Drone Delivery - never going to work. Lots of solar power - too expensive. Autonomous cars - too risky
This is supposed to be a community of "Hackers" making cool stuff, and here we have a company talking about making cool stuff, and every single comment, without exception, is negative.
Yes, this is a very difficult problem to solve. Yes, there are many things they have not addressed yet. Yes, this needs a lot of work. No, they shouldn't just start doing this and see how many crashes happen. But yes, they need to keep talking, testing, learning and working towards a future where this is possible.
Does anyone in their right mind honestly think that in less than 150 years there will still be a single human-controlled vehicle (plane or automobile)?
Of course it's coming, and these guys are starting it. Now.
The same negativity could be said of the Wright brothers when they told people they were going to fly, or Henry Ford when he set out to mass-produce the automobile, or the people that said we'd have a global computer network and a computer in every home.
I honestly don't understand why the community here isn't more open to new ideas. Even ideas that never come to fruition are still worth analyzing. There is always something to be learned.
We should be talking about the interesting parts of this challenge and how they could be overcome, not saying "Not safe enough" Every. Single. Time.
</rant>
Most engineers are conservative and skeptical. If anything, as someone who is an aerospace engineer by education, I'm always surprised by the wild eyed optimism around here.
> The same negativity could be said of the Wright brothers when they told people they were going to fly
It could also have been said of the generations of idiots that jumped off cliffs to their deaths in flying machines that had no hope of working.
In any case, I don't think people are pessimistic about the technology. They're pessimistic about the ability of our social institutions to accommodate and manage the effects of that technology.
And it never ceases to amaze me how the tech community so easily blows off legitimate safety concerns.
You can't just "reboot everything" after a drone wipes out a Cessna or smashes a person's skull. Any drone capable of delivery is going to be big, powerful and not light.
Everybody thinks of drones as "cute little things" when a delivery drone is going to be more like a flying lawnmower like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5FqYiZb_5s
I seriously doubt any drone proponent will be dismissive of safety concerns. If there are people who don't care about the safety concerns drones bring, this is just the other side of the same coin with people so resistant to the ideas of autonomous vehicles. Both are people not forward looking in their own way.
When Amazon says, "hey we want to use drones," reactions shouldn't be, "hell no there's no way you can make that safe," and instead, "great idea, let's make sure there is a discussion at large to reach a consensus on the safety standards required to make that happen."
or may be a community of voyeurs who like to watch the Hackers making cool stuff?
That's because the HN community has a high bar, and most "new ideas" are bullshit (when it's not a rehash of failed old ideas shot down 100,000s of times, like "perpetual motion machines").
Partly I think this is people setting themselves up to be able to say "I told you so!" at a later time. You look less silly predicting a failure that doesn't happen than if you extol the virtues of an idea that later turns out to be complete hogswash under further scrutiny.
Though to put a more positive spin on it: critical thinking is a much neglected skill. Sometimes things genuinely aren't well thought out, and identifying and documenting a problem are the first steps to someone coming up with a solution.
You do realize that we don't even have clean water on a global scale?
The technology to filter and clean water has existed since the Roman era, but its implementation is highly dependent on political and economic factors (fun fact: western civilization didn't match the Romans' quality of water engineering until the mid-19th century).
The technology for automated cars could well exist in 150 years, and its implementation depends on the cycles of industrial production and consumption. It's likely that much of the western world will have automated transit in 150 years, because everyone will eventually get rid of their 2015 toyota for a model 2077 automated Tesla-google car.
You: You do realize that we don't even have clean water on a global scale?
I think the parent commenter's point was that it's pretty naive to think that there will be no more human-driven vehicles at all. Change will happen quickly in some parts of the world, and other parts will take a long, long time to catch up.
With automated transport, the early movers could absolutely dominate the future of transport.
I just looked at the live map for the SF area. A Temporary Flight Restriction over most of SF begins in 39 minutes, surface to 3000 feet, because there is a baseball game at the ballpark.
Autonomous drone operations in urban areas are going to be very tough to control. Drones are going to need their own airborne radar. Maybe only a hundred meters of range, but they're going to need to be able to see details down to power lines. This is available now, but needs more downsizing.[1]
What might work is a system where all manned aircraft have ADS-B (this is coming) and drones also have ADS-B and enough smarts to stay well out of the way of anything bigger. Drones also need short-range radar so they can avoid bumping into obstacles and each other. Think of this as "micro-see-and-be-seen'. It's a lot of electronics to carry, but less electronics than a smartphone.
This is more likely to work than some scheme where everybody phones home to Amazon's cloud.
[1] http://www.autonomoustuff.com/sms-radar-proximity-warning-sy...
As out of the box hobbyist drones can already travel at 50 mph [1] (or more I assume). And 100 meters assuming approach of a stationary object would provide just over 4 seconds for the drone to respond and avoid the object.
While 4 seconds is sufficient time, it will lead to drones flying very close to objects before avoiding them which will not inspire public confidence. Also as faster drones appear that window will become even smaller. They should probably have radar with a range measured in nautical miles to avoid having to implement a new system almost immediately. I would say at least 5 nautical miles, although I feel even that would be on the short sighted end of implementation.
The state of the art in radar is that sensing power lines and similar wires is not reliable. 77GHz radars employed in cars can sense people and bicycles, but that's not good enough. There's been much effort put into power line detection for aircraft (helicopters hit power lines about 50 times a year in the US) but no good solution yet. Drones zipping around streets with overhead wires and trees is not yet workable.
Having ADS/B or a variant of it for the drones would take care of that issue, as in 2020 every aircraft will require ADS/B.
Many will equip, but nowhere near all, and nowhere near enough to design a system that relies on every bogey having ADS-B out to avoid mid-air collisions.
Anyone touting ADS-B as a realistic solution for avoiding mid-air drone collisions in congested areas is severely naive in my opinion, at least based on current technology. My assumption is that those advocating for it in this context aren't actually familiar with its specs and how it works.
In aviation, separation between flying objects is usually measured in miles horizontally, and a thousand feet or more vertically, and the systems are based on that reality for the most part.
Some consumer drones use a radar altimeter to determine altitude AGL. The hardware is inexpensive. GPS is accurate for altitude in the US using WAAS (extremely small cost to use WAAS over traditional GPS).
> Anyone touting ADS-B as a realistic solution for avoiding mid-air drone collisions in congested areas is severely naive in my opinion, at least based on current technology. My assumption is that those advocating for it in this context aren't actually familiar with its specs and how it works.
Disagree. ADS-B was designed specifically for this circumstance (traffic avoidance).
Disclaimer: I have electrical engineering experience, a private pilot license with an IFR endorsement, and have worked on projects using ADS-B in production environments.
I think the only viable solution would be to have sensors on the drones themselves -- visual and perhaps low-power radar. That way they should be able to avoid other drones and helicopters. It might be necessary to limit operations to VMC, although that shouldn't be much of an issue at below 500ft (you're only really going to be shut down during fog).
ADS-B broadcasts contain a unique ICAO code, 6 hexidecimal characters filled in by the Transponder. The collision avoidance logic is handled by the TCAS unit on aircraft.
While new collision avoidance logic is being developed for unmanned vehicles in order to allow them to legally fly in airspace once the FAA restrictions are changed from see and avoid to sense and avoid, when it is released implementing it on an air frame will not be cheap, or light so will be reserved for larger drones. Think about 100k and 20-30 lbs in equipment for an ACAS-Xu Unit, Transponder, and antenna.
And because ADS-B is an internationally used system, changes like the addition of new messages to provide any other information commercial entities wanted their drone to provide would be unlikely to happen quickly if at all, as they would have to go through committee review.
I agree. We need to be critical of this idea because, as one of my design professors taught us, designers often "win" because they are the first ones to get their ideas out there and thus control the conversation.
I personally don't want anything dangerous or loud flying within a quarter mile of me. It's a cool hobby to do in a field, but those things in suburban or city environments could be looking into windows to see who's home, aiming bullets at kindergarten teachers or piling up C4 on a mall rooftop with next to no accountability or policing. Cars and people can do all the bad things I'm talking about, but there are license plates and cops. Looking at the frequency of attacks where non-traditional policing is the only option (e.g. online) tells us drone crime will be rampant, perpetrated by a spectrum of interests from foreign governments to financial crime syndicates, abusers and corrupt and paranoid politicians. All other dangerous networks like highways, runways and gas pipelines are tightly regulated. Drones belong in that category.
The real issue is that I don't want a drone highway over my house. If I don't want planes flying over my house, all night and day, I don't live by an airport. If I don't want traffic noise, I don't live by a highway. But if Amazon decides that 300 feet above my house is the best route for deliveries or some other logistical exercise, I have far less recourse than I would for a road or an airport.
I guess all the media and government fearmongering since 9/11 has been successful. When someone pitches a piece of tech, people now immediately think of how that tech can be used by Bad People to do Bad Things.
I would expect Hacker News of all places to not succumb to this type of irrational paranoia. But I guess we are all human in the end.
There is tremendous likelihood that regulating drones will lead to less crime. Banning drones within 1/4 mile of permanent residences and mall rooftops will prevent a large chunk of drone crime.
Banning drones from mall areas is not about "making it more illegal to put C4 there." It's about empowering the law and private citizens to forcibly remove drones from a dangerous areas to prevent drone crime.
If drones are allowed to buzz around malls, there are no police to determine if one of them is piling up C4 on the roof. If drones are not allowed to buzz around malls, as soon as one as spotted in a no-fly zone, it can be taken out to prevent a dangerous crime.
That much is covered in the diagram in the article: anything near an airport is designated no-fly for the drones.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_S...
Food for thought
It also has some real issues in that it's glossing over the challenges of steep terrain and obstacles. Most of our air navigation takes place by reference to MSL altitude (i.e. relative to sea level), but this is exclusively based on AGL (i.e. relative to ground level). Not an insurmountable challenge of course but it seems like they are skipping a lot of important parts. Same impression of the "real time data" plan, which sounds extremely complex in the context of aviation.
The overall impression is that nobody has really thought this through particularly, that this is more of a conversation starter at best.
(Relevant: I have a pilot's license)