News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by torrent-of-ions on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:23AM (#9492306)
I grew up in the suburbs and hated it. I hated the idea of having to go long distances to get milk and eggs. I'm happy now in a city centre.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by greggman on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:22AM (#9492975)
I grew up in the suburbs and loved it. It was safe. I was allowed to go miles in any direction. I'd go 5 miles to Disneyland or 9 miles to El Dorado Park. I'd ride 3 miles to Knott's Berry Farm or 3 miles the closest mall. I could launch model rockets at the local school. There was some dirt patches where kids would make berms for riding their bikes on. My friends were all within a couple of miles. We'd play D&D and use peanut M&Ms as monsters. There was a bunch of hobbit stores just a mile away where I got model rocket parts and other hobby things.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by aswanson on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:00PM (#9493552)
How could someone who grew up in a suburb where he could buy rockets from Bilbo Baggins, et al, not have a fun childhood? :) Seriously though, I hated the suburb I grew up in. Something happens around 12-13 where kids need a change from the early childhood setting, I think. It was a great place for that time period was was too small of a world after that.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by locustreign on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:45PM (#9493464)
You grew up very close to me and I'm still playing D&D! I don't mind the suburbs at all, I'm very content having access to Los Angeles (with a bit of a drive) and then not have to worry about where to find parking at night when I get home.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by symkat on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:34PM (#9494446)
You just captured my early teens -- I lived up and down Beach Blvd in the La Habra to Anaheim area from the time I was 5-6 until my mid-teens, and then spent a lot of time in Huntington Beach.

I never really thought of it as the suburbs at the time. Thanks!

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by nkozyra on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:34AM (#9492357)
I have this feeling that kids tend to hate where they grow up due to all of the perceived failings and things they're missing out on.

I grew up in a relaxed beach town in Florida, and hated it. My family all moved from NYC and fell in love in a heartbeat.

Something about not being in the same place for too long applies here, too.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mod on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:49AM (#9493119)
I grew up in a relaxed beach town in Florida (Venice), and I liked it pretty well--but all of my peers hated it.

"There's nothing to do here."

I just thought "seriously? We have everything but a theme park." Go carts, beaches, movies, skating rinks, arcades, everything!

I've since learned that kids say that no matter where they live, seemingly.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by Nicholas_C on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:32PM (#9494431)
I have a similar anecdote. My parents moved from the country into practically the middle of Austin and took my little brother with them. He always complains how there is nothing to do in Austin and he wishes he still lived out in the country where we're from. Which is ridiculous, because there is never nothing to do in Austin!
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by vitd on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:07PM (#9493960)
I grew up in Flint, MI in the 80s. We didn't just think it was the worst place in the country to live – Rand McNally actually rated it as the worst place in the country to live!

But teen angst aside, I got a really good education, and had a lot of fun and opportunities growing up. (I actually lived in the suburbs of Flint and my family was middle class, so that probably helped.) I hated it at the time, but I can see the good and the bad now that I'm removed from it. I don't think I could ever go back, but there were positives despite its problems.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by longlivegnu on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:09PM (#9493974)
As a software engineer near Venice FL in his early 20s there isn't a lot to do here still. I guess some people do enjoy going to the beach a lot but it definitely gets old.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mod on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @08:01PM (#9495797)
Great outdoor activities (saltwater & freshwater fishing, myakka river, camping, pretty awesome parks, beach obviously). I personally hate the beach--sand, salt, and sunburn are three of my least favorite things.

Venice YMCA has a ton of offerings--rock wall, skate park, basketball gym, adult leagues, etc.

You have pretty much every other normal amenity, like theaters & community college.

Tampa isn't far for theme parks, concerts, etc.

You're missing having a hometown bar scene, but those aren't too far anyway (and the 20-somethings make do with what's available, anyway).

What do you feel like you're missing?

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by kenrikm on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:46PM (#9493465)
Grew up in Fort Lauderdale (city) and my family owned land over in Everglades City (country) where we would go and enjoy the outdoors. Swimming fishing and boating in the 10,000 islands. Overall I actually had a pretty good childhood. A few years ago I moved to the Bay Area and do like it here. However recently I've been looking to purchase some land just outside the Bay Area to build a small cabin and grow a garden,and enjoy the outdoors. I feel like it's important that my son not just grow up in an apartment playing on playgrounds with rubberized ground so he does not hurt himself.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by declan on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:32PM (#9493750)
>I've been looking to purchase some land just outside the Bay Area to build a small cabin...

You can do this in the Bay Area itself, though in general the closer you want to be to a supermarket, bank, etc. the more you'll pay. If you're west of Palo Alto, Los Altos, Mountain View, Cupertino and cross the 280, you encounter rural areas very quickly. And if you head far enough into the hills, prices begin to fall rapidly relative to flatland prices.

Near Boulder Creek, for instance, you can get 2 acres for $52K that's three miles from a shopping area: https://www.redfin.com/CA/San-Lorenzo-Valley/0-HARMON-GULCH-...

That's 23 miles from Cupertino via route 17 and smaller roads. Of course it helps if you enjoy living in the middle of the woods!

I've posted about this concept on HN before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9437492

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by kenrikm on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:45PM (#9494510)
Yup, also if you head south you get more open ground and the prices fall rapidly. For example I found a some land within an hour of San Jose with 100acres for 200k. The trick is finding a lot with good water access. I'm up in San Mateo so it's a bit more of a drive. Ideally I could get somthing within an hour and a half drive at a reasonable price.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by declan on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @04:18PM (#9494697)
That's cheaper than I thought it would be! But if you're trying to get to a job in San Mateo from someplace like Gilroy or Hollister, that would be a bit of a hellish commute. Maybe you could pull it off more easily if you work off-hours? Also if you're within an hour's drive of San Jose you may be paying Silicon Valley prices for new construction, which tends not to be cheap.

But if you're willing to live that far from work and can find water and a nice lot, I'd give it a try. Also with a private pilot certificate you could fly an older ~$20K Cessna from South County or Hollister to KSQL pretty quickly on most days -- certainly a fraction of your effective groundspeed in 101 traffic -- and bike from there to work.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sedachv on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @06:51PM (#9495504)
Thanks a lot for the airplane tip, I had no idea you could get a decent Cessna 172 for 20-30k. That would certainly be an awesome commute.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by declan on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:51PM (#9496341)
Quite welcome! Engineers (I take it you are one) seem to make natural pilots, in my experience.

I don't own a plane but have in the post thought idly about commuting to the SF bay area from the Sierras. I've heard of pilots doing it from Pine Mountain Lake in the foothills, for instance, and a faster plane would make living in Nevada doable.

Trade-A-Plane lists 145 Cessnas for sale under $30K, though most in that range are 152s. There are a few older 172s: http://www.trade-a-plane.com/detail/aircraft/Single+Engine+P...

It would be nice to have the additional capacity of a 172, especially if you want to (a) fly with two friends, for three people total or (b) you're a large or heavy person yourself, which might exceed the maximum payload of a 152 with a similarly large or heavy flight instructor or passenger. Also I don't think 152s can be IFR certified.

It is kinda funny that these older Cessnas are now cheaper than the average car! Anyway, good luck on your project!

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by dougmccune on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @06:04PM (#9495289)
If you're in the Bay Area and want your kid exposed to less sheltered play spaces, there's the Adventure Playground in Berkeley, where kids can get tokens for collecting rusty nails and then trade them in for paint to paint all the play structures. http://www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/adventureplayground/
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by Immortalin on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:34AM (#9492679)
After all, the grass is always greener on the other side..
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by M8 on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:48PM (#9493477)
And that is why our species is present on all continents.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by jefurii on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:12PM (#9493623)
Except in California.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by pjmorris on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:33AM (#9493027)
I also grew up in a relaxed beach town in Florida, and hated it (then).

I've moved to larger, and larger, and larger cities since, pursuing academia and career, and they have their charms and I'm glad I went. But now I miss the beach town, and hope to get back. I guess we are the sum of our experiences. Maybe the feeling you're missing out helps by driving you to seek new things out.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by silverbax88 on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:45AM (#9492731)
I was born in a large city and we moved to a rural area when I was in grade school. We lived there for years and it was okay, but when I was a teenager I moved out at 16 and made my way back to the big city.

I never moved back to the country. Okay to visit, but fuck that, I realized quickly that I much preferred the city over the country.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by coldtea on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:04AM (#9492854)
>I have this feeling that kids tend to hate where they grow up

Even so, you don't hear as many kids hating on the big city as they hate on the suburbs or the countryside.

I mean, kids hatred for the suburbs have inspired tons of movies and songs, for the city, not so much.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by xrange on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:36PM (#9494459)
>Even so, you don't hear as many kids

>tons of movies and songs

...this seems like self-selection bias, similar to I don't know anyone who voted for "X" in the last election. I'd present the country and western music genre as a counter-point, where there is a preference for non-urban living.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by coldtea on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @07:25PM (#9495638)
>...this seems like self-selection bias, similar to I don't know anyone who voted for "X" in the last election. I'd present the country and western music genre as a counter-point, where there is a preference for non-urban living.

Not many teenagers listen to "country and western"...

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by brianwawok on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:11AM (#9492910)
Really? My daughter hated the big city. "I can't even go outside alone".

Who knows, maybe she will move back when she is 20 and love it.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by tlear on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:35AM (#9493040)
Thats a problem with messed up North American culture. Kids should be able to go outside by themselves in cities. They do exactly that all over the world. In places much more dangerous then normal city in US. I commuted to school at age of 9, having to switch streetcars and walk for 15 mins. Total time of about 40 mins one way. Often I would walk back through the city instead, this would take about 2 hours of wondering through city of more then 2 million. I love cities, but I also love countryside in different way. I despise suburbs.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by coldtea on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:03PM (#9493218)
>Thats a problem with messed up North American culture. Kids should be able to go outside by themselves in cities. They do exactly that all over the world

They did exactly that in the US too, up until the eighties -- and at a time when cities had crime rates even higher than today.

There is this nice article from the Austin Chronicle about it (pdf):

http://michaelventura.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/This-Is...

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by tlear on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:58PM (#9494248)
yeah I was talking about present, it is really weird why this change happened
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by brianwawok on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:40PM (#9493439)
I mean a 2-8 year old in Chicago? I consider myself not a helicopter parent.. but that seems like bad news.

Now living in a smaller town.. she can go up and down the block alone. Not worried about it. Chicago was different. We had drug dealers living a block away, and a shooting about once per week. (And this was in a middle of the road neighborhood)

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by coldtea on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:04PM (#9493239)
Well, if she's much smaller than 20 (basically: not a teenager interested in boys and music and such yet), then this does't apply. And of course there are always exceptions to the rule...
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by philbarr on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:30AM (#9492340)
I never understood that about America. I've been lost in the suburbs in Michigan once, driving along for ages with just house after house after house, and thinking, "where's the local shop?"

Surely it's got to be worth someone setting up a local shop every couple of miles?

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mietek on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:54AM (#9492469)
Apparently, it’s not permitted:

> In North-American zoning, zones clearly specify which use is allowed on it. In general, zones allow only one or two uses. For example, a residential single-family detached home zone tolerates only single-family detached houses. Don't try to put a convenience store or a school in one, nor a duplex.

http://urbankchoze.blogspot.co.uk/2014/04/japanese-zoning.ht...

Previous discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8540845

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:24AM (#9492622)
This is purely a suburban problem and typical of the short sightedness of suburban development, which often corrupts the political process because a mandated retail lot is one less high-profit residential home they can't sell.

Here in the city, there are shops everywhere. Mix use residential is fairly common with retail on the ground floor and condos/apartments up top. This has created a glut of storefronts with varying results. Its nice to have all these shops, but the glut of small storefronts means much lowered rents than before so a lot of fly-by-night businesses take over, and in my opinion, hurt the neighborhood like pawn shops, yet another open 4am tattoo shop, yet another shitty independent cricket/boost reseller, yet another liquor convenience store, yet another e-cig store, yet another detailing/hand carwash, yet another gourmet-style restaurant that will fold in 12 months, etc. Desireable shops like Trader Joes or Nordstrom can't open in those tiny and no parking storefronts so its high margin retail junk.

This isn't as common anymore -- thank god, but when I was a kid, every other residential block in Chicago had a corner bar. A few nice, but most just depressing places full of serious drunks causing problems all through the night. So yeah, being too liberal with business licenses isn't so great.

So this kind of thing cuts both ways, but yes, in the suburbs its especially bad. But at least they have the roads and capacity to handle it and their shopping centers are massive, which is nice as you can park at a giant mall or strip mall and get everything you need done. I can't do that, I have no giant structures like this remotely near me. In the city, we need closer stores because of how bad traffic and parking are. If suburban driving was this bad then they'd have the political impetus to change zoning.

tldr; city planning is hard and political.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by akgerber on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:05PM (#9493579)
It's mostly a zoning problem— for whatever reason, America treasures areas of purely single-family homes, probably because it creates an economic barrier that enforces a general demographic sameness in an area. That means that, even if you wanted to open a corner store in a neighborhood by building a storefront at the base of a house, as was traditional in the United States (e.g. http://www.moline.il.us/images/pages/N716/1403%207th%20Ave%2... ) it'd be illegal.

And Trader Joe's can and does operate in no-parking storefronts in sufficiently dense neighborhoods.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mgob on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:29PM (#9493380)
Those fly-by-night establishments are what keep a neighborhood vibrant at night, though. I understand that's not what everyone is looking for, but all else being equal, a populated neighborhood is safer than an empty one.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:49PM (#9493492)
In my neck of the woods, population density is not an issue. The decision by condo developers to dedicate the bottom floor to small retail storefronts has surprisingly become quite disruptive!

I don't consider pawn shops and e-cig shops keeping things vibrant. Nice bars and clubs, restaurants, and unique retail do. Personally, I think pawn shops and payday loan stores are predatory and should be highly regulated if not eliminated. High margin junk like that edges out nicer stores because condo associations just want to go with the quick cash. For example, a lot of women here would love more boutique stores but the rent these stores can afford is being edged out by the guy selling $50 e-cigs. Then the e-cig market will normalize, crash, and these guys will go away, but we've chased off the boutique crowd and our neighborhood is now known for e-cigs, pawnshops, and tattoo parlours. That isn't terribly appealing, especially in Chicago where we have world-class tattoo artists within a short CTA ride away. Why go with the local shady scratcher on the corner? In other words, we are already vibrant.

I do very much like that we have mixed zoning bringing some unique things like a very nice comic book shop and lots of interesting small restaurants that would otherwise have a hard time renting a proper stand-alone brick and mortar store. I think this is all working itself out or will in the long run. I've already seen multiple shady convenience stores go out of business, but that's largely because we won't give them liquor licenses as there are already enough liquor outlets within walking distance. I think one of the vape lounges died recently too and newer development seems to be attracting a higher caliber of business. Maybe the low end high margin stuff is maximized for our neighborhood at this point? Or maybe condo associations are learning that its within their interests to be more discriminating and vetting businesses that might affect their property values, the neighborhood feel, neighborhood safety, etc.

I'm okay letting the market sort it out, but I think its fair to say that all this sudden cheap retail space in an gentrifying urban neighborhood can be disrupting in a bad way until things get sorted out. The argument above that the suburbs should accept this model without criticism is weak sauce. I've lived in poorer suburbs that saw their city counterparts do well with heavy retail and became more liberal with business licenses and now these suburbs just became liquor store, payday loan, and fast food havens. Large blocks of residential with no retail in the suburbs is a feature, not a bug. They're trying to avoid these and other problems (noise, traffic, etc) by segregating the two. Its actually a smart approach if you have the land and the roads to pull it off. If you guys are unhappy in the suburbs because of that, then come join us in the city.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sedachv on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @07:06PM (#9495557)
> High margin junk like that edges out nicer stores because condo associations just want to go with the quick cash. For example, a lot of women here would love more boutique stores but the rent these stores can afford is being edged out by the guy selling $50 e-cigs.

I don't understand, you just claimed the rent is too low, now you are saying it's too high for boutiques.

> I'm okay letting the market sort it out.

You just wrote 4 paragraphs on why you're not ok with letting the market sort it out. The "market" (people who live in your neighborhood) is obviously supporting this "high margin junk." Maybe your neighbors aren't interested in overpriced boutique crap?

> Or maybe condo associations are learning that its within their interests to be more discriminating and vetting businesses that might affect their property values, the neighborhood feel, neighborhood safety, etc.

Let me tl;dr your post for you - "I don't like poor people."

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by josinalvo on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:46PM (#9496329)
you, dear friend, are assuming too much
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by wcummings on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:20PM (#9493683)
I'd way rather have walking access to smaller independent grocers and bodegas than a mediocre specialty food store like Trader Joes with a big parking lot.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by juliangregorian on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @04:24PM (#9494733)
Where I live, we're swimming in "bodegas", which are full of soda, canned food, processed white bread -- nothing you'd want to eat. Most of the people who can afford to or who commute shop at... Trader Joe's.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:27PM (#9493723)
Except we're swimming in those. We actually lack the the goofier franchise stores.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by rayiner on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @06:26PM (#9495395)
Some of the worst traffic in the country is in the suburbs. I'd rather drive in Manhattan than Northern Virginia.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by maxsilver on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:04AM (#9492516)
It's usually heavily frowned upon to setup a local shop in Michigan like that, and sometimes illegal.

Retail creates undesirable traffic and crime (at least, that's their common assumption). The suburbs fight hard to keep that as far away from residential areas as possible.

Sometimes they push this to the logical extreme conclusion -- zoning commercial spaces almost exclusively at the edge of their limits.

Here's examples of the actual zoning permitted in Kentwood and Grandville, (suburbs of Grand Rapids, Michigan).

http://www.ci.kentwood.mi.us/CityOfKentwood/media/files/orig...

http://www.cityofgrandville.com/images/pdf/Zoning%20Map%20Ap...

On both maps, you'll see almost all of the red (commercial) areas are near various edge boundaries, and there's little-to-no commercial activity allowed near any central neighborhood(s).

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sliverstorm on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:39PM (#9494137)
It's not for everyone (including me), but there is a certain serenity to a nice suburb with no traffic, small streets, kempt housing, kids wandering around, and faces you recognize. Corporate retail is the antithesis of that vision. A small gas station or tiny corner store is pushing it.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mtbcoder on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:51AM (#9492447)
In the Midwest, suburbs are designed and developed around the car and the "local shops" are generally located in a series of strip malls off the major roads. On the coasts and in denser populated areas, there seems to be a renewed push for more walk-able areas, public transit and such though.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by narrator on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:07AM (#9492532)
I'll tell you the real, but awful, reason why we have such restrictive zoning in the U.S. The idea behind zoning is to make sure that different classes and races don't have to see each other if they don't want to. Putting commercial retail in a residential area would give outsiders an excuse to be there. The whole "white flight" from the cities has left it's mark on zoning ever since the 1960s. IMHO, this is also the reason for really bad public transit.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by zrail on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:21AM (#9492608)
> IMHO, this is also the reason for really bad public transit.

This is an undisputed fact, as people in those communities will readily protest the "crime train" coming through their neighborhoods.[1][2]

[1]: http://lewwaters.com/2012/05/22/light-rail-likely-to-raise-v...

[2]: http://larslarson.com/would-you-trust-your-kid-on-the-crime-...

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by pnathan on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:46PM (#9493470)
That's horrifying. 'specially as I thought Portland area had good transit!
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by zrail on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:11PM (#9493612)
Don't get me wrong, Portland has excellent transit. However, a very large number of people who work in Portland actually live in Vancouver, WA. Those commuters strenuously object to running light rail over any proposed replacement bridges for the more than 100 year old trestles that currently handle all of that traffic. In addition, commuters to the south of the city limits also strenuously object to light rail running into their neighborhoods.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sedachv on Saturday May 09, 2015 @03:40PM (#9517432)
If you thought that was nuts, check out this anti-subway video produced by Beverly Hills NIMBYs on behalf of the Beverly Hills High School:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81tihdzaecc

This is the same high school that has a huge active oil derrick in the middle of campus:

http://www.nileguide.com/destination/blog/los-angeles/2010/0...

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by logfromblammo on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:32PM (#9494090)
Zoning was invented as a reaction to the Equitable Building in NYC, which was built with no setbacks, effectively bricking over all of its neighbors' windows.

That was the camel's nose under the tent, and organizations influenced by the Ku Klux Klan used zoning laws as a tool for enforcing segregation at a municipal level.

Zoning has been leaving its dirty mark since the 1920s.

Nowadays, you can probably just mentally substitute "colored" wherever you see "multi-family" or "high density", to get a sense of the original wording of the laws. The zoning map for my municipality actually uses the color brown for multi-family residential zones, and a light peach color for single-family & detached residential!

That may be an unfortunate coincidence. Zoning is probably much more about class boundaries than race now. Rich people don't want poor people walking past their houses. Or driving past them. Or seeing them. Or knowing they exist.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by Snesker on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @08:00PM (#9495792)
>The idea behind zoning is to make sure that different classes and races don't have to see each other if they don't want to.

What's wrong with that? It's what they want.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:05PM (#9493580)
Americans are big optimizers. Our retail has gone big for logistical and economy of scale reasons. Paradoxically, this is how we are frugal while maintaining a nod to consumerism. For a complex set of reasons ( much of which involves how our tax system works ) , we tend to separate housing space from business space unless you're in a city where that grew up closer together.

Suburbs are unnatural and inorganic, and that's what people either hate or love about them.

This being said, there's frequently a "convenience store" that's sometimes closer than Big Mart. No veggies or actually even food, but they're there.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by Symbiote on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:14PM (#9493993)
Optimising what? Logistics for the supermarket?

The British are big optimisers. That's why the supermarket oligopoly (Tesco, Sainsbury's etc) have taken over many -- perhaps even the majority -- of small, neighbourhood shops (Tesco Express, Sainsbury's Local etc). The distribution centres and large vehicle fleet that delivers to the big supermarkets is reused to deliver to the neighbourhood shops, and many people then walk (or cycle) to those shops.

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/search/Tesco+OR+Sainsburys+in+...

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/search/Tesco+OR+Sainsburys+in+...

Milton Keynes is generally regarded as a boring, US-style city: https://www.google.co.uk/maps/search/Tesco+OR+Sainsburys+in+... (I've never been).

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @06:31PM (#9495420)
Optimizing multiple things at once - logistics for suppliers, specified land use on adjacent parcels ( a nod to developers ) , but mostly tax revenue for the town where zoning happens.

The British invented optimization in the WWII sense of the word, so yeah.

I don't know Britain beyond what I read of it, but I understand there's the concept of "little Britain" as a thing so maybe that's why small shops exist. In Montreal, I know there are actual bodegas in the city center and American-style convenience stores in the 'burbs.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by adwf on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:57PM (#9494568)
Milton Keynes is probably the worst place I've ever been to in the UK.

No easy walking around town. All chain stores, very few independent shops. No hailable black cabs for some reason, everything involved calling a minicab and waiting. Just a terrible city to be in without a car and a designated driver.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by logfromblammo on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:46AM (#9492743)
At a suburban population density of 640/mi^2 (1 acre/person), a circle with 3 mile radius covers 18000 people. A 2 mile radius covers 8000. A 1.5 mile radius covers 4500. A 1 mile radius, only 2000. A 0.5 mile radius has 500 people in it.

Realistically, a person walking at 3 mi/h won't walk more than 0.5 miles to visit the local shop, and a person bicycling at 12 mi/h won't go more than 3. They won't, unless they are combining trips. If the shop is on the way to somewhere else, or a very short distance beyond their primary destination, they might go further overall.

But pedestrian and bicyclist infrastructure is practically nonexistent anywhere in the US except for a bare handful of cities and suburbs. Many places don't even have sidewalks. Nearly everyone uses an automobile for personal transport.

As such, the "local shop" is right there at the gas station. We call them "convenience stores". They are most often placed at the intersection of arterial roads. So if you are lost in the back streets of suburbia, you will never see one.

It doesn't make sense from a planning perspective, but it does from a money perspective. When a developer subdivides a large property, they reserve commercial lots next to the arterial road, and build access roads past those into the residential lots. In theory, once the houses are 80% built, all that residential traffic will be flowing past the commercial lots at least twice per day, and a business will build there.

In practice, the developer exits after 95% of the houses are built, dumps the remaining 5% and the commercial lots on a strawman company, moving on to the next subdivision, and those businesses never actually get constructed.

So you end up with huge areas of houses and very few businesses. There might be one strip mall every 3 miles, filled with businesses that usually last a few months before failing from lack of customers. (The exception is the pizza delivery, which will be absolutely thriving.)

Residential buildings simply have a higher profit margin. Think about that before you decide to trust the developer's "phase IV" plans, when you're buying in "phase I".

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by jessaustin on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @07:41PM (#9495711)
Many places don't even have sidewalks.

The USA would be a much nicer place if no new residential development could be built without sidewalks. It would only require a little vision on the part of planning & zoning boards, with perhaps a little empathy for children, the elderly, and others who can't drive.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by logfromblammo on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @01:16PM (#9500200)
If the empathy were there, the zoning board would not be needed. The law is not an effective substitute for morality.

Besides that, have you ever read a zoning law? Be careful what you wish for; you just might get it, good and hard.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by jessaustin on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @02:26PM (#9500763)
I have skimmed the regs for several counties in which I've built or managed buildings. Different jurisdictions vary in their rigor, but very few developments escape P&Z entirely. We don't rely on the empathy of real estate developers to ensure that houses don't fall down. I propose that we not rely on it to ensure that pedestrians have a safe corridor for travel.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by hydrogen18 on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:35AM (#9492363)
I don't know much about Michigan, but it could be due to zoning that you don't see any shops.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by VLM on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:21AM (#9492970)
Economy of scale when constructing. You can usually tell the age of a burb by how big its zones are. Some of the newest burbs have absolutely huge, staggering, sized zones.

I live in a burb thats a bit over fifty years old and there's no spot more than maybe 6 blocks from the arterial retail/commercial/restaurant strips? In some new burbs you can easily be over a mile from anything other than residential.

I will say that when I was a kid there was a lot more to do in big zones because obviously there's more basements and garages and back yards and just plain old more kids. I mean, there's only about 200 kids in my current subdivision so with a distribution of ages its quite likely that there's no one to hang out with in the neighborhood for my own kids, whereas that's never an issue in a bigger zone where there's always a friend in the same neighborhood to hang out with. Some modern zones are so big that entire elementary school districts live within the borders of single zone! Obviously those kids always have someone to hang out with in the neighborhood.

And of course the bigger the zone, the crazier the traffic on the roads between the zones, which sucks.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by Ygg2 on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:36AM (#9492364)
Not really. The longer the distance traveled the more you buy per trip. It's universal foraging behavior.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by shasta on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:40AM (#9492388)
That explains why the mega store doesn't want a local shop but not why there is no local shop.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by steego on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:56AM (#9492482)
Many Americans don't see the value in a local shop because local shops tend to be more expensive and offer fewer choices. It's easier to consolidate your errands and hit a big grocery store and a big box store.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by EliRivers on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:47AM (#9492757)
That conflicts with a different cultural "fact" I have about US citizens. They love convenience (for example, "convenience stores") and willingly pay extra for it.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by VLM on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:35AM (#9493043)
Its a class thing.

Middle levels have the money to burn and often prioritize time over money. Plus complaining about paying $3 for an apple at the gas station quickie mart is a rare and cheap conspicuous consumption opportunity for them. I only have about 2 hours "off" unallocated tonight and I'm not going to spend 1/4 of my time off today saving $2 on the cost of an apple by going out of my way to shop at the food store.

For poor people its a poor people budgeting thing. As per the previous recent discussions on HN, poor guy has $3 in pocket, gas station has $3 apple on shelf, he buys it because 1) he doesn't have $5 to buy a 5 pound bag from the supermarket 2) no idea when/if he'll ever have an extra $5 again to spend on an extra luxury like an apple 3) travel isn't free when you're poor so bus fare and hours spent taking public transit to the store and time spent not working means that $5 bag is more like $15 total systemic cost and thats a bit steep for a poor guy who just has a taste for an apple today?

Upper levels have their personal assistant / admin assistant buy the apple for them. Its all going to be expense-d and its a rounding error anyway and the admin assistant is in a hurry so fine here take this $3 convenience store apple and I need a receipt for that thanks.

And thats how we love our $3 convenience store apples. Despite most apple sales being in 5 pound bags at the supermarket of course.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by steego on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @03:01PM (#9494260)
> For poor people its a poor people budgeting thing. ...

I couldn't help but read the rest of this paragraph in Cartman's voice.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by steego on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:52PM (#9494222)
In the suburbs convenience matters with things people buy regularly. You see this manifested as large convenience stores with gas bars and large drug stores that also sell sandwiches and ice cream. Small independent convenience stores tend to lose out to larger ones that have larger gas bars, cheaper gas and more options inside.

What's interesting is this trend seems to be reversing a little bit in clusters. Younger people are migrating back to the cities, and more developers in the suburbs are building apartment complexes with shops and restaurants mixed together, giving it the feel of living above a really nice mini mall. :)

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:54PM (#9494235)
Yes, but...

The ultimate convenience store is attached to a gas station and has a drive-up window so you don't need to get out of your car.

While the ones with drive through windows are rare, I'd be hard pressed to think of a convenience store within a 30 mile radius that was not also a gas station. As far as I can recall, I only see c-stores that don't sell gas inside cities.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:08AM (#9492535)
I think the assumption, which is so basic that other commenters don't bother to mention it, is that every family has two cars. Suburbs in US are car-oriented to the extreme. Having a car changes shopping habits, because you can bring back much more things with you in a single trip to shop.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by ryandrake on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @09:57AM (#9492485)
Combination of zoning ordinances keeping shops away from residential areas and shops not being able to compete on price against the mega stores' huge economies of scale.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mattste on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:26AM (#9492637)
Having grown up in Michigan, I can attest to this. It has made me want to abandon this state so heavily built around the automobile. Even downtown Detroit has wide city streets and few walkable areas. Ann Arbor, on the other hand, is pedestrian friendly, and one can manage without a car.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sredne on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:05AM (#9492857)
I grew up in the suburbs also, and hated it. As a kid, you have no freedom until the age of 16 where you have the POSSIBILITY of owning a car/borrowing your parent's car. We had bikes, but the nearest anything was 1-1.5 miles away, and there were very little sidewalks or safe places to bike. Nothing was convenient without a car.

I went to school in a small/medium city (Champaign/Urbana) and loved it. It was the perfect mix of having a city and space for a small suburban life. I lived in a house that was off campus, and was within walking distance to downtown and busing distance to the bars/main campus. It was peaceful and crazy when I wanted it to be.

I now live in Chicago and while I love the convenience of everything(huge advocate of all things public transit), I miss being able to easily just disconnect from urban life.

My next move will probably be somewhere warmer, but it'll probably be in a small/medium sized city for sure.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by jnet on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:16AM (#9492576)
I grew up in the city. As I got older I realized that I didn't want my children to have to deal with the dirt, crime, rats, and noise that I had to deal with when I was growing up. Hopefully, they will appreciate the things I didn't have as a kid. A backyard, nice neighbors, low crime,and better schools.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by coldtea on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @11:08AM (#9492888)
>Hopefully, they will appreciate the things I didn't have as a kid. A backyard, nice neighbors, low crime,and better schools.

They'll appreciate them as kids, but they'll probably hate you as teenagers...

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by mahyarm on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:32PM (#9494096)
I think the reason why kids and co don't like X is probably because of isolation effects. If you can independently travel to wherever you want with little hassle and have a rich social life, then you'll like where you live. If you have helicopter parents in the suburbs or city centre that insist to drive you on their schedule to wherever, then you'll hate it.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by sbov on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:05PM (#9493577)
I grew up in the suburbs and I was fine with it. As an adult I prefer city life.

I probably would have hated SF as a kid. I've lived in SF for 7 years, and I can't think of anything that is more convenient that I would have cared about as a kid. I don't know if its just SF, but it seems very adult oriented.

That said, while growing up, the closest mini mall was about 1.5 miles away. Which we would go to because one of the shops had arcade games. I've never lived in a suburb (3 of them) that wasn't 1-1.5 miles from a mini mall. That is easily within biking distance.

We didn't spend most of our time there though. We spent most of our time in the hills around us (South San Jose), and on the Baseball fields/Basketball courts at the local elementary school. Or playing baseball with tennis balls in our cul-de-sac. Or digging forts in our backyard. Or riding our skateboards through the streets.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by atmosx on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @10:33AM (#9492669)
I live in a small town in Northern Greece and hate the idea to drive a long distance[1] to get milk and eggs.

[1] A long distance where I live is anything more than 8 minutes drive.

Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by blueskin_ on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:09PM (#9493274)
I had the same feeling - plus the broadband there was terrible. I would never live in a suburb even if I was paid to. The middle of nowhere though, would be even worse than a suburb as it's the same problems but more so and without the (relative) proximity to work.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by aidenn0 on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @01:03PM (#9500082)
I grew up in the suburbs and walked to the store to get milk and eggs. I had to bike to get to the library in a reasonable time though.
Re:Death of a Programmer, Life of a Farmer by kstop on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @02:36PM (#9494116)
I hated it even more, which is why I now live in the crawlspace of a supermarket.