News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by bad_user on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @06:51AM (#10008888)
The "Nazi" label has been used by the communists, being their common and invisible enemy, the modern equivalent being "terrorism". For example all political opposition that they arrested, executed or deported during communism were labeled with Nazi, or the local variant. Labeling Ukraine's government as being a "puppet Nazi government" shows a clear bias to Russia, as that's were this nonsense came from.

I wonder why he hasn't mentioned the struggle of the people against the imperialist bourgeoisie.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by rorykoehler on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @10:55AM (#10010160)
Discussion around what happened in the Ukraine is generally presented as a false dichotomy. As much as I dislike Putin, his mafia style regime and everything it stands for, as an EU citizen, I'm embarrassed by how our (and the US) leaders acted. It was provocative and dare I say at a similar moral and ethical level to how Russia acted. I'm not sure it would have been possible to handle it perfectly given the situation but we handled it especially poorly. There was a possibility to take the middle road without unnecessary ultimatums and possibly by trying to instigate inclusive policies that straddled the line between Russian, Ukrainian and EU interests but instead the EU waded in with a heavy handed inflexible policy. It was clear that following the path we did would only result in violent confrontation and now that it has mostly settled down again I feel that the region is worse off and more fragile than before. All that death and destruction for what!?
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by oblio on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @06:04PM (#10013210)
To paraphrase a famous quote: "for Danzig". Some things are worth fighting for.

Abandoning 45 million people to 17th century "spheres of influence" is extremely cynical.

The EU might not be great, but on its worst day it's better than Russia (in all its forms) on its best day. I really hope that Russia can prove me wrong. But 500 years of Russian history back me up.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by bad_user on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @04:01PM (#10012432)
You're making it sound like what happened is the fault of Europe and the US. How could you possibly reach such a conclusion?

If anything, I believe that the reaction was not aggressive enough and that the mild economic sanctions and ultimatums have been the only thing that prevented a serious escalation of the conflict, a conflict in which I must say, Russia illegally occupied a territory and created the rebels in the east, trampling on the sovereignty of another nation and they did so in your own backyard. This wasn't an ego fight, but a calculated move that would have happened regardless of the western reaction. Because lets be honest, Putin was losing in popularity, there's nothing like a new nationalistic drive to keep an impoverished population in line, plus occupying some territory, while teaching the neighbors what happens when leaving the party does have benefits.

I'm also disappointed, but my reasoning is different.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by rorykoehler on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @10:26PM (#10014217)
If I recall correctly EU expansionism was the catalyst for all that happened.
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by ptaipale on Thursday August 06, 2015 @01:33AM (#10014727)
Of course you can call it "EU expansionism" if Ukraine slipping away from Russia's sphere of influence and making a trade deal with EU since it believes this will be in the long-term interests of its people. However, I believe in the right of people and nations to decide their own destinies. A "catalyst" is not a reason, nor is it a justification.
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by rorykoehler on Thursday August 06, 2015 @10:58AM (#10016875)
If you look at it from an entirely neutral perspective it is clear provocation. This has nothing to do with democracy. It is pure empire building and it is dishonest to dress it up as anything else. The terms of the trade deal were EU exclusivity and the termination of strong existing Russian ties. This is nothing but provocative. It's reckless and incendiary.

Sure I would prefer people to have European values over Russian ones (I'm very happy we just legalized gay marriage in Ireland for example), but not like this. Ukraine is much more Russian culturally than it is European, and if it came to a EU wide referendum I would vote against Ukraine becoming an EU member. I wouldn't be surprised if I am part of the majority in this opinion. The EU, a project I strongly believe in, is struggling to hold itself together as it is without pissing in the hornets nest. We need stronger ties with Russia, not weaker ones. Weaker ties only bring us closer to a hot war and that will help nobody. What happened in Ukraine was a microcosm of what could happen on a much larger scale if we do not act more subtly and inclusively.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by peterfirefly on Friday August 07, 2015 @06:12PM (#10025325)
If you look at it from an entirely neutral perspective it is clear you are an idiot... or maybe that's not actually such a neutral perspective after all?
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by rorykoehler on Friday August 07, 2015 @08:51PM (#10025888)
One of the reasons I enjoy this forum is because of the lack of the type of comments such as yours. This isn't Reddit. Under the guideline of the site, which I'm sure you have read due to it getting posted regularly (here's the link in any case https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), it states the following:

In Comments

Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say in a face-to-face conversation. Avoid gratuitous negativity.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Please bear this in mind for the future.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by peterfirefly on Saturday August 08, 2015 @11:24AM (#10027493)
I'm pointing out that your "neutral perspective" really isn't in a way you couldn't miss. That's all. I don't find you an idiot but I do find that you are strongly biased. Please refrain from that in the future and provide arguments and sources instead.
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by rorykoehler on Saturday August 08, 2015 @01:23PM (#10027955)
Well you could have phrased it more eloquently. Please feel free to elaborate on what a truly neutral perspective is.

Memories seem to be short when it comes to politics. Timeline... Russia has historically strong ties with with Ukraine and a bunch of trade agreements. NATO make noise about Ukraine joining (dangerous provocation, imagine Russia got Mexico on board with military strategy) http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7312045.stm .... Yanukovych gets democratically elected (accepted as legitimate by international monitors... whether it was or not in reality I don't know so I will take this at face value. You can read the wikipedia on Ukraine Election 2010 for more infos).... EU push for trade deal that will bring Ukraine closer to Europe at the expense of Russia (despite all the marketing fluff about shared values, democracy, good governance that the EU like to roll out I think we are all smart enough to read between the lines. There is also a side story here in that EU were trying to slow the NATO expansion by stepping in first https://wikileaks.org/gifiles/docs/16/1653792_us-embassy-cab...).... Euromaiden happens after a tug of war between Russia and EU ... Yanukovych gets booted (undemocratically... it's ok when it suits us but not when it doesn't)... The likes of John McCain turn up in Ukraine to supports the demonstrators (wtf is he doing there?)... Russia invades the Russian parts of Ukraine and takes over.

I am a little biased in that I think peaceful methods should be pursued almost exclusively and I think the EU has been largely successful with this internally so far. Ukraine was a step too far. All parties involved in Ukraine acted deplorably and it pains me to see people taking sides based on a perceived moral superiority. I find it hard to buy into the good guy bad guy narrative when everyone is slaughtering each other left, right and center. Having a soft border, both geographically and economically, between the EU and Russia is probably best for everyone involved in regards to Ukraine.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by ptaipale on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @04:25PM (#10012583)
What's more, Russia set a precedent of trampling down the nuclear non-proliferation treaty (NPT) - the Budapest Memorandum where Ukraine gave away its nuclear weapons in 1993 after USSR collapsed, in exchange for an assurance that others (specifically Russia) will "refrain from the threat or use of force against Ukraine’s territorial integrity."

So, we now know how much worth the NPT is in Russia's eyes. Nothing.

Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by barry-cotter on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @07:20PM (#10013566)
Don't forget that the US and UK both guaranteed Ukrainian sovereignty in exchange for that. The lesson from this and what happened in Libya after Gaddafi gave up his chemical weapons is left as an exercise for the reader.
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by ptaipale on Thursday August 06, 2015 @03:13AM (#10015005)
So US and UK should have been more aggressive over Russian involvement in Ukraine?
Re:Athens 1944: Britain’s dirty secret by ptaipale on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @07:33AM (#10009008)
However, I see a change here happening over the past two decades: before, the opposition painted by Soviets and puppets was usually "fascism". Now it is "nazism"

I believe this was simply because nazi is "national-socialist", which inconveniently rhymes with "international-socialist", which was the officially perfect doctrine of the Eastern Block. Therefore, "fascist" was the preferable enemy, even if it was the name of the lesser, Italian variant which was not quite as nasty and murderous.

You can see this in all sorts of memorials in Russia, as well as textbooks.

Nowadays there is less talk of international socialist, so Nazis have become a better term - perhaps because it is more useful in propaganda work in the West.