Maybe someday small point to point aircraft will be economical, but we aren't there yet. Southwest has done pretty well operating outside of hubs mainly due to smart management that knows when to hedge fuel costs and a fleet composed of a single type of aircraft (737).
Very small airplanes have the problem that many costs don't scale linearly like the wage for 2 pilots, structural weight, efficiency of combustion engines.
I found this Wikipedia article interesting... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Examp...
Similarly a Cessna 150 could get you a better seat/mile cost than a CRJ if you're going 30 miles.
A 747-400 going 6000 miles nonstop will have tremendous first hour fuel burns because it's carrying... tons of fuel. Each extra pound of fuel you carry requires that you take on.... yup more fuel. It compounds.
Airline customers care about price above all else. A price differential as low as $5 is enough to get people to switch flights, even if the pricier flight is better. It's utterly cut-throat.
Why do airlines cram people in so tightly you can barely breathe? Because that lets them shave dollars off the ticket price, which attracts customers from anyone who doesn't do this. Given the choice between a cheaper flight that's less comfortable, or one that's $5 more and has more room, people will choose the former.
Why do airlines not serve meals anymore unless they absolutely have to? Well, those meals aren't free. People will choose the meal-less flight for $5 less over the flight with a meal that costs slightly more.
Why does everybody charge for checked luggage now? Because it lets them shave the price of a ticket.
If people wanted comfort, good food, free luggage, and all that, we would have it. But what people want above all else is to pay less.
And actually, airlines have gotten pretty good at segmenting the market, which for their customers (us) means we can pretty much choose our own tradeoff there. You'd rather pay more money for a larger seat? Almost all of them let you do this now. You want a meal during your flight? Just about any suitably-long flight will have meals available for purchase. You want to check bags? Go for it, just pay for it.
I hate getting crammed into tiny airline seats (I'm 6'3" and barely fit) and all the rest... but every time I get on an airplane and pass those better seats, I remember that I'm just voting with my wallet here, and clearly I value the $100 or whatever it is more than the space.
This is interesting, I travel on a lot of different airlines, and I always go with the lowest-priced feasible option. However, I don't really see it as much of a choice between quality and price.
Why? Because I don't feel like I have any information about the quality of the service or level of comfort before the flight. A lot of the cheaper and mid-range budget airlines are pretty much like-for-like in terms of experience, reviews are always skewed towards the negative and therefore don't contain too much useful information (people very rarely go online to write a good review after a comfortable flight with a cheap airline, but they absolutely do go online to complain and vent when it's uncomfortable) and anyway I don't feel like it's worth the time and effort to dig through reviews and try to find out what exactly my experience will be like on one 3 hour budget flight vs another, considering the amounts involved are not massive. Obviously I do go off my own experience, but even this varies from flight to flight with the same airline.
There's a lot of noise, therefore usually the easiest way to feel like you're getting the best value is simply to spend the lowest amount possible, assuming the experience will not be different enough to make you wish you'd spent more. To be honest, I think this is a decent strategy. It's very rare I've taken a flight and wished I'd spent $20 more on another airline to get a better cheese and crackers and coffee or a slightly more comfortable seat. These aren't differences which really matter in the budget short flights market.
In other words, you appear to be in violent agreement.
To be fair though, I'm really saying that there isn't a source of such information, but even if there were, it might not much matter for most, myself included. If I don't regret not 'upgrading' after the fact, when I do have slightly better information, I probably wouldn't think it was worth it in advance either, even with perfect information.
I'm not sure how true this is; airline customers have convenient automated tools for optimizing price that don't provide facilities that easily let them specify and optimize for a balance of price with other factors.
There certainly is a significant preference for minimizing price, but I think that the apparent preference that manifests in the market is a result of the fact that (base ticket) price is unambiguously measurable, clearly and consistently available, and available to optimized by convenient, ubiquitous comparison tools.
I suppose it's true but it just seems so, so surreal.
Sorry to say I have to disagree. Not only is the appeal to chasing dollars in the last part of your argument contradictory with the loss statement of your first point, the behaviors of customers and the role of competition under Capitalism is completely ignored or misunderstood.
Under Capitalism, trades are voluntary. If the common customer were not receiving sufficient value for their travel dollar, they wouldn't be spending it on air travel. It's true, I would love to have one of those Emirates private rooms on every airline trip I take, but even a cramped little chair across country is often sufficient... when it's not I upgrade. Sometimes that trade isn't worth it: if I'm travelling between the Bay Area and Los Angeles, I'll usually drive because of the security hassle, though the cramped seats don't help the airlines either. Mind you, efficiency likely does require that I settle for the sufficient rather than the desirable... at least to keep things at a price I am willing to pay.
If the current system is not sufficient, under Capitalism a few things can happen. Airlines can go bankrupt if they don't attract customers or fail to keep costs reasonably below revenue. If you see an industry where the entrenched players are old, inefficient, and failing to genuinely meet customer needs, hell that sounds like a golden opportunity! Why not create an airline that is efficient and caters to the common customer and take advantage of the vacuum? If a record label executive can do it why not some of the YC crowd? I thought this group was about entrepreneurial disruption! That is the Capitalist solution to marketplace inefficiency and it happens all the time. So I have to reject your premise about what Capitalism is or is not about: your statement just doesn't make sense nor does it bear up under study of the facts.
I suspect that the reason the airline industry is so apparently FUBAR is because it's not so easy to achieve that ideal you envision for it, at least not without stealing money from some people to subsidize the travel of others.
They don't participate directly, but they're still economically coupled the concessions (and various other surcharges like for taxis): to the extent that airports can charge extra for frills, they don't have to charge for the landing spots. The ability to do so may be what makes them viable (that landing charges + surcharges can cover operating costs).
An efficient and beloved system would turn to smaller planes and point-to-point trips. Smaller planes would allow automobile-like scaling of plane manufacture and point-to-point trips would provide a reduction in fuel costs. But we will never see it, b/c as it turns out, Capitalism is not about efficiency or catering to the common customer. Rather it is about moving around as many bits of currency as fast as possible. The airline industry is one the great examples of this.