News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by derefr on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:47PM (#10348524)
That's a broken expectation; pretty much no other "business" has an unsharded, all-to-all visible userbase large enough to get these effects. (I can only think of one: Youtube.)

The more direct comparison, to me, would be a city that has drug dealers and homeless people. Every city has them, because they live at the fringes of everything large enough to be called a "city." It's not a matter of choosing to live in some other city (not shopping at Best Buy, in your terminology); the only option for avoiding the pitfalls of city life is to avoid cities altogether.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by intopieces on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:56PM (#10348584)
>That's a broken expectation; pretty much no other "business" has an unsharded, all-to-all visible userbase large enough to get these effects.

Telling your userbase that they shouldn't expect what they expect is rarely a successful strategy. Again, what does Reddit's unique position as an all-visible userbase have to do with the actual experience of the user? We can make excuses and explanations for why Reddit is the way it is, but that doesn't ultimately address the fact that Reddit, despite being massively popular now, also hosts content so horribly offensive that it risks alienating both common users and advertisers.

Your city analogy doesn't quite fit. People who live in a city are often 'stuck' there for far more important reasons (money, family, culture) than the reasons people stick to a website. And we know it's easy for a website with a massive userbase to collapse, because we've seen it many times over the years.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:38PM (#10348910)
Some things are social problems that can't be resolved with technology but I don't think reddit's casual racism and sexism is one of them. Borrow from HN: Add site-wide flags for content you consider unacceptable that only users with $x comment karma can use. Borrow from Dota 2: If a user is flagged enough don't shadow ban them, just make their comments invisible to everyone except those who are also flagged. They can make their terrible comments to and with each other.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:53PM (#10349016)
Fantastic, power users dominating over everyone else.

Fantastic, another tool for the perpetually offended to abuse en masse.

Doubly broken.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:56PM (#10349721)
HN is going to provide the ability to counter-flag as well as moderator intervention in cases of abuse. If your power users are abusing their flagging privilege they lose it.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:59PM (#10349738)
That will probably work on Hacker News. That will almost certainly not work on Reddit. The scales involved are just not even in the same universe as each other, and that's before any discussion of the corruption or other problems on the latter site.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by 15155 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:37PM (#10350137)
Expectations are different, IMO, as well.

HN is not a free speech zone and does not even try to be one.

reddit, inc. executives have previously stated that reddit is a place for free speech.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by s73v3r on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:50PM (#10349372)
Again, the user does not care. The user sees blatant racism and sexism being tolerated, and in some cases celebrated, think the place is full of that, and leaves, never to return again.

You don't see how this is a problem for Reddit?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by derefr on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @06:58PM (#10349735)
Oh, I certainly do see how it's a problem; but it will be a problem with anything trying to compete with, or replace, Reddit just as much. I'm not too concerned with whether Reddit lives or dies; that's up to their PR department.

I'm concerned, instead, with the user attitude of attempting to move on to the "next big community" to avoid the problems with the last. If Reddit dies, and the thing after it dies, and the thing after that dies—I hope we eventually stop and look at what we're doing and realize that there's no point in this "grass is greener" pursuit of a utopian community, when these problems eventually face every community at scale. At some point, I hope we just sit down and try to maintain the community we've got (turning it into a society), rather than thinking that rebuilding it with slightly different rules but the same microcosm of people will help.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by intopieces on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:19PM (#10350525)
>At some point, I hope we just sit down and try to maintain the community we've got (turning it into a society), rather than thinking that rebuilding it with slightly different rules but the same microcosm of people will help.

I think this is accomplished with the ability to create new Subreddits. To my mind, the best way to separate the nasty parts of Reddit with the profitable ones is heavy moderation for the defaults, free reign for the non-defaults, and charge money for access to private subreddits. If a particular subreddit draws too much controversy, force it private.