News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by azernik on Sunday December 06, 2015 @03:47PM (#10686514)
The New York Times tries to play up the issues of the (indeed, terrible) American military procurement system, but I think there's something else going on. The B-52's Soviet equivalent, the Tu-95 (turboprop-powered, even!) is also still flying!

Part of the cause is that big bombers with enormous payload capacity and long range can always be adapted to new missions and tactics - there's always something you can do with an extra few tens of tons of ordnance.

Where the US military-industrial complex has fallen down on the job is that the physical airframes are still from the original production run. While the USAF always thought its new and different (first supersonic, then stealth) bomber designs would allow it to retire the B-52, the Soviets kept building new variants and retiring old airframes. So while American B-52s have been heroically kept operating since the 50s and 60s, Russian Air Force Tu-95s were all built in the 80s and early 90s with assorted design improvements and new avionics.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mangeletti on Sunday December 06, 2015 @05:59PM (#10687086)
Indeed!

I've often wondered why, for instance, we don't build brand new A-10 Warthogs. They provide the best close air support in perhaps the entire history of military aviation worldwide (great range, extremely resilient to small arms fire, low altitude / low speed capabilities, etc.). Instead, the Marines Corps scrambles (no pun intended) to find a replacement after realizing that the JSF program wasn't real (it turns out that the F-35 will bankrupt the Milky Way Galaxy before being finished, not to mention it has too much wing loading to provide adequate close air support). Yet, the wonderfully designed A-10 Warthog languishes in military relic status.

Why not make new copies these greats, with any of the little kinks worked out?

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by engi_nerd on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:54AM (#10688244)
JSF costs are on a downward trend, and will continue that trend as production numbers increase[0]. For a financial breakdown of the projected costs of the program, see [1], [2](actual source for data in [0] and [1]).

And the program is very, very real. I am aware of other programs which really existed to funnel money to more secret programs, but the JSF program is not one of those front programs.

We don't build more A-10s because they no longer meet the projected operational needs of the USAF, which, along with the rest of the military, is changing strategic focus to the Asia/Pacific region. [3] Not to mention the production line is long since shutdown (32 years ago!) and the tooling either destroyed or lost. The knowledge to build them is lost. You do not simply build more. You have to teach yourself to build them again. This would take years.

[0]: https://i.imgur.com/H5fTkIU.png

[1]: http://i.imgur.com/6cV6I7g.png

[2]: http://breakingdefense.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2014/0... (The definitive source for F-35 cost data).

[3]: https://www.reddit.com/r/F35Lightning/comments/3a7yol/articl... (full text of paywalled Aviation Week article)

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mangeletti on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:07AM (#10690244)
I wrote a similarly hyperbolic F-35 comment on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9446079 earlier this year (the comment at the top). I'm half-way kidding in both comments, regarding my comments about the F-35, but on the other hand, unless my aforementioned comment about secret programs, etc. is at least partly true (meaning you're partly wrong), then the F-35 (or at least the opportunity cost of it) will surely turn out to be the fall of US military dominance.

When we're spending nearly (or more than) $100MM for a jet that cannot even stand up against an F-16, a jet introduced in 1978. That's 5 years before I was born, so it's really weird to think about a jet from that long ago even flying today, let alone a pre-Nintendo jet dog fighting (let alone, beating!) a modern jet in 2015, that surely has orders of magnitude more computational power on board than did the entire world at that time.

In other words, the scenario described is a bit like that movie, The Final Countdown, except the fighter jets on the aircraft carrier lose to Japanese Zeros :/ what a frightening situation to be in.

All that said, I understand that we live in a different world now, and that air superiority isn't defined only by dog fighting capability, and that we also have to factor in that most modern dog fights would be over before either pilot could see the other with their own eyes, and that this is, in fact, part of the promise of the F-35. But, regardless of this, what was the value gained by the F-35 by making the wings so small? A slightly larger wing size could have increased fuel capacity, increased fuel efficiency, increased low-speed and low altitude capabilities, and made it a much better dog fighter, at no real expense to other features.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by engi_nerd on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:50PM (#10692150)
You think the F-35 isn't real? I'm here to tell you otherwise. I've seen and touched and been around many of them. They are real, they fly.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mangeletti on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @11:08AM (#10697193)
Ha, no. I don't think that at all. I've watched many videos of them flying / vertical take-off. That's why I refer to my comments on the matter as "hyperbolic". When I say "half-way kidding" I'm referring to the costs primarily; as in, I have doubts that the quantities of money being dumped into the program are going completely to the F-35, and I argue that, perhaps, some (a lot?) of it is being funneled in secret to top secret projects. To state that this definitely isn't happening would be silly, since we wouldn't find out for many years, and to state that it's probably not happening seems a little silly, considering the level of cost overruns we're talking about, and considering the fed closed F-22 but now leaves F-35 open, despite gross cost overruns and lobbying by the rest of the military–industrial complex.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by jasonwatkinspdx on Sunday December 06, 2015 @08:22PM (#10687564)
The A-10 is great, but there are a number of reasons why we aren't building more of them. Chief among them is that the teams and facilities that produced them have been gone for decades now. It's not a product you can simply re-order. Of the planes in inventory, it's efficient and useful in low intensity CAS, but if you were ordering new for those missions you'd likely focus on something that's less overkill and lower cost like the super tucano.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by s_q_b on Monday December 07, 2015 @08:04AM (#10689152)
Ironically, after the request from JSOC and the Marine Corps for a modified Super Tucano (A-29B) was nixed, the United States' main procurement facility for this plan is still building them... for the Afghan airforce.

Sure, the Super Tucano doesn't have the punch from the main gun or crazy survivability of the A-10. But in a battlespace where air supremacy is guaranteed, it has the advantage of being able to get a close-up visual on the target, and accurately fire ordinance tens rather than hundred of meters away from friendly forces.

My personal understanding is that the Super Tucano was sacrificed on the alter of the myth of technological progress.

Every airframe, every digital HMI, and every weapons system must be more technologically sophisticated than the last, even if that solution is completely unsuited to ongoing and forecasted combat missions.

The fact that our most common enemies can't field a proper SAM site, much less a fifth-generation fighter, be damned.

Of course there is also the cultural issue. That the great United States might have to admit that the South Americans know more than us about air warfare in counter-insurgency campaigns is anathema to both the military and the civilian government.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mangeletti on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:15AM (#10690315)
However, I think light attack roles that the Super Tucano can fill can be filled by the new Sikorsky S-97 Raider, and because the Raider is a helicopter, it can also server a number of other roles, and it can land anywhere, and when you consider the cost and strategy differences between a helicopter carrier and a carrier battle fleet, or between a helicopter carrier and taking over / maintaining / defending an airfield behind enemy lines, the Raider, IMHO, will be a godsend for roles where the Apache Longbow is overkill and where the goal is to continually push for new FOBs behind the lines (range for Thunderbolt II and Super Tucano is ~800nm - got a new air field every 325 miles? Only plan to attack targets near the ocean?).
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by s_q_b on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:30AM (#10690444)
The Sikorsky S-97 is the perfect emblem of what I mean by the myth of technological progress.

The Super Tucano A-29B:

•Has a greater range, at 800nm vs. 320nm, much more for the Tucano with one pilot and the extra fuel tank, with an even greater difference if the Raider flies at top speed. (Yes, I know, it's easier to refuel a helicopter.)

•Is currently in proven service in CAS roles in COIN operations with 23,000 combat hours vs. the S-97's zero combat hours, which only flew its first demonstration flight in 2015.

•Costs far less at $9 million per unit with almost no development cost vs. a government projected program cost of $200 million and a unit cost of $15 million at full production. Defense analysts expect this to rise to $30 million a unit and $500 million in development costs.

•A low-flying CAS helicopter is a great idea, unless of course you're flying in thin air in the Hindu Kush, or your opponent has the ability to down such aircraft. Ask the Soviets how that worked out...

But the totally unproven S-97 incorporates new technology, which requires R&D thus inviting the procurement bonanza, so it beats out the combat-tested Super Tucano in the GAO procurement arena every time.

There's a reason JSOC wants the A-29B.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mangeletti on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @11:00AM (#10697127)
You're right, except for the first point. The value of not having to return to a base or ship to refuel cannot be passed up as a small point. It's a game changer. Being able to establish FOB and project from there changes everything in irregular warfare.

I hadn't heard about the Raider costing $30 million eventually, but that's ridiculous, if it turns out to be correct. However, $30 million is still less than half that of the AH-64D.

The one thing I'll add to your criticisms is that the Raider (badly) needs more armament (perhaps another 7-shot Hydra 70 pod).

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by poof131 on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:03AM (#10688055)
The super tucano is a great plane. Saddened me that the Navy and Air Force couldn’t get them operational in a much quicker fashion and on a much larger scale. They provide better ground support and targeting, longer on station time, and all at a substantially cheaper cost than fixed-wing. Plugging square, fixed-wing jets into round, low-threat-CAS holes cost the American tax payers billions. This is one of my greatest disappointments in military leadership.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by MrBuddyCasino on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:08PM (#10687121)
The A-10 is not a plane that will be useful for long. It is great against rebels with kalashnikows, but it is far too vulnerable to rockets. In 10-20 years, manpads will be commonplace, and the A-10 will be an easy target.

Its a great plane, and the JSF is shit, but we need a different solution going forward.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by dsfyu404ed on Sunday December 06, 2015 @09:45PM (#10687771)
The A-10 was meant to go head to head with Soviet armored divisions. It's built to be hard to take out with a rocket which is what makes it so great for CAS.

MANPADS have been common for a very long time. The Mujaheddin used them with great success.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by swang on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:25AM (#10688192)
1. Manpads are already pretty common 2. A-10 has both jamming and flare countermeasures against infrared. 3. Anything terrorist groups can acquire are probably going to be infrared MANPADs. My guess is ISIL would probably have acquired MANPADs from the large cache of SA-7 MANPADs Gaddafi stocked, meaning they're all likely infrared MANPADs.

A-10s are not invulnerable against MANPADs, but they're not helpless against them either. In fact, one of the biggest reasons the air force hated the A-10 was because it was "too slow" and could be "easily" hit by a SA-7

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by rjsw on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:27AM (#10688418)
The A-10 is too slow. It is just used in a similar way to other planes these days, to drop smart bombs, a supersonic jet can cover a lot bigger area to respond to requests from ground troops.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by CydeWeys on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:28PM (#10687190)
The main armament of the A-10, the GAU-8 Avenger Vulcan cannon, no longer does its job against modern armor. It still has all sorts of rockets and missiles it can be equipped with that do, but so do many other planes. It's fine in asymmetric conflicts like the current wars, where targets are slightly armored if that, but it will no longer serve its purpose in a war of first world nations.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by Phrodo_00 on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:36PM (#10687211)
Yeah, but first world nations don't fight wars with each other, they mostly finance small nations and fight proxy wars. I'd say mostly out of a (justified) fear of WW3.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:57PM (#10691717)
And the A-10 is overkill for counter-insurgency. It doesn't have a primary mission anymore.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by gozur88 on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:26AM (#10688416)
The GAU-8 won't penetrate the front armor of a modern tank, but I doubt it could penetrate the front armor of 1980s era tanks, either. However, there isn't a tank in the world that will remain operational after a properly executed A-10 gun attack from the top or sides.

Don't get me wrong - I love the A-10, but it's pretty much obsolete at this point. Not because you can't use it to destroy tanks, but because there are much cheaper, safer, and more efficient ways to destroy tanks than low-and-slow strafing. A properly equipped strike aircraft can hit a tank with a laser guided bomb without ever exposing itself to AAA or MANPADS fire.

And if we're just going to mow down groups of jihadis with rusty AK-47s we should be using something cheaper like the Super Tucano II.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:59PM (#10691729)
Armor design has advanced a lot since the 80s. I'm thinking the A-10 was actually significantly more effective against a contemporary tank than it is against a modern new production one. Sure, it could definitely still get a kill, but not as easily, and as you point out, other aircraft could do so more safely, without exposing themselves to danger.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by Marazan on Monday December 07, 2015 @06:11AM (#10688736)
I love the A-10 but in keeping with the rest of the US military it got lucky which hlped it's reputation enormously.

The US military spent the 80's allegedly training to fight a defensive war in Western Europe - but when you look at the wargames they engaged in what they actually trained for was an aggressive war in a desert (this isn't some wacky conspiracy theory, it's just basic incompetence by the people setting the military exercises, they looked at the crowded cluttered maps that represented Germany and despaired that they wouldn't get to use the 2 mile cannon range on their tanks in the wargames so the maps got altered until they were far to open to be Western Europe).

The A-10 is perfect for CAS in a desert - in Afghanistan they didn't do as well as their lower agility compared to other jets made it harder for them to dodge mountains which affects their legendary ability to loiter.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by epaga on Monday December 07, 2015 @04:39AM (#10688537)
The A-29 was meant to be exactly this. It's a sad story, well-told by Vice. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/low-and-slow
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by kjs3 on Sunday December 06, 2015 @09:12PM (#10687700)
The A-10 is the P-51 of today. It was a defining weapon of it's time, but it became unsurvivable on a more modern battlefield. Ask the guys who flew the P-51 in Korea how awesome it was. The A-10 is extremely vulnerable to any number of modern tactical AA weapons, and it won't get any more survivable.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday December 06, 2015 @04:09PM (#10686624)
The B-52 airframes have long been planned to be in use for 95 years when they're finally retired. I wish I could find an image but I distinctly remember a publication from the 80's that showed a chart of the all aircraft in use from their first year of entering service to the projected EOL. The B-52 was a notable outlier in how long it was going to be kept in service. I always assumed it was an extended life test for the USAF. They are also insurance against a cataclysmic event that makes modern technology hard to maintain.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by radiowave on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:56PM (#10687299)
The B-52 was intended to carry out the airborne nuclear deterrent role, and therefore accrue a colossal number of flying hours. But of course after about 1992 they stopped flying quite so much.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by ekianjo on Sunday December 06, 2015 @10:32PM (#10687890)
If I remember correctly, nuclear deterrence with planes flying 24/7 in the skies was still a thing until the early 2000s. It took a long time for the Air Force to scale down that role.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by sirkneeland on Sunday December 06, 2015 @11:56PM (#10688044)
I think that was SAC (Strategic Air Command) which was shut down in 1992 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Air_Command

"Following Operation Desert Storm, the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the de facto end of the Cold War, President George H. W. Bush and Secretary of Defense Dick Cheney directed SAC to take all bomber and refueling aircraft and Minuteman II ICBM's off of continuous nuclear alert on 27 September 1991[85] and placing said aircraft on quick reaction ground alert"

So, still ready for Armageddon, but with a bit higher latency.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by CompelTechnic on Sunday December 06, 2015 @11:23PM (#10687985)
Thankfully, our fleet of submarines makes sure that the threat of nuclear apocalypse remains imminent.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by ekianjo on Sunday December 06, 2015 @11:28PM (#10687988)
And ICBMs, too. I prefer the idea of submarines, though. There were several cases of very serious incidents involving planes losing control and crashing while carrying nukes, at least with submarines the collateral risk on population is much less.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by niij on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:44AM (#10688335)
Yummy radioactive ocean water!
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by kqr on Monday December 07, 2015 @05:51AM (#10688691)
Water is a very good neutron regulator for fission reactions and general radiation absorbant. Not sure how it deals with fusion though (given that it contains hydrogen and a nuclear blast can probably rip apart water molecules pretty handily).
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by cstross on Sunday December 06, 2015 @04:16PM (#10686655)
Yup: the Russian Tu-95 fleet (over 60 flying airframes) is currently undergoing modernization (upgraded navigation and weapons systems, including newer nuclear-warheaded cruise missiles) and is expected to stay in service until 2025 or later:

http://sputniknews.com/military/20151121/1030508547/tu-95-bo...

(They're trying to restart production of the Tu-160 -- the world's biggest, fastest bomber ever to enter service: a bit larger than a B52 but with supersonic dash capability -- but having real trouble with the engines; my money is on the Tu-95 sticking around at least as long as the B52, for exactly the same reason.)

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by antubbs on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:55PM (#10687295)
There have never been very many operational Tu-160 bombers in service. The Tu-160 is focused on the standoff weapon role, and is ideally meant to delivering tactical ordinance while enemy air defense is still in effect. Standoff weapons are expensive, even compared to "smart" conventional weapons.

Tu-95 is a big dumb bomber much in the way the B-52 is; since it also has/is getting the standoff capability, it's hard to argue the purpose of the Tu-160.

A lot of the newer bombers were built with the nuclear role in mind; in reality the world went in the direction of smart conventional weapons instead. For that role, aircraft like the Tu-95 and BUFF are more ideal, as they can just act as a large "bomb truck" and drop a large quantity of guided conventional munitions very efficiently once air defenses are suppressed.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by yareally on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:49PM (#10687271)
Eh, the Tu-160 looks like a faster clone of the B-1 Bomber. The B-1 was supposed to replace the B-52, but proved to be much more expensive and nowhere as versatile. Guessing Russia is going to find out it's also not a practical replacement for the the Tu-95 as the US did with the B-1.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by antubbs on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:58PM (#10687306)
Pretty much.

The B-1 was designed for a role (low altitude nape of the earth bombing) that was obsolete before they worked out the bugs in the jet (Russian interceptor and fighter aircraft got look-down shoot-down capability). The B-1 was kept alive because of its electronic warfare capabilities, but efficiency of the bomb trucks matter more than high-speed delivery in a hostile radar environment these days.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by rjsw on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:30AM (#10688425)
The B-1 makes a pretty good bomb truck itself, it can carry a bigger payload than the B-52.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by ceejayoz on Sunday December 06, 2015 @03:57PM (#10686568)
> So while American B-52s have been heroically kept operating since the 50s and 60s, Russian Air Force Tu-95s were all built in the 80s and early 90s with assorted design improvements and new avionics.

I'd expect modern B-52s are mostly Ships of Theseus and that little of the original avionics, wiring, metal, etc. still exist.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by mikeash on Sunday December 06, 2015 @03:59PM (#10686579)
Wiring and avionics and such, yes, but the structure is still original. This matters because of metal fatigue, which means that the structure is getting worse by the year.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by sokoloff on Sunday December 06, 2015 @05:10PM (#10686888)
Semi-modern inspection techniques (eddy current inspection) and X-ray inspection can detect hidden defects and cracks and aluminum airframes are fairly readily repairable.

I wouldn't expect that metal fatigue will prove to be an impediment to the B-52's ability to continue to deliver ordinance.

Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by rdtsc on Sunday December 06, 2015 @08:17PM (#10687554)
It would seem to me that if they didn't have fancy CAE (Computer Aided Engineering) and CAD packages to precisely calculate tollerances they would over-estimate and overbuild to be on the safe side. Perhaps as a positive side-effect is that those frame would last longer because of that.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by caf on Sunday December 06, 2015 @06:01PM (#10687096)
Yes, compare it to the C-130 which entered service around the same time as the B-52 - it's been revised many times over the years, up to the J model.
Re:After 60 Years, B-52s Still Dominate U.S. Fleet by Shivetya on Sunday December 06, 2015 @05:31PM (#10686969)
throw in that the enemies it is used against aren't first rate and the stand off ability with cruise missiles and why wouldn't it have a place?