Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing
by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:50PM
(#11623207)
Sorry, I wasn't as clear about the plan as I could have been.
To be more specific, I'd set UBI at a level that everyone who is currently getting Social Security based on age would rather switch to getting UBI instead. Then I'd discontinue SS and call the UBI program "Social Security", and pretend that I didn't get rid of the entire SS program. Wrap that change up as a package deal along with taxes to fund it, and call it "Social Security for Everyone".
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing
by forgotmysn on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:53PM
(#11625176)
im not sure people are happy enough with the implementation of social security to be sold with that premise. id sell it as a solution to social security, rather than an expansion of it
No, it doesn't. Social security isn't a fixed amount, its based on prior earnings, adjusted by a wage index since the time they were earned, put through formula to get a base benefit amount in the year you start drawing them, and then inflation adjusted after retirement.
So calling a UBI "Social Security for everyone" does not, in fact, tell you what the benefit amount would be -- if the benefit amount is calculated anything like Social Security, the program is nothing like a UBI.