It sounds like you were never in enigneering. You never had to deal with building reliable system in regards of safety and high availability. And you even don't know what is really happening in that industry.
Just a small example Rollce Royce revolutionized that business years before IT invented the Cloud and XaaS (X as a service). RR is proving flying as a service since years. As an airline, you don't buy an airplane with engines. You as an airline decide and tell either Airbus or Boing what engines you like. Then RR (and others these days) don't sell you the engine. They sell you flight time. So RR is reponsible that the engines runs without downtimes. RR provide service staff at all major and many minor airports to be able to provide service. RR inventend the Internet of Things way before IT came even close to those ideas. Because to be able to sell airtime, RR needs to know about the status and diagnostics of those engines. Competitors to RR are doing the same since years.
Then, a modern aircraft is stuffed with electronics to replace mechanics, like your car. Because mechanics are wheigt. With electronics this weight can be reduced. It also allowed "services" like autonomous flying. Different to the car industry, almost any modern airplane from Airbus and Boing is able to completely fly on its own inclusive take-off and landing. Only taxiing is not possible.
But electronics have to problem of requiring redundancy to build highly available systems and all that with limited ressources. All way before IT has their 99.999 SAL and with much higher rates. We talk in these industries with undetected errors with a probability of 10^-15 and less.
The real issue is flight capacity utilization. Airline cost structures follow what accountants would call a step-fixed cost. In other words, the marginal cost per person is negligible until you fill the aircraft and then the marginal cost per person is the cost of a whole new flight. This also means that once you fill a plane past its break-even load factor, every additional seat sold is pure profit.
The airline industry as a whole is operating on load factors between 82% and 84%, and it is net neutral in terms of profitability. That would lead me to believe that at current fuel prices (really the only source of variability in operational cost), that 83% load factors represent the zero-profit scenario. Now if Airline A can achieve 85% load factors, they will have a positive EBIT. If Airline B can acheive 87% load factors, they will roughly double the EBIT of Airline A.
Some airlines make money. They do it using the same exact planes and technology as other airlines that do not make money. The difference is that they have higher load factors. They are better at selling seats.
As for "if we mastered air travel, we could remove fuel from the equation"- I don't think that's true. Jets are already 20-40% efficient[1], so even with a perfect plane we could only quarter to halve fuel requirements.
[1]: http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/sres/aviation/index.php?idp=9...
It would be interesting to see if development costs plummet if we were all willing to accept auto traffic rates of accidents and deaths in air travel.
1: http://www.statista.com/statistics/269285/most-profitable-ai...
I'm far from an expert, and this is pure, naive speculation, but on a philosophical level, I wonder if the issue is that we've not yet really mastered the technology of air travel. By that I mean we seem incapable of building and managing aircraft at a sustainable, "MVP" level, operating on a fuel consumption minimal enough to withstand the vagaries of commodity prices.
Perhaps Boeing and Airbus are overengineering their aircraft and baking in economic rent to a degree that makes the airlines fundamentally incapable of sustaining a profitable business model. Perhaps this industry can't actually survive with current technology and design methods absent some sort of government backstop or subsidy. Not sure. But the supply-side theory of this business seems like the most compelling (if not wholly complete) theory I've heard.
Maybe we need a firm to come along and build the AK-47 or Toyota Prius of commercial aircraft, so to speak: cheap, reliable, efficient, elegantly engineered, and innovative in its use of parts and fuel.
I also wonder if there is a correlation between airline profitability and the airlines using the oldest aircraft. Seems to me (again, naively) that aircraft from back in the day were more purpose-built and simpler, with less complex global supply chains. Sort of a similar situation to the military's concerns about phasing out the old, reliable A-10s and F-16s in favor of the massive, modern boondoggle that is the F-35.