Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ...
by anonjon on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:21PM
(#1021455)
I always take it to mean that a down vote is supposed to represent that the content of the post was off-topic, misinformed, or otherwise not useful or inappropriate.
I often up-vote people that I disagree with (or who are disagreeing with me) because they are presenting their argument in a way that is reasonable and intelligent.
Ex. I would down-vote someone if they started name-calling, I would not down-vote them if they had an opinion that I thought was wrong. Of course, this would be dependent on how good the argument that they present is, or if the opinion is intentionally flammable.
I often up-vote people that I disagree with (or who are disagreeing with me) because they are presenting their argument in a way that is reasonable and intelligent.
Ex. I would down-vote someone if they started name-calling, I would not down-vote them if they had an opinion that I thought was wrong. Of course, this would be dependent on how good the argument that they present is, or if the opinion is intentionally flammable.