News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @02:49PM (#1021119)
I would like to take this opportunity to bring up downvoting. Doesn't downvoting have the same end effect as DH0 (or DH3)?

A downvote signals disapproval/discouragement, yet it requires no legitimate counterargument or reasoning for it.

I haven't seen people calling each other "fags" here, but it seems the downvote is simply the HN version of calling people "fags."

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by pg on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:29PM (#1021235)
There's a lot in what you say. In the next couple months I'm going to be experimenting with solutions to this and related problems. The general plan will be to de-emphasize points and to add more types of flags.

For comments, there will be at least flags for incivility, fluff, and spam. Spammers, as now, will get banned instantly. People who accumulate a lot of flags for incivility may also get banned for some set period.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by ghshephard on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:14PM (#1021338)
Flags would be wonderful. There are many times where I've seen a wonderfully reasoned argument that I _completely_ disagree with (usually because of the premises of the argument). I am always conflicted - do I

A) Downvote the comment because the I think the conclusions are grossly wrong.

B) Upvote the comment because I'm so enamored of the elegance of the argument, it's contribution to the conversation, and how it made me think more carefully about my own argument.

C) Ignore it - and unjustly not provide my reasoned critique on what clearly took a great deal of effort by the author.

If I could only Flag it as "DISAGREE WITH CONCLUSION" and "ADDS TO CONVERSATION" then everything would be good.

The four flags that I think would be useful would be:

  FLUFF vs CONTRIBUTES
  AGREE vs DISAGREE
  SPAM
  INCIVIL
That way, I can now simultaneously rank an article as both contributing, as well as disagreeing with the conclusion.

An author may then write an unpopular, but carefully reasoned discourse, and still enjoy the positive feedback of his peers on his contribution, even if he is challenging their perspectives.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by blahedo on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @07:07PM (#1021614)
I worry that having an explicit "agree/disagree" axis would encourage a popularity contest mentality, so I was about to say that this was a terrible idea... but then it occurred to me that by having it there, it might siphon off the people that are using the upmod/downmod function as if it were agreement-based. So maybe it would be good after all.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by berntb on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:17PM (#1021342)
Personally, I'd prefer if you'd write a comment and explain why the argument is totally wrong. (And preferably starting with praising what you approve of; that would give the right tone to any answers you get.)

Edit: On consideration, I should have followed my own advice and started this with: "A well reasoned, well written and interesting argument. But why aren't you adding the alternative of ANSWERING the argument instead of just moderating?!"

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by ghshephard on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:38PM (#1021380)
Fair Point with regards to answering the argument, but, with tens of articles a day, and hundreds of comments per article, sometimes all you can afford to do is take 5 seconds to flag your feedback. Also note that flagging/ranking an article also has an impact on how many people see the article, as it rises to the top.

There is also the (strong) possibility that I really have nothing to add to the conversation other than a DH3 "Disagree" - which perhaps suggests that I have no right to be moderating that particular comment in the first place.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by tokenadult on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:33PM (#1021369)
Personally, I'd prefer if you'd write a comment and explain why the argument is totally wrong.

I sometimes invite people to write such comments if they disagree with me. Often, when a comment makes a factual assertion for which I know of no evidence, I will reply to ask for the evidence. I will say things such as "Citations, please?" or "What are some examples of this?" or in some other way ask for the participant to back up the statement to which I reply.

But there are cases when a comment is totally wrong, and not a good contribution to the thread besides (which has always been a generally supported basis for downvoting), and it's just too much bother to post a countering reply or to ask follow-up questions. In such cases, I don't feel embarrassed at all in downvoting the wrong comment. The site founder pg, who announced news of changes he is considering in flagging options on HN in this thread, wrote 681 days ago,

I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

Voting and flagging options today are still much as they were then, and so for the moment I don't think it's a bad idea to downvote for disagreement, particularly if a comment has other undesirable characteristics. I will happily adapt to a new system if the site management implements a new system. And I invite participants who disagree with this reply of mine to write a comment and explain why my argument is totally wrong, if that is not too much trouble to you.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @06:17PM (#1021548)
Perhaps it's okay to use the up/down arrows to express agreement/disagreement, but then the ranking of comments can only be seen as an indicator of popular comments, not necessarily thoughtful, quality ones.

That's the inherent issue here. It's that the arrows used to represent quality in theory are actually used in practice to indicate agreement. And then with the down voting, you effectively have a system of negative reinforcement because your comments are being downvoted because you're a dissenter, but interpreted as a sign of bad quality and discouraged to speak further. It's interpreted as a sign of bad quality because all the signs say so. You get grayed out if it's too negative and your comment gets pushed to the bottom. Perhaps you'll become alienated and leave the community, making the HN community slightly more homogenous.

I agree with you in that it's a good idea to allow people to indicate their agreement and disagreement, but to have it clearly defined as an indicator of popularity.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:30PM (#1023808)
I think that it also seems to "taint" an entire thread the same as "leper unclean!". Especially when I see an entire thread of negative scores, I know that somebody has a chip on their shoulder for whoever steps in that turf they've decided to police. Participating in that thread is the same as a guaranteed downmod.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Pistos2 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:10PM (#1021436)
I think a good system would be to have just two voting axes:

1) "worth reading" / "not worth reading" 2) agree / disagree

Then add a system of whatever flags you think are necessary, like "spam".

I treat the current voting arrows as if they meant (1). I vote up things that I think are worth other people's time to read; vote down things that are a waste of time to read. I very rarely downvote. In some cases where others might more liberally downvote, I simply don't vote.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:34PM (#1023812)
Even then, I think the scores for each should be bifurcated so that people can see the number of "worth reading" vs. "not worth reading" votes, and the same for agree/disagree.

I think the practice should at least be modeled liked a number-line. The default is 0, neither an upmod or downmod. Just as it is, an upmod (or +1) should be given if the post was particularly interesting (not agreeable, interesting), and a downmod (or -1) should be given if the post was particularly non-interesting (not disagreeable, non-interesting).

I think too many people only see the world as either +1/-1 with no option to just leave a comment alone.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Pistos2 on Thursday December 31, 2009 @12:51PM (#1024612)
To be clear, I thought it went without saying that marking agreement or disagreement would not count towards the worth-reading score, and that the two arrow pairs would not be accumulated into a single score. Two scores would have to be displayed, perhaps giving users the option of seeing only the worth-reading score.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by mtts on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @07:34PM (#1021653)
I treat the voting arrows as if they meant (1) as well, and in addition to that, if something is at 0 or worse and isn't in fact a waste of time, I'll vote it back up.

Downvoting something you disagree with kills a discussion, IMHO.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by rbanffy on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:49PM (#1021398)
Just flagging adds meaning to downvotes, but can still be used to suppress opinions and people.

Perhaps a way to balance this is making flagging (up or down) cost karma points, but that would lead to them (KPs) being visible to give immediate feedback on the user's actions. Likewise, upvotes give back the karma you lost modding some comment. A different cost for up/down seems also a good idea. This, simply, could create an incentive to post even when one has nothing to say and prevent constructive modding by people who post little.

Hmm.... Perhaps an agreeing vote would redeem part of the karma paid to up/down vote.

This balancing act is a very hard problem.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by tokenadult on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @08:15PM (#1021709)
Perhaps a way to balance this is making flagging (up or down) cost karma points, but that would lead to them (KPs) being visible to give immediate feedback on the user's actions.

I asked last week

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1006946

whether attempts to make the site better, which is what many downvotes and flags currently are, ought not to be rewarded with MORE karma rather than less. I think people who clean up the trash should be paid for their work.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:42PM (#1023832)
The flag mechanism already exists to deal with true trash if I'm not mistaken.

It seems to me, respectfully, that using the downvote to try and clean the community is like a small-town sheriff trying to keep the perceived riff-raff of city-slickers, with their strange ways and funny hair, out of his community.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by rbanffy on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @07:48AM (#1022340)
"I think people who clean up the trash should be paid for their work."

I think a bigger danger is the suppression of dissent. Rewarding it with more karma would be a huge mistake.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by tokenadult on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:02PM (#1022833)
Dissenting from your opinion in what I hope will be a civil, constructive manner, I agree with you that once in a while I get downvotes solely because I am expressing an unpopular opinion. But that is rare. And I don't shy from expressing minority opinions here on several issues. I don't get a large number of downvotes at all. My two comments with the largest net number of downvotes were (to me, in hindsight) comments that I could have written more clearly with more effort at relating them to the main concern of the thread and adding new information to the thread. On the whole, I think most downvotes are adding quality of expression to the site rather than subtracting opinions from the site. There are a lot of strong opinions here, not all of them in unison, and a lot of those opinions get expressed here.

By the way, it's an EMPIRICAL question whether downvotes or posting disagreeing replies does more to discourage expressions of certain opinions. It seems to me that someone thin-skinned enough to cease posting his opinions because his comments get downvoted (rather than reconsidering how he comments and seeing if he can improve how he comments) might be just as discouraged from posting minority opinions if he sees a lot of replies that disagree with him. If a person has courage of his convictions because his opinions are based on evidence and careful thought, there is little reason not to come back here and express the opinions, even if his comments don't get a huge number of net upvotes.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:47PM (#1023843)
> It seems to me that someone thin-skinned enough to cease posting his opinions because his comments get downvoted (rather than reconsidering how he comments and seeing if he can improve how he comments) might be just as discouraged from posting minority opinions if he sees a lot of replies that disagree with him.

I respectfully disagree. A downmod supplies almost zero feedback to the recipient. Many posts I've seen with negative mod scores are complex and have a number of topics in them. A downvote at no time explains what precisely was wrong with the post.

It's like a presidential candidate not getting a vote, he doesn't know what part of his platform lost him the vote, just that he didn't get it.

In real life a candidate can pay for a poll and find out why, here it seems that asking why immediately results in more downmods.

(I admit the analogy is imperfect, but hopefully you see where I'm trying to go with it).

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:40PM (#1023830)
Maybe only downmods force a user to "spend" karma? This would weed out habitual downmodders.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @08:52AM (#1025675)
This is not a bad idea. Force a person to spend some karma to take somebody else's karma away. It's similar to how and upvoting commenting seems to help build karma here.

And meta-comment, really? Your post was downvoted? Way to discourage ideas and effort....sigh

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jazzdev on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:24PM (#1022888)
* The general plan will be to de-emphasize points and to add more types of flags.*

I'm anxious to see this experiment. If flags are not binary, I'm curious how the number of different types of flags will be used to bubble up articles and comments.

I like the idea of separating "worth reading" from "agree". If only "worth reading" makes things bubble up then people that strongly agree might mark things as "worth reading" because they want them to bubble up. An interesting problem.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:18PM (#1021345)
I'd like to suggest another experiment for a feature. If the comment author's name is hidden unless you click on the link to the comment, so that by default it isn't shown, it might be able to reduce bias on the initial read or comment. It would reduce the tendencies of people to, at the very least, unwillingly be affected by the commenter's name.

Personally I never even notice the person's name unless I'm going back and forth, so I'm not even sure how much effect this has.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by mixmax on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:23PM (#1021352)
This has been discussed before, and if my memory serves me correctly it wasn't that well received.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:30PM (#1021367)
What was the problem?
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by ghshephard on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:48PM (#1021396)
Well, for one, seeing an comment on cryptography by cperciva already communicates a great deal before you've even read the first word. Not to say he's never wrong, but I'm inclined to believe that his largest mistakes on the topic are still more accurate than my most carefully reasoned treatises on the subject. You can find many, many such Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) on HN who likewise carry weight on a topic (PG on Startups?) by their very identity.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by gruseom on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:51PM (#1021399)
Absolutely. When Peter Norvig drops by to make a comment or two, I want to know.

Besides, it's human nature to always ask "who". Any system that tries to override human nature has its work cut out for it.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Locke1689 on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @02:40AM (#1022142)
Besides, it's human nature to always ask "who".

Not just nature, but efficiency. The statement, "In argument subject, not author, holds interest" may be true in theory but in practice this breaks down. People without established expertise may have worthwhile contributions but it's easier for people to receive contributions from people with known expertise. For example, I would just as wholeheartedly receive a comment from cperciva as one from "A well-known cryptographer and talented mathematician with a relevant and competitive PhD."

This is mostly notably seen in the physical sciences wherein most theoretical physics treatises are given little attention from the mainstream physics community unless there is a credible and relevant PhD backing it. Physicists simply don't have the time to pick through all of the papers from amateur hour and point out where they messed up the calculation that they should have learned in Quantum Optics 332.

This expedience is partially reflected in HN comments. While ideally everyone would have a chance to respond to every comment to point out where it is factually incorrect, few have the time. It is also disconcerting to see a factually incorrect comment with more points than the factually correct reply. In each of these cases, one could comment to express agreement with the reply and reinforce the incorrectness of the original comment, but a combination of vote up/vote down fulfills a similar function in a fraction of the time. Perfect? No. Expedient? Yes.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:46PM (#1021495)
I didn't mean to suggest hiding the name so that we can't find out who posted the comment, but rather just making it more difficult. So you can still find out who wrote the comment, by clicking on the link to the comment, or perhaps requiring a mouseover.

I mean I can already see some problems to being able to see a name, and having that "communicate a great deal" just by the name. If the comment communicates a great deal, then why can't the comment stand on its own merits? It just seems that more people will be inclined to upvote because of the person who said it.

And I understand the concern about being able quickly skim and find notable experts replying. This is a potential problem with hiding author names. But I think some of this problem can be alleviated by the fact that better comments usually float to the top anyways.

Also perhaps this feature can be something that is only disabled after reaching a karma threshold?

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by roundsquare on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @12:15AM (#1021981)
I think your right if you assume that the argument is a self contained object. But a lot of times an argument draws on someone's experiences. In these cases, it can be useful to know who the person is.

For example, I remember reading earlier comments about the negative impact of working all night long on a start up. If I had said this, people would (rightly) ignore me. But if someone who has a startup had said this, it should carry more weight.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by bugs on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:40PM (#1021260)
I think points do a good job of positioning comments in a thread as you can easily pick out the common consensus, one thing that would be nice if it was encouraged is leaving comments when you downvote so that maybe a discussion can occur.

(Obviously however there are some comments that do not warrant discussion but this probably would end up fitting into the types of flags.)

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:03PM (#1021305)
On the downside exposing points can lead to bias. You could easily make up your mind based on the points. It discourages individual thinking, and frankly if someone is too lazy to analyze and filter out the good comments for him/herself do we really want his/her opinion?

It can result in less accurate filtering. Popular comments may be voted up simply because someone sees the amount of points, skims the comment with perhaps a bare understanding, and thinks "hey, this guy's probably right." And then, ding, a possibly unwarranted upvote. The same effect can apply to an unpopular comment, but the effect is probably stronger for unpopular comments, which is why I think it is so dangerous. An unpopular comment would suffer more of this effect because people who disagree may build up more negative emotions, and this emotion may lead to more impulsive, irrational behavior making them more susceptible to the bias.

Seeing a comment he/she disagree with, and seeing that a bunch of people agree with him/her about disagreeing gives that person a sense of approval which erodes his/her ability to truly evaluate a dissenting comment objectively.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jacoblyles on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @06:17PM (#1021549)
I like this idea alot. It gives community values explicitness, visibility, and teeth.

If people have no incentive to refrain from bad behavior except the occasional posting of the commenting guidelines to the front page, then they will engage in bad behavior. People respond to incentives.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by revorad on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @06:42PM (#1021583)
I have a suggestion: Make it compulsory to leave a comment explaining a downvote i.e. when a user clicks on the downvote button, he is asked to comment. You can't downvote unless you provide a reason.

Flags can play the role of downvotes for controlling spam and totally rubbish comments.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:46PM (#1022932)
I think this is simple and reasonable, and it's usually the particular pain point I usually mention while grinding away on my "downvotes are bad" axe. I think this is better than tags because the universe of possible reasons to downvote something appear to be so large that we'd need a large menu of flags to select from, and also would need to be able to select multiple flags, making scoring posts (which I still think is useful) very hard.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by charliepark on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @08:16PM (#1021710)
It would be interesting, too, if the downvotes could, themselves, be downvoted by others, rendering them valueless. That is, if my explanation for my initial downvote doesn't pass muster, others could downvote-the-downvote, and the initial comment (which I had downvoted) would be left with its full complement of points, as though I hadn't downvoted it to begin with.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by InclinedPlane on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @09:00PM (#1021747)
There's already a mechanism for this. It's called upvoting.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @04:48PM (#1023303)
An upvote is semantically different than a downvote. A downvote is like saying "I am providing negative feedback", while a downvote-downvote is like saying "You have no reason to provide negative feedback".

An upvote on the otherhand is "I'm providing positive feedback".

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Pistos2 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @08:27PM (#1021722)
It would be good if "cancelled" downvotes were deleted or hidden. I think there is a risk of downvote explanations cluttering things.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:35PM (#1023819)
This seems like a cool idea, just not sure how it could be implemented. Any examples of something like this you know of?
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by charliepark on Thursday December 31, 2009 @09:15PM (#1025355)
Closest example I can think of is Amazon's "did you find this review useful" button. You can suss out — somewhat — how helpful a review is.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by revorad on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @08:25PM (#1021718)
That would only be fair because the downvote to your downvote comment would also have to provide a reason. So, it would encourage a real discussion.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @04:46PM (#1023299)
I upvoted this because I think this is reasonable. The purpose of HN is to be a discussion forum, not a karma generating tool. Requiring comments for votes (particularly downvotes) fits the theme.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:37PM (#1023824)
After following this topic for a while, it seems that the main problem is objection to comment-less downmods, not downmods in principle.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @08:49AM (#1025671)
Precisely.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by revorad on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @05:01AM (#1022240)
Unlike this one where comments are apparently getting downvoted for no obvious reason.

Another interesting experiment would be to display the top downvoters from time to time. We'll at least be able to weed out some of these invisible trolls.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @04:45PM (#1023295)
As this thread and numerous others are demonstrating, there is a group of people that lurk and troll through the consequence-free mechanism of the downvote. I don't really care who the top downvoters are (though the metrics would be interesting, I'd like to see different mixes and matches of the various statistics that HN could generate, upvoters, downvoters, karma, number of posts, average comment scores etc), but I think there should be some limit per unit time they can downvote. Like say 5/every 30 days or some such. Given how many perfectly reasonable comments in this topic have been downvoted, I would suspect it's the same lurker-trolls every time, they would have just blown their quota for the month under this kind of system.

And if you notice, it's like pulling teeth from an angry lion to even get any of these guys to bother posting a reason. The answers so far seem to amount to either

1) My time is too important, I'm too important.

2) The downvote is enough reason, it should be obvious to the recipient that they weren't contributing anything.

I'm sorry, but I don't find either of those reasons even remotely satisfying.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:39PM (#1023828)
I don't think you're right. The reasons seem to be that people are downmodding as a social normalization function. It's like saying "don't post more like that please".

I think you are taking downmods a bit too personally.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @06:44AM (#1025626)
Well, different people are having different takes on the semantics I guess. How about a quota though? Nobody likes an overly negative person at a party. IRL, we can't enforce good behavior that way, but here we can through the power of software.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Friday January 01, 2010 @05:50PM (#1026393)
I don't think a quota makes sense. But a comment/vote does.

I don't want to limit the amount of times a person can disagree with me (at risk of allowing for disagreeable persons).

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by roundsquare on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @12:40AM (#1022020)
I think this sounds interesting, but with this system, it becomes more critical for the crows to know the rules.

However, a lot of that might be solved by using words instead of arrows. E.g. a "Agree", "Disagree" and "Detracts From Conversation" button.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by GoboGobo on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:36PM (#1021376)
I hope that you'll be cautious with the amounts of possible flags? More choices makes the decision to vote harder, possibly reducing the number of votes, which is not what you want.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by RiderOfGiraffes on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @04:40AM (#1022227)
Perhaps fewer votes is exactly what you want. I can imagine that lots of people read things and go "Oh - yeah - (click)" without thinking too hard. Perhaps requiring mental investment on the part of the voter is a good thing.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by wglb on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:02PM (#1021156)
I disagree. I see, and myself, do downvote comments that I disagree with, if it is a strong disagreement. I think there is also a post where pg says something similar: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=392347

I have found that comments of mine that get downvoted cause me to think about why.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jm4 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:11PM (#1021184)
I don't think it's clear whether pg is endorsing the downvote as a form of disagreement or simply making the observation that it is often used that way.

Petercooper wrote a great response in that thread. Disagreement by downvote stifles any attempt at honest debate.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by wglb on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @11:20PM (#1021902)
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jm4 on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @08:19AM (#1022367)
Downvoting people who are mistaken is different than downvoting people you disagree with. Something that is factually incorrect should be downvoted because it contributes negatively to the discussion.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kmcgivney on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:08PM (#1021175)
In this case, that would be "DH3" according to the article. Contradiction with no supporting evidence.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:49PM (#1021283)
Sure, but you could probably argue that calling someone a "fag" without evidence is also DH3. But I think the nuance is that down voting is not explicitly stating a contradiction, only stating that you disagree (albeit anonymously), which is slightly more like DH0.

So yea it technically is also DH3.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by berntb on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:14PM (#1021335)
I try to not down vote for disagreeing, because most of my opinions are wrong. I have changed almost all my positions more than once and it will happen again. If people disagree without trolling it is valuable, even if they are more wrong than me. It helps me be less wrong.

I have started to down vote when people wastes my time: Trolls and sometimes for boring flame wars that show up in every discussion on a subject (like Perl 5 trolls that obviously don't know the language, but has Googled a reference to the operators of Perl 6!).

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by vaporstun on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:05PM (#1021167)
Not when used correctly.

I thought this was on some sort of FAQ page or the guidelines but couldn't find it now.

Downvoting is not to be used to show disapproval/disagreement, but rather to filter out messages that add nothing to the conversation by being off-topic or just devoid of content.

If you use downvotes to show your disapproval and add nothing to the conversation, then I suppose you're right they are tantamount to DH0 comments, but when used correctly they can (in theory anyway!) help provide better, more intellectually stimulating conversations by burying useless banter.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by ajb on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:16PM (#1021341)
There is a generic problem with mechanisms of this nature: it is difficult for a crowd to learn. I saw an excellent example of this at the Festival of Lights in Lyon earlier this month:

During one exhibit, there was a giant game of 'breakout' (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakout_%28video_game%29) projected onto a large ferris wheel. The crowd was supposed to play it by all waving orange lights. If you remember breakout, you know that there is a limit on the speed at which the bat is allowed to move, so if you let the bat get too far from where the ball is going to be, there will not be enough time to fix it before the ball hits the floor. It was impossible for the crowd to learn this, however, because an individual in the crowd gets no noticeable feedback from their actions once they have been averaged with those of the rest of the crowd.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:25PM (#1021222)
Perhaps a better system would be to tally both up and downvotes rather than upvote-downvotes. This way comments with a score of 0 might still have 1000 upvotes and a 1000 downvotes, showing that it is both a popular as well as a polarizing opinion.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:12PM (#1021329)
That's a good idea. I think the central issue with the voting system is that it's supposed to be a mechanism for determining quality, but it's being used for determining popularity of viewpoints. And popularity does not correlate with validity. So some way to clearly define and separate mechanisms for these purposes would resolve the issue.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by tokenadult on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:44PM (#1021392)
popularity does not correlate with validity.

On the other hand, if this site was seeded initially with thoughtful participants (as I believe it was before I got here, and as I believe it continues to be by visitors who come here from pg's personal website), being popular (upvoted) rather than unpopular (downvoted) may be a fairly reliable mark of a comment worth reading. Everyone here reads a lot of the best of what is on the Web, and observes the behavior of other users here, and I think there are many examples here of highly upvoted comments (or, from another point of view, participants with high karma) being signals of good quality. It may be that there are some equally clear examples here of comments with many downvotes, all the way down to the system-imposed limit of a score of -4, or users with very little karma, being examples of poor quality.

After edit: so my assertion, in friendly disagreement with you, is that popularity DOES correlate with validity to a useful degree here, so even if not every popular comment is factually valid, and not every factually valid comment is popular, noting popularity can still be a guide to busy readers here about what to devote time to reading.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jazzdev on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:11PM (#1022854)
my assertion, in friendly disagreement with you, is that popularity DOES correlate with validity to a useful degree here

Unfortunately, this doesn't scale. It is true now and that makes HN valuable. As HN grows there may be more people who express opinions that are not thoughtful and well reasoned, and then popularity no longer corresponds with useful. I think that's the problem that pg is trying to solve.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by tokenadult on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:39PM (#1021381)
I thought this was on some sort of FAQ page or the guidelines but couldn't find it now.

There is a previous comment by pg on this subject

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

that I have had bookmarked for a long time now that says,

I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness.

As we can see from this thread itself, pg is currently considering a different approach to marking comments for disagreement by multidimensional flagging. I am happy to adapt to any rule that this site sets up. For the moment, there is NOT a rule here that "Downvoting is not to be used to show disapproval/disagreement, but rather to filter out messages that add nothing to the conversation by being off-topic or just devoid of content." On my part, I mostly only downvote to disagree if there are thread-contribution-dimension reasons to disfavor the comment as well, and of course I upvote a lot to show agreement to try to emphasize the positive, but there currently isn't a rule about this here from the keyboard of the site management.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:14PM (#1021337)
The issue is that in equilibrium, it is not used correctly. It's better to design the system to model natural behavior than theoretical behavior.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:20PM (#1021454)
Precisely, pg has put some interesting controls on the site based on lessons learned at other places. For example, new users can only post so fast, and can't downvote until they hit some karma threshold.

The idea being that new users are forced to observe the community conventions on the site and decide if they want to conform to them. By the time they "grow up" they can then move about with greater and greater freedom. This seems to work pretty well regarding arguments and comments.

However, as this topic most clearly demonstrates, the pain point on the site is not the nature of the comments or forms of argument, it's the up/downvote problem. The theory was that higher quality posts would naturally end up with higher scores from more upvotes. Lessons learned from this site should show that to not be entirely true.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Xichekolas on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:03PM (#1021160)
While I agree with you, one has to realize that downvoting existed before flagging. At the time, it was used mostly for suppressing spam/trolls and egregiously rude people. Now we have flagging for that, although I still occasionally downvote stuff that is rude rather than flagging. Consider it like a minor flag. That said, I'd be fine if it went away and we just had upvotes and flags, but we've discussed this ad infinitum.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by RevRal on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:33PM (#1021244)
I call them drive-by downvotes.

I imagine some guy in a black leather chair going "hmph," with an angry face, then clicking the down arrow.

This is why I find it annoying. I see a lot of DH3+ comments being downvoted with no explanation. Then I want to upvote the comment and, at the same time, ask why it has been downvoted.

My upvote probably wouldn't count. Then, in return, I'm afraid I'd get downvoted. From time to time I see someone else say "hey, why are you guys downvoting this? This guy is saying something worthwhile."

In which case, the situation reverses and the originally negative comment is +1 or +2. Or more. BUT, still lacking an explanation as to why the comment was downvoted to a negative in the first place.

Annoying.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:47PM (#1021276)
I think terse negative feedback (a downvote) deserves some level of explanation otherwise the feedback from the vote is meaningless and people become afraid to post.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by axod on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:00PM (#1021153)
I think downvoting is supposed to be used to mark spam/offtopic etc - Things that don't add to the conversation or contribute anything interesting.

Using downvoting to disagree with the comment isn't the intention afaik.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:15PM (#1021194)
I wholeheartedly disagree:

1) Spam should be flagged not downvoted.

2) On/Offtopic is about as subjective as you can get. Some of the most interesting comments I've seen on HN were the ones that were non-obviously related to the post or were meta-comments, or even better, when an interesting conversation ran wild and flowed from topic to topic to topic.

3) Downvoting is being used more and more and more for uncommented disagreement.

Don't believe me? Visit any thread here and see which posts are sitting at <=0 karma. I guarantee the vast vast majority of them will be

1) Humorous and on-topic (even if the humor is bad).

2) On topic but non-specifically disagreed with by somebody (who? nobody knows since no comments were probably provided).

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jodrellblank on Thursday December 31, 2009 @06:43PM (#1025208)
How does your claim that any given comment was downvoted for disagreement backup your wider claim that downvoted comments were downvoted for disagreement? That's circular.

> 1) Spam should be flagged not downvoted.

Agree.

> 2) On/Offtopic is about as subjective as you can get

Roughly agree, except there are official guidelines from the HN HQ so it isn't completely subjective.

> 3) Downvoting is being used more and more and more for uncommented disagreement.

Maybe, but even if so I don't see it being a problem. HN isn't turning into an echo chamber because of it, HN has always been a self selected echo chamber, as are all self selected groups of people who choose to belong to a group focused on some area(s) of interest.

> Don't believe me?

Don't understand you.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @09:13AM (#1025687)
> Roughly agree, except there are official guidelines from the HN HQ so it isn't completely subjective.

This is true, but even within the guidelines, there is considerable room for topics. Some people seem to want to constrain that further to some smaller set of topics they are personally interested in by using the downvote.

> Maybe, but even if so I don't see it being a problem. HN isn't turning into an echo chamber because of it, HN has always been a self selected echo chamber, as are all self selected groups of people who choose to belong to a group focused on some area(s) of interest.

Self-selected, narrowly focused? Sure. But an echo chamber is not what we want, they are by definition, undesirable.

> Don't understand you.

I wasn't clear I guess. My point being is that posts that are off-topic and generally disagreeable are not the ones being downvoted because by and large we tend not to have those too much on HN. The ones that are being downvoted are the ones that are, on topic, but have some other characteristic that the downvote patrol doesn't want to see, such as humor or a dissenting or contradictory voice.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:03PM (#1021163)
It may not be intended, but I'm pretty sure it's what it's used for. Plus intuitively, it's as if it is put there for that purpose, since there is also a "flag" action which seems more suited for marking spam/off-topic already.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jm4 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:06PM (#1021170)
I don't have any supporting evidence, but it seems like the downvote has been increasingly used to disagree over the past several months.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by dangoldin on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:13PM (#1021191)
I think it's fair to say that if most people upvote with things they agree with, then they will downvote things they disagree with.

It may even be a subconscious act.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kmcgivney on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:17PM (#1021199)
I suppose someone out there disagrees with you.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:28PM (#1021232)
As your score on this now perfectly demonstrates.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by bmj on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:16PM (#1021195)
I agree. I've always thought the intention here was to use comments to disagree, and reserve down-voting for really poor comments that may not be constructive to the conversation. As another poster pointed out, getting down-voted does cause me re-think my comment, but I'd rather know why someone down-voted me.

Personally, I tend to avoid down-voting, even for egregious comments.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:27PM (#1021229)
Personally, getting downvoted tends to make me rethink wanting to even bother to comment.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:44PM (#1021269)
Exactly. It discourages participation through negative feedback. If you want to condition people to do a certain thing, like post thoughtful comments, then I think that's best achieved solely through positive reinforcement.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Ixiaus on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:12PM (#1021187)
I would agree with this sentiment, I find it immeasurably frustrating when I spend twenty minutes writing a cogent and thoughtful response to someone to only get downvoted with no refutation/counter argument. I can agree with downvoting when there are pointless one-liners that don't add any value, like "This post sucks" or "What was the author thinking?"; but not at all when someone has spent time constructing a chain of arguments.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by evgen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:34PM (#1021247)
You may think it a cogent and thoughtful response (and you might be correct) but others may disagree even though they do not have the time to spend in a point-by-point refutation of your thesis. Voting is a filtering mechanism, and by downvoting without comment we collectively filter out "noise" from "signal"; what those two terms mean varies from person to person and may in fact have wildly different meaning to the people voting up or down, but that seems to be the intended effect of the voting arrows. Sometimes just saying "no/yes, I (dis)agree with you" is sufficient and the site is better served by encapsulating these statements into up and down votes rather than encouraging the equivalent of "+1 I agree" messages you see on some mailing lists.

I do not visit HN to argue epistemology or ethics and have little use for back-and-forth discussions between two people that nest twelve layers deep and which you can see after the first exchange are never going to end until they grow bored talking past each other and move on to some other comment thread. I would much rather that these disagreements and conflicting positions are handled in a way that does not take up space for other interesting arguments or points of discussion -- downvoting without a reply serves this purpose.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by gruseom on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:14PM (#1021444)
You make two subtle observations that I think are worth emphasizing:

what those two terms ["noise" and "signal"] mean varies from person to person and may in fact have wildly different meaning to the people voting up or down, but that seems to be the intended effect of the voting arrows

It's probably the ability to aggregate these wildly different meanings in an interesting way that makes the voting system good.

Sometimes just saying "no/yes, I (dis)agree with you" is sufficient and the site is better served by encapsulating these statements into up and down votes rather than encouraging the equivalent of "+1 I agree" messages

That's exactly right.

In this whole area, less is more. Many of the objections and suggestions for changing it strike me as overengineering. Given that the site is the creation of an inveterate minimalist, though, I doubt we have too much to worry about. :)

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Friday January 01, 2010 @05:35PM (#1026371)
The simple fix that's been recommended quite a few times here, that of requiring a comment for each upmod and downmod, seems to me a reasonable and minimal fix that makes the user more judicious with their votes.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:49PM (#1021280)
If you don't have time to post even a single sentence in response "I disagree, particularly on point...", you don't have time to be reading the post anyways. Better to keep off the site entirely until you get some proper time.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by gruseom on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:06PM (#1021426)
I don't agree with this, and almost downvoted it for that reason, but to do so could only seem snarky in context, and that's not my meaning. I just disagree with what you said. Not with any particular point; with all three points, equally. Not in any interesting way, either: I just evaluate my time and whether I should be "off the site" differently than you apparently do.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:47PM (#1021497)
Even if you had downvoted me, by the simple fact that you provided some explanation (however minimal) is loads more engaging and interesting than providing an opinion, and coming back to see it scored at -3 or whatever.

I would understand the vote, and would still feel interested in engaging. I would view the downvote as a punctuation or an emoticon on your comment. Not a ricochet bullet in my living room.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by evgen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:15PM (#1021339)
I disagree, particularly on the point where you suggest that scanning through ten or twenty comments and being able to recognize and vote on those comments which are cogent/useful/correct and those which are not takes an equivalent amount of time to hitting the reply button, setting focus on the reply entry form, composing a well thought-out and cogent response, and then hitting the reply button. Perhaps if we limit ourselves to snarky two-sentence replies it might be possible, but it seems that the parent was requesting more thoughtful responses than you have afforded me in this case.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:27PM (#1021465)
>...to hitting the reply button, setting focus on the reply entry form, composing a well thought-out and cogent response, and then hitting the reply button

You forgot about "having to hit each and every individual key used in word formation in the correct order, some keys more than once (and a few several times), having to adhere to reasonable rules of grammar to string the words together into a sentence with meaning, and to remember to stay on topic and respond to the comment rather than slowly drifting off topic into a stream of consciousness, having to maintain visual focus on the screen while typing, and after hitting the reply button, waiting for the comment to refresh, and then another 30-40 minutes refreshing to watch my karma".

I think you assign far too much effort to the task of typing a single sentence.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Semiapies on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @06:48PM (#1023515)
Every single objection you make to downvoting can be applied to upvoting, including this one.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:21PM (#1023794)
I agree with you entirely except for one thing,

Downvoting without comment can do far more damage to conversation than can upvoting.

Imagine a real life conversation where you are speaking to another party, as you speak your mind, the other party continuously nods their head yes -- an upvote. You don't particularly feel the need to stop and ask "why do you agree with me?"

While on the other hand if, in the same situation, the other party started nodding their head no - a downvote, you would probably stop and ask them "why do you disagree with me?"

The conventions of this site essentially say that:

a) You can shake your head no, and the speaking party cannot ask why you disagree with them.

b) If the party asks why they are being met with disagreement, the response is the real world equivalent of a beating.

c) If you compare their negative, comment-less disagreement with any other similar situation, the response is a beating.

The result is that, after a couple exchanges like this, a typical person will not bother to speak their mind at all since they may end up with the online equivalent of a beating. Thus we end up with people that don't want to suffer the consequences of speaking out.

For example: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1014800

Upvotes are like cake, it encourages people to work for more cake. But people will similarly work to avoid a beating, and non-participation is the easiest path to do so.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Semiapies on Thursday December 31, 2009 @12:03PM (#1024530)
"Imagine a real life conversation where you are speaking to another party, as you speak your mind, the other party continuously nods their head yes -- an upvote. You don't particularly feel the need to stop and ask "why do you agree with me?"

No, I'd feel the need to politely excuse myself from that person's company. I have better things to do than blather on to bobble-heads.

"You can shake your head no, and the speaking party cannot ask why you disagree with them."

You can ask why you're downvoted. I've seen that asked and answered many times.

"the response is the real world equivalent of a beating."

The real world equivalent of a beating is a beating.

A downvote is not a beating. A downvote is a stuck out tongue, a disgusted look, a thumbs-down, or a shook head.

I can only assume you've never actually had a real beating or helped tend to the injuries of someone who's actually experienced a beating. Otherwise, I can't imagine why you would use such melodramatic terms to describe the mere act of strangers not following your personal protocols if they dislike one of your comments.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @09:22AM (#1025695)
> No, I'd feel the need to politely excuse myself from that person's company. I have better things to do than blather on to bobble-heads.

I'm guessing that you participate in remarkably few conversations then, since that just about characterizes every conversation I've ever had.

> You can ask why you're downvoted. I've seen that asked and answered many times.

No you can't, it's even mentioned in the guidelines. You'll also notice that requests like that are usually immediately downvoted, again without comment (or with a link to guidelines). Even requests on somebody else's behalf are treated like raw sewage.

Resist complaining about being downmodded. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.

> I can only assume you've never actually had a real beating or helped tend to the injuries of someone who's actually experienced a beating. Otherwise, I can't imagine why you would use such melodramatic terms to describe the mere act of strangers not following your personal protocols if they dislike one of your comments.

The melodrama does not end with me apparently ;)

What I mean by that image is that beatings are usually provided with little commentary, and if commentary is provided, it's usually of the epithet variety. I'm equating the downmod not so much to the beating I suppose but to the abject lack of reasoning as to "why the beating?". Beatings are usually rather senseless and provided without much reasoning.

A comment that's immediately downvoted several times without comment is certainly a comment that's being ganged up on. And I can tell you that when a gang of people has set themselves on somebody, there's usually not a whole lot of interesting conversation during the altercation.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Semiapies on Friday January 01, 2010 @04:40PM (#1026281)
"since that just about characterizes every conversation I've ever had."

As the words of wisdom go, "Smile...and back away."

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @05:52PM (#1026398)
...or perhaps I only converse with crazy people :)
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Semiapies on Thursday December 31, 2009 @12:14PM (#1024552)
"I agree with you entirely except for one thing,"

Then, more to the point, why don't you oppose voting in general on this site?

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @09:25AM (#1025698)
That's a fair question. I think upvoting tends to provide positive feedback and encourages discussion. Downvoting (particularly the uncommented variety) tends to provide negative feedback and discourage discussion.

The point of HN is to encourage discussion ergo, upvoting is, in general, in line with the point of the site.

I agree that upvoting can also create an echo chamber, but since it doesn't outright suppress contradictory voices, the effect is much less pronounced.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by dasil003 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:19PM (#1021209)
Just because you spent time constructing an argument doesn't mean it's cogent. In some cases it may be indistinguishable from a troll. But even conceding that popular opinion will tend to suppress valid arguments, I think it's just a fact of human nature that no community can escape no matter how much the members may pride themselves on their [relative] objectivity.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:45PM (#1021273)
There's a well known relationship between comment length and comment quality. In general, longer comment have more thought and effort put into them.

http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2009/09/29/comments_size_does_...

In other words, you can only snark or troll for so long; there's only so many ways to call somebody an idiot.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by dasil003 on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:25PM (#1022891)
what does this have to do with my comment?
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @02:39PM (#1023074)
It's in response to:

>Just because you spent time constructing an argument doesn't mean it's cogent.

I'm (perhaps mistakenly) equating time spent constructing an argument with argument length, since longer posts tend to take more time to write. It's also fairly well established that longer posts tend to be of higher quality on most message boards, and I'm equating cogent with quality (again, perhaps mistakenly).

time -> length -> quality, therefore invoking the law of transitivity time -> quality.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by boredguy8 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:19PM (#1021208)
Lots of words does not an argument make, and I'd bet often a downvote on a long post reflects that.

Nor does length equal quality: a good one or two line post can speak volumes more than a poor wall of text.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by NathanKP on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @07:18PM (#1021634)
The simple solution to that would be to require a comment if you are going to down vote. If you down vote you have to comment and say why.

Maybe that should be added as a feature for up vote to. To up vote or down vote you would have to comment. This would ensure that only people who were really serious about their opinion would vote at all.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by anonjon on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:21PM (#1021455)
I always take it to mean that a down vote is supposed to represent that the content of the post was off-topic, misinformed, or otherwise not useful or inappropriate.

I often up-vote people that I disagree with (or who are disagreeing with me) because they are presenting their argument in a way that is reasonable and intelligent.

Ex. I would down-vote someone if they started name-calling, I would not down-vote them if they had an opinion that I thought was wrong. Of course, this would be dependent on how good the argument that they present is, or if the opinion is intentionally flammable.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @02:52PM (#1021131)
100% agreed, it's used the same way here.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by RevRal on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:01PM (#1021300)
Your post is a martyr post.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Friday January 01, 2010 @05:37PM (#1026374)
This whole thread should be captured in time as an example of rampant abuse of the modding system.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:29PM (#1021236)
as just demonstrated at least twice.

edit lost track now it's down to -5....

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by CodeMage on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:17PM (#1021343)
I read what you proposed in your comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1013330

I agree with it wholeheartedly. The reason why I downvoted this particular comment here is because I really don't think that it adds any value -- you're beating a dead horse.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:03PM (#1021416)
edit btw, I forgot to mention that I appreciate you taking the time to read that overly long post.

And in this case, because you bothered to comment I don't feel bad. I feel engaged and I see your point. Not every post I make has a great deal of value, but I'd say that not every post anybody makes here has a great deal of value, even pg. Do they deserve a downvote? Not if the cost is that the poster will not bother in the future, we may loose valuable commentary because of that. And especially if the entire thread becomes contaminated because a downvote patrol has gone and tainted the entire thing, preventing other people from posting because they too might be downvoted.

But this is entirely different than my post a few levels up (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1021131), that's now down to -5 at last look, which is topical, in response to somebody else, laments the use of the downvote as a shorthand for "fag" isn't snarky, or rude, isn't spam, isn't overly lengthy, conforms to supposed community standards on being short (as several posters in this topic have brought up) etc.

By merely showing agreement with the repondant, I took I a -5 hit to my karma and absolutely nothing in response as to why a downvote in this case is not shorthand for "fag".

And the main problem is that I can't confront my attackers. Their downvotes are about as anonymous as you can get (anonymity can breed abuse). And the community standards also say that I can't question "why the downvotes?". It's not questioning the votes, it's asking for a reason. So there is absolutely no resolution to this.

From the downvoters perspective, theirs is an perfect crime, they have no repercussions for abusing the system, the victim has no recourse, and no defense, and cannot even ask why, they cannot even metacomment that downvoting appears to be becoming a problem without martyring themselves and getting more downvotes.

If by some happenstance that the victim learns the identity of the attacker because they bothered to post a response, they can't downvote the response and at least see some reciprocity (maybe at higher karma levels than mine you can, but I have no option for example to downvote your reponse). Basically they have absolutely no recourse. They can't even flag somebody who has it out for them and downvotes everything they post because they don't know the identity of their attacker. It's a system perfectly setup for abuse by habitual downvoters as we are now seeing.

It's at these moments that I'm saying to myself "you know what, fuck all of you I'm done here" even though I know it's just a handful of people that run around in a downvote patrol and do that kind of thing.

There's lots of ideas here about how to fix the brokeness of the voting system, here's another, people who habitually downvote, say more than 5 times a month, are no longer able to downvote, and must post at least 20 comments and receive +20 points before they can downvote again. Basically it should be a weapon with consequences.

My gut reaction to this absurdity is to disengage and forget the entire thing. To stop posting, and stop conversing and stop trying to find and contribute to interesting discussion in what is probably one of the better forums I've come across in a great many years. pg hasn't commented on this aspect of the system yet as I'm suspecting he's still observing and watching.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by CodeMage on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:21PM (#1021457)
Since the comments for this post have grown a lot, maybe you haven't seen PG's own comment. If that's the case, here's the direct link: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1021235
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by elblanco on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @06:01PM (#1021522)
Well, the good news is that pg seems to agree with the general consensus that downvoting is broken.

I'm afraid though that unless each negative tag is balanced with a positive tag, and the tag scores are provided, that we'll end up in a similar state we are now, only with more complexity.