News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by onion2k on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:48AM (#9817389)
One of the first pieces of advice I had when my company landed its investment was to pay ourselves a decent (not extravagant) wage so that my time went on worrying about the company rather than how I was going to afford to do things in my personal life. The same is true for employees - if they're paid a good living they will spend more time on thinking about problems in their job instead.

If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off - people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford their rent.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Fuxy on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:37AM (#9817558)
I would wager there will be people who will take advantage of the system and use it as a opportunity to not work and laze around all day however those people will be the one who are not particularly productive in their work anyway.

They might find something else to do they might not but that's OK it is an acceptable loss.

On the other end companies which used to take advantage of the job market and the fact that everybody needs a job to survive will have a hard time to find employees since now people can afford to be selective.

When survival is off the table nothing is more important than enjoying your job since you spend a great deal of the day doing it.

Another possibility is part-time work being more sought after since some people may want to work but wouldn't like to spend 8 hours every day doing it.

Overall i believe it will have a positive effect on society if you don't get hung up on the fact that some people will take advantage of it which most politicians tend to do even with the benefit system in the UK.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by uhwhat on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:02AM (#9818081)
I imagine partitioning living NEEDS [housing, food, transportation] as an area of the economy with its own money/token/basic-income-credits system separate from the WANT economy of everything else.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tarblog on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:12AM (#9819418)
Maybe, but there's strong evidence (from the field of macroeconomics) that allowing people to just receive money (rather than payments in kind) makes them even better off. Although you may fret about people using the money for bad things, in reality mostly they don't, but they are better at allocating resources than a central planner. Think of it this way, to the citizen who actually wants to be better off, would you rather be able to cut your spending in order to make a smart investment or not be able to do so?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Lawtonfogle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:27PM (#9821395)
They can also better fit their own needs. Maybe a smaller worse shelter wouldn't be an issue for them, but they would much prefer to have warmer clothing (smaller and warmer in comparison to peers in the same location). Maybe they forgo milk to buy even more lentils.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pjlegato on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:24PM (#9821024)
The problem is the intractable dispute about what things should go into which category. Empirically, there has been a strong historical tendency to move things into the "NEED" category that were traditionally in the "WANT" category.

For example, indoor plumbing was considered a grossly extravagant luxury for almost all of human history. Within the last hundred years, the richer societies have made laws (building codes) that have switched it to a "NEED". The same thing happend with indoor heating systems.

As for food, most medieval European peasants considered themselves lucky if they got a bowl of thin gruel every day. Asian peasants thought they were lucky to get a bowl of rice. Many didn't get anything on many days. Now in the US the government is talking about "food deserts" and shifting many previously "luxury" fresh nutritious foods into the "NEED" category.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:20PM (#9821355)
>For example, indoor plumbing was considered a grossly extravagant luxury for almost all of human history. Within the last hundred years, the richer societies have made laws (building codes) that have switched it to a "NEED". The same thing happend with indoor heating systems.

Yes, we rather do like preventing dysentery, bubonic plague, and flu epidemics. Public health is indeed a necessity rather than a luxury.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pjlegato on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:32PM (#9848549)
This is precisely my point. For almost all of human history, public health was indeed a luxury rather than a necessity. In many parts of the world, it still is today.

The details of a specific proposal are not relevant. No matter what specific items you choose for these categories, eventually people will want things you say are "extravagant luxuries" and call them "needs".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by sbov on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:37PM (#9821456)
Progress will always shift things from "WANT" to "NEED".

If you want to play that game living past your 30's is a "WANT" rather than a "NEED". You probably won't find many people who think this particular "WANT" isn't a "NEED".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pjlegato on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:35PM (#9848567)
"Progress" is a nebulous and heavily opinion-based concept. It is not a well defined factual, monotonic process whereby society invariably moves from "bad old ways" to "better new ways".

This is not a game, and I'm not arguing the merits of any specific proposals. It's an empirical analysis of what has actually happened in world history.

Things you think are "needs" today were considered extravagant luxuries for almost all of history, and many of the things you personally view as luxuries will be called "needs" by others. Thus, the parent comment's plan to divide the economy into "wants" and "needs" is not tractable, since these categories are both shifting through time and also heavily disputed from one person to the next at any given point in time.

I am not arguing in favor of this arrangement. I'm pointing out that that's simply the way it actually is, regardless of our personal preferences or judgements of the situation.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ghthor on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:52PM (#9822276)
What if items from the WANT category are moved to the NEED category when either 1 of 2 things are met. It's empirically shown to improve the health of the owners. Or it's possible to create the item for everyone on earth, meaning we have the resources/manufacturing without harming the biosphere.

With these 2 rules we should see a steady increase in QoL for everyone.

The main problem with the whole idea is that it is inevitable that an exchange rate will be set and they will be traded. What does a NEED collector do with the collected NEED currency?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by clavalle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:05AM (#9819352)
I've thought about this, too but I can't figure out how you'd prevent those tokens from being bartered for more traditional currency outside of the necessary conversion by landlords and grocers and other providers.

With ubiquitous computing now available to everyone we might be able to fully track that sub set of transactions with 'currency with state and history' as opposed to traditional 'dumb dollars' but I think it would be a hard problem getting it to play nice with the traditional currency economy.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Lawtonfogle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:31PM (#9821412)
It won't. The more industrious will barter at a gain while others will barter at a loss. Consider food stamps. Some will trade them $2 of stamps for $1 of cash. But others will buy food, cook and then sell the food, bringing in $2 dollars of cash for $1 of stamps.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by uhwhat on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:06PM (#9822038)
Food stamps are a decent example. It's not perfect yes, but it basically becomes undesirable to trade the cash of the WANT economy for the goods of the NEEDs economy.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Lawtonfogle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:24PM (#9821376)
Is physical intimacy (no, this doesn't mean sex, though that is one form) a want or a need? Consider the mortality rate of infants who receive no physical touch but have all their classical needs met compared to infants who are held and cared for.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by budu3 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:22PM (#9820632)
How will you deal with inflation? Wouldn't the sudden influx of many cause the price for basic goods, rent etc to go up?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Silfen on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:27PM (#9820672)
If you pay for basic income with tax dollars, it will (theoretically) cause no long-term inflation.

See: https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rconti on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:03PM (#9821265)
Thanks. I need to read this when I have the time -- my initial reaction (from skimming) is that it keeps insisting that increasing money supply does not cause inflation because of the Fed pumping money into the economy, and giving it to investors who are not spending it.

Giving it to the poor, who have a higher marginal utility for their dollars, should cause more inflation than giving it to the rich. Again, from skimming, they seem to mention the idea of it being more useful for the poor, but dance around actually addressing it directly.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mikehawkins on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:56PM (#9820848)
Thanks for including the source - that was my question as well.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TTPrograms on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:31PM (#9820698)
Inflation doesn't necessarily follow. If everyone was given a 10% raise then you would get inflation, but a fixed distribution results in a very different effect. One possibility is that people would purchase roughly the same amount with the lower classes having free time to educate themselves rather than working minimum wage jobs. I mean, I can't imagine somebody throwing their lives away just to buy another loaf of bread or bottle of milk every week.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by cmdkeen on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:00PM (#9820883)
What incentive do they have to educate themselves? After all they currently had an incentive to educate themselves during their period of compulsory education yet still ended up working in a minimum wage job they value so little they'd quit if they were given a minimum wage.

You don't see masses of low waged workers in countries with maximum working hours (and thus some leisure time) educating themselves.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jfoutz on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:36PM (#9821096)
The modern economy is hit driven. 1 J. K. Rowling pays for a lot of not J.K. Rowlings.

Individual's fortunes look a whole lot like a random walk. Some people, get over their crack addiction and become writers for the new york times, some people get over their wall street addiction and become crack smokers. It's tough to say where a particular person will be in 20 years. Before you start listing off titans of silicon valley, i'd like to point at all the super rich Vanderbilts running around.

It's up to us as a civilization to decide how low to make the floor. any benefit will have fraud. Straight up anarchy, you keep what you kill sounds rough. If that's your plan, i'm going to get together with my friends and stop you. Nobody works ever, also sounds dumb. I'm going to get together with some other friends and stop that too.

So, we pick a spot somewhere between the two extremes. Historically, value was created by people. More and more, value is created by machines. Cab drivers, sports writers and port masters are all on the way out.

I'm not at all sure how civilization works when only the top 10% or 1% of people are actually capable of being useful to the economy, regardless of level of training.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by erkkie on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:40PM (#9821472)
Very wonderfully put, this is the basic premise in which I see no other way than a form of basic income for developed nations in the future. The interesting question is one of timeframe and methods.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TTPrograms on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:06PM (#9820922)
Free education via internet + age/experience + potential for income at a level significantly about basic income.

I don't think comparing how a 15 year old treated mandatory education and how a 25 might treat the opportunity to educate themselves to better their lives is very fair.

I'd assume the maximum working hours in those countries are above 0. When you have to take an hour long bus each way from an exhausting minimum wage job there's not a lot of time to make significant progress in education.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vaaaauughn on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:10PM (#9821645)
You seem to assume that every school gives an equally good education and accommodates all students' individual strengths and difficulties perfectly. In some parts of the world, like the US, better school districts are correlated to areas with higher property tax revenue.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by undersuit on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:45PM (#9822243)
In the US better school districts are inversely correlated with poverty rates.

http://nasspblogs.org/principaldifference/2014/02/pisa-its-s...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by uhwhat on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:33PM (#9821074)
Peg the basic income to the Consumer Price Index or MIT's BPP [ http://bpp.mit.edu/usa/ ]
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:44AM (#9817578)
You don't mention the fact it's completely unworkable mathematically. In the UK I believe it'd cost £240 billion a year. Where the hell would anyone be able to find that money from? (Tackling tax avoidance from Starbucks isn't a credible answer).

Just to put it in context, that's twice the entire NHS's budget, or 5 times our defence spending.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dagw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:13AM (#9817672)
To put it further into context £240 billion is slightly less than what the UK government spends on pensions and welfare. Since basic income would replace much of the need for pensions and welfare, it might just end up more or less balancing out.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by stephentmcm on Friday July 03, 2015 @12:16AM (#9823427)
Note that this £240 billion will have the overheads of running the welfare system built into it too. So the actual pension checks are only a percentage of that figure, with a basic income that's not means tested the government has far less overhead.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:13AM (#9817905)
The UK government currently spends around £120b on welfare (Including pensions) a year. Please don't pluck false information out of thin air.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dagw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:14AM (#9817912)
I got my numbers from here:

http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/

Perhaps I misread the data.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanBC on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:21AM (#9817937)
It would be useful if you cite your sources. People use different definitions for the various categories.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by onion2k on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:04AM (#9817639)
We wouldn't need money for most benefits any more (pensions, income support, etc) so that's about £120bn of the £240bn found immediately. You mention the NHS - we'd be able to spend a lot less on that if people didn't have poverty-induced health problems, so there's another £35bn (assuming a 30% reduction of the £110bn). It's not unreasonable to assume that the difference of £85bn would essentially pay for itself by increasing the tax revenue from people spending their basic income. over time the country's GDP and tax revenue would increase due to people being better off (they go hand-in-hand).

This could well be cost neutral for the UK.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by bmelton on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:11PM (#9821306)
> It's not unreasonable to assume that the difference of £85bn would essentially pay for itself by increasing the tax revenue from people spending their basic income.

If the idea is to give everybody money so that you can tax it more, you're engaging in economic waste. Without being able to increase productivity in other areas to cover the lost value, you will, hopefully slowly, but eventually trend towards zero, and a failure of the system overall.

Encouraging economic productivity in an environment in which nobody has to be productive may or may not be possible, I honestly haven't any idea, but its certainty doesn't seem terribly obvious to me.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Haegin on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:48PM (#9821530)
It's also worth remembering that at the moment everyone in the UK gets a tax free allowance of £10,600 and an NI free allowance of about £8000 (in 2015/16). The basic income is expected to replace that as well, which means if everyone continues to earn the same amounts that's an extra £2000 per person earning more than £10k (roughly, assuming it's now taxed at 20% in the first tax bracket). NI would be less, and is probably more complex as employers pay some of that, but just assuming that only the employees contributions are now paid on what was previously NI free you're still looking at another £1k each. It's not much individually, but when you take out the costs of administering all of that it'll add up.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by cmdkeen on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:04PM (#9820911)
Why would poverty related health problems disappear unless the basic income is significantly higher than the current unemployment or disability benefits as you're saying those are being replaced.

A basic income doesn't remove the potential for poverty.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:07AM (#9817650)
Yeah I'm sure you could find that missing £85bn down the back of a sofa in whitehall.

Sorry, but the whole idea is laughable. Not to mention the fact that it's another incentive to have more children and bigger families because the state will give you more money.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by zimpenfish on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:24AM (#9817716)
> it's another incentive to have more children and bigger families

Should be easy to back that wild claim up with statistics. Can you?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jackweirdy on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:57AM (#9817851)
My inner pessimist is expecting to see a "there was this Daily Mail article one time".

Everywhere I look, I see the opposite. Families with a comfortable amount of disposable income have the 2.4 kids, but those in poverty (and particularly the working poor) have 3, or upwards. Anecdotal, but I'm yet to see evidence to the contrary

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:17AM (#9817923)
There's evidence on a national scale that birthrate is anticorrelated with wealth. The better off people are on average, the less kids they have.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by knodi123 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:23AM (#9819485)
is it a smooth relationship, or is it more of a step function with 1 steps?

I always suspected that the reality was more like "people who are able to afford children and able to make long-term plans tend to have only as many children as they want, when they feel they are ready, but people who aren't able to afford children or who don't make long-term plans will tend to take a more devil-may-care attitude towards procreation."

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @12:05PM (#9819780)
From what I heard, in very poor countries children are often treated as investment. A child can start paying itself off by working as soon as even 5 years after being born. As a parent, you want someone to take care of you when you're old, and given high children mortality, you're better off making more of them in hope at least one survives to adulthood. Basically, those people are too poor to afford not having many children.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday July 02, 2015 @12:07PM (#9819792)
This is rapidly becoming ancient history. There's a wonderful youtube video showing all the countries on earth, moving on a multimensional chart by infant mortality and standard of living. The origin is ideal. All countries but 1 or two have shot like arrows toward the origin over the last century.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by exch on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:59PM (#9822303)
This talk by Hans Rosling may be what you are referring to.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dymPP9RhPjw

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by marcosdumay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:29PM (#9821048)
Across countries this is a very noisy cloud of points where, if you go out and calculate a regression it's pointing down. Like every other social variable.

Since population explosion has felt out of fashion, there's a long time that I didn't see such plot. But what I've seen has a much clearer tendency than most social correlations people use at real decisions. It's about as clear as most correlations of quality of life with GDP.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Retric on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:42AM (#9819180)
This is not true; on average richer men have more children.

If you try and slice it by family you find that the 'traditional' family makes up a fairly small percentage of the population.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:47AM (#9819209)
This TED talk focuses on the anticorrelation I wrote about: http://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_shows_the_best_stats_y....
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Retric on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:49AM (#9819225)
Richer countries have lower birth rates.

Richer men in the same country have more kids.

PS: I think I just misread your comment. By "national scale" I thought you meant in the same country.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:55AM (#9819272)
Ok, I think I should have written "international scale", I apologize for the confusion.

I don't know of any study on national level, i.e. of families in a single country. The only thing I know of are anecdotes and stories about very poor families having 5+ children.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Retric on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:10AM (#9819401)
I have seen this stat from a few studies.

EX: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/kids_are_normal....

Higher income > more kids, Higher education > fewer children.

This seems fairly obvious as people are less likely to have children and stay in school. But, as I understand it the effect is larger than that.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by MSM on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:51PM (#9820451)
I have heard the opposite from many studies as well. You linked a post that spawned many, many rebuttals by various organizations.

http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/07/01/richer-people-w...

http://freakonomics.com/2011/06/10/the-rich-vs-poor-debate-a...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Retric on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:29PM (#9820685)
Both of those ignore the education factor.

Basically if you have two groups of American born, collage educated men, with of the same age then income positively correlates with number of children. But, if you compare collage dropouts vs. people that have PHD's then the PHD population makes more money and has fewer kids. So, education is a huge confounding factor.

We went from 14 being a reasonable age to start a family to 24 or even 34 being the 'reasonable age' that's a huge impact. But, ‘wealth’ as an independent factor aka adjusted for age, education, country etc becomes a positive factor.

PS: Historically, starvation also limited family size.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by exch on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:41AM (#9818752)
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by zo1 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:25PM (#9821029)
Statistics have nothing to do with it. Either the incentive exists, or it doesn't. Ask for a citation/study/logical-argument on that, not statistics.

But bear in mind: Statistics could indicate the extent that the incentive is having on the incentivized population group, if at all.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by 314 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:12AM (#9817667)
Checking the latest figures for 2016: 155B for pensions and welfare 56B. I assume the point is to replace both of those completely with the basic income so the net cost is not 240B, it is 29B. Not cheap, but not pie in the sky either. Sell a bank or two :)
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dagw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:17AM (#9818603)
There's an addition ~55B spent on welfare that comes from from local rather than central budgets, so that should probably be included.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by just_had_tea on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:46AM (#9818034)
Cut defense wastage. Uh, sorry, I meant defense spending.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s_kilk on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:27PM (#9820295)
Less bombs, more bread.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tosseraccount on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:37PM (#9820733)
How did not spending on defense work out for France and Poland?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ZenoArrow on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:30PM (#9821053)
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by JonFish85 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:55AM (#9818481)
Basic math:

£240 billion / 64.1 million people in the UK = £3,744/year (assuming no government overhead).

Seems low. That works out to be £312/mo/person. That certainly wouldn't seem to replace many costs (especially pensions and the like).

Let's say you wanted it to be £500/mo/person. That'd run you £384.6 billion/year. Add in, say, 5% overhead and you're at £403 billion/year. Where does that money come from? If you stick with the idea that the income is universal, you're dishing out £6,000/person/year, waiting a year, then taking it right back via taxes. Which seems incredibly wasteful, and might drive up that 5% overhead number.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DougWebb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:33AM (#9818702)
You also have to factor in the fact that for most government welfare-type agencies a large portion of their budgets are spent running the bureaucracy, rather than going out to the people. Universal Basic Income greatly reduces the overhead costs. So £1 of Basic Income doesn't replace £1 of a current welfare program; it replaces £2 or £3 of the current program.

Put another way, if the current welfare spending is £120 billion/year, the recipients are only getting £40-£60 billion/year. So that's all of the Basic Income you need to replace the welfare spending, leaving you with a £60-£80 billion/year surplus.

Obviously, the actual amounts depend on the detailed overhead costs for each agency that would be replaced by a UBI program. But I'd be willing to bet on anywhere from 20% to 60% savings for each agency. UBI can be highly automated; with electronic payments and ties to a tax database, it can be as little as a smallish office of administrators and DevOps, and a server farm.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by saalweachter on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:42AM (#9819176)
Eh, government bureaucracies in first-world aren't as inefficient as some people make a living claiming. In the US, administrative expenses for Social Security run less than 1% of the budget. Medicaid and Medicare run with similar margins. Compare this to private-sector insurance in the US, where 80-85% "medical loss ratios" (ie, the fraction of premiums paid out for medical care, as opposed to the fraction kept for administration, advertising, and profits) are common; even in the good old days (before the excesses of modern executive compensation, profits, and advertising) MLR peaked at around 95%.

The simple fact is that many social welfare programs are just expensive, because there are a lot of people being helped and the quantity of money you need to spend to make any difference is just adds up.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:47AM (#9819655)
Bear in mind that "administrative expenses" can mean one thing to ordinary people, and something quite different to a government-sponsored accountant.

When Medicare/Medicaid pays $150 for the same type of crutch that sells in a local pharmacy for $15, that difference does not go into "administrative expenses". I might prefer the expense of a human employee driving to Walgreens, buying a crutch off the shelf, and delivering it by hand to the patient that needs it, rather than paying a hospital that big markup just because that's the most they can charge without the benefits management program automatically denying the expense. Because even if it costs $135 in labor and transportation for a human to do all that, the mere possibility that might happen would discourage the hospital from charging significantly more than the pharmacy across the street for exactly the same item, or from charging different prices to different people based on their insurance plans.

It would even work to just give the patient $150 in cash, and tell them to buy a crutch with it and keep the change. Or carve one out of a tree branch and keep all of it. If they end up not having a crutch, it won't be because they couldn't afford it.

You can't rely on a bureaucracy's reports on itself to reveal the inefficiencies of that bureaucracy. There is just too much political pressure to cook the books.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pekk on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:00PM (#9820874)
What distinguishes normal accountants from these apparently corrupt "government-sponsored accountants" who "cook the books"? Do they have pointy ears or forked tongues?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by logfromblammo on Sunday July 05, 2015 @01:01PM (#9834109)
Normal accountants don't have 300 pages of federal regulations telling them exactly how they need to lie in their reports.

They have 20 pages of corporate guidelines telling them how they have to lie. Zing!

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:24PM (#9821378)
The plural of anecdote is not data.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by thomnottom on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:44AM (#9818776)
Your basic math is assuming the money is distributed to everyone. Wouldn't it make more sense to only give it to adults? That knocks out probably about 25% of the population so you're looking at 48 million. That gets us to £5000/year. Of course the article mentions differences between what single people get and what couples/families get which would also bring down the numbers.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by JonFish85 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:20AM (#9819472)
The reason for that is to cover the cost of raising kids (in my extremely basic example). If the idea is to replace things like welfare, food stamps or whichever programs cover the cost of raising children, I think it's easiest to assume that everybody gets the same dollar amount (the de-facto average amount). There's a lot of ways to try to dice up the numbers (family size, married/unmarried, etc), but I think as a basic example, the numbers are fairly solid.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by phaemon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:57AM (#9818257)
I did a back of the envelope calculation on this last year (so using 2013 figures) which I've pasted below. It works out not too bad; it's certainly within the realm of reason. I think it would probably be better to start it very low, around £20 a week, and slowly scale it up and let it replace welfare payments gradually.

If you think my figures are significantly out, I'd appreciate any corrections.

--------------------------------------------------

[There were requests for "back of a napkin" calculations, so I've done some for the UK. To convert to USD, just add 50%, as a rough measure.]

Firstly, I prefer to refer to this as a "Citizen's Dividend" rather than a "Basic Income", as I know for a fact that anyone on a low income would prefer to get a guaranteed £20 a week extra rather than hear a politician say, "We can't afford to pay £75 pounds a week to everyone, so we're doing nothing." Tell me if I'm wrong. But "Basic Income" if the preferred name, so I'll refer to it as that from now on.

The UK government spends £732 billion. If we subtract £222 billion for Social Protection (we're replacing all of it with our BI), we get £510 billion required. If we add up all government income except Income Tax - Business Rates, Excise, etc - we get £481 billion.

That leaves us a shortfall of £29 billion. For the sake of simplicity, I'm going to assume that reductions in crime, the increase in VAT revenue, better health, etc are going to cover that. Let's call it close enough for government work. At the end of the day, we currently borrow £84 billion anyway, so at worst I've slashed the deficit!

Income Tax brings in £167 billion. UK population I'm going to take at 60 million. So, as a starting point, that gives us a BI of £2,783 annually, or £54 ($80) a week. Well, that's not a bad start! Let's consider what it means for actual people. Thus far:

Who loves me: - Right-wingers. I've eliminated (or vastly reduced) the deficit, effectively increased the income tax allowance by £2,783 and given them this amount in cash, while reducing welfare payments to lazy, single-mother immigrants. I should be head of the Conservative party.

- Most people on Job Seekers Allowance (unemployment benefit). While I've cut the amount they actually get, I've also cut out all the paperwork, visits to the job centre, taking money off them if they happen to earn something that week, etc etc. Money without the hassle.

- Low wage workers. This is a big boost above Working Tax Credit and is hassle free (you don't lose it by earning more). It also allows some degree of security in the event of losing their job.

Who hates me: - Left-wingers. While I've helped some low paid workers, I've also slashed benefits, there's no housing support...in short I've cut welfare while giving more money to wealthy people. I should be head of the Conservative party.

- People who're claiming several benefits. People who're on sickness benefit. Basically, all the folk who've had their income reduced below a living wage.

- Pensioners. The state pension has been cut significantly (and illegally).

Ok, I think I need to balance it a bit more. I'm going to reduce the Income Tax allowance from £10,000 (current) to £6,000. This should balance out at the end. I'm going to assume this increases income tax revenue by 25% (I've no idea if this is remotely close. If anyone can be bothered finding out, please let me know). More controversially, I'm also going to increase income tax by 25%, so the basic rate is now 25% rather than 20%.

That should give me a total revenue increase of 50% from Income Tax which gives me a BI of £4,175 annually or £80 ($120) per week.

There is a problem: we've neglected the people who require more than that either because they're owed it (e.g pensioners) or because they have extra requirements (e.g. orphaned children), so having increased the BI up to £80, I'm now going to cut it again down to £60 a week. This will cover pensioners, people claiming benefits which are currently in excess of £60 and support for vulnerable children (note that children also receive the BI, so 'child benefit' has seen a massive boost from the regular £20 per week maximum).

I'm assuming that 20% of people fall into one of the above categories, so cutting £20 off the BI gives us £160 a week to help these people. This is more than the current basic state pension (£113.10/week) so that's a fairly big increase. I don't want to complicate the calculations any further, so the small number of people who require more than this will have to be paid out of the £50 billion we haven't borrowed.

That's us at £60 per week basic income and up to £160 per week for pensioners and vulnerable people.

And I think I'll leave it there. We might still need to borrow (or cut spending elsewhere) to make up other shortfalls, but as long as these borrowings total less than £50 billion we still come out ahead. It might be more natural to cut the payment to £50 for everyone in order to free up some cash for other payments. In the real world, you wouldn't exclusively reserve Income Tax to one specific spending area anyway, but it makes things simple enough to get a rough measure.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:13AM (#9819422)
Do a thought experiment. Imagine that the entire UK were walled in by an impenetrable barrier enclosing the country out to the boundary of its exclusive economic zone, and every record and memory of ownership were wiped away, such that no one could be entirely certain who owned what. Stimpson J. Cat pushed the History Eraser Button.

On the morning following the event, some boffins assemble and work out an emergency plan for re-establishing a workable economy, on the assumption that one existed before everyone forgot what it was.

Now, with no memory of the past, does the UK have the land, labor, and capital to completely provide for the needs of its people? If that costs £X per year, can the people of the UK produce £X of economic output per year, and with the correct proportions of goods and services?

(For your reference, the UK represents approximately 4% of the global economy.)

I reached my own conclusion as a result. It is completely workable mathematically. It just doesn't work within the existing legal tradition. That's the one that respects property and contracts--the one we all like because it's what we rely on to assure ourselves that the car we drove to work will still be there when we knock off for the day, and the house we go back to won't be full of grubby squatters when we get there.

But as much as we like it, those with more wealth, who lack the will or the imagination to spend what they earn--to keep the production-consumption economy circulating efficiently--like it more. It keeps the grubby middle class from building ugly-but-productive anthills and beehives within sight of their beautiful-but-inefficient homes, yachts, and luxury resorts. And that is what stops the socialist schemes to erase poverty--we just don't have the stones to commit armed robbery to do it. The middle class largely pays for itself, and no more, so the only available source for the necessary resources to haul the lower classes out of poverty is the rich, including the synthetic rich people better known as corporations.

So you swallow your lofty free-market, shalt-not-steal ideals, abandon your pipe dreams of one day being in the upper class, and you tax the rich at near-extortionate rates. Naturally, they would want to flee such a tax regime. Let them. Just stop them from taking the productive capital with them as they go.

It might work out like France. It might work out like Venezuela. It might work out like the USSR. But if it doesn't work out, it won't be because it is a mathematical impossibility. It will just be because someone made a wrong assumption in one of the thousands of possible places to make a mistake when trying to re-engineer an entire national economy.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by atlih on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:13AM (#9817674)
They would get it from economic growth among other things.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanielBMarkham on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:28AM (#9817736)
"If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off - people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford their rent."

Looking at populations of people who have gone from being very poor to being very rich overnight does not support that statement. Most of the time the money is more of a curse than anything else. I believe the same goes for people who go from very poor to receiving an annuity from things like legal settlements, but I am only guessing at that.

(I'm not arguing against it, I think it's an experiment worth having)

I think there is are a few hidden premises here that need to be called out: the premise that having more money is better for everybody than having less, the premise that not struggling at all in life -- whether for personal goals or paying the rent -- is better than struggling, the premise that everybody will respond in a positive way to the same external stimulus, and so on.

I find many of these premises dubious, but I cannot deny the fact that I personally feel better the more folks in the world that go to bed without being hungry or sick. The trick is separating my personal desire to feel good from what actually may be happening with various policies I would support. That's why we need more data here. It's very easy to grandstand something like this either way. There's a lot of smoke but very little light.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by clavalle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:23AM (#9819490)
>I think there is are a few hidden premises here that need to be called out

That's what the experiment is for.

But let me put this bug in your ear:

Most economic models are based on the premise that people can walk away from a potential transaction with no losses. That when people trade value, each party leaves the table with more value than they brought to it but if they leave they are no worse off. That's a large part of the brilliance of the free market -- value is continually created.

However, this breaks down when one party loses value if they walk away, negative utility, especially if the other party knows it. And it is especially troublesome when that negative utility is expandable e.g. when the alternative is pain or death -- things people will generally pay whatever they can to avoid. That's why strong arming is not considered good economic policy. It can lead to net destruction of value. In some cases this can be ignored because the value created for one party more than makes up for the value destroyed for the other party but, in general, it is more than possible that the net effect is negative.

With the poor they might not be threatened directly but the consequences of not, say, selling their time for less than it is actually worth can be just as bad as if someone was robbing them.

We're not talking about making people rich, we are talking about removing desperation and avoidance of death and pain as a motivating factor.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by notahacker on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:01AM (#9817868)
The most galling implicit premise of all is that every proposal for basic income I've ever seen accepts that BI isn't practically feasible with open borders, and therefore nothing changes at all for the class of people who work the longest hours in the worst conditions (indeed their wage slavery becomes even more essential to ensuring future riders of the purple wage can still buy consumer goods)

An argument for implementing BI in the foreseeable future isn't really a "nobody should be forced to work" argument, as desirable as that might ultimately be. An argument for implementing BI in ones own developed country in the near term is a "nobody with the right passport should be forced to look for work" argument. I think social security - essentially insuring people from a risk of unemployment caused at least in part by policies enacted by an elected government - is a good idea, but I categorically don't agree that my fellow Brits should have an automatic right to receive more than the world average purchasing power adjusted income without even thinking about doing anything for it.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:25PM (#9821384)
Your countrymen don't have to think about doing anything for it because their forebears and ancestors already thought about it, and already took the necessary steps so that later generations wouldn't have to.

They may have done it mainly for the benefit of their own heirs and successors, but now that it's done, it's done. All those improvements multiply, and Brits get more because it takes less individual effort to produce the same amount in the heavily-improved UK than in a country where improvements are more easily destroyed or converted. So anyone willing to obey British law, participate in the British economy (accept and spend pounds), respect British infrastructure, and assimilate into British culture should get more than the rest of the world, because those are the practices that allow Britain to be more productive than the world median.

A hedgerow along a country lane does not grow that way naturally. It takes an effort to force it. But once established, it just needs a regular trim and an occasional re-laying to keep the livestock out of the road. You just don't need to pull a new barbed wire fence in front of a blackthorn hedge, so why would anyone complain that no one is doing it?

The resources of the country are preferentially distributed to its own citizens because one country lacks the sovereign authority to force any other country to change its culture and institutions to be more productive. If those other countries wanted to be as prosperous as Britain, they could fork the British system, or selectively merge changes from it into their own repositories. See also: USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand.

So those people aren't exactly thoughtlessly doing nothing. They are being British, as hard as they possibly can. And that allows the UK to have nice things like the NHS. In contrast, Americans, in being as American as possible, can only manage a hybrid public-private healthcare monstrosity that no one can examine too closely or for too long, because most of our psychiatric hospitals are cleverly disguised as prisons.

In light of that, there's really only one essential element that needs to go along with open borders. Assimilate the immigrants.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:18PM (#9821345)
Arguing for suppressing the Western working classes on the basis that this will somehow help the working classes in the developing world doesn't make any sense. Labor is labor, around the world. You strengthen the working class in one place, and you've strengthened it everywhere. Pay a basic income in the West, and consumer spending can rise, aiding a rise in demand, leading to a tighter hiring market for developing-world employers who make the stuff, making labor actions for shorter hours and higher wages more successful.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by notahacker on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:39PM (#9822213)
Seriously, you consider me to be "arguing for suppressing the Western working classes" because I suggested that any right to earn more than the average global labour income even after cost-of-living adjustments probably ought to be incumbent upon them to actually doing some work? That's got to be the most intellectually dishonest characterisation of my arguments I've seen on HN.

Labour isn't labour when it's sitting with its feet up enjoying the privileges of accident of birth, and any benefits from their additional consumption that might trickle down to the developing world poor can easily be cancelled out if unconditional redistribution happens to have side effects on the Western economies in question. Not to mention the likelihood of barriers to entering Western countries getting a lot higher...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by 7Z7 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:19AM (#9818609)
>Looking at populations of people who have gone from being very poor to being very rich overnight does not support that statement..

That isn't a remotely analogous situation. This is people not being able to afford food, suddenly being able to afford food. Being suddenly very rich brings with it opportunities and responsibilities that simply being fed do not.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jotm on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:02PM (#9822016)
Looking at populations of people who have gone from being very poor to being very rich overnight does not support that statement. Most of the time the money is more of a curse than anything else. I believe the same goes for people who go from very poor to receiving an annuity from things like legal settlements, but I am only guessing at that

That's a bad comparison, there have been studies that show a small no-strings-attached monthly allowance made people's lives easier and overall better. They did not spend the money on crap like most lottery winners do.

I assume the reason is that those people realize they're still poor, but got a bit of help. Lottery winners get more money than they can handle, start assuming they're rich and that messes up their spending habits.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:10PM (#9820583)
But we're not going from very poor to very rich. We're going from very poor to not that poor.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by hueving on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:51AM (#9817399)
>people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life

Some people will. I have met many plenty of people though that don't care about other people regardless of their income.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Merovius on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:41AM (#9817569)
I never understood, why this is a problem. We live in a society of abundance. Tying coverage of living expenses to work done, just leads to people doing pointless work. This is at least the reality in Germany: There aren't enough jobs for everyone, people live under the illusion that it is wrong to just subsidize people living, thus the government rather subsidizes jobs, that are not profitable to be done by people (my mother crimped cables from home for a living, something that can be done by a machine for a fraction of the price in orders of magnitude less time).

Apart from that, it is called "basic income", not "luxurious income". Ask these people if they still wouldn't work if the alternative is not being able to afford a smartphone, Game console, plasma TV or car.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mcv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:45AM (#9819198)
We need to get rid of the myth that everybody needs to work. Better would be to automate all the work so nobody has to work anymore.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by brobinson on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:18PM (#9820246)
Who owns the machines in that system? The government?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mcv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:21PM (#9820630)
I don't care who owns them, as long as the value they produce is at least partially shared.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Noelkd on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:50PM (#9821180)
If you haven't read this[1] I think you might enjoy it. It covers the ideas you are talking about. I think it was featured on HN some time back.

[1] http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by brobinson on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:22PM (#9821369)
This is awesome. Thanks for linking it.

I've had dreams of doing this to an In-n-Out location. Every one I've been to has had all the employees doing every job like a scatterbrained beehive, and it takes 15-20 minutes to get your food.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TisButMe on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:01AM (#9817421)
But those people will always be a net negative for society, basic income or not. Empowering those who would make a positive difference if they had enough time/money sounds like a good idea to me.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by JustSomeNobody on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:00PM (#9820887)
I think those who are against a basic wage feel the current net negative portion of society would be a greater net negative because not only would they be receiving a wage, but they'd spend it on crap and society would still have to take care of them (hospital bills, food, etc).
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by thuuuomas on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:00PM (#9822310)
> but they'd spend it on crap

Sounds like a good deal for the crap vendors. Also, maybe the instant-gratification app scene...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by branchless on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:20PM (#9821353)
After swinging your hammer several times you hit the nail on the head with the final word.

We should have land value tax which will eliminate land hoarding, reduce rents and replace income tax. More incentive to work, less incentive to speculate.

You'll never get this in the UK/US as the last thing the elite want is a level playing field where you get to keep most of what you contribute.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by macspoofing on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:45PM (#9820782)
>If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off

I don't think it's obvious hence the necessity of actually testing it in a real-world setting.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ancap on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:20PM (#9820623)
I'm all for this (and any other form of welfare), provided the funding of such a program is done on a purely voluntary basis.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by shostack on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:24PM (#9820646)
If the net result is lower cost than funding existing forms of welfare and ends up improving other areas of the city, would you care as much about the voluntary nature of it?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by macspoofing on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:55PM (#9820841)
>provided the funding of such a program is done on a purely voluntary basis.

Like taxes right?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ancap on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:04PM (#9820913)
If you live in Greece
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tluyben2 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:10AM (#9817452)
What round of investment was that? And yes that is sound; in later rounds even a number which makes you never (at least the coming 10 years) having to worry about money so you can focus on your company 100%. If you do not do that you will not be able concentrate even when something trivial like having too little money for your family occurs for some reason. Which is bad for investors and everyone else involved in the company.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by wooyi on Thursday July 02, 2015 @12:05PM (#9819779)
This assumes everyone is motivated, wants to improve their lives and do well in their jobs or in society.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by frogpelt on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:04PM (#9820915)
According to Thomas Sowell, this assumption is at the heart of the difference between liberals and conservatives.

Liberals assume "everyone is motivated, wants to improve their lives and do well in their jobs or in society" given the right system.

Conservatives basically assume the opposite.

I'll let him explain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5KHdhrNhh88&feature=youtu.be...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:09AM (#9817890)
> If a government were to do that for everyone

Inflation would eat it up.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by chi-sq on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:14AM (#9818124)
> Inflation would eat it up.

As discussed above, funding for UBI can be mostly reassigned from existing welfare & pension budgets.

Demand for basic food and shelter is more or less a constant (unless you can argue otherwise), regardless of people's income, so as I see, prices for non-luxurious items could stay about the same under UBI.

It's a simplistic overview and there are tons of important factors e.g. farming subsidies or migrations, but in general UBI makes a lot of sense.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dageshi on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:34PM (#9820346)
I don't see that demand for property/shelter is constant because people can and do buy it as investment. My assumption would be that rental prices would rise to the point where BI barely covers shelter and the money is effectively transferred via rental to "investors".
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:32AM (#9817983)
How? Competition would increase and prices would come down. We are currently fighting to avoid deflation anyways and all indicators point towards this continuing. If anything UBI will stop people hoarding cash as is happening now and re-introduce some cash-flow into the macro economy. A little inflation is healthy.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:40AM (#9818014)
Why would competition increase?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:53AM (#9818053)
For basic goods there would be more demand (people who can't afford even basics would enter the market making the total market larger) in turn making it more attractive to compete there. People always go where there is opportunity.

We are also on a long term trend of prices coming down in any case.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by foota on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:07PM (#9820179)
This is not how economics works. There are supply curves and there are demand curves, then there is the quantity supplied and quantity demanded. If the demand for a product shifts up (increases) due to basic income, then the quantity demanded increases. Then inventories of that product decrease, indicating that the firms could start producing more and still be able to sell it. They do this, but there costs go up, since each unit that they produce now costs them more on average. [assuming they are producing with increasing marginal costs, which is generally true]
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by marcosdumay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:49PM (#9821177)
> assuming they are producing with increasing marginal costs, which is generally true

The norm is marginal production costs decreasing with scale. The usual exception to it is when those costs stay constant.

Unitary costs increasing with scale isn't unheard of, but it's also not common in any way.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by foota on Sunday July 05, 2015 @09:58PM (#9836209)
Up to a certain point, yes. But, in the short term, firms must increase their production by, say, hiring more workers. They might now have a less optimal worker/capital ratio which would increase their per unit costs. In the long run, their costs are flatter but still could eventually increase with quantity, imagine they're using all the resources locally available and have to start importing from somewhere else, that's going to increase costs.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:56PM (#9820845)
Everything will be automated. Cost per unit will be down. In an open competitive market without monopolies or price fixing cartels the price for high demand cheap basics gets driven down due to increased competition. For cheap basic good the main competitive strategy is to be cheaper than your rivals. It's the classic race to the bottom like we are seeing with low end electronics. The more the system fully automates and becomes hyper efficient the closer we move towards zero marginal cost.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:10AM (#9818107)
So you say demand will increase and production will have to catch up. I think prices will go up, not down in such case.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:19AM (#9818144)
How did you come to that conclusion? We can easily increase production to meet demand. In fact supply is a largely solved problem. The new problem is lack of demand.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:10PM (#9820575)
Depends on how elastic the demand for the good is. Not everything can handle a large price hike like that. McDonald's, for instance, wouldn't be able to jack up their prices a whole lot, because then people simply wouldn't go there.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dharmach on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:13AM (#9818964)
A company will hire and keep only those who are able and willing to worry about company's issues. For such employees it makes sense to pay them decent wage so they are free to worry about company. How should government fire citizen who are not performing well?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:07PM (#9820555)
Why should they bother?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by wozniacki on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:07AM (#9817443)

  If a government were to do that for everyone it seems 
  pretty obvious that society will be better off - people 
  will spend their time working on things to improve 
  everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford
  their rent
The incredulity of this is plainly galling.

How does one draw a broad conclusion like that?

Plenty of European examples abound where despite generous - some would argue very generous - state dispensed benefits certain sections of the society just do not respond positively in measures of improvement of their own station in life much less "working on things to improve everyone's else (lives)".

A good - and I admit quite controversial - account of this kind of malaise is recounted in the British Channel 4 documentary, Benefits Street [1] [2]

[1] Benefits Street Season 01 Episode 01

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlrLp-R4g_M

[2] Benefits Street

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefits_Street

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dagw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:49AM (#9817588)
The huge 'problem' with most European benefit systems that I am aware of that as soon as you take the money, your time is no longer your own. You cannot go to to school or take courses, start a company, do odd freelance work, do certain types of charity work, travel freely or a whole host of other potentially self improving things, without losing your benefits. Living on benefits is also living in constant fear that your benefits can be removed at any time for any (or no) reason. Remove all those barriers and requirements and remove the need to keep jumping through time consuming and seemingly arbitrary hoops to get your money and perhaps people will react differently.

Personally I come down on the skeptical side of the fence, but would really love to be proven wrong.

Also Benefit Street is not a documentary interested in facts, but reality TV at its finest, interested in entertaining, and should be judged as such.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ptaipale on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:17AM (#9817691)
> 'problem' with most European benefit systems that I am aware of that as soon as you take the money, your time is no longer your own.

Getting a job has similar disadvantages.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanBC on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:13AM (#9817906)
GP post was specifically about those lazy benefits claimants who don't study or do voluntary work to improve their chance of getting back to work.

Parent post correctly points out that many of those claimants were prohibited - under threat of criminal prosecution - from doing those things while claiming some benefit.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:54AM (#9818057)
Often benefits put you in a situation where it makes no economical sense to pursue a job. I have a friend who lost her mother and had a pension that would be taken away if she got employed, but the pension itself was much bigger than she could ever dream of earning at that time (hell, it was bigger than I was earning in my first two programming jobs). So there's your incentive to go and get employed.

Or another example; until not so long ago, my mother (single parent) got social benefits that would disappear if my own personal income would exceed a particular (not very big) amount, and this would turn into a problem with paying rent and feeding her and my siblings. She also spent some time unemployed after a company she worked in went bust (the original owner died, and his son mismanaged it into the ground), because all jobs available for her wouldn't even pay enough to cover the lost benefits.

Basically, living at the lower end of income spectrum is incredibly hard, and you end up doing a lot of weird calculations. When working hard for 8+ hours a day pays you less than not working at all (and caring about your kids instead), suddenly this "laziness" becomes a perfectly rational choice.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ptaipale on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:46PM (#9821159)
Quite. I wouldn't call people "lazy" if they've fallen in a benefit trap. The benefits have been created with good intentions, but they have paved a road.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanBC on Friday July 03, 2015 @05:23AM (#9824456)
To be clear: I wasn't calling people claiming benefits lazy; I was saying that wozniacki was calling them lazy. I should have used scare quotes.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ptaipale on Friday July 03, 2015 @06:59AM (#9824739)
Clearly you didn't. Though wozniacki's message was phrased a in bit more nuanced way as well:

certain sections of the society just do not respond positively in measures of improvement of their own station in life -- I think we cannot escape the fact that this is true. Even in the wealthiest welfare states, there is poverty and unhappiness, but mostly it's not because of lack of (monetary) benefits, or access to education etc.

At least in my country (Finland), the development has been from state assistance (for instance, a tired single parent gets someone to help him/her a couple of times per week and do a bit of looking after the whole situation) to monetary payments (they get 123 € per week, which is taken away if they go to work, and they have freedom to decide what to do). And I must admit that when I was younger, I tended to be very liberal/libertarian (in the American sense) and say just giving people money and freedom is what we should do, but now I think it was a mistake. In the short term, people do hate waking up and going to work every day, even if in the long term they will live better lives if they do so.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mcv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:52AM (#9819249)
True, but with a job, at least you're producing something. Well, there are also bullshit jobs, but I'd like to believe that most jobs still provide some kind of value in some way. The hoop jumping for the unemployed is just plain value destroying. If they could get an education or do charity work, they'd at least be doing something useful. I'd rather pay my taxes for that.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanBC on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:21AM (#9817499)
> Plenty of European examples abound where despite generous - some would argue very generous - state dispensed benefits certain sections of the society just do not respond positively in measures of improvement of their own station in life much less "working on things to improve everyone's else (lives)".

For many years people on English out of work benefits were not allowed to do voluntary work or be a student - those were things that would have stopped the benefits.

This carried over to some of the disability benefits. If you did voluntary work to prepare you to get back into full time work your benefits would be stopped.

Citing benefits street, and calling it a documentary, is an odd choice. Do you think that programme has any credibility?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by caminante on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:37AM (#9817554)
I'm looking at the wiki[2] and 1. it's a documentary 2. it's on Channel 4 -- a public-service (non-commercial) channel in the UK.

Can you help add more context for what you're getting at?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jamesbrownuhh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:44AM (#9817579)
Channel 4 is a "public service" channel only in the sense that it was one of the first four channels to come into existence at a time when the quid pro quo for having a broadcast licence was that challenging, worthy, high-quality programmes were broadcast.

Today, Channel 4 is still technically a PSB, but it's not and has never been "non-commercial" - it shows adverts and makes profits just like any other commercial channel.

Calling "Benefits Street" a documentary would be like saying that Jersey Shore or The Osbournes was a documentary. It's not.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by DanBC on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:16AM (#9817686)
The term "documentary" covers a broad range of material. There are in-depth explorations of fact or investigative reporting at one end; and populist fly on the wall fluff at the other end. Benefits Street is definitely on the fluffier end. There was little attempt to explain how benefits work; what the rules are or how they're applied to most people.

The OFCOM investigation is, I think, evidence that the programme was low quality, and focused on sensationalism rather than accuracy. (Although they didn't uphold any of the complaints).

Channel Four is publically owned but is not non-commercial -- it has to mostly fund itself; it carries ads and sells its programmes.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by naz on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:13AM (#9817462)
You're woefully misinformed about exactly how generous benefits in the UK are. People who do manage to live off benefits here can't expect a quality of life that even begins to approach comfortable.

You shouldn't let some opportunistic reality TV show be the basis for your world views.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by wozniacki on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:30AM (#9817752)

  You shouldn't let some opportunistic reality TV show be  
  the basis for your world views.
Well if Western societies didn't function in a miasma of political correctness highly sensitive to even the least prickly of criticisms perhaps Channel 4 or any other outlet for that matter wouldn't have seen a need to reach for an alarmist tone in the way they fashioned their programming in matters such as this, that one could argue have influenced the most recent UK national parliamentary election.

The opinion polls suggested quite the opposite outcome [1] which goes to prove that many of the voters were quite concerned about the issues such as these and general direction in which UK as a sovereign nation was headed, but rather stopped short of voicing them openly, lest they be branded prejudicial or worse.

[1] Election 2015: How the opinion polls got it wrong

http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-32751993

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tomp on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:18AM (#9817486)
Benefits incentivize you to not work, because if you do, you lose benefits.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Lawtonfogle on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:39PM (#9821467)
Poorly applied benefits do. If at any point, you lose $2 of benefits by earning $1 more, you are encouraged to not work harder. Of course there is a cap, such as if you earn $5,000 more you'll only lose $4,000, but people don't have the option to increase by $5,000 at a time and are stuck where working harder only earns you enough to cost even more in benefits than you earn, thus discouraging working harder.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by audunw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:28AM (#9817521)
I don't think what you're referencing works as a good counterexample. Currently benefits only goes to those who needs it or seeks it. It says little about how the people who don't need it, or wouldn't seek welfare payments they don't need, will behave.

I think public welfare systems has a tendency to make "leechers" more visible. They leech on the government rather than family and they probably tend to collect in specific areas, but I'm not convinced it makes the problem worse.

Although I think basic income would work, I agree that he was exaggerating when he wrote that it "seems pretty obvious". There are some evidence that it would be beneficial, and there's also some pretty straight-forward arguments for why it would be good on a national scale (less bureaucracy). But we won't know until we try. I think more experiments are in order (1: removing restrictions and terms of welfare payments to see if that leads to more undesirable behavior. 2: giving basic income to a whole town with correspondingly realistic taxes to see if working people's behavior changes)

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ctack on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:14AM (#9817471)
But we got all those great British bands out of the deal.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:18AM (#9817483)
People starting companies are driven, determined people who want to create things.

The vast majority of people are not. You're vastly over-estimating the general population. The majority are lazy, and if given money, will sit watching reality TV and stuffing their face with ice cream. (Step outside the startup bubble for a while). Most people are also selfish. The idea that they'll all start doing things to benefit others is a bit far fetched.

Communism (Which is what this is), has failed. Why this generation seems determined to try it again is beyond me.

This is about stealing money from the successful, and giving it to everyone, regardless of merit. It's a fantastic way to reward failure and penalise success, and society will suffer because of it. The numbers are also staggering - it just doesn't work mathematically unless you can magic up billions from somewhere each year.

Also be under no illusion - if a basic income was implemented, the chances are (Assuming you're better off than the average person) you would have to reduce your quality of life substantially to pay for it.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Fuxy on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:04AM (#9817641)
> Communism (Which is what this is), has failed. Why this generation seems determined to try it again is beyond me.

A bit of a stretch there and i should know i was born in a communist country. The reason Communism has failed is because of the lack of checks and balances on power compounded with corruption not because of concepts like this.

> This is about stealing money from the successful, and giving it to everyone, regardless of merit.

Be realistic most rich people are not rich because they are extraordinarily successful it's because they are born rich and there's entire companies with the sole goal of taking advantage of the system (in some cases doing morally wrong things that are technically legal) in order to make rich people get richer. Over the past 5 - 10 years the middle class has been getting poorer while the rich have been getting richer even with the economy collapsing. If you start off rich a lot of doors that are closed for regular people are wide open to you so you don't have to be successful just don't be a fool.

I see basic income as more of a equalizer so people who can't afford billion dollar companies and robotics to replace the workers get to eat as well.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by goldfeld on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:00AM (#9817861)
The real reason Communism couldn't succeed (not necessarily the reason it failed) is because none of the countries trying it were or are advanced capitalistic economies before the revolution. Imagine a transition into communism in a less-scarcity scenario, where robots generate so much material wealth as to provide it to everyone, and no one HAS to work, and technology married to political science in turn allows more distributed forms of governance by the people for the people. Once you have that, and of course less bigots running the roost, you have a shot, as a society, to completely do away with 'marginalization', since every city and every community will be self-contained and no one will have to do commutes to serve a master.

Communism, for all I know, is the alternative to Totalitarism (be it from American corporate overlords or from so called extreme "left") in a future where jobs are no longer to be found lying around. It probably won't be called communism, though. China or Germany (and other smaller european countries) may have a shot, but the US seems destined to be ruled by corporate emperors.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:27AM (#9817968)
> because none of the countries trying it were or are advanced capitalistic economies before the revolution

revolution was the least common way to turn communist. Far more common was "forced by nearby communist country"

Also for example Czechoslovakia was advanced capitalist country. It's often overlooked - it was very industrialized country, with long capitalistic traditions, and democracy before WW2. It also went through war relatively unscratched. In 1950 it had GDP per capita roughly equal to Italy and Ireland, 50% higher than Spain.

> Imagine a transition into communism in a less-scarcity scenario

From the POV of medieval people We're already in a less-scarcity scenario. We just don't like to share, as a species. I highly doubt technology will change that.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:39AM (#9818011)
> From the POV of medieval people We're already in a less-scarcity scenario. We just don't like to share, as a species. I highly doubt technology will change that.

It seems to me that technology will force that change on us. In a world when a robot can do every job you can, only faster and better, and doesn't eat, sleep or complain, there's little use for you and me. So either we get rid of the whole concept of jobs or starve (or stop the progress, but good luck with that, the very system that threatens to destroy us is the one that's driving progress).

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vidarh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:06AM (#9818928)
> Czechoslovakia was advanced capitalist country

Did it have sufficient over-production that redistribution would remove "common wants" for everyone?

As early as 1845, Marx set that out as a central criteria that would have to be met before a socialist revolution would have any hope of succeeding.

> We just don't like to share, as a species.

And in fact, this is a central aspect of Marx' argument for socialist revolutions: We don't like sharing, and so for the vast majority of workers, the only way of getting a reasonable share is to join up and force the upper classes to surrender their wealth.

Marxism is basically founded on two ideas: 1) Capitalism will eventually make production efficient enough to produce substantial surpluses. 2) Workers will only get "their" share by cooperating to fight the ruling classes, and if they don't they will eventually get marginalised as capitalist competition starts driving down employment and/or incomes.

Nothing assumes people wanting to share. On the contrary, the Marxist focus on revolution is basically based on the idea that there's no chance you'll get wealthy ruling classes to voluntarily give up their wealth.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:23AM (#9819037)
> Nothing assumes people wanting to share.

It assumes once workers won the surpluses won't decrease.

This turned out to be false assumption, because people don't like to share, so they don't work as well if they only get part of the fruits of their work, as they would if they got most of the fruits of their work for themselves.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vidarh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:37AM (#9819144)
Today they don't generally get a share of the surplus, so by your argument they should be working even worse.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by ajuc on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:44AM (#9826176)
In "the west" they get less than in 50s, but they still do.

The important thing is - salaries depend on their performance and on the demand for given product/service.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:04AM (#9817874)
From what I learned, Communism has this successful capitalism as an assumption, as starting condition. They tried to speed up the process (with bloodshed), so it's no surprise it didn't work, just like you wouldn't expect a baby born 5 months premature to survive. It's not developed enough.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by bitJericho on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:35AM (#9817772)
No doubt. Had companies in general not taken advantage of employees nobody would even be considering this option. This is what you get when companies look at the bare minimum they can pay somebody for the work they want.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tiatia on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:24AM (#9819051)
>> Communism (Which is what this is), has failed.

> communist country. The reason Communism has failed is > because of the lack of checks and balances on power > compounded with corruption not because of concepts like

Socialism did not fail because of corruption - capitalism has this too. Socialism failed because of its inability to put pricing on a product due to lack of a market place. On the other hand, Socialism had tremendous growth. Hitler (another socialist) said, "The Soviet Union is a rotten house - kick in the front door and the whole house will collapse". This was true in the WWI but in WWII the Soviet Union was a different country, they probably had a higher GDP than Germany. Why? Because Stalin achieved growth rates that may have dwarfed China (controversial, but he may have achieved up to 500% Growth in 13 years based on some estimates).

So socialism failed, back to capitalism. Yes, capitalism survived. But how much longer?

"There is No Steady State Economy (except at a very basic level)" http://ourfiniteworld.com/2011/02/21/there-is-no-steady-stat...

Limits to Growth–At our doorstep, but not recognized http://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-02-12/limits-to-growt...

Wealth And Energy Consumption Are Inseparable http://www.declineoftheempire.com/2012/01/wealth-and-energy-...

Galactic-Scale Energy http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-e...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Sir_Substance on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:25AM (#9817512)
>The vast majority of people are not. You're vastly over-estimating the general population. The majority are lazy, and if given money, will sit watching reality TV and stuffing their face with ice cream.

I've always felt that this argument against basic minimum income said more about the arguer than society at large. In my experience, everyone has a personal project that gets sidelined for their work.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dagw on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:34AM (#9817538)
everyone has a personal project that gets sidelined for their work.

For many people that project is to watch their favorite TV shows while eating their favorite ice cream.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by onion2k on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:54AM (#9817605)
No it isn't. That isn't their personal project. That's all they have the choice of doing. Most people do those things because they're tired after working hard all day for a wage that doesn't give them enough money to do anything but sit in front of the television. If people had the opportunity to work a bit less in their job so they could do something worthwhile and fulfilling in their spare time, most people would take that choice.

Just look at people who inherit or win large sums of money - a few of them end up just enjoying themselves, but most use the money to follow a cause that they think is something worthwhile. There's no reason to believe the same wouldn't be true (on a smaller scale) for a minimum income.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:50AM (#9817823)
Exactly this. After 8h+ of work for little pay, 2h of commute, doing dishes, dinner and cleaning up, you'll have little energy to do anything creative and constructive. Grabbing a beer and turning on TV is a way to relax before turning in and beginning another day of work. I don't know of a person who doesn't have dreams, hobbies, things to do and create. Many just put it off until they can buy a house, until they can have children, until they can give children education, until they retire...
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by goldfeld on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:14AM (#9817911)
I think it's even more than necessarily being tired: people who struggle to get by are in a constant state of alert and stress that precludes developing their creative dreams (they will have them, but can't advance on them). When you're stressed you'll turn to addictions to relieve yourself: chocolate, TV, MJ, and some will even become workaholics through some basal twisted work ethic.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:35AM (#9817999)
That's true, and I know this from first-hand experience. Having an unstable financial situation, constant worrying about how to support 4 people and pay off debts pretty much shuts down your ability to do anything creative. It didn't stop me from having ideas, it didn't even stop me from starting to work on them - but it always stopped me from advancing on them - either because lack of money for required components, or being too stressed out worrying to focus on doing the theoretical/software work. So in the end I ended up opting for watching stuff and reading books as a way to tune down before another day of struggle.

And yes, I am a programmer. You can end up in shit as one too. I made some bad work choices before and ended up pretty much not being paid for half a year.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by goldfeld on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:35AM (#9818190)
I think especially because us programmers can get high salaries early on, divorced from both having to save and from the experience of handling money well, we can fall hard. I also speak from personal experience :)/:(
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by just_had_tea on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:41AM (#9818016)
I wish there was a translation of this article into English: https://decorrespondent.nl/511/waarom-arme-mensen-domme-ding...

Basically, the argument is that "poor people do stupid stuff" because their "intelligence bandwidth" is being sucked up by worry about where to find the next meal/rental payment/etc. leaving no brainpower for what we well-off and spoilt folk would call "constructive pursuits".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mattchew on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:53AM (#9818472)
> Just look at people who inherit or win large sums of money - a few of them end up just enjoying themselves, but most use the money to follow a cause that they think is something worthwhile.

Can you link to the source you're talking about? I'd like to know more about what you're referring to.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by paulhauggis on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:08AM (#9819378)
"a few of them end up just enjoying themselves"

The studies about people that win money that I've seen paint a different picture: 75% lose it all within 5 years by not spending wisely. It's the same with professional sports players and it's gotten so bad, they have started getting them mandatory professional money managers. I believe there is a Netflix documentary about it called "broke".

People that inherit money also end up losing their money at crazy rates unless they already had good money management skills/work for a living/were taught these skills by their parents.

I don't see how this would be any different with a basic income. Not to mention the inflation caused by it. For starters, all businesses will have their prices raised automatically to pay for the new taxes imposed on them.

In the very beginning, it might be okay in terms of economics. However, as the years go on, more and more people will start relying on this basic income and we will have entire generations of people depending on it to live.

Costs will only increase and there will be less people actually contributing to the tax base, so the only way to continue to pay for it is tax increases on the middle class and everyone else making a living. It's basically just another wealth transfer scheme to people that never earned it.

The sad fact is that the vast majority of people never really appreciate things they haven't earned and although a basic income sounds nice in theory, it's a flawed idea that is doomed to fail.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by chimprich on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:43PM (#9820763)
With all due respect, I think you're really confusing two arguments here; that of wealth distribution and the concept of basic income.

The idea of a basic income does not imply a transfer of wealth from the middle class to the poor or indeed anyone. You could set up a basic income system tomorrow in your country of choice and set the level of basic income and tax levels so that everyone, at least in the beginning, was receiving the same amount of cash they were before.

One advantage of the idea is that the poor would be more likely to find work because the marginal reward is so much better, leading to more wealth overall and sharing out the tax burden more. At least in theory.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by paulhauggis on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:26PM (#9821769)
"With all due respect, I think you're really confusing two arguments here; that of wealth distribution and the concept of basic income."

With all due respect, you are only thinking about basic income at step 1. I laid out what will happen at step 10..which is essentially a wealth distribution system.

"You could set up a basic income system tomorrow in your country of choice and set the level of basic income and tax levels so that everyone, at least in the beginning, was receiving the same amount of cash they were before."

Where do you think the money comes from to support a basic income? Who do you think pays for it?

"One advantage of the idea is that the poor would be more likely to find work because the marginal reward is so much better"

How so? Many poor people will be content with not finding work and just living on basic income. Minimum wage will also need to be well above what they are getting from the government, further contributing to inflation.

"leading to more wealth overall and sharing out the tax burden more. At least in theory."

You are only looking at it from one very small part of it.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by gregjwild on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:44PM (#9820411)
> In the very beginning, it might be okay in terms of economics. However, as the years go on, more and more people will start relying on this basic income and we will have entire generations of people depending on it to live.

The problem here is the rate of job automation vs. job creation right now. There's a lot of indicators suggesting we're reaching - or have reached - the tipping point here. We need a strategy for giving people breathing space to adapt to job destruction. That might be a basic income, or a government backed re-training program perhaps. But the latter supposes that there are enough jobs to go for when they re-train. And the one big growth area, IT, is really limited to those with some some degree of innate talent. Think about all those truckers and taxi drivers who are going to see their jobs eliminated by maybe 2030.

[dead]
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dtech on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:46AM (#9817809)
I think you should come out of your elitism bubble and actually interact with some "dumb" people (dumb according to you, you sound like a 1930 eugenics propagator with how you treat IQ).

You'll find that there are a lot of people with drive but lack of opportunities there, just like there are a lot of lazy smart people.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by bitJericho on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:37AM (#9817782)
IQ is not a valid indicator of intelligence.
[dead]
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:44AM (#9817803)
Just provide any reasonable explanation for your claim. I can't imagine any. IQ is a metric that works like this: you do a test on a population, then take the median result and call it IQ 100. If suddenly God Himself put intelligence-enhancing drugs in the rainwater, making everyone smarter than Solomon, you'd still have half of the population below IQ 100.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anon4 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:04AM (#9818911)
dont worry i upvoted u. i couldn't understand what u sayd, but it seemsed bad to just get so very downvoted fer what u believe in.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tormeh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:06AM (#9817648)
I know one single person like that. Wanting this is very rare and is a symptom of mental illness. Most people want to be proud of something. Granted, MacDonald's will have problems finding workers, but is that so bad?

Living in Norway it is perfectly possible to slack off on the taxpayers' bill if you want to, but society doesn't collapse. People would rather avoid the low status associated with living on the dole than avoid work.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mierek4ever on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:30AM (#9817749)
Norway is extremely different than for example US. With all due respect, I'm sorry, I can't see Norwegians happily supporting social programs if they are mostly designed to help immigrants. US is immigration based. What about Norway consisting in 15-20% of Blacks, than the other 80% coming from all over the world. I believe that about 75% of all Americans are immigrants, their children, or their grandchildren. Would you not mind supporting Latinos, Blacks, Poles, Russians, Germans, Brits, Indians, Pakistanis, and whoever else is there in this pot?

I think in Norway it would end up with much worse results than in the US. I think Norwegians in this case would vote for some kind of nazi stuff. It's enough for you to have a few immigrants here and there to become extreme right.

So, please don't compare and don't think you are any better. You are not.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rhizome31 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:54AM (#9817840)
I don't think the point was saying that Norway is better than the US. The point was saying that in Norway, it's already possible to live with tax payers money, but most people choose to work. So based on the assumption that US people are as good as Norwegians, most US people would still choose to work even if they didn't have to.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vidarh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:43AM (#9819182)
> It's enough for you to have a few immigrants here and there to become extreme right.

If you refer to the current government, consider that the junior partner in the current government that is considered "extreme right" by Norwegian standards would mostly be Democrats by US standards. E.g. a substantial proportion of them are in favour of continuing most of a welfare system that would get even many Democrats in hysterics over socialism.

By Norwegian standards, the majority of the US Congress is "extreme right" and threatening "US conditions" is a well established way of scaring people.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by just_had_tea on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:43AM (#9818023)
...in which we learn the real reason you're against UBI—dirty immigrants.

I really fail to see how this can be anything other than an argument for more fair/equal wealth distribution in the world. If most countries had similar schemes, then why would the "good for nothing immigrants" go to supposedly scrounge in the US?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:53AM (#9818055)
If we redistributed wealth around the world, everyone would be poor, unable to start companies, etc etc. Does that really solve anything useful?

You do realise that if you redistributed wealth over the world, you would be drastically worse off don't you...

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by nekopa on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:18PM (#9820617)
If all the world wealth was distributed to everyone on the planet, we'd all get about $51,000.

I'd be drastically better off.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:31PM (#9821802)
Yeah, at that rate, I'd only be very slightly worse off than I am now. Maybe I'd lose... $10k-$20k to Horrifying Socialism. But hey, I could restart my life from a capital base of $51k.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jchrisa on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:48AM (#9819214)
You can take all our money, we'd still have plumbing, fiber, and college degrees.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tiatia on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:49AM (#9819224)
Mate, "The one who speaks the truth needs a fast horse." (Chinese Proverb).

Don't "overunderstimate" the reason of the average reader here and don't be discouraged by the down vote.

"Zwei mal drei macht vier, widewidewitt und drei macht neune, ich mach mir die Welt, widewide wie sie mir gefällt."

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anon4 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:05AM (#9818921)
If everyone is equally worse off, won't it lead to lower prices?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:32PM (#9820701)
That's a lie and you know it. Isn't the refrain parroted here all the time something about bootstrapping your own company? Self funding and all that? While a couple people like you might throw a tantrum and decide not to participate, I imagine there would be 5x that many in poorer places in the world who would be able to more than make up for it and start amazing companies.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by icebraining on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:59AM (#9817615)
It's less socially destructive than many of the jobs I know.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:27PM (#9820669)
No it's not. That's what they do to try and escape the stress from having a shitty job. Which they have to do in order to have a roof over their heads.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by verinus on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:10AM (#9817661)
and my take on people arguing for basic minimum income have not understood the human nature.

communism was doomed from the beginning as they were removing all incentives to do something useful in the long therm.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:01AM (#9817865)
Human nature is people wanting to reap rewards for their work (that includes having private property). UBI doesn't take away that.

Speaking of "removing all incentives to do something useful in the long term", this is what capitalism does today. There aren't many businesses or even people caring about long-term in their lives, because you have to pay your rent next month, you have to be competitive today, you have to reach your company's quarterly goals, etc. Competition makes things inherently short-term. UBI is a way to remove some of the pressure from general population, so you'd have an option to say "fuck it, I'm gonna do something for long-term payoff" and not starve in the process.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by koonsolo on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:35AM (#9818187)
> Human nature is people wanting to reap rewards for their work (that includes having private property). UBI doesn't take away that.

How are you going to pay for UBI? With taxes. If you already receive a tax free UBI, this means the percentage of taxes on your extra income will drastically increase (with factors, not percentages). This means that when you work for someone else (sell your time/products), only a tiny percentage will go into your pocket.

If daycare of your child costs $500, and your full-time job gets you $500, how many people in this situation will drop their job and become a stay at home parents?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by splawn on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:18AM (#9819008)
Good point! More stay at home parents is another benefit of BI that I haven't even thought of yet. I get more sold on this idea the more I read about it.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by koonsolo on Sunday July 05, 2015 @05:24AM (#9833015)
Who is going to pick up the trash, bake bread, repair your car, build your house, build streets, build cars on an assembly line? Less and less people. And less people producing, means less people consuming. Your BI won't be able to support you for very long because prices will increase (less supply). It won't take long before your economy is screwed.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by splawn on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:43AM (#9837459)
I thought BI was mainly a response to the question "What will we do when most menial jobs are automated with better AI?". Tech that could pick up trash, bake bread, repair your car (If owning a car even makes since at that point in the future).. etc. Honestly its all speculation right now. I think its cool that they are doing this experiment right now, but they may be jumping the gun. However, I also think its jumping the gun to assume it will never work.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by koonsolo on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @03:09PM (#9847462)
Yes indeed you are correct, I forgot about that. But in such a case I think it's still a good idea to own plenty of those robots or be able to do something that a robot can't :).
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dtech on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:30AM (#9817753)
There is a huge difference between everyone gets exactly the same regardless of merit* (communism) and everyone gets a guaranteed income on which you can just barely make a living (basic income).

The second doesn't disincentivize working, as you still get increased rewards if you work or work harder.

* Unless you are in a position of power of course, then you deserve more.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vidarh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:07AM (#9819364)
> There is a huge difference between everyone gets exactly the same regardless of merit* (communism)

Everyone getting exactly the same regardless of merit has nothing to do with communism. So much so that Marx spent a lot of time criticising this idea and tearing it totally apart whenever someone raised it (Critique of the Gotha Programme has a substantial section on this subject).

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by xienze on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:39AM (#9818411)
> and everyone gets a guaranteed income on which you can just barely make a living (basic income).

You realize that basic income will just become another campaign promise to secure votes, right? Couple that with "I can barely live on my basic income!" sob stories and we'll quickly find that basic income won't be so "basic" given enough time.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:32AM (#9817532)
Seriously? Do you not think you're in a bubble of 1%ers? Most people aren't itching to start a company you know... Most want to watch American Idol and do nothing.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by wubwubwub on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:55AM (#9817608)
Why does everything have to be an extreme at each end of the spectrum? Either starting companies or doing nothing?

I'd like to believe, possibly naively, that for a lot of people there would be a middle ground. Spending their time on personal growth, creative pursuits, general fitness and well being. In essence, living well.

Just because you're not attempting to start the next social media, it doesn't automatically mean that you have no other interests or internal framework for living.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Loughla on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:51AM (#9818465)
That's exactly what would happen. Many people would transition to part-time jobs to spend time with their families/friends/volunteer or civic organizations they are already involved in.

You can see it when an 'Average Joe' gets a windfall. Anecdotal evidence is all I have, but having observed several people inherit money from older relatives who have passed, the general first focus is on creating free time to spend with family and friends. Then they focus on those organizations they are already involved in. Then they focus on fun nonsense like large TV's and dumb cars.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:17AM (#9817922)
Listen bra, if you're not crushing it you ain't worth .

Welcome to the hyper-individualist bro culture based around status and money. The self-worth crutches for people with low self-esteem/ huge uncontrollable egos.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:56AM (#9817847)
There are also a lot of things that can and need to be done for others (as opposed to personal growth, general fitness, etc.) that don't make sense as companies, or that are perverted beyond recognition when exposed to market pressures. Starting a company is one of many ways of doing things useful to the public, but not the only one.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by merijnv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:59AM (#9817623)
Who says it has to be a company? How about that guy that wants make music but doesn't have the time to practice due to work. The girl that wants to paint, but is to tired after work.

Why does everything have to be about companies and money? Can't you really imagine any useful social, artistic, or other things these "dumb, lazy" people might want to invest their time into? How about just being a stay at home parent and investing more time in their kids? Do you really think society would not improve from any of these things?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:54AM (#9817837)
How about science or engineering? Imagine how it would be if scientists actually had time to read papers in their field, perform experiments and pursue some research goals, instead of cranking paper after paper in order to stay employed?

What about all those social projects that people want to do, but don't have time to really support?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by knodi123 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:48AM (#9819661)
> Imagine how it would be if scientists actually had time to read papers in their field, perform experiments and pursue some research goals

That's part of the reason why most scientists before the 1900s were wealthy men from the upper class.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:04AM (#9817640)
So you want to spend £240 billion pounds, twice the NHS budget in the UK, on helping struggling artists?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by merijnv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:19AM (#9817700)
Struggling everyone. Why the hell is some bank CEO making several hundred million a year and we have people that can't even reliably be home in the evening to tuck their kids in because they're working 5 jobs. I'm all for taxing high-end income (coporate and private) even more to pay for this.

Why would everyone need to work anyway? It's not tenable. A few more years/decades and we'll have automated so much it'll be impossible to actually employ everyone. So unless you suggest we let everyone who is in a now obsolete field starve, I suggest we start thinking of how we're going to manage a society where it's just impossible for everyone to work.

EDIT: Also, where's this 240 billion figure coming from?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:18AM (#9817925)
The level of koolaid here is just too large a mountain to attempt to scale.

Automation will just move a few jobs around, like it always has done. And yes - we don't need jobs. But no - that doesn't mean the state should give everyone free money.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by merijnv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:26AM (#9817963)
> But no - that doesn't mean the state should give everyone free money.

Why not?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:26AM (#9818359)
Because there is no free money. We would all have to pay for it. We would be subsidising laziness.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by merijnv on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:39AM (#9818738)
> Because there is no free money.

Ok, sure.

> We would all have to pay for it.

Well, yes.

> We would be subsidising laziness.

Why is it laziness? As I pointed out, repeatedly, above. There's two ways we can go with this discussion. You can state "There is nothing worth of value, except economic value". If that's what you believe, fine. But I think that is a very shallow and hollow belief and then there is not much sense in further discussion.

Alternatively, you can agree that there are pursuits that, while not producing any economic value, are very valuable to society. Such as arts, social projects, research, etc. and that those of us who are good at maximising economic value (but, most likely not spending as much time/effort in other areas) should subsidise those of us who ARE taking care of our elderly, raising kids, or otherwise fulfilling socially and artistically important roles. In which case we can discuss whether basic income is a good way to accomplish this or whether there are better ways.

And what is so terrible about subsiding laziness? Why do you care? If you have more than enough money to do whatever you want, what does it hurt you that someone manages to "not starve" even though they don't "do anything"? Is that really so bad? You would honestly prefer thousands, if not millions, starving to avoid "subsidising laziness"?

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by robmcm on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:04AM (#9817638)
The irony that you chose American Idol as the TV show is delightful. It's a prime example of people often from impoverished background trying to better them selves rather than sitting around doing nothing :)
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by notahacker on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:18AM (#9817694)
Alternatively you could interpret American Idol as people spending one day a year pursuing an unlikely dream of lavish wealth before going back to the couch to see how the few contestants that made it through get on :)

I'm not sure "practising for reality TV shows" falls into the category of self-actualisation I'm particularly keen to uproot the economy as we know it to fund.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:36PM (#9820727)
Wouldn't that be similar to startup culture, though?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by celticninja on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:13AM (#9817678)
I think you need to define most. Where is your sample data? You have a biased opinion and you are sticking to it it seems.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:34PM (#9820712)
The more I read your posts, the more I imagine you're just someone who's scared that they won't be able to have a bunch of employees paid minimum wage at his beck and call, that he can treat however he wants because they're dependent on him for a job.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by JulianMorrison on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:29AM (#9817744)
Wrong. The majority isn't lazy, the majority is rebelling, in a passive-aggressive way. Faced with a job that they easily recognize as worthless economic make-work, they do as little of it as they must. Faced with having their mental energy drained down to nearly nothing, they prefer no-effort recreational activities like TV.

Basic income will unleash a temporary plague of laziness, as people snatch back control of their own life, raise a middle finger to the world that has hurt them, and seek comfort activities and recuperation. This will continue for a month or two, and then they'll get intolerably antsy for something constructive to do. It's at this point that you'll start to see how much human creativity was stomped upon by "the 9-to-5".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by fwn on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:55AM (#9817845)
Isn't that the atlas shrugged plot, just mirrored?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by icebraining on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:12AM (#9818116)
I've only read summaries, but I don't see the similarities, except in a very general sense, maybe.

I'd say it's closer to the ideas defended by the Situationists.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by beeglebug on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:27AM (#9817516)
Communism: "A theory or system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community, and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs."

Basic Income: "An income unconditionally granted to all on an individual basis, without means test or work requirement."

I dunno, they sound pretty different to me.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:11PM (#9821657)
I can make it more clear.

Communism: From each according to his ability; to each according to his need.

Basic Income: From each according to his willingness to work; to each according to his need, plus a share of society's surplus production proportionate to the market value of his contributions.

In the event where people are as a whole unwilling to contribute an amount greater than necessary to meet everyone's basic needs, Basic Income is very similar to Communism. There is no additional incentive to work harder, because any excess you produce is immediately applied to the shortfall. If you really bust your ass instead of skating by, everyone gets an extra roll of toilet paper this year.

If people are generally willing to contribute more than is strictly necessary to keep everyone else alive and healthy, they are very different. Once everyone reaches that critical tipping point, additional voluntary effort is rewarded by the ability to get things you want in addition to the things you need. And that is probably incentive enough to keep the economy from tipping back into "looks like Communism" mode. If you bust your ass instead of skating by, you, personally, can get your very own expensive thingamabob. And that allows someone else to work a job making those expensive thingamabobs, which in turn allows them to get an uncheap doohickey.

As such, it seems rather important to always calculate the "needs" in such a way that people are always incentivized to work, or to work harder than they otherwise would.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by kentt on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:50AM (#9817591)
There are different if course. I think other people are saying they have very similar flaws, not that they are the same.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:36AM (#9817547)
So in effect Basic Income is even worse as it doesn't means test recipients. If you're a billionaire, the state is still going to give you money.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mkingston on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:51AM (#9817596)
Yes, but the state will take more than it gives from the billionaire. This is actually more bureaucratically efficient than manually means testing every possible recipient.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:59AM (#9817619)
How would they take more from the billionaire? Means test them? What if they're asset rich, cash poor... or if they have no income? The whole idea is unworkable. It's like it's been dreamed up by a 5 year old.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by dtech on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:51AM (#9817827)
> How would they take more from the billionaire?

We have this obscure system that has been around for a few thousand years to do this. It's called "taxes".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mkingston on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:07AM (#9817652)
In the current system, yes. But at least we do away with one set of means testing. I would actually argue for a flat tax rate in the presence of a basic income. As for "asset rich, cash poor, no income" there are plenty of ideas out there for capital or capital gains taxes.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by bitJericho on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:41AM (#9817796)
The point of it is that our technology is far outpacing our own capabilities, and pretty soon you'll have to literally become a robot in order to compete for basic income. Instead of allowing only the 1 percent of the rich people to own everybody else, we'll have them pay for everyone to live comfortably so they can do good works, while the rich continue to have their robots do all the work. Everybody wins.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by jon-wood on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:46AM (#9817583)
So what if some people decide to use their money to watch TV all day? Its a trade off, in return for some people being able to do things improving society they couldn't have done otherwise, or being able to spend time with their kids rather than work a bullshit job which mostly pays for childcare so they can do their job, we have to put up with a few people having more reality TV to bore us about in the pub. Sounds good to me.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:08AM (#9817885)
Not to mention all the jobs that are socially destructive and other jobs created to counteract the results of the former.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mrottenkolber on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:52AM (#9817831)
Unless you cite any scientific sources I am going to be blunt here: You are dead wrong. About every point you try to make. Its exactly the other way around. Give people minimum wage with no perspective and they will learn to love the TV. Give people opportunities to be creative and they will flourish.

Be under no illusion: the reason why our culture is so fucked up and our common psyche is so damaged is the capitalist system, that robs humankind of its humanity by stripping humankind of its dignity. We are not cheap resources. We have rights.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:00AM (#9817862)
Communism is something else entirely (C & P from wiki: "is a socioeconomic order structured upon the common ownership of the means of production, absence of social classes, money, and the state."). Clearly we can see that UBI is not communism by I will take the bait anyways.

Every single person I know has a passion they would pursue outside of work. Some of them would be productive for society (startups or SME's) and some would be largely neutral (self-indulging in sports for example) but none would be destructive. Contrasting that to their work lives I have witnessed some of them taking part in activities that are largely destructive to society because it is the only thing that will put food on the table. Surviving at a minimum level of comfort should not be merit based. Living in opulence perhaps but not at bare minimum level.

Finally with your last point if society is stabilized through UBI and we leave behind our guilt based protestant work ethic and crime through desperation ridden society I can't see how I would be worse off. I would be able to pursue any project I deemed worthy (even some that are not profitable but would have a profoundly positive impact on society) and not fear financial ruin. The quality of society would improve and therefore the quality of life for everyone also.

Your post is heavily emotional but full of glaring factual inaccuracies that reflect on you more than they reflect on society itself.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by msvalkon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:24AM (#9817508)
It seems to me you are not entirely objective on this. The studies (also mentioned in this article) seem to contradict your view.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by nshepperd on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:33AM (#9817763)
> Communism (Which is what this is), has failed. Why this generation seems determined to try it again is beyond me.

Isn't communism about central economic planning? Basic income is explicitly capitalist. No-one decides who ought to do what. We just distribute money, and let the market determine what to fund with it.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:11AM (#9817897)
Exactly.

Though because you bring up central planning - I think that we should reconsider this idea. In a technological society, central planning run by supercomputers executing global optimization algorithms doesn't sound like that bad of an idea. Historically, central planning failed mostly because there was no way for flesh and blood humans to react fast enough and to optimize well enough (that and usual human corruption). Not to mention we didn't have properly developed optimization theory before the 60s.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by anticon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:12AM (#9818572)
It's extremely funny how every argument for Basic Income completely ignores the fact you will have to centrally plan how you're going to get all this endless money to give people. You're going to decide where to raise taxes.

The other problem is that if implemented, any future elections would boil down to which party is going to raise basic income the most (Bribing the electorate).

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by SCdF on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:26AM (#9817723)
> This is about stealing money from the successful, and giving it to everyone, regardless of merit. It's a fantastic way to reward failure and penalise success,

That implies that being poor is a product of a personal 'failure'. Sometimes it is. From what I understand though, the vast majority of times it's not. Much like the vast majority of wealthy people aren't wealthy because they really worked at it, but because maybe they worked at it and mostly they were given opportunities that the less fortunate weren't.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by Altay- on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:26AM (#9817965)
I believe you are making yourself upset by arguing from the point of the ideal.

Its not a matter of meritocracy vs basic income. Its the current welfare state vs basic income.

People like you and I are already paying loads of money to the masses in the form of (from an American perspective) Food Stamps, continued Federal make-work programs (like the USPS/military), Social Security, Disability Insurance, Medicare/Medicaid, etc.

Just as a freebie example, The US spends ~$3000 per capita on its military. Cut that in half and give everyone $1500/year no strings attached. That alone would relieve a lot of stress for a large percent of Americans.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by laurentoget on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:05PM (#9821272)
Add to this the money you are paying to pay police, prisons, security systems, and insurance to protect yourself against petty crime.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pknight on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:09AM (#9818101)
No one's arguing that only a small percentage of people are geared toward pursuing high risk/high cost opportunities. But it's not really relevant to the idea of basic income or an indictment of the majority.

The vast majority are happiest when they are doing meaningful work, not by sitting on the couch and eating ice cream while being void of engaging work. This is true for people of all walks of life, the super bright, the super disciplined, the super motivated as well as the other end and everything in between. The concept of basic income would free people to pursue engaging work. Meaningful work does not have to come in the form of trying to cure diseases or build sky scrapers, or start a tech company.

Meaningful work is abundant and not limited by the arbitrary limitations created by a material-consumption-based society what was ushered in by the industrial age, which for the the majority has dictated what is economically viable to make a living. Meaningful work can come in the form of volunteering, gardening, looking after elders, helping the environment, creating beautiful neighbourhoods, social support, skilled crafts, the list is endless and not limited to people with above average intelligence or motivation. Right now these types of endeavours are not economically sustaining for people to focus on.

Given that technology will drastically cut down the amount of jobs required it is beyond obvious that the current orthodoxy just isn't applicable in tomorrow's world. It is obvious today and it's only get worse tomorrow. Autonomous cars and trucks alone will kill millions of jobs, how do these people find economically viable jobs? Office jobs will decline at an exponential pace, because there will be no economically viable reason to employ people for work that is done more efficiently by software.

Given that we can actually sustain billions of people's material needs with most of the work being done by our tools, rather than people, it is complete lunacy to handicap the population by limiting it because the majority won't actually be able to find economically viable work according to yesterday's economy. It is also completely arbitrary. The conditions have changed dramatically and the sooner we adjust the system to fit the new conditions, the better.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by mkingston on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:59AM (#9817617)
What is merit?

“What then! Do you think the old practice, that ‘they should take who have the power, and they should keep who can,’ is less iniquitous, when the power has become power of brains instead of fist?” - John Ruskin.

Practically, I believe you have an argument (though it may not be correct). But I think it's worth reassessing your moral framework: if there's any correlation between wealth and moral worth I expect that's purely a consequence of an increased ability of those with greater resources to act morally; a lifestyle choice.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by halviti on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:26AM (#9817515)
Translation: "Society at large has no value, it is up to the strong to take from the many and cull the weak."
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by fsloth on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:33AM (#9818385)
I'm not sure what you are getting at. Basic income is a form of income transfer -a practice that is considered civilized and expected of modern nation states in a scale or another. This is not communism. It is to enable stable societies with people who are content and not prone to be recruited for an armed mob for populist causes.

Income transfers were implemented as tools to block communism by no one else than the benevolent, friend of the people, Iron-Friggin-Chancelor Bismarck, not because of fairness, but of social stability.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by nabla9 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:54AM (#9817601)
Most successful North European countries can implement basic income in cost neutral way. For example, in Finland 560 EUR basic income would not increase overall taxation.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rorykoehler on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:19AM (#9817930)
Didn't know this. Do you have any links to find out more about this please?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by tonyedgecombe on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:26AM (#9817724)
"Communism (Which is what this is), has failed."

No it isn't, communism is a form of government, which in theory everybody is equal.

Basic income is a variant of welfare / taxes.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by thomnottom on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:56AM (#9818862)
> This is about stealing money from the successful, and giving it to everyone, regardless of merit. It's a fantastic way to reward failure and penalise success, and society will suffer because of it.

Then those people starting companies you mentioned are not interested in creating things; they are interested in making money.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by andruby on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:29AM (#9817526)
This is not communism. Not at all. Don't confuse socialism with communism.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by afsina on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:01AM (#9817867)
Socialism and Communism are "almost" the same thing.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by kriro on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:43AM (#9818022)
I think the basic argument for testing this is that in the future it might very well be the case that only a small portion of society can do "meaningfull work". Think of an AI future or a vastly automated one.

Sure one solution is pushing the wages of say a factory worker up so it's enough to sustain them. In reality we'll probably reach a point where lots of manual labor jobs shouldn't rationally be done by humans. It's a very hard problem to solve imo and naive "comperative advantage though" isn't the answer.

I mean I can see a ton of reasons against base incomes but I also don't see many good answers for a scenario where say half the currently working population could be "optimized away".

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by belorn on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:03AM (#9817636)
With just basic income, how will the majority afford buying a TV or ice cream? Neither of those two products are basic necessities, and ice cream specifically is kind of expensive and would require a job in order to be afforded.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by vidarh on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:26AM (#9819062)
> The majority are lazy, and if given money, will sit watching reality TV and stuffing their face with ice cream.

I'm sure you can cite evidence of this claim from basic income pilot programs, then? (there has been a few).

> Most people are also selfish. The idea that they'll all start doing things to benefit others is a bit far fetched.

Here we agree, but it's beside the point as there's a very good reason for them to do things to benefit themselves that will have the side effect of benefiting others:

They'll make more money. The point of basic income programs is to create a lower threshold that is predictable, simple to administer and unconditional. It's not to create a ceiling on income.

> Communism (Which is what this is), has failed.

This is quite comical, because it has nothing to do with communism, and indeed the idea predates socialism by about 300 years.

It has over the centuries had supporters spanning large parts of the political spectrum. One of the important aspects of basic income is that it is not particularly ideological in its basic form:

There's no implication that the basic income is meant for widespread redistribution, though some proponents wants it to be high enough for that. Many proponents, in fact, specifically makes the argument that done properly it may potentially reduce government expenditure by eliminating a whole host of benefits programs that are expensive to run and hence cut administrative costs. This is an argument often made by liberalists (as in classical liberals by the European definition) for example.

In fact, if you were to push for a form of basic income that would be high enough to make it something most people would happily live on if they could otherwise work, it would be fundamentally at odds with Marx ideas of communism. In "Critique of The Gotha Programme" he skewered the idea that communism involved equal pay, by pointing out that this would be extremely unfair:

People have different needs. Instead, according to Marx, the goal for a communist society should be from each according to ability, to each according to need - in other words: while a basic income could fit within a communist framework, as the only source of income it would just create different problems: it would overpay people who choose to not contribute even though they are able to, and would underpay people with special needs.

This, incidentally is also the reason pretty much no proponents - regardless where they fall on the political spectrum - advocate a basic income that is particularly high. It's called basic income for a reason.

Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by pknight on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:17AM (#9818134)
And even if your dim view of people is true - that all but a minority of people are so lazy they would all just sit on the couch and do nothing - it would not matter. When our tools are providing all of what the population needs, what is the realist, capitalist, economic argument for employing them?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday July 02, 2015 @11:30AM (#9819535)
So you oppose selfishness when the masses do it, but support it when Startup Ubermenschen do it?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by rwmj on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:34AM (#9817994)
What you say may or may not be true, but such a sweeping statement about humanity needs to be backed up with facts. Has anyone studied whether people are generally lazy?
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by megalodon on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:13AM (#9817676)
Are you that scared that it might work? It's a social experiment carried out by the government, not judgement day. Let's see what result it produces before rejecting it.
Re:A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic incom... by s73v3r on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:24PM (#9820651)
"People starting companies are driven, determined people who want to create things."

Most of them are also extremely lucky in that they either don't need things like healthcare, or don't have families.

"This is about stealing money from the successful"

No, it's not. Those people would not have been successful in the first place if not for the advantages and benefits they had growing up in a first world country.