News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Pistos2 on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @05:10PM (#1021436)
I think a good system would be to have just two voting axes:

1) "worth reading" / "not worth reading" 2) agree / disagree

Then add a system of whatever flags you think are necessary, like "spam".

I treat the current voting arrows as if they meant (1). I vote up things that I think are worth other people's time to read; vote down things that are a waste of time to read. I very rarely downvote. In some cases where others might more liberally downvote, I simply don't vote.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by kburn on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:34PM (#1023812)
Even then, I think the scores for each should be bifurcated so that people can see the number of "worth reading" vs. "not worth reading" votes, and the same for agree/disagree.

I think the practice should at least be modeled liked a number-line. The default is 0, neither an upmod or downmod. Just as it is, an upmod (or +1) should be given if the post was particularly interesting (not agreeable, interesting), and a downmod (or -1) should be given if the post was particularly non-interesting (not disagreeable, non-interesting).

I think too many people only see the world as either +1/-1 with no option to just leave a comment alone.

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by Pistos2 on Thursday December 31, 2009 @12:51PM (#1024612)
To be clear, I thought it went without saying that marking agreement or disagreement would not count towards the worth-reading score, and that the two arrow pairs would not be accumulated into a single score. Two scores would have to be displayed, perhaps giving users the option of seeing only the worth-reading score.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by mtts on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @07:34PM (#1021653)
I treat the voting arrows as if they meant (1) as well, and in addition to that, if something is at 0 or worse and isn't in fact a waste of time, I'll vote it back up.

Downvoting something you disagree with kills a discussion, IMHO.