Well, the solution would be to provide the source of that information that lets you make an informed choice. I, for one, don't really know whether it's worth an extra $5 to fly, say, Delta instead of United from New York to Los Angeles. I don't know where I'd find that information, either.
That's a fair assessment, I think my opinion changed in the process of writing it!
To be fair though, I'm really saying that there isn't a source of such information, but even if there were, it might not much matter for most, myself included. If I don't regret not 'upgrading' after the fact, when I do have slightly better information, I probably wouldn't think it was worth it in advance either, even with perfect information.
In other words, you appear to be in violent agreement.