News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by bpodgursky on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:48PM (#10814919)
It's great how we're living in a world where tax codes are so idiotic and complex that it takes long lawsuits to figure out what tax is actually due.

It's not about following the letter of the law; it's about following the letter of the law, avoiding the court of public opinion, and coughing up whatever is necessary to stop the complaints when some politician wants to distract people from their incompetence and whip up some good old nationalist fury.

What do you legally owe? It's undefined. Or more, defined by whether the country you are in likes you for PR reasons (Google is stealing our newspaper jobs!) * the skill of your lawyers. Great!

How about, we admit corporate income tax is a stupid idea, get rid of it, and raise capital gains taxes respectively (and dividends)? People have the great feature of being corporeal beings which live in a country, which makes them much easier to tax than ethereal corporations.

Of course there are rough edges to fix around overseas investors, but it could not possibly, in any world, be worse than the system we have today.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:57PM (#10814952)
What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits. Do the same for all countries.

The Apple problem is that its lawyers are deliberately avoiding using current tax codes, and instead essentially claiming that Apple is based in Ireland, then playing shell games with what counts as U.S. sales, U.S. profits, and also U.S. property. Apple ends up paying ~10% U.S. tax, rather than ~35%.

Where Apple is located is clear to me: Apple products say Cupertino and there's a gigantic new Cupertino headquarters in progress. Apple also has many subsidiary locations worldwide, and occupies real property, and hires real people; these locations should pay their respective country taxes.

Tim Cook and Apple have an opportunity and moral responsibility to help close these tax loopholes that are siphoning money out of the U.S., California, and Silicon Valley-- then do similarly with the EU and worldwide.

Specifically, the goal is to streamline tax codes to be more clear, more consistent, and more algorithmic. This would be unpopular with stockholders but it's the right thing to do for employees, customers, and countries.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by bpodgursky on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:02PM (#10814971)
No! No! No!

What you legally owe in taxes, in a reasonable tax structure, has NOTHING to do with your moral compass. You should be able to plug numbers into a spreadsheet and get it.

I'm not saying that taxes are bad. We need tax revenue. I get that. But there should NEVER, EVER, be two legally correct answers to how much you owe.

The fact that you had to spend paragraphs making your case, makes mine -- when you resort to emotional appeal to try to get people to pay their taxes, the system is completely broken.

Edit: the original comment said that this was clear to anyone with a "moral compass"

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by supercanuck on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:50PM (#10815463)
You may not realize this, but there is a similiar argument happening in the Accounting world. You are basically arguing for Rules (Clear, Bright Lines) instead of Principles: There is already a current debate about this in the accounting world in GAAP vs IFRS and it has nothing to do with morality.

One of the advantages of GAAP, as you seem to be arguing is the reduction of risk since the rules are clear, unfortunately, the downside is the ability to circumvent them.

it is also funny how investors feel about accounting standards when it is THEIR money at risk and not the governments.

https://ifrsusa.wordpress.com/2011/04/05/which-is-better-%E2...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:01PM (#10815495)
Excellent point. I strongly prefer IFRS over US GAAP, for exactly your reasons. IFRS tends to favor principles, GAAP tends to favor rules.

The ideal (IMHO) is to improve the principles and rules together, and Apple is in a unique leadership position to do this.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by junto on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:18PM (#10815043)
OK, I'll add another 'no' to you both. If a company is operating in a certain country offering goods and services to the population of that country then that country has the right to levy taxes upon the sales of those goods, and upon the operating profits of that company operating within that country.

Global corporations fiddle this by moving money around so it appears that they don't make a corporate profit in that country, hence they pay no corporation tax. For example, companies like Vodafone continuously buy other companies that are making losses deliberately to offset their profit making mobile operators.

A simple way to solve the problem is to levy an internet sales tax, which is the same percentage as the corporation tax that these companies should have paid if they were operating solely in that country in the first place.

This would have some added advantages to companies that have bricks and mortar stores, who currently struggle to survive and compete with online competition. They provide the customers advice and the ability to try on their goods and then the customer price compares and buys cheaper online.

Whilst customers are benefiting from lower prices in the model we have today, we face the real risk that in twenty years you will only be able to buy a book from Amazon. There won't be any other book store.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ksec on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:27PM (#10815946)
But you need to take into account how much some countries are charging for cooperate tax. A stupid insanely huge amount!

You have sales tax, then this company invest into the country and hire people, paying rental for stores, advertising and spending. Once you take away all that, the country has to take 35% of your profits?

The case for Apple isn't as convincing as they are the most profitable company in the world. What about company that operate on laser thin margin? As most company are these days.

I am not again Tax, but it needs to be fair and reasonable. And in most cases it is not. As per your example, how about Vodafone, or many other SME who invest their profits into property market, driving up the cost of property which are every days needs for people in their country, and yet does not pay a single dime of tax.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by 1stop on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:04AM (#10817021)
No it doesn't need to be fair or reasonable, if you want access to the market - pay the tax. Simple. If you don't think it's fair or reasonable, don't enter the market.

Kind of like saying "I'll only play monopoly if I don't have to pay anyone elses rent, but you pay mine".

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ksec on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:24AM (#10817892)
What you are saying is perfectly correct until no one on the market is actually paying their part. Why should other company follow to give themselves an disadvantage?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by junto on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:57AM (#10817132)
The point is to level the playing field and de-power the global corporation. They have now become more powerful than countries and I see that as a problem. It means that they can overpower democracy, which we are seeing more and more through the corruption of our politics.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by derefr on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:41PM (#10815159)
> A simple way to solve the problem is to levy an internet sales tax, which is the same percentage as the corporation tax that these companies should have paid if they were operating solely in that country in the first place.

Ah, but how does something like Google work, then? They don't sell a product to people all over the world (where tax can be collected); people all over the world are the product, and they sell that product to advertisers mostly from the US. Google uses the population of a country to make money without actually receiving any money from anyone in that country.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by cballard on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:26PM (#10815357)
People are not the product. Advertising is, and it's sold somewhere and served from somewhere.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by junto on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:46PM (#10815176)
Goods and services. In terms of their core business, the money they charge British companies to advertise on the Google network should be taxed and paid to the UK government. I don't understand the problem?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by benzoate on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:04PM (#10815260)
Because corporation tax is a tax on profit. Profit is roughly revenue - expenses. How do you ever reliably calculate Google's expenses for the UK? It's basically always going to be a pseudo made up number between total world wide expenses and 0, and shockingly they declare the highest number they think they can get away with.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by 1stop on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:07AM (#10817030)
No, if there are no expenses in the UK, then their UK revenue IS ALL profit.

If their US company is wearing all the expenses then they get a tax saving there.

They are trying to have their cake and eat it, and declare expenses in high tax regions and profit in low tax regions. Hence Ireland being popular.

It's not complicated unless you actively start trying to move money around to avoid tax, which is what they all do.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by junto on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:53AM (#10817123)
You've missed my point. There is no point in levying a profit based corporation tax. I'm suggesting a straight internet sales tax, similar to VAT, rated to raise a revenue comparable to what the country is missing or on in terms of corporation tax.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by 1stop on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:01AM (#10817012)
Tax is 100% a moral issue. Just as all laws are. There can be multiple legally correct answers because there are different circumstances, that's why we have courts, and not Judge Dredd.

You are preaching utopian idealism, but a high school ethics assignment of "stealing medicine to save your mum" undoes your "one set of rules to apply to everything" point.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by wavefunction on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:11PM (#10815007)
People pay their taxes, generally. Corporations on the other hand... Well many pay their taxes as well, if I'm being fair.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by adventured on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:40PM (#10815152)
Very few corporations in the US can dance around jurisdictions to avoid high tax rates like Apple & Co can. To be fair, most American corporations pay very high tax rates compared to the rest of the world, and almost none of them as a percentage are able to avoid paying those high rates.

The median corporate income tax rate, is higher than the median individual income tax rate.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:59PM (#10816241)
Yes. The current situation heavily favors multinationals over wholly domestic corporations. In almost every country, but particularly in the US. That's why "inversions" are all the rage - if you aren't a subsidiary of a corporation in a low-tax country you almost have to become one.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by threeseed on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:59PM (#10815245)
It's a bit meaningless to talk about the corporate tax rate when there are so many deductions available to businesses.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by madeofpalk on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:00AM (#10816243)
But people try and minimise their taxes as much as possible.

Taxes that corporations pay are more complicated and they have more legal avenues to minimise tax payable.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by melted on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:30AM (#10816517)
If you're a regular middle class wage slave, there are very few ways you can reduce your tax burden. My accountant says the only way to even begin to optimize taxes in my tax bracket is to start my own business.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gertef on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:15PM (#10815030)
Until we have a One World Order with no nations, what do you propose?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by meric on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:13PM (#10815299)
I think the world will become more fractured before we go towards something like a one world nation. Unity and Disunity waxes and wanes through out history[1], and now we're near a peak.

[1] For example, 50BC with the Roman Empire, Han Dynasty and this interesting map about Greeks in India, that I found just now. http://www.historyfiles.co.uk/FeaturesFarEast/CentralAsia_Ma...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by rubyfan on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:34PM (#10815123)
It wouldn't matter anyway, we'd still have states. In the US, state to state regulations vary just as much.

One world government would be just as screwed up.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by xxpor on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:43PM (#10815630)
Doesn't the UCC cover 99% of those regulations though?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by rubyfan on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:57PM (#10815670)
Nope, the tax system is pretty screwy. The whole Irish domicile thing is basically Deleware or Nevada headquartered corporation just on a larger stage.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ryanwaggoner on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:14PM (#10815730)
I don't believe that having a Delaware or Nevada corp affects your taxes at all, actually.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by rubyfan on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:40PM (#10815810)
That doesn't apply to your federal but state taxes. It's basically the same as Ireland, certain states are shelters...

http://pennbpc.org/time-close-loopholes-delaware-loophole

Here’s how it works: A large multi-state corporation creates a shell company in a tax-haven state like Delaware. The subsidiary has no employees and is often nothing more than a post office box. The corporation then uses accounting gimmicks to funnel profits through the shell company, leaving no apparent income on the books in Pennsylvania. It may be legal, but it isn’t fair.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by rayiner on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:48PM (#10815192)
Even accountants don't just plug numbers into a spreadsheet and get an answer. There are judgment calls and a range of reasonableness even within the Accounting rules.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by luckydude on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:40PM (#10816166)
I get the spreadsheet. I get that there should not be two answers. What I'd ask you is where is your moral compass? Where do you think the taxes should be?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:56PM (#10816232)
Taxes and morality have nothing to do with each other. Individuals and corporations have a legal duty to pay duly constituted taxes. Nothing more.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by 1stop on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:15AM (#10817048)
If taxes and morality have nothing to do with each other, then the answer is simple: Everybody should avoid paying taxes.

But if we borrow a lesson from moral philosophy just to help us with that thought – Descartes universality principle might help us: If everybody (corps, and individuals) avoided tax, would our system still work? Would it be a system that encourages growth (a requirement for capitalist enterprise)? Would our governments revenue system completely dissolve? Thus our governments completely dissolve? Is "Taxes aren't a moral issue" equivalent to "I want pure free market anarchy"?

Great business idea: Create a corporation that represents employees, with offices in every country. It then signs your employment contract, pays you in a 0 income tax territory and does all the same funny money games Apple et al do.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:17PM (#10819133)
>If taxes and morality have nothing to do with each other, then the answer is simple: Everybody should avoid paying taxes.

Everybody should avoid taxes as long as they stay withing the law, particularly corporations that have a fiduciary duty to do so.

It's moral, usually, to follow the law. But companies like Apple are following the law. Apple already pays billions in tax, far more than it uses in services. Even by that argument Apple isn't doing anything immoral by avoiding more tax.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by solidsnack9000 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:34AM (#10816531)
It is hard to avoid a notion of morality when we are asking, how should things be? Before there are rules, there are choices.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by supercanuck on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:51AM (#10816407)
> Taxes and morality have nothing to do with each other

Bullshit, the concept of fairness is a universal moral.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:07AM (#10816459)
The concept of fairness is so subjective it's meaningless in the context of morality. Decrying something as being "unfair" is childish.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by supercanuck on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:51AM (#10816722)
Right.. nothing subjective about tax:

The report found that Irish officials essentially “reverse-engineered” Apple’s tax bill by first discussing with company representatives the size of the profit they wanted from the Irish branch. Apple’s own tax adviser acknowledged there was “no scientific basis” for the figures, the report said.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/01/business/international/eur...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:12PM (#10819107)
Of course there's something subjective about tax. That was my whole point. I'm going to assume you meant "objective" so your post makes sense.

There's nothing objective the concept of fairness, particularly when it comes to taxes. Taxes are almost completely arbitrary, depending more on what the government in question thinks it can actually collect than anything else.

It's pretty easy to make the case corporations shouldn't be taxed at all. A corporation is nothing more than a group of people that have pooled their resources to make money, after all, and they're already taxed as individuals when profits are disbursed. How is that fair?

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by hyperbovine on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:20PM (#10815051)
> You should be able to plug numbers into a spreadsheet and get it.

But we have that. Take profits and multiply by 0.35. Done.*

The fact that Apple effectively pays less than %10 corporate tax rate in the US is, I think, what the parent poster was referring to.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by bpodgursky on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:36PM (#10815134)
* except that's not really true

For it to be this simple, you're declaring that every company paying less than 35% tax is in breach of the law. Which is obviously not the case in the eyes of the IRS -- there is totally legitimate foreign income, deductions, etc etc.

Whether you think those things are a GOOD idea doesn't matter, there are plenty of companies paying way less than 35% which are not going to get prosecuted, and the IRS would declare in the clear.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:44PM (#10815434)
> The fact that Apple effectively pays less than %10 corporate tax rate in the US is, I think, what the parent poster was referring to.

Can you source this claim, please?

The only sources I've seen that make this claim arrive at this number by treating Apple's worldwide sales as if they were entirely US sales, which is an absurd basis for this calculation.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:33PM (#10815116)
Yes. Thanks for posting this. I've edited my original post to add your information.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ThomPete on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:13PM (#10815017)
I would love for you to explain why Apples shouldn't be paying taxes in the US instead of Ireland I simply don't get it.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by simonh on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:43PM (#10815168)
If a phone's components are made in Korea, Japan and China, assembled in China, then sent on Greek owned ships to Europe where they are sold for Euros by European stores to European citizens and paying European sales taxes, how much tax is due in America?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by iofj on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:26PM (#10815087)
We all know the answer. Because all governments feel they should spend that money instead of Apple. And they can take it, so they should.

And the more left-leaning part of the aisle has this idea that they will get to decide what that money will be spent on. So they support this. (I'm not rightist, in fact I'm probably extreme left by American standards, but I just don't believe the government is on the people's side anymore)

Of course there's a million different ways to say this, many are more polite, but it all boils down to this. They want money, they have the ability to take it.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by beatpanda on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:46PM (#10815179)
Yeah, or, Apple benefits handsomely from money spent on their behalf by the federal and local governments (e.g. the roads and public transit infrastructure serving their headquarters, the funding for the public universities and subsidized loans for private universities from which they draw their employees), but apparently doesn't feel any obligation for funding those benefits.

It's not about "feeling that they can spend the money better", it's that government already spent the money, and Apple (and other companies) benefited from it, and now they need to pay their share.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by digbyloftus on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:47PM (#10815446)
"Their share" is exactly what's up for debate. You make it sound like the US Government has a number and they're failing to collect because Apple is strong arming them. The US Government has the largest military in the world by a far margin and Apple has roughly zero physical might. If the US wants Apples money they can easily take Apples money. Until that point they're just talking.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by meanduck on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:12AM (#10816777)
> the roads and public transit infrastructure serving their headquarters, the funding for the public universities and subsidized loans for private universities from which they draw their employees

Citizens pay taxes. Citizens get infrastuctures and subsidies.

> it's that government already spent the money, and Apple (and other companies) benefited from it, and now they need to pay their share.

It does not work like that. It has to be explicitly agreed by both parties.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:04AM (#10816263)
>Yeah, or, Apple benefits handsomely from money spent on their behalf by the federal and local governments (e.g. the roads and public transit infrastructure serving their headquarters, the funding for the public universities and subsidized loans for private universities from which they draw their employees), but apparently doesn't feel any obligation for funding those benefits.

It's hard to see any way to do the accounting such that Apple doesn't already pay for that and more.

And if you're going to start doing that kind of accounting, shouldn't governments credit Apple with the personal income taxes Apple employees pay?

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by zepto on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:16PM (#10815035)
Because the money is not made in the US
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by npizzolato on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:32PM (#10815111)
Is all that money actually made outside the US? Or is it made outside of the US in the same spirit as how Hollywood movies never make a profit?[1][2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting

[2] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/09/how-holl...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:36PM (#10815403)
To my understanding, this is money that is actually made outside the US. If Apple (US) sells an iPhone to an American customer, they will pay US corporate income tax on the profits from that sale.

However, if Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, the 'double Irish' arrangement lets them avoid paying corporate income taxes on those profits.

There are two issues here:

1. Some might argue that because Apple is based in the US and the R&D for these products occurs in the US, that when Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, Apple (US) should pay taxes on those profits. This is somewhat questionable, I think.

2. When Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, they should pay Italian corporate income tax on those profits, instead of being able to wipe those profits out using licensing agreements with Apple (Ireland). This is more straightforward and is the loophole being addressed by this settlement.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:12AM (#10816292)
>If Apple (US) sells an iPhone to an American customer, they will pay US corporate income tax on the profits from that sale.

Except they don't, really. They use the same "double Irish" scheme in the US. Apple has offshore holding companies that own the IP for that iPhone. When a US customer buys an iPhone, much of the actual profit gets shifted to the offshore subsidiaries as an expense. That's how they ended up with $200bn offshore and only $10bn or so in the US.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by HSO on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:35AM (#10816685)
> That's how they ended up with $200bn offshore and only $10bn or so in the US.

Wrong. They initiated a capital return program a few years ago and ran down their US cash holdings while taking on debt "against" part of their overseas holdings. Once you account for the debt issues, their net cash holdings are a lot lower (though still substantial). Please don't make wild accusations if you don't know what you are talking about.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:57PM (#10819028)
It's not wrong.

http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/07/22/as-apples-offshore...

They still can't repatriate that money without paying taxes. And as of two quarters ago they still have $200bn offshore and $10bn in the US. That offshore tax horde is still growing and it's still growing as a result of Double Irish flim-flam.

Don't accuse other people of not knowing what they're talking about unless you know what you're talking about.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by HSO on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:26PM (#10820057)
For the record, I said your assertion that Apple's cash position was due to Double Irish tax maneuvers on US income is wrong, and that net cash (once you account for debt issued to pay dividends) is significantly lower, both in absolute terms and in the disparity between overseas and onshore holdings. Before the initiation of the 140bn capital return program, relative balances were less skewed and more reflective of where profits were generated.

I won't respond to you again in this thread because I can't deal with people who lack basic reading comprehension, logic, and fact-checking skills.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:47PM (#10820153)
You have a talent for seeing the trees and missing the forest. Apple isn't changing anything by borrowing against its foreign cash horde. That just gives it access to the money without having to pay taxes.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by zepto on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:55PM (#10820632)
No. They are still liable for taxes on the cash horde. It is simply deferred.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:26PM (#10820721)
That was the point.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by zepto on Friday January 01, 2016 @02:02PM (#10822854)
Well you misstated it then. You said they 'without having to pay taxes'. This is false. They do have to pay the taxes. And the cash hoard might technically be 'growing' but there is a corresponding liability that is growing too - so it's no longer Apple's money to do what they want with - it's owed to creditors.

So the 'film-flam' as you call it avoids no taxes with regard to the cash-horde.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:06AM (#10816765)
Please provide a source for your claim. Everything I've read indicates these tax arrangements are only effective for foreign profits.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:56PM (#10819023)
Would it be too much to ask that people looked at the wiki page before they demanded sources? The page for Double Irish mentions Apple by name.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:15PM (#10819127)
Wow, thanks for your incredibly condescending reply. Let's look at the actual Wikipedia page for the Double Irish arrangement:

"The offshore company continues to receive all of the profits from exploitation of the rights outside the US, but without paying US tax on the profits unless and until they are remitted to the US."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement

"However, tax experts say that strategies like the Double Irish help explain how Apple has managed to keep its international taxes to 3.2 percent of foreign profits last year, to 2.2 percent in 2010, and in the single digits for the last half-decade, according to the company’s corporate filings."

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/business/apples-tax-strate...

"Under a typical “Double Irish” structure, a U.S. parent company (USCo) forms two Irish subsidiaries, IrishCo1 and IrishCo2. IrishCo1 is a first-tier Irish subsidiary organized under Irish law but managed and controlled in a low-tax jurisdiction (e.g., Bermuda or the British Virgin Islands). While U.S. rules determine tax residency of a corporation based on its place of incorporation, Irish law often determines tax residency based on the country where the company is managed and controlled. Accordingly, IrishCo1 will be treated for U.S. tax purposes as an Irish corporation, but for Irish tax purposes generally will be structured so as to be treated as a nonresident of Ireland resident in, for example, Bermuda. USCo will retain all US rights in the relevant IP and will license to IrishCo1 the rights to develop and exploit the IP outside the US. IrishCo1 will then sublicense these IP rights to IrishCo2, which in turn will use the IP to manufacture/produce IP products and then sell those products to customers outside the U.S."

http://www.taxeswithoutbordersblog.com/2014/10/death-of-the-...

You clearly do not understand how the double Irish arrangement actually works or what taxes it is supposed to reduce. Hint: if Apple could wipe out their US income tax obligations so easily using this arrangement, they probably wouldn't have bothered to pay that $14 billion in corporate income tax last year.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:42PM (#10819256)
You're missing the implications. How much foreign business did Apple do in the 1980s? Look here:

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/business/MemoOnOff...

>The Apple case study examines how Apple Inc., a U.S. corporation, has used a variety of offshore structures, arrangements, and transactions to shift billions of dollars in profits away from the United States and into Ireland, where Apple has negotiated a special corporate tax rate of less than 2%. One of Apple’s more unusual tactics has been to establish and direct substantial funds to offshore entities that are not declared tax residents of any jurisdiction. In 1980, Apple created Apple Operations International, which acts as its primary offshore holding company but has not declared tax residency in any jurisdiction. Despite reporting net income of $30 billion over the four-year period 2009 to 2012, Apple Operations International paid no corporate income taxes to any national government during that period. Similarly, Apple Sales International, a second Irish affiliate, is the repository for Apple’s offshore intellectual property rights and the recipient of substantial income related to Apple worldwide sales, yet claims to be a tax resident nowhere and may be causing that income to go untaxed.

That's not some guy in his pajamas, there. It's a Senate report. For most US companies the whole point of the lowered Irish tax rate is to pay that on profits you've moved offshore.

And while most of Apple's profit would probably still come from other markets if it weren't playing these kinds of offset pricing games, Apple has moved billions of dollars in profits out of the US to avoid taxes.

It's not just Apple, either. This is why the effective US tax rate for corporations is 12.6% even as the statutory rate is 35%. I suspect that figure would be a lot lower, too, if only multinationals were considered.

This is the elephant in the tax tent: The IRS has wide latitude when determining what's reasonable for companies to charge subsidiaries for goods and services (and vice versa). But it's easy to arbitrarily complicate these kinds of arrangements.

And it's pretty subjective to start with - how much should Apple pay Apple Sales International to use a patent that nobody else is licensing? How would you even determine the fair market value? There are rules, of course, but even assuming there's no undue influence by corporations (and you can't assume that), imagine writing a set of rules that covers every conceivable business arrangement between multinationals that doesn't leave any grey area. Can't be done.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:08PM (#10819685)
I’m only defending my statement that the double Irish arrangement doesn’t work for US sales, and that Apple (US) continues to pay corporate income taxes on the goods they sell to US customers.

That Apple uses various tax arrangements to wipe out profits from its international sales is not in question. However, these are sales made by Apple’s foreign subsidiaries to foreign customers. They weren’t moved offshore, they were offshore to begin with.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:03PM (#10819951)
Except that isn't actually true. Irish subsidiary revenues include payments from the parent that subtract from recognized US profits of sales made in the US. They're moving profits from US sales to Ireland.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by nodamage on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:56PM (#10820186)
Again, please cite a source for this. Nothing I've read, including the above memo, indicates that sales of Apple products to US customers get transferred to Ireland. The memo specifically indicates that Apple Inc. retains the marketing and distribution rights in the US, whereas ASI gets the distribution rights for the rest of the world.

I can see how Apple (Italy) and Apple (Germany) end up transferring their profits over to Apple (Ireland). I don't see any mechanism for how this could apply to Apple (US).

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:41PM (#10820748)
Never mind - you guys are right. I got them confused with another company.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by zepto on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:54PM (#10820629)
No they aren't - this is a false claim which is not substantiated by any of the citations.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gozur88 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:40PM (#10820747)
Never mind - you guys are right. I got them confused with another company.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by npizzolato on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:32PM (#10818893)
Thanks for the explanation. I agree with you that (1) is rather questionable, but to me, (2) seems like a fair tax.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:05PM (#10815267)
I agree with you and I'm updating my post to show that your position and mine are similar.

We both want a reasonable tax structure. But Apple is exploiting the unreasonableness of the tax structure, e.g. by using outdated codes, shell games, tax havens, etc.

Apple leaders have the opportunity and moral responsibility to stop exploiting, and start helping.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by sigzero on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:28PM (#10815593)
You keep saying "moral responsibility". They don't. Companies have already been telling the government what's wrong and the government refuses to change it. Apple is responsible to its shareholders bottom line.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by paulddraper on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:00PM (#10816038)
In fact, Apple has a fiduciary obligation to act in the interests of their shareholders.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by marincounty on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:36PM (#10815132)
Yea, I'm with you, but don't expect the United States to fight/do anything for that money/employees if we have some calamity.

Basically, if someone decides to take that money overseas--don't throw up you hands, and expect U.S. Soldiers to save the day.

So we live in this new world economy. Fine. If things go haywire; your company is on its own. Don't use our military. Don't use our government, and courts. Don't complain. You're on your own.

The problem , I see, is even if these companies didn't expect any favors from the United States in times of crisis; the United States would still try to rectify the problem. Tim Cook knows his money is safe anywhere. Why not pay close to nothing on profits? I wish we weren't the ambasitors of right/wrong, or the world's police.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jacobolus on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:47PM (#10816189)
> What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits.

This is exactly what they pay currently.

> Do the same for all countries.

This is what they just settled with the Italian government about; previously they thought they were legally in the clear paying Irish corporate taxes for profits from across the EU.

> The Apple problem is that its lawyers are deliberately avoiding using current tax codes, and instead essentially claiming that Apple is based in Ireland, then playing shell games with what counts as U.S. sales, U.S. profits, and also U.S. property. Apple ends up paying ~10% U.S. tax, rather than ~35%.

Apple does pay standard US corporate tax on profit from all US sales, the same 35% as any other company, and makes no claim that Apple, Inc. is located in Ireland. The Irish subsidiaries are money pools that collect Apple’s foreign profits, so that e.g. in Europe Apple pays VAT in each country but only small amounts of corporate taxes. They can then take that money and use it to acquire foreign companies, run their foreign retail/support operations, invest in manufacturing capital, fund overseas R&D offices, et cetera, or just hoard a pile of cash. In the US, Apple has simultaneously taken out big loans (because they currently get ridiculously low interest rates) which money they can use for capital expenditures in the US or dividends or whatever.

But Apple isn’t playing any shell games about US sales, profits, or property, per se. In my opinion you should do some basic research before making such obviously false accusations.

There’s plenty about the Irish tax setup that is questionable, and arguably Apple should repatriate more of its foreign profits back to the US and pay US corporate taxes on them. However, the discussion should be focused on what they currently do vs. what they should be forced to do by an improved tax code, not on some imaginary scenario based on what some other companies do.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Friday January 01, 2016 @11:43PM (#10825070)
> But Apple isn’t playing any shell games about US sales, profits, or property, per se. > In my opinion you should do some basic research before making such obviously false accusations.

I've done research. Here are examples from news summaries and the U.S. Senate report.

"Apple Inc. transferred the economic rights to its intellectual property through a cost sharing agreement with its own offshore affiliates, and was thereby able to shift tens of billions of dollars offshore to a low tax jurisdiction and avoid U.S. tax. Apple Inc. then utilized U.S. tax loopholes, including the so-called “check-the-box” rules, to avoid U.S. taxes on $44 billion in taxable offshore income over the past four years, or about $10 billion in tax avoidance per year. The hearing will also examine some of the weaknesses and loopholes in certain U.S. tax code provisions, including transfer pricing, Subpart F, and related regulations, that enable multinational corporations to avoid U.S. taxes."

"In annual reports between 2009 and 2011, the company told investors it was setting aside $13.7 billion to pay federal taxes—but it has actually paid only $5.3 billion. "

"The report alleges more than just the avoidance of US taxes on foreign sales of Apple’s products. It also argues that Apple is effectively sending US profits to its Irish subsidiaries, too. How? Transfer pricing. Apple has set up a cost-sharing agreement with its Irish subsidiaries that gives them a disproportionate share of the profit from research and development that occurs in the United States. From 2009 to 2012, Apple allocated $4 billion in R&D costs to its US unit, which had $38.7 billion in profits, while its Irish subsidiary had $4.9 billion in R&D costs—and $74 billion in profits."

Here's a Forbes summary URLs that may interest you for more specifics that I'm reading-- feel free to provide counter-examples or point to better research if you're aware of it.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2013/05/21/the-real-stor...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ChuckMcM on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:12PM (#10815013)
I wish it were that simple, but it isn't. Whether it is New York trying to collect income tax from people who didn't live in the state or California trying to get everyone to pay 'use' tax (the equivalent of sales tax) on anything they bought outside of California, there are plenty of examples of tax law where morality never enters the picture.

What you can do is insure that you follow all applicable laws, and within that simple admonishion are two "get out of jail free" cards, one "Does this law actually apply?" and the other "What does this law actually say?". And after paying cash to the IRS on gains which you didn't actually get (looking at AMT here) you start wondering, what is the law here trying to do, other than suck as much money as possible into the government? And once you enter into an adversarial mindset it is you vs the government over whether or not you need to pony up the money.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by gnicholas on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:27AM (#10816663)
Unfortunately, tax codes cannot simply be streamlined to be more algorithmic because every company has different facts and circumstances, which ultimately require judgment calls. If you tried to build an algorithm that accounted for all of the complexities, you'd just send the problem upstream (who writes the algorithm?).

You mention Apple's Ireland operations, and you allude to the "earnings stripping" that is commonly achieved through such foreign companies. In some cases, the subsidiary is a pure tax play. But in other cases, it's simply a matter of having foreign operations that perform services that are charged out to affiliates in various countries. Deciding how much to mark up these services is a classic facts-and-circumstances inquiry. There's no one-size-fits-all rule that can adequately capture the spectrum of activities.

Compounding the problem is the fact that there are multiple taxing authorities involved, and if one gets greedy then others are affected (through foreign tax credits, for example). Sometimes a company just ends up getting stuck in the middle of a turf war between tax agencies in two countries.

Lastly, Tim Cook does have a "moral responsibility" with regard to taxation: maximize shareholder value. Granted, he could reasonably decide to take actions that do not minimize tax liability in the near term, on the grounds that he would generate goodwill with consumers and increase sales. But if he announced that he was going to dismantle Apple's foreign subsidiary structure so that Apple could pay more taxes, you can bet he'd face shareholder lawsuits in no time flat.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by asuffield on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:53AM (#10816860)
> Do the same for all countries.

So here's the specific reason why this is difficult in the case under discussion:

The EU runs as a "single market". It is intended to function such that you do business "in the EU" rather than "individually in every country that is part of the EU". There are no tariffs on moving goods between countries in the EU. Having imported something into the EU, you don't then have to pay more tax to sell it in a different EU country.

Except... the tax rates are not fixed across all EU countries. That was a bridge too far for the politicians when this was being set up. So under the rules as written, it's entirely legitimate - and intentional - to pick which EU country you want to operate in and pay your taxes there. This worked fine until some EU countries realised that they could compete against the other ones to offer more favourable tax regimes and attract businesses to themselves.

This isn't really a fight between companies and governments. The companies are the ball being played. This is a fight between governments over who gets to collect how much of the tax (to call it Germany versus Ireland would be unfair but not entirely imprecise). I do not see a way for it to be settled other than agreeing on tax rates being set by the EU, but that is politically challenging at the moment.

> Tim Cook and Apple have an opportunity and moral responsibility to help close these tax loopholes

I strongly disagree. I do not think that US corporations should be trying to settle arguments between EU governments. That is a level of political involvement which seems grossly inappropriate.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by harryh on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:14PM (#10815544)
When Apple designs a phone in CA, buys supplies from companies located in a dozen different countries, assembles it in China and sells it in Australia what tax should be paid and to whom?

These aren't "tax loopholes." They're legitimate rules to answer this fairly complicated question.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by dangrossman on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:18PM (#10815557)
When the income ends up on the books and taxed only in Ireland, after expensing most of it as licensing fees to a shell company in Bermuda, despite none of those things (design, sourcing, manufacturing, assembly, sales) occurring in either country, it starts looking more like a loophole than legitimate rules around taxing an international business.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by harryh on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:22PM (#10815572)
None of the profits from selling things in the US goes on the Irish books. Only profits from selling things outside the US. This is done because the US (almost uniquely so) taxes worldwide earnings for companies based in the US.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by dangrossman on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:26PM (#10815584)
What about all the other countries that they have property, employees and sales in? It's a loophole if it lets them pay nothing to any of those nations, despite being as much a corporate citizen of those nations as whatever office is next door to theirs.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by harryh on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:32PM (#10815604)
It's not a loophole that lets them pay nothing to any of those nations. Apple pays taxes in every country it operates in.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:36AM (#10817959)
> When the income ends up on the books and taxed only in Ireland, after expensing most of it as licensing fees to a shell company in Bermuda, despite none of those things (design, sourcing, manufacturing, assembly, sales) occurring in either country, it starts looking more like a loophole than legitimate rules around taxing an international business.

That's because it's a tax on profit, not a tax on design, sourcing, manufacturing, assembly, or sales.

Suppose I have an idea for a piece of hardware. So I hire one of these body shops in India to design the hardware. They make hardly any profit. Then I pay a Chinese company to manufacture it. They make hardly any profit. Then I sell the hardware through some retailer in Germany. They make hardly any profit.

But the enterprise is very successful for me and I'm sitting at home in my mansion driving my Ferrari because I've made all this profit. And you don't have any idea what country I live in because it doesn't matter -- if I move to a different country because it has lower taxes then the profits are still mine. Which is what international corporations do.

Stop trying to tax profits. They have no physical presence which means they just disappear into whichever jurisdiction has the lowest taxes. Tax something that physically exists in your jurisdiction and be done with it.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by madeofpalk on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @11:50PM (#10816207)
Tax is a system of rules, codified in law. When you have a system of rules, I don't think it's reasonable to hold them accountable to some arbitrary second standard, nor expect them to unnecessarily hand over billions of extra dollars.

Apple, and the rest of them, are following these laws. If governments are unhappy with the the amount of tax Apple pays after following the rules then they should change them.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by echaozh on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:21AM (#10816328)
Totally agree. Lay down better rules and let the companies decide whether to play with your rules or exit your market. Games have to be played fair.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by bpodgursky on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:50PM (#10815652)
Also... that was a really low, shameless edit:

> Specifically, the goal is to streamline tax codes to be more clear, more consistent, and more algorithmic.

Your original post said (I don't have it saved), that the goal was to make all income from US companies taxed as US income. COMPLETELY different.

It is very dishonest to completely change your post after there's a whole comment tree under you.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jph on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:08PM (#10819684)
I see your point. What I wrote originally was misunderstood by one of the repliers, so I edited to clarify, and commented on his reply that I was doing it.

> that the goal was to make all income from US companies taxed as US income. COMPLETELY different.

I'll explain more detail so my goal is better-understood. My goal is to have Apple, the U.S., and Ireland come to an agreement about the the U.S. Senate report "Offshore Profit Shifting and the U.S. Tax Code (Apple Inc.)". Here is a specific paragraph that introduces one of the important issues.

"In addition, the hearing will examine how Apple Inc. transferred the economic rights to its intellectual property through a cost sharing agreement with its own offshore affiliates, and was thereby able to shift tens of billions of dollars offshore to a low tax jurisdiction and avoid U.S. tax. Apple Inc. then utilized U.S. tax loopholes, including the so-called “check-the-box” rules, to avoid U.S. taxes on $44 billion in taxable offshore income over the past four years, or about $10 billion in tax avoidance per year. The hearing will also examine some of the weaknesses and loopholes in certain U.S. tax code provisions, including transfer pricing, Subpart F, and related regulations, that enable multinational corporations to avoid U.S. taxes.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tn13 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:05PM (#10815264)
There is nothing moral about paying taxes. What Apple has earned belongs to Apple and in ideal world it should pay nothing to US government. US government should probably think of simplifying and lowering the tax to the extent that avoiding it becomes more expensive than paying it.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ves on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:27PM (#10815587)
Keep in mind that Apple does owe the US government a significant amount, so your statement is inaccurate. Apple would not function without the infrastructure provided by the government, would not be able to protect its IP without US patents, relies on the US for its workforce in Cupertino, etc.

So while I agree with your first claim, and do think Apple should "not" be taxed (tax people, not corporations), I don't agree with your second statement.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tn13 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:04AM (#10817151)
I said in "ideal case" and not in general case and I was only emphasizing why the government attitude that Apple owes US government something is wrong.

As far as public infrastructure etc. is concerned only a minuscule portion of over taxes get spent on actual government functions such as protection of property rights and Liberty. Most of the money is currently going in wars we cant win or end, military junk and welfare. If I had a choice I would pay government to run a police force and courts but not for these things.

US gov already gets sufficient tax money to run its basic business. I would appreciate if the cut their spending instead of stealing money from me and Apple.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by wookasz on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:45PM (#10815639)
Thanks for saying this. I don't understand how people can forget that everyone relies on public roads, the power grid, police and armed forces, and a plethora of other expensive infrastructure items without which it would be nearly impossible to make a penny.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Alupis on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:41PM (#10815157)
It's not somehow patriotic to pay more in taxes than you legally owe.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:01AM (#10817788)
> What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits. Do the same for all countries.

The whole problem is, what are "U.S." profits?

Google pays a bunch of engineer salaries to design Google Docs. Most of the engineers are in the U.S. If they declare that huge expense in the U.S. then it will cancel all the U.S. revenue for Google Docs, which they're happy to do because the U.S. has a high corporate tax rate.

Meanwhile the parent company in Ireland now owns a bunch of valuable new code that can be used world-wide and be licensed to Google UK and Google France etc., creating lots of profits for Google Ireland where taxes are low.

No part of this is doing anything "wrong" -- whichever corporate entity is the one that owns the rights to the code is the one that will make all the profits, because the code generates more revenue than it costs to create. And there is nothing that ties that entity to a particular country, especially when the expenses aren't actually all in the same place. The product is created by huge teams spread all over the world. Which corporate entity in which country "owns" the profits is completely arbitrary. So they choose the one in the country with the lowest taxes. What would you expect?

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by guelo on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:57PM (#10815229)
It's only complicated because the corporations hire hordes of top-notch lawyers to figure out the optimal structure for paying the least amount of taxes by exploiting all loopholes and coming as close as possible to skirting the laws. If the corporations optimized for simplicity the corporate structures would be much different.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tn13 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:03PM (#10815257)
Corporations are trying to keep their own money. Hiring top notch lawyers is economical because they actually help them save more than what the lawyers get paid. I dont see how fault lies with the corporations.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by guelo on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:11PM (#10815291)
Sure. And that complication actually benefits the corporations that have the resources to figure it all out.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jgalt212 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:11PM (#10815289)
I assume you do understand the problem that would result if everyone could pursue every possible loophole to the maximum extent like Apple, Google, Amazon, FB, et al do.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tn13 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:05AM (#10817154)
I don't understand your point. If there is a loophole I can exploit to pay 0 tax I would and recommend everyone else to do so.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jgalt212 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:20AM (#10817183)
My point is what would happen if everyone had the resources and moral turpitude to exploit every possible loophole.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by xixi77 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:49AM (#10817244)
Perhaps the government would then have an incentive to simplify the tax system and eliminate the loophole?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by jgalt212 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:14PM (#10820979)
I guess, but that actually depends on congress actually enacting new legislation.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tn13 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:07PM (#10819395)
Yes and it would be good thing. I don't agree that there is anything moral coercing people to part with 50% of their hard earned wealth so government could fund losing wars, foodstamps for bums and lobster fight clubs.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by cmurf on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:09AM (#10816769)
Corporate profits have to be taxed, either the tax is paid by shareholders (annual pass through like S) or by the corporation (C corporation). Just doing it on cap gains doesn't work because there is no tax unless the asset is sold, and the asset doesn't even have to be sold, it can be borrowed against cheaply and make even more money that isn't taxed at the same rate as earned income.

There's a reason why it's stupid and complicated, it's a political and economic compromise. Compromise is exactly why it's ugly. There is no possible meritocracy here. It won't ever happen, it's politically untenable.

Also, corporations have fought to be recognized as persons when it comes to political free speech, so tough noogies they can pay tax like a person too.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by belorn on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:41PM (#10815994)
People do have the great feature of being corporeal beings, but companies has the great feature of having limited liability. Owners and investors likes this because the state will take part of the responsibility if the ethereal corporations goes south, and countries likes it because it makes corporations an entity which they can tax.

A easy solution is to admit that creating ethereal entities is a stupid idea, get rid of it, and just has owners and investors. It would scare away the larger corporations, but it would make life much easier for everyone else, eliminate a bunch of complicated laws, and make international trade much easier since you then only deal with corporeal beings.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tim333 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:12PM (#10815540)
>How about, we admit corporate income tax is a stupid idea, get rid of it, and raise capital gains taxes

Technical reasons why that doesn't work - basically it makes it too easy to avoid all tax by keeping the money in corporations.

What we need is a unified global tax regime for international corporations so they can't play off each countries tax loop holes.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by ves on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:32PM (#10815605)
But you can't do anything with that money (left in the corporation) - it eventually winds up buying things for people, or being transferred to someone's bank account, at which point it will be taxed.

You could leave it on the company's balance sheets forever, but that's pretty stupid, especially if you're trying to avoid taxes, as then you just get none of the money instead of most of it.

Why not just tax the people that make up the corporations? They have to spend 51% of their time somewhere, and all taxable stuff winds up in their hands (don't tax reinvestments), so figuring out their tax obligations is simple, relatively.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tim333 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:00PM (#10815680)
Yeah but say you own a house and write some hit software that brings in $1m a year. At the moment either you or your company pay income tax on the $1m. With zero corp tax you leave all the money in the company, the company buys a corporate yacht and jet, for spending money you pay yourself minimum wage and borrow a bit against the house. Result millionaire lifestyle, zero tax. I see your point in principle but in practice it makes the above kind of avoidance too easy. Unless you are some place that doesn't need to raise income tax because it has another source of money eg, Dubai with oil or Monaco with real estate.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:07PM (#10815702)
You can (in principle) do this anyway - the jet and the yacht are expenses, and you only pay corporate income tax on the profit ($1M - cost of yacht - cost of house ~= $0).

In practice the IRS will treat use of the yacht as taxable income paid to the user.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tim333 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:53PM (#10815841)
Maybe but I'd bet if you surveyed all the corporate jets out there and found what percentage were being treated as personal taxable income you'd find it pretty low.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:19PM (#10815920)
Perhaps, but its moot. Taxing corporations does not fix this problem (since money spent on yachts is treated as expenses and not taxed as income) and eliminating corporate income tax would not change this.

In fact, eliminating corporate income tax would discourage this, since it makes alternatives (namely taking a profit and reinvesting in the business) cheaper.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by digbyloftus on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:13PM (#10815905)
It would seem like fixing that problem directly rather than using a roundabout system of taxing corporations, which comes with its own set of problems, would be the better way to go about things.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by funkyy on Thursday December 31, 2015 @01:35AM (#10816535)
Or just introduce 1% revenue tax, get rid of all other taxes and tax credits?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by funkyy on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:58AM (#10816746)
I would like the person that downvoted this to speak up, after all HN is conversation driven community. Whenever I see someone mentioning revenue tax for corporations I see those posts being downvoted a lot and I never see anyone ever explaining why.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by IanCal on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:19AM (#10817059)
I didn't downvote, but you seem to have put basically no thought into this or have at least not shown any in your comment. Why 1%? How would that work? What are the downsides, etc? Why is VAT in the EU not the right way?
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by funkyy on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:22AM (#10817185)
1% would mean there would be increase in revenue to the government. For example Adam Smith Foundation in Poland have calculated that introducing revenue tax of 1% would increase revenue to the country budget, remove black market and allow country to tax international corporations easily. Also savings from tax collection process would be huge and there would be no place to manipulate with tax credits. At the moment in Poland 0.44% of revenue gets to the budget through corporate taxes which is really low. Then additional benefit is that business owners will not need to worry about bad decisions by tax office. The institute found that around 60% of companies in Poland do not pay any kind of corporate tax at all meaning all of them - at least on paper - are loosing money. Google has not paid any tax in Poland in last years despite owning 80% of ad market. The research on the new tax was done by the brightest economist and they are hoping it will be introduced at least for foreign corporations.

The VAT is OK as long as it is fixed and low (10-12% without discounts etc.), the issue is with corporate taxes.

Source: http://wyborcza.biz/biznes/1,100896,15540136,Podatek_od_przy...

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by IanCal on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:46AM (#10817519)
> 1% would mean there would be increase in revenue to the government.

For all governments? UK corporation tax receipts were £40B in 2013-2014, to be matched there would have to be over 4 trillion pounds in revenue to tax. GDP seems to be less than half of that. While you're providing a source, does this extend to other countries? What other impacts are there? Does everyone need to switch over to this approach at the same time?

Are small businesses selling in a chain hurt because there are multiple sales, therefore promoting huge single companies where there's only one sale?

> The VAT is OK as long as it is fixed and low (10-12% without discounts etc.)

Well, that's not what happens now (UK is between 0 and 20%), so again you're glibly making huge changes to large tax setups without looking at the consequences. Increases to basic staples would hit the poorest harder, for example.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by funkyy on Thursday December 31, 2015 @09:52AM (#10817748)
> GDP seems to be less than half of that

GDP is total INCOME not revenue. GDP is total value of FINAL product, so all steps in the shipping chain are not calculated, just the last one.

>Are small businesses selling in a chain hurt because there are multiple sales, therefore promoting huge single companies where there's only one sale?

SMBs are actually the ones that will profit from this the most. Since the tax is on all revenues and there is no tax credit, the tax amount on final product between large shopping chain and small shop is rather small. Large chains undercut small shops now by using advanced accounting, something that small shops cannot afford to do. This way of taxation was used before in communism to some extent to help to ease tax burden. It was quite successful - and now would be even better with country-wide usage of banking to handle revenues rather than cash.

The amount of sales does not matter - only thing that matters is the amount of middle man in the shipping chain. Small shops would be encouraged to get products from local producers and directly from warehouses that avoid middle man in order to save on taxes. This would encourage direct transactions between farmers and vegetable shop owners for example boosting local markets and distributing employment more evenly. Large companies would need to fight the market with higher quality products, better marketing and unique products - driving technology up.

>Increases to basic staples would hit the poorest harder, for example.

With overall products being cheaper and local markets being boosted, the distribution of wealth would be easier. Also government instead of reducing VAT on certain products which creates a lot of creative accounting by corporations, could for example provide "food stamps" for certain products to the poorest. Additional £25 a week in food stamps for groceries from government to poorest families would have way better affect than decreasing tax equivalent to £25.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:00PM (#10815681)
Don't forget that many of these large companies paid off the politicians to ensure there were these loopholes to exploit in the first place.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Pyxl101 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:00AM (#10816244)
> Don't forget that many of these large companies paid off the politicians to ensure there were these loopholes to exploit in the first place.

Which companies did that? Can you provide a link to more details?

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by JohnTHaller on Thursday December 31, 2015 @12:28AM (#10816339)
In addition to the usual political donations, the amount of money big tech companies put into lobbying firms like Digital Economy Group, Fipra and RLM Finsbury is pretty absurd. Heck Apple hired a top lawyer away from the European Commission that was investigating their tax irregularities because that's somehow legal at the moment.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by bedhead on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:40PM (#10815418)
It's one of the great misconceptions. You can't tax a corporation, you can only tax people.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by tim333 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @08:16PM (#10815551)
You can tax corporations. They of course will be owned by people until the AIs take over.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by forrestthewoods on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:55PM (#10814945)
It's worse than that. Countries will make up taxes for foreign companies just because they can. Microsoft EU settlements being a prime example. Windows 7 N is one of the dumbest things ever. The whole situation makes a lot more sense if you view it as a tax.
Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Oletros on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:11PM (#10815012)
> Countries will make up taxes for foreign companies just because they can. Microsoft EU settlements being a prime example.

What has to do Microsoft N with taxes?

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by forrestthewoods on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:37PM (#10815145)
Windows 7 N exists because of the 2004 European Commission decision. That decision being a 497 million Euro fine. The fine was stupid when it was issued and it's ramifications were stupid when they forced Windows 7 N into existence.

If you view the fine as a tax it all makes far more sense. The fine is merely a tax that is the cost of doing business in Europe. Microsoft is willing to pay it because they still net profit in Europe. And Europe certainly has no issue demanding money from an American corporation.

Nation states demanding unreasonable things from foreign companies is nothing new. There's many a ruling that would have gone another way were the defendant a local entity.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Oletros on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:45PM (#10815173)
> The fine was stupid when it was issued and it's ramifications were stupid when they forced Windows 7 N into existence.

This is just opinion

> If you view the fine as a tax it all makes far more sense

It is not a tax, so it doesn't make sense

> The fine is merely a tax that is the cost of doing business in Europe

Wrong, the fine is a consequence of breaking competition laws

> And Europe certainly has no issue demanding money from an American corporation.

The majority of the fines have been given to European companies, more than 80% of the money.

>Nation states demanding unreasonable things from foreign companies is nothing new. There's many a ruling that would have gone another way were the defendant a local entity.

Reality says that this is not the case, but if you have more data, I will look at it

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by kchoudhu on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:05PM (#10815269)
> Wrong, the fine is a consequence of breaking competition laws

I assure you, the cost of breaking the law is factored into a spreadsheet somewhere in all corporations of note, and that this metaphorical spreadsheet is always used to make decisions.

The OP is absolutely correct when he says that fines are the cost of doing business. He's wrong when he says that this is a phenomenon associated with Europe though -- corporate amorality ultimately knows nothing of national boundaries.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Oletros on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:36AM (#10817211)
> The OP is absolutely correct when he says that fines are the cost of doing business

Perhaps is correct is it is the cost of doing business BREAKING the law, but it is wrong when the OP says that it is the cost just for operating in a place without breaking any law

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by forrestthewoods on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:16PM (#10815315)
1) Windows 7 N is as objectively stupid as can be given that is an object with zero consumer interest created in the name of consumer protection. It's not a thing that anyone wants or wanted. It's a colossal waste of resources that provides zero value.

2/3) You're right. A fine isn't a tax. Now assume you are a nation state and some foreign entity is making a shit ton of money off your population. Now let's assume that you feel you aren't getting as large of a slice of pie as you deserve. What are some ways you can increase your slice size? Raising taxes is one way. Issuing fines is another way.

For example local police generate money off things such as parking fines. It's true that the parking fine is a consequence of breaking a local ordinance. However the rationale for issuing more fines can one of several reasons. It could be an increased focus on enforcing existing laws. It could also be because the police need more money and they looked at ways to generate more revenue and found that an increased focus on parking violations would be a cost efficient way to do so. This same line of reasoning can be applied to certain Euro fines.

4) That's fine. The commission can issue fines for many reasons.

5) Ask some lawyer friends for the opinion on Nintendo vs Galoob. They almost certainly discussed it in school. Opinions will vary. More than a few will likely agree that if Nintendo were an American company the outcome would have been different. That's the most famous case I know of.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by Oletros on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:12AM (#10816634)
> 2/3) You're right. A fine isn't a tax. Now assume you are a nation state and some foreign entity is making a shit ton of money off your population.

Still waiting a proof that it is because an American company

> 5) Ask some lawyer friends for the opinion on Nintendo vs Galoob. They almost certainly discussed it in school. Opinions will vary. More than a few will likely agree that if Nintendo were an American company the outcome would have been different. That's the most famous case I know of.

Some USA case doesn't make any argument for your accusation about EU.

You can believe what you want, but reality is what it is

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by forrestthewoods on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:31PM (#10819529)
Oh, I misread you. Sorry. I thought you didn't believe that such cases existed at all. As opposed to not believing this case was such a scenario. That's why I gave an unrelated example. Sorry!

And of course reality is what it is. No shit! Saying that isn't an argument.

Windows 7 N is objectively stupid. The default browser choice is objectively stupid. The released Excel file formats were stupid. In fact I think you'll be hard pressed to come up with a list of changes I product or behavior brought on by the ruling that benefit consumers in any meaningful way.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by threeseed on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:55PM (#10815218)
> If you view the fine as a tax it all makes far more sense

Which you shouldn't since it's a ridiculous premise.

Microsoft was found to have acted in an anticompetitive manner and for that they have to pay a fine. Not all multinational companies who exist in the EU have to pay an ongoing fine. It's not the cost of doing business. It's the cost of breaking the law.

Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl... by lumberjack on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @07:25PM (#10815348)
Why are you blaming the tax code? I think the problem originates in the loss of economic sovereignty of nations after signing countless FTAs. It is only because of that reason that Apple and Google can play nations against each other to dodge taxes. What has happened in the last 30 years is that laws has been passed that allow these multinationals to operate as such while at the same time everyone else is still limited by national borders. Why is it so easy for these corporations to open and close subsidiaries everywhere as they please? Oh right, something to do with the (misguided) liberal ideal that foreign and domestic investors should be treated equally, completely ignoring the fact that the foreign investor is not tied to the nation in the same way that the domestic investor is.