I strongly disagree with that. England and US not interfering in other countries would not have stopped other countries, most notably the USSR, in interfering with other countries. And the places where other countries, not England and US, had major influence, generally had much bigger problems with civil rights, freedom and material well-being.
A significant indicator in this respect is the need to build walls to keep in the population in a country, because otherwise it would flee (and then call this "anti-Fascist protection wall").
Your hyperbole about "puppet Nazi government" in Ukraine pretty much proves the point: the Poroshenko government, elected with rather clear majority in what is a relatively free election, does have its problems in corruption and whatever, but not any worse than the previous one, which was an actual puppet of Putin.
The EU has many problems, but being "Nazi like" is not really one of them.
I wonder why he hasn't mentioned the struggle of the people against the imperialist bourgeoisie.
Abandoning 45 million people to 17th century "spheres of influence" is extremely cynical.
The EU might not be great, but on its worst day it's better than Russia (in all its forms) on its best day. I really hope that Russia can prove me wrong. But 500 years of Russian history back me up.
If anything, I believe that the reaction was not aggressive enough and that the mild economic sanctions and ultimatums have been the only thing that prevented a serious escalation of the conflict, a conflict in which I must say, Russia illegally occupied a territory and created the rebels in the east, trampling on the sovereignty of another nation and they did so in your own backyard. This wasn't an ego fight, but a calculated move that would have happened regardless of the western reaction. Because lets be honest, Putin was losing in popularity, there's nothing like a new nationalistic drive to keep an impoverished population in line, plus occupying some territory, while teaching the neighbors what happens when leaving the party does have benefits.
I'm also disappointed, but my reasoning is different.
Sure I would prefer people to have European values over Russian ones (I'm very happy we just legalized gay marriage in Ireland for example), but not like this. Ukraine is much more Russian culturally than it is European, and if it came to a EU wide referendum I would vote against Ukraine becoming an EU member. I wouldn't be surprised if I am part of the majority in this opinion. The EU, a project I strongly believe in, is struggling to hold itself together as it is without pissing in the hornets nest. We need stronger ties with Russia, not weaker ones. Weaker ties only bring us closer to a hot war and that will help nobody. What happened in Ukraine was a microcosm of what could happen on a much larger scale if we do not act more subtly and inclusively.
In Comments
Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say in a face-to-face conversation. Avoid gratuitous negativity.
When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
Please bear this in mind for the future.
Memories seem to be short when it comes to politics. Timeline... Russia has historically strong ties with with Ukraine and a bunch of trade agreements. NATO make noise about Ukraine joining (dangerous provocation, imagine Russia got Mexico on board with military strategy) http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7312045.stm .... Yanukovych gets democratically elected (accepted as legitimate by international monitors... whether it was or not in reality I don't know so I will take this at face value. You can read the wikipedia on Ukraine Election 2010 for more infos).... EU push for trade deal that will bring Ukraine closer to Europe at the expense of Russia (despite all the marketing fluff about shared values, democracy, good governance that the EU like to roll out I think we are all smart enough to read between the lines. There is also a side story here in that EU were trying to slow the NATO expansion by stepping in first https://wikileaks.org/gifiles/docs/16/1653792_us-embassy-cab...).... Euromaiden happens after a tug of war between Russia and EU ... Yanukovych gets booted (undemocratically... it's ok when it suits us but not when it doesn't)... The likes of John McCain turn up in Ukraine to supports the demonstrators (wtf is he doing there?)... Russia invades the Russian parts of Ukraine and takes over.
I am a little biased in that I think peaceful methods should be pursued almost exclusively and I think the EU has been largely successful with this internally so far. Ukraine was a step too far. All parties involved in Ukraine acted deplorably and it pains me to see people taking sides based on a perceived moral superiority. I find it hard to buy into the good guy bad guy narrative when everyone is slaughtering each other left, right and center. Having a soft border, both geographically and economically, between the EU and Russia is probably best for everyone involved in regards to Ukraine.
So, we now know how much worth the NPT is in Russia's eyes. Nothing.
I believe this was simply because nazi is "national-socialist", which inconveniently rhymes with "international-socialist", which was the officially perfect doctrine of the Eastern Block. Therefore, "fascist" was the preferable enemy, even if it was the name of the lesser, Italian variant which was not quite as nasty and murderous.
You can see this in all sorts of memorials in Russia, as well as textbooks.
Nowadays there is less talk of international socialist, so Nazis have become a better term - perhaps because it is more useful in propaganda work in the West.
This was magnitude worse that British/American influence.
I am from Czech Republic, a former communist country. And it was nowhere as bad as Chile or El Salvador. Or, if you want just to compare Russian atrocities, occupation in 1968 was nowhere as bad as mass rapes in Germany after the end of world war, or Ukrainian famine, or Stalin's purges.
It's not just it's not black and white, it's not even one-dimensional. You can have regime without freedom of speech that puts couple tens people per year into jail (like Czech Republic in the 70s and 80s), or you can have a regime with freedom of speech that commits torture and war abroad, killing hundreds of people. To ask/answer which one is worse is meaningless.
And to compare it from economic perspective is just outright disgusting. Even if killing some people would indeed cause higher economic growth, no human should agree to such a trade.
First of all you are comparing third world countries like Chile or El Salvador with European countries that were doing well before WWII. At least Romania was. This makes your comparison flawed, because when a country is somewhat rich, with a working middle class, with somewhat working institutions, it does have the resources to spare and it will still be doing OK.
Because of the Molotov–Ribbentrop pact between Hitler and Stalin, we've lost territories like Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina to the Soviet Union, by force of course. And I must say that this was happening in 1940, with a Romania that hadn't entered the war yet. Russians later blamed us for giving support to the Germans on their invasion, but that's why they say you reap what you sow. Bessarabia is now the republic of Moldova. We still think of them as being Bessarabia, as Moldova is also the name of the adjacent region in Romania.
After the war, the soviet induced famine has hit us as well, but it hit Moldavians much harder. Hundreds of thousands of people have died of hunger and the official numbers are actually lower than what happened (my grandfather lived to tell me the story). But furthermore, we had to pay war reparations. And during their invasion on our territory, they've established what are called Sovroms, which were enterprises meant to deplete the resources of our country, with the effect that we've paid much, much more than the war reparations that were demanded. The soviets also mined us, for example we've shipped thousands of tons of uranium ore which ended up being used in their atomic bomb project.
In Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina the soviets did what Russians do best when invading a territory. They arrested, executed or deported to labour camps in Siberia hundreds of thousands of people and they also planted Russians on those territories, with the purpose of completely destroying their national identity. And this strategy of theirs does wonders. In the eyes of many Moldavians, the Russians are their "brothers" and Romania has had a "colonial policy" that has to be terminated. In return we've started granting them dual citizenship that has been their gate to the EU. We wouldn't have any economic benefit in an eventual unification of course, the difference between Romania and the Republic of Moldova being the difference between western and eastern Germany in the eighties. This is why Ukraine is so divided btw, as this is their usual modus operandi and anybody that says Russia's actions there are justified is either an ignorant or full of shit.
But back to the soviets, in Romania the result was poverty of course. But as a fun fact, even our former communist government was anti-Russian. For example at some point under Ceaușescu we declined to place our military forces under the Warsaw Pact's joint command and we also refused to increase our military expenditures. We also refused to side with Russia on several political conflicts. And Romania was actually isolated from the rest of the Eastern block. We were the pariah of the Warsaw Pact. Our neighbors had it easier.
But by far the biggest damage that the soviets did to us is the mentality, which is the cause for the corrupted system we've inherited after the communist block fell. We've been recovering quite well, but it's far from over, being much like cancer extirpation. And while our brethren from around our country are sometimes giving signs of missing the USSR, we don't. In fact that's the reason I'm proud of my country - we've always been at the intersection of empires, we're still here, we're still speaking a romance language and we hate everybody :-)
Moldova is bigger than just "the adjacent region in Romania", Moldova is that and Bessarabia together. What's in Romania now is Moldova without Bessarabia.
I strongly agree with "damaging mentality", but we don't hate everybody! Nowadays we don't resent anyone other than the russians (with their wishful "sphere of influence" over us), and I hope that that will pass too.
Not the best way to say "thank you" to the European Union -- not only do we have to suffer your Gypsies, we also get your Moldovans :(
(Don't put all the blame on the Soviets, the Ottomans didn't treat you so well, either.)
Also, we don't need to "thank you" dude, as the EU is not a charity, but a mutually beneficial arrangement. If it's not mutually beneficial, then we can negotiate, but don't give me this condescending attitude and we really don't have to apologize for giving citizenship to Moldavians or for having a gypsy minority. This is who we've always been and speaking of gipsies, we've been lectured for years in how we aren't doing a good job of integrating them in society. Well, here's your chance.
> (Don't put all the blame on the Soviets, the Ottomans didn't treat you so well, either.)
Yeah, no shit, we were amongst the ones that engaged the Ottomans in battle, helping in preventing their expansion into Europe. In 1475 for example our own Stephen the Great delivered what is said to be the greatest defeat of the ottomans until that time. He was then denied European assistance, yet he kept waging war until 1484. He was a Moldavian ;-)
I was myself only briefly one of those Gutmenschen until I got hold of better data (which I actively sought and which were contradictory to everything I was taught in University).
On the other hand, this is pretty plonk-worthy:
> but don't give me this condescending attitude
and, yes, you probably should apologize for letting random Moldavians into the Schengen area.
All of the states in the Holy Roman Empire did pay extra taxes to pay for wars against the Ottomans a few decades later.
Plus, because it seems to have slipped further down the list that the GP the Guardian ran a correction pointing out the article has no historical basis and the damage these incorrect allegations have done to Greece in plainly visible in the writing of the GP.
http://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/mar/28/readers-editor-...
For example, how sanguine should I be about the claimed non-violent, non-Stalinist goals of the revolutionary forces?
As I read it, the major claim of the article is that the British supported elements of the Greek state who had been collaborating with the Nazi occupiers in purging the EAM resistance. This does not seem to have been disputed.
For that matter, the use of the term "concentration camp", while accurate, is not provided the context to differentiate it from the modern connotations associated with Nazi death camps.
This isn't journalism, but historical propaganda.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_military_junta_of_1967%E...
In any case, justifying the application of violence with the possibility of preventing more violence some 20 years later is kind of outrageous.
"Greece was to be portioned 90/10 to the West, while Romania was to be divided 90/10 in favour of the USSR"
See more at: http://www.historytoday.com/blog/books-blog/taylor-downing/y...
> Greece has been for a long time a vassal state, British
> and American interfering in our political life down to
> very basic levels
"A long time" being 2,000 years, since ~ 146BC.Then the UK, France and Russia helped it become an independent country in 1830, an "interference" without which a Greek state may not have existed in 1947...
All for the egos of some politicians who wanted to feel important. The Pasoak leaders from the late 90's / early 00's should be ashamed of their short-sighted greed.
It very well might be the best thing for the long-term wealth of the Greek economy for it to exit the Euro and reestablish the Drachma, to better facilitate trade/labor growth with what would initially be the much more expensive Euro group. Manufacturing, generally, moves to places where labor and total production cost is cheaper, increasing the economic productivity of the region it moves to... this could only be a good thing.
They've reduced the status of the last three Greek governments to hollow bureaucratic institutions which rubber stamp Troika diktats. That is not anti-totalitarian.
There aren't many countries in Europe that can support the lavish social programme of the EU, yes Greece lied but so did Portugal, Spain, Italy, Ireland and many other countries.
There is just as much blame to be placed on the big financial players as onto Greece at this point.
Absolutely false. There is no record of national account abnormalities on any country other than Greece.
And the aims are clear - to unite Europe into one undemocratic state and remove individual countries and cultures.
And it appears to be completely controlled and driven by Germany.
If by "unelected dictators" you are referring to the council, these are ministers appointed by the democratic governments in the individual member states.
(One entire commission was dismissed in 1999, a candidate was not accepted a few years back -- I think she was from Romania. Might have been Bulgaria, though.)
I'd say that as quite good as democracy goes.
The EU is controlled by Germany, and its aims are to unite Europe into a single state. There is one winner in the EU project - Germany.
Hopefully in our lifetimes it will all collapse as the USSR did, and we will once again have a bit more freedom.
That is, by the way, true everywhere. In Western democracies, laws are typically initiated by a government who is not elected directly but formed by the parliament, based on who has a majority or who can come up with a working coalition. The the actual text of law is created, written, by civil servants who work for the government. It is reviewed by a number of unelected parties who propose changes. Then it is approved, or not, by the parliament. You cannot really say that you'd have "elected people creating the laws".
There are exceptions, of course; most notably the process in Switzerland where direct polls actually sometimes create laws and can even change the constitution. Elsewhere, this is uncommon.
European Directives have to be passed by the EP. You can't create European Law without directly elected MEPs.
Some people? Some people want to convert into a federal USE? It's there in black and white. Crystal clear. "Ever closer union".
You can oppose it all you like, but the people behind the project won't care one bit. The end game is a united states of Europe, with a single army, single parliament, abolition of individual state parliaments etc etc
Then when people have forgotten they'll just rename it United states of Germany. You can understand why those who don't win from a United states of Europe (Everyone apart from Germany), would associate it with Nazis.
The Lisbon treaty does not cover the same things as the TCE did, only a subset of which there was consensus.
It's ok to have a difference of opinion, but please keep your facts straight.
As it is, the comments about British and US interventions in Greece are illustrative of what I'm sure is a modern history of Greece less known internationally and are surely interesting.
Your debt ( Greeces) is like 177 times your GDP... And the politicans of the EU made the mistake of accepting greece in the European Union, because they all lied about there economic numbers.
Now you are dependant on the EU, yes, but you still have a lot of financial help. If you would have fallen without the EU ( sooner or later), there wouldn't be anyone to pay debts for you and forgive them ( partially).
I'm a Belgian and even every Belgian pays 1000€ for Greek financial support... And there are many other countries. Every European citizen is paying for the Greek mistakes. But i don't mind.
You still have to do a lot of yourselve, but it isn't our entire fault.
Stop blaming this on other things/people/instituations, it isn't a "one side has right" situation..
177% of GDP, which is 1.77 times. For comparison, Belgium is at about 100% of GDP.
> I'm a Belgian and even every Belgian pays 1000€ for Greek financial support
That money doesn't go to the Greek people. It's used to preserve the international banking system.
Stop lying. That money went to the Greek people. If the Greek people had not squandered their income for years on ridiculous levels of social spending and had maybe considered collecting taxes, they would now not need additional loans to “preserve” their local banking system.
Financial support "to Greece" now goes to the holders of those bad debts: mostly governments, the IMF, and the ECB.
I won't deny that there was pressue by other EU countries, but you make it sound like as if there was no other option for the greek people.
That money goes to the Greek treasury, which is run by the Greek government, the elected, representative administrative body of the Greek people.
These banks and other sovereign states hold debts that Greece issued in exchange for capital it needed to fund its national budget. Greece needs to make payments on its debt, unless Greece wants to ruin its credit and not be able to participate in international economic trade.
The money does go to the Greek people, but their elected government needs to generally be responsible and use the money to pay their national debts.
What a silly sentence to finish with. Does the Greek public support the government? Can you give me an example of what 'not supporting' would look like? Why are you combining millions of people in a sweeping generalisation?
This whole democracy thing (which I'm quite sure you know about) is a ugly blunt tool that allows the general public some vague influence on what their nation does. But most of these things happen due to self perpetuating systems that have been there for generations and which are invisible to the public.
South Korea is another US "vassal state". So is Taiwan. So were Japan and Germany after WW2. I'd say that the Greek problems have other sources.
As a Romanian I wish they traded Greece for Romania in 1944. So that you'd learn a painful lesson.
You are so lucky that Churchill got an agreement out of Stalin to keep Greece out of the Soviet sphere of influence.
Then the Americans came, who saved us from the "communists" and who openly supported dictactorships; dictaroships that challenged the basic human principles such as freedom of speech.
Unfortunately, Greece has been for a long time a vassal state, British and American interfering in our political life down to very basic levels. Even today, IMF, which is an American institution promoting privatization and looting of public resources, along with the Nazi like EU, govern our miserable life.
You need not go to far. Substitute the British actions of 1946 in Greece with the American actions in Ukraine supporting the puppet nazi government over there or supporting the so called "freedom fighters" of Jihad in Syria who have murdered thousands of innocent civilians.
The world would be a better place if England and US had kept to themselves and never interfered in other countries. But that would be asking a wolf to not kill a sheep if the wolf finds one.
What is worse, though, is that the British/American public support the governments, thus making them complicit in their crimes against humanity, which in essense, is quite tragic.