One of the advantages of GAAP, as you seem to be arguing is the reduction of risk since the rules are clear, unfortunately, the downside is the ability to circumvent them.
it is also funny how investors feel about accounting standards when it is THEIR money at risk and not the governments.
https://ifrsusa.wordpress.com/2011/04/05/which-is-better-%E2...
The ideal (IMHO) is to improve the principles and rules together, and Apple is in a unique leadership position to do this.
Global corporations fiddle this by moving money around so it appears that they don't make a corporate profit in that country, hence they pay no corporation tax. For example, companies like Vodafone continuously buy other companies that are making losses deliberately to offset their profit making mobile operators.
A simple way to solve the problem is to levy an internet sales tax, which is the same percentage as the corporation tax that these companies should have paid if they were operating solely in that country in the first place.
This would have some added advantages to companies that have bricks and mortar stores, who currently struggle to survive and compete with online competition. They provide the customers advice and the ability to try on their goods and then the customer price compares and buys cheaper online.
Whilst customers are benefiting from lower prices in the model we have today, we face the real risk that in twenty years you will only be able to buy a book from Amazon. There won't be any other book store.
You have sales tax, then this company invest into the country and hire people, paying rental for stores, advertising and spending. Once you take away all that, the country has to take 35% of your profits?
The case for Apple isn't as convincing as they are the most profitable company in the world. What about company that operate on laser thin margin? As most company are these days.
I am not again Tax, but it needs to be fair and reasonable. And in most cases it is not. As per your example, how about Vodafone, or many other SME who invest their profits into property market, driving up the cost of property which are every days needs for people in their country, and yet does not pay a single dime of tax.
Kind of like saying "I'll only play monopoly if I don't have to pay anyone elses rent, but you pay mine".
Ah, but how does something like Google work, then? They don't sell a product to people all over the world (where tax can be collected); people all over the world are the product, and they sell that product to advertisers mostly from the US. Google uses the population of a country to make money without actually receiving any money from anyone in that country.
If their US company is wearing all the expenses then they get a tax saving there.
They are trying to have their cake and eat it, and declare expenses in high tax regions and profit in low tax regions. Hence Ireland being popular.
It's not complicated unless you actively start trying to move money around to avoid tax, which is what they all do.
You are preaching utopian idealism, but a high school ethics assignment of "stealing medicine to save your mum" undoes your "one set of rules to apply to everything" point.
The median corporate income tax rate, is higher than the median individual income tax rate.
Taxes that corporations pay are more complicated and they have more legal avenues to minimise tax payable.
[1] For example, 50BC with the Roman Empire, Han Dynasty and this interesting map about Greeks in India, that I found just now. http://www.historyfiles.co.uk/FeaturesFarEast/CentralAsia_Ma...
One world government would be just as screwed up.
http://pennbpc.org/time-close-loopholes-delaware-loophole
Here’s how it works: A large multi-state corporation creates a shell company in a tax-haven state like Delaware. The subsidiary has no employees and is often nothing more than a post office box. The corporation then uses accounting gimmicks to funnel profits through the shell company, leaving no apparent income on the books in Pennsylvania. It may be legal, but it isn’t fair.
But if we borrow a lesson from moral philosophy just to help us with that thought – Descartes universality principle might help us: If everybody (corps, and individuals) avoided tax, would our system still work? Would it be a system that encourages growth (a requirement for capitalist enterprise)? Would our governments revenue system completely dissolve? Thus our governments completely dissolve? Is "Taxes aren't a moral issue" equivalent to "I want pure free market anarchy"?
Great business idea: Create a corporation that represents employees, with offices in every country. It then signs your employment contract, pays you in a 0 income tax territory and does all the same funny money games Apple et al do.
Everybody should avoid taxes as long as they stay withing the law, particularly corporations that have a fiduciary duty to do so.
It's moral, usually, to follow the law. But companies like Apple are following the law. Apple already pays billions in tax, far more than it uses in services. Even by that argument Apple isn't doing anything immoral by avoiding more tax.
Bullshit, the concept of fairness is a universal moral.
The report found that Irish officials essentially “reverse-engineered” Apple’s tax bill by first discussing with company representatives the size of the profit they wanted from the Irish branch. Apple’s own tax adviser acknowledged there was “no scientific basis” for the figures, the report said.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/01/business/international/eur...
There's nothing objective the concept of fairness, particularly when it comes to taxes. Taxes are almost completely arbitrary, depending more on what the government in question thinks it can actually collect than anything else.
It's pretty easy to make the case corporations shouldn't be taxed at all. A corporation is nothing more than a group of people that have pooled their resources to make money, after all, and they're already taxed as individuals when profits are disbursed. How is that fair?
But we have that. Take profits and multiply by 0.35. Done.*
The fact that Apple effectively pays less than %10 corporate tax rate in the US is, I think, what the parent poster was referring to.
For it to be this simple, you're declaring that every company paying less than 35% tax is in breach of the law. Which is obviously not the case in the eyes of the IRS -- there is totally legitimate foreign income, deductions, etc etc.
Whether you think those things are a GOOD idea doesn't matter, there are plenty of companies paying way less than 35% which are not going to get prosecuted, and the IRS would declare in the clear.
Can you source this claim, please?
The only sources I've seen that make this claim arrive at this number by treating Apple's worldwide sales as if they were entirely US sales, which is an absurd basis for this calculation.
And the more left-leaning part of the aisle has this idea that they will get to decide what that money will be spent on. So they support this. (I'm not rightist, in fact I'm probably extreme left by American standards, but I just don't believe the government is on the people's side anymore)
Of course there's a million different ways to say this, many are more polite, but it all boils down to this. They want money, they have the ability to take it.
It's not about "feeling that they can spend the money better", it's that government already spent the money, and Apple (and other companies) benefited from it, and now they need to pay their share.
Citizens pay taxes. Citizens get infrastuctures and subsidies.
> it's that government already spent the money, and Apple (and other companies) benefited from it, and now they need to pay their share.
It does not work like that. It has to be explicitly agreed by both parties.
It's hard to see any way to do the accounting such that Apple doesn't already pay for that and more.
And if you're going to start doing that kind of accounting, shouldn't governments credit Apple with the personal income taxes Apple employees pay?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
[2] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/09/how-holl...
However, if Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, the 'double Irish' arrangement lets them avoid paying corporate income taxes on those profits.
There are two issues here:
1. Some might argue that because Apple is based in the US and the R&D for these products occurs in the US, that when Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, Apple (US) should pay taxes on those profits. This is somewhat questionable, I think.
2. When Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, they should pay Italian corporate income tax on those profits, instead of being able to wipe those profits out using licensing agreements with Apple (Ireland). This is more straightforward and is the loophole being addressed by this settlement.
Except they don't, really. They use the same "double Irish" scheme in the US. Apple has offshore holding companies that own the IP for that iPhone. When a US customer buys an iPhone, much of the actual profit gets shifted to the offshore subsidiaries as an expense. That's how they ended up with $200bn offshore and only $10bn or so in the US.
Wrong. They initiated a capital return program a few years ago and ran down their US cash holdings while taking on debt "against" part of their overseas holdings. Once you account for the debt issues, their net cash holdings are a lot lower (though still substantial). Please don't make wild accusations if you don't know what you are talking about.
http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/07/22/as-apples-offshore...
They still can't repatriate that money without paying taxes. And as of two quarters ago they still have $200bn offshore and $10bn in the US. That offshore tax horde is still growing and it's still growing as a result of Double Irish flim-flam.
Don't accuse other people of not knowing what they're talking about unless you know what you're talking about.
I won't respond to you again in this thread because I can't deal with people who lack basic reading comprehension, logic, and fact-checking skills.
So the 'film-flam' as you call it avoids no taxes with regard to the cash-horde.
"The offshore company continues to receive all of the profits from exploitation of the rights outside the US, but without paying US tax on the profits unless and until they are remitted to the US."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement
"However, tax experts say that strategies like the Double Irish help explain how Apple has managed to keep its international taxes to 3.2 percent of foreign profits last year, to 2.2 percent in 2010, and in the single digits for the last half-decade, according to the company’s corporate filings."
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/business/apples-tax-strate...
"Under a typical “Double Irish” structure, a U.S. parent company (USCo) forms two Irish subsidiaries, IrishCo1 and IrishCo2. IrishCo1 is a first-tier Irish subsidiary organized under Irish law but managed and controlled in a low-tax jurisdiction (e.g., Bermuda or the British Virgin Islands). While U.S. rules determine tax residency of a corporation based on its place of incorporation, Irish law often determines tax residency based on the country where the company is managed and controlled. Accordingly, IrishCo1 will be treated for U.S. tax purposes as an Irish corporation, but for Irish tax purposes generally will be structured so as to be treated as a nonresident of Ireland resident in, for example, Bermuda. USCo will retain all US rights in the relevant IP and will license to IrishCo1 the rights to develop and exploit the IP outside the US. IrishCo1 will then sublicense these IP rights to IrishCo2, which in turn will use the IP to manufacture/produce IP products and then sell those products to customers outside the U.S."
http://www.taxeswithoutbordersblog.com/2014/10/death-of-the-...
You clearly do not understand how the double Irish arrangement actually works or what taxes it is supposed to reduce. Hint: if Apple could wipe out their US income tax obligations so easily using this arrangement, they probably wouldn't have bothered to pay that $14 billion in corporate income tax last year.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/business/MemoOnOff...
>The Apple case study examines how Apple Inc., a U.S. corporation, has used a variety of offshore structures, arrangements, and transactions to shift billions of dollars in profits away from the United States and into Ireland, where Apple has negotiated a special corporate tax rate of less than 2%. One of Apple’s more unusual tactics has been to establish and direct substantial funds to offshore entities that are not declared tax residents of any jurisdiction. In 1980, Apple created Apple Operations International, which acts as its primary offshore holding company but has not declared tax residency in any jurisdiction. Despite reporting net income of $30 billion over the four-year period 2009 to 2012, Apple Operations International paid no corporate income taxes to any national government during that period. Similarly, Apple Sales International, a second Irish affiliate, is the repository for Apple’s offshore intellectual property rights and the recipient of substantial income related to Apple worldwide sales, yet claims to be a tax resident nowhere and may be causing that income to go untaxed.
That's not some guy in his pajamas, there. It's a Senate report. For most US companies the whole point of the lowered Irish tax rate is to pay that on profits you've moved offshore.
And while most of Apple's profit would probably still come from other markets if it weren't playing these kinds of offset pricing games, Apple has moved billions of dollars in profits out of the US to avoid taxes.
It's not just Apple, either. This is why the effective US tax rate for corporations is 12.6% even as the statutory rate is 35%. I suspect that figure would be a lot lower, too, if only multinationals were considered.
This is the elephant in the tax tent: The IRS has wide latitude when determining what's reasonable for companies to charge subsidiaries for goods and services (and vice versa). But it's easy to arbitrarily complicate these kinds of arrangements.
And it's pretty subjective to start with - how much should Apple pay Apple Sales International to use a patent that nobody else is licensing? How would you even determine the fair market value? There are rules, of course, but even assuming there's no undue influence by corporations (and you can't assume that), imagine writing a set of rules that covers every conceivable business arrangement between multinationals that doesn't leave any grey area. Can't be done.
That Apple uses various tax arrangements to wipe out profits from its international sales is not in question. However, these are sales made by Apple’s foreign subsidiaries to foreign customers. They weren’t moved offshore, they were offshore to begin with.
I can see how Apple (Italy) and Apple (Germany) end up transferring their profits over to Apple (Ireland). I don't see any mechanism for how this could apply to Apple (US).
We both want a reasonable tax structure. But Apple is exploiting the unreasonableness of the tax structure, e.g. by using outdated codes, shell games, tax havens, etc.
Apple leaders have the opportunity and moral responsibility to stop exploiting, and start helping.
Basically, if someone decides to take that money overseas--don't throw up you hands, and expect U.S. Soldiers to save the day.
So we live in this new world economy. Fine. If things go haywire; your company is on its own. Don't use our military. Don't use our government, and courts. Don't complain. You're on your own.
The problem , I see, is even if these companies didn't expect any favors from the United States in times of crisis; the United States would still try to rectify the problem. Tim Cook knows his money is safe anywhere. Why not pay close to nothing on profits? I wish we weren't the ambasitors of right/wrong, or the world's police.
What you legally owe in taxes, in a reasonable tax structure, has NOTHING to do with your moral compass. You should be able to plug numbers into a spreadsheet and get it.
I'm not saying that taxes are bad. We need tax revenue. I get that. But there should NEVER, EVER, be two legally correct answers to how much you owe.
The fact that you had to spend paragraphs making your case, makes mine -- when you resort to emotional appeal to try to get people to pay their taxes, the system is completely broken.
Edit: the original comment said that this was clear to anyone with a "moral compass"