News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by skrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @12:48PM (#9459625)
I wish someone would stop some of them and ask them:

"What do you think will happen if you actually GET $15/hr?"

"Do you expect your employer to keep his same prices and same amount of work force and just eat the labor cost?"

"What happens if you make $9 now, make $15 tomorrow, but tomorrow the prices of everything you buy suddenly doubled?"

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:25PM (#9459972)
> Do you expect your employer to keep his same prices and same amount of work force and just eat the labor cost?

Many will simply eat the cost, actually. The minimum-wage debate is more about politics than economics. There's not as many minimum wage workers as people think, so for very little economic cost, you can increase the quality of life for the lowest paid workers in our society.

A few businesses may be forced to change, but those are the ones that run razor-thin margins.

> What happens if you make $9 now, make $15 tomorrow, but tomorrow the prices of everything you buy suddenly doubled?"

Nothing will double in price. Given the amount of minimum wage workers that actually exist in the US, prices shouldn't increase by more than 5%. Anything more would just be opportunistic gouging.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:47PM (#9460164)
There are about 3.3 million people who are affected by this per http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/09/08/who-makes-mi...

    The minimum-wage debate is more about politics
    than economics
Not for those 3.3 million people, it's not.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by chrismcb on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:59AM (#9469747)
I don't know the numbers, but far more then 3 million will be affected. 3 million are at or below minimum wage, but how many make more than minimum wage but less than $15?
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:57PM (#9460269)
> Not for those 3.3 million people, it's not.

3.3 million is about 2% of the workforce of the US. The point I'm making, is that the economic cost of the price increase (which is the argument made against minimum wage increases) is far less than the tangible quality-of-life benefits to those 3.3 million workers.

I'm for raising the minimum wage BTW. Because the pros (better life for those workers) far outweigh the cons, especially from an economic standpoint.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by imacomputer2 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:56PM (#9460258)
How many minimum wage workers are there? If you only look at the number of current minimum wage workers there may not be many, but we are talking about raising the minimum wage to $15. That means everyone under $15/hr is affected. So, I think the real question is how many people are making less than $15/hr. I skimmed this article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_S... and it seems that median personal income is somewhere around 30K in the US. Well, $15/hr of full time work is about 31K. Therefor the number of people who will see a rise in their wages is potentially very large. So, I think that the problems with price increases are a real issue.

Another issue I thought of is this. If min wage workers all suddenly have wage increases by law, then businesses like fast food chains might just replace many them with machines. I mean, you already know your McDonald's burger is disgusting, so probably wont mind if it gets pooped out of a dispenser like pudding. So, this policy may simply lead to layoffs.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by ntkachov on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:32PM (#9460597)
If the median is the middle number, wouldn't that mean that around half of america makes less than $15/hr? The same wiki page says "slightly under 45% had incomes below $25,000". So a raise to $15/hr would potentially impact half the county.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Alupis on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:16PM (#9460464)
> then businesses like fast food chains might just replace many them with machines

Like McDonald's is currently piloting in France where you order your food from a touch-screen kiosk instead of a cashier.[1]

[1] http://www.cnet.com/news/mcdonalds-hires-7000-touch-screen-c...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by fragmede on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:28PM (#9461055)
Wawa in Pennsylvania has touch-screen sandwich ordering machines, and has since a pilot program in 2001. It briefly gained national attention when a edited clip surfaced of Mitt Romney being "amazed" by the machines.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:07PM (#9460877)
That's incredibly naive. Most business owners won't eat the cost. They'll cut hours. How do I know? Because I used to work in the fast food industry as a GM. Whenever CA increased the min wage, the first thing our owner would do is ask us how much more this was going to cost us, then he'd instruct us to cut the number of hours scheduled. Because in fast food, it's not like it only affects the workers making minimum wage, it bumps the entire pay scale. So if min wage is raised by $1, everyone working hourly gets a $1 bump. For a restaurant that has say 100 man hours of labor a day, that means $100 extra cost per day right out of the owner's pocket. Multiply that by 365 and you have a pissed off owner. He can't always raise prices, and labor costs are the largest controllable expense. So what happens is that each store manager is told that they need to make everyone work harder, and they have to cut $100 worth of labor each day. So the survivors get more money, but they get worked harder; the losers get their hours cut, or they don't get hired as the positions/hours are not replaced when attrition occurs. TANSTAAFL!
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:27PM (#9461494)
I worked in fast food as well for a while. There ain't no such thing as a free lunch for the restaurateurs either - at some point people want more for the demands of increased productivity, and if they don't get it they'll quit. Employers have been in a buyer's market for most of the last decade, while a great many employees have done a great deal of belt-tightening. If labor pricing is such a concern for a restaurant owner, it may be time to consider raising prices or raising the quality of the offering, or watch your employees walk across the street. there's enough churn in the restaurant business that anyone who thinks they're the employer of last resort is lying to themselves.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:44PM (#9461623)
Owners are limited by franchise agreements to what they can charge, as well as limited by what the market will bear. As wages got pushed lower and lower in fast food, QSC declined dramatically. Owners have already invested a lot in automation (steps that ironically have damaged quality), and there's only so much blood you can squeeze out.

The issue isn't that owners will fare worse, but that raising the min wage while it makes us feel good won't necessarily help lower income workers. Doubling the salary of an entry level position will only reduce the number of entry level positions. And as I'm sure your experience in fast food illustrated, there's some people who aren't even worth paying min wage. Except for a few management folks, it shouldn't be a long term job or career.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:48PM (#9461654)
I'm fine with people exiting the market in that situation. They're not providing jobs any more, but their departure leaves underserved demand that can be met by someone else.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @06:20PM (#9462222)
Just because demand is underserved doesn't mean it can be met when it's unprofitable.

I used to love flying flight sims back in the Falcon 4.0 days, and I expected flight sims to progress as hardware advanced. Nowadays the flight sim market is DOA, despite my demand.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:44PM (#9461614)
Most will and do, judging by the amount of fast food outlets that still are in operation, and still hire people, despite the numerous wage hikes over the years.

Sounds like you just worked for an asshole. Also sounds like you guys eventually adapted to the wage hikes (I'm assuming he's still in business?).

Of course no one's happy when things become more expensive. Here they just announced a new tax on gas (making it as expensive as before the price of oil went to shit), and a new tax on booze. Guess what - people still drive, and drink beer (hopefully not at same time).

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by tzs on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:16PM (#9460963)
I don't understand why the restaurant waited until there was a wage hike to do that. If they were able to cut hours and make the remaining people work harder in order to make up for the extra costs due to minimum wage, couldn't they have cut hours and made the remaining people work harder long before that, when instead of the savings going to offset a new expense, they would have gone into profit?
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:10PM (#9461365)
I can't speak for all owners, but our franchisee had relatively higher standards than many. He expected QSC (quality, service, cleanliness) to surpass the minimum expectations of the parent corporation. However, he was only willing to pay so much in salary. Just because we made the remaining people work harder didn't mean that things were the same in terms of QSC. Service was slower, and the place wasn't as clean. Quality didn't drop as much as the other two metrics.

Also, he had a lot of longer term employees who were making more than min wage, but still would benefit if it was raised. So it became more economical to let them go, despite the loss of their higher productivity.

Also, you can't just think in terms of the hourly rate. Increases in the hourly rate also affect worker's comp rates, Social Security contributions, etc. So an $8 increase would probably be at least a $10 cost increase to the owner.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by fragmede on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:02PM (#9461307)
Well, first off, maybe the restaurant doesn't run on greed? Hopefully there's room in your philosophy for that to be a possibility.

Outside of that though, raising prices immediately hurts sales, but worse customer service due to the restaurant being chronically short-staffed takes longer to hurt sales. Being chronically short-staffed also makes for a worse working environment which leads to employee turnover, which is more costly in the long run, but when you're struggling to make rent this month, the long term costs may not be as apparent.

Finally, if it's a small restaurant where the owner also helps with the day-to-day operations of restaurant (maybe they're even the chef), it mean's they'll have to work even harder. The owner may just find it worth the cost to have an extra employee and be able to work just a little bit less.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:17PM (#9461412)
Another issue is the misperception of franchisees as fat cats. Our owner had five franchises; each cost over $2M back in the 80's. The average annual sales were around 1-2 million, and he would net around 10%. So he invests $10M to make $750K a year before taxes. That's 7.5% return. Not exactly AAPLesque.

So if you increase his labor costs from 20% to 30%, you just wiped out his return. If you double it to 40% like a $15 increase would do, then he's got to either automate or cut to the bone.

And yes I realize I'm conflating figures from the 80s to today, but the percentages still hold.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:52PM (#9461681)
Sounds like he overpaid for the franchises themselves. That's just called a bad investment.

I'd generally expect a restaurant to do twice as much in sales (or more) in a year compared to the initial cost, and be able to recuperate the initial investment in 5-10 years (one of the more recent restaurateurs I worked for paid back his investors in 3 years, and has a second location 5 years in).

But even using his sub-par numbers, $750K a year since the 80's means he's already recuperated his costs and made some serious profits since. What more does he expect? He could close them all tomorrow and be ahead. If anything, this anecdote does show just how greedy some people are.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @06:23PM (#9462239)
The franchise business is just wacky really. The parent corporation owns the land you use, so they become real estate tycoons, and they can cause huge headaches to franchisees who don't play ball with their latest initiatives. It's really hard to compare them to regular restaurants though. I'm not sure if it's much different in Canada, as I've lost touch with a cousin who owned some White Spots in BC when I was a kid.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by crdb on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:47PM (#9460173)
Or they'll just hire more illegals. There's 11.5 million illegals in the US already [1] (edit: vs 3.3m legal workers on or below minimum wage [3]!), a large part of which are probably doing "minimum wage" type jobs for less than minimum wage. Every rise in the cost of doing business legally will push a few more jobs towards the illegal, or law-abiding businesses to bankrupcy from lack of competitiveness. My entirely anecdotal evidence places the dishwasher illegal salary in big cities (my data is from New York in 2010 or so) at around $3/hour.

Different countries handle the issue of high minimum wage differently. Some countries have very thorough enforcement and drive the cost of everything through the roof, but end up with a more egalitarian society (I think Norway, where a beer costs as much as a large meal in neighbouring countries, counts). Singapore chooses not to have a minimum wage and to make it easy to import manual labour legally, and affords these labourers the same legal protection afforded any other resident. China uses the hukou system [2] to regulate the influx of unskilled labourers into more prosperous regions.

The US simply turns a blind eye to the rule of law when it comes to unqualified labour, which allows businesses to keep their costs low, and politicians to save face and pretend they did something "for the workers", whilst a side effect is increasing the stress on the legal unskilled residents which might even be a positive for politicians as they love a good crisis.

Conclusion: legal unskilled workers should fight for the law to be enforced, not for minimum wage to be legally increased. It would both remove competition and drive up demand for their unskilled work, and since there is no population explosion in the United States and legal immigration is incredibly regulated, should result in a natural rise of wages matching the higher cost of living in locations like Seattle.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_immigrant_population_of...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou_system

[3] http://poverty.ucdavis.edu/faq/what-are-characteristics-mini...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:05PM (#9460366)
So that's why, even with the recent strengthening of the US dollar vis à vis the Canadian dollar, things are still dirt cheap in the US compared to Canada.

I do enjoy travelling down there to Montana - ski tickets are cheaper, gas is cheaper, and good beer is much, much cheaper (I seriously love the micro-brew scene in the US. Canada has a good micro-brewing scene too, but not to the same degree).

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by crdb on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:15PM (#9460459)
I'm guessing there's other factors. For example, Australian prices are high because of labour (it's very hard to illegally immigrate to an island surrounded by oceans) but also because everything has to be transported over vast distances and many products have to be imported.

I'd guess the much smaller market (35m inhabitants vs 320m - Australia has 22m), the weather, the distance from production centres and major ports, and so on would impact prices as well.

As for beer it might be taxes, which Wikipedia says are amongst the highest in the world.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:21PM (#9460525)
Everything you said is true (especially the taxes on beer).

It was a little tongue-in-cheek, however I still am surprised that there are so many illegal immigrants in the US...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:21PM (#9461448)
Seriously? If you were a Mexican national, why wouldn't you come to the US? Better jobs, more safety, more hope for your kids. Mexico has so many problems that a trip across the border solves. I have no ill will towards anyone traveling north. It's a rational response to conditions in Mexico that seem intractable.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:56PM (#9461717)
> Seriously? If you were a Mexican national, why wouldn't you come to the US?

No, I'm more surprised that the US is so bad at dealing with illegal immigration. Do they tacitly accept it?

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by crdb on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @11:46PM (#9463241)
Yes, because there is no choice in the matter. The only durable way to stop mass illegal immigration would be to relieve the enormous incentives for both illegals to come in, and businesses to hire them, which means making it legal for a restaurant to hire anybody - including foreigners - to work 16 hour days for $3/hour vs 10 hour days for $9/hour. This will never happen, not even under the most hardcore Tea Party government, not even if Goldwater rose from the ashes and brought with his election victory a House and Senate majority somehow with the same spine he had.

I thought the (excellent) movie "Act of Valor" pointed out the other way this issue could be resolved. In the movie, terrorists use the people smuggling networks to allow suicide bombers into the US, targeting a few stadiums in Southern cities. This is not the first time enemies of the US try to smuggle people in illegally - the Soviets and the Cubans especially sent many agents that way, as well as infiltrating US criminal organisations (see for example Oleg Kalugin's biography [1] which explores the links between the Soviets and the Italian mafia).

In the real world, no criminal organisation would be mad enough to let that happen (much as gangs in Mexico try to avoid killing gringos) because it would mean a promotion from "criminal organisation" to "effective terrorist organisation" and we saw after 9/11 how the American public reacts to that. So long as you're "just" smuggling drugs and people, it's "just" the DEA and ATF and the odd border agent.

If they did facilitate terrorist attacks, you can bet there'd be an enormous appropriation and militarization of the border, coupled with a systematic destruction of virtually all smuggling networks on Mexican soil and maybe temporary occupation of the territory south of the border. Panama was invaded for less.

But this is not going to happen just because a few people go on strike, especially when the majority of manual labour (11m vs 3m) appears to be illegal already without much outcry from the public which tacitly understands that this is key to cheap food and service.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/First-Directorate-Intelligence-Espiona...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @07:53PM (#9462610)
> No, I'm more surprised that the US is so bad at dealing with illegal immigration. Do they tacitly accept it?

Some industry players benefit from having low-skilled workers that are demotivated to complain to government of labor violations, etc., so there is some of that.

OTOH, a bigger issue is that, while most people would agree that illegal immigration, per se, is bad, there is no census on how to deal with the issue.

There are groups that oppose not only illegal immigration, but are strongly concerned with controlling the level of immigration (and often with managing its origin), so that they see the solution in enforcement measures (though even groups in this category often don't agree on which enforcement measures.)

Then there are groups that are less concerned with the level of immigration than with illegality itself, and so would favor new avenues of legal immigration, or increased quotas within existing avenues, etc.

And there are additional disagreements over approaches to dealing with the existing population that is present without proper immigration status beyond the different views on "going forward" policy.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @06:21PM (#9462228)
Half the voting public supports it, half opposes it. So there's no real movement on the issue.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @09:38PM (#9462854)
I love when downvotes get politically motivated. No one wants to deny or refute that immigration has been in a gridlock for at least 29 years.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by crdb on Thursday April 30, 2015 @05:21AM (#9464036)
I am genuinely curious about why several people downvoted my original post as well.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @07:31PM (#9462517)
Strange. Even though Canada strongly supports multi-culturalism, our public is equally opposed to letting illegal immigrants stay (and we certainly make it more difficult for illegal immigrants to stay).
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:07PM (#9459792)
Every time I visit, say, Macdonalds, I try to figure out how much it would cost to pay everyone in the logistic chain decently. E.g. let's suppose we agree to give 5% extra to Macdonalds at the register to distribute to its employees in some equitable fashion. So my $12 order (two happy meals and a burger, say) costs me an extra $0.60. <10 people are processing something like 200 orders per hour (I suspect it's more like 5 people and 400 orders, I'm guesstimating), so that's $12 for each of them. But let's assume there are another ten people in the logistic chain. So that's $6/h for each of them.

Now imagine the flow-on effect to the rest of the economy if people in those horrible jobs had some kind of living wage. I suspect not only would these workers be $6/h better off, I'd probably be better off too.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by bigtunacan on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:15PM (#9459866)
I really don't think the people in these jobs understand the whole picture. I already typically won't establish a McDonald's already because prices have gotten so high. It's cheaper to cook at home. If wages double and prices raise less people are going to eat there and hence less people who are employed.

These people should be focused on how they can increase their long term earning potential instead of helping to further squeeze out the middle class.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by misterbishop on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:21PM (#9459930)
Huh? If you can't afford to eat at McDonalds, maybe you should be protesting for a higher wage.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by bigtunacan on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:02PM (#9460328)
My point was not that I can't afford to eat at McDonalds, but rather that it is a convenience purchase and eating at home is more cost conscious. If prices raise, which they will if wages go up, then more people will choose not to eat there and this will result in less jobs for the very people protesting the wages.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:05PM (#9460869)
Preparing food at home is not actually cheaper than Macdonalds -- I defy you to create a double cheeseburger for $1. (The beef alone would cost over $1 at Walmart -- roughly $6/lb. Macdonald's gets its beef a lot cheaper.) The food at home is possibly healthier, but healthy food is even more expensive. That said, I doubt people will baulk at paying $1.05 (after all they are paying sales tax on it in many cases).
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by bigtunacan on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:21PM (#9461001)
Indeed, the dollar menu is incredibly cheap, but I cringe to even call that food. I'm probably better off eaten the cheapest off brand hot dogs than those slime burgers.

That said, they are looking for a $15/hour rate. Since federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour we are talking a potential wage cost doubling. I doubt that will only result in a 5% cost increase and that it will be much more.

Also, I'm not saying that all sales will stop, but that they will decrease. That is the substitute goods effect. McDonalds food is an inferior good. As it's prices raise more people will move away from them to substitute goods.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Thursday April 30, 2015 @02:13PM (#9466689)
It's easy and fun to dismiss Macdonalds, but their "slime" burgers are made from beef (no pink slime even). I doubt that cheap hotdogs are made from better ingredients.

"I doubt that will only result in a 5% cost increase and that it will be much more."

Well -- make your case.

A Bloomberg reporter guesstimates that doubling salary costs at fast food franchises would increase prices by 25%.

http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2013-08-02/this-is-what...

But that's pretty much a worst case scenario (assumes that everyone working there is minimum wage -- in fact from the figures I see, no-one at Macdonalds earns the Federal minimum wage).

I suspect if you did the analyses what you'd see is something like this:

1) Increasing the minimum wage would have flow-on effects to other salaries causing wage increases across the board.

2) There would be price rises generated by increased labor costs, and also by more money being in the economy (this would improve GDP, but that's not a useful measure).

3) It would have a significant stimulus effect (low income people tend to spend more than save, so giving them more money has a high multiplier effect -- it's really the best kind of stimulus). This would reduce unemployment.

4) A lot of people who have multiple jobs to survive would be able to give up some of them, which would reduce unemployment.

5) Some companies would make do with fewer employees, which would increase unemployment.

6) My guess is 3 + 4 would overwhelm 5. Combined with 2, this would raise interest rates.

Seems like a pretty desirable outcome all round.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by kefka on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:59PM (#9460295)
Mcdonalds is expensive for the quantity and quality you get.

I can make the similar much healthier, tastier, and cheaper than they can.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:09PM (#9460892)
Good grief, I didn't plan to defend Macdonald's, but this sounds delusional to me. If you're trying to get food cheaply, unless your labor is pretty much free and you're incredibly efficient I very much doubt this is true.

Assuming I were to prepare a home cooked meal from scratch, the chances I would get away with less than 1h of labor (including driving to markets, shopping, and preparation) alone justifies eating out (at a restaurant, forget Macdonalds).

Certainly eating home-cooked food is healthier. And it's probably more delicious. And cooking can be enjoyable, but not as a daily grind. But don't make the cost argument unless your time is free.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by bigtunacan on Thursday April 30, 2015 @10:26PM (#9469045)
Ok, I'll follow on just slightly here related to the cost argument. First let's take time out of the picture because there are too many factors to measure it properly... How close is a McDonalds, do you enjoy cooking, blah... blah...

Instead let's compare on cost only...

When I originally posted I did not mention the dollar value menu, that is what was immediately posted as a response by someone else. But since it is the lowest common denominator and the representation of McDonalds has cheap food... Let's try to approximate how much it costs in money only to make a "dollar burger".

The dollar burger has only 1.5 ounces of meat.

Today when I checked my local grocer 80% lean ground was $2.48 a pound. So that should make about 12 dollar burgers.

~21 cents per burger for hamburger

Hamburger buns were 68 cents for an eight pack; that's 8.5 cents per burger.

It was $2.50 for an 8 pack of presliced cheese These were much thicker higher quality cheese, and unsliced cheese can be bought far cheaper... But we splurged so that's another 32 cents per burger.

88 cents for a head of lettuce which will easily make 20+ dollar burgers so that's 4.4 cents per burger

So we add this up and we are now at a burger that costs 57.4 cents to make. We still need to add a sprinkle of onion crumbs as well as a squirt of mustard and ketchup; I think we can safely assume that is going to cost less than the remaining 42.6 cents.

So yes; in fact I can make an equivalent burger for less than it costs at McDonalds. If I was going to get a sandwich at McDonalds more likely I would end up with something that doesn't totally suck, like the Big Mac, which averages $4.79 in the US. For $4.79 I can make one hell of a burger.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by kefka on Thursday April 30, 2015 @11:15AM (#9465564)
Don't make the argument "unless your time is free" unless you have 0-turn around time->money converter. Which, your argument is that "Time isn't free, so neener neener", which falls flat in its face.

I'm not in the upper, or middle economic class. And making our own food is how we save a great deal of money, and also eating much healthier. We probably could eat on $50/wk for both my wife and I. But it would be junk food and bad calories and malnutrition.

Last night, we had shrimp, tilapia, roasted veggies, and a capezzi salad. That would have been ~$40 each out on the town. It cost us $10 for both of us combined. And it was a half hour work for one of us. We can't even work a half hour on no minutes notice.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Thursday April 30, 2015 @01:58PM (#9466593)
Yes but your "free" time is valuable in a different way. I cheerfully cook for myself and my family on occasion, but having to do it all the time (for a family which has different conflicting dietary issues) is not much fun. (We don't eat out much for reasons of health as much as anything.) I just wouldn't make the cost argument -- it doesn't hold water.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Tloewald on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:53PM (#9460225)
> These people should be focused on how they can increase their long term earning potential instead of helping to further squeeze out the middle class.

"These people" -- what, people with awful jobs?

"further squeeze out the middle class" -- how is this squeezing out the middle class?

Low end salaries in the US are a tragedy of the commons. Because people can cobble together subsistence services when collecting a "salary" (e.g. by going to the ER for medical care or collecting food stamps to eat) companies are able to get people to work for them for artificially low prices. Effectively, taxpayers are subsidizing Walmart and Macdonalds for paying people too little.

This is not the same as, for example, providing decent welfare or unemployment benefits that go away when you have a job. That drives up salaries because it makes having a shitty job seem worse than just collecting welfare. Instead we have income-based support that cuts in even for people who are working.

The middle class are being squeezed by medical costs which are in large part driven by the US healthcare situation. If our health costs were under control, the "middle class" would have enjoyed healthy salary increases over the last decade.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by bigtunacan on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:15PM (#9460449)
'"These people" -- what, people with awful jobs?'

People with completed unskilled jobs that could be performed by a twelve year old if labor laws allowed. An unfortunately high number of unskilled, unmotivated people take jobs at places like McDonalds with no ambition to do anything better.

Raising the minimum wage ONLY raises the minimum wage in terms of earning, so yes it squeezes the middle class as their earning comes closer to the minimum wage. Raising the minimum wage results in inflation and raising costs; this directly impacts the middle class.

Quite frankly many of these are also providing services that just aren't necessary; they are purely convenience. People only have so much money to spend, so raising prices results in fewer sales as some people will switch to substitute goods. In the example I'm working with here, buying groceries and cooking at home is a cheaper substitute good for McDonalds; as the cost of McDonalds raises more people will substitute this with cooking at home.

This is just the basics of supply and demand. So yes, "these people", anyone with a low paying unskilled job should be doing anything in their power to develop needed and in demand jobs so they can raise their earning potential. Aside from the few that move up to managerial roles at a place like McDonalds there is no earning potential. These are the types of places where you get hired with no prior job experience or skills. They are not now, nor have they been in my lifetime, sustainable careers.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:36PM (#9461562)
This is not basic supply and demand. You're making the common error of applying the laws of perfect competition to a complex, non-zero-sum marketplace. So suppose more people do substitute away from McDonalds to cooking at home; that means more jobs in the supermarket and consumer packaging industries, to name but two.

anyone with a low paying unskilled job should be doing anything in their power to develop needed and in demand jobs so they can raise their earning potential

Guess what, taking classes or developing a new skill often costs money, even with the internet, community college subsidies and so on. If you only pay people barely enough to live, then there's nothing left over for them to invest in career development.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jws on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:28PM (#9459999)
The prices will not double. According to someone on the internet†, labor is 25% of fast food revenue. The prices need only go up 25% to maintain profit margins.

Economics wil then raise its ugly fuzzy head and the balance between automation and human labor will shift, there will be more machines doing work. People already making $15/hour will eat less fast food since it is more expensive, people who have had their wages double will probably eat more fast food since they have more money. Total consumption could go either way. Total employment could go either way, it depends.

One possible outcome is that revenue gets shifted to lower paid workers who spend it, creating more jobs and a larger economy. Capital investors will get less, but they already have so much capital piled up that there is a glut and they have difficulty getting people to rent it from them (~3% prime rates).

What actually happens? That is the realm of gamblers.

␄

† http://smallbusiness.chron.com/common-food-labor-cost-percen...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by wiredfool on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:11PM (#9460418)
So, basic restaurant economics:

  30% food cost
  30% labor
  30% overhead
  10% profit (ideally)
Most restaurants run on really thin margins, a percent here or there is going to eat the profit. And a lot of restaurants, unless they're super successful are right at the edge. The owner puts in long unpaid hours or something similar.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by wavefunction on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:45PM (#9460148)
technically, if labor is 25% of costs and the cost of that labor is increasing by 66%, prices would only need to rise 16.5% to maintain current rates of profitability (.25 * .66)
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:40PM (#9461591)
But raising the min to $15 is a 107% bump, so prices would have to rise by +/- 27%, before you factor on the increase in Social Security costs. The employer contrib to SS is 6.2%, and Medicare is 1.45%. So a $15 min wage actually costs the employer an additional $8.60/hour.

An even easier and more insightful way is to carve up a Big Mac. In the US, the average price for a Big Mac is $4.79.

Overhead: 30% or $1.44 Food Cost: 25% or $1.20 Labor: 25% or $1.20 Franchise Royalties: 13% or $.62 Profit: 7% or $.34

Now a Big Mac isn't as profitable as fries or soda, but those percentages are across the entire menu. Not a lot of profit for a burger...

I think a lot of devs here are not seeing the overall economics of the fastfood world, and perhaps feeling a bit of guilt due to the difference in their salaries versus the fastfood workers...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by misterbishop on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:19PM (#9459913)
The state already subsidizes the cost of your Big Mac by providing foodstamps and assistance to McDonald's poverty-wage workers.

McDonald's had a 'bad' 3rd quarter last year, which means they only made $1B in profit. It was down from 1.5B the previous year.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurengensler/2014/10/21/mcdonal...

These companies can afford to pay their workers a living wage. It's not a question of whether workers "deserve" one hourly rate or another. The question is whether the working class will continue to tolerate it.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jerf on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:45PM (#9460156)
"McDonald's had a 'bad' 3rd quarter last year, which means they only made $1B in profit. It was down from 1.5B the previous year.... These companies can afford to pay their workers a living wage."

Big number fallacy... you see a big number and it doesn't occur to you to check against the other big numbers that may be involved. Wikipedia has 36,000 franchises worldwide. Assume we're paying about 100 person hours/day for a franchise, assume 360 days in a year, and you get... about 1.3 billion paid hours. (And I suspect I'm being generously conservative with 100 personhours/day for an average franchise, especially when you account for the whole thing, like the shipping and accounting and such.)

So, all else being equal (which it never is, but roll with it), and had they paid everyone another $1/hour, they'd be making a loss.

You can't just see big profit numbers and go "Oh, they've got money, surely they can pay better!" Capitalism is very efficient (in the conventional sense of the term of "using inputs well") and very competitive, in that McDonalds can't just charge 50% more and nobody changes their buying habits, and it's actually really good at shaving profit margins down to a surprisingly small level, contrary to the numerically-illiterate rhetoric often flung at it.

A lot of big corporations make billions a year, but it turns out that when you do the analysis in percentages, they're typically making waaaay less than you think. For instance, here's the 10 most profitable companies in 2013: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/01/20/10-p... By #10, "Wal-Mart" (how convenient, a favored bête noire of the labor community), you've got a company pulling in $467 billion in revenue, to make a "mere" $16 billion earnings. That's a 3.4% of their revenue! Yes, it would be a big pile if you just handed it to me personally, but it means that a 4% fuckup at a high enough level would be enough to fry their entire profit.

(Do you do your job with 4% tolerance?)

And those are the 10 most profitable, not even the "average" companies.

There both is, and is not, a lot of money in the system. Start trying to "distribute" the "excess" out and suddenly it looks a lot less "excess".

Further, bear in mind this is simple math. You can't argue away the math.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by cgearhart on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:16PM (#9460462)
The numbers are not so bleak as you think.

> Wikipedia [sic] has 36,000 franchises worldwide

McDonalds only has 14,339 franchises in the US [1] -- where the pay raise debate is happening.

> Assume we're paying about 100 person hours/day for a franchise, assume 360 days [sic] in a year, and you get... about 1.3 billion paid hours.

According to the parent comment, McDonald's made $1B in profit during the 3rd quarter alone. Correcting for both the number of franchises & the quarter vs the whole year of labor yields an estimated $7.64 in profit per hypothetical hourly employee (HHE). And keep in mind that it's down from $1.5B profit previously, which corresponds to an estimated $11.46 per HHE.

> That's a [sic] 3.4% of their revenue!

McDonald's has $7.95B of earnings on $27.44B in revenue [1]; about 29%. Even if their profit is only $4B annually ($1B in Q3 x 4 qtrs.), that's still 14.6%.

> Capitalism is very efficient...

People are not. And that's the point. People making minimum wage don't always have the flexibility to take risks that would allow them to advance. "A bird in the hand" and all that often means that a stable minimum wage job is more valuable than a risky opportunity to make more.

[1] http://www.statista.com/topics/1444/mcdonalds/

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jerf on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:35PM (#9460625)
"McDonalds only has 14,339 franchises in the US [1] -- where the pay raise debate is happening."

As I mentioned in another reply, the point was more to recalibrate understandings of the money size involved than to specifically speak to this discussion.

I'm not sure how you "corrected" for the number of franchises, then... if you did it by accounting all worldwide profit as for US franchises that is not a "correction". And regardless of the correction remember not to party too hard with "profit" amounts right now when McDonalds may very well go negative in the near future; the point I'm trying to make survives that, but it would make hash of yours. Profit is not guaranteed!

Somewhere online I saw a list of the profit margins of all the Fortune 100. Single-digit percentages were the norm. I was unable to google it up for this.

"> Capitalism is very efficient...

People are not. People making minimum wage don't always have the flexibility to take risks that would allow them to advance. "

That's a complete nonsequitor. And moreover it's a frankly stupid accusation of me you're trying to implicitly make. Give me the button to push to make everyone in the world effectively as rich as billionaires and somehow it all works out with no negative effects, and I'd push it in a heartbeat. I'd love to manifest Iain Bank's Culture. It sounds great.

But in the real world, we have to work with what resources we have, and we don't actually have anywhere near as many as people think. The rich may be rich, but divide their riches up somehow perfectly efficiently amongst everybody, and we all get a lot less than our generally-innumerate intuitions are telling us we would.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by cgearhart on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:59PM (#9460823)
> ...you did it by accounting all worldwide profit as for US franchises that is not a "correction". [sic]

The corporation is not debating raising wages worldwide, only in the US. Their total corporate revenue (including international revenue) can be included in the calculation of whether it is "affordable". But only the workers in the US should be included in the calculation.

> Profit is not guaranteed!

The focal point of the discussion is that the current distribution of earnings marginalizes the hourly workforce. It does not have to be this way. The napkin math supports the idea that changing the proportions in the distribution could be reasonably accomplished. Furthermore, the napkin math ignores price increases, which would likely be part of any more sophisticated projections.

> That's a complete nonsequitor. And moreover it's a frankly stupid accusation of me you're trying to implicitly make.

People are not "efficient" in the economic sense. They do not make perfect decisions for themselves, even given perfect information. They will compete with each other irrationally, and even against their own best interests. The efficiency of capitalism exploits those traits. We ought to use reasonable policies and regulations to address that.

> The rich may be rich, but divide their riches up somehow perfectly efficiently amongst everybody, and we all get a lot less than our generally-innumerate intuitions are telling us we would.

I'm not arguing for carving up the wealth of the rich and redistributing it. But hourly workers should share in the gains wrought by their labor. As it stands, the top 1% takes an amazingly disproportionate share. [1]

[1] http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/jan/22/...

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by LesZedCB on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:58PM (#9460286)
That basic math assumes that you add on the cost of raising the minimum wage by $1.00 instead of reallocating it from one paycheck to another. Person A now makes $999/hr and Person B now makes $11/hr from 1000 and 10 respectively. Net loss: $0.00. The real problem isn't that people making minimum wage don't make enough, it's that the wage gap is gigantic.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jerf on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:36PM (#9460633)
There aren't anywhere near enough people making "gigantic" wages to make that math work. The vast bulk of the McDonalds labor force will be middle class at best.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by LesZedCB on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:56PM (#9460795)
what happens to the 1.5 billion in profit? It certainly isn't trickling down to the workforce. Bonuses, dividends, some in the bank.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by misterbishop on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:09PM (#9460397)
You're right that it's a 'big number fallacy', but you've made many mistakes here:

- $1B profit is only for a quarter, not for an entire year, for which you've attempted to roughly calculate labor costs.

- $15 minimum wage is only in the US, not worldwide. Although McDonalds does pay its workers more than $15 in some parts of the world, and somehow manages to stay in business despite the ruthless efficiency of capitalism http://www.businessinsider.com/denmark-mcdonalds-pays-20-hou...

- It's a mistake to talk about profits as a percentage of revenue because the profit is distributed to very few hands. You scoff at "a big pile if you just handed it to me personally", but McDonald's board of directors is 14 people.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by greedo on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:15PM (#9460947)
You think that the MCD board of directors gets all the profits? McDonalds is a publicly held corp, and pays dividends to shareholders, not to the board.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jerf on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:29PM (#9460578)
"$1B profit is only for a quarter, not for an entire year,"

Fair. $4/hour then, which is still less than we're talking about. I rather suspect I'm lowballing the labor by about 2x, also, if not more, but I'll stick with my numbers below.

"$15 minimum wage is only in the US, not worldwide. Although McDonalds does pay its workers more than $15 in some parts of the world, and somehow manages to stay in business despite the ruthless efficiency of capitalism "

I very deliberately did not try to calculate the price of raising minimum wage, because I do not have that data. I very deliberately calculated what they even theoretically could pay additionally across the board, because I think even at ~4$/hour, people are still going to be surprised at how small that number is! I do not think that when people think "Oh, big companies are just using people as wage slaves and sucking oodles of value out of everyone's pockets" that they're thinking "McDonalds is making about $4/hour/person." I think people think that McDonalds is making at least $dozens/hour/person, but there's no way that's the case.

Also, McDonalds has a lot of people who get more than minimum wage. They've got stacks of professionals, accountants, managers business people, etc. But, contra what LesZedCB asserts, you can't make up for it by just taking it out of their paycheck, because then those people will on the margins go work for someone else... plus these are still generally speaking middle class people (not even upper middle class here, I'm sure!), not people getting "rich". And if you do just try to take it out of a few execs hands, well, we're back to the problem where even all of McDonalds profits being reallocated back to the workers doesn't do as much as people think.

There is no scenario where McDonalds can pay enough to make a front-line order taker a "middle class" job.

"It's a mistake to talk about profits as a percentage of revenue because the profit is distributed to very few hands."

The board of directors do not just walk off with the profits. That's not how this works, and it's the sort of criticism that makes this sort of argument hard to take seriously. Where it does go is complicated, but theoretically it eventually ends up in the stockholders hands, and "the set of people who own McDonalds stock" is extremely widely distributed. The executives generally get a good chunk of stock and that's how they get the money, but in order to pay the executives "lots" it also means paying out to the rest of the stockholders "lots and lots and lots", and a lot of that stock is also ultimately going to middle class holders via various funds.

And again, my point is to work on recalibrating your understanding of just how much money "$1.5Billion" isn't, rather than argue for or against any particular policy. It isn't anywhere near as impressive as it sounds. It is not an infinite money fountain that can be easily "just" handed out to employees en masse and simply isn't Because Greed. And given the variance we experienced between quarters, it's a money fountain that can in the blink of an eye become Negative $1 Billion Dollars, even with labor costs where they are now. It's way more temperamental and way more fragile than it looks.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:39PM (#9461581)
So, all else being equal (which it never is, but roll with it), and had they paid everyone another $1/hour, they'd be making a loss.

You're applying annual wage costs to quarterly profits.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Partyfists on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:17PM (#9459898)
There are a few things in play here that you may not be considering. First this minimum wage increase would probably happen over 5 years like San Francisco and Seattle are doing. So businesses would have time to prepare and it would not go from $9 -> $15. Second, these companies have many costs outside of labor. If labor were to double for just employees making less than $15/hr, the price of everything would not just double. It would have to go up, of course, but it would not double. The final thing to consider is that if every one in the USA is making more money, they will also have more money to spend. This means they are more likely to spend money at these types of businesses thus increasing daily sales for the company.

The argument you are making is an extremely common argument from before the minimum wage was instituted decades ago where minimum wage was also (relatively, of course) significantly higher than it is right now. It turns out that people do like to spend money and when they have more of it, they spend more of it.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by onion2k on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:21PM (#9459929)
You're speculating. There no economic evidence that increasing the minimr um wage pushes up prices significantly. The fact is there are plenty of corporations that make billions in profit while paying their workers badly - there's a lot of room to pay people better without affecting prices at all.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Domenic_S on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:25PM (#9459973)
> without affecting prices at all.

You're speculating, too.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by wavefunction on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:48PM (#9460185)
That's not speculation, that's simple facts. A profitable company can drive some of its profit towards higher employee wages without raising prices.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by onion2k on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:01PM (#9461304)
You misunderstood my point - I'm saying that a company that makes billions in profit could put wages up without putting prices up by redirecting some of that profit in to better pay for it's workers, rather than, say, piling money up in the bank. That is not speculation, that's very basic accounting.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by poikniok on Thursday April 30, 2015 @02:39PM (#9466842)
But would they?
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by kushti on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:13PM (#9459849)
Probably prices will not be doubled, but even more jobs will be transferred to China / other countries. And the Valley will win as well due to increased demand for automation.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by jarin on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:37PM (#9460075)
Food service workers and laborers are the most likely to be affected by these wage increases. I don't think anyone's going to be driving to China to get a Big Mac or flying in shelf stockers from Shenzhen.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by misterbishop on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:22PM (#9459947)
Automation is inevitable regardless. Keeping wages low will not prevent McDonalds from implementation labor-saving technologies.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by kushti on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:30PM (#9460017)
Expensive labor helps automation a lot. It's the question of economy after all, if humans are cheaper than robots, there's a little incentive to spend money on deploying the bots.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Domenic_S on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:44PM (#9460142)
It will dictate when the labor-saving technology is cheaper than cheap human labor. If fast food workers were making $200/hour, it would probably be cheaper to replace them with robots today.

Keeping that inflection point far away gives us time to solve other issues (like housing affordability) that will impact the minimum-wage class of workers extremely hard when they're automated out.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by Kiro on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:39PM (#9460097)
> And the Valley will win as well due to increased demand for automation.

You mean a win for humanity. How can anyone be against automation?

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by spacemanmatt on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:43PM (#9460128)
Well, the oft-maligned Luddites were against automation because it was a tool used to cut them out of the income stream. To be absolutely certain, however, they weren't anti-technology, they were anti-getting-screwed.
Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:20PM (#9461443)
"What happens if you make $9 now, make $15 tomorrow, but tomorrow the prices of everything you buy suddenly doubled?"

Wages go up 66% and prices double in response? Not gonna happen, except in the greed fantasies of a few petit bourgeosie.

Re:Fight for $15 swells into largest protest by low-wage wor... by matthewowen on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:35PM (#9460055)
Absent overall changes to the competitive forces that drive pricing (which is complex, because this might force some companies to increase prices, which would decrease competition for companies which don't need to, which would allow them to increase prices), and assuming this pricing change doesn't make labor alternatives (eg increasing automation) economically viable, it's actually pretty reasonable to expect employers to eat the labor cost. It's probably the rational thing to see.