Re:Apple's $348M Tax Settlement In Italy Bodes Ill For Googl...
by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:01AM
(#10817788)
> What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits. Do the same for all countries.
The whole problem is, what are "U.S." profits?
Google pays a bunch of engineer salaries to design Google Docs. Most of the engineers are in the U.S. If they declare that huge expense in the U.S. then it will cancel all the U.S. revenue for Google Docs, which they're happy to do because the U.S. has a high corporate tax rate.
Meanwhile the parent company in Ireland now owns a bunch of valuable new code that can be used world-wide and be licensed to Google UK and Google France etc., creating lots of profits for Google Ireland where taxes are low.
No part of this is doing anything "wrong" -- whichever corporate entity is the one that owns the rights to the code is the one that will make all the profits, because the code generates more revenue than it costs to create. And there is nothing that ties that entity to a particular country, especially when the expenses aren't actually all in the same place. The product is created by huge teams spread all over the world. Which corporate entity in which country "owns" the profits is completely arbitrary. So they choose the one in the country with the lowest taxes. What would you expect?
The whole problem is, what are "U.S." profits?
Google pays a bunch of engineer salaries to design Google Docs. Most of the engineers are in the U.S. If they declare that huge expense in the U.S. then it will cancel all the U.S. revenue for Google Docs, which they're happy to do because the U.S. has a high corporate tax rate.
Meanwhile the parent company in Ireland now owns a bunch of valuable new code that can be used world-wide and be licensed to Google UK and Google France etc., creating lots of profits for Google Ireland where taxes are low.
No part of this is doing anything "wrong" -- whichever corporate entity is the one that owns the rights to the code is the one that will make all the profits, because the code generates more revenue than it costs to create. And there is nothing that ties that entity to a particular country, especially when the expenses aren't actually all in the same place. The product is created by huge teams spread all over the world. Which corporate entity in which country "owns" the profits is completely arbitrary. So they choose the one in the country with the lowest taxes. What would you expect?