News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by onion2k on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:19AM (#11010493)
Its depressing to make comparisons, but 99.9% of developers will never make half of what a specialized MD or successful lawyer or someone in finance might make.

Why not make a much less depressing comparison and compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff? Compare a typical developer to a typical retail worker and we get way more money for way less stress. We're not at the top end of the scale, but we are nowhere near the bottom either.

We get to sit in comfortable offices, working on interesting projects (mostly), building things that make a difference to people, without getting dirty or abused by the public, and we're pretty well paid for it on the whole. And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

I've been a professional developer for over 20 years, and I've enjoyed most of it. It afforded me the opportunity to do my own startup for a while, and when that failed it was easy to get back in to work with a job that pays quite well. I certainly wouldn't want to do anything else.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by LoSboccacc on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:25AM (#11011121)
> compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff

apples to oranges.

we're highly specialized knowledge workers. well most of us are, so it is more fair to compare with bankers, lawyers, medics, architects, politician and middle managers which can count on a year to year income growth instead of having to playing idea lottery.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by agentultra on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:45AM (#11012366)
I'd compare us only superficially to capital-P Professions like lawyers, architects, engineers and the like. There are no bar exams to get a license to practice programming in the industry; no liability -- it's really easy for people to misrepresent themselves and for companies to take advantage of us.

Comparing us to retail workers has some merit. We're not professions, have no collective representation, and can be easily replaced (despite current myths about how difficult it is to hire programmers there are hoards of new graduates and self-taught individuals making the leap from other careers and professions because of the money and cushy benefits -- most hiring processes seem to be designed to keep the majority of people out).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by vinceguidry on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:07AM (#11012080)
I wouldn't exactly call developers highly specialized. Specialized developers work in a tiny niche and make lots of money by being one of the very few in that niche. Any of us could potentially become specialized, but very few of us actually are.

Hell, most of us could jump fields without losing steam. Systems administration, security, database administration, all of these can be done by a decent developer.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:45AM (#11012371)
At some level. But I would never hire a developer to do security, or sysad. Because they have the wrong mindset for it. I want some OCD single-minded person keeping my network safe. Not someone who like to just 'get it done' as efficiently as possible. Totally different goal, and to be really good at it takes a different person.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Chris2048 on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:23AM (#11011553)
Arguably, none of us are chartered. But I agree, you have to compare like-for-like.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:51AM (#11010780)
On one hand, yes, absolutely. We have much better than the vast majority of the people and there are times when it doesn't feel right to complain about it.

On the other hands, it's turtles all the way down until you reach "well, we are still alive, at least that's something".

While some humility and reality check is good, aspiring to have something better (be it in the monetary terms or whatever drives you) is also important to make progress.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by yodsanklai on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:58AM (#11011022)
> Why not make a much less depressing comparison and compare developer wages to manual labourers or retail staff?

Some software engineers undertook difficult curriculums in highly selective universities. In that case, I think it's understandable to feel a little bit depressed when comparing to former classmates in more prestigious fields. Personally, I have to admit that sometimes I feel that way (even though I'd probably do the same if I could go back in time because I love this field).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Philipp__ on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:34AM (#11010954)
We get to sit in comfortable offices, working on interesting projects (mostly), building things that make a difference to people, without getting dirty or abused by the public, and we're pretty well paid for it on the whole. And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

Very well said.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by spacecowboy_lon on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:11AM (#11010864)
Less stress? Retail workers turn up a 9 leave at 17:30 - they dot get called up outside of work in an emergency to fix some one elses code that causing a problem.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dagw on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:17AM (#11010901)
If I'm 45 minutes late for work 3 days in a row with no good excuse, no one gives a fuck. Retail worker shows up 45 minutes late one day and they're most likely fired. I also don't have to worry about people fucking around with my shifts and thus how much money will be in my next paycheck.

Having even a modicum of job and financial security removes so much stress from your life.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Amezarak on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:25AM (#11011339)
> If I'm 45 minutes late for work 3 days in a row with no good excuse, no one gives a fuck.

Unfortunately it doesn't work that way for all developers. At my last job there were continual reminders and reprimands for being even five minutes late.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by arethuza on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:51AM (#11011439)
In my first job ~25 years ago I got told off for coming in 5 minutes late even though I had gone on to a customer site at 9pm the previous evening and worked to ~1am to fix the problem.

Left there after 9 months and have never worked anywhere like that since.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by knodi123 on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:42AM (#11012341)
you've heard of "code smell", right? that right there is a "career smell".
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by logfromblammo on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:19PM (#11013867)
If you are a salaried exempt employee, you should not have to put up with that BS from timeclock nazis. But it is all entirely legal, and for many companies, obeying the letter of the law on paper is the only requirement for corporate policy.

Sadly, without the muscle of collective bargaining to back you up, your only real options are to politely beg your management to stop being timeclock nazis, or to leave for greener pastures.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dizzystar on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:26AM (#11010929)
In retail, you don't get free food / liquid. You have to stand on your feet all day. Customers are allowed to scream at you and you have to figure out how to make them happy. Bosses are more than happy to fire you because, let's be honest, there are 1,000 others that can do your job. No guarantees of a 40 hour work-week. No paid holidays, no benefits. Raises are like 25c, and that is only if the boss really likes you and you aren't in a union, shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve... (don't care to continue)
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Amezarak on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:30AM (#11011358)
> In retail, you don't get free food / liquid.

Water is free, most likely. I've never had free food programming, beyond nutra-grain bars, once.

> Customers are allowed to scream at you and you have to figure out how to make them happy.

Toxic clients exist in the programming world, too. And as a low-level peon, you have a lot more leeway in telling an abusive customer to get out than you do a multimillion dollar client.

> shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve...

Still happens for developers.

As strange as it may sound, I think I personally was happier waiting tables. But it wasn't going to pay the bills. In general, I totally agree that most people, all things considered, are better off programming. But let's not overstate our case. :) There are definitely some programming jobs which are light-years better than any retail job because e.g., you don't have to deal with customers, but that's not all programming jobs.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by chrshawkes on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:49AM (#11011671)
Try crawling around in asbestos filled attics or rat infested crawl spaces for 12 bucks an hour.

Programming is much easier than so many professions I've had in the past it's absolutely unbelievable.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by callinyouin on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:18AM (#11011829)
I was a "pest control technician" (exterminator) before I started programming professionally, so I know how you feel. My life now is a cakewalk by comparison.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by bobwaycott on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:34AM (#11012280)
Oh, man. At 16-17, I used to do that installing HVAC systems. At 21-22, I worked in a factory to support a family. Then I spent the next 3.5 years selling cars. Finally said, "Fuck this", and decided to start programming as work instead of just play.

Even the worst days of the last 9 years have never been as hard as the best days before it.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by mathgeek on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:57AM (#11011454)
> I think I personally was happier waiting tables.

Sometimes, the social aspects of your job outweigh other factors. Throw in the simplicity of jobs like waiting tables, and I've found that it can be a lot of enjoyment.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by cableshaft on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:20AM (#11012186)
Ignoring the financial aspect of it, I actually didn't mind working in a department store all that much. During downtime you got to socialize with coworkers (many of whom were female), during busy times the time just flew by, you got to move around a lot and be active, you weren't expected to know every detail about everything you were responsible for, just be able to answer some basic questions about certain products ("Why is this more expensive? Which one is best for situation X?"). Also your friends could stop by your workplace to chat from time to time.

As for the no guarantee of 40 hour work week... well, again ignoring the financial aspect of it, only working 20 or 30 hours a week was much more enjoyable than 40-55 hours (or even higher at some places) work weeks.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by knodi123 on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:44AM (#11012353)
> shifts well past midnight on Friday and Christmas Eve.

Haha, try working as a developer supporting a retail-based operation! Our company pulls all-nighters on black friday and christmas eve.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by pjc50 on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:31AM (#11011148)
There are plenty of people on so-called "zero hours" contracts who don't know from day to day when their working hours will be, may be called in at short notice to work an off shift, and have no predictability of pay.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by 3minus1 on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:40AM (#11011400)
there are plenty of programming jobs where you don't get bothered outside of work.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by jkereako on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:13AM (#11012122)
I assume you have never worked in retail.

As a retail worker, the pay is at or just above minimum wage and benefits like PTO and health insurance do not exist because the jobs are usually part time. Additionally, retail work always comes with irate customers who will piss you off, your coworkers off and your bosses off. So everyone is angry. Retail workers often do not have a set schedule, this is especially true during the holiday season. They have to find coverage before taking an unpaid day of leave. Lastly, because no real skill is needed to work in retail, workers are easily replaceable. 1 mistake can get you canned.

How is a situation like that more stressful than being on call of which you get paid to be on?

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by spacecowboy_lon on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:08AM (#11026002)
I don't think payment for on call is the norm in the USA - it can be very lucrative in the uk I knew of people on 4 in 4 who got called twice a year.

15 Years ago it was £400 for 1 in 4 plus Toil (time off) for time worked

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by ryandrake on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:46AM (#11012909)
> And there's always the possibility that we might hit on an idea that returns literally billions of dollars. Or work for someone else who had that idea and walk away with literally hundreds of millions of dollars. Most people don't have that sort of opportunity.

This reads like a sales pitch for the lottery, and as a random developer, your odds are pretty similar.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by timwaagh on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:47AM (#11010770)
its not a good comparison since retail takes absolutely sero education or brains.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:56AM (#11010803)
While I see your point (and I agree a bit), it's not exactly fair to put it this way.

There are many people working in these industries who didn't have much opportunity to get decent education, etc. For example, my parents. They are from rural areas from Soviet Union, where getting higher education was not something that goes by default as it is now (which might not be a great thing given the number of people with worthless law/business management degrees from the bottom 10% of universities... oh well).

Obviously, there's a segment of people who didn't give a crap and held an attitude that education is for losers / nerds (before the word 'nerd' was cool) and I don't have much for them sympathy.

So it's not fair to just disrespect everyone working in the retail as 'zero brains'.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by timwaagh on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:27AM (#11010933)
I'm saying the job requires zero brains or education. I did not mean to imply people who work in retail have no brains or even less than average. in my country it's not really a legit career choice. it's mostly high school kids or people under 23 who do it as it's compensated below adult minimum wage. after a certain age you either get promoted or fired.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by gedrap on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:56AM (#11011014)
I see, sorry for getting you wrong.

Meanwhile in Lithuania, it's fairly typical that the majority of people working in retail are in their 40s and been doing that for the last ~20 years with very minimal increments in salary (usually because of increased minimal salary).

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by mantas on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:29AM (#11011571)
It's not about disrespect. It's about how much effort you put in to get to that point.

How much effort is needed to get a cashier position? Show up, be sober - you got a job. Many people in IT started learning the ropes in their own time after school. Although it was a hobby, it was still an effort that turned out to be helpful in job market.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sotojuan on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:47AM (#11011971)
Here in the US it's not so different. When I was 20, I worked at Target when I took a semester off school. I think only two or three of my coworkers were around my age. The rest were 30+.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by VLM on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:40AM (#11011624)
Meaningless class based prattle

Hardest management job I ever had - working night shift manager at a food store while going to college during the day. Like surviving a hurricane while running a marathon while the building's on fire, every single night. I lived roughly a decade of "real" management in my senior year.

Cashiering required a surprising amount of memorization of obscure procedures and policies and item codes, not to mention carefully tracked flawless arithmetic skills when giving change.

The general manager was an artist of endcap design. At non-megacorp retail you're on your own when designing displays. Its truly an art. At the megacorps you have teams of CAD drafters, graphics artists, and sales consultants designing displays, at a non-megacorp story you have yourself, and the boss expects you to do as good of a job as the team. Teams are usually much less productive than individuals, so its not as hard as it sounds.

Stock clerk at higher levels was insane. Its really a two level job and the new hire teen kids merely threw product on marked shelves, but if you were there more than a year and were not an idiot you watched the more experienced guys and took over for them, after which you spent all your time on rotations and resets and price changes and sales stickering and being a reception clerk for the 50 or so direct store delivery trucks we had. I don't care if you have 20 pounds of soup cans for a 10 pound shelf, make all of them fit somehow and you need to accept deliveries from dairy and bread and beer and you have two hours until break time to get this all done plus or minus helping out everyone else.

I've noticed over many decades that despite enormous quantities of (self serving) propaganda, the hourly pay rate people get generally has little relationship with how difficult or important the job is, on a large enough scale.

Another interesting observation is the dumb people didn't survive on the job nearly as long as the smart people, and the dumb people absolutely suffered horribly compared to the smart people.

Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by solotronics on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:34PM (#11013380)
Anecdotes like this make me wonder what will people in the bottom 1/4 of the bell curve do for a living in the future?
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by dagw on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:20AM (#11010909)
Depends very much on the retail job. If you're expected to sell stuff and work on any sort of commission, then retail jobs take a lot of (a certain type of) smarts if you want earn good money.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by Kluny on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:45PM (#11013494)
Retail managers certainly act that way, but I wish it weren't so. The one thing that has the potential to bring me to a brick and mortar store instead of buying online, is the chance to talk to an employee who is an expert on the product. Sadly it doesn't happen too often. Usually you get someone with enough brains to operate a cash register and no more than that. Ask a good question, you get a blank stare in return. Or they tell you to google it. And because they get paid garbage money, they often can't even afford to buy the product they're selling, so they don't have firsthand experience with it. Could be so much better...
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by sdgsfsfgfg on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:34AM (#11010718)
But the thing is I could have been an MD, lawyer or someone in finance - these things were well within my reach. But I was sold a false dream and now I am stuck in misery.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by rifung on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:31AM (#11012762)
Why not just switch? Is it too late? You can always take out loans if it's money; that's what most people would have to do anyway I imagine.
Re:Ask HN: How happy are you working as a programmer? by endzone on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:07AM (#11026791)
working conditions in all of those industries are terrible compared to almost all software jobs. and the work in finance and law is tedious. you're dreaming.