News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Pxtl on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:28AM (#11610770)
Except that Reddit is gradually turning into 4chan. Every time I see /r/all, it's a little more mean-spirited, a little younger, a little more toxic.

Outsourcing moderation and libertarian ideals all sound nice, but when the rubber hits the road it gradually chases normal people away. Reddit just did it it slower because the strengths of their platform and content overwhelmed it... but it's getting there eventually.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by surge on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:19AM (#11611550)
The default sub-reddit's turn into what happens when you have a site populated mostly by the lowest common denominator and posts that appeal to the same. Once it became mainstream the defaults just fell into an Eternal September cycle (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September) that most sites never recover from. However, reddit had a defense mechanism against this in that there are many, many subsections and almost hidden communities or "True*" sub-reddit's for the core/original users who prefer some semblance of thought provoking content or discussion, or at least pretend to.

I generally unsubscribe from all of those defaults (except maybe /r/WorldNews) and almost never look at them, have some lists of subject related sub-reddits I like (ex: tech). There are sub-reddits that have communities in them I haven't found a replacement for elsewhere aside from maybe some private FB groups. There is something to be said for exclusivity or staying obscure. For every /r/The_Donald there is a /r/Sweden, or for /r/SRS and /r/RedPill there is /r/TwoXChromosomes and /r/AskMen. You aren't going to read about the good communities in the news, as polite people having interesting level headed discussions rarely makes headlines.

To me Hacker News is just another sub-reddit like site. I usually see the same links posted in my sub-reddit's as I do HN, and I'd wager the discussion is sometimes better in the sub-reddit's than it is here, it's at least on par.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by pavel_lishin on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:53AM (#11611814)
> I generally unsubscribe from all of those defaults (except maybe /r/WorldNews)

Maybe I don't understand how bad the rest of the default subs are, but the last time I went to the comments in r/worldnews, I saw nothing but awful, racist garbage. Maybe the links and headlines are worth reading, but those comments have completely killed any interest in discussion there.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by dfrey on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:11AM (#11611979)
The comments are probably as terrible as you describe. Keep in mind that the comments on the website of every major newspaper are as bad or worse.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by pavel_lishin on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:47AM (#11612423)
Sure, which is why I always go back to the Reddit comments, instead of reading them there. It's just disappointing.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by byuu on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:04AM (#11611904)
They also think the US isn't part of the world.

I get it, you want a news place that's not all US, all the time. I'm right there with you, but if I am going to "world news", then I expect news from everywhere in the world.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by jdietrich on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:38PM (#11612974)
"World news" is commonly used to mean "news from countries outside of our main remit".

Examples:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world http://www.theguardian.com/world http://www.nbcnews.com/news/world http://edition.cnn.com/world

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by bpicolo on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:38AM (#11612317)
The US is the focal point of basically every other subreddit (e.g. politics), so they specifically go out of their way to be the rest of the world. That's not unfair by any means. If they open it up to US news then that's all it becomes. Call it "WorldNewsExceptTheUS" and you still put US at the focal point.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ultraforce on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:03PM (#11614452)
r/news does that, I don't actually go on r/worldnews and instead just use r/news which has actually a decent variety of news from around the world sometimes, also there are people who work hard to balance off the racist and hateful comments for the sub
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by benatkin on Monday May 02, 2016 @02:25PM (#11614054)
/r/AskMen is a very skewed community too, just not as skewed as RedPill. It's like this all over the site. The whole site disproportionally attracts people who are unsatisfied with their social circles and looking for an alternative. It's like 4chan except people have recognizable usernames, so it feels like people are having genuine interactions with other people.

To see it all you have to do is go to a mainstream subreddit click on a few usernames and read the comment histories.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Pxtl on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:26AM (#11611616)
Yes, but we can't pretend that the low quality of the defaults doesn't affect the quality of the good sub-reddits.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by pavel_lishin on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:54AM (#11611823)
Does it? A subreddit is as good as its moderators; a good team can keep a sub from being flooded with trolls, or even regulars who are unfamiliar with a sub's rules or culture.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by fragmede on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:20PM (#11612790)
It does.

When a really nice niche subreddit is thrust into the lime-light by becoming a default, it usually dies from an influx of low-quality default users. If it doesn't die from that, the moderation team has to really step up their job - a job they're not getting paid to do which means moderation teams get overworked and burned out, and the quit and the sub dies from lack of moderation. If the subreddit is survives that, the more successful approach seems to be for moderation to become very heavy-handed, which does quite well in a number of places, but also forces a change to the subreddit's culture that was doing well before it became a default.

If the answer is to not become a default sub, well, then the low-quality of the default has affected a good quality sub from becoming a default and prevented quality content from reaching more users.

Unfortunately, a good moderation team doesn't just appear, and one way of acquiring talent is to gasp pay for it. Reddit's avoidance of paying moderators results in relying on unpaid volunteers to do the bulk of the work, so good teams are few and far between, and horrible racist troll-y shit is de jure.

Reddit wants to be "the front page of the internet", but when the default not-logged-in front page features shit like "What's the difference between a feminist and a gun? (self.Jokes)" (pulled just now), it's never going to rise above being dismissed as the front page for horrible trolls, racists, and misogynists.

If I'm supposed to make an account then wade through a pile of shit subreddits just to find an AskHistorians diamond or two, how about I just don't wade through the pile of shit at all?

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by pavel_lishin on Monday May 02, 2016 @01:34PM (#11613574)
> When a really nice niche subreddit is thrust into the lime-light by becoming a default

Ah, I didn't realize you were talking about subreddits getting "promoted". That definitely sounds like a nightmare.

I think that quality subs can bubble up slowly, with manageable growth, by virtue of being featured on r/bestof and the like.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ultraforce on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:06PM (#11614487)
I think some would be able to survive even the danger of being a default sub, for example either AskHistorians or AskAnthropologists just straight up deletes any top level comments without a source and are very ban happy leading to questions with only 5 answers, albeit all of decent quality.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by jxramos on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:49PM (#11614919)
This made me just imagine an aristocracy of commentators where once a community grows to a certain size/popularity it locks up and others must be vetted into the group through some process I can't imagine yet.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Tiksi on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:22PM (#11617157)
That's pretty much how every private tracker site has worked. Just s/seed/karma/ ratio and use the same process. Might as well take the whole system where power users/VIP users with higher ratio or who paid can get extra privileges.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Pxtl on Monday May 02, 2016 @05:30PM (#11615824)
Comment karma makes your upvotes/downvotes worth more? Let admins endorse power-users with the power to "bless" people with high vote-power, including a buff to the implicit self-upvote?
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MustardTiger on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:07AM (#11610979)
Reddit is overwhelmingly "normal people". Mean spirited and "toxic" is normal people. Go look at twitter, and tumblr and facebook. They all have the same thing. These sites didn't chase normal people away, they attracted them.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by vanderZwan on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:20AM (#11611057)
> Go look at twitter, and tumblr and facebook.

As much as I despise how close-minded and backwards society is on average, this particular argument doesn't hold. What you see on a social networks is not a likely to be valid data-point for what the average person is like; at the very least it will be heavily biased. SMBC has a very concise explanation:

http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2939

Of course that's just nice a hypothesis/observational humour mix, but it fits with the well-known effect of people thinking the world is a lot worse because the news reports only the negative, or that everyone else in their (virtual) social circle is more happy and successful than them because Facebook shows the most liked posts first.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by goldbrick on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:01AM (#11611398)
More rather, people arguing on the internet are moreso what the average person is "like".

    Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth.
    - Oscar Wilde
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MustardTiger on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:38AM (#11611190)
No, that is purely humor, and isn't related to what I am talking about. There are no sides here. This isn't "people on side X of issue are bad, not like us wonderful side Y people". It is the simple fact that those sites demonstrate that reddit is not driving away normal people. Facebook is the definition of normal people, and they act the same way. And note, I am not saying ALL normal people are mean and "toxic". I am saying having a small vocal subset of the population be mean and "toxic" is normal. What was abnormal was having a higher standard than that, caused by having a small, fairly homogeneous community. Reddit went from abnormal to normal, not the other way around.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by jdietrich on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:40PM (#11612988)
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by valarauca1 on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:08AM (#11611465)
-SNIP-

Missunderstood parent poster

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by vanderZwan on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:48AM (#11611779)
> If/If not a negative vocal minority exists is irrelevant, nor its interactions.

The amplification of the loudest and most brash is the social interaction equivalent of selection bias, or cherry picking, except without it being by choice on the recipients end. How is that not relevant?

Furthermore, a social network is nothing but interactions. That's all communication is: interaction between people.

> All you do is provide a rationalization that the world isn't as bad of a place as the comment section suggestions.

Given that I am responding to a comment that EDIT:appears to argue that the comment section represents "normal people" I think that is a pretty relevant argument. Although GP has since explained that he meant something else.

And no, it is not like hidden variable theory at all, since that argues that there is an unseen explanation of observed effect, without arguing that the observed effect is not representative. I am arguing the observed effect isn't representative to begin with.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MustardTiger on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:53AM (#11611811)
>How is that not relevant?

Because nobody is suggesting that minority is anything other than a minority. Simply that having that minority is normal.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by vanderZwan on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:02AM (#11611880)
Ok, I must be missing something: first you say "this is what normal people are like", I respond "no, it's a vocal minority appearing like they take up a bigger share of society than they are." How can you claim "nobody is suggesting that minority is anything other than a minority" when I am literally arguing that they are, in the sense that they are over-represented on the internet?

And if you are saying "this is what normal social websites look like", just say that instead of claiming that this representation maps to what normal people are like. Because that is what this message reads as:

> Reddit is overwhelmingly "normal people". Mean spirited and "toxic" is normal people. Go look at twitter, and tumblr and facebook. They all have the same thing. These sites didn't chase normal people away, they attracted them.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MustardTiger on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:07PM (#11612631)
I don't understand the confusion. Normal people includes a diverse group of people, including those you would consider "toxic". This is true in real life, and on every mainstream website. Real name policies did not change this. Because this is reality. Reddit has become more like facebook, twitter, etc. Because it has grown, and is no longer mainly a homogeneous little group of tech guys. Saying reddit has driven away normal people because it has become more representative of normal people is absurd.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by forgueam on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:40AM (#11611208)
IMHO, niche sub-reddits are really where Reddit shines. I can't even remember the last time I intentionally visited /r/all. Topic-specific sub-reddits are my go-to source for unbiased information, advice, and birds of a feather.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by vanderZwan on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:52AM (#11611311)
> unbiased information

I agree with you, but just to be pedantic: kinda by definition they are biased; in a way that's what makes them great!

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by overcast on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:24AM (#11611093)
I can't even go on Reddit anymore, in fact I just avoid it all together at this point. I'm sick of the memes, I'm sick of the left wing, hive mind, down vote brigades, and I'm especially sick of everyone just being an asshole to everyone else.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by KKKKkkkk1 on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:05AM (#11611435)
It's funny you mention this, but Reddit was always this way. Nobody remembers this now, but two election cycles ago, Reddit was the Internet epicenter of the Ron Paul reLOVEution that was about to take over the world. That's when I got tired of Reddit.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by frabbit on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:12AM (#11611489)
Left wing? I don't bother with Reddit because they strike me as a herd of authoritarian neo-liberal drones. Left-wing definitely not.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Pxtl on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:34AM (#11612283)
Liberals think Left is too right-wing because of its strong libertarian and racist/sexist contingent, and Conservatives think Reddit is too left-wing because of its hatred of religion and wall-street economics.

The truth is that Reddit is just full of assholes.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by overcast on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:17AM (#11611540)
Reddit is absolutely a liberal dominated forum.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by c0nducktr on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:11AM (#11611977)
> they strike me as a herd of authoritarian neo-liberal drones.

> Reddit is absolutely a liberal dominated forum.

Sounds like you two agree.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by optimuspaul on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:05AM (#11611433)
I don't really go for reddit either for similar reasons. It's not so much the left/right thing, just the general lack of maturity.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by emodendroket on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:36AM (#11611178)
You can just go to some other subreddit with a right-wing hive mind instead. Problem solved.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 55acdda48ab5 on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:13AM (#11611508)
You actually can't. Lefty types show up in pretty much all the otherwise good topical sub-reddits and signal and get their upvotes. There will be some utterly irrelevant aside with Trump bashing, or whatever, on thread about single cylinder engines. There are some guys upthread here arguably doing it, for example.

Ask the lefty signaler to shut up and stay on topic and you get downvoted or even deleted.

Reddit is dominated by entry-ist lefties to the point it's too annoying to read.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 59nadir on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:49AM (#11612441)
> You actually can't.

I had to download Reddit Enhancement Suite today (where I previously didn't bother at work) only to be able to hide r/The_Donald from r/all. It's just fucking everywhere, I can't take it. 50% of the posts are doomsday prophecies and just pure and utter shit. During every US election this happens, and your/their election process is so long you're basically wading in bullshit for 2 years.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 55acdda48ab5 on Monday May 02, 2016 @07:41PM (#11616724)
I'm not talking about /all. I'm talking about how, for example, on the C++ subreddit some lefties lost their shit and ruined a bunch of discussions because some guy innocently mentioned as an aside using the King James Bible as a text corpus for algorithm testing and interview questions. Only a crazy person would care that this guy mentioned using the KJB, but apparently a fifth of the people there are crazy. Which is weird because a lot of the specific crazies are otherwise very smart and interesting people. But they just couldn't let it slide. This is the totalitarian nature of the left.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Kadin on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:54PM (#11617786)
While I can appreciate the annoyance when people take a discussion off-topic, in a threaded forum like Reddit, you always have the option of just clicking the little 'close' button and collapsing a comment and all of its children. This is really the beauty of threaded comments; it lets people have their sidebar conversations in detail, without permanently dragging the discussion there. Everyone else can just continue to respond to the comment upstream of the derail while interested parties hash it out. (Without this, you end up with something like Metafilter, where there's a huge amount of active moderation and fairly severe community-norms-enforcement, much of it aimed towards keeping discussions on track and dissuade trolling / derails.)

And depending on the context of the conversation, I can totally see why placing "the Bible" and "interview question" in the same sentence would attract attention. My internal HR-department DEFCON meter just went up about two points just thinking about it, and I'm certainly less attuned to Bad Ideas than most. I'm not sure that's a reasonable thing to expect people to just leave alone, particularly again when you have threaded discussions so there's not a ton of social pressure against nitpicking.

Reddit does have its share of problems, but given their apparent goal of being sort of the heir to Usenet in terms of an everything-to-everybody discussion platform, rather than simply a subject-specific discussion site, they seem to do rather well. I sometimes think they're insane and hubristic for the whole "platform" ambition, but they're one of the more successful attempts around right now.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 55acdda48ab5 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:22AM (#11618127)
> I can totally see why placing "the Bible" and "interview question" in the same sentence would attract attention. My internal HR-department DEFCON meter just went up about two points just thinking about it

You are the problem and you don't even realize it. You don't realize how crazy you are.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 59nadir on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:42AM (#11618207)
Actually, I'm pretty sure most people reading this thread will have the same reaction, though not about him.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 55acdda48ab5 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:55AM (#11618265)
Your need to pipe in further solidifies my point. It's the totalitarian nature of the left. No dissent from the party line can be brooked.

I am not a christian. I'd be fine with the koran or the bhagavad gita as a corpus. But internet lefties like you two lose your shit and ruin any discussion over mention of the bible.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 59nadir on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:22AM (#11618353)
I don't mind anyone using the bible in any technical capacity during a job interview. It's clearly not about religion. The reason I said what I said is because you keep saying things like "It's the totalitarian nature of the left.". You sound like a character from K-pax, and it's not one of the doctors/nurses.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by 55acdda48ab5 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:39AM (#11618422)
That's some cute back tracking.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by overcast on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:38AM (#11611189)
No, I can't, because if I want information on a particular game/field/whatever, it's been overrun with trash by now. Sure, you can find your little niche subreddits that are civil, but how is that helping me? I don't want to use it, just to use it.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by emodendroket on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:39AM (#11611195)
I didn't mean that comment to be entirely serious; sorry.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by vanderZwan on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:51AM (#11610893)
First "the fappening" attracting juvenile sexist dudebros and alienating the rest, now /r/the_donald (and I'm skipping a lot of drama).

It's not a coincidence that the best subs are the ones where the goals of the sub are clearly defined and the mods enforce the rules with an iron fist (/r/AskHistorians is the best example of this).

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by soapdog on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:19AM (#11611053)
/r/AskHistorians is the reason I started using Reddit. Found some threads by accident, was then amazed with the quality answers and good community. I am but a lurker there but I extract an immense value from it in terms of "having fun online", it is one of my favorite places on the internet.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Yhippa on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:17AM (#11612053)
Can anybody explain how /r/The_Donald even happened? I can't tell if it's serious about Trump or if it's the new containment sub for dudebros. I'm very surprised at how often posts from there show up in /r/all.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by srtjstjsj on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:17PM (#11612760)
Reddit, as a text forum, has a common problem with Poe's law: dry satire is sustained for too long and starts to be taken seriously.

Subs that start as sarcastic mockery become havens (and recruiting posts) for true believers.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by lsc on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:36AM (#11618410)
See... I dunno. I don't think that's the problem, though, at least, that's not my problem with reddit.

My counterexample is Kuro5hin, back when it was still a thing. In the good old days; sure, you could never really be sure who was trolling and who wasn't, but it was usually well-written, erudite trolling. It wasn't particularly repetitive, and it was entertaining.

In my opinion, the problem is not trolling, it's people expressing opinions in repetitive, uncreative and not very entertaining ways. Fundamentally, I believe that the problem is bad writing.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MrRadar on Monday May 02, 2016 @01:10PM (#11613320)
As someone who follows /r/ShitRedditSays and /r/SubredditDrama on and off I find it completely unsurprising. For years reddit has been fertile recruiting ground for racists, sexists, anti-semites, homophobes, transmisogynists, and ableists. This is largely the fault of Reddit's administrators who had a strict laissez-faire approach to content on their site and refused to remove content that was overtly any or all of the above. Hell, getting them to remove /r/jailbait (which, even if the public posts were strictly legal (a few posts were proved not), provided a convenient meeting place for actual pedophiles who would trade illegal content over private messages) required the attention of the mainstream media! In 2015 they created a Terms of Service that bans "involuntary pornography" and content which "encourages or incites violence" or which "threatens, harasses, or bullies" but before then they did not.

The admin's attitude towards speech on their site fostered a strong contingent of posters who posted edgy "ironic" non-politically correct content in what was a relatively safe space to do so. Having a place where this type of speech was normalized attracted people who actually believed those non-PC stances and they posted "ironically" as well until the lines between irony and un-irony completely broke down. A very good example of this is /r/fatpeoplehate. Before it was banned it was one of the fastest-growing subs and their horrible bullying "memes" permeated the site ("found the fattie!"). After it was banned there was a brief shitstorm in which FPH subscribers flooded the site with FPH content but after a few weeks they largely disappeared from the site. Fortunately FPH was nipped in the bud; other hate/bullying groups are established enough on the site that even the removal of their dedicated subs (like the Chimpire network) did/will not drive them off.

You may have also been under the impression that Reddit in general (as much as that can be a thing) was somehow "progressive." This has some truth to it but the events of the past few years have mostly exposed this for what it mostly really was: "brogressiveism." Basically, on any issue that would impact young white middle-class men Reddit will generally hold progressive views. This includes gay marriage, drug legalization, college tuition/student debt, etc. But when it comes to issues that do not affect that demographic Reddit becomes far more conservative. The blistering responses to Black Lives Matter (about racial inequality) and Tropes vs. Women/GamerGate (about feminism and representation in video games) demonstrate this nicely. (That's not to say there are not people who are genuine progressives on Reddit; there most definitely are but they are far outnumbered by "brogressives" and outright conservatives on the most popular subs.)

/r/The_Donald combines both of these traits. It may have started ironically as a way for people to make jokes about a joke candidate, but just as his campaign became serious so too did the "jokes" on /r/The_Donald. Additionally, Donald Trump has enough brogressive views that he can appeal to that crowd without the inconvenience of challenging them to consider people who have different life experiences than their own like true progressive candidates would. Basically, /r/The_Donald is a perfect confluence of issues that have been underlying Reddit for years.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by striking on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:33PM (#11614759)
> strict laissez-faire approach

You mean they allowed speech that didn't tread on the rights of others? I think racism is shitty too, but I'm not going to ban it. And that makes me sound like a bad person, but people's definitions of racism vary extremely widely.

It's not possible to say something without offending someone out there. If you think taking down posts that simply offend you is a good idea (rather than ignoring posts that you don't like and refusing to take those people seriously), then there are other platforms out there.

Better yet, you can make your own subreddit and stop complaining about the others on the site.

Everyone else has as much a right to reddit as you do.

> brogressive

Libertarian?

There's nothing wrong with having a differing opinion.

> blistering responses to BLM [...] demonstrate [conservatism] nicely

So you're saying that people who disagree with BLM in some way are conservative?

I disagree with their methods. Am I a conservative now?

> BLM, GamerGate, Trump supporters

Do you think these groups should not be allowed to use reddit?

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by MrRadar on Monday May 02, 2016 @05:10PM (#11615666)
You are right that at some point what is and is not acceptable speech becomes a judgement call but at the same time some speech is so incredibly corrosive to the health of a community that you must draw that line. All social media sites should be taking that lesson from Reddit.

"If you don't like the moderation just start your own sub" is a nice idea but breaks down in practice. The very reason you visit Reddit is to discover and discuss links. If you don't like how a sub is moderated you can start your own but that doesn't mean anyone else will use it over the other one. If there is a general sub for topic X just starting a sub that is "X with stricter moderation" isn't very likely to attract a lot of users. However, if you frame it as "X for people [pro/anti]-hate" you are going to draw in the passionate minorities of users on either side which will cause extremification rather than moderation. Having an extreme sub may also attract users who are only marginally interested in X but have a deep interest in the hate (for or against) which will cause further extremification.

This extremification can in turn poison the general subs. On Reddit if a link is posted in multiple subs there will be an "other discussions" link which will show you where else that link has been posted. If a news story is posted in both a general sub and a [pro/anti]-hate sub the users from the latter can easily find and post/vote on the general sub's discussion. (Not to mention posting Google-able quotes and outright direct links to other subs.) This was overtly a major problem with /r/fatpeoplehate. If a link (or quote or screenshot) was cross-posted to FPH you could count on FPH trolls to show up in short order and flood the general discussion with their hate. Even when it's not that overt the extreme users can subtly shift the tone of a general sub towards their point of view over time, such as with rampant racism on /r/worldnews.

The most straightforward solution to this that I can see is to 1) moderate general subs so that their tone remains, well, moderate, and 2) ban extremely offensive subs (using the standards of society at large as an indicator of what is too extreme). That's not to say this is an easy task or even clear-cut in many cases and it will prevent some people from expressing their legitimate opinions, but if the thin extremes at the end of the bell curve need to be cut for the benefit of the fat middle on a privately-controlled website I do not see a problem with that. (I do believe that governments should not restrict speech but social media sites are not governments and should not be held to the same standards.)

EDIT: Also, to clarify, the third paragraph of my original post was regarding people's perceptions of Reddit in aggregate, not how it actually is. Reddit (for a time) had a reputation as "progressive" but the reality does not and did not not match this reputation. I did not intend it as an attack on people who have non-progressive views (I obviously consider myself a progressive), I was merely providing examples of how the reality of Reddit's aggregate political views (to the extent that millions of people can be classified as having aggregate political views) are (or can be perceived as) "progressive" on some prominent issues but non-progressive/conservative on others.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by joezydeco on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:19AM (#11611553)
It boggles me that there's no way to filter out specific subreddits on /r/all without using some custom viewer or plugin. Or am I missing something?
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by stronglikedan on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:28AM (#11611632)
Perhaps the FilteReddit[0] feature (under Filters) of RES is what you're looking for?

[0]http://redditenhancementsuite.com/features.html

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by joezydeco on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:05AM (#11611917)
Like I said, is it possible without a browser extension?
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by c0nducktr on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:07AM (#11611936)
It is a paid feature that is part of reddit gold.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by stronglikedan on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:57AM (#11612523)
Oops, missed the "without". Innocent mistake. That, I don't know.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by srtjstjsj on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:18PM (#11612770)
Log in and unsubscribe, visit reddit.com/ instead of /r/all
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by Pxtl on Monday May 02, 2016 @01:50PM (#11613721)
Or even just offer /r/default as an alternative to /r/all that only shows the default subs instead of all the subs.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ultraforce on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:14PM (#11614559)
I find it interesting that with social media sites as big as reddit giant events can happen without users being at all aware this is the first time I have heard about r/the_donald

the only recent dram I have heard about is stuff related to league of legends which is humorously enough the largest sub I am on outside of /r/news

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by gherkin0 on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:01PM (#11612562)
It's really unfortunate that this post about the (final?) end of Kuro5hin.org ended up getting completely derailed and dominated by an unoriginal discussion about reddit.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by jxramos on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:51PM (#11614938)
ha! I didn't even realize I got dragged into the reddit tangent. Thanks for setting us straight
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by homulilly on Monday May 02, 2016 @01:06PM (#11613265)
More than moderation, I think it's just an artifact of their ranking system. It basically guarantees that the only stuff on the front page or top of large reddits is going to be stuff that's shallow and easy (not to mention quick) to consume.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by cwmma on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:39AM (#11611197)
Or is it the same age and your a little older?
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by orionblastar on Monday May 02, 2016 @06:28PM (#11616250)
Reddit when they started to ban subreddits for hate speech and other things, that is when 4Channers came over to cause some trouble.

I never had any problems on Reddit until after they changed their policies, I don't go for hate speech and other things, but /r/Ferguson was about the Ferguson riots and Black Lives Matter and other stuff related to Ferguson, but the racists came in and took it over and then it became one of those subreddits that was in lock down and it warned you about it when you tried to access it. I got downvoted by racists and had to leave that subreddit.

I live near Ferguson and shop there, the people of Ferguson are good people no matter what race they are. The rioters and looters came from outside Ferguson. Maybe people don't always wave back or smile, but they got their own problems they are dealing with.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by benatkin on Monday May 02, 2016 @02:18PM (#11613980)
This. I just deleted my 10 year old reddit account. I might miss a big AMA from a famous person I'm interested in, but I'd rather that they choose another platform besides reddit for taking questions, so I'm voting with my clicks.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by lintiness on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:38AM (#11610826)
unsub to all the political nonsense, and reddit's still a valuable resource.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ihsw on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:51AM (#11611794)
He said /r/all and not the default subs.

/r/all is generally a cesspool nowadays, especially with all the #TREMENDOUS /r/the_donald shitposts.

I have seen Trump-tier shitposting leak into /r/China and other completely unrelated subs as well.

It's getting out of hand.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by lintiness on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:39AM (#11612328)
you must have missed all the bernie sanders stuff.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by xienze on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:08PM (#11612645)
Well it was OK then because it agreed with his worldview, you see.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ihsw on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:42PM (#11613008)
Oh come on now, despite being a Trump supporter I find it 9/10 crude and tasteless.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by karmajunkie on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:06AM (#11610966)
I use it almost exclusively for Elixir stories. I think for very narrow topics it still has some value. Then again, I've never been a serious redditor, so take that with a grain of salt. I miss the old days of slashdot...
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by pjc50 on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:54AM (#11610909)
The politics leaks everywhere, except in the most heavily moderated subreddits like AskHistorians.

Not to mention that reddit doesn't police offensive usernames.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by TeMPOraL on Monday May 02, 2016 @09:01AM (#11610950)
Fortunately usernames are short, limited, and easy to filter out visually; there's no space to put something actually offensive in them. It takes one going out of their way to get offended for one to have a problem with Reddit usernames.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ilitirit on Monday May 02, 2016 @11:18AM (#11612060)
r/all looks nothing like my front page.

While it's arguably true that the level of discourse is not what it was 5 years ago (or maybe my interests/world view has changed - probably a combination of both), a (personally) curated list of sub-reddits is still 100x better than the default reddit.

Re:RIP Kuro5hin by oliyoung on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:18PM (#11616893)
depends on the subreddits - r/nba, r/hiphopheads, r/comicbooks are all great quality communities
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by ak_wa on Monday May 02, 2016 @02:00PM (#11613814)
It feels so incredibly good to watch them slowly getting corrupted. After the cancer they introduced to 4chan, they deserve it.
Re:RIP Kuro5hin by nobody_nowhere on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:34AM (#11610805)
Regression to the mean...