solve a vast majority of hotly debated issues in this country.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by specialist on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:33PM (#11624406)
"if you want to get a basic income to appeal to people on the right you"

Basic income is a conservative proposal (now gaining support among us liberals). My trog relatives are pimping the idea to me, a screaming pinko socialist hippie.

The conservation appeal, rationalization of BI is fairness. It lifts the floor for everyone, doesn't reward cheating, doesn't thwart personal initiative, etc. Being easier to admin is a bonus.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gnaritas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:46PM (#11625138)
> Basic income is a conservative proposal

Uh, what? In general conservatives consider basic income as welfare/wealth redistribution and hate the very notion of it. Just because some of your conservative relatives like it doesn't make it a conservative thing, it's very much a liberal policy, not a conservative one.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by specialist on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:31PM (#11625338)
The Conservative Case for a Guaranteed Basic Income

http://theatln.tc/1yydmC9

"The idea isn’t new. As Frum notes, Friederich Hayek endorsed it. In 1962, the libertarian economist Milton Friedman advocated a minimum guaranteed income via a “negative income tax.” In 1967, Martin Luther King Jr. said, “The solution to poverty is to abolish it directly by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.” Richard Nixon unsuccessfully tried to pass a version of Friedman’s plan a few years later, and his Democratic opponent in the 1972 presidential election, George McGovern, also suggested a guaranteed annual income."

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gnaritas on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @12:02AM (#11626087)
Just because a prominent conservative supported the idea doesn't make it a conservative ideal. If you were to poll conservatives on the idea of basic income you will not find wide support for it, you'll hear it called welfare and income redistribution. What the conservative party is now bears little resemblance to what it was in the 60's and a negative income tax is not the same thing as a basic income anyway. You've confused support for an idea among intellectuals for support for the idea of the party. The conservative party in no way supports the notion of a basic income, it is opposed to their very core of what the party is today.

Lincoln for example was a republican, but by today's standards he's a liberal. Basic income is a liberal policy in today's world, not a conservative one by any means. It is very much a liberal policy.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:23PM (#11625312)
> A FairTax + Basic Income hybrid solution could solve a vast majority of hotly debated issues in this country.

Completely aside from the other response, this point is just...wrong. The vast majority of hotly debated issues in this country are not hotly debated because people share a concern but are divided on the best way to address it, such that there is some policy solution that exists which could "solve" the issue. They are hotly debated because people disagree on the first principles of what goals we should seek, not the mechanics of how to address them.

As well as the obvious culture-war issues where this is the case, this is true of much of the immigration debate, many economic debates (where fundamentally clashing ideas of what constitutes "fairness" that should be sought exist), and so on.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:06PM (#11624242)
> By bipartisan support, I mean that if you want to get a basic income to appeal to people on the right you can appeal to existing branding. FairTax is just a basic income with a smaller stipend. Brand it that way. When you co-brand it with the ability to gut a lot of existing federal programs so that they can be reformed without inducing panic that will also garner support.

That's not rebranding basic income to appeal to people on the right. That's rebranding "FairTax", a right-wing proposal, with fairly niche support on the right, despite a small group spending lots of effort trying to promote it, as basic income. Presumably, to gain some support on the left for FairTax. But Basic Income is also a fairly niche idea, and the people that do support it tend to have a fairly specific idea of the features they support and why, and not just be attached to the BI brand, so rebranding FairTax as BI probably won't get you support from left-wing UBI fans, for whom the tie to a progressive income tax is pretty central to their support (though there's probably some on the left who support UBI who would prefer moving to a Georgist Land Value Tax.)

There's nothing there getting you bipartisan support.

> Things that hurt the middle class much worse than a consumption tax are an income tax that is a percentage and continually increases in that percentage until the percentage caps at the point that most people would call "incredibly wealthy" (IMO).

How does that hurt the middle class? (And, incidentally, are we using middle class in the common modern media sense of middle income workers or are we using it in the classical sense of the petit bourgeoisie? Because it makes a pretty big difference in evaluating claims about what hurts them, and to how important that is -- how it affects the latter will, of course, vary from person to person.)

> The perk to something like a Fair Tax is that it's also an economic solution to illegal immigration.

No, its not. (OTOH, the 2001 and 2009 recessions, and the poor distribution of the gains between and after them, was an economic solution to illegal immigration. But a solution worse than the problem...)

> If you're in the country, you're paying taxes.

True without the hilariously misnamed "FairTax".

> If you're legal, you're getting the BI/stipend.

Without the "FairTax", if you can establish that you are legally present (and, for some of these, legally eligible to work, which aren't the same thing) you have access to a variety of public benefits, perks, and, well, the right to work that aren't available if you can't establish that.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:09PM (#11624654)
> Redesigning the tax structure to favour millionaires (massive net beneficiaries because their US consumption expenditure is usually a tiny fraction of their capital gains tax and/or income tax bills)

This hasn't been true in decades. The people ("millionaires") who make ~150K/year pretty much spend all of it. It's the multi-millionaires and billionaires who make millions a year and don't spend that much, but those are the same people whose "income" is mostly unrealized capital gains. Switching to a consumption tax wouldn't materially reduce their taxes because they're not paying hardly any taxes as it is. (And getting rid of capital gains tax would increase economic efficiency because it currently prevents people from selling shares in order to buy better shares unless the advantage of the new shares can overcome the taxes due from selling the existing ones. Which would grow the economy and increase government revenue.) It's conceivable that a consumption tax would cause the super-rich to pay more taxes, because if you want the yacht you have to pay the tax, but there are currently a lot of tricks you can play to convert stock into stuff without paying tax, like selling only the shares that have decreased in value.

The best way to think of a basic income is as a fixed tax refund. A middle class person who pays $10,000/year more in taxes to fund a basic income and then gets the $10,000/year basic income it isn't actually any better or worse off than before.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:01PM (#11624927)
> And getting rid of capital gains tax would increase economic efficiency because it currently prevents people from selling shares in order to buy better shares unless the advantage of the new shares can overcome the taxes due from selling the existing ones.

Getting rid of capital gains tax to encourage reinvestment is kind of silly. Heck, you could tax capital gains as regular income, and still eliminate any drag on reinvestment by allowing deductions for investment so long as the investments for which such deductions were taken were treated as having a zero basis value.

> It's conceivable that a consumption tax would cause the super-rich to pay more taxes, because if you want the yacht you have to pay the tax

Not really. You just structure the transactions to avoid what is taxable, e.g., you buy the yacht at a low nominal price and simultaneously (and completely coincidentally) by some financial investment not subject to consumption tax from the same party at an inflated price.

Anyone who can avoid paying taxes on their income in an income tax system can avoid paying taxes on it in a consumption tax system. (If you have an "unconditionally tax every transfer of money between two parties" system, it gets harder, but that has all kinds of downsides.)

> but there are currently a lot of tricks you can play to convert stock into stuff without paying tax, like selling only the shares that have decreased in value.

Sure, if you only ever sell shares that have lost value, you can avoid paying the (low) capital gains tax, at the expense of always losing money.

That's not a way to maximize your net, after taxes, utility, but if you want to lose money just to avoid paying a small portion of the gain in taxes...

> The best way to think of a basic income is as a fixed tax refund.

I think you mean "fixed refundable credit" rather than a "fixed refund".

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:20AM (#11626573)
> Heck, you could tax capital gains as regular income, and still eliminate any drag on reinvestment by allowing deductions for investment so long as the investments for which such deductions were taken were treated as having a zero basis value.

Which is a de facto consumption tax because it means you only pay tax when you sell securities without buying other securities, which you only do when you want to spend the money.

> Not really. You just structure the transactions to avoid what is taxable, e.g., you buy the yacht at a low nominal price and simultaneously (and completely coincidentally) by some financial investment not subject to consumption tax from the same party at an inflated price.

As opposed to the current system where you work for somebody for a low nominal wage and simultaneously (and completely coincidentally) they "sell" you a car for one dollar. Which in either case will get you prosecuted for tax fraud.

> Anyone who can avoid paying taxes on their income in an income tax system can avoid paying taxes on it in a consumption tax system. (If you have an "unconditionally tax every transfer of money between two parties" system, it gets harder, but that has all kinds of downsides.)

This is not actually that hard. You make the amount of the consumption tax based on the market value of the purchased item rather than the amount you nominally paid for it, with a presumption that the amount you paid is the market value, which the IRS can easily rebut when you're claiming the market value of a yacht is $20.

> Sure, if you only ever sell shares that have lost value, you can avoid paying the (low) capital gains tax, at the expense of always losing money.

It's not actually losing money. You invest in a diverse portfolio of stocks, some go up, some go down, some stay the same. When you want to spend some money you sell the stocks that have underperformed rather than the stocks that have performed well, which (at the risk of selling low) is plausibly what you want to do anyway, and then you pay no taxes because you realized no gains.

Even if all your stocks went up and by the same amount, if you want to spend 1% of the total assets then you still only pay tax on 1% of the gains because the rest of the gains are still unrealized. So it's already effectively a consumption tax as long as you can avoid changing what you're invested in.

Except that it's a consumption tax that taxes only the spending of interest (and earned income) but not principal, which seems to be to the benefit of people with more wealth.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by hfourm on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:01PM (#11624930)
They do need to make a higher tax bracket to distinguish the 150-300k a year people from the 500k+ a year households.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by SilasX on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:48PM (#11625151)
Apples and oranges: millionaires would pay no tax on income, but would pay the full tax the moment the income is applied to consumption -- so sure, they could accumulate wealth untaxed, but in order to enjoy it rather than just stare at it (in theory -- see below), they'd have to pay the full rate. It doesn't seem very relevant to compare progressivity of income in preference to consumption.

With that said, the FairTax is bad for other reasons -- by concentrating all your taxation on something that's relatively easy to hide, you massively increase regulatory and compliance costs. Imagine the blooming industry in recharacterizing consumption purchases as investment purchases! (For the rich, "sufficiently advanced investment is indistinguishable from consumption".)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:11PM (#11622453)
> If you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well.

No, you wouldn't. Flat tax proposals and national sales tax proposals like the "FairTax", have support almost exclusively on the right (and each particular such proposal has minority support on the right.) You won't get bipartisan support for any of them.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by MikeHolman on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @04:14PM (#11631376)
Both flat tax and sales tax disproportionately tax the poor.

The very rich spend less money relative to how much they make, which puts higher burden on the poor than with our progressive tax.

Flat fax is bad, because 40% of the guy making 20k per year is going to severely change quality of like. 40% from the guy making $40 million has much less impact on his quality of life. This is the whole reason for having a progressive tax... Impact of money on quality of life doesn't work on a linear scale, so neither should our taxes.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by T2_t2 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:52PM (#11632213)
If the rich paid taxes...

That's the missing element, not paying. As much as IN THEORY I agree with these ideas, in practice, rich people find all sorts of ways to not pay tax.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by brightball on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:46AM (#11627908)
I've noticed an increasing number of friends who are very left leaning, promoting the Fair Tax lately.

Most of the issue with support for Fair Tax is that it's enough of an overhaul that people believe it to be an unrealistic pipe dream, which is may well be.

One of the big perks of the Fair Tax is that it makes it easier for people to pay off debt and would actually encourage it. That gets a lot of support from many different angles.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nightski on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:21PM (#11624723)
Just to be clear however, the Fair Tax and a Flat tax are very different things that would have wildly different consequences to different people.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:12AM (#11621345)
IMO social security is too much of a hot button issue to touch. I'd market UBI as "social security for everyone" - that sets both the level that people get, and neatly removes the issue of giving both UBI and social security to retirees.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:45PM (#11622234)
>I'd market UBI as "social security for everyone" - that sets both the level that people get

No, it doesn't. Social security isn't a fixed amount, its based on prior earnings, adjusted by a wage index since the time they were earned, put through formula to get a base benefit amount in the year you start drawing them, and then inflation adjusted after retirement.

So calling a UBI "Social Security for everyone" does not, in fact, tell you what the benefit amount would be -- if the benefit amount is calculated anything like Social Security, the program is nothing like a UBI.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:50PM (#11623207)
Sorry, I wasn't as clear about the plan as I could have been.

To be more specific, I'd set UBI at a level that everyone who is currently getting Social Security based on age would rather switch to getting UBI instead. Then I'd discontinue SS and call the UBI program "Social Security", and pretend that I didn't get rid of the entire SS program. Wrap that change up as a package deal along with taxes to fund it, and call it "Social Security for Everyone".

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by forgotmysn on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:53PM (#11625176)
im not sure people are happy enough with the implementation of social security to be sold with that premise. id sell it as a solution to social security, rather than an expansion of it
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by phkahler on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:44PM (#11625130)
"fair tax" is the stupidest thing ever. How do you implement a progressive tax on consumption? You'd have to keep track of every purchase a person makes to know how much they've spent. It's worse than keeping track of income, and it's also a massive surveillance tool. Then there's the whole problem that people who have lower income will pay a higher percentage of it in tax. There is nothing good about that scheme.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pvnick on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:59PM (#11625206)
How come it has to be progressive? Wealthier folks consume more and therefore pay more.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by taurath on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:03PM (#11625229)
Wealthier folks consume less as a percentage of their income than poor people do. If you add a 10% sales tax on food, the poor are hit harder, as a percentage of their income.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by tstrimple on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:58PM (#11630750)
This is such an important point that so many seem to miss. The more income you have, the higher your disposable income. A person who earns $20k per year probably spends $20k per year. A person who earns $50 million a year isn't going to spend $50 million every year. Even if their income skyrockets to $150 million, they likely aren't going to spend $50 million in a year. It's just not feasible. Therefore, any sort of FairTax or FlatTax is hitting the poor a lot more than the rich and is regressive by definition.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by taurath on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @03:09PM (#11630846)
Its a basic fallacy of the fairtax/nonprogressive tax movements that consumption equal to income. It is true, until you have your basic needs met. Go around to your local rich neighborhood - not everyone has the latest Maserati, because their transportation needs are fully met by a cheaper vehicle. If you're well off much more of your income is going to go to investments and savings.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by throwanem on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:34AM (#11620452)
> You get $700 / month from the government for basic income.

I thought the idea was that it be enough to live on.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by skybrian on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:13AM (#11621350)
Doesn't have to be. You could start it out any level. That might be better, giving the system time to adjust.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by brightball on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:56PM (#11624176)
Depending where you live 'enough to live on' will vary. I lived on about $700 / month pretty happily for 4 years in college. Doesn't need to be a desirable long term amount but it does need to solve the problem of the unemployment trade off, namely that if you're getting unemployment and you get a job you lose it. A BI needs to simply ensure that you have a base level and if you get some work, you make more money...period.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by prostoalex on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:08PM (#11622909)
> You get $700 / month from the government for basic income. Your social security, welfare, unemployment, disability, etc is reduced by $700 / month.

What happens to Medicare under that scenario? Some medical procedures, particularly for old people, can exceed that.

Current federal government revenues top out at $3 trillion. Dividing it by a rough population number of 300 million (and ignoring the fact that portion of it comes from corporate income tax, excise taxes, etc.), the revenues collected stand at $10,000 a year a citizen. Distributing $8,400 a year back requires rather deep cuts to every single entitlement program and then some (defense, USPS, air traffic controllers, national parks, etc.)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:48PM (#11624110)
Medicare and UBI would have to be separate programs, just like Social Security and Medicare are today. Poor old people living off of Social Security don't pay their medical bills out-of-pocket, they have Medicare to pay for them.

In a system with UBI, we'd really need to have universal healthcare ("Medicare for all"). Someone making only the basic income isn't going to have any money for sky-high Obamacare premiums, and would likely be on Medicaid. But that whole system is a complete mess, with a lot of people unable to afford Obamacare because their state didn't expand Medicaid enrollment. And now with one of the biggest insurance companies pulling out of the Obamacare exchanges, rates are going to skyrocket even more. There's only two solutions to this: 1) repeal Obamacare and change to a system where people who have no insurance are denied healthcare and are left outside the ER to die on the street, or 2) universal healthcare.

The way politics are going in this country, I predict we'll see #1 before we see #2.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by prostoalex on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:33PM (#11624792)
If one is keeping the largest entitlement program of them all, the originally quoted $700 a month is a bit pie in the sky number.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mac01021 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:35PM (#11625359)
Check out these pie charts to see what money get's spent for each different entitlement programs [1].

It seems like we currently have 2 buckets:

- living money for people who, for whatever reason, have no source of income

- publicly funded medical insurance

It doesn't seem totally unreasonable to classify medical expenses separately from routine living expenses.

The amount of spending in the routine-living-expenses bucket is enough to pay about $350 per month to each of the country's 320M residents.

I think a good proposal is to instate that $350 universal half basic income, replacing social security and unemployment insurance, and then reduce the minimum wage to $0. Even with the rise of a robotic workforce, just about anyone should be able to find work that will pay the remaining 350 if they're allowed to work for little enough.

[1] https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...

Edit / Afterthought: No one currently receiving social security or unemployment will support this proposal because they are all receiving way more than that. More than 700/month, and certainly more than they need to survive.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:24PM (#11625519)
I think you're going to have a hard time eliminating Social Security; the voters won't stand for it. They paid into it, so it seems unfair for them to not get paid back out of it.

What would work, I think, might be a phase-out: for anyone who's getting less in SS payments than the UBI, just replace their SS with UBI. For everyone making more, they don't get a UBI, they just keep drawing SS. (Or, you could say they get UBI plus the difference between SS and UBI.) Then eliminate the SS portion of the FICA tax and stop everyone from paying into it going forward. Then there'll be some math involved in figuring out how much people who partially paid into it get, but the end effect is that SS will cost less and less money until finally everyone's aged out (to the point where the amount they'd draw is less than UBI so we can just cancel SS altogether). It'll cost a bit more in the short term to do it this way, but it's more fair to people who paid into the SS system and it won't get the AARP voting against you.

>Edit / Afterthought: No one currently receiving social security or unemployment will support this proposal because they are all receiving way more than that. More than 700/month, and certainly more than they need to survive.

Again, you'll have to phase it out. Unemployment is an insurance program that people have paid into, just like SS, so of course they expect it to be there if they need it. And it may (or may not, depends on the person and their income) pay more than they need to survive, but if they have a lot of expenses like a big mortgage then that's irrelevant. They've been forced to live in a society where having a job is basically required for survival unless you get on the dole (which prevents you from working, so it's a trap), so unemployment is something the society has created to mitigate risk.

But like SS, it could be phased out (and the taxation from that eliminated). It could probably be replaced with privately-run unemployment insurance though, but it wouldn't be as necessary with UBI.

But your $700/month sounds low to me. I know it's supposed to be a bare minimum, but even that seems too little to me to live on with today's rent prices. I do think the government has a responsibility to do something about that; rents have been driven up far too much by Wall Street, foreign investors, speculation, etc. UBI needs to be enough for someone to live on with roommates (and not more than 1 per bedroom at market rates), in an average cost-of-living area, plus reasonable grocery store bills and a bit extra to cover transportation costs. If it isn't enough for that, it won't work, and it needs to be jacked up until it is. If that means instituting a big tax on Wall Street, then so be it, since they're largely responsible for the cost of living being what it is.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mac01021 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:27PM (#11625733)
I agree with you 100% about the lack of political viability.

But I also think a system that requires taxpayers to fund more than basic living expenses for non-taxpayers is unjust.

Everyone should be able to stay warm and dry, safe and clean, with a soft bed and a healthy diet. Anything beyond that is luxury.

In particular:

- Just because you don't have enough income to pay your big mortgage doesn't mean others should have to pay so you can live in a massive house. Regardless of your previous income, you should sell it or let it be repossessed (and continue to live safely and healthily elsewhere). Otherwise you're asking people who live less extravagantly to fund your own extravagance.

- Likewise, many hardworking people take a roommate to save money. Should they have to pay for other people to live more extravagantly? There is nothing unhealthy or unsafe (in general) about sleeping in the same room with another person, or turning a room that fits 2 people into two smaller rooms.

I think in an average cost-of-living town in the US, you need 300 to 350 to rent a room (all to yourself!), 250 for groceries, soap, razor blades, etc. That leaves 100 or 150 to get around. Certainly not enough for a car or taxi rides. But I think just about everyone should be able to find a place within walking/biking/city-bus distance from the grocery store, though in some sprawly towns it might take a couple of hours to get there.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by majewsky on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:33AM (#11627833)
> Everyone should be able to stay warm and dry, safe and clean, with a soft bed and a healthy diet. Anything beyond that is luxury.

The definition of "luxury" changes over time. Today, you should include internet access in the list of basic needs since it is needed for many forms of social interaction.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:51AM (#11628722)
Here again is another place where we need a lot more government regulation. People who don't work should not be getting $100/month or whatever for internet access. Instead, they should be able to afford a $15/month plan. Over in Europe, they have stuff like that, because they have real regulation, so internet service is much, much cheaper (of course, their internet and telecom companies aren't as profitable as ours; boo hoo). We need to do the same thing here.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mac01021 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:57PM (#11630241)
I've never seen a $100 internet bill that wasn't bundled with other kinds of services.

A more normal number, I think is $50.

If you couple that with the fact that people with out income most likely need to share housing and might as well share in internet connection too, you're already down to $17 per month for broadband.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:38PM (#11633625)
$50 is more like a starting price; they jack you up to $75 after 6 months (been there, done that).

Also, you're assuming someone has internet service where they live and a stable enough situation to sign up for long-term service. I was thinking more like mobile internet service, which is how people in developing countries use the internet (and they don't pay the ridiculous monthly rates we do either).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mac01021 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:13PM (#11629818)
So that I can think about this more concretely - what forms of social interaction do you have in mind?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:49AM (#11628712)
>- Just because you don't have enough income to pay your big mortgage doesn't mean others should have to pay so you can live in a massive house.

Yes, they should. This is the way it is right now. That's how unemployment insurance works: you pay into it as you work, and then draw from it when you're unemployed. (Of course, a lot of people don't bother because it's a huge hassle, but that's beside the point.)

Do you also think that someone who has full insurance on their $90,000 Mercedes shouldn't get a full payout when someone crashes into it?

I do think that unemployment insurance (since it's a government program and not optional) should be phased out under UBI. But "phased out" is the key phrase here, just as with SSI.

>- Likewise, many hardworking people take a roommate to save money.

>Should they have to pay for other people to live more extravagantly? There is nothing unhealthy or unsafe (in general) about sleeping in the same room with another person, or turning a room that fits 2 people into two smaller rooms.

This is illegal. Most municipalities have codes which prevent more people from living in a place than a certain number, based on the bedrooms (usually 1 per bedroom, except with kids). And yes, I think asking people to have roommates (in the same bedroom) is going too far. Housing is this country is cheap: it's cheaply constructed, with cheap materials, and land is plentiful outside of downtown metro areas. There is absolutely no reason for rents to be as high as they are. Instead of trying to force people into unsafe living situations with strangers, the government needs to fix the housing problem. They're not going to do that as long as people like Hillary are in bed with Wall Street and allow speculation on residential real estate.

>I think in an average cost-of-living town in the US, you need 300 to 350 to rent a room (all to yourself!), 250 for groceries, soap, razor blades, etc. That leaves 100 or 150 to get around. Certainly not enough for a car or taxi rides.

This is what I'm proposing. If that's enough for someone to get by in an average location in the US, that's what the UBI should be set at. And $150/month for a car is actually doable: you can get a pretty decent used car for $5k, and if you're mechanically handy (buy tools at Harbor Freight) you can maintain it yourself for next to nothing, and then as long as your commute is short, and with liability-only insurance, the monthly cost for your transportation should be in that range, even better once you get the vehicle paid off (which you can do by doing some extra work for more money, then after it's paid off you can relax and not work as much or at all). But really, affording a car shouldn't even necessarily be part of it (though as I pointed out, if you're frugal and able to do your own maintenance, it's not that expensive; insurance might blow the budget though). There is public transit in places (though it mostly sucks and needs serious revamping; see SkyTran), and people at the minimum could just get by with a bicycle.

The whole point of UBI is so people can get by and not have major financial stress; it literally kills people, by shortening their lifespans. Sticking them in a room with some stranger and not allowing them any privacy at all is not the answer. So the UBI should be set so that they can afford to rent a room (the whole room), buy groceries, and have a little extra (maybe riding a bicycle) so they don't feel completely miserable, and then can go seek employment as they wish for more money.

I do think unemployment insurance and SSI should both be phased out, and maybe unemployment insurance can be a private matter instead, and I also think universal healthcare needs to be instituted. I also think the UBI should be the same for everyone; it's too complicated otherwise, and I don't think people who want to live in Manhattan or other high-rent areas should be given that luxury and funded by the rest of us (otherwise, we'll all move to high-rent locations). People living in high-rent places like that now with government benefits will have to move under UBI; too bad. If $700/month is enough to make all this work, then great, let's set it at $700/month.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mmanfrin on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:48PM (#11623195)

  If you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for 
  basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well
Poe's Law is pinging.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chadzawistowski on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:00PM (#11624205)
I think the comment was earnest. Check out this article: http://www.vox.com/2015/4/2/8332115/rubio-lee-basic-income

  It's called the FairTax, and it would replace nearly all federal taxes with
  a 30 percent national sales tax. That on its own is a regressive idea —
  low-income people spend more of their incomes than the rich do, so would pay
  a greater share of their incomes in sales tax — so the FairTax would give
  each household a "prebate" equivalent to the sales tax they'd pay on
  poverty-level spending. For example, in 2013 the FairTax "consumption
  allowance" for a family of four (two parents, two kids) was $31,020. If you
  spent that much money in a FairTax world, $7,135 of it would go to federal
  sales taxes. So the FairTax provides a $7,135 annual rebate to families of
  four, distributed monthly.

  Make no mistake: this is a basic income. There is no work requirement. You
  get it regardless of whether you make any money. It is a straight-up basic
  income. FairTaxers object to this characterization, saying that because the
  prebate is meant to compensate for taxes you pay on necessities, it's "your
  money being returned to you." But if you live below the poverty level, you
  come out ahead from the rebate. It's just a cash transfer program.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by goda90 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:38AM (#11619995)
Or instead, give it universally to children, but require a certain percentage be saved in some sort of fund that they are given full control of when they turn 18. That way the parents don't have to shoulder all of the expense of a child, but the child isn't screwed over by irresponsible parents either.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by brightball on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:01AM (#11620186)
When they turn 18 they are already going to have access to the BI. I'm not sure of the benefit of a fund rather than directing it to school funding.

Prior to school it would allow parents to pay for daycare, diapers, food and subsidize paternity/maternity leave.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nojvek on Thursday May 05, 2016 @11:41AM (#11637059)
I know of folks who end up many kids to maximize on the welfare per kid. Can you really trust all parents? I've seen some abuse of welfare in my days in Australia.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:46AM (#11620064)
Cool idea. I'd advocate for an age of 25 though.

An 18 year old these days is still a child. Give them a couple years into the drinking age to get their bad decisions out of the way.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by random_upvoter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:22AM (#11620357)
That is mainly because "these days" 18 year olds are no longer empowered to make any relevant decisions. You propose to keep treating them like children for seven more years. The day they become 25 you'll say "My gosh, they're 25 now but they're STILL like children!".

It is my opinion that this huge collective distrust towards youth is one of the biggest hidden problems of today's society. If it was up to me, kids would get a basic income from the age of 14.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:22AM (#11620922)
I think it's mainly because these days, it's much harder for an 18 year old to make an indipendent living than it was back in the day. Today, most people don't even begin their careers until after college, which is usually around 23 at the earliest. When my Dad was growing up, it was not unusual for 16 year olds to begin working full time to support themselves. By 25, most people were already well on their way to marriage. This is not the case today. Today, people who are 18 are usually still dependent on their parents.

It's not the children's fault, either. It's just a fact of the times. More schooling is required than before, and continuous schooling shelters people from having to make many real world decisions. It's easy to live a "don't care" lifestyle during college, only to be hit with reality hard once you graduate. I've personally experienced this.

There is a major difference in meltalities of someone who's been in school their entire life and someone who's been in the "real world" for a few years.

I'm not sure of your age, nor am I suggesting that it would have any negative impact on your perception here, but we seem to have different perceptions of the youth of today. I am 25 years old and I can only speak on my experiences.

And my experience shows that there's not much of a difference in maturity between an 18 year old senior in High School and a 22 year old Junior in college.

However, there's a huge difference between a 22 year old Junior in college and a 24 year old who's been working for a year.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Retric on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:16AM (#11620861)
There are plenty of biological changes from ~18-25 which impact reasoning. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1411647...

In the end all society's have a baby-elder process with many stages. We let 15 year old's risk their and others lives driving multi thousand pound vehicles at 70+MPH. We keep prescription medication behind many additional hoops even for well educated 60 year old's.

IMO, the real difference is how much education people need. A 15 year old can dig a ditch just fine, but cancer research takes quite a bit more. In the end society simply values 15 year old's time less.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:35AM (#11620459)
That's offensive. I am 23 and have lived away from home since I was 17. I've been financially independent since I turned 18.

Don't stereotype.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:06AM (#11620757)
That's quite the accomplishment, and is by far not the norm. I am 25 and have only been financially independent since 23, and even I am the anomaly amongst my peers.

I don't see what's wrong with my stereotype in this case. Most people under 25 are not financially independent, and it's mainly due to the society we live in, not the children themselves.

When my Dad was growing up, people had full time jobs at 16 years old and were married with kids by 25, where as today, the average person doesn't even graduate college before 23.

I'm not blaming the children for that.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:14AM (#11620835)
Stop calling us "children." It's offense and rude. How very convenient that the cutoff of adulthood is your own age—if you're going to insult vast numbers of functional adults, at least insult yourself in the process. Silly child.

First of all, you are in fact wrong. The majority of young adults do in fact live independently. [0]

Second of all, if you think that adulthood isn't reached until 25, why would you be advocating for reinforcing this supposed infantilization?

[0] http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/07/29/more-snake people-living-with-family-despite-improved-job-market/

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Joeboy on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:40PM (#11623587)
> [0] http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/07/29/more-snake people-living-with-family-despite-improved-job-market/

Um, has that url been through this?

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/millennials-to-sna...

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:34AM (#11621030)
The link you posted doesn't seem to work.

[How very convenient that the cutoff of adulthood is your own age]

I chose the number 25 because it is usually a few years after most people have graduated college and have entered the work force. The number 25 is used in many places as a "special" age. Insurance companies, rental car companies, hotel bookings, etc...

[you're going to insult vast numbers of functional adults, at least insult yourself in the process. Silly child.]

I don't know about your peers, but from my graduating class of ~1000, I would guess there were less than 100 who were completely independent by 23.

[First of all, you are in fact wrong. The majority of young adults do in fact live independently.]

I'll do some research on that.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by logfromblammo on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:26PM (#11623945)
I'd like to lend my support to "old enough to realize that the real world sucks".

By that measure, I reached adulthood two weeks short of my 25th birthday. That, of course, was when I was laid off for the first time, just after signing a year-long lease on a new apartment.

That's probably just coincidence, though. I'm sure that many people realized the real world sucks earlier than I did.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gnaritas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:54PM (#11625178)
Most people don't get college degrees, so that's a poor jumping off point to begin with. Near 68% of Americans do not have a bachelors degree. Many who do enroll simply drop out long before graduating.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by techabuse on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:36AM (#11621050)
I see plenty wrong with the stereotype. I've been on my own since 17, too. I'm 28 now. In that time I've worked at nearly every job you can imagine, with no parents to beg money from or go back home to live with. I know what grinding poverty feels like, and how it's all the worse when you actually have a full time job. Doesn't mean I wasn't financially independent. There's lots of us in the same boat.

I eventually ground out night classes while working and job-hopped my way into industrial automation and a halfway comfortable life, so I understand the appeal of passing judgement from a high and mighty place - but don't. It's a particularly pernicious intellectual weakness.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:57AM (#11621216)
I'm not trying to condescend people who aren't financially independent. Maybe the use of the word "children" wasn't the best, because I can see how it gives off that vibe. I am just pointing out what I have observed.

Most people at the age of 23 are not in a position to support themselves yet, which is kind of off-topic w.r.t my original point anyway.

The fact that there are people like you who were able to work hard and make good things happen at a young age doesn't nullify the fact that the average 23 year old is still dependent on their parents.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:01AM (#11621246)
But what I was really getting at is that there is a certain level of judgement/wisdom that is obtained by working hard and living on your own/supporting yourself.

This can be learned at any age (as pointed out by my comment about my Dad working at the age of 16). However, many people today are not exposed to these types of desicions until after they get done school, which is usually at the age of 23.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by themartorana on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:31PM (#11623988)
If that's offensive, I'm not entirely sure you have been participating in the real world. You'd be offended by damn near everything.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by khedoros on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:04PM (#11624622)
Some people are forced into an adult mindset earlier than others. I've known 14 and 16 year olds that could be trusted with more responsibility than most 30 year olds. I've also met 60 year olds with a child's mindset. Clearly, age doesn't cause maturity, but it's certainly correlated with it.

An outlier can't be treated like the center of a distribution. Your own experiences don't mean that most 18 year olds aren't still children. It's not like the government is going to start maturity-testing people to decide when to start dispensing a basic income. They're more likely to test a "representative population" and set the age to the point where 2/3 test as "adult", or use one of the traditional age-cutoffs like 18, 21, or 25.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by slavik81 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:43AM (#11620525)
Many adults make bad decisions their whole lives.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by IndianAstronaut on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:59PM (#11626073)
Probably one of the biggest mistakes is not learning more skills and different skills. In this era of online learning, there is really no excuse for not spending a couple hours bere and there to learn something new or different.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by cujo on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:05AM (#11620206)
Sounds like you should advocated for a drinking age of 25 instead. Or move all those other things you get to do at 18 to 25 also.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:21AM (#11620345)
I think we should actually lower the drinking age. It's currently 21 here. In fact, being 18 really gains you nothing here other than the ability to join the military and get into trouble with the law.

My main point is that a few years should go by after a child enters into the adult world before they have access to a fund left for them.

There's usually a short "reckless" period immediately after graduating high school and college. However, this usually calms down after the initial shock of having sudden freedom wears off.

I have two friends who inhereted $20,000+ sums of money from relatives when they were in their late teens, and both of them pissed it away in under a year. Looking back, both of them seem to regret it.

(Me and my friends are all around 25 years old).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by slavik81 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:25AM (#11620960)
> I have two friends who inhereted $20,000+ sums of money from relatives when they were in their late teens, and both of them pissed it away in under a year. Looking back, both of them seem to regret it.

Would they have learned that lesson without making that mistake? Are you even sure they really wouldn't do the same again?

To quote Time, "About 70 percent of people who suddenly receive a windfall of cash will lose it within a few years, according to the National Endowment for Financial Education."

Just to make the anecdotes match the statistics, I inherented roughly 30k. It remained in my education fund until I finished undergrad. At 22, I opened an investment account. It's been paying dividends for the better part of a decade now.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:40AM (#11621080)
[Would they have learned that lesson without making that mistake? Are you even sure they really wouldn't do the same again?]

It's hard to say. However, I think one really learns the value of money after having been in the work force for a while. I think that experience may have had a positive impact on their decision making had this happened later on in their life.

[To quote Time, "About 70 percent of people who suddenly receive a windfall of cash will lose it within a few years, according to the National Endowment for Financial Education."]

I believe it. But I also believe that the likelyhood of making good financial choices increases with some time spent in the work force. In this case, they had been living a nice lifestyle under their parents when they received the money.

[Just to make the anecdotes match the statistics, I inherented roughly 30k. It remained in my education fund until I finished undergrad. At 22, I opened an investment account. It's been invested in the TSX60 for the past 6 years now.]

You are also on hackernews, a website which consists of generally well-educated people. I'm not trying to sound snotty here, but there's a good chance that you have better judgement than most people.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by slavik81 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:35AM (#11621550)
> I think one really learns the value of money after having been in the work force for a while.

Perhaps you should consider using that as your criteria rather than discriminating based on age. I'd still disagree, but that policy would deprive fewer people than your current proposal.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Unklejoe on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:41AM (#11621606)
True. Even though there's a correlation, basing it off of age would screw some people who are otherwise capable. Point taken.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by PietdeVries on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:13AM (#11620271)
Let me know when you have this thing in place: I will start a "Spring Break Holiday Park" somewhere in the south where beer is $20 and a Rum&Coke goes for $40. Only people from 25 are allowed in.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by maaku on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:04AM (#11621273)
Mildly related, but for a while I've felt we should change the age of majority / self responsibility to age 25. It would improve a lot of things about society...
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by knz on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:26PM (#11622600)
Personally I think the opposite is true to some degree. Age does not guarantee that you are a rational and well informed citizen. I've also read numerous articles about how young people are more tolerant (gay marriage is a good example), moving back into dense urban areas (causing less sprawl and a renewed interest in better public transport and urban planning), and willing to at least admit that major challenges like anthropogenic climate change are real. Society can learn from people of all ages, but often the enthusiasm and free time of youth is what is needed to drive real societal change.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by maaku on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:20PM (#11623880)
I'm not sure what that has to do with age of responsibility? The statistical facts are there to show that people under the age of 25 have generally impaired judgement compared with those over. (Among other things that's why you can't rent cars until 25.)
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by serge2k on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:55PM (#11625630)
Okay, lets also ban anyone under 25 from joining the army.