Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by Symbiote on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:20PM
(#10521391)
Ryanair has a very effective marketing department, which seems to work on the basis that any exposure is good.
Hence there are press releases and news articles about plans for standing tickets, or charging to use the toilets.
I guess the theory is, if you tell people how cheap Ryanair is often enough, they won't check other airlines.
Norwegian is the budget airline that's flying US-Europe, for example NY to Oslo in January for $300 return (hand luggage, no food, no seat reservation).
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by brianbreslin on Sunday November 08, 2015 @10:44PM
(#10531268)
Interesting thing to note, the Icelandic airlines are using Reykjavik as a hub to Europe because you can fly a smaller A320 from new york or boston to there and its much cheaper than transatlantic in bigger planes. This is why they do lots of $200 round trip fares to Europe now.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by pavornyoh on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:31PM
(#10522187)
You are right. I wondered ever since that article came out how they arrived at $200 in taxes if the ticket cost $15. Unless they are changing taxes on using the bathroom and other things then maybe. But like you said, a clear gimmick...
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by URSpider94 on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:22PM
(#10522463)
In most cases, these taxes are per-passenger landing fees charged by various international airports/nationalities to cover the costs of Customs and terminal operations. They have no bearing on the actual ticket cost, i.e. they are the same for a $15 ticket as for a $1500 ticket.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by cbr on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:38PM
(#10521501)
Has anything changed with pilots unions?
"The interaction between labor laws and FAA regulations results in pilot unions having a strong claim on 100 percent of an airline's profits. An investor in a unionized U.S. airline should not expect to see a return on that investment and, indeed, should expect an eventual Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing to wipe out his or her investment altogether."
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by 6stringmerc on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:42PM
(#10521887)
Yes, George Bush (i.e. his administration) forbade the Delta pilots from going on strike, sent the pilots and airline to binding arbitration, and as a result, the pilot's pensions were dumped on the US taxpayers:
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by trhway on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:54PM
(#10522316)
make money or show profit? If one to look at the salaries of the army of airlines' executives and mid-managers one would definitely see the money (and would understand why no profits are shown).
Oil is cheap. Planes are reliable and fuel-efficient. The flights are completely booked and the passengers are stuffed tightly in. Tickets are pricey. Where are the money going once it ingested by an airline?
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by samfisher83 on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:55PM
(#10521218)
Pretty much every major airline has gone Bankrupt at some point. I think there are short periods when they can make money, but based on history it is unlikely they can make profits long term.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by chrismealy on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:10PM
(#10522063)
Businesses with high fixed costs (like airlines) generally need to be some kind of monopoly to survive. Some monopolies are based on difficult to duplicate quality (Apple) or network effects (Windows). Sometimes it's regulatory. But without some protection from price wars, high-fixed costs business usually end up in a death spiral.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by codazoda on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:10PM
(#10522401)
I recently read an article about the government wasting money on billion dollar jets that didn't work for front-line fighting. The author suggested the slower, cheaper, and more capable WWII airplanes instead. Got me wondering, could someone maintain and fly dual prop or larger airplanes on the cheap and disrupt the airline industry with it's jets that cost hundreds of millions?
I have no idea if props or jets are more fuel efficient but I assume the former.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by CamatHN on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:21PM
(#10522710)
You would first have to build a suitable dual prop for long flights which costs hundreds of billions of dollars (boeing doesnt sell dual props I dont think for big commercial flights). Thats assuming you can get it working and fits with all the safety requirements and what not.
As such perhaps only for short distance flights? i.e. 3 hours.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by transfire on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:54PM
(#10516971)
The business model of airlines is to shove as many people as possible into a giant tin can and deliver them from one hub to another. Despite the number of people and high cost of tickets, this alone is not enough to turn a profit, so the hubs are turned into high-priced shopping traps. When fuel prices are low enough, it is enough to keep the airships afloat. But it is a completely backward system of travel, where the actual travel becomes almost a secondary matter. It's all the fanfare and bazaar around it that drives the wasteful economics, and likewise the hate of it.
An efficient and beloved system would turn to smaller planes and point-to-point trips. Smaller planes would allow automobile-like scaling of plane manufacture and point-to-point trips would provide a reduction in fuel costs. But we will never see it, b/c as it turns out, Capitalism is not about efficiency or catering to the common customer. Rather it is about moving around as many bits of currency as fast as possible. The airline industry is one the great examples of this.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by lujim on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:44PM
(#10521152)
Traditionally the cost per seat/mile is lowest on wide bodies and skyrockets as you get towards regional aircraft. The higher (per seat/mile) cost of operating smaller planes is offset by the near poverty wages payed to regional airline crews.
Maybe someday small point to point aircraft will be economical, but we aren't there yet. Southwest has done pretty well operating outside of hubs mainly due to smart management that knows when to hedge fuel costs and a fleet composed of a single type of aircraft (737).
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by ju-st on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:40PM
(#10521513)
No, narrowbodies have lower cost per seat mile because they weigh less per seat because they fly shorter routes (=less fuel and structures).
Very small airplanes have the problem that many costs don't scale linearly like the wage for 2 pilots, structural weight, efficiency of combustion engines.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by lujim on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:56PM
(#10521602)
Yeah agreed. That chart is great, but it's not telling the whole story. If you take a 747-400, 757, 737, and a CRJ (1 fuel stop) move a full load of passengers 3000 miles the widebodies will have better seat/mile costs. That chart compares the seat/mile of a 737 going 1000 miles to a 747 going 6000 miles. If you flew a 737 6000 miles (with stops of course) the seat/mile cost would be huge.
Similarly a Cessna 150 could get you a better seat/mile cost than a CRJ if you're going 30 miles.
A 747-400 going 6000 miles nonstop will have tremendous first hour fuel burns because it's carrying... tons of fuel. Each extra pound of fuel you carry requires that you take on.... yup more fuel. It compounds.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by jessaustin on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:46PM
(#10521168)
I'm sympathetic to this sort of critique, but my impression after years of observing this industry is that anything that makes air travel less insane also makes it less affordable, so there is strong pressure toward insanity. It doesn't seem odd that a market for expensive short-term services would be like that, or at least would have a segment like that. After all the utopia you envision exists for those who are willing to spend more, e.g. on fractional ownership.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by mikeash on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:54PM
(#10521588)
It's absolutely this.
Airline customers care about price above all else. A price differential as low as $5 is enough to get people to switch flights, even if the pricier flight is better. It's utterly cut-throat.
Why do airlines cram people in so tightly you can barely breathe? Because that lets them shave dollars off the ticket price, which attracts customers from anyone who doesn't do this. Given the choice between a cheaper flight that's less comfortable, or one that's $5 more and has more room, people will choose the former.
Why do airlines not serve meals anymore unless they absolutely have to? Well, those meals aren't free. People will choose the meal-less flight for $5 less over the flight with a meal that costs slightly more.
Why does everybody charge for checked luggage now? Because it lets them shave the price of a ticket.
If people wanted comfort, good food, free luggage, and all that, we would have it. But what people want above all else is to pay less.
And actually, airlines have gotten pretty good at segmenting the market, which for their customers (us) means we can pretty much choose our own tradeoff there. You'd rather pay more money for a larger seat? Almost all of them let you do this now. You want a meal during your flight? Just about any suitably-long flight will have meals available for purchase. You want to check bags? Go for it, just pay for it.
I hate getting crammed into tiny airline seats (I'm 6'3" and barely fit) and all the rest... but every time I get on an airplane and pass those better seats, I remember that I'm just voting with my wallet here, and clearly I value the $100 or whatever it is more than the space.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by davnicwil on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:36PM
(#10521849)
> Given the choice between a cheaper flight that's less comfortable, or one that's $5 more and has more room, people will choose the former.
This is interesting, I travel on a lot of different airlines, and I always go with the lowest-priced feasible option. However, I don't really see it as much of a choice between quality and price.
Why? Because I don't feel like I have any information about the quality of the service or level of comfort before the flight. A lot of the cheaper and mid-range budget airlines are pretty much like-for-like in terms of experience, reviews are always skewed towards the negative and therefore don't contain too much useful information (people very rarely go online to write a good review after a comfortable flight with a cheap airline, but they absolutely do go online to complain and vent when it's uncomfortable) and anyway I don't feel like it's worth the time and effort to dig through reviews and try to find out what exactly my experience will be like on one 3 hour budget flight vs another, considering the amounts involved are not massive. Obviously I do go off my own experience, but even this varies from flight to flight with the same airline.
There's a lot of noise, therefore usually the easiest way to feel like you're getting the best value is simply to spend the lowest amount possible, assuming the experience will not be different enough to make you wish you'd spent more. To be honest, I think this is a decent strategy. It's very rare I've taken a flight and wished I'd spent $20 more on another airline to get a better cheese and crackers and coffee or a slightly more comfortable seat. These aren't differences which really matter in the budget short flights market.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by jessaustin on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:13PM
(#10522076)
This comment starts with the proposition that there is no choice available between price and quality. Then there are numerous anecdotes that reveal a preference for price over quality. b^)
In other words, you appear to be in violent agreement.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by untog on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:42PM
(#10522250)
Well, the solution would be to provide the source of that information that lets you make an informed choice. I, for one, don't really know whether it's worth an extra $5 to fly, say, Delta instead of United from New York to Los Angeles. I don't know where I'd find that information, either.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by davnicwil on Friday November 06, 2015 @11:50PM
(#10523766)
That's a fair assessment, I think my opinion changed in the process of writing it!
To be fair though, I'm really saying that there isn't a source of such information, but even if there were, it might not much matter for most, myself included. If I don't regret not 'upgrading' after the fact, when I do have slightly better information, I probably wouldn't think it was worth it in advance either, even with perfect information.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by dragonwriter on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:40PM
(#10522238)
> Airline customers care about price above all else.
I'm not sure how true this is; airline customers have convenient automated tools for optimizing price that don't provide facilities that easily let them specify and optimize for a balance of price with other factors.
There certainly is a significant preference for minimizing price, but I think that the apparent preference that manifests in the market is a result of the fact that (base ticket) price is unambiguously measurable, clearly and consistently available, and available to optimized by convenient, ubiquitous comparison tools.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by mikeash on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:00PM
(#10522351)
I believe those convenient automated tools optimized for price above all else came as a result of this preference, which predates it by a long time. But I don't have any sources offhand and could be totally wrong.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by MichaelGG on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:23PM
(#10522132)
What kind of people are really switching for $5? Do people actually look at a multi-stop nightmare that'll save $25 and say "yeah, makes sense"? (Then end up spending as much on overpriced water?)
I suppose it's true but it just seems so, so surreal.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by MichaelGG on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:54PM
(#10522603)
Every search I've done shows the number of stops as well as overall duration. If I do a price-only search on, say, Kayak, I get these idiotic 20+ hour trips that involve just 6 hours of flight time.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by lujim on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:54PM
(#10521214)
Until a technological leap as large as the move from piston engines to turbine engine occurs and flight crews are replaced by computers, airlines will scrape by on the narrowest margins of almost any industry. As much as it seems like the airlines torture passengers for the shear joy of it, this model is the best thing that could come out of intense competition, high overhead costs, and the prohibitively high fuel costs of the early 2000's
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by sbuttgereit on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:09PM
(#10521312)
So let me get this straight: airlines, for all their pseudo-efficiencies, cannot make a profit (since they really aren't efficient) so they rely on ground concessions. But to my knowledge airlines don't really participate in the ground concession profit stream... airports do, but not airlines. Yet, all these inefficient, unprofitable airlines care about is moving currency around quickly. All of this is spite of the customers. And this is Capitalism.
Sorry to say I have to disagree. Not only is the appeal to chasing dollars in the last part of your argument contradictory with the loss statement of your first point, the behaviors of customers and the role of competition under Capitalism is completely ignored or misunderstood.
Under Capitalism, trades are voluntary. If the common customer were not receiving sufficient value for their travel dollar, they wouldn't be spending it on air travel. It's true, I would love to have one of those Emirates private rooms on every airline trip I take, but even a cramped little chair across country is often sufficient... when it's not I upgrade. Sometimes that trade isn't worth it: if I'm travelling between the Bay Area and Los Angeles, I'll usually drive because of the security hassle, though the cramped seats don't help the airlines either. Mind you, efficiency likely does require that I settle for the sufficient rather than the desirable... at least to keep things at a price I am willing to pay.
If the current system is not sufficient, under Capitalism a few things can happen. Airlines can go bankrupt if they don't attract customers or fail to keep costs reasonably below revenue. If you see an industry where the entrenched players are old, inefficient, and failing to genuinely meet customer needs, hell that sounds like a golden opportunity! Why not create an airline that is efficient and caters to the common customer and take advantage of the vacuum? If a record label executive can do it why not some of the YC crowd? I thought this group was about entrepreneurial disruption! That is the Capitalist solution to marketplace inefficiency and it happens all the time. So I have to reject your premise about what Capitalism is or is not about: your statement just doesn't make sense nor does it bear up under study of the facts.
I suspect that the reason the airline industry is so apparently FUBAR is because it's not so easy to achieve that ideal you envision for it, at least not without stealing money from some people to subsidize the travel of others.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by SilasX on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:46PM
(#10521543)
>But to my knowledge airlines don't really participate in the ground concession profit stream... airports do, but not airlines
They don't participate directly, but they're still economically coupled the concessions (and various other surcharges like for taxis): to the extent that airports can charge extra for frills, they don't have to charge for the landing spots. The ability to do so may be what makes them viable (that landing charges + surcharges can cover operating costs).
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by sbuttgereit on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:06PM
(#10521680)
It's a fair point. Do you know of any instances where landing fees have been abated by airport concessions? True, you might simply not see as steep of a rise, etc. (hard to see evidence of an offset) but it would be more in line if the airport simply took what they could get from both sides rather than seeing it as sort of a zero sum offset.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by jonnathanson on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:26PM
(#10521421)
Excellent encapsulation.
I'm far from an expert, and this is pure, naive speculation, but on a philosophical level, I wonder if the issue is that we've not yet really mastered the technology of air travel. By that I mean we seem incapable of building and managing aircraft at a sustainable, "MVP" level, operating on a fuel consumption minimal enough to withstand the vagaries of commodity prices.
Perhaps Boeing and Airbus are overengineering their aircraft and baking in economic rent to a degree that makes the airlines fundamentally incapable of sustaining a profitable business model. Perhaps this industry can't actually survive with current technology and design methods absent some sort of government backstop or subsidy. Not sure. But the supply-side theory of this business seems like the most compelling (if not wholly complete) theory I've heard.
Maybe we need a firm to come along and build the AK-47 or Toyota Prius of commercial aircraft, so to speak: cheap, reliable, efficient, elegantly engineered, and innovative in its use of parts and fuel.
I also wonder if there is a correlation between airline profitability and the airlines using the oldest aircraft. Seems to me (again, naively) that aircraft from back in the day were more purpose-built and simpler, with less complex global supply chains. Sort of a similar situation to the military's concerns about phasing out the old, reliable A-10s and F-16s in favor of the massive, modern boondoggle that is the F-35.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by PinguTS on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:37PM
(#10521853)
> Perhaps Boeing and Airbus are overengineering their aircraft and baking in economic rent to a degree that makes the airlines fundamentally incapable of sustaining a profitable business model. Perhaps this industry can't actually survive with current technology and design methods absent some sort of government backstop or subsidy. Not sure. But the supply-side theory of this business seems like the most compelling (if not wholly complete) theory I've heard.
It sounds like you were never in enigneering. You never had to deal with building reliable system in regards of safety and high availability. And you even don't know what is really happening in that industry.
Just a small example Rollce Royce revolutionized that business years before IT invented the Cloud and XaaS (X as a service). RR is proving flying as a service since years. As an airline, you don't buy an airplane with engines. You as an airline decide and tell either Airbus or Boing what engines you like. Then RR (and others these days) don't sell you the engine. They sell you flight time. So RR is reponsible that the engines runs without downtimes. RR provide service staff at all major and many minor airports to be able to provide service. RR inventend the Internet of Things way before IT came even close to those ideas. Because to be able to sell airtime, RR needs to know about the status and diagnostics of those engines. Competitors to RR are doing the same since years.
Then, a modern aircraft is stuffed with electronics to replace mechanics, like your car. Because mechanics are wheigt. With electronics this weight can be reduced. It also allowed "services" like autonomous flying. Different to the car industry, almost any modern airplane from Airbus and Boing is able to completely fly on its own inclusive take-off and landing. Only taxiing is not possible.
But electronics have to problem of requiring redundancy to build highly available systems and all that with limited ressources. All way before IT has their 99.999 SAL and with much higher rates. We talk in these industries with undetected errors with a probability of 10^-15 and less.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by saosebastiao on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:56PM
(#10521607)
I think the aircraft has only a tiny effect on profitability. In general, aircraft total cost of ownership and operations is proportional to size. There are some outliers, but the purchase price and/or leasing costs are negotiated up or down based off of perception of costs, so if there are any issues with aircraft costs they are short lived and go away after a while because those cost differences are eventually negotiated away. Similarly, any aircraft with lower than normal operational costs will have its price bid up until it breaks even with the cost levels of inferior aircraft (scarcity of production capacity for aircraft ensures that higher bidders get first dibs).
The real issue is flight capacity utilization. Airline cost structures follow what accountants would call a step-fixed cost. In other words, the marginal cost per person is negligible until you fill the aircraft and then the marginal cost per person is the cost of a whole new flight. This also means that once you fill a plane past its break-even load factor, every additional seat sold is pure profit.
The airline industry as a whole is operating on load factors between 82% and 84%, and it is net neutral in terms of profitability. That would lead me to believe that at current fuel prices (really the only source of variability in operational cost), that 83% load factors represent the zero-profit scenario. Now if Airline A can achieve 85% load factors, they will have a positive EBIT. If Airline B can acheive 87% load factors, they will roughly double the EBIT of Airline A.
Some airlines make money. They do it using the same exact planes and technology as other airlines that do not make money. The difference is that they have higher load factors. They are better at selling seats.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by sliverstorm on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:26PM
(#10521791)
Fuel represents 25-30% of most airline's OPEX, while capital (planes) is something like 15%. I would suggest this means we are actually doing pretty well. In a hypothetical ideal market, an airline would directly convert consumables to travel with zero other expenses. This is the most efficient (in the market sense) an airline could be.
As for "if we mastered air travel, we could remove fuel from the equation"- I don't think that's true. Jets are already 20-40% efficient[1], so even with a perfect plane we could only quarter to halve fuel requirements.
Re:Can Airlines Make Money?
by nether on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:55PM
(#10521599)
Aeroflot opted for the 787 but has ordered some Sukhoi Superjet 100s. I think "simple, rugged" philosophy is difficult to maintain for massive projects with huge part counts. Most Russian airliners have not had much success in the global market. I think the biggest cost saving in aircraft development will come from cheaper engineers, mainly in China.
It would be interesting to see if development costs plummet if we were all willing to accept auto traffic rates of accidents and deaths in air travel.
Hence there are press releases and news articles about plans for standing tickets, or charging to use the toilets.
I guess the theory is, if you tell people how cheap Ryanair is often enough, they won't check other airlines.
Norwegian is the budget airline that's flying US-Europe, for example NY to Oslo in January for $300 return (hand luggage, no food, no seat reservation).
Like Amazon!
I mean, nearly all Ryanair flights are to Europe.
"The interaction between labor laws and FAA regulations results in pilot unions having a strong claim on 100 percent of an airline's profits. An investor in a unionized U.S. airline should not expect to see a return on that investment and, indeed, should expect an eventual Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing to wipe out his or her investment altogether."
http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines
http://money.cnn.com/2006/06/16/news/companies/delta_pension...
Later, when Delta started doing well again, they didn't bother taking back that obligation.
Oil is cheap. Planes are reliable and fuel-efficient. The flights are completely booked and the passengers are stuffed tightly in. Tickets are pricey. Where are the money going once it ingested by an airline?
How come no one has disrupted it? Surely there has to be way to make it work?
I have no idea if props or jets are more fuel efficient but I assume the former.
As such perhaps only for short distance flights? i.e. 3 hours.
Dual props are also a lot slower.
An efficient and beloved system would turn to smaller planes and point-to-point trips. Smaller planes would allow automobile-like scaling of plane manufacture and point-to-point trips would provide a reduction in fuel costs. But we will never see it, b/c as it turns out, Capitalism is not about efficiency or catering to the common customer. Rather it is about moving around as many bits of currency as fast as possible. The airline industry is one the great examples of this.
Maybe someday small point to point aircraft will be economical, but we aren't there yet. Southwest has done pretty well operating outside of hubs mainly due to smart management that knows when to hedge fuel costs and a fleet composed of a single type of aircraft (737).
Very small airplanes have the problem that many costs don't scale linearly like the wage for 2 pilots, structural weight, efficiency of combustion engines.
I found this Wikipedia article interesting... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Examp...
Similarly a Cessna 150 could get you a better seat/mile cost than a CRJ if you're going 30 miles.
A 747-400 going 6000 miles nonstop will have tremendous first hour fuel burns because it's carrying... tons of fuel. Each extra pound of fuel you carry requires that you take on.... yup more fuel. It compounds.
Airline customers care about price above all else. A price differential as low as $5 is enough to get people to switch flights, even if the pricier flight is better. It's utterly cut-throat.
Why do airlines cram people in so tightly you can barely breathe? Because that lets them shave dollars off the ticket price, which attracts customers from anyone who doesn't do this. Given the choice between a cheaper flight that's less comfortable, or one that's $5 more and has more room, people will choose the former.
Why do airlines not serve meals anymore unless they absolutely have to? Well, those meals aren't free. People will choose the meal-less flight for $5 less over the flight with a meal that costs slightly more.
Why does everybody charge for checked luggage now? Because it lets them shave the price of a ticket.
If people wanted comfort, good food, free luggage, and all that, we would have it. But what people want above all else is to pay less.
And actually, airlines have gotten pretty good at segmenting the market, which for their customers (us) means we can pretty much choose our own tradeoff there. You'd rather pay more money for a larger seat? Almost all of them let you do this now. You want a meal during your flight? Just about any suitably-long flight will have meals available for purchase. You want to check bags? Go for it, just pay for it.
I hate getting crammed into tiny airline seats (I'm 6'3" and barely fit) and all the rest... but every time I get on an airplane and pass those better seats, I remember that I'm just voting with my wallet here, and clearly I value the $100 or whatever it is more than the space.
This is interesting, I travel on a lot of different airlines, and I always go with the lowest-priced feasible option. However, I don't really see it as much of a choice between quality and price.
Why? Because I don't feel like I have any information about the quality of the service or level of comfort before the flight. A lot of the cheaper and mid-range budget airlines are pretty much like-for-like in terms of experience, reviews are always skewed towards the negative and therefore don't contain too much useful information (people very rarely go online to write a good review after a comfortable flight with a cheap airline, but they absolutely do go online to complain and vent when it's uncomfortable) and anyway I don't feel like it's worth the time and effort to dig through reviews and try to find out what exactly my experience will be like on one 3 hour budget flight vs another, considering the amounts involved are not massive. Obviously I do go off my own experience, but even this varies from flight to flight with the same airline.
There's a lot of noise, therefore usually the easiest way to feel like you're getting the best value is simply to spend the lowest amount possible, assuming the experience will not be different enough to make you wish you'd spent more. To be honest, I think this is a decent strategy. It's very rare I've taken a flight and wished I'd spent $20 more on another airline to get a better cheese and crackers and coffee or a slightly more comfortable seat. These aren't differences which really matter in the budget short flights market.
In other words, you appear to be in violent agreement.
To be fair though, I'm really saying that there isn't a source of such information, but even if there were, it might not much matter for most, myself included. If I don't regret not 'upgrading' after the fact, when I do have slightly better information, I probably wouldn't think it was worth it in advance either, even with perfect information.
I'm not sure how true this is; airline customers have convenient automated tools for optimizing price that don't provide facilities that easily let them specify and optimize for a balance of price with other factors.
There certainly is a significant preference for minimizing price, but I think that the apparent preference that manifests in the market is a result of the fact that (base ticket) price is unambiguously measurable, clearly and consistently available, and available to optimized by convenient, ubiquitous comparison tools.
I suppose it's true but it just seems so, so surreal.
Sorry to say I have to disagree. Not only is the appeal to chasing dollars in the last part of your argument contradictory with the loss statement of your first point, the behaviors of customers and the role of competition under Capitalism is completely ignored or misunderstood.
Under Capitalism, trades are voluntary. If the common customer were not receiving sufficient value for their travel dollar, they wouldn't be spending it on air travel. It's true, I would love to have one of those Emirates private rooms on every airline trip I take, but even a cramped little chair across country is often sufficient... when it's not I upgrade. Sometimes that trade isn't worth it: if I'm travelling between the Bay Area and Los Angeles, I'll usually drive because of the security hassle, though the cramped seats don't help the airlines either. Mind you, efficiency likely does require that I settle for the sufficient rather than the desirable... at least to keep things at a price I am willing to pay.
If the current system is not sufficient, under Capitalism a few things can happen. Airlines can go bankrupt if they don't attract customers or fail to keep costs reasonably below revenue. If you see an industry where the entrenched players are old, inefficient, and failing to genuinely meet customer needs, hell that sounds like a golden opportunity! Why not create an airline that is efficient and caters to the common customer and take advantage of the vacuum? If a record label executive can do it why not some of the YC crowd? I thought this group was about entrepreneurial disruption! That is the Capitalist solution to marketplace inefficiency and it happens all the time. So I have to reject your premise about what Capitalism is or is not about: your statement just doesn't make sense nor does it bear up under study of the facts.
I suspect that the reason the airline industry is so apparently FUBAR is because it's not so easy to achieve that ideal you envision for it, at least not without stealing money from some people to subsidize the travel of others.
They don't participate directly, but they're still economically coupled the concessions (and various other surcharges like for taxis): to the extent that airports can charge extra for frills, they don't have to charge for the landing spots. The ability to do so may be what makes them viable (that landing charges + surcharges can cover operating costs).
I'm far from an expert, and this is pure, naive speculation, but on a philosophical level, I wonder if the issue is that we've not yet really mastered the technology of air travel. By that I mean we seem incapable of building and managing aircraft at a sustainable, "MVP" level, operating on a fuel consumption minimal enough to withstand the vagaries of commodity prices.
Perhaps Boeing and Airbus are overengineering their aircraft and baking in economic rent to a degree that makes the airlines fundamentally incapable of sustaining a profitable business model. Perhaps this industry can't actually survive with current technology and design methods absent some sort of government backstop or subsidy. Not sure. But the supply-side theory of this business seems like the most compelling (if not wholly complete) theory I've heard.
Maybe we need a firm to come along and build the AK-47 or Toyota Prius of commercial aircraft, so to speak: cheap, reliable, efficient, elegantly engineered, and innovative in its use of parts and fuel.
I also wonder if there is a correlation between airline profitability and the airlines using the oldest aircraft. Seems to me (again, naively) that aircraft from back in the day were more purpose-built and simpler, with less complex global supply chains. Sort of a similar situation to the military's concerns about phasing out the old, reliable A-10s and F-16s in favor of the massive, modern boondoggle that is the F-35.
It sounds like you were never in enigneering. You never had to deal with building reliable system in regards of safety and high availability. And you even don't know what is really happening in that industry.
Just a small example Rollce Royce revolutionized that business years before IT invented the Cloud and XaaS (X as a service). RR is proving flying as a service since years. As an airline, you don't buy an airplane with engines. You as an airline decide and tell either Airbus or Boing what engines you like. Then RR (and others these days) don't sell you the engine. They sell you flight time. So RR is reponsible that the engines runs without downtimes. RR provide service staff at all major and many minor airports to be able to provide service. RR inventend the Internet of Things way before IT came even close to those ideas. Because to be able to sell airtime, RR needs to know about the status and diagnostics of those engines. Competitors to RR are doing the same since years.
Then, a modern aircraft is stuffed with electronics to replace mechanics, like your car. Because mechanics are wheigt. With electronics this weight can be reduced. It also allowed "services" like autonomous flying. Different to the car industry, almost any modern airplane from Airbus and Boing is able to completely fly on its own inclusive take-off and landing. Only taxiing is not possible.
But electronics have to problem of requiring redundancy to build highly available systems and all that with limited ressources. All way before IT has their 99.999 SAL and with much higher rates. We talk in these industries with undetected errors with a probability of 10^-15 and less.
The real issue is flight capacity utilization. Airline cost structures follow what accountants would call a step-fixed cost. In other words, the marginal cost per person is negligible until you fill the aircraft and then the marginal cost per person is the cost of a whole new flight. This also means that once you fill a plane past its break-even load factor, every additional seat sold is pure profit.
The airline industry as a whole is operating on load factors between 82% and 84%, and it is net neutral in terms of profitability. That would lead me to believe that at current fuel prices (really the only source of variability in operational cost), that 83% load factors represent the zero-profit scenario. Now if Airline A can achieve 85% load factors, they will have a positive EBIT. If Airline B can acheive 87% load factors, they will roughly double the EBIT of Airline A.
Some airlines make money. They do it using the same exact planes and technology as other airlines that do not make money. The difference is that they have higher load factors. They are better at selling seats.
As for "if we mastered air travel, we could remove fuel from the equation"- I don't think that's true. Jets are already 20-40% efficient[1], so even with a perfect plane we could only quarter to halve fuel requirements.
[1]: http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/sres/aviation/index.php?idp=9...
It would be interesting to see if development costs plummet if we were all willing to accept auto traffic rates of accidents and deaths in air travel.
1: http://www.statista.com/statistics/269285/most-profitable-ai...