News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by eli on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:57PM (#10347679)
I don't buy the "Media vs Reddit" narrative. I don't think this has anything to do with journalism or even intolerance.

I just don't like hanging out with racists and sexists (in real life or online). If Reddit wants to keep me as a contributor to their site, they need to do something about that or I will not return. I doubt I'm alone in feeling that way.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:29PM (#10348848)
If we live in a world, this real world, we necessarily live with people we find tasteless and disgusting. If reddit is a world onto itself or if it's a reflection of the real world, then there will be unsavory characters of all types, sexually, philosophically, politically, etc.

I really don't believe in sanitizing reality. I don't believe in intolerance for the intolerant. It's a nice, easy, euthanistic way to make our own little pure vision of the world.

It'd be like the regular news saying, you know what, crime is disgusting, it's repugnant, we're not going to tolerate it on the news. No more violence reporting.

Showing news of violence is not "giving a voice to violence", or terrorists. What would be the next step, stop misogynist musicians or filmmakers depicting violence, etc., other than in documentaries?

Don't get me wrong, I'd prefer a world where people self moderated and would act decently, but I also fear a world which proscribes received behavior.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by dasil003 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:13PM (#10349136)
> I really don't believe in sanitizing reality. I don't believe in intolerance for the intolerant. It's a nice, easy, euthanistic way to make our own little pure vision of the world.

Are you comparing the internet to reality? Because the internet is not reality, the type of behavior you see on reddit and 4chan may reflect our nature, but it is enabled by anonymity and the complete lack of repercussions. If people behaved the way they do on these boards they would quickly be ostracized by society if not having the shit beaten out of them on a regular basis.

Applying some sort of freedom ideology to internet communities like reddit is not very useful in practice. We have to look at the shape of the internet and recognize that freedom on the internet is not the problem—after all cyberspace is unlimited, you can have infinite communities, and geography is irrelevant. All groups can find a place on the internet, and they will always be able to. We simply don't need to worry about that, and it's silly to wring our hands over the decision to moderate this or that community.

What we do need to worry about is the ability for formerly marginalized sociopaths to hurt other people from the safety of their basement dwelling. Whether it's unending bombardment of harassment or actual physical harm like swatting, we need to get a handle on this. Arguing that hate speech should not be moderated or restricted in any way is sort of like giving equal coverage to crackpot climate change deniers on basis of "fairness".

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:42PM (#10349648)
>If people behaved the way they do on these boards they would quickly be ostracized by society if not having the shit beaten out of them on a regular basis.

If people talked in public the way they do on those boards there might be consequences.

But if people behaved the way they do, they'd probably be voted into office.

We've just had the British Prime Minister give one of the most offensive and hate-filled conference speeches a lot of people have ever seen. His administration is full of people who are questionably sane.

The Chancellor has turned up in Parliament looking like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBtXxYrp7mo

Cameron's colleagues have been directly implicated in starving dying people - some of whom can't walk or speak - to death by claiming they're "able to work" and so shouldn't receive any state aid.

You want physical harm? We've got as much of it as you can bear to read about.

So really, hate speech on Reddit is a non-issue compared to what goes on in supposedly serious politics.

And did I mention the Internet censorship and surveillance? Because we have that too.

In reality free speech isn't a panacea. There are too many crazy people in politics all over the world, and free speech on Reddit or elsewhere has done nothing to keep them out of power.

It's not the basement-dwelling sociopaths with twitchy keyboards you need to worry about - it's the professionals.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by dreamfactory2 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:53PM (#10350417)
how could you not mention the pig?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by timlyo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:04AM (#10351428)
I don't really think it matters, everyone makes mistakes when they're young, that's the point of growing up.

Besides, Cameron does plenty of stupid stuff as an adult anyway.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:19PM (#10350528)
For me having different subs with different moderation policies, etc., satisfies both sides of people's needs.

People who want to be civil and interact with other civil people have their subreddits, people who want to engage in uncivility also have their subreddits. I don't see the problem.

Here is what I have noticed. I like forums where people can voice opposing opinions even be unkind but not vile. But I accept that some forums do harbor people who like being vile, either as a persona or their true selves. I avoid those forums/groups/subreddits.

Also, at times some of the offensive people do have great knowledge in their area of expertise, but otherwise can be very offputting and vile. Despite that, I want to be able to have those voices. Certainly I don't want to have them sprinkled all over. So, for as long as they can exist in predictable places and can be sought out or avoided, I'm for that. If push came to shove, I'd have to allow it all over and just have to dig through the noise.

The reason is I don't want proscribed forums. The problems are group-think, shaming, socio-forming, brainwashing. And you can bring out examples of things we want to eradicate, say ideas about terrorism (killing and raping other people indiscriminately or discriminately, as it were) but the thing is there are slippery slopes, grey areas and social movements of the day. Ideas and preferences change over time. I want to allow all those voices, no matter how offensive to be expressed --I don't have to like those ideas. I'm sure I would have a very visceral reaction to most the monsters on hateful forums, but yet, I think there is value in not shutting that off.

That said, reddit has the authority, obviously, to do whatever they like with their platform.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:52PM (#10349386)
I'm not so sure that is a thing that happens with any great regularity - and I say that because the previously bright line between "this person offended me" and "this person is harassing me" has become a lot more blurry.

Sure, any of us can point at high profile cases, but there's that old saying about anecdotes and data.

The problem with your entire last sentence is that it's full of value judgements, value judgements shaped by your experience as a human and your own knowledge and biases. One person's "hate speech" is another person's "spirited argument", one person's "disagreement" is another person's "harassment".

You might have a very clear definition of "hate speech" in your mind as you write those words, but I'd be willing to bet if you defined it here in the most clear and unambiguous language you possibly could, you'd find perfectly reasonable people disagreeing with it.

And therein is the problem - I'm on the side of that line that leaves people the hell alone in all but the most egregious of cases, because at the end of the day, it's all words on a screen.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:37PM (#10350607)
Perhaps the rise of microaggression complaints is exaggerated, but one has to wonder where we're headed as a society when the smallest insignificant things are labeled as (micro)-aggressive[1].

I'm loath to live in a culture where people have to walk on eggshells so as to not offer the semblance of offense. I think it's childish and also hypocritical --as if we can expect no one to think or say anything that would ever offend anyone. They never try to be mean to an ex-lover, they would never think bad of someone who ignored them unwittingly, etc.

[1]http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/09/the-rise...

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:39AM (#10350924)
This is a huge problem and has actually destroyed something very near to me, video games. The oversensitive attitude you mentioned has poisoned online gaming. Personally, I love to talk shit. A well spoken insult is a thing of beauty to me. It is an art, a craft, a science. Talking shit in video games used to be half the fun of playing, now it's unacceptable. What was once a staple of the culture is now it's greatest crime. Gamers today have this word "toxic". We used to have an antonym for that word, it was called "being a pussy". It's like one day everyone just decided to start taking the internet way too seriously. I can't talk shit in my favorite video game, some college student is facing charges because of a joke he made on twitter, and the presidential candidates are getting asked questions from facebook. What the fuck is going on.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tomlock on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:59AM (#10350984)
The internet is growing up.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:31AM (#10351065)
The question is, is the locker room, the powder room, the boardroom, etc. growing up?

There is a place for civil discourse and there is a place for people to be as ugly as they want to be or are. Else you're just pretending it does not exist or that you can wish it away.

This is like religious people thinking that if you only think pure thoughts all will be well in the world.

The same people who want to see crime-ridden neighborhoods bulldozed over to bring about the new society where everything is resplendescent, bright and tame and only the good people live and there is no Other. There are no drug abusers, misogynistic men, cruel women, or human traffickers.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tomlock on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:51AM (#10351127)
I don't really think that the action of sanitizing reddit could be characterized as "pretending it does not exist or that you can wish it away". Its pretty likely that the people that are trying to do that are acutely aware of the presence of the Other.

I also find it curious that you're using the capital o Other. Is that a deliberately existentialist term?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by zyx321 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:55AM (#10351732)
The capital-O Other is our capital-E Enemy. They stand for everything we don't stand for.

Jokes aside, it seems that has been a growing awareness for the concept of "othering," as in emphasizing the difference between your ingroup (AKA Us, AKA people like you) and an outgroup (AKA Them). Unfortunately it has little to do with the relatively benign idea you might be thinking about.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:27AM (#10351052)
I think it just became popular. I don't think it grew up at all. This all seemed to start happening after the facebook boom and all of my friends suddenly knew what a meme was.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Super_Jambo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:36AM (#10351681)
Play dota instead of league, yes you can get communication banned for being abusive but I think largely they just seem to lump all the unpleasant people on teams together.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:07PM (#10354109)
dota was the first game to mute ban me. I came home after a night of drinking and roleplayed troll warlord at 3 in the morning. I woke up to find myself mutebanned (something I'd never heard of). I had won 2/3 games and had the best stats in all three games. Very quickly I realized that this mute system was automated. A game could start with me unmuted, a teammate could report me because he didn't like the hero I picked or the lane I was going to, even if I hadn't said anything to said teammate, and I would become muted before creeps even spawned. The whole system was supper shoddy and lazily put together. Valve actually responded by posting an essay on why they were right and how the system wasn't automated, but perfect in every way. As a long time fanboy of Valve, I had never seen them do anything like this and I had never seen them post an essay like this. That was the nail in the coffin for me.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by dasil003 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:15PM (#10349500)
Sure. It's complicated. Heck, even just a passive laugh at a funny picture which is totally innocent and non-harmful in person, can become a crushing attack on a person when it goes viral and it's millions upon millions of people doing it.

But just because these issues are messy doesn't give us a license paper over their complexity with reductive founding-father-esque ideology. It's pretty clear to me that in aggregate freedom of speech on the internet is not suffering—people have unprecedented access to spread whatever thoughts they happen to have. Meanwhile an increasing number of people being hurt by internet bullying, harassment, and other anti-social behavior is growing by leaps and bounds in a way that society is not yet equipped to deal with.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:58PM (#10349734)
In aggregate is not what we're talking about in this instance. "In aggregate", crime is down worldwide, people are living longer than ever. That does not mean focus gets shifted away from individual criminals and diseases.

People being cut off from any medium based on, not because someone was hurt in any tangible way, but because they were offended, is a crying shame, and that goes double when the medium plays at being precisely against that sort of thing.

Source on "anti-social behavior growing by leaps and bounds", and a definition would be nice, too. It seems to me words like "harassment" and "bulling" are being used as stand-ins for things as innocuous as simple incivility.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mistermann on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:02PM (#10350445)
> it is enabled by anonymity and the complete lack of repercussions. If people behaved the way they do on these boards they would quickly be ostracized by society if not having the shit beaten out of them on a regular basis.

It depends where you do it - if you've ever been in a locker room or out drinking with the boys or the girls, all sorts of things are said and done that are extremely "inappropriate". Now, keeping that sort of thing off the front few pages of /r/all to me seems completely reasonable - banning it from the entire site (as was the plan) is something else entirely.

> All groups can find a place on the internet, and they will always be able to. We simply don't need to worry about that, and it's silly to wring our hands over the decision to moderate this or that community.

A lot of people liked reddit the way it was and didn't really feel like just finding another place on the infinite internet....why can't the SJW's and their ilk who came late to the party go find their own place? It's like renting an apartment beside a bar and then trying to get it shut down because of the noise.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mark_integerdsv on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:47AM (#10352050)
>why can't the SJW's and their ilk who came late to the party go find their own place?

Because their cause is evangelical in nature.

Were it just kept to Tumblr then they wouldn't have much with which to stoke the fires.

SJW's are specifically about pointing out to others where they are wrong/insensitive/racist/sexist/ableist/etc.. if they just kept to themselves then who would they persecute with their 'justice'?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:51AM (#10351128)
There are all kinds of subs on reddit, ones with anything goes as well as curated ones. If you like civil talk only head on over there, if you like uncivil conversation, head over there. There is no reason they can't coexist, just not in the same sub.

Physical harm is a crime. Some speech is a tort. Very limited aspects of speech are a crime (doxing, some bullying) but aside from those forms, I think it's disingenuous to want to control people's thoughts, no matter how ridiculous.

Climate change deniers are laughably wrong, by the vast majority of accounts and evidence _however_ I would not want them silenced just because they are in the wrong on their opinion or facts. I do not agree with that.

I am glad that reddit, for the most part, has not greatly changed their stand on speech. I understand they have commercial concerns and need to bow to those pressures, but I am glad they allow, by and large, the full spectrum of humanity and inhumanity.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:19AM (#10350873)
1. I don't think you actually know what a sociopath is. Slapping labels you don't understand on people you don't like is never going to solve your problems.

2. And are you seriously pulling the "cyber bullying" card here?

3. Since when is this a discussion about swatting?

The case seems pretty clear to me. You are free to create any subreddit you see fit, and moderate it however you wish. Why should every existing subreddit be forced to conform to your personal sensitivities? Just go make your own subreddit.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by baddox on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:47PM (#10348977)
> we necessarily live with people we find tasteless and disgusting.

Sadly, there is a loose but large movement of people who disagree that this is inevitable and tolerable. Lots of people think that human society can and should prevent the distribution of any expression that is considered to exceed some subjective threshold of tastelessness or offensiveness. This movement is, of course, an explicit and unabashed call for rigid suppression of free expression, and is something I oppose wholly.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by epistasis on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:35PM (#10348881)
> I really don't believe in sanitizing reality. I don't believe in intolerance for the intolerant. It's a nice, easy, euthanistic way to make our own little pure vision of the world.

And most people don't believe in hanging out with people they don't like.

You seem to be implying that it's more important for Reddit to represent unsavory people than it is for Reddit to hold onto a larger audience. I think that's ridiculous, because Reddit's purpose is not to be a safe haven for unsavory people, even if they "represent" reality. That might be an admirable goal for sociologists, but it doesn't have to be the goal of any website.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wisty on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:10PM (#10349116)
Here's the problem.

Let's look at something non-controversial like Doctor Who. There's /r/doctorwho, which allows posts like "My cat pretending to be Matt Smith" and "My girlfriend made me this bow-tie - look how cute it is on my cat!".

Then there's /r/gallifrey, which only allows posts about Doctor Who. Then there's a few others (/r/classicwho for episodes before the reboot).

Now, imagine if /r/DoctorWho banned criticism of Moffat. Obviously, all the Moffat haters would get banned, and go to /r/gallifrey. You'd suddenly have a large Moffat hating sub, and a large sub that couldn't understand why every other sub seemed to hate Moffat. These people wouldn't politely debate anything, because they'd get more upvotes and positive responses for attacking the other side than trying to be reasonable.

FWIW, I dislike Moffat, because I think Doctor Who works better in a more episodic format - long arcs don't work when the Tardis is in the mix. But that's not the kind of nuance you get when there's two subs that both have a bunker mentality, throwing bombs at the brainwashed idiots on the other side.

Anyway, reddit is not a "free speech" site. It's a site that lets mods do what they want, for their sub. It's architecture is not one that allows a free, civil discussion of ideas, so much as a place that encourages group-think. (And while you can blame the "SJWs", there were prominent "hate" subs, like Fat People Hate, that behaved the same way - it's just the way the site is designed and run).

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wisty on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @07:28PM (#10349881)
edit:

Reddit really could create a code of conduct for mods - only ban people / delete posts enforce reddiquette (it's a pretty good guide). Some kind of appeals process could ensure a bit of consistency.

The problem with reddit is the vast number of warring subs who hate each other. To some extent, this is inevitable (some groups just don't like other groups), but the double standards (often on both sides of any debate) just encourages the level of vitriol.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:25PM (#10350554)
A voluntary version of this is something I was shopping around before straight-up disillusionment set in.

https://www.reddit.com/r/blueribbon/wiki/constitution

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mc32 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:42PM (#10348941)
>And most people don't believe in hanging out with people they don't like.

Isn't that one of the problems we find with lots of people we don't like. They are bigots! They don't like anyone who isn't like them.

Yes, reddit surely may do as it pleases. That's their call to make. I'm simply voicing my preference with reason behind it. Facebook could lock out all selfidentifying males living in new York or all selfidentifying females in Uganda, that's their call. I'd be against it, but that's their call to make, sure.

Also, 2channel is at least one site which finds it important to allow unsavory communication large degrees of expression.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mark_integerdsv on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:09AM (#10352145)
>And most people don't believe in hanging out with people they don't like.

Then they shouldn't do that.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by RamenJunkie_ on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:39PM (#10357152)
Go ahead and enjoy your world.

I don't subscribe to any of the "hate groups" on Reddit, frankly, I never really noticed it.

But I stopped visiting the site after all of this.

I don't want a sanitized watered down "approved" bull shit feed of news and opinion. Guess what, Reddit, has a mechanism built in to manage site behavior. Its called the Downvote.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by egeozcan on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:07PM (#10347755)
But there are sexists and racists both in real life and online. Reddit is like a giant building with many halls for discussions. You don't have to enter or participate in the ones that racism is welcome but you don't need to avoid the building. I don't see it as hanging out together, but using the same tools. Yes the analogy is a bit of a stretch but I hope you get my point.

In short, IMHO, reddit is a tool and tools don't have political statements to make.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wetmore on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:36PM (#10347979)
As a heavy reddit user for the past 5 or 6 years I'd say the issue of intolerance on reddit is not entirely the fact that there are subreddits for racist or sexist ideals. What bothers me most is the way racism and sexism has seeped into the general site culture. The large subreddits which appear on an unregistered user's frontpage are full of comments and submissions whose magnitude of upvotes paint a picture of a casually intolerant status quo.

Using your analogy, I'm not upset because I can walk into a hall called "coontown" and see racism; I'm upset because I walk into a hall called "videos" or "worldnews" and see people throwing around stereotypes of women and minorities with great prejudice behind their words. Since I've been using reddit for some time now there has been a very noticeable shift in the status quo when it comes to the level of discourse and the amount of hate speech that shows up, and I'm really not happy with it.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by derefr on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:06PM (#10348234)
> I'm upset because I walk into a hall called "videos" or "worldnews" and see people throwing around stereotypes of women and minorities with great prejudice behind their words

These subreddits are big enough that their userbases are converging toward a statistically-normal sampling of the world population. To the degree to which the world contains prejudiced people, so will large subreddits. To the degree to which the world contains groups that venerate prejudice, prejudiced comments on large subreddits will be upvoted.

The big difference between a large subreddit, and the world-at-large, is that the majority cannot hang the implicit threat of mob violence over a disliked minority. In the world-at-large, disliked minorities usually meet in secret because they fear what would happen if they were outspoken in the presence of the majority. On a subreddit, there is no such fear to throttle behavior. As long as that fact remains true, large open online communities will always be outspoken-minority cesspools.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by intopieces on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:39PM (#10348474)
>These subreddits are big enough that their userbases are converging toward a statistically-normal sampling of the world population.

How is this information relevant to the experience of the user? If we transplant your explanation to any other user experience, does it work?

"I don't go to Best Buy anymore. It's full of people shouting racist things, men talking about beating women, and general prejudice againt minorities."

"Well, that's how the world is, mostly."

Does that make you want to go back to Best Buy?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by derefr on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:47PM (#10348524)
That's a broken expectation; pretty much no other "business" has an unsharded, all-to-all visible userbase large enough to get these effects. (I can only think of one: Youtube.)

The more direct comparison, to me, would be a city that has drug dealers and homeless people. Every city has them, because they live at the fringes of everything large enough to be called a "city." It's not a matter of choosing to live in some other city (not shopping at Best Buy, in your terminology); the only option for avoiding the pitfalls of city life is to avoid cities altogether.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by intopieces on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:56PM (#10348584)
>That's a broken expectation; pretty much no other "business" has an unsharded, all-to-all visible userbase large enough to get these effects.

Telling your userbase that they shouldn't expect what they expect is rarely a successful strategy. Again, what does Reddit's unique position as an all-visible userbase have to do with the actual experience of the user? We can make excuses and explanations for why Reddit is the way it is, but that doesn't ultimately address the fact that Reddit, despite being massively popular now, also hosts content so horribly offensive that it risks alienating both common users and advertisers.

Your city analogy doesn't quite fit. People who live in a city are often 'stuck' there for far more important reasons (money, family, culture) than the reasons people stick to a website. And we know it's easy for a website with a massive userbase to collapse, because we've seen it many times over the years.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:38PM (#10348910)
Some things are social problems that can't be resolved with technology but I don't think reddit's casual racism and sexism is one of them. Borrow from HN: Add site-wide flags for content you consider unacceptable that only users with $x comment karma can use. Borrow from Dota 2: If a user is flagged enough don't shadow ban them, just make their comments invisible to everyone except those who are also flagged. They can make their terrible comments to and with each other.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:53PM (#10349016)
Fantastic, power users dominating over everyone else.

Fantastic, another tool for the perpetually offended to abuse en masse.

Doubly broken.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:56PM (#10349721)
HN is going to provide the ability to counter-flag as well as moderator intervention in cases of abuse. If your power users are abusing their flagging privilege they lose it.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:59PM (#10349738)
That will probably work on Hacker News. That will almost certainly not work on Reddit. The scales involved are just not even in the same universe as each other, and that's before any discussion of the corruption or other problems on the latter site.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by 15155 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:37PM (#10350137)
Expectations are different, IMO, as well.

HN is not a free speech zone and does not even try to be one.

reddit, inc. executives have previously stated that reddit is a place for free speech.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by s73v3r on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:50PM (#10349372)
Again, the user does not care. The user sees blatant racism and sexism being tolerated, and in some cases celebrated, think the place is full of that, and leaves, never to return again.

You don't see how this is a problem for Reddit?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by derefr on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:58PM (#10349735)
Oh, I certainly do see how it's a problem; but it will be a problem with anything trying to compete with, or replace, Reddit just as much. I'm not too concerned with whether Reddit lives or dies; that's up to their PR department.

I'm concerned, instead, with the user attitude of attempting to move on to the "next big community" to avoid the problems with the last. If Reddit dies, and the thing after it dies, and the thing after that dies—I hope we eventually stop and look at what we're doing and realize that there's no point in this "grass is greener" pursuit of a utopian community, when these problems eventually face every community at scale. At some point, I hope we just sit down and try to maintain the community we've got (turning it into a society), rather than thinking that rebuilding it with slightly different rules but the same microcosm of people will help.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by intopieces on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:19PM (#10350525)
>At some point, I hope we just sit down and try to maintain the community we've got (turning it into a society), rather than thinking that rebuilding it with slightly different rules but the same microcosm of people will help.

I think this is accomplished with the ability to create new Subreddits. To my mind, the best way to separate the nasty parts of Reddit with the profitable ones is heavy moderation for the defaults, free reign for the non-defaults, and charge money for access to private subreddits. If a particular subreddit draws too much controversy, force it private.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by lotso on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:38PM (#10348907)
>These subreddits are big enough that their userbases are converging toward a statistically-normal sampling of the world population.

Do you really think the makeup of a large subreddit mirrors the real world? I would be my life savings that they are still predominantly white men on these subreddits.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by irishcoffee on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @07:35PM (#10349909)
I'll take that bet. How much you got?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by throwawaymaroon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:31PM (#10348428)
This is a straightforward way of saying the problem people have here isn't with Reddit, but with humanity.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:28PM (#10348837)
I think the only problem here is that not everyone can handle the internet. And worse, instead of realizing this, they expect websites to cater to their special needs. They are expecting websites to babysit them, to put people they don't like on timeouts, to exclude participation from anyone they don't like. This has been a huge issue since the internet became popularized. Things were not always this way.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tomlock on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:05AM (#10351001)
To quote another one of your comments: "The case seems pretty clear to me. You are free to create any subreddit you see fit, and moderate it however you wish. Why should every existing subreddit be forced to conform to your personal sensitivities? Just go make your own subreddit."

So, why don't you create your own internet? You really could if you wanted to.

It seems like you feel entitled to the internet, whereas people on the other side can't feel entitled to generic subreddits?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by eertami on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:12PM (#10348713)
>Using your analogy, I'm not upset because I can walk into a hall called "coontown" and see racism; I'm upset because I walk into a hall called "videos" or "worldnews" and see people throwing around stereotypes of women and minorities with great prejudice behind their words. Since I've been using reddit for some time now there has been a very noticeable shift in the status quo when it comes to the level of discourse and the amount of hate speech that shows up, and I'm really not happy with it.

What do you expect to happen when you start removing those halls where people can go talk freely about it?

It's not like the subscribers suddenly disappear when you ban a subreddit. They stay there, but without a place for the content they like they will take that same content to other places.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Excavator on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:36PM (#10348891)
As I see it, the issues are mainly caused by SRS being allowed to police the site. Not only closing "venting chambers" but also causing a lot of backlash and increasingly severe behaviour due to their harassment. Harassment on the level of harassing or threatening family, friends, and co-workers of their target.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by res0nat0r on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:37PM (#10348901)
That was happening long before any type of this subreddit "crisis" and overreacting drama.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mercurial on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:03PM (#10348205)
I don't use r/videos, but r/worldnews is the youtube of reddit: full of bigoted, intolerant, can-barely-form-a-coherent-thought, what's-spelling posts. In my experience, it has remained pretty much consistent over time.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wtbob on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:19AM (#10351474)
> I'm upset because I walk into a hall called "videos" or "worldnews" and see people throwing around stereotypes of women and minorities with great prejudice behind their words

Yeah, well I'm upset because I walk into a hall called 'politics' and see people throwing around stereotypes about anyone who's not a coastal leftist with great prejudice behind their words.

I am, actually. I remember when one could actually have a somewhat decent political conversation in /r/politics. But, well, that's life.

Perhaps it helps to think of the subreddit labels as merely suggestions. Each community is what it is, despite its label.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by akira2501 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:02PM (#10348202)
> Since I've been using reddit for some time now there has been a very noticeable shift in the status quo when it comes to the level of discourse and the amount of hate speech that shows up, and I'm really not happy with it.

Are you sure this isn't just a personal bias? None of this is new on reddit, the volume has increased, sure.. but so has the general userbase of the site.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by bduerst on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:11PM (#10348706)
Reddit isn't static. I think the whole fatpeoplehate debacle and it's preceding growth demonstrated that reddit is capable of generating large, biased communities that can dominate the site.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:53PM (#10348133)
then unsubscribe from /r/videos and /r/worldnews.

problem solved and done so in a way that you have complete control over and doesn't impose yourself on others.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wetmore on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:09PM (#10348255)
But these are subreddits whose original purpose is to provide content I want to see, so the problem isn't solved.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:30PM (#10348418)
Put bluntly, the problem (as much as opinions can be a problem) is of your own creation - you want to impose your standards of behavior and decorum on strangers on the internet.

And that's fine, there's a widely-accepted and successful mechanism for doing that: creation of your own community which you can gatekeep as you see fit. If enough people agree with you, perhaps it'll even eclipse the original!

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by kaitai on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:06PM (#10349450)
This can just as easily be turned around. Why do people who spout racism get to impose that standard of behavior and decorum on those who want to discuss video? Why does racist or sexist discussion trump relevant content in a content-specific forum?

You're right about the problem -- the problem at its root is that some people feel that having no standards that deprecate these off-topic discussions is equivalent to free speech which is equivalent to freedom, while others feel that some standards that keep people "polite" (for lack of a better word) and on-topic are useful to the discussion. You are not necessarily right about who created the problem. Why not say it's the people who want to be racist in the video forum who created the problem? Why don't they create their own community as you suggest? Because part of their desire is to spread their ideas -- they don't actually want to stay on-topic or primarily discuss video, they want to get a rise out of other people. It's engagement in bad faith, really.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:54PM (#10350206)
> This can just as easily be turned around. Why do people who spout racism get to impose that standard of behavior and decorum on those who want to discuss video? Why does racist or sexist discussion trump relevant content in a content-specific forum?

It can be easily turned around, but it can't be reasonably turned around.

It's reasonable to expect someone to simply not participate in a community whose culture they don't agree with.

It is NOT reasonable to expect that community to be forced into the behavior that an individual, or a small number of individuals, disagrees with.

I can tell you right now I'm a huge fan of vim, but I stopped posting on /r/vim several years ago due to the behavior I saw from some posters there.

I don't post much oh /r/programming for much the same reason. Or /r/politics.

Your problem is in not understanding that reddit gives you the TOOLS to curate your own experience. It sounds like you haven't been putting much effort into it, and you've, understandably, been inundated with shit. Which is why so many of us DO curate our own experience.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:40PM (#10348923)
The "default" subreddit issue needs to be resolved first. You shouldn't automatically be enrolled in any subreddit.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:56PM (#10349038)
I'm not sure that's possible. The only other option that comes to mind is asking people what their interests are and subscribing them to those rather than the same set for everyone, but then all you've done is create de-facto, topic-based defaults.

You could show people random content, but that's both not PC from a business standpoint and would lead to the outright destruction of smaller communities.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:41PM (#10348488)
The thing about communities is that they don't always do the thing that you want them to. You can always start your own subreddit and fork the community if you want to.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by chiph on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:25PM (#10348386)
Start your own subreddit for sharing content that you like.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by anu_gupta on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:00PM (#10348185)
Or, better still, don't unsubscribe, and instead challenge the intolerance and prejudice.

If you don't like that, then perhaps you can unsubscribe from places where people don't want to put up with this kind of behaviour.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by stinkytaco on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:23PM (#10348362)
Hey! Someone is wrong on the Internet!

Seriously, though, I find this is rarely a debate worth having, and certainly not in the quip-centric, 3 sentences or less culture that makes up Internet discussion boards. I would much rather pursue systemic solutions to problems like this than embark on trying to convert anonymous strangers.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:58PM (#10350219)
If reddit means so much to you that you're willing to spend the time brigading against it, be my guest. Just don't be surprised with many people (most?) don't want to put that sort of emotional investment into a news aggregation site.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tsotha on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:38PM (#10350370)
>Or, better still, don't unsubscribe, and instead challenge the intolerance and prejudice.

Good lord, no. 99% of the "intolerance and prejudice" is from out-and-out trolls. They're posting because they want to see a bunch of angry denunciations. Don't give them what they want.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by s73v3r on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:10PM (#10349464)
No, I don't believe that is an acceptable solution to the problem. Especially from Reddit's point of view, where they want users to stay and therefore generate revenue.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pil4rin on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:27PM (#10348399)
Take a look at http://redditenhancementsuite.com/features.html

I understand your issue is with the underlying platform and it's users, however, RES will allow you to setup filters by word- across all subs. I believe alienblue (the reddit client for iOS) allows for this functionality as well.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by lagadu on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:30AM (#10352256)
Those two are very large, general subs. You find sexism and racism in them as you would in any other semi-randomly sampled population extracted from the planet. You're actually angry that the subs are large enough to contain people whose opinions you don't agree with, which is exactly like the real world.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by learning_still on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:13PM (#10348719)
So what exactly are you proposing. Are you saying that the large subreddits that appear on the front page should be replaced with other subs because the moderators aren't doing a good enough job of excluding the kind of participation you want them to exclude?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by kobayashi on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:23PM (#10348808)
Hopefully more of the bigots will continue their migration to Voat and reddit might perhaps 'revert' to its more reasonable, tolerant roots
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by shinigami on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:46PM (#10348061)
Sure, you can avoid the hate-specific subreddits. The problem is that this kind of behaviour is mostly everywhere in reddit.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by johnward on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:05PM (#10347747)
Most of the sub reddits I hangout in don't have those tones or maybe I'm used to ignoring those types of comments online. I think any community starts to have those problems as they grow. HN isn't immune but it's still a small enough niche that we tend to still get higher quality comments than your average site. If you're in r/funny you're going to get comments from the lowest of the low just like youtube. I don't see it as a reddit issue it's more of a human nature problem. When you get enough of people in one area you're going to find the assholes.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:56PM (#10348156)
I don't see those issues either, OTOH I have a tendency to stick with specific subreddits of interest to me.

I've never viewed reddit as a community, but as a community of communities, and I've always chosen to be a part of specific communities, ignore others, and stay the hell away from yet others.

I don't go anywhere near /r/politics or /r/programming, for example. I just can't deal with the people in either. But I love me some /r/cpp and /r/startrek.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:28PM (#10348406)
Pretty much this - at least it was while I still used reddit.

The default large communities were crap, not because of any "-ism" as the article states, but because people were just plain disagreeable, non-contributing assholes, up to and including the moderation staff. It's the YouTube comments problem, writ large.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by copsarebastards on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:11PM (#10349121)
> I don't buy the "Media vs Reddit" narrative. I don't think this has anything to do with journalism or even intolerance.

Right, it's about selling ads. Reddit wants to keep its users (who want free speech) which sells ads. But Reddit also wants a PC site, which sells ads. Newspapers want to whip a popular whipping boy because it sells ads. They're all morally bankrupt: none of them care about the other or intolerance.

> I just don't like hanging out with racists and sexists (in real life or online). If Reddit wants to keep me as a contributor to their site, they need to do something about that or I will not return. I doubt I'm alone in feeling that way.

You're welcome to unsubscribe from racist and sexist subreddits. You're also welcome to subscribe to TwoXChromosomes and other similar subreddits. I'm literally subscribed to 4 very specific interest subreddits that don't tolerate hate speech and I haven't encountered a comment that could be even construed as racist or sexist that I can remember since shortly after I created an account.

So let's stop pretending that this isn't about you not wanting to hang out with racists and sexists: that's easily within your power by using the services Reddit offers. Let's admit that this is about silencing racists and sexists.

I don't have any skin in this game (the subreddits I subscribe to could easily be replaced by going back to the bulletin boards I used in the early 2000s) so I really don't care if Reddit crashes and burns, or if they have free speech: it's just not a platform that I care about. But I do think it's a bit disingenuous for people to pretend this isn't a free speech issue.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by wil421 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:04PM (#10348221)
Do you ever visit YouTube? Some of the worst comments I have ever read have been on YouTube?

Its up to the reader to decide what they want to read. Usually I skim over the bad comments and talk about what I want. Ignore the rest even if they PM you.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by baddox on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:43PM (#10348950)
Do what, exactly? Prevent you from getting linked to racist or sexist threads? Because almost certainly the only way you see racist or sexist content on reddit. You will very rarely see it on the logged out front page (the big reddit blowup is obviously a major exception), and probably rarely in any threads on default subs unless you deliberately browse the heavily downvoted comments.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by fweespeech on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:03PM (#10348638)
> I just don't like hanging out with racists and sexists. If Reddit wants to keep me as a contributor to their site, they need to do something about that or I will not return. I doubt I'm alone in feeling that way.

Many, many people think Tech has a sexism problem.

The logic you are applying to Reddit would in theory require you to leave HN as well. It would also apply to any venue that is commonly felt to have a sexism and/or racism problem.

Leaving because a subset of a given population is a "problem" is silly.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by kaitai on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:35PM (#10350354)
Look at the numbers of women or racial minorities in tech: in fact, exactly what you suggest happens. It's unfortunate that you think it's "silly" but everyone's got to live their life and subjecting oneself to constant discomfort just doesn't appeal to everyone.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by lagadu on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:58AM (#10352417)
Really? I work at a software house. Looking around me in my room, right now I can count: 8 males and 7 females. Overall I suspect we do have more guys in the company but by a very small margin.

Have you considered that the issue you're looking at is not a tech industry issue but rather a country-specific issue? Most studies I've read about it seem to have been made in the US.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by fweespeech on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:02PM (#10350443)
I work with an IT department that contains a majority of minorities and women.

So...its a question of picking what part of a larger whole that you hang out in. Just like you don't hang out in the racist/etc parts of Reddit.

Sorry if that message was lost.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by potato on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:18PM (#10347841)
> I just don't like hanging out with racists and sexists

Then don't?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Nimitz14 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:57PM (#10349041)
And I don't want to hang around cry babies. I hope reddit stays the same so people like you go away.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by rhizome on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:22PM (#10347877)
You may not be alone in feeling that way, but that doesn't mean that being on the internet means that you're "hanging out" with everybody on the internet.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by GauntletWizard on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:16PM (#10347828)
You hang out with racists and sexists in real life and online. You just are not comfortable acknowledging that others can have opinions you consider racist and sexist and still be human. Were you to actually probe your friends about their beliefs, you'd likely come across some that have beliefs that are incredibly sexist in your view, and that's okay.

For example, some of my friends believe that spaces need to be made 'safe' for women, and that means you cannot make any joke that references rape. Some of my friends are dark humored rape survivors, and find spaces where they cannot make those comments unsafe. I am friends with both of them, and they are friends with each other, despite disagreeing vehemently on what and where those spaces are. When they are around each other, neither of them can consider the space they reside 'safe', and yet, they survive.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by drdeca on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @07:11PM (#10349804)
This might be counterproductive, but hopefully it isn't (and is, at worst, neutral):

by "racists" and "sexists", do you mean these terms based on the beliefs of those described, or are you including things like, subconscious(?) biases, (which one might be trying to correct in oneself)?

It seems like it might be useful to have two different terms for the two concepts?

But maybe this is not a context where this would be a useful addition.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by samstave on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:43PM (#10349651)
In what /r/ are you "hanging out" that you feel like you're actually with racists and sexists?