News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by dang on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:13PM (#9886924)
Please don't start flamewars on HN. Perhaps you didn't mean to, but threads are sensitive to initial conditions and vulnerable to being derailed, and the trainwrecks that result are not at all what HN is for.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by whatshisface on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:41AM (#9884387)
It's true that all of humanity will benefit, but it's also true that a very specific subset of humanity payed for it.

Look at it from a purely practical perspective - it is absolutely unnecessary for anyone outside of America to like this program!

The American voting public took on all of the downsides of this program (the expense, mainly). They hold complete control over its existence, and the existence of many missions like it. Patriotism motivates people, and until we start frequently sending international space probes it seems pretty useful to me.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pavlov on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:49AM (#9884422)
Rosetta/Philae was a European achievement paid by the EU public, yet that barely gets mentioned. It's really a shame that the endless churn of downbeat economic news has overshadowed everything good that European countries are able to do together...

Maybe Europe would benefit from having a bit more American-style "rah-rah" patriotism around the good old "12 stars on deep blue" EU flag.

Nowadays it seems that we European citizens are constantly looking for reasons to argue rather than reasons to stick together, and that's a huge change from the positive European atmosphere of the '90s.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by scrollaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:42AM (#9884787)
> Maybe Europe would benefit from having a bit more American-style "rah-rah" patriotism around the good old "12 stars on deep blue" EU flag.

Something most americans don't understand is how repulsive blatant patriotism is. A lot of europeans, along with their nationality, have a sense of being "european", just like most americans have a sense of being "american" (rather than just "Californian" or what have you).

There's nothing wrong with being proud of your country (or continent). There's everything wrong with an "in your face, my country is better than yours" attitude.

If you're a citizen of any EU country, you can just go anywhere else in Europe, no questions asked. You're welcome, anywhere in Europe. I travel a lot. I move a lot (I've lived in several different countries in the EU). This is one hell of a wonderful feeling; and even though, by distances, EU countries are similar to US states... there's really nothing like being immersed in a completely different environment. The weather is different, the language is different, the customs are different.

Singing the national anthem in schools? Chanting "<country>! <country>!" whenever something cool happens which you want to be a part of? It's alright I suppose when you aren't constantly crossing national borders. When there's only [edit: realistically] two other countries on your continent. Nobody's going to be offended (well, nobody that will be able to tell you). But it's the last thing Europe needs.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by andor436 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:02AM (#9884931)
Have you never attended a European football match?!
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by scrollaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:09AM (#9884990)
Have you never attended any football match? I'm not sure this counters my point in any way. If I were to listen to my local club, the east side of my city is just so much better than the west side.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by andor436 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:20AM (#9885053)
I've been to plenty, and at the national level there is ample patriotism for one's country, regardless of nationality. I do agree with your point. I just don't think it's quite as clear-cut as you suggest.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by lmm on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:33PM (#9888797)
I have, and I feel like they bring out the worst in my people.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by snowwrestler on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:29AM (#9885115)
People chanting "USA" are literally not saying "in your face, my country is better that yours." I think if that's what you're hearing, you're bringing some personal interpretation to your hearing.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:06AM (#9885444)
What you seem to miss is that Americans chanting "USA" is so frequent and so common even in situations that wouldn't be considered to warrant any nationalism by anyone else that it's a point of ridicule by anyone else.

Case in point, this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhITpTtG888

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mturmon on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:47PM (#9886696)
I admit, that's laughable (and I did get an honest laugh, and upvoted you for the pleasure), but that was taken at Oral Roberts University, which is a fundamentalist college founded by one of the most notorious ex-Pentecostal televangelists my fair nation has ever produced. And that's saying something.

In other words, about as representative of Americans as a Le Pen rally is about French.

[Contra another comment nearby: due to the venue, I believe it was a genuine chant, not ironic, although probably a bit giddy. If it had been a more mainstream university, I agree, that would have definitely been a goofy ironic chant.]

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by jsmthrowaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:41PM (#9886648)
Please, keep explaining America to us. Most of the socially liberal Americans consider it just as ridiculous and it is regularly parodied in our media all the time. I especially love that you dug up an obviously ironic chant by college students at the presence of a bald eagle and cited it as if it meant something. The bald eagle is our national symbol and is so over-the-top American that I could see the joke immediately, but I guess I understand how it would be lost on a European. That you take that video seriously is hilarious.

There's something I could counter relating to certain European tendencies to explain the world to the world since certain parts of Europe still consider most of the planet as belonging to them, but I won't, because this isn't the thread or the place. Did everybody in this thread wake up today and say "gosh, I'm going to argue about America in a thread about Pluto, that's my achievement for the day"?

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by scrollaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:41AM (#9885204)
It's not what I'm hearing, and you probably missed my point. It's alienating and very shallow. Like I said, there's nothing wrong with being proud of one's country's, or a country's achievements. There's nothing wrong with being proud of your government, of your people, of your land.

But turn that into mindless yelling and that's just a pissing contest. It's ignorant of what other countries have to bring.

To give you a concrete example: I'm french. There's a lot of things I'm not proud of from my country. I'm proud of my language; French is beautiful. But I also make an effort to learn the language of every country I live in. I have fallen in love with Swedish. Had I been in a pissing match telling everybody (but mostly myself) how amazing French is, would I have gotten the chance to learn any other language? Would I have gotten the chance to even write my thoughts, in English, on this very forum?

This is a relevant example because, in France, a lot of people have that attitude of being too proud to learn another language. It's one of the recurring tourist complaints about France, in fact! I see this as no different.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Retric on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:27AM (#9885638)
If you have ever been to a high school pep rally; most people don’t actually care about the school. But, it’s fun to stand up and yell really loudly.

Nationalism is IMO deeper than that. To use a EU example, many people in Greece complain about countries that are giving them money. “How dare they attach strings when handing us money!!!” That’s nationalist in ways I have trouble understanding.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by david-given on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:07PM (#9885951)
Speaking as a UK citizen living in Switzerland, I have to ask: what is a high school pep rally?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Retric on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:10PM (#9885972)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pep_rally

It's really just a time filler to cover the gap between when classes end and a school game begins. Growing up in the US I think we had ~1 or 2 per year from ~8th-12th grade. They were also generally fairly short as in 10-15 minutes with I think one lasting 45 when the other team was late.

PS: Most games did not take place during the school day, but I think they scheduled a few that with a small overlap if a team would otherwise get home really late during a week night. I think there much more common in low density areas for this reason.

Edit: Though like all such traditions it's been morphing for a while. With some schools holding them before big events and or in the middle of the day.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by david-given on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:53AM (#9891985)
Frankly, that sounds pretty creepy --- it looks to me like an outright indoctrination session.

I couldn't imagine my school in Scotland doing anything similar (and we were a very sporty school, with compulsory attendance at a lot of inter-school games, which I mostly sneaked away from).

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mturmon on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:54PM (#9886758)
You are in for a treat. This excerpt from Fast Times at Ridgemont High (worth watching in its entirety) tells you what you need to know: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLTTugZ4BIw
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by bla2 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:07AM (#9884975)
I agree with all this, but note that he suggested chanting "Europe! Europe!", not "<country>! <country>!". That doesn't make it less blatant, but it does mostly solve the alienation issue you mention.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by kale on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:40AM (#9885195)
What continent are you referring to that has two countries? North America has 23 countries, with the U.S.A., Canada, and Mexico being the largest countries.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:01AM (#9885392)
Most of them are tiny island nations, everything south of Mexico is generally considered "Central America" by everyone else and everybody ignores Greenland (which is technically still kinda part of Denmark).

Comparing the 41(!) countries of North America[0] with the 58 countries of Europe[1] is really comparing apples and oranges.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_North_American_countri...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_European_countries_by_...

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by yellowapple on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:28PM (#9889206)
> everything south of Mexico is generally considered "Central America" by everyone else

Define "everyone else", because I certainly don't. "Central" America is part of North America; the dividing line is between Panama and Colombia.

Claiming that Central America isn't really North America is like claiming that the Middle East isn't really Asia. It's a geographically-ignorant statement.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by scrollaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#9885338)
Sorry, I meant two other countries and you're right; I have edited to clarify.

My point was centered on borders and neighbouring countries. Do you ever see US immigration politics talking about anything else than Mexico? Canada + Mexico + the US occupy something like 95% of the landmass alone.

Whenever you hear people talk about immigration in europe, we're talking about immigration from generally 5+ other countries, and often enough another neighbouring continent. Each of those countries are so incredibly different from one another it is very hard to put it in perspective with the US.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by jsmthrowaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:33PM (#9886588)
When we discuss immigration we are talking about immigration from generally the entire planet, including Europe. I can think of noteworthy discussion around Cuba, Asia, refugees from numerous conflicts, all of South America... we immigrate far more people and nationalities than you would ever dream because of historical status and in spite of our broken system.

We have an illegal immigration problem from Mexico due to conditions there and our border situation. However, countless people from South America flow though the same system by buying their way to Mexico first. That's the immigration politics you observe, because how to handle it is partisan.

This whole thread, which was extraordinarily stupid from the get go, is amounting to Europeans explaining the U.S. to the U.S. You guys are getting it wrong, too, your comments included. Who gives a shit about immigration policy? We are in a bloody thread about mankind's achievement in space. Christ, hang it up for one day.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:48PM (#9886708)
> Do you ever see US immigration politics talking about anything else than Mexico?

Yes, there's quite a lot of immigration politics around employment based immigrant visas and the dual-intent H-1B and related immigration issues, which is mostly not about Mexico.

Its true that much "immigration" discussion centers around addressing both the current population and the ongoing influx of unauthorized immigrants, where the majority are from Mexico (largely, as a result of an immigration policy based on country-of-origin based quotas, that has guaranteed that the countries that have the largest pool of otherwise-qualified applicants have the longest lines, and the fact that that Mexico, as a result, is one of the hardest places to immigrate to the US legally from, particularly in the family-based categories, while, because of geography, being one of the easiest places to immigrate illegally from.)

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by yellowapple on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:32PM (#9889217)
> Do you ever see US immigration politics talking about anything else than Mexico?

As a Californian: all the damn time. Mexico is the target of immigration debates because it's the U.S.'s immediate neighbor; most immigrants (legal or otherwise) from South and Central America either go through Mexico or take a boat.

North America differs from Europe only in the linear arrangement of nodes in a migration graph. In terms of origins, I reckon you're significantly downplaying the similarities.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by vilmosi on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:24AM (#9884649)
>>> Rosetta/Philae was a European achievement paid by the EU public, yet that barely gets mentioned.

I don't know man, I was reading quite a lot about it and loving every minute of it.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by saiya-jin on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:09AM (#9884548)
oh please, no american-style patriotism here in europe. I respect our american friends, but please, just... no. to give reasons would mean insulting probably more than few, so I refrain from that. let's say we're not all the same, we've grown up in different environments, and there are quite a few things I personally don't like in current US, and would not see many reasons to be proud.

that we have our own issues is true, just as everybody else out there, including US. personally I am proud of any european space achievement, especially since it's obvious how hard it is to do some coordinated international effort.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by adventured on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:25AM (#9884651)
You already have that exact same patriotism there.

Enter any thread, on any major forum online, and bring up any of the following topics: healthcare, crime rates, gun control, two party systems, standard of living, inequality, conservative religiousness. You'll be rapidly overwhelmed by bragging from Europeans, about how they're superior.

You can't get away from the boastfulness out of Scandinavia, Germany, France, the UK, the Netherlands - about how they're all superior to America on any given topic. I've yet to find a major forum where this doesn't occur.

I disagree that patriotism or nationalistic bragging is in any way uncommon in Europe.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by vilmosi on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:17AM (#9885035)
>>> You'll be rapidly overwhelmed by bragging from Europeans, about how they're superior.

Very few of those people are actually European. For one, nobody introduces themselves as European :)

I heard they're just American teenagers trying to troll people.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by EarthLaunch on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:41PM (#9888840)
I have a habit of checking the profiles of people who brag about how Europe is superior - such as by saying Europeans aren't posting such comments. You can try it; most are European. Such as yourself.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by vilmosi on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @04:21AM (#9890276)
Well obviously I made the mistake of not considering comments like mine as bragging.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by HarryHirsch on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:08AM (#9884983)
What if Germany, France and Scandinavia were superior to the US? The murder rate in the US is 3 times higher than in Europe, French banlieues are pretty harsh but have nothing on Northeast Philly, creationism is a non-issue on the Old Continent outside minor communities, and US healthcare is a total mess. I saw this video the other night about a team of physicians going somewhere near Bristol, TN. What's this? It's scenes you'd think you'd see in Africa.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by EarthLaunch on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:39PM (#9888829)
You're trapped either way. If being objectively superior is the criteria for celebration (or as you see it, bragging), then the US trounces any of those countries in space and can be celebrated. If superiority were irrelevant, then it would be fine for the US to celebrate also.

I think this view of celebration as bragging is your real issue.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by scrollaway on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:52AM (#9884856)
> You can't get away from the boastfulness out of Scandinavia, Germany, France, the UK, the Netherlands - about how they're all superior to America on any given topic. I've yet to find a major forum where this doesn't occur.

You do realize all these "boasts" tend to come from people who don't live, and usually have never lived, in said countries, right? Not to mention the whole Scandinavia deal which comes 99% from americans talking about it like it's the true land of the free, or something. Scandinavia's pretty great for a lot of reasons, don't get me wrong, but unless you're frequenting very nationalistic forums, poeple tend to complain about their country rather than boast it. The grass is always greener in the other country. (Except for Scotland. The grass is greenest in Scotland.)

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by arethuza on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:09AM (#9885471)
"The grass is greenest in Scotland"

That's a bit harsh - have you seen our weather, foodstuffs, national sporting teams or famously short tempers....

Of course, wouldn't surprise me if our grass wasn't rather green, but I refer you to our my comment about the weather!

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pygy_ on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:51AM (#9884846)
Usually, national pride > Euro pride.

Regarding the specific issues you raised, I may mention it, not out of pride, but just as concrete examples of things that work fine elsewhere and could work in the US, despite what some conservative folks would want you to believe.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by saiya-jin on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:13AM (#9885011)
ok you got me there, due to my bad wording. I am not specifically proud of European achievements (although our bureaucracy can be spectacular, so it's even bigger achievement in my eyes), if China/India/Russia/whoever would be doing some successful novel space exploration missions, I would be proud equally. And by same logic, same is valid for US (and this mission).

It's just that I long consider myself citizen of this world, rather than citizen of some pre-marked real estate, which was different 500 (or even 100) years ago, and will no doubt change beyond recognition many times in future. patriotism goes in direct opposition to this belief, bringing "us and them" mentality (with obvious emphasis that "us" is better), which I personally believe isn't something to be proud of and strive for in 21st century. Bear in mind this is my personal opinion, I don't represent all citizens of Europe any more than you do represent all US citizens :)

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by user_0001 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:43AM (#9885226)
Please link to a video showing a group of people from the UK chanting

"N-H-S N-H-S" *

*NHS - National Health Service for the UK

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by nsxwolf on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:56PM (#9887219)
Not quite what you asked for, but "Save our NHS, it is the best!"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BB5tJNJSER4

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Thriptic on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:10PM (#9885970)
> and there are quite a few things I personally don't like in current US, and would not see many reasons to be proud.

As an American, I agree that we don't have much to be proud of lately, but I think that's why it's especially important to rally around achievements like the success of our space program as citizens. Despite how it may appear from abroad, the US is more divided than ever at home, and our government pursues policies that many of our citizens don't agree with. It's very, very rare that we can all get together as citizens and be truly proud of something our nation has done, and it serves as a way to build good will between people who normally would never come together. Please don't try to take this away from us.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by grkvlt on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:22AM (#9885590)
> Rosetta/Philae [...] barely gets mentioned

There was huge news coverage of the initial landing, and the amazing images. Then, when contact was re-established, there was another burst of coverage - so much, in fact, that many friends who ordinarily have no interest in space or science would mention it to me as a 'pub conversation' bit of trivia. I was actually very pleased with the coverage of the Rosetta/Philae mission, modulo the shirt issues, and I hope more space science gets that kind of exposure.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by oh_sigh on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:40AM (#9884770)
Rosetta/Philae was all over the news a few months ago. Not sure what news sources you read but I saw it everywhere, including cool animations about their lander
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pavlov on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:34AM (#9885149)
Sure. But did you think of it as a European achievement? That's what I was getting at.

When news media talks about European integration, it's always with the "Greeks are lazy, Germans are stuck up" style angle that tries to play up national stereotypes.

Rarely do we get to read about Europe as a group of people that get together to put spacecraft on comets, and the EU as a project that has brought 70 years of peace to Central Europe for the first time since the Roman Empire.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:21AM (#9885576)
To be frank, across the whole lot of NASA, ESA and even the Indian, Chinese and Soviet space programmes, I had never once seen any achievement as an achievement for anyone other than all of mankind. More than forty thousand years of human civilisation have lead us to where we are -- even if it's a team effort by people alive today, they're standing on the shoulders of millions of giants and they're achieving this for all of us, living or dead as well as all future generations to come.

This is actually why I never warmed up to Star Trek "Enterprise" (Captain Archer and friends) -- it basically presented itself as "Americans in Space", starting with the intro's repeatedly showing (exclusively) American flags. All the other shows didn't waste much time on modern nations because those were something mankind had outgrown: it wasn't even "us humans" anymore, the Federation spanned different species just like the UN today spans different nations.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Zirro on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:54AM (#9885332)
Such sentiments are only rarely or not at all expressed in any news I consume. While some media are intentionally sensationalistic and some others aggressively push an agenda, I find that they can easily be avoided with some critical thinking.

To give my answer to your first question - yes, while I did think of it as a European achievement, being impressed that so many countries can come together for a common goal, I was more impressed with it as an achievement for humanity as a whole.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mattlutze on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:37AM (#9884741)
Rosetta/Philae were all over the news here in Germany for weeks before and weeks after the approach, landing, etc. Once again here as they came back into communication.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by moron4hire on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:27AM (#9885102)
Barely gets mentioned? WTF news outlets are you reading that you got New Horizons but not Rosetta/Philae?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pavlov on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:35AM (#9885158)
It's the European angle that barely gets mentioned; see my reply to oh_sigh.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by moron4hire on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:06AM (#9885442)
I think you're falling victim to confirmation bias. I've seen lots of talk about ESA in relation to Rosetta, with a lot of pictures of ground crews cheering.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by brlewis on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:29AM (#9885117)
319 million people spending $650 million[1] amounts to $2.03 per person. I probably paid more than average taxes, but I don't feel like I can claim more credit than, say, the Yuan dynasty of 13th-century China and its contributions to rocket science.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Horizons#Mission_profile

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by fit2rule on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:26AM (#9884662)
>The American voting public took on all of the downsides of this program.

True. But the rest of the world bears the brunt of American liabilities.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by benkuykendall on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:29AM (#9885122)
Sorry, could you explain this a little further? As an American, my income taxes seem to be pretty solid evidence that I am bearing American liabilities. Especially in a case like space exploration, where the only cost is monetary, I don't see how a burden is being placed on anyone save the taxpayers.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by fit2rule on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:47AM (#9885247)
America can't survive without war. Where do you think it wages those wars?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Trombone12 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:29AM (#9885652)
You might remember the government shut down of 2013 and its relation to the debt of the USA?

Although according to wikipedia the rest of the world owns about half of the american liabilities.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mempko on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:15AM (#9884586)
It can be said the people of the world payed for it given American imperialism abroad. All the reparations countries pay might have contributed...
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by maratd on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:24AM (#9884647)
Do you even know what the word imperialism means? If you're European, it would be quite appalling if you didn't.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by tptacek on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:02AM (#9884930)
Thank you. Thanks to your insightful comment, instead of discussing Pluto and New Horizons, we have an entire thread dedicated to discussing whether "U-S-A!" is toxic jingoism, and because you got so many replies, no amount of downvoting will fix it.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Pyrodogg on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:01AM (#9885389)
This is one of the biggest reasons why HN needs thread folding. Once the first-loudest voice catches on, it's hard to see the rest of the discussions without distraction.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by smackay on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:22AM (#9884277)
"This necessitated aiming New Horizons at a "keyhole" in space just 100km by 150km (60miles by 90 miles), and arriving at that location within a set margin of 100 seconds."

That's pretty damned impressive by any standard you care to mention so go ahead, "U-S-A" yourselves a few more times. I think it was earned.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by sabertoothed on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:30AM (#9884324)
You do not seem to have understood his / her remark. He / she was not trying to diminish the remarkable achievement nor questioning the celebration of this success. But the jingoistic way it was celebrated.

EDIT: Why do I get downvoted? I was merely explaining OP's point of view.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by snowwrestler on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:52AM (#9884436)
Can someone express pride in their country without being jingoistic? I think so. Jingoism usually connotes aggressive foreign policy, militarism, and extreme bias on top of pride in nation.

I don't see the bias here--New Horizons is legitimately a project to be proud of.

On the other hand, it's arguably pretty aggressive to accelerate a machine to over 13 km/s and send it inside the orbit of a planet's closest satellite.

On the gripping hand, Pluto's government hasn't complained, so why should you?

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by bullsbarry on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:33AM (#9884340)
Yes. We must make sure to reserve such celebrations for truly important things. Like the World Cup and Olympics.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by nothrabannosir on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:40AM (#9884381)
Assuming you're being sarcastic; those are actual competitions between nations, by design. His entire point was that this is not a competition. Obviously, if it were, America would be winning. That's not being contested; the problem is not that the US won, the problem is that by continuing to beat the rest of the world over the head with it they are alienating a large chunk of the world.

The Art Of War, and all that.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by happyscrappy on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:51AM (#9884429)
Are Europeans so hypersensitive that the we should ban celebrations at NASA?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by saiya-jin on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:18AM (#9884606)
patriotism in such things as space exploration is laughable, however reasonable commercial reasons behind it are (well described in another post). seeing logic "usa reached pluto" instead of "mankind reached pluto" is a bit sad, and i don't care if it's US, China, India or Monaco spacecraft. it just feels as wrong and antiquated view of the world... but maybe typical to generic US person? (no clue really)
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by rimantas on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:52AM (#9884855)
Maybe you don't care, but I am sure that people in US, China, India or Monaco care a lot. And this is a normal view of the world.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by saiya-jin on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:19AM (#9885047)
well if they care, you shouldn't be then surprised that this approach would go against the fur of quite a few people (safe to say more than 1000% of US population?). and since even people with different mindset, like me, find it a bit distasteful and unnecessary, not-so-positive reactions are to be expected. btw welcome to the internet, where people complain about stupid things, all the time :)
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Zirro on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:05AM (#9884519)
Why, out of all parts of the world, do you bring up Europe specifically?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by adventured on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:37AM (#9884363)
Because every other country on earth isn't known to take deep pride in their culture and national accomplishments.

What's the disagreement exactly? That they cheered for their country? It's ok at a FIFA match, but not for something drastically more important? Subjective bias at its worse. When I see that attitude about something like this from non-Americans, it reeks of other countries feeling intimidated and jealous because they're not even on the same playing field with the US when it comes to space. It's nothing more than ugly envy.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pavlov on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:28AM (#9884310)
I imagine they do that embarrassing routine so that American TV channels would report on their achievements.

If they stick to science, Fox News won't mention it. And if Fox News never mentions NASA, then people get upset about spending their tax dollars on an organization that seemingly does nothing...

In Russia, you have to remember to thank Putin. In USA, you have to remember to wave the flag with sufficient enthusiasm. It's the same thing -- Russians just prefer personified nationalism while Americans rally around abstracted symbols (flag, original text of the Constitution, etc.)

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by thatsone on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:40AM (#9884765)
I remember reading that this spacecraft would not have been launched without a Russian rocket engine, and that the plutonium fuel also came from that country.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by TeMPOraL on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:26AM (#9885097)
Well, to be honest, if we were to treat vendors as contributors to projects, the entire world would owe almost everything to China.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:27AM (#9885629)
... which we do. Your point being?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by moistgorilla on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:47AM (#9885791)
We owe nothing to China considering we pay them
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @04:40AM (#9890331)
"Owing" something is not always about money. "The West" owes a large part of its wealth to Africa and Asia. It's a team effort, not just a business transaction.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 16, 2015 @07:44AM (#9896571)
True, but I meant a particular subset of "owing" in which you consider which parties are directly responsible for some event. Paid out vendors are usually not considered the primary parties.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by aaron-lebo on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:56AM (#9884452)
I'd guess most of the posters here hate jingoism. I'd also venture to say that most of us find the typical USA chant really boorish.

But if this (exploring space) is the result of jingoism? Give us more of it. Seems like a really minor thing to get worked up about.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by cromwellian on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:32AM (#9884705)
If you want the American public to increase funding for NASA instead of cutting its budget and spending more on wars, maybe it's good to let them run up the scoreboard and slam the football on the field. It is hard to convince the public times of economic trouble to fund missions like this is felt out of fear or national pride.

In an ideal would people would support it for science alone, but we don't live in that world.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mseebach on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:05AM (#9884512)
Welcome to the Internet. Where even the greatest scientific achievements are eclipsed by the politically incorrect slights of those responsible. (See also: The Rosetta-shirt).

Also, jingoism: "the feelings and beliefs of people who think that their country is always right and who are in favor of aggressive acts against other countries".

Get. Over. Yourself.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by dombili on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:26AM (#9884663)
I wouldn't go so far as saying it was appalling, but it was in bad taste. No one doubts Americans are ahead of everyone else in terms of science and exploration, so they certainly deserve to celebrate however they want, but science and exploration are beautiful and inspirational because they're borderless and bring humanity closer, even if it's for a short moment. I'd have preferred them not to chant U-S-A and wave flags during the flyby, because that short moment is at its peak when the flyby is happening and everyone around the world share the same curiosity and happiness by watching the stream live, but if that's the way they want to celebrate, that's the way they're gonna celebrate. They deserve it.

On a side note: I completely disagree with people who compare this to the World Cup or the Olympics. The whole idea of those competitions are nations competing with each other and science and exploration is not about the achievement of one particular nation, rather the advancement of humanity.

None of this means that we should take any credit from NASA or the American tax payers. Everyone should be thankful and I am.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by lukeschlather on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:11AM (#9885000)
I think everyone talking about this as in bad taste isn't looking at the big picture. What if we could take all the energy people direct at the World Cup and redirect it towards space exploration? I mean seriously, the World Cup's budget this year is roughly 15 billion, NASA's budget is 18 billion.

I think part of me would prefer a calmer, more civilized approach to space exploration, but on the balance I'll take twice the budget if I can get it.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:33AM (#9885681)
If populism is the focus, why not just do what the US always does and declare War on Space so you can send troops to look for space terrorists?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mason240 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:35AM (#9884726)
Just like with Rosetta, there are always people eager to tear down the accomplishments of others.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pi-rat on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:34AM (#9884346)
I agree, though I get that they're very proud. I think it's a major achievement for humanity.

Humanity has now sent probes to every of our original 9 planets (poor pluto..), we've sent probes into interstellar space. We've landed on comets. We've a permanent international presence in orbit onboard ISS. We're talking manned missions to Mars. We're commercialising space flight.

At this point it's about humanity, not countries.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by Dirlewanger on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:48AM (#9884823)
Jingoistic? Do you know how to use that word? Quit the hyperbole.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by pluma on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:34AM (#9885695)
Jingoistic, Adj. See everything the USA does.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by 7952 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:57AM (#9884458)
These kind of missions need public support top hopefully maintain funding, and a little patriotism could help that along. If flag waving helps planetry science then I am happy to play along.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by hashmymustache on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:50AM (#9884838)
When universities celebrate their faculty member winning a nobel prize, is that an appalling eclipse of the work's broader contribution to humanity?
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by chasing on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:19AM (#9884614)
Some excited researchers expressing their joy at one of the greatest scientific accomplishments of the age "was one of the most appalling, jingoistic, alienating spectacles [you've] ever seen?"

You, sir, need to watch the news.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:08AM (#9885461)
"was one of the most appalling, jingoistic, alienating spectacles I've ever seen." If no one died, then that is demonstrably not true.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by jasonkostempski on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:59AM (#9884914)
I'm American and I cringed the second I heard that too but I noticed they stopped pretty fast, I suspect the few people that did it got caught up in the moment and then quickly realized they might sound a little foolish. Or someone in the crowd gave them a dirty look.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by acheron on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:06AM (#9884529)
Your xenophobia is unwelcome here.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by ajross on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:22AM (#9884634)
If we can't cheer for our country over this, then when would it possibly be appropriate? There was plenty of cheering ("jingoism") about Rosetta too, as I remember. And it was just as appropriate.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by user_0001 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:50AM (#9885284)
The US is still a young country. They are currently in their (perhaps declining) outward expanding imperial militaristic stage. For this, excessive patriotism is required, is absolutely necessary.

It has been the same for any outwardly expanding empire, from the British, French, Spanish, German in more recent times back to the Roman / Greek days.

The first rule for near constant warfare, get the flags out, get the crowds chanting....

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:11AM (#9885483)
How is Germany older than the US? Unless you mean the Holy Roman Empire and its various entities that made it up.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by mynameisvlad on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:20PM (#9886971)
Why is this even downvoted? He's correct. Germany, as a country, was first established in 1815 with the German Confederation. The US confederation predates it by 34 years. The parent comment already mentions Romans, so you can't count the various Roman tribes collectively known as Germania under "Germany".
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by jasonlotito on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:09AM (#9884546)
Monumental achievement in science and in space, and you make it about war. Grow up, indeed.
Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by outworlder on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:11AM (#9885493)
Yeah, that's an immense cultural shock for everyone not in the USA.

I'm not surprised by it, but it feels... out of place. If anything, they should be chanting "NASA", as not all of the USA is onboard with the space missions.

If overt patriotism is what's needed to get more NASA funding, then so be it.

Re:New Horizons: Nasa spacecraft speeds past Pluto by namuol on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:56AM (#9884453)
When the public (read: the political body) needs to be convinced that this kind of exploration and research is worth the money, then a little nationalism is bound to creep in.

It's brown-nosing, at worst.