News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by laxatives on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:35AM (#11010368)
6/10. I'm less than 3 years into my career, but I think I've worked for some of the best companies with great pay, benefits, environments, etc, including a tech giant and two startups. End of the day though, work is boring. Its always work. Your time and effort is going towards making someone else rich and their priorities are more important than your own.

The only things I really look forward to are vacations and events outside of work. Learning things is always exciting and sometimes its extremely rewarding getting a project (or even a feature) off the ground and seeing a company rise and beat projections. But then a few weeks later, its just back to work and nothings really different. Its a temporary victory at best, then expectations just get higher and more grind.

The best you can possibly hope for is enjoying the people you work with and getting a couple good exits. I'm never married to my work and I would be incredibly depressed if I allowed it to define me as a person. It pays the bills, and generally pretty well.

Even compensation wise, it peaks very early and probably won't get most rich without a ton of luck. Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make. Granted, the barrier to entry is much lower in CS (sometimes nearly nonexistent depending on the line of work).

edit: Reading some of the other comments made me realize how dissatisfied I am with this line of work. On average, the people really are incredibly boring, especially at large companies. It is true that it is dominated by men and many are socially awkward. Its even worse that I think being on a computer for so many hours a day for years at a time makes everyone a little less socially adept, at least compared to the sales folks who spend most of their days on the phone. I'm literally spending my weekends looking for the most reckless and dangerous things I can do (lately its been surfing 2-3x head high waves, before it was motorcycling through snow/ice storms) to compensate and its completely unhealthy.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by onion2k on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:19AM (#11010493)
Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make.

Why not make a much less depressing comparison and compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff? Compare a typical developer to a typical retail worker and we get way more money for way less stress. We're not at the top end of the scale, but we are nowhere near the bottom either.

We get to sit in comfortable offices, working on interesting projects (mostly), building things that make a difference to people, without getting dirty or abused by the public, and we're pretty well paid for it on the whole. And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

I've been a professional developer for over 20 years, and I've enjoyed most of it. It afforded me the opportunity to do my own startup for a while, and when that failed it was easy to get back in to work with a job that pays quite well. I certainly wouldn't want to do anything else.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by LoSboccacc on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:25AM (#11011121)
> compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff

apples to oranges.

we're highly specialized knowledge workers. well most of us are, so it is more fair to compare with bankers, lawyers, medics, architects, politician and middle managers which can count on a year to year income growth instead of having to playing idea lottery.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by agentultra on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:45AM (#11012366)
I'd compare us only superficially to capital-P Professions like lawyers, architects, engineers and the like. There are no bar exams to get a license to practice programming in the industry; no liability -- it's really easy for people to misrepresent themselves and for companies to take advantage of us.

Comparing us to retail workers has some merit. We're not professions, have no collective representation, and can be easily replaced (despite current myths about how difficult it is to hire programmers there are hoards of new graduates and self-taught individuals making the leap from other careers and professions because of the money and cushy benefits -- most hiring processes seem to be designed to keep the majority of people out).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by vinceguidry on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:07AM (#11012080)
I wouldn't exactly call developers highly specialized. Specialized developers work in a tiny niche and make lots of money by being one of the very few in that niche. Any of us could potentially become specialized, but very few of us actually are.

Hell, most of us could jump fields without losing steam. Systems administration, security, database administration, all of these can be done by a decent developer.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:45AM (#11012371)
At some level. But I would never hire a developer to do security, or sysad. Because they have the wrong mindset for it. I want some OCD single-minded person keeping my network safe. Not someone who like to just 'get it done' as efficiently as possible. Totally different goal, and to be really good at it takes a different person.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Chris2048 on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:23AM (#11011553)
Arguably, none of us are chartered. But I agree, you have to compare like-for-like.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:51AM (#11010780)
On one hand, yes, absolutely. We have much better than the vast majority of the people and there are times when it doesn't feel right to complain about it.

On the other hands, it's turtles all the way down until you reach "well, we are still alive, at least that's something".

While some humility and reality check is good, aspiring to have something better (be it in the monetary terms or whatever drives you) is also important to make progress.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by yodsanklai on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:58AM (#11011022)
> Why not make a much less depressing comparison and compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff?

Some software engineers undertook difficult curriculums in highly selective universities. In that case, I think it's understandable to feel a little bit depressed when comparing to former classmates in more prestigious fields. Personally, I have to admit that sometimes I feel that way (even though I'd probably do the same if I could go back in time because I love this field).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Philipp__ on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:34AM (#11010954)
We get to sit in comfortable offices, working on interesting projects (mostly), building things that make a difference to people, without getting dirty or abused by the public, and we're pretty well paid for it on the whole. And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

Very well said.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by spacecowboy_lon on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:11AM (#11010864)
Less stress? Retail workers turn up a 9 leave at 17:30 - they dot get called up outside of work in an emergency to fix some one elses code that causing a problem.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dagw on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:17AM (#11010901)
If I'm 45 minutes late for work 3 days in a row with no good excuse, no one gives a fuck. Retail worker shows up 45 minutes late one day and they're most likely fired. I also don't have to worry about people fucking around with my shifts and thus how much money will be in my next paycheck.

Having even a modicum of job and financial security removes so much stress from your life.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Amezarak on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:25AM (#11011339)
> If I'm 45 minutes late for work 3 days in a row with no good excuse, no one gives a fuck.

Unfortunately it doesn't work that way for all developers. At my last job there were continual reminders and reprimands for being even five minutes late.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by arethuza on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:51AM (#11011439)
In my first job ~25 years ago I got told off for coming in 5 minutes late even though I had gone on to a customer site at 9pm the previous evening and worked to ~1am to fix the problem.

Left there after 9 months and have never worked anywhere like that since.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by knodi123 on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:42AM (#11012341)
you've heard of "code smell", right? that right there is a "career smell".
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by logfromblammo on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:19PM (#11013867)
If you are a salaried exempt employee, you should not have to put up with that BS from timeclock nazis. But it is all entirely legal, and for many companies, obeying the letter of the law on paper is the only requirement for corporate policy.

Sadly, without the muscle of collective bargaining to back you up, your only real options are to politely beg your management to stop being timeclock nazis, or to leave for greener pastures.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dizzystar on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:26AM (#11010929)
In retail, you don't get free food / liquid. You have to stand on your feet all day. Customers are allowed to scream at you and you have to figure out how to make them happy. Bosses are more than happy to fire you because, let's be honest, there are 1,000 others that can do your job. No guarantees of a 40 hour work-week. No paid holidays, no benefits. Raises are like 25c, and that is only if the boss really likes you and you aren't in a union, shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve... (don't care to continue)
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Amezarak on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:30AM (#11011358)
> In retail, you don't get free food / liquid.

Water is free, most likely. I've never had free food programming, beyond nutra-grain bars, once.

> Customers are allowed to scream at you and you have to figure out how to make them happy.

Toxic clients exist in the programming world, too. And as a low-level peon, you have a lot more leeway in telling an abusive customer to get out than you do a multimillion dollar client.

> shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve...

Still happens for developers.

As strange as it may sound, I think I personally was happier waiting tables. But it wasn't going to pay the bills. In general, I totally agree that most people, all things considered, are better off programming. But let's not overstate our case. :) There are definitely some programming jobs which are light-years better than any retail job because e.g., you don't have to deal with customers, but that's not all programming jobs.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by chrshawkes on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:49AM (#11011671)
Try crawling around in asbestos filled attics or rat infested crawl spaces for 12 bucks an hour.

Programming is much easier than so many professions I've had in the past it's absolutely unbelievable.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by callinyouin on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:18AM (#11011829)
I was a "pest control technician" (exterminator) before I started programming professionally, so I know how you feel. My life now is a cakewalk by comparison.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by bobwaycott on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:34AM (#11012280)
Oh, man. At 16-17, I used to do that installing HVAC systems. At 21-22, I worked in a factory to support a family. Then I spent the next 3.5 years selling cars. Finally said, "Fuck this", and decided to start programming as work instead of just play.

Even the worst days of the last 9 years have never been as hard as the best days before it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by mathgeek on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:57AM (#11011454)
> I think I personally was happier waiting tables.

Sometimes, the social aspects of your job outweigh other factors. Throw in the simplicity of jobs like waiting tables, and I've found that it can be a lot of enjoyment.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by cableshaft on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:20AM (#11012186)
Ignoring the financial aspect of it, I actually didn't mind working in a department store all that much. During downtime you got to socialize with coworkers (many of whom were female), during busy times the time just flew by, you got to move around a lot and be active, you weren't expected to know every detail about everything you were responsible for, just be able to answer some basic questions about certain products ("Why is this more expensive? Which one is best for situation X?"). Also your friends could stop by your workplace to chat from time to time.

As for the no guarantee of 40 hour work week... well, again ignoring the financial aspect of it, only working 20 or 30 hours a week was much more enjoyable than 40-55 hours (or even higher at some places) work weeks.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by knodi123 on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:44AM (#11012353)
> shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve.

Haha, try working as a developer supporting a retail-based operation! Our company pulls all-nighters on black friday and christmas eve.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pjc50 on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:31AM (#11011148)
There are plenty of people on so-called "zero hours" contracts who don't know from day to day when their working hours will be, may be called in at short notice to work an off shift, and have no predictability of pay.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by 3minus1 on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:40AM (#11011400)
there are plenty of programming jobs where you don't get bothered outside of work.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by jkereako on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:13AM (#11012122)
I assume you have never worked in retail.

As a retail worker, the pay is at or just above minimum wage and benefits like PTO and health insurance do not exist because the jobs are usually part time. Additionally, retail work always comes with irate customers who will piss you off, your coworkers off and your bosses off. So everyone is angry. Retail workers often do not have a set schedule, this is especially true during the holiday season. They have to find coverage before taking an unpaid day of leave. Lastly, because no real skill is needed to work in retail, workers are easily replaceable. 1 mistake can get you canned.

How is a situation like that more stressful than being on call of which you get paid to be on?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by spacecowboy_lon on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:08AM (#11026002)
I don't think payment for on call is the norm in the USA - it can be very lucrative in the uk I knew of people on 4 in 4 who got called twice a year.

15 Years ago it was £400 for 1 in 4 plus Toil (time off) for time worked

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:46AM (#11012909)
> And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

This reads like a sales pitch for the lottery, and as a random developer, your odds are pretty similar.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by timwaagh on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:47AM (#11010770)
its not a good comparison since retail takes absolutely sero education or brains.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:56AM (#11010803)
While I see your point (and I agree a bit), it's not exactly fair to put it this way.

There are many people working in these industries who didn't have much opportunity to get decent education, etc. For example, my parents. They are from rural areas from Soviet Union, where getting higher education was not something that goes by default as it is now (which might not be a great thing given the number of people with worthless law/business management degrees from the bottom 10% of universities... oh well).

Obviously, there's a segment of people who didn't give a crap and held an attitude that education is for losers / nerds (before the word 'nerd' was cool) and I don't have much for them sympathy.

So it's not fair to just disrespect everyone working in the retail as 'zero brains'.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by timwaagh on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:27AM (#11010933)
I'm saying the job requires zero brains or education. I did not mean to imply people who work in retail have no brains or even less than average. in my country it's not really a legit career choice. it's mostly high school kids or people under 23 who do it as it's compensated below adult minimum wage. after a certain age you either get promoted or fired.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:56AM (#11011014)
I see, sorry for getting you wrong.

Meanwhile in Lithuania, it's fairly typical that the majority of people working in retail are in their 40s and been doing that for the last ~20 years with very minimal increments in salary (usually because of increased minimal salary).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by mantas on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:29AM (#11011571)
It's not about disrespect. It's about how much effort you put in to get to that point.

How much effort is needed to get a cashier position? Show up, be sober - you got a job. Many people in IT started learning the ropes in their own time after school. Although it was a hobby, it was still an effort that turned out to be helpful in job market.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sotojuan on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:47AM (#11011971)
Here in the US it's not so different. When I was 20, I worked at Target when I took a semester off school. I think only two or three of my coworkers were around my age. The rest were 30+.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by VLM on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:40AM (#11011624)
Meaningless class based prattle

Hardest management job I ever had - working night shift manager at a food store while going to college during the day. Like surviving a hurricane while running a marathon while the building's on fire, every single night. I lived roughly a decade of "real" management in my senior year.

Cashiering required a surprising amount of memorization of obscure procedures and policies and item codes, not to mention carefully tracked flawless arithmetic skills when giving change.

The general manager was an artist of endcap design. At non-megacorp retail you're on your own when designing displays. Its truly an art. At the megacorps you have teams of CAD drafters, graphics artists, and sales consultants designing displays, at a non-megacorp story you have yourself, and the boss expects you to do as good of a job as the team. Teams are usually much less productive than individuals, so its not as hard as it sounds.

Stock clerk at higher levels was insane. Its really a two level job and the new hire teen kids merely threw product on marked shelves, but if you were there more than a year and were not an idiot you watched the more experienced guys and took over for them, after which you spent all your time on rotations and resets and price changes and sales stickering and being a reception clerk for the 50 or so direct store delivery trucks we had. I don't care if you have 20 pounds of soup cans for a 10 pound shelf, make all of them fit somehow and you need to accept deliveries from dairy and bread and beer and you have two hours until break time to get this all done plus or minus helping out everyone else.

I've noticed over many decades that despite enormous quantities of (self serving) propaganda, the hourly pay rate people get generally has little relationship with how difficult or important the job is, on a large enough scale.

Another interesting observation is the dumb people didn't survive on the job nearly as long as the smart people, and the dumb people absolutely suffered horribly compared to the smart people.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by solotronics on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:34PM (#11013380)
Anecdotes like this make me wonder what will people in the bottom 1/4 of the bell curve do for a living in the future?
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dagw on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:20AM (#11010909)
Depends very much on the retail job. If you're expected to sell stuff and work on any sort of commission, then retail jobs take a lot of (a certain type of) smarts if you want earn good money.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Kluny on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:45PM (#11013494)
Retail managers certainly act that way, but I wish it weren't so. The one thing that has the potential to bring me to a brick and mortar store instead of buying online, is the chance to talk to an employee who is an expert on the product. Sadly it doesn't happen too often. Usually you get someone with enough brains to operate a cash register and no more than that. Ask a good question, you get a blank stare in return. Or they tell you to google it. And because they get paid garbage money, they often can't even afford to buy the product they're selling, so they don't have firsthand experience with it. Could be so much better...
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sdgsfsfgfg on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:34AM (#11010718)
But the thing is I could have been an MD, lawyer or someone in finance - these things were well within my reach. But I was sold a false dream and now I am stuck in misery.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by rifung on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:31AM (#11012762)
Why not just switch? Is it too late? You can always take out loans if it's money; that's what most people would have to do anyway I imagine.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by endzone on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:07AM (#11026791)
working conditions in all of those industries are terrible compared to almost all software jobs. and the work in finance and law is tedious. you're dreaming.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by zzalpha on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:44AM (#11010574)
Uhh... I have to ask: what, exactly, were you expecting? Exhilarating highs and a path to millions?

It's a job. Most people don't have jobs that'll make them "rich". Be glad you aren't living paycheck to paycheck, or worse, are unemployed because the job you had was optimized away with computers.

To be blunt, there's a sense of entitlement evident, here, that I have trouble grokking. You get to spend all day in a comfortable office working with no more than your hands and brain making double to triple what a day labourer pulls in with a hell of a lot more effort.

And your complaints are, what, you have to hammer someone else's nails, the work is repetitive, and it isn't a fun party every day while you amass untold riches?

Look, I get being dissatisfied. Humans love looking at that greener grass on the other side of things fence. But appreciate what you have. Seriously.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dikdik on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:48AM (#11011210)
This is a horrible comment. There is 100x more to a career than living a comfortable existence.

Personally, I want to feel purposeful at work and that I am contributing to a better world. I also absolutely require regular challenges or I end up severely depressed. Also, I have undertaken extensive education partially as a way of raising my standard of living and having a more enjoyable life outside of work.

THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS TO DO WITH YOUR LIFE! Yea, it's not always going to be a party, but there's a hell of a lot more to it than sitting in air conditioning. And you're allowed to demand a hell of a lot out of your career as long as you are willing to put in the work to get it.

My search for a challenging and intrinsically and extrinsically rewarding career brought me to study the life sciences. Then I ended up in a healthcare company doing menial crap and then a graduate degree in bioinformatics. I'm looking through job-ad after job-ad, and while the occasional one looks challenging I am absolutely terrified that I am going to end up as a desk-monkey who doesn't interact with people and again gets no challenges.

I hope I am wrong and I can make this career work for me, but I am already looking at applying to medical school in a year if can't find a challenging and decently rewarding job in bioinfo. Sucks, because I had originally intended on being a doctor when I was in undergrad but went in another direction because I wasn't 100% sure about it at the time. Unfortunately, I am 100% sure I do not enjoy being a desk jockey.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by lgieron on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:14AM (#11011296)
> This is a horrible comment. There is 100x more to a career than living a comfortable existence.

I thought so too. However, the funny thing with market economy is that it IS pretty efficient, so jobs that are regarded as satisfying and challenging are approached by so many talented people that they don't have to pay very well and the conditions are usually not great.

The solution is to either accept that the role of a career is to get to you to early retirement ASAP (Mr Money Mustache style) or to get excited about something that most people don't care about.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by user24 on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:21AM (#11011321)
> jobs that are regarded as satisfying and challenging are approached by so many talented people that they don't have to pay very well and the conditions are usually not great.

Agree! If I could be a florist on a developers salary I would jump at it and never look back.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dikdik on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:42PM (#11016913)
Yes, I am beginning to realize that a lot of people actually don't want to bang their heads against the wall regularly at work. I do, though :/

Solving an insanely hard problem I have struggled with for days, weeks, or months is the most satisfying thing I've ever experienced.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by forgetsusername on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:15AM (#11011299)
>Personally, I want to feel purposeful at work and that I am contributing to a better world.

And yet you are depending on your employer to provide you with this?

>but I am already looking at applying to medical school in a year if can't find a challenging and decently rewarding job in bioinfo

I see you running into the same issue.

Just because you've received "an education" doesn't entitle you to a glamorous, exciting job. You'll probably have to make that yourself.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dikdik on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:50PM (#11016954)
They don't owe me a purposeful, challenging job with a livable wage you are ABSOLUTELY right. However, I don't owe anyone 40+ hours a week when I get nothing out of it but the ability to pay rent and eat.

I am okay with dying. I don't see a point in living a life where I spend my days contributing to a company that does nothing for the world and I am bored out of my mind. I would rather work at McDonald's if that's the case. I am being serious! Money is only a secondary goal.

My ultimate goal is to work for myself and I will at some point. Hopefully that means starting a company focused on genomics, big data, or healthcare, but if not I will buy a gas station and run it myself.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by kaitai on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:42AM (#11011630)
THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS TO DO WITH YOUR LIFE! And you're allowed to demand a hell of a lot out of your career as long as you are willing to create it.

No one will ever just give you an interesting career tailor-made for you. Find out what is interesting, fulfilling, and challenging, and make that your career over time. You start in your company doing menial crap but then move to interesting crap over time, by being intentional about what the company needs, what you need, and how you can leverage one to get the other.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dikdik on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:20PM (#11017088)
I spent 4 years in a healthcare company in a job that REQUIRED a BS in the life sciences. I never had single day where I was challenged by the goals set by my managers. For 2 years I doubled those goals every single month, some days I was able to quadruple those goals. I was the highest performing one in the department, I asked regularly for new "opportunities" only to get more crap that would not have been challenging for me at the age of 15.

I am sorry that doesn't fit with your world view, it was the worst experience I have ever had and I won't go into another job where they promise me career growth, opportunities, and challenges after I "prove myself." I've already wasted a HUGE amount of time, the past 4 years have been extremely inefficient compared to what I could have been learning in a challenging job.

The only reason I went to college was because I thought it would lead to a job that was actually challenging. My parents never had those, they don't have beyond a high school education. So fuck me for believing education could lead to a challenging job (and you better believe I am prepared for extensive work on top of my education). I've been working since I was 15, I had a full-time job the last half of my senior year in high-school as a stock room manager and yet I still have never had a regularly challenging job. I have never had less than a stellar performance review.

BUT, all my experience isn't the right experience. It seems I am assumed to be borderline mentally-retarded on anything I have not done 100x before.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by kendallpark on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:38AM (#11012313)
> I hope I am wrong and I can make this career work for me, but I am already looking at applying to medical school in a year if can't find a challenging and decently rewarding job in bioinfo. Sucks, because I had originally intended on being a doctor when I was in undergrad but went in another direction because I wasn't 100% sure about it at the time. Unfortunately, I am 100% sure I do not enjoy being a desk jockey.

Do it. I'm a programmer in my first year of med school. Love every single day. Beats sitting in a chair from 9-5 pounding in to a computer. FWIW I still do a ton of programming on my own.

Also, the field needs more doctor-programmers. You'll find boundless areas to apply your CS skills. Plus, if you don't try, I think you'll always wonder: what if?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by laxatives on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:05AM (#11018007)
How did you make this transition? Did you take the necessary course work in school, or take time off of work? Where do you get meaningful recommendations after leaving school?
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by rifung on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:18PM (#11013202)
While I agree with many of your feelings, I think you should try to think of this in a more positive way. Many other people go into med school without really having any professional experience at all or knowing what they are signing up for. You on the other hand now can be pretty confident that if you do go to med school, it's what's best for you.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by PhasmaFelis on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:51AM (#11010781)
A lot of the loudest voices in tech are people who appear to be rapturously happy and fulfilled working 10-12 hour days. It's easy for young people to get the message that good coders love working all the time, with the obvious corollary that if you don't feel that way, you're not a good coder. It's not an accident--spreading that idea makes it easier to buffalo people into the ruinously long hours that some parts of the industry are infamous for.

It's important to cut through the 10x rockstar ninja buzzword bullshit and remind people--especially young people--that most coders are working for the weekend just like anyone else.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by zzalpha on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:05AM (#11012529)
This, right here, is a brilliant comment.

The pop culture obsession with the valley tech industry, and the resulting insane expectations folks hold when entering the industry, is a disservice to us all.

I love the work I do. It's not life changing. It's not going to make me rich in money or in spirit. It's a cushy lifestyle job that gives me the time and monetary freedom to do the other things I'm passionate about.

But that doesn't align with the fantasy of the valley, or frankly, the American protestant work ethic.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by wr0ngway on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:02AM (#11011249)
Working with your brain takes just as much effort as working with your muscles. Think back to taking a multiple hour exam in school, and how knackered you'd feel at the end of it. Now imagine doing that for 8+ hours every day, trying to solve problems that you don't even know have a solution. Yes, your body may still be ready to go, but there's nothing left upstairs to make it happen.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pikzen on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:51AM (#11011997)
Oh come on.

Working with your brain is a breeze. Yes, you get mentally exhausted. Eat some damn sugar, problem solved. You know what you don't get, that manual workers do ? Crippling disabilities, having no energy left once you get home, a terrible salary, dangerous work conditions.

We have it easy. Stop lying to yourself.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by LesZedCB on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:50AM (#11012407)
Exactly. My partner hates it when I mention that I had a boring day with little interesting to work on, so I spent a couple hours reading reddit. Meanwhile she works in a fast-paced, no stopping, energy draining customer service managerial job. She hardly even gets breaks, no less time for catching up on your favorite internet blogs.

And yet, for some reason, I get paid almost three times more than her per hour.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by joesmo on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:07AM (#11012543)
You've obviously never heard of repetitive stress injuries like carpal tunnel and others. Your brain doesn't do the typing/pointing and such crippling injuries are fast becoming the norm in most long-term tech workers. For some, it's putting them out of a job or even out of a career. Easy my fucking ass.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pikzen on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:25PM (#11013294)
Boo hoo hoo

Now, I hate the "but other others have it worse" logic, but let's go ahead. I have a family member who was a mason. Started at 16. He is now 45, is unable to do anything properly because his back is completely busted.

I'd love to say that this is an isolated case. I'd love to say that the other construction workers I know are in better health. And I'd love to say that percentage of construction workers with health problems is extremely low. But they're not. Their job is physically hard. They're laying bricks, moving things, moving around on roofs. The body can take it, but not for too long. And they can't take breaks, because their job doesn't allow it. Their body is perpetually being used, and all they can do is reduce the rate at which the damage is done.

Now let's compare with the average developer, which can do regular wrists exercises, sits in a comfy office chair and can perfectly well go exercise after work. Whee, such danger. Take care of your body at least 30 minutes every day.

And yes, carpal tunnel sucks, and can put you out of a career. It can't put you out of 80% of jobs because your back, or your leg, or your shoulder is busted.

Compare both, and tell me the construction worker doesn't have it a thousand times harder than the dev, I dare you.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by joesmo on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:37PM (#11013400)
I wasn't comparing, just simply pointing out your error.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by patrickdavey on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:40AM (#11011401)
"Working with your brain takes just as much effort as working with your muscles."

Well, funny you should say that. Years ago when I first moved to New Zealand (as a backpacker) my mindset was to find a job immediately, then look for a better one. My first "job" was as a labourer. Carrying large marble table tops up narrow windy stairs. Hardest job I ever did! Quit after one day, and my back is probably still thankful for it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by oldmanjay on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:52AM (#11012423)
So you weren't physically strong enough to do the job is what you learned. If you weren't smart enough to program, how easy would you find it?
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by forgetsusername on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:12AM (#11011290)
>Working with your brain takes just as much effort as working with your muscles.

Does working with your brain leave you susceptible to long-term injury or disability?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by joesmo on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:08AM (#11012555)
Repetitive stress injuries like carpal tunnel if you use computers, so absolutely yes!
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by VLM on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:41AM (#11011629)
Obesity and diabetes, sure.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by geebee on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:26PM (#11013949)
I agree with you, but there are two very different angles on this.

On one hand, there are programmers complaining that they can't get exactly the job they want at what they feel is good pay. Your answer to these complaints is fair enough - lots of people have it tough. Nobody is entitled to a job on their own terms. You choose your own life.

The other angle is the employer who complains about the "shortage" of software developers out there who have top skills and are ready and willing to work for the salary the employer feels is fair in a big, loud, open office with little autonomy or job security. This second, employer-based sense of entitlement is no less appalling in my opinion.

I'm going to guess we disagree on the stress level involved in being a programmer, where you are almost always pressured to commit to deadlines on things you don't yet understand, where people blame you for schedule slips, where you are tempted to compromise to meet deadlines but know that you are cutting corners that may lead to real risk, where you can make errors that destroy data and/or prevent thousands of people from getting work done, where you may severely compromise secure data, and so forth.. in short, I do think it is a job that people can reasonably find very stressful. I think that people overstate the "cushiness" of programming and IT jobs. These jobs can really induce and trigger anxiety, it doesn't take an entitled whiner to feel that way, at all.

Say what you will about programmers, it's the employers (at least here in the States) whose sense of entitlement about who they should be able to hire at "market rate" is so strong they will lobby congress rather that pay more or find ways to make the job less stressful.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by rifung on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:38PM (#11013414)
I don't know how old you are, but I have a similar experience level with the person you're responding to and I think I and many of my peers relate in some ways. I think the parts he said about getting rich are a bit silly; that's probably more of a personal regret of his/hers then anything else.

On the other hand, I think many other people I've talked to who have only worked for a few years kind of feel lost. I guess in a way we've been so busy with school and constantly pressured into finding a good paying job and that it would all be worth it that we didn't take enough time to experience life and find out what actually makes us happy. In fairness, it's also a bit difficult to know if you'll enjoy a job until you actually do it for a while.

I like my job, don't get me wrong, and I really do appreciate all the opportunities it gives me. I think the real question is whether that job enables you to do what you truly want to do, or handicaps you instead. I am fortunate enough that my job is the former, but I've certainly taken jobs where it was more the latter.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by zzalpha on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:34PM (#11015164)
On the other hand, I think many other people I've talked to who have only worked for a few years kind of feel lost.

And that, I think, is a failure in our culture. American Protestant ethics teach us that your job should be a deep, elemental, almost spiritual part of who you are as a person. The result is that, when people graduate, and get that job, they discover that working is, quite often, a pretty shallow experience that, if you let it define you, will lead to a pretty unsatisfying existence.

So now you have a choice: get dissatisfied and start changing careers, hoping you can find something to give you a sense of meaning and purpose (which, if you're like a lot of people I know, very probably means you never excel at any one thing and therefore never get to the point of having a sustainable career that can fuel a fulfilling lifestyle). Or, start spreading those wings and becoming a well rounded person so that you're defined by more than your career.

I advise the latter.

Speaking for myself, I have a great lifestyle job. I love the people I work with, and the projects are reasonably interesting but not life changing, and occasionally repetitive. The work environment is comfortable and laid back, and I get to leave work at the office. The job absolutely will not make me rich, but it allows me to engage in not exactly cheap extracurricular activities (traveling, skiing, etc), while leaving me with free time to pursue numerous hobbies beyond programming.

To me, this constitutes success.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by rifung on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:48PM (#11015767)
Indeed I'll admit I had a rough transition but I've come to accept that my job is just a job. I really like the people I work with and the company I work for, but the thing I like most about it is that it enables me to do the other things I want in life.

Of course, one day I would like to pursue a PhD so that I could study full time, but that's a dream for another time I guess.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dagw on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:25AM (#11010925)
Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make.

What percentage of people with law or finance degrees to you think actually make what you seem to think people with law or finance degrees make?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by verbify on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:47AM (#11010985)
Not to mention that by being a developer, I started earning money in my early 20's, without hefty university debt. Less risk (plenty people study for the bar and fail) and upfront costs.

There's also less chance of getting a casual 9-5 environment in finance.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by JBReefer on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:58AM (#11012031)
I'm having a tough time finding it, but there was a really good article that analyzed median performance of law school grads and found that, if law school was a security, it would be below a junk rated bond.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by raverbashing on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:43AM (#11011409)
How many would be specialized MDs dropped out during the course/residency?

I'm sure something similar happens to top finance positions.

Also, developers have a nice chance of making it big by either starting up or getting equity.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by scalesolved on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:10AM (#11011511)
Nice chance is overstating it by a HUGE amount on the 'making it big part', yes quite a few developers in the start up world can get equity, the former rarely happens.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ac166 on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:00AM (#11012038)
In fairness, I work in the U.K. and most of my friends that I went to uni with, now in Law or Finance (including PAs) make more than I do.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by lucaspiller on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:58AM (#11010436)
> End of the day though, work is boring. Its always work. Your time and effort is going towards making someone else rich and their priorities are more important than your own.

I feel exactly the same. I've been in the game for nearly 8 years now, and it doesn't get any better. At the end of the day, as you say work is work, I don't think I would feel any better working in another career. I like programming, I just don't really like working as a programmer :D

For the last two years I've been contracting which helps as I get to pick and choose projects a bit more, and if I get bored, contracts are only usually a couple months at a time so it's easy to get out ("I can't renew, I've already got another contract"). I'm focussing on saving to buy a small property outright with no mortgage, so once I am living there my living expenses will be greatly reduced and I'll have more freedom to explore my interests outside of work.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:45AM (#11010756)
> Your time and effort is going towards making someone else rich

You are free to start your own business and get rich except it's not so easy, very few people can do it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pbhjpbhj on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:02AM (#11010823)
Unless you're rich to start with then you'll still end up making either your investors or your landlord rich. Do it right and you get rich too.

But then you're often still perpetuating the system by then employing people who work making you rich.

Start a cooperative, forget about being rich and seek the fulfillment of all its members.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by J-dawg on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:40AM (#11011183)
I've often thought about the possibility of designing a company specifically to maximise the wealth of its employees. Choose a location with a low cost of living, give equity to all employees, maybe provide accommodation / food as part of the benefits package.

I'm not sure if I'm describing a cooperative, I just know that most normal companies do the exact opposite of this: they force you to live in a high cost area where you spend a large proportion of your salary on housing and other living costs.

I know there are plenty of good reasons why humans have decided to live in cities, but I can't help thinking there's a better way.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by forgetsusername on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:10AM (#11011278)
>I know there are plenty of good reasons why humans have decided to live in cities, but I can't help thinking there's a better way.

The fallacy is in believing you can't have both a reasonable cost of living and the benefits of a city. There are plenty of such places, globally. As more and more people realize that it's unnecessary to assemble in specific places I think we'll see a sea change. Programmers are going to be some of those most able to take advantage of it (they already are).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by J-dawg on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:01PM (#11013054)
It would be cool if you could expand on this. Do you live in one of these places?

I'm also wondering when there's going to be a sea change. London is full of people in their 20s spending ~50% of their income on rent, and pretty much just breaking even overall.

I feel like people are going to get sick of this eventually. Either people will leave the most expensive cities, or new ways of "hacking" housing will emerge.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by kcole16 on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:52AM (#11011695)
That's basically the point of most law and financial firms (at least when they start out). Until it went public (and still to a large degree), the whole point of Goldman Sachs was to make its' employees rich.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by J-dawg on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:06PM (#11013098)
I guess you could say it's also the point of most tech startups, but only for the founders and the first few employees.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:08AM (#11010848)
You know this cooperative(aka socialism :) sounds good on paper but it does not work most of the time in real life.

If someone takes a risk to build something valuable, he/she deserves to get rich.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by 1stop on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:17AM (#11010899)
Paying people the same value they contribute is not socialism. It's called: Being a good person.

Capitalism seems to have made us all think it's completely okay to exploit someone else's surplus labour. How is the risk the founder takes that different to Employee #1's? Their payout is usually vastly different, but their contribution not so much.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by splintercell on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:40AM (#11011940)
> Paying people the same value they contribute is not socialism. It's called: Being a good person. <

I am sorry but the whole disagreement is on what value a worker contributes.

According to Capitalism and Capitalism supporters, a productive activity is the sum of (Land/raw materials + Labor + Capital). Capital is nothing but deferred consumption. If you don't consume what you could consume, then that constitutes as capital.

When you say that Capitalism exploits another's surplus labor, what you don't understand is that the Capitalist pays for that surplus labor via capital (or time). Any worker in Capitalism is entitled to the full share of the profit as long as he does not expect wages to be paid out immediately, and that he is willing to wait until the profits pour in.

Because most labor is paid immediately, and workers have no risk or delayed consumption, they don't get the share from the profit.

Karl Marx noticed this phenomenon, but was unable to understand the role of Capital(and yea I know he wrote a whole book on this concept). To him, careful inspection revealed a 'conspiracy theory' among the capitalists which he dubbed as class struggle and class interest.

> How is the risk the founder takes that different to Employee #1's? < When you compare the risk of the founder vs risk of the employee #1, it is the matter of how much capital is on line there. Clearly the risk taken by someone who has invested $1000 is less than the risk taken by someone who has invested $10,000 into the same venture at the same time.

Funny thing is when people talk about a cooperative, it's no different than an early stage equity startup where nobody gets paid a salary. The moment a cooperative pays salary before the revenue, it will need capital and the person providing the capital would deserve a bigger share from the profits.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by bobwaycott on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:49AM (#11012399)
> Karl Marx noticed this phenomenon, but was unable to understand the role of Capital(and yea I know he wrote a whole book on this concept). To him, careful inspection revealed a 'conspiracy theory' among the capitalists which he dubbed as class struggle and class interest.

You possess an either infantile and misinformed understanding of Marx, or you're just being ideological here. Have you read Capital? It's not just one book. Marx very well understood the concept, role, and agency of capital. His careful inspection did not reveal a conspiracy theory; instead, it elucidated the ways capital influences our material existence. There was no conspiracy among capitalists, only naturally flowing consequences of capital's impact on the material bases of society.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by splintercell on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:08AM (#11012551)
> You possess an either infantile and misinformed understanding of Marx, or you're just being ideological here.<

I don't understand what is offending you so much here. I am claiming that Marx does not understand Capital, and just because he claimed to have analysed the role of 'capital', it doesn't mean that he 'understood' it. A christian biologist writing about the role of fossils doesn't mean he understands it.

> His careful inspection did not reveal a conspiracy theory; instead, it elucidated the ways capital influences our material existence. <

Did Marx not say that the employer is able to claim a right to 'surplus labor' because the capitalist class (state being one of them) protects this right(property rights)?

Does he not claim that almost all property is acquired via theft and coercion of the labor class? I understand that conspiracy theory is a loaded term, but his idea of 'class interest' is nothing but a conspiracy theory. That somehow all the capitalist are conspiring against the workers, without being explicitly aware of it.

Karl Marx did not understand that Capital allows production but doing division of 'labor'(used here to mean 'tasks'). Workers don't need to invest their time in the production process, and wait for the revenue of a business to pour in, while a person specializing in saving, does the job of providing the wages.

That this is a necessary factor needed in any economy and it's impossible for any society (including the one recommending by Marx) to live by not having division of capital accumulation from labor.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by bobwaycott on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:38PM (#11015198)
> I don't understand what is offending you so much here.

Why are you assuming I am offended? I'm calling out your erroneous claims of Marx's work as either misunderstanding or ideology. I'm not in the slightest bit offended. Your clarifications haven't moved the needle on being unable to determine if you're being purely ideological, or if you're infusing ideology into what is, fundamentally, a misunderstanding of Marx.

> I am claiming that Marx does not understand Capital, and just because he claimed to have analysed the role of 'capital', it doesn't mean that he 'understood' it.

Just because you think you know what Marx says, and because you have a couple of his terms in your head, does not mean you understand Marx.

You are claiming that you understand capital better than Marx, who devoted 25 years to analyzing and explaining it--particularly insofar as it relates to the material conditions of our existence, and how it informs, produces, and reproduces the social, economic, cultural, and political structures of human society. Considering the vast breadth and depth of Marx's work, that is a very bold claim to make. You can certainly disagree with the more philosophical and political conclusions Marx draws from his understanding of capital, but to make a blanket assertion that he simply does not understand capital is something that requires an incredibly strong argument. Even Marx's detractors do not make such wide-sweeping, hand-waving claims as "Marx doesn't understand capital". They typically disagree on finer points, many of which have more to do with the material ramifications of capital on political economy and social structure.

> A christian biologist writing about the role of fossils doesn't mean he understands it.

Please. You're creating a ridiculous argument here.

As an ignostic, even I wouldn't say the religion of a biologist is inherently relevant to determining whether or not that biologist understood the role of fossils. There are plenty of Christians who do not find their faith at odds with the scientific consensus on evolution and the fossil record. If you read the biologist's writing about the role of fossils, and it accurately describes the role of fossils in accord with the greater body of scientific work on the matter, what exactly does the biologist's faith have to do with determining or proving anything? Sure, it might be worth considering as a signifier of a certain probability of misunderstanding based on factors external to the biologist's own work, but it's sounding like you're giving automatic preference to a non-Christian biologist's writing about the role of fossils for absolutely zero reason. The non-Christian could be a complete imbecile who winds up on the History Channel shouting, "Aliens!" You're making errors based on a loud segment of Christians who reject the science of evolution, and automatically applying their ignorance/misunderstanding/ideology as something that the Christian biologist shares. That's foolish.

---

Anyway, this is really an irrelevant tangent from a thread that was asking about people being happy programming. Although, Marx might find it rather relevant, as there is quite a bit of voiced discontent that he'd categorize as expressions of alienation. The labor of the many is transformed into the capital of the few. Dialectically speaking, it's a struggle of contraries that co-exist with different interests. Labor has nothing and its members are required to sell themselves to subsist and exist. Capital has everything, and is motivated to keep as much of that everything as it can, while expending as little as necessary to further increase the share of everything it has as more of everything is produced by those who have nothing. What does labor get in return? Nothing but a wage that is (ideally) as low as possible to prevent them from leaving the workforce (and certainly not enough to permit capital accumulation by the laborers themselves). Moreover, those with capital are additionally motivated to protect this arrangement that they might continue to profit off those who sell themselves to subsist and exist, so that those with capital do not have to work.

> Did Marx not say that the employer is able to claim a right to 'surplus labor' because the capitalist class (state being one of them) protects this right(property rights)?

You're somewhat confusing categories and their relations here. Surplus labor is that labor which is demanded of and performed by a worker that exceeds the labor necessary to pay for her wage. In the majority of cases, surplus labor is unpaid. It is a necessary condition of increasing capital through profits, which is most simply the extraction and control of the surplus value created by workers in excess of their labor cost. The capitalist appropriates this surplus value when the products of workers' labor is sold. Marx goes further to argue that capital accumulation is the condition that drives production--when production ceases to be profitable for the capitalist, capital will eventually be diverted elsewhere, withdrawn from the unprofitable enterprise, etc. There are, of course, absolute and relative surplus values, but suffice to say that capital accumulation is the driving force of the capitalists. Private property is that legal protection that is based on a history of convincing people that objects were only useful and valuable if they could simultaneously possess them use them for themselves. It has nothing direct to do with surplus labor, but is instead used to establish and defend the private ownership of the capitalist means of production, and thus the claims to surplus value and capital accumulation. If you cannot understand how this accurately reflects the workings of capital and capitalism, I'm simply not sure how we can get you past your ideological lens.

Marx does not argue that "almost all property is acquired via theft and coercion of the labor class". At least, not in such a crudely simplistic way as that. Profits are acquired via alienation and exploitation of the labor class. In earnest material modes of existence, property didn't exist until those who were more powerful began staking and defending claims on the products of others' labor--so that they themselves would not have to labor. This has continued a circuitous and tortuous route through human history until our present age in which we've codified these practices into centuries of legal trappings that convince everyone it is good and right, and entirely fair and above-board. Or so Marx might loosely argue.

The notion of class interest is no more a conspiracy theory than the capitalist narrative that labor and capital work hand-in-hand to create a better tomorrow. Class interest is trivially easy to spot and demonstrate--both in Marx's time and our own (and far back before both, as well). Look at pg's now-infamous essay on income inequality from the start of the year, and his vociferous critics. Class interest on display in both. The capitalist 'class' is inherently motivated to protect their interests and see them expanded. This is not some insane idea that requires tin foil hats, or the ravings of a lunatic. Marx doesn't exactly argue that the capitalists are inherently conspiring against the workers. Just that they are guilty of accumulating capital from surplus value that is the product of surplus labor for which the workers have not been compensated, and the capitalist does not own.

> Karl Marx did not understand that Capital allows production but doing division of 'labor'(used here to mean 'tasks').

This is how I know you have no serious understanding of Marx and his work. Marx has most certainly written of, categorized, and fit division of labor into dialectical materialism and his explications of capital and its place in human society. Exhaustively.

> Workers don't need to invest their time in the production process, and wait for the revenue of a business to pour in, while a person specializing in saving, does the job of providing the wages.

The wages are not provided by a person who specializes in saving. They are provided by the capital accumulated from the surplus value appropriated from the workers' own surplus labor, for which they are not compensated, Marx would say. Wages come from the revenues of the business. If there are no revenues, there are no wages.

You seem to be making a number of simple mistakes here that are perhaps related to misapplication of your understanding of working in tech/startups to the role of capital. It's a pretty easy set of mistakes to make, but it seriously would require a lot of discussion to even try to completely straighten all of this out. Marx is almost universally misunderstood. Even among those who understand him better than most as a result of spending years studying his vast body of work, there is still disagreement on how to properly understand him. It's the nature of such a prolific beast.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by bobby_9x on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:12AM (#11012118)
I'm fine with this, as long as the risk/reward ratio is equal.

Maybe each employee has to donate credit to the company for expenses if they don’t have the cash?

I started my company with bank loans and credit lines. If it goes bust, it's my reputation and I will have to pay back the money.

If someone isn't willing to risk this as well, they aren't an equal partner and shouldn't share equally in the reward.

Some people aren't willing to risk this much, yet still want to contribute. They are employees.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:54AM (#11011233)
You misunderstood me, I am not saying you should exploit your workers, pay them fair wage. What I am saying is that founder who took the risk should enjoy the fruits.

> How is the risk the founder takes that different to Employee #1's?

Employee #1 will probably be getting a salary, if the company fails he can get a job somewhere else. Meanwhile the founders who worked on the idea probably used their savings initially not to mention quitting their jobs and working on the idea and facing humiliation if the company fails.

That takes courage which everyone cannot do which is why founders deserve to get rich if they build something valuable, employees not so much unless they are willing to stick it out till the end.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by forgetsusername on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:17AM (#11011304)
>What I am saying is that founder who took the risk

Please describe what "risks" the average high-flying tech startup CEO has taken.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:11AM (#11011513)
I am not sure what you mean by the high flying CEO, I am talking more from the founder's side who puts his money and time on the line. Take Musk as an example, he invested most of his money in Tesla and Space X and both the companies came close to bankruptcy.

Those companies and many others will not work as a cooperative.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by krisdol on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:40AM (#11011622)
Why not?
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:03AM (#11011757)
Because most people who will be working in the cooperative are sane and will bail out if things get tough. You need a crazy founder to take enormous risks.

Just look around you, most of the tech titans are founders who took risk, can you give examples of tech cooperatives which are equally famous?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pbhjpbhj on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:33AM (#11011907)
>if the company fails he can get a job somewhere else //

Because it's so hard to adapt CEO skills to the jobs market? Whilst peons can pick up a low paid job and should just lap it up and be happy about it??

If the founder is taking a risk running the company then the employees are taking a risk working there; their risk is often as great, the chance to lose one's livelihood.

To my mind a guy in sales that wrote up £1 million of orders in one days work and a guy in janitorial that cleaned the toilets all day both did a days work and both deserve a days pay - they're both humans who gave a day of their lives to the purposes of the company.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:17PM (#11016767)
The founder is also putting his money on the table while the employee is not. The employee can just say no to working in a startup, nobody is forcing him to work there.

The janitor should be paid the market rate, nobody is denying that but he should not expect to get rich via the company

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by UK-AL on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:22AM (#11010920)
As someone who extremely capitalist and believes in free markets, I don't believe cooperatives are inherently socialist.

In a free market people are free to create their own ownership structures. If people want to setup up a company, and distribute equity equally to employees that's completely up them

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by wdmeldon on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:37AM (#11011609)
The problem is that risk has become an absurdly exponential factor of increasing wealth where hard work is at best only additive. Risk should not take the value that you provide and raise it to the power of 10 just because you might have failed.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:09AM (#11012565)
For whatever reason, society seems to value risk-taking 10x more than it values work. Just look at the replies in this thread. People are actually arguing that founders deserve their megawealth because at some point they risked something, and that employees do not deserve it, regardless of how much they work, because they didn't risk anything (although I would argue that employees #1-4 risk a hell of a lot more than most founders).
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sumedh on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @07:12PM (#11023784)
> I would argue that employees #1-4 risk a hell of a lot more than most founders

How can it more risky for first four employees?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by timwaagh on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:34AM (#11010951)
a cooperative is usually not really about socialism. they just have members instead of shareholders. there are big banks structured this way.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by shubhamjain on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:09AM (#11010857)
> Your time and effort is going towards making someone else rich

I don't mean to harsh but I don't understand this sentiment. Will any serious company exist if everyone thought like this? Why would a builder put another brick if he thought he is getting paid very less compared to million dollar building he is creating? Will any sales guy put so much of effort if he thought he is getting minisicule % of what he is selling?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by beatpanda on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:39AM (#11011398)
Yes, lots of serious companies would (and do) exist; they're called worker-owned cooperatives, wherein all members of a firm share the risk and reward/of running the business, instead of one or two individuals paying themselves an arbitrary "risk premium" that workers have no say over.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by kendallpark on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:46AM (#11012380)
> Even compensation wise, it peaks very early and probably won't get most rich without a ton of luck. Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make. Granted, the barrier to entry is much lower in CS (sometimes nearly nonexistent depending on the line of work).

Med student here. Programmers don't have to take out 200K in loans. Also, when you do something like medicine, you're basically giving up a DECADE of you life before you actually start making the big bucks. Residents make less than the average programmer. Med students make negative $$. Debt compounds.

But seriously, if that's what you want, stop romanticizing and just do it. Though I have to say, do law school. Doctors that became doctors for the prestige and money are really the worst.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by id on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:13AM (#11012589)
There a many countries where you don't have to borrow a single cent to study medicine. Instead, you even get paid a small support every month.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by kendallpark on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:27PM (#11015124)
That's true. I have heard that in these countries the docs typically don't get paid as much, though I don't have a source for this.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by id on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @09:01AM (#11019423)
That's somewhat true, but they are free to go wherever they want to.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by anthonybsd on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:49AM (#11011670)
>Even compensation wise, it peaks very early and probably won't get most rich without a ton of luck. Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make.

Software engineers in Finance can make a pretty good living though. Definitely not as high as specialized MD or M&A specialists, but rivaling some successful lawyers for sure. Then again even for people with top business degrees M&A is a top tier which takes quite a bit of luck to get into. My 2c.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by abalashov on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:16AM (#11010478)
On average, the people really are incredibly boring, especially at large companies.

I wrote a post recently that is tangentially related to this. Don't want to shamelessly plug myself, but I think you might enjoy it:

http://likewise.am/2016/01/22/more-lessons-from-my-twenties-...

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by hibikir on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:21AM (#11011849)
You are less than 3 years into your career, and you think you have worked for some of the best companies, and yet you are unhappy. How do you know you have worked for some of the best for you? You are going by names.

My guess is that you are talking about hot valley companies, and guess what? In those, someone with little experience will not get to work on anything fun, because they have enough talent that almost everyone is batting below their weight. You see similar things in startups where there is no challenging technical component to the business: If all you need to do is scale an app that is just a bunch of forms, then guess what? it will be boring. Go work at a company that is doing science instead, and then tell me it's boring.

You complain about compensation peaking early, as if that's a bad thing. In the US, 300K is not insane for senior devs, and that doesn't count miraculous exits. Many doctors don't make that, and they had to pay for a lot more education, and handle the terrible life of the resident before they can get to real money: And let's not forget, the top of the market for doctors involves getting your own practice. How long does it take to save the money, and have the name, for the practice to be that profitable?

There are a lot of people with law degrees that wish that, at 45, they made the money that anyone with a breath makes in SV when they are 22.

I have seen finance: You don't have a life when you work for a big hedge fund. Not even close.

And let's not forget, you don't have to live in San Francisco to get paid very well writing software. I have a 4 bedroom house that is worth about 200K. I work from home. It's not hard to amass major savings when you don't have a $5000/mo mortgage. And if I am sick of the place, I can spend a month working from Puerto Rico, or an island in Georgia, go to conferences in Europe. How many doctors can say that? How many lawyers? And I am no early googler: I have never made a dime in equity.

As far as people being boring: Different people have different ideas of boring. For instance, I find the classic "I work in software, but look at my unique outdoorsy activity" profiles that most of SV seems to follow to be very boring. Yes, you can enjoy your rock climbing, or your kayaking, or whatever else you do, but it's not something that is really any fun to hear about: People with different activities like that just get to vomit information onto the other. At the same time, many people find the things I do, like reading literature, history and philosophy, to be boring as hell. There's nothing wrong with that.

Also, in America, we hide the things that might make us interesting, different from the crowd. When instead of belonging, we try to fit in, we do what everyone else does. For someone to be really interesting, they have to be different. To be different is to take personal risks of being disliked, because what will make you interesting for one person will make you a weirdo to another. In my experience, the more you get to know about someone, the less boring they are, precisely because of all the little things that we couldn't see before, when all they were to us was a role at a company and some clothes.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by zzalpha on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:18AM (#11012630)
Be realistic. 300k a year is waaay above the median for senior dev salaries save for a few very specialized niches (fintech and biotech spring to mind).

This is exactly the kind of misinformation that makes newbs to the industry think they're gonna be rich rockstars programming... stop it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sethammons on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:47AM (#11012384)
$300k? Where? How? While I have metric-tonnes more to learn, I'm a senior developer. I write and maintain (with our team) the main services (it used to be _all_ the services before we grew) at our SAAS providing 10s of millions in revenue. I make less than half that.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by laxatives on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:24AM (#11018049)
I don't think this invalidates your argument, but your assumptions about my work choices are completely wrong. I have almost always been the youngest person at offices dominated by scientists and mathematicians. Most of my work before graduation was at a national lab in condensed matter physics. I joined my current job as the 7th hire because the team is mostly comprised of math and EE PhD's from MIT and Berkeley. I'm not working on creating "forms" that "scale". Its all data science and optimization models/machine learning and the related engineering.

At the end of the day though, the business isn't about how much you are learning and any early stage start up is going to conduct R&D based on short term returns. If I could work somewhere like Voleon, I might have greater freedom, but I don't have an advanced degree to get a foot in the door.

I agree about traveling. That is one of the only things that continues to excite me. I spent several months working remotely and plan to continue doing so once this company starts to get revenue (if ever). That's certainly one freedom working from a computer provides that most other occupations don't get to enjoy.

That being said, at the end of the day, its just work. And thats fine. Thats still better than most jobs. But this line of work has a relatively low ceiling (in terms of job satisfaction, not compensation) if you want more and I feel like sticking too it makes it only easier to accept that ceiling. Maybe this is too strong, but it almost feels like giving up and settling for something easy/cushy.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:25AM (#11012700)
Thank you for pointing out the fact that software compensation peaks early, and you pretty much hit a ceiling unless you win the startup lottery. A lot of people see the early money and forget this. As a software developer, 20 years into your career, your buddies that majored in finance, marketing or anything else, really, will likely have eclipsed you in terms of compensation, as they'll be senior directors of this or vice presidents of that.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by varjag on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:36AM (#11012808)
There's not enough director or VP positions in the world for every buddy out there.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:43AM (#11012876)
Tell that to my buddies :-)
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gizi on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:13AM (#11011810)
> but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make.

It is exactly the other way around. Mark Zuckerberg is a PHP programmer, not an MD or a lawyer. Same for Bill Gates, Sergey Brin, Larry Page, and another host of lesser known billionaires and millionaires. In other words, an MD or a lawyer could impossible make what a successful programmer might make.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:34AM (#11012792)
You're talking about the 0.1% of programmers who became millionaires and billionaires. The parent comment was specifically about the other 99.9% (and he/she even specified the number).
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by yourapostasy on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:41AM (#11011185)
If you miss excitement, social connection, and orders of magnitude higher compensation cap in your life, while you still like coding, then I suggest you consider sales. Not just technical sales (though that gets your foot in the door), but eventually landing strategic sales accounts. It is pretty thrilling cold-calling people to establish your bona fides with a new customer; only a tiny fraction of the population finds it and public speaking (which you will also be called upon to perform in sales) not paralysis-inducing terrifying. You have to genuinely like people and be interested in them to really excel at sales. At the high-end of sales, where you lead sales organizations, sales-metric-based compensation plans will easily exceed that of nearly all programmers save the ones exiting unicorns with founder-level equity positions intact. You are constantly learning both technical and non-technical subject matter. There are grind-y parts, sure (every job has that), but I've never seen in sales the kind of grind programmers routinely endure.

Once you establish a successful sales record, you wield enormous influence upon product direction and implementation. If you keep your coding chops up to that point, then it is not inconceivable for you to be able to throw your weight around and pick and choose both what to code and actually implement it. Of course, if you aren't good at coding, then the engineering lead will continue to hate your guts. They will all hate your guts at first regardless of your skill level and ability to smoothly work with their teams, but if you are really, really good you can earn the respect of most after awhile.

Very good sales people who are still top 20% coders are an extremely rare combination. It would be difficult NOT to stand out in the crowd. That's good and bad.

The Great Filter in my suggestion is getting out and meeting people trying to connect with them. There are lots and lots of programmers, even "brogrammer"-types, who claim they are very extroverted, etc., who I find will freeze when faced with a list of contacts or a room of strangers and tasked with establishing connections. The vast majority of people, extroverted programmers included, are extroverted with people they know; it's human nature. Of those who can manage to overcome that nature, even fewer will come back with a systematic collection of facts and data about their contacts that you can work with as the start of a sales funnel. Of THAT population, even fewer will actually follow through the sales funnel. Out of THAT, anyone who can continue following up prospects and re-running them through a sales funnel under different campaigns is a unicorn. This is why sales is often broken up into pieces and parceled out to different people. But programmers possess a systems-thinking background that uniquely positions them to excel at sales if their personality really fits it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by nilkn on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:41AM (#11012334)
Why do you think most developers should be paid similarly to a highly specialized doctor?

First of all, you might be thinking of doctors like neurosurgeons. Less than 1% of practicing physicians in the US are neurosurgeons, and some neurosurgeons make as little as $250k (often ones with special academic appointments). Not all of them make $1M/year or even $700k/year.

Second of all, you might in general be overestimating doctor compensation. See this report:

http://www.medscape.com/features/slideshow/compensation/2015...

Primary care doctors earned an average of $195k in total compensation. Half that is $97.5k. There are many developers who make more than that -- certainly far more than .1% of developers. That is, in fact, the median pay for software developers:

http://www.bls.gov/ooh/Computer-and-Information-Technology/S...

Granted, you did say specialized doctor, and we see from the MedScape report that they make $280k on average. Half of that is only $140k. There are fresh college graduates who make more than that in total compensation. I've even known relatively new developers making $250k once bonuses and vesting stocks are taken into account. Either way, $140k in total pay is not uncommon at all for an experienced senior developer. Again, certainly far more than .1% of developers are in that income bracket.

Finally, and perhaps more importantly, I think you might underestimate the difficulty of becoming a specialized doctor. It's certainly much harder than becoming an average programmer. The educational requirements are vastly higher and more rigorous. The debt load is in the six figures for all but children of the rich. And the time investment is at minimum 11 years (4 undergrad + 4 medical school + minimum of 3 residency). But since we're talking about specialized MDs, the residency will actually be longer than that, as long as 7 years for a neurosurgeon, plus an extra 2-3 for a fellowship if desired. After all that, the doctor will potentially work twice as much as the programmer.

It's not fair to compare the average heart surgeon to the average programer, because the heart surgeon is by definition vastly above average among doctors in both education, grades, and pay. It would really only be fair to compare the heart surgeon to, say, a senior engineer at Google (or similar), where a total compensation exceeding $250k is common.

As for lawyers, many law school graduates I know don't even have a job. The days are long gone where a law degree was automatically a golden ticket. It's certainly true that the top lawyers make a large amount of money, but becoming a partner (say) at a large firm is just not comparable to becoming a programmer. These days, it's like winning the lottery.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Jonovono on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:54AM (#11012444)
They never said programmers SHOULD make as much as doctors (or lawyers or finance).
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by nilkn on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:39AM (#11012836)
Why feel depressed about it then? The statements were also factually misleading -- (far) more than .1% of programmers make more than half of a specialized doctor on average.