News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chrischen on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:46PM (#1021495)
I didn't mean to suggest hiding the name so that we can't find out who posted the comment, but rather just making it more difficult. So you can still find out who wrote the comment, by clicking on the link to the comment, or perhaps requiring a mouseover.

I mean I can already see some problems to being able to see a name, and having that "communicate a great deal" just by the name. If the comment communicates a great deal, then why can't the comment stand on its own merits? It just seems that more people will be inclined to upvote because of the person who said it.

And I understand the concern about being able quickly skim and find notable experts replying. This is a potential problem with hiding author names. But I think some of this problem can be alleviated by the fact that better comments usually float to the top anyways.

Also perhaps this feature can be something that is only disabled after reaching a karma threshold?

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by roundsquare on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @12:15AM (#1021981)
I think your right if you assume that the argument is a self contained object. But a lot of times an argument draws on someone's experiences. In these cases, it can be useful to know who the person is.

For example, I remember reading earlier comments about the negative impact of working all night long on a start up. If I had said this, people would (rightly) ignore me. But if someone who has a startup had said this, it should carry more weight.